4 ms·
Maybe I’ll sound like a bitter old techie, but it’s absolutely wrong to have someone with no direct experience managing something that is technical. If you can
by lordnacho 8y ago
Maybe I’ll sound like a bitter old techie, but it’s absolutely wrong to have someone with no direct experience managing something that is technical.
If you can’t code, you shouldn’t manage coders. If you’re not a lawyer, don’t run a law firm. If you haven’t been in charge of a class of kids, you shouldn’t run a school. And that’s despite the day-to-day of these management roles not touching code/clients/kids.
The experience gained in a few years on any ladder is enough to appreciate most of how people in those fields think.
Have you ever tried working for someone who didn’t have relevant experience? You get people deciding that they don’t need an issue tracker, let alone a code repo. You get people who think paying Google 5 bucks a months is not worth it, they’d rather have their own email server. And it’s not that there’s never a case for having your own server, it’s that the case is never made in a technical way (eg we want security / uptime / whatever). The techies end up having to translate complex reasoning into something a layman could understand, or at least pretend to. A lot of time is wasted explaining things. And then when there’s feedback - and most people cannot resist the temptation to act like they’re contributing - it only makes sense to the non technical staff, while the tech people are trying to implement whatever crazy modification it is they’ve been given.
What these people tend to do is to make everything a management issue. So management, just like politics ends up having its own ladder. Relevant experience for being a health minister is to have been an MP. Relevant experience for managing a code department is having managed the interns.
It massively corrosive to let this continue.
And before someone makes this argument, it's perfectly possible for techies to do the managing and politics.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pokemongoaway 8y agoIt is a demonstration of the culture we are in to have to acknowledge that we sound "bitter" or "old fashioned" merely to state a self-evident truth that people with more experience know more...
- nnforall 8y agoYou shouldn't manage an auto manufacturer unless you've worked on the assembly line? You shouldn't manage an auto manufacturer unless you have engineered an automobile? You shouldn't manage an auto manufacturer unless you have been in marketing? You shouldn't manage an auto manufacturer unless you have been a personal injury attorney? You shouldn't manage an auto manufacturer unless you have been an accountant?
- dingoegret 8y agoYou shouldn't manage an auto manufacturer unless you have relevant experience in auto manufactoring, yes, correct, absolutely.
- jayd16 8y agoThey should at least have been inside a car!
- SiempreViernes 8y agoSure, but the argument by lordnacho is an extreme overextension of the idea that the leader should have relevant experience. The context here is a member of the national executive, so demanding detailed micro level experience is required is just silly, at that level nobody can have such broad detailed knowledge. The only practical way is that whoever is in charge learns what they need as they go along. I think far more important is that whoever is in charge isn't an idiot so they can realize when they have to learn new things. The fact that this guy accepted a position for cyber-security without reading up on computers is plenty of evidence he is an idiot.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- nnforall 8y agoHow about a bus? Or a train? Or a van? Do you suppose that there is really a Japanese minister today that has never used a computer? A smart phone? A microwave? A TV? An MP3 player? A network-connected device? They probably use a computer to enter their home or office. Their desk phone is probably a computer. Their car radio is a computer. It would be quite a challenge to find a living person in Japan today who has not used a computer. I suppose nothing is impossible, but some claims are so hyperbolic as to be ignored.
- 3pt14159 8y agoNo it is not because you are a bitter old techie. You're right. The world has gone mad. Look at the most competitive industries: Software, automotive manufacture, film, news, energy, finance, accounting, law. What do they have in common? The principles of the major corporations all have deep, deep backgrounds in multiple areas related to their business. They often don't even come with a mere CS degree, they've layered it with a masters or PhD or have a degree in a useful field like law.
- rossdavidh 8y agoIt is totally possible for a non-technical person manage a technical team well. There are even certain downfalls (trying to make technical decisions that they are not knowledgeable enough to make) that a manager with a technical background is MORE likely to make. That doesn't mean this particular one is good at it, of course. But the role of management is often to manage external relations, with the non-technical world. They can either do that by having a few trusted technical direct reports who advise them, and they have the bureaucratic and political skills to manage relations with the outside world, or they can do it the other way. But virtually no one is good at both. The most important thing is if you are self-aware of which one you are not good at.
- leeoniya 8y agolet's say this Cyber Security Minister has trusted subordinates who do actually understand the technical aspects. how do they even begin to communicate with a person who's never used a computer? purely in metaphors? there needs to be at minimum some common language between managers and what they're managing. otherwise it worse than broken telephone. without a certain level of understanding, it's just a useless abstraction level for the sake of filling a govt position.
- SiempreViernes 8y agoIn a more sane situation the minister would read up to gain some basic literacy in the field, the fact that he hasn't is strong evidence that he is an idiot. But you can be an idiot regardless of experience, and selecting an idiot as minister is arguably the graver error.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoWhy would they need to understand any technical aspects? Ultimately it comes down to making a decision between several alternatives, those alternatives have tradeoffs. If the technical people can't explain what those tradeoffs are in terms the non-technical decision maker can understand, then either they don't understand them themselves, or they aren't worth being concerned about.
- 8y ago
- jorblumesea 8y ago> If you can’t code, you shouldn’t manage coders. It should be, if you're not technical, you shouldn't manager coders. I've met many a manager that couldn't code, but had a very good understanding of architecture, systems, logging, etc. Engineering is more than coding and arguably the actual coding part isn't very important.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- SiempreViernes 8y agoElon Musk gets a lot of props and he was never been an automotive worker or a rocket engineer before founding the technical companies he is famous for. Are you arguing that he succeeded at running a rocket company because he once programmed for a computer game?
- kodablah 8y agoYour analogy is too literal. GP is saying some relevant experience has value, not experience in every little aspect. So, with that in mind, GP is arguing he succeeded at starting/running a technical company because he once started/ran a technical company.
- SiempreViernes 8y agoNo, he literally said > If you’re not a lawyer, don’t run a law firm and then never climbed down, just adding detail about why it was bad. You are defending a more reasonable position than the one GP expressed and I attacked.
- mixmastamyk 8y agoIndividuals running private companies can do whatever they want, as long as they can convince others. This is a public postion. Reasonably sure EM has also used a computer and managed technical companies. Someone who hasn't used a computer in 2018 is not suitable for most jobs, short of digging ditches.
- perl4ever 8y agoIn 2018, there are plenty of people who don't own a computer and have no real experience using one (other than their phone). And they are employable, because there are jobs (other than digging ditches) that don't revolve around computers. But when they apply to a sizable company, they are told that they need to come in to the employment office to fill out their application on a computer there. So I think it's pretty hard to avoid computers entirely because most things are paperless.
- komali2 8y agoRight, but for government agent in charge of cyber security, they would need a pretty high level of IT knowledge for it to make any difference. I don't see how that's feasible for career politicians. I also don't see how it's necessary, they in the end are just managing people.
- kodablah 8y ago> I don't see how that's feasible for career politicians Goes to show that's not who should fill the position > I also don't see how it's necessary, they in the end are just managing people. But not empathizing with them, a trait most would say effective management requires. Also, you are completely ignoring the decision making aspect. It's not like 100% of decisions will be deferred.
- tgtweak 8y agoSome of the best managers I know, especially in tech, are the ones that admit their teams are far better qualified to make those decisions than they are. We're not talking about an architect here. A team lead is different than a V or C level, my understanding is that the minister has about 3-4 layers between him and someone pushing code or writing policy. If I have the choice of putting someone at the head of a division of 200 people with excellent people management skills or good domain knowledge the former will trump in almost all cases. Domain knowledge is great, but it can actually make you less open minded and unbiased. I've seen some pretty scary discussions about underlying technology in executive management with seasoned industry veterans and it's the usually the person with no domain knowledge that asks the right questions that lead to a good decision. You depend on your team to execute. They depend on their team and so on. That's why the minister expressed that he preferred the questions in advance so he can distribute them with his team (the experts) and get the right answers instead of answering on behalf of them. Also it's pretty hard to get hacked when you don't have a computer. If anything the fact he rose to his position without the help of modern devices is a pretty strong testament to his fundamentals. Most managers and executives in tech would find their day-to-day pretty difficult without modern productivity tools.
- fermienrico 8y agoI strongly disagree with "Some of the best managers I know, especially in tech, are the ones that admit their teams are far better qualified to make those decisions than they are." These people defer everything to their subordinates including major technical decisions. Then what the hell is their job!? To "people manage"? As Steve Jobs said, "I don't hire managers. I hire amazing individual contributors, but the only reason they become managers is that they can't achieve their vision on their own." Just to be clear, technical managers don't necessarily have to get mangled up in detailed work - they need to have a vision for what their team is going to do. It is a "pull" rather than "push". An ideal manager should be someone that their subordinates aspire to be and they have a leadership character that is worthy of following. They give room for their team to provide inputs and they're decisive when time comes.
- tgtweak 8y ago
- moneil971 8y agoI'm not sure they need to code and know every detail but...having actually USED a computer and having a basic understanding of how it works would be a good start.
- Spooky23 8y agoA government minister isn’t a tech. Honestly, not having experience with computers may be an advantage from a policy perspective — having no dog in the fight may be useful.
- michaelt 8y agoLet's say a minister talks to two groups, which give him two different pieces of advice. Each group is an industry body with supporters that includes some companies the minister has heard of. Group A says he should ban IoT devices that don't come with a guarantee 5 years of security updates. Group B says he should ban cell phones that don't come with antivirus software. How would you propose a minister weight the advice of the two industry bodies?
- tomatotomato37 8y agoIdeally the minister would troll[1] the universities for security experts and defer those type of decisions to them so that he would have more time to play the politics game and secure funding and resources In actuality he would probably try banning keyboards in the organization after learning USB devices could carry viruses [1] fishing definition
- settler4 8y agoDo whatever the one that donates more money to him wants him to do.
- j45 8y agoIt's not bitter, or old. I'm neither! It's hard to keep on top of technological possibilities and capabilities. Especially for someone non-technical making and overseeing technical decisions. Tech folks can learn business easier than business folks can learn tech... Time to get to it.
- trimbo 8y agoHere's a counterpoint: Lou Gerstner. He saved[1] IBM 25 years ago and had no relevant tech experience. I've also had personal experience with non-techie managers who were exceptional. Moral of the story is I don't think it's wise to automatically overlook non-techies in the available pool of candidates who might do better at the job. [1] - Arguably ruined it as well by turning it into a services company, but hopefully everyone agrees he exhibited competence in the turn-around despite the direction chosen.
- jon-wood 8y agoAll the truly non-technical managers I've worked under have been great. They know the bounds of their knowledge, and will either work to expand them if needed, or accept that they should take advice. Very technical managers are also generally fine (up to a certain layer, where business and people management fundamentals trump all). The scary ones are the pseudo-technical managers who think they know far more than they actually do, and so insist on getting into the weeds of technical discussions, and even overruling people who know what they're doing - my worst was a manager who in a post-mortem on a weekend outage after someone pushed "urgent" code on a Saturday morning came out with "well people just shouldn't write bugs, its that simple".
- Twisell 8y agoCan’t agree more about pseudo-technical managers. In 2011 I warned a manager that we must go full JavaScript/HTML5 to be tablet friendly on a website we had to launch (lots of dataviz was involved). He overruled my advice, in front of the boss, and choose a hybrid flash/Wlanguage solution that only him master in the company. ️ Of course it’s 2018 and said site still haven’t transitioned out of flash. ️ I’m not frontend, theirs customers are not techs savvy, but I can’t help feeling ashamed everytime I need to interact with this site.
- jrace 8y agoSounds like he was effective in steering the bus away from the brick wall....and into the ocean. Makes you wonder if a different person could have both turned the company around and steered it into the right direction.
- torstenvl 8y agoAgreed 100%. > If you’re not a lawyer, don’t run a law firm. Fun fact: the ethics rules of most state bars prohibit lawyers from becoming partners with non-lawyers in a business whose business model involves providing legal advice. See ABA Model Rule of Professional Responsibility 5.4(b). https://www.americanbar.org/groups/professional_responsibility/publications/model_rules_of_professional_conduct/rule_5_4_professional_independence_of_a_lawyer/ https://www.americanbar.org/groups/professional_responsibili...
- okefficiency 8y agoTouching kids?!
- chrisBob 8y agoThe tech manager is an apt analogy for me because I am currently working on hiring a new boss for (myself and) a team of programmers, high performance computing consultants and geographic information systems specialists. Each applicant has different levels of experience in these areas, but I think its safe to say that there are few people in the country that have good GIS and HPC experience. Different groups need different managers/leaders. I could argue that I need a manager that understands my work so that they can guide me appropriately choosing techniques/languages/architectures. I could also argue that we have a diverse team of experts that self-manage well, and that we need a manager who is a good advocate for the group and good at dealing with the politics of university management, who won't micro-manage, and can deal with all of the admin requirements so that our team can program, make maps and support HPC customers. I agree that they should probably have some kind of a tech background, but I don't think you need to have been a professional programmer to manage me. * Hopefully no one from HR, and none of the candidates read this. * * Actually if a job candidate gets an advantage by reading a HN comment then I would consider that in-bounds for their interview prep in this case :)
- around_here 8y agoJust go raid the BCIT GIS program. Find the ones who have management success.
- lisper 8y agoThis depends on what you think a manager's job is. If you think it is to "be the boss", to run things, to make decisions, to tell people what to do, then yes, relevant experience matters. But there's another view of a manager's job, and that is to create an environment where they can get their work done without having to worry about bullshit like schedules, budgets, and politics. For that kind of a role, a non-technical person can be a great fit, possibly better than a technical one.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Stryder 8y agoAs an engineer turned manager, I disagree with this. While it is absolutely essential that the person managing the domain area needs to be capable of understanding the technical details surrounding it, it's not a requirement to have to have done the exact same work as the team. What's much more valuable and preferable to me and my team is for the person to understand how to build trust and push/prod/coach/enable folks to do their jobs in ways that are best for the team and for the company while having thought through the strategy of the direction we're heading into, and of course, take responsibility for the execution. In order to do that, being able to talk shop is important, but it's only part of the picture. From being a good engineer to being a good manager is analogous to going from being a good runner to being a good tennis player: some relationship between the two exists (both are athletes), but it's a different set of skills.
- mmsimanga 8y ago> While it is absolutely essential that the person managing the domain area needs to be capable of understanding the technical details surrounding it Having been a developer who worked his way into management. I cannot see how a manager has time to get to understand the technical details. Between meetings, HR duties and one on ones there isn't much time to get to the technical detail. You need loads of uninterrupted time to get to grips with technical details. As a manager, you don't have that time.
- Stryder 8y agoEmphasis: "capable". Mapping one concept into another and between abstraction levels is something displayed by all the strongest leaders I've met.
- dagw 8y agoHave you ever tried working for someone who didn’t have relevant experience Many times. You get people deciding that... Literally never happened. I've had a few bosses/managers who'd be the first to admit they knew nothing about programming. And in every case they defer to team experts when it comes to specific technical questions. On the flip side I've had managers who where deeply technical and spent all their time getting involved with every little technical detail and completely neglecting their job as manager.
- PaulHoule 8y agoIt depends on many things. The lady who manages my gym spent 8 years doing cybersecurity in the U.S. Army. If you were trying to fill this kind of role in today you could definitely find somebody who has technical experience in the military. The military was an early adopter of computers (in the 1970s my high school science teacher was an air force officer who managed computers. He would, with trepidation, board an Army Helicopter to go to an Army base and help them out with their computers.) Same for police, intelligence, and other careers. There is a social conflict between I.T. professionals and other professionals. A bank like "Ally Bank" is entirely an electronic operation with no branches, no cash, etc. Even the areas that require a bank officer to get involved could be best done by a bank officer who knows how to make Jupyter notebooks. You could take an extreme fintech point of view here and have all the C-level people be techies and put VCs who invest in blockchain and pot on the board, etc. But you won't. You'll put down the bong and find some bankers to fill the C-level slots because the C-levels have job #1 of being down with the regulators. That way you can get your service in front of customers. Thus bankers stay in the driver's seat and the bank that was so innovative in 1928 went bust the year after and inexplicably has been bailed out ten thereafter still has the gall to do business under the same name and (like most established businesses) is able to use influence to establish a 'moat' that keeps competitors out. I was once a full-stack dev-ops programmer/analyst level G embedded in an academic library and saw similar conflicts. Library science is about ontology and modelling things; Dewey doing by hand what Knuth would do with a computer decades later. I took to library science readily and found it went together with my blue collar appreciation of data structures and algorithms like peanut butter and jelly. From the viewpoint of the union, however, the library is a machine for employing people with MLS degrees and when budget cuts came my division got the squeeze and I was out. There was no way, however, I got have gotten to pay band H or I at that organization even if we were crammed with cash because librarians came first. (We could avoided a diplomatic incident by sending me to Germany instead of the meanest physicist in the world but they told me they only had a travel budget for Librarians!)
- stcredzero 8y agoI concur. I worked for awhile in a software company where the CEO was literally the boss who had his secretary print out his email so he could read it. it's perfectly possible for techies to do the managing and politics. The trick is finding those who can do it well.