7 ms·
Is there an actual crisis, outside the media narrative? Has Facebook seen an actual fall in monthly, weekly, or daily active users? To me, this story reads a l
by jseliger 8y ago
Is there an actual crisis, outside the media narrative? Has Facebook seen an actual fall in monthly, weekly, or daily active users?
To me, this story reads a lot like a media narrative that has very little to do with users's actual lives. And I've been reading variations on "Why Facebook sucks" and "Why Facebook is doomed" for a very long time. It's like the "Why this is the year of Linux on the desktop," but for media companies.
Don't get me wrong: I'm barely a Facebook user and agree with much of the criticism. But what I do, anecdotally, is less significant than what users do and want to do.
I think the conventional media sources, including the NYT, doesn't want to confront its own role in the 2016 election (the relentless media focus on Clinton's email server was insane). We don't want to acknowledge that most people's epistemological skill is low. Why look at ourselves, when we have this handy scapegoat right... over... there?
https://www.iep.utm.edu/girard/#H3 https://www.iep.utm.edu/girard/#H3
- annadane 8y agoSure there is. If they've been proven to have repeated privacy violations and ethics violations on a social space where people post a lot of their information it absolutely affects lives.
- tareqak 8y agoWould you consider a significant drop in Facebook's European user base to be crisis [0]? [0] https://www.businessinsider.com/facebook-revenue-and-user-growth-declining-in-europe-2018-10 https://www.businessinsider.com/facebook-revenue-and-user-gr... - Facebook's user base is declining in Europe, and that ought to terrify its American bosses
- bepotts 8y agoLosing 2 to 4 million users out of 375 million users is hardly "significant". It's something to look out for of course, but trying to insinuate that Facebook is in trouble in Europe with those numbers is a stretch.
- radicaldreamer 8y agoThe same network effect that allows social networks to grow at a blistering pace also work backwards.
- wpietri 8y agoIt's definitely significant for a company that a) has grown steadily since inception, and b) has a valuation based on continued growth. Facebook's stock is trading something like 35% below this year's peak, and this is part of why.
- bromuro 8y agoIt seems to me that some people and the mainstream media want to see Facebook in crisis, so they interprete any stats or analysis with such bias.
- wlesieutre 8y agoI can't tell, are those monthly active user numbers for all Facebook owned services, or just Facebook itself? If everyone quit Facebook and replaced it with Instagram, that's a very different story.
- bepotts 8y agoThis is exactly it. Look, Facebook needs to get its act together. They are in need for serious reform. However, mainstream media knows that Facebook is under a ton of pressure and these types of stories generate a ton of clicks. I know people want Facebook to die, but Facebook's usage has remained pretty much the same during all these negative stories. The public is not hating Facebook as much as people want to believe. But the media has its narrative and it'll continue this "Facebook is evil" beat. The same with Clinton's email server, and more recently, the same with that immigrant caravan coming up from Central America.
- ForHackernews 8y agoI mean, you can bloody well hate some business and still patronize it. I'd wager most Americans hate their cable company. I agree there's little risk of users deserting Facebook en masse, but what we may see is lawmakers coming down on FB like a ton of bricks. It will be popular, too: Heavily regulating social media and slapping them with massive fines will be winning issues with constituents on both sides of the aisle.
- dcow 8y agoIf 3 other people pledge with me, I’ll delete my Facebook account right now. I’ve already exported all my data.
- pm90 8y agoI did it 3 months ago. Its really made my life so much better. No more worrying about not being good enough as my peers who live far away in a different country. No more dealing with ads. However, I cheated somewhat and switched to twitter and continued to stay on Instagram (for sharing photos) and Whatsapp (talk to social circle).
- nickcotter 8y agoI left their whole enterprise, I was just sick of them from top to bottom. I still use twitter, but I keep my distance, and it’s hardly a social platform.
- TrevorAustin 8y agoMore than a quarter of Americans, and half of young people, report having deleted the flagship Facebook app from their phones in the wake of these scandals. (https://www.recode.net/2018/9/5/17824116/delete-facebook-mark-zuckerberg-social-media-break-time-well-spent https://www.recode.net/2018/9/5/17824116/delete-facebook-mar...) The losses are offset in their topline numbers by growth in the developing world, but that's a lagging indicator, and those are much less lucrative user eyeballs. It's mitigated to the extent those users migrate to other FB-owned properties like Instagram and WhatsApp, but there the negative media narrative increases the chance that antitrust regulators will break up FB and force it to divest those properties.
- thanatropism 8y agoIt's a small piece of a wider process, but Jaron Lanier is having such a global impact; probably much more than what Anglos imagine.
- skeptic_69 8y agonot just jaron lanier! there are multiple thinkers who are fellow travelrs. Cal newport, Tristan harris, Nicholas Carr...
- TrevorAustin 8y agoTim Wu makes the case for breaking up tech giants, and FB specifically, at book length
- skeptic_69 8y agoAre you referring to master switch or attention merchants? been meaning to read both.
- hyperdimension 8y agoThey're likely referring to The Master Switch, but I'd definitely recommend both. They're fantastic books, and Tim Wu really goes into significant depth in each.
- dawhizkid 8y agoI think what you'll see is a similar divergence to what we now see with obesity rates: uneducated/low income people experience higher rates of obesity than more educated/higher income e.g. low income or less educated people will remain oblivious and continue using FB normally while higher income or more educated people might start using FB less and less.
- astrange 8y ago> Is there an actual crisis, outside the media narrative? Yes, the part where Facebook is paying people to spread anti-Semitic conspiracy theories and supporting SESTA.
- tobr 8y agoNo, you don’t understand, an actual crisis is something that affects growth.
- minitel 8y agoCriticizing the organizations funded by George Soros has nothing to do with Judaism. And ironically you ignored: > It also tapped its business relationships, persuading a Jewish civil rights group to cast some criticism of the company as anti-Semitic. Misrepresenting things does not help you in your goal of critiquing the behavior of large companies. It actually serves as ammunition against your credibility.
- sehugg 8y agoIs there an actual crisis, outside the media narrative? This article ends with Facebook's COO testifying before Congress, so I'm going to say yes, there was a crisis.
- bepotts 8y agoTestifying before Congress doesn't mean one is in crisis. People are called to testify before Congress all the time and you don't hear about it because the testimony is irrelevant.
- pm90 8y agoThere is so much wrong with this comment. > It's like the "Why this is the year of Linux on the desktop," but for media companies. I don't think this is an accurate analogy. In fact, I think this analogy just muddies your argument. Its only analogous in that its a an event ("year of linux desktop" == "lets delete facebook") that pops up every now and then. But while the former argument is mostly one of technical adoption, usability and taste, the latter has morphed into a more insidious need to protect the public from targeted disinformation campaigns. The delete facebook movement is not just a technological/taste argument anymore, its a political one and you're doing it much disservice by comparing it to something which has much less impact. > I think the conventional media sources, including the NYT, doesn't want to confront its own role in the 2016 election (the relentless media focus on Clinton's email server was insane). We don't want to acknowledge that most people's epistemological skill is low. Why look at ourselves, when we have this handy scapegoat right... over... there? I think its important to not lump conventional news media into one big blob, just like we don't lump tech firms into one big blob. Cable News is, IMO, much more culpable for Trump's rise than NYT. NYT does actual reporting while CNN/MSNBC/FOX cable news have more punditry/opinions (NYT does have opinions too, but it doesn't dominate the medium).
- vincvinc 8y agoFacebook’s downfall does not necessarily have to come from “lower user engagement”. Think about the context that FB operates in. Imagine more and more governments reading more and more stories about how this powerful platform is influencing elections, allowing hate speech, spreading lies and even causing genocides. You don’t have to have a too big imagination to see what they will do next. Not to mention the influence of all these awful stories on how end users feel when they go on the site. Smoking, too, has many “daily active users”. A crisis for Facebook surely can start with media narrative. “Growth solves all problems” is only for early-stage startups, not for social networks used by 1 in 4 humans.
- mandevil 8y agoAlso, what effect does "we are evil" have on employee morale? What effect does a 20% decline in stock price (for a company where the RSU's and options were a significant hiring advantage) have on their ability to hire and retain talent? If they lose the talent war, does that affect their future growth potential?
- humanrebar 8y ago> ...doesn't want to confront its own role in the 2016 election... Of all the things to blame the media for, being too critical of Clinton is an unfamiliar one to me. Especially when conventional media sources were clearly hostile to Trump but enamored with Trump stories. If we are going to blame the media for something, it should be feeding the trolls, which it still has a hard time with to this day. Trump got incredible amounts of free press despite having much lower funding levels than Clinton. We could call the email controversy uninteresting but it is clearly a story about corruption and unevenly applied laws and regulations. The story was about the corruption and cover-up, not IT infrastructure.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> Is there an actual crisis, outside the media narrative? There isn't much short-term stock prices are good for. Determining if investors will bet there is a problem is one of them. Facebook's stock is down 20% YoY [1]. Unless you believe investors were blindsided by stalling rich-country MAU growth due to demographic saturation, the market is pricing something in. Facebook, too, appears to believe there something is awry--Q3 2018 operating income was down 8 points relative to the same period in 2017, due mostly to costs and expenses ballooning 53% over the same period [2]. If the New York Times' sources about Zuckerberg hiring PR firms to write hit pieces against those criticizing Facebook are accurate, it seems he, too, sees a crisis. It requires multiple suspensions of disbelief to think this is a manufactured problem. Facebook has been a principal actor in major scandals and atrocities around the world, appears to have reacted petulantly, and relies almost existentially on not having Instagram and WhatsApp torn out of it by antitrust regulators. The final point makes political vulnerability salient to its future. [1] 144.55 on 12 November 2018 / 177.95 on 15 November 2017 [2] https://investor.fb.com/investor-news/press-release-details/2018/Facebook-Reports-Third-Quarter-2018-Results/default.aspx https://investor.fb.com/investor-news/press-release-details/...