30 ms·
Small robots may kill the tractor and make farming efficient
- nickparker 8y agoThe company is fairly interesting, if seemingly early, but this article is atrocious. It repeats itself all over, it’s riddled with broken grammar, weird sentence structure, and a few typos, and the “name all our products like people” thing only adds to the confusion.
- SlowRobotAhead 8y agoYea, hit or miss with wired. On the topic, this is one of those things that looks good to a non-farmer, but tractors are big and heavy for reasons. I encourage the idea; but I don’t think the manual tractor is going anywhere soon.
- filoeleven 8y agoCame here to say this. A less confusing overview of the robots can be found at the company’s site. https://www.smallrobotcompany.com/meet-the-robots/ https://www.smallrobotcompany.com/meet-the-robots/
- hmottestad 8y agoThose all seem like renders to me. From their crunchbase profile it says they've got 1.2 million pounds in funding, but need double that ++ to get started: https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/the-small-robot-company#section-recent-news-activity https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/the-small-robot-comp...
- all2 8y agoThose are definitely all renders. I've worked on my share of prototype robotics. To get to the degree of polish they present, you'd need a heavy industrial behind you (see Fanuc or Mitsubishi or similar).
- B1FF_PSUVM 8y ago"The company's own figures claim that Small Robot Company could cut chemicals and emissions by 95 per cent, increase revenues by up to 40 per cent and reduce costs up to 60 per cent." They forgot to toss in figures for capital and return on investment, that would really seal the deal.
- 4043D 8y agoFarming as a service won't work for smaller landholders (less than 1000 hectares) people on smaller farms have money to spend 2 or 3 times a year that is when they make investments that they can write off on tax (buying a tractor) all these agtech startups pushing farming as a service fundimentaly don't understand farming as a business.
- GreeniFi 8y agoSmall scale farming often doesn’t work as a business. The economics of modern day commercial agriculture support only the big farmer. These technologies, unless they get super cheap, will drive more and more farm consolidation.
- criddell 8y agoI think there's a possible future where small scale farming takes off because it makes small-scale farming profitable and leads to fragmentation of the agriculture market. It would be great to be able to choose from more types of bananas and tomatoes and potatoes and carrots and other fruits and vegetables. I don't want cheaper food, I want better food.
- sturgill 8y ago> I don’t want cheaper food, I want better food. Say what you want about Big Ag, but the very fact that this is a reasonable position (and it is reasonable) is a tremendous testament to our progress as a species.
- 4043D 8y agoSmall scale farming absolutely does work as a business and the vast majority of farms (world wide) are in the sub 1000 hectare range. If you are talking sub 100 acre hobby farms then yeah they aren't a profitable main source of income (excluding some market garden operations)
- GreeniFi 8y ago
- dicroce 8y agoMany crops would not need so many pesticides if they were grown in close proximity to the other plants they naturally occur with... in some cases this is because other plants attract predator insects that keep other insects at bay... humans could never farm this way because harvesters just chop everything down at once... But a robot capable of recognizing all the plants could tell... and could selectively harvest just what is needed. I suspect this is a very difficult problem however just because of how varied individual plants can be... telling plants apart can be hard even for trained humans.
- amelius 8y agoHow about putting different plants in different rows, e.g. plant A in even rows, plant B in odd rows.
- based2 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No-till_farming https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No-till_farming
- nerdwaller 8y agoI definitely agree with your point, there may not be a need for a high tech solution to that problem. I would be curious what ratio of producing vs protecting rows a farmer would need. Perhaps it’s less than alternating rows, not harming yield as drastically. Perhaps 1/4 or 1/5 would do.
- ourmandave 8y agoIf you're cash crop is plant A, then plant B needs to be cheaper than spraying herbicides and the cash value of all the plant A you could have grown instead.
- amelius 8y agoUnless there are laws against spraying those herbicides. And laws could be drafted once it becomes known that these types of method are feasible.
- eksemplar 8y agoIf I was younger, farming tech is definitely the place I'd be headed. Imagine being able to change the world.
- SubiculumCode 8y agoand stick it to big herbicide companies using lasers to kill weeds. Sounds cool imo.
- shriek 8y agoSo, I'm not that young but how would a person living in an apartment in the city go about start learning this? I mean I can kind of see the tech involved in this but actually putting into practice is probably going to be challenging due to the circumstances.
- ObsoleteNerd 8y agoGo do some Farm-stay holidays and ask lots of questions. While there, ask around for other farms that will show you around. Talk to them, look for pain points, then go home and work on solutions. If you come up with something they agree would be helpful, let them be your beta testers (for free). You'll be helping real people in real ways, and might stumble on something that can change the industry. I have family on farms, and friends who work in larger scale farming, and have spent plenty of time at both. They're always happy to hear about things that could make their lives easier, but most of the big startups are coming at this completely wrong and offering expensive over-complicated "solutions" that don't solve anything the real farmers really care that much about.
- shriek 8y agoI don't know why I've never heard of farm-stay holidays until now. I'll have to find one which is more hands-on.
- nradov 8y agoMany cities have community gardens where you can rent a small plot. Use that to learn the basics and test your prototype devices.
- stretchwithme 8y agoRobots will eventually be doing everything in agriculture. Even warding off pests. That will enable farming happen in all kinds of impossible places, like on roofs and the side of buildings. They'll even be harvesting and selling produce. We'll see very small vehicles on the road that humans can't even fit into, supporting a huge automated economy. Not just for farming but for manufacturing too.
- geggam 8y agoTractors dont just do one thing. They are quite a versatile piece of equipment. Portable power plant ( PTO shaft is huge ), taking thousands of lbs of grain to the storage bin, and countless other tasks.
- blensor 8y agoYes it's always funny and kind of scary to look at when the farmers in our area put a Tractor next to the fixed water pumps that are located on their fields and have them running without anyone nearby. The tractors are driving the water pumps directly and the shaft that connects them is usually exposed without any safeguards around it.
- geggam 8y agoI worked for a farmer who was caught in one of those. It spun him around a few times. His right side his body was somewhat sideways after that. That happened to him when he was in his 40's He was 87 yrs old and still farming hard when I worked for him
- vvanders 8y agoWhile the PTO shafts are "exposed" these days they're in a sheath that covers the whole length with guards on both ends. You still want to be really careful around them but things have become much safer. That said, farm equipment still needs to be treated with a healthy amount of respect, being lax around any running machinery will easily get you killed.
- blensor 8y agoI don't think that's the case here, I can see the whole shaft rotating, and also could easily touch the joints where it is connected at both ends. But the tech they are using is sometimes more than 20 years old I guess, so maybe new ones are required to have protections. Anyway, I am treating those things with a healthy kind of respect.
- 8y ago
- adrianmonk 8y ago> But how does the company plan to make money? The co-founders say they aren't going to tell the bots, but plan to provide them as a service through a subscription fee. Is that a typo that should be "sell" instead of "tell", or are they making a little joke about protecting self-aware robots from the knowledge that they are being prostituted out for money?
- Regardsyjc 8y agoThere's a thread on Fast.ai about a similar project called Open Sprayer, "An autonomous land drone crop sprayer". It was great to see deep learning being applied to real problems, read about some of the initial issues like struggling to train a model to detect weeds, and see him build and develop his prototype over the last year. https://forums.fast.ai/t/grassland-weed-detector/7635 https://forums.fast.ai/t/grassland-weed-detector/7635 http://www.opensprayer.com/ http://www.opensprayer.com/
- mrfusion 8y agoAny ideas how to get involved in projects like this?
- phkahler 8y agoFarming is already incredibly efficient. Anyone who wants it to be even more efficient is just a huge company wanting to rid their supply chain of humans entirely.
- iguy 8y agoGrowing corn or wheat is indeed super-efficient in its use of human labor. But pretty wasteful in topsoil, chemicals, energy. And other crops (like fruit, or herbs) are much more labor-intensive. So that's two directions where it would be great to get more efficient.
- sidibe 8y agoFarming some things is efficient: wheat, soy, corn, etc. Most vegetables and fruit are still very, very labor intensive especially organic farms where you need a ton of labor just to deal with weeds.
- jsilence 8y agoVegetable and fruit are below 1% of the agricultural production by mass. The major parts are cereals, oil grains and tubers.
- ggggtez 8y agoI'm sure they would have said the same thing when the Aquaduct was invented. Anyone who wants to stop companies from becoming more efficient should carefully analyze what they are trying to prevent, and fix that problem more directly.
- phkahler 8y ago>> Anyone who wants to stop companies from becoming more efficient should carefully analyze what they are trying to prevent, and fix that problem more directly. Thanks. I reached the same conclusion in my response to another comment here. More efficient farming is good. What I foresee happening as a result may not be so good. You are right to suggest separating the issues.
- 8y ago
- shanev 8y agoIf farming can be done more mechanically than chemically, it'll be better for the environment in the long run. We'll need less pesticides, and have less top-soil erosion.
- randomdata 8y agoThe funny part is that mechanically is how it used to be done. A significant change from the shift towards chemicals was the enabling of processes like no-till and cover crops that help with soil erosion and other ecological factors.
- Nasrudith 8y agoI think it is important to remember that environmentalism is always loaded with trade-offs and there are many aspects to it as well. It brings to mind vicious yet silly lawsuits between plastic and wooden pallet makers over which was more environmentally friendly given variables like weight, fuel consumption, ecosystem impact, and biodegradability. If you really want to be a smartass you can say with one hundred percent truth that styrofoam and plastic are better for carbon long-term compared to paper and cardboard which break down over time and release it into the atmosphere. (Ignoring the relative accounting of the manufacturing processes themselves for now.)
- shanev 8y agoAren’t paper and cardboard biodegradable compared to styrofoam and plastic? The atmosphere and soil know how to handle it.
- Nasrudith 8y agoYeah the point was that biodegradability also eventually releases it to the atmosphere. Nonbiodegradability technically sequesters it until burnt but causes its own problems given things like microplastics.
- jsilence 8y ago
- acd 8y agoBackground grew up on the country side. I think robotic farming with less pesticide spray will be the future! There seem to be an ever increasing size increase of tractors. Many of these tractors runs proprietary software John Deere which makes them hard to self service. Robots can run from solar/bio energy generated locally at the farm. I think there will be a movement of build your own open source robots at farms. Farmers are very inventive and good at making things!
- sandworm101 8y ago>> Robots can run from solar/bio energy generated locally at the farm. If the robots are going to harvest the same amount of product, they are going to need at least similar amounts of power to today's machines. If they are airborne, and doing fancy AI things too, they will need far more power for every ton harvested. However it is harvested, by hand or by flying drone, the same weight of fruit has to make it from field to barn.
- hutzlibu 8y agoUsing flying drones to harvest is not a plan I heard of yet.. Not efficient. But they are good for checking on your plants. And if you do have a big solarfield and a small wind turbine as well, you probably can power your own machines.
- userbinator 8y agoMany of these tractors runs proprietary software John Deere which makes them hard to self service. ...and what's stopping the same from happening to farming robots? In fact I'd say it's even easier, since there's no existing notion that they have to be easily serviceable, unlike tractors.
- randomdata 8y ago> I think there will be a movement of build your own open source robots at farms. As a farmer, as much as the techie in me would love nothing more, I struggle to see it. There is a pretty large chasm between hobbyist-level tools and industrial-level tools, and it is a stretch to, quite literally, bet the farm on the former. Proven tools with timely service and support are essential to getting the work done in time. Robotics is already big in agriculture and has been for decades. As someone once said "technology is developed by military, adopted by agriculture, and then the rest of the world is finally exposed to it." If you can dream of a way to robotize agriculture, it is quite likely already commercially available. Any farmers who do happen to come up with a novel idea to improve agriculture will be undoubtedly looking at commercialization to raise the necessary capital to develop such a machine. There is unquestionably a long history of farmers bringing innovations to the industry, and undoubtedly will continue to be, but they are not exactly projects that you slap together in your free time from open source materials. Those who have something to build put forth serious investment, and often requiring outside investment, to make them a reality. That said, I could definitely see popularity among gardeners, where the scale is tiny and the practice is already a hobby.
- TaylorAlexander 8y agoIf anyone is interested, I’ve designed a totally open source 3D printable off road robot that is meant as a software development platform for farming robotics. I’m currently working on improving the longevity of the gearboxes and on a camera based vision system using reinforcement learning. Some videos: https://youtu.be/LIkX7wniYh0 https://youtu.be/LIkX7wniYh0 https://youtu.be/cU_0M1_TvD0 https://youtu.be/cU_0M1_TvD0 https://youtu.be/DXPmqCd0r04 https://youtu.be/DXPmqCd0r04 The whole robot and software is licensed CC0 and BSD respectively. Onshape and github links are on the site I promote in the videos. Would any of you want to build something like this? What would you use it for? Anything you would want that this one is missing?
- ph0rque 8y agoThat looks awesome! Here's a comment I wrote earlier about the topic: I've been thinking about a suite of robots on the residential level that could not only mow the grass and edge it, but also shovel snow, and perhaps eventually prune plants and pick the harvest. If a base, plus a suite of attachments, could be affordable at less than $5k retail, I would buy it.
- TaylorAlexander 8y agoAwesome! That price might be hard to achieve any time soon. Mostly because the engineering team will be very expensive, so the price will have to be many multiples of the unit cost for some time. Such a thing might be possible at a $20k price in five to ten years, and a service company could offer that work on contract to many different households. As robotics matures as a field, the engineering costs to accomplish this will go down, as will per unit costs. Maybe in 20 years time such a multi bot could be available. It’s hard to predict the future and probably of questionable merit. That said I’ve become much more pessimistic about timelines for robotics as I’ve continued to work in the industry. My hope though is that open source robotics can keep pace with the industry as time goes on, just as open source operating systems have kept pace with their closed source counterparts. That way people will have options when the technology does become feasible.
- 8y ago
- petersand 8y agoI'm working on similar machines. The goal is to do farming that is better for the soil, uses less water and fertilizer, and doesn't use any pesticides (aside from beneficial insects). The economics of farming are certainly tricky, but I think we can make it work. We may start out by operating our own farms. If you're experienced in mechanical and electrical design and fabrication and want to help (in San Francisco), let me know (info at modularscience dot com).
- mymythisisthis 8y agoFarms used a system of cables. The tracker, because it was too heavy, would only stay on the side and a cable and pulley system employed. The plough would be suspended from the cable and driven back and forth across the field. The tracker, and anchoring vehicle on the other side, would be slowly driven in parallel. https://www.alamy.com/stock-photo-a-balance-plough-being-pulled-by-a-cable-from-a-fowler-ploughing-engine-50085624.html https://www.alamy.com/stock-photo-a-balance-plough-being-pul... https://c8.alamy.com/comp/CWDH37/fowler-ploughing-engine-15357-built-in-1919-ct-4132-with-cable-drawn-CWDH37.jpg https://c8.alamy.com/comp/CWDH37/fowler-ploughing-engine-153... I think such a system would be easier to automate: cabling above a field, with an automated vehicle for spraying, harvesting, dealing with weeds.
- ggm 8y agoMy mum told me she remembered seeing this in wiltshire in the 1930s, and it was used for drainage pipe laying a lot too. The "mole" which is pulled through the ground laying the pipes has a huge amount of static resistance to overcome, the fowler engine had bloody huge anchors to stop it being pulled towards the mole. If you see a steam-engine at a fairground or history society and it has a giant wheel under the boiler mounted horizontally, thats what its for: this kind of static engine work. There were mobile threshers which used it too as a form of PTO using belts. The whole business was a convoy of about three trucks and associated labour. Steam trucks. Awesome! I was hitchhiking in Yorkshire once back in the 1980s, on an "A" road (not a motorway) and a steam engine passed me by the other way. I was so tempted to cross the road and hitch a ride the wrong way...
- jackfoxy 8y agoDidn't read the article, but wow, if someone would build an asparagus harvester that could bring back fresh Sacramento Delta asparagus. The sh*t served in Bay Area restaurants and pathetically displayed in markets now is pathetic.
- cprayingmantis 8y agoI’ve been thinking about robots on the farm for a long time myself. I’ve always approached the idea from the view point of cheaply modernizing tractors first so that more farmers would benefit. My idea would be to take a platform that farmers already love: the desiel tractor and start adding more automation. There’s so much already invested in the three point hitch, hydraulics, pto, and other systems that it just makes sense to build on it. There’s several tasks that are perfect to build automation on. A big one where I’m from is hay harvesting it’s a four step process that could take days. Having the ability to get these task done async without involving help would be a boon to farmers. I see modernizing tractors as a 4 step process. 1: add automation to existing tractors. Mountable kit that would cost less than $10k 2: replace said tractor with electric variant that has the same platform. Target price $30k 3: provide a way to charge based on solar power (most automation worthy farm task need to be done on a sunny day anyways) Target price would probably be in the $20k range. 4: Build smaller more specialized tractor replacements like what’s shown here. Shooting for a sub $20k platform average.
- abledon 8y agoSeems like only a matter of time till Tesla has something on the burner for this. After pickup truck I think they are doing a electric bike then after that.....
- Nasrudith 8y agoWhile I suspect small robots would have a place in the future eventually I'm not entirely sure if tractors would be entirely replaced - I would expect bulk tasks to be handled by a tractor more efficiently. They certainly have the potential to be far more versatile as platforms however.
- King-Aaron 8y agoYou're correct. Small robots aren't going to help you pull a road train out of a flooded track. I'd imagine though it would help offset large fleets of large vehicles, however.
- gavztheouch 8y agoI am also building an open source small robot for the farm. www.opensprayer.com trying to design for a total build cost of £2000. The idea is to use machine learning to identify weeds in my grass fields and selectivity spray them.