9 ms·
My Band Has 1M Spotify Streams. Want to See Our Royalties? (2016)
- hartator 8y agoCan’t they sum their earnings? After reading the article, it’s unclear if they are complaining of msking too much ot too little.
- gxigzigxigxi 8y agoThey do sum it up. $5k for 1M streams. Which is reasonable or not compared to CDs depending on your assumptions. Let’s say a CD has ten tracks and the average buyer plays a CD five times. That’s fifty streams per buyer. One million streams yields twenty thousand CD buyers under this assumption. CDs are $10 (or were the last time I bought them ages ago). That means $200k gross, but the band would probably not see more than 20% of that at the most optimistic. Still, $5k is a lot less than $40k. But if you double the number of plays a typical CD buyer would listen, and halve the band’s cut, you’re suddenly in the same neighborhood. You also have to factor in that many Spotify streams are not full track listens.
- jsjohnst 8y agoLast time I heard a number, bands got a single digit percentage of the sale of a CD. Edit: Quick web search shows I’m right. https://bandzoogle.com/blog/record-sales-where-does-the-money-go https://bandzoogle.com/blog/record-sales-where-does-the-mone...
- gxigzigxigxi 8y agoThanks. So if the artist is both the performer and the writer, they get about ten percent. So that’s one power of two accounted for. I think my assumption about the typical number of CD listens is also quite conservative.
- jsjohnst 8y agoI agree, I think it was conservative. So your root point appears valid.
- bestskiieronthe 8y agoTotal number of streams: 1,023,501 Total revenue: $4,955.90 Specific time period accounted: 10/15/2013 – 2/15/2013
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sanketskasar 8y agoTotal number of streams: 1,023,501 Total revenue: $4,955.90 Specific time period accounted: 10/15/2013 – 2/15/2013 (March, April, May periods not yet reported; estimated) Average per-stream payout: $0.004891 They couldn't be any more explicit.
- mkagenius 8y agoHow does this ($4990) compare to youtube's 1M views? Perhaps $500?
- sanketskasar 8y agoBut YouTube, at least the popular video platform, is not meant for publishing songs and is doesn't claim that either. Spotify's sole business is dependent on music and claims to be benefit artists.
- bjelkeman-again 8y agoBut many people use YouTube as their music jukebox. Why is it that Google should pay significantly less for this?
- fenwick67 8y agoFor one, an average YouTube video is more expensive to stream than just audio
- bjelkeman-again 8y agoBut even if I put up a static image with the audit the artist get way less from YouTube than from Spotify. I don’t see why that should be the case.
- zamadatix 8y agoProbably about that. CGP Grey has a great video about the whole YouTube system https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KW0eUrUiyxo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KW0eUrUiyxo.
- nkozyra 8y agoPeople still seem to be stuck quantifying the value of music (sales, streams, etc) against a time when there was less saturation and the actual cost of producing, marketing and distributing music was much higher.
- untog 8y agoWell yes, because that was a time when musicians could earn a living. It's legitimate to question the current situation.
- petra 8y agoThe world is filled with talented people not using their talents in their job. Why do you assume that musicians in particular must be the ones to make a living from their talent ?
- danharaj 8y agoMaybe it's a broader proble with society.
- petra 8y agoI'm not so sure. Why ? Well, one way to conceptualize human needs is maslow's hierarchy. the final, LOWEST priority need is self-fulfillment. so there are many more pressing problems before that to solve. but: It says nowhere that self-fulfillment must be in your job. Who says that being a successful musician is "the" useful trait to develop ? reading about successful musicians, and knowing one, they don't seem particularly psychologically healthy. Same goes for probably many other talents. And who says the "self" is the key thing to develop anyway ? if you ask spiritual people, peak human development looks quite different.
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoIt's odd how this argument is applied to artists, but never to financiers, investors, and CEOs. What if being insanely rich isn't "the" trait to develop? Reading about successful CEOs, and knowing one very distantly, they don't seem particularly healthy. And who says creative expression is a thing to develop anyway? Why can't we just keep making already rich people even richer without complaining about it?
- ksec 8y agoSo 1M Streams gave them $5000 dollars, Over 4 months. Still not entirely sure how this business will work out.
- nkozyra 8y agoWhich business? Spotify or music careers? Do we consider 1M streams worthy of a "living?" Why?
- agumonkey 8y ago1250$ per month, 41$ per day. 20 per day per capita (it's a band so at least 2 persons ?). I know some hobos that make more by asking for pennies(granted you have to do that all day every day). Jokes aside, maybe they should just play outside and in bars they'll have more fun and probably as much money.
- kapauldo 8y agoStreaming is not work. Concerts are work. This is more than fair money for what they did.
- n-a 8y agoHow does Tidal compare in terms of paying artists
- nwrk 8y agoHere is more numbers across platforms: https://blog.songtrust.com/the-guide-to-music-streaming-platforms https://blog.songtrust.com/the-guide-to-music-streaming-plat... Tidal Launched: 2014; relaunched in 2015 after an acquisition by Jay-Z in 2015. Subscribers: Estimated 3 million subscribers in 52 countries Market Share: N/A Payout: $0.01284 per stream
- jrace 8y agohttps://www.digitalmusicnews.com/2018/01/16/streaming-music-services-pay-2018/ https://www.digitalmusicnews.com/2018/01/16/streaming-music-... {tidal}"Last year, the service reportedly paid $0.0110 per play. This year, The Trichordist found that the platform paid $0.01284 per stream. " {spotify} "Last year, the service paid out $0.0038 per play. Not much has changed this year. With a reported 51.51% market share in the US, Spotify pays $0.00397 per stream."
- source99 8y agoHow much revenue does Spotify generate for the 1M streams?
- jdmichal 8y agoI think this question is part of the problem. Every stream is actually negative revenue for Spotify. It costs them money to have a song in catalog that is amortized per stream, and it costs them money to stream that song each time. And some listeners are paying a subscription, which means fixed revenue but variable streams and therefore costs. While others are ad-based model, so hopefully variable revenue but guaranteed positive per stream...
- nikanj 8y agoI feel like it's a false analogy to compare Spotify Streams to CD sales. For a fairer comparison, you should measure against something more ephemeral. The biggest radio channels in the US have a few million listeners each. Let's say your record does ok, and gets airtime on a few second-tier radio stations. For easy math, let's do 20 plays * 50,000 listeners per play. This also gives you a total of one million listens. I would be _extremely_ surprised if they would net much more than $5000 from these radio listens.
- iamben 8y agoI'm with this all the way. Appreciate this article is from 2016, but surprised the physical sale is still compared to Spotify streams. They're very different and I think Spotify is far more like radio with choice (a bit like Netflix and TV). I listen to lots of stuff on Spotify I never would have bought 15 years ago (thus no sale would be accounted for). But conversely, I suppose, I rarely buy a lot of records I listen to with fair frequency on Spotify. That said I go and watch live shows of a bunch of people I probably wouldn't have. Times have changed. Everyone has to adapt. I doubt as many people are buying DVDs or Bluray anymore, right?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bachmeier 8y ago> I would be _extremely_ surprised if they would net much more than $5000 from these radio listens. Me too. Unless they've recently changed the rules, the artist gets nothing when a song is played on the radio.
- nwrk 8y agoThat's really greedy. "Spotify charges around $0.015-$0.025 per ad served" https://blog.adstage.io/2018/04/03/spotify-advertising https://blog.adstage.io/2018/04/03/spotify-advertising while "Average per-stream payout: $0.004891"
- imustbeevil 8y ago16-26% is better than CD sales (6% from the other link in this thread).
- detaro 8y agoI don't remember the free version running one ad per song, so I don't know why those numbers should compare directly?
- ken 8y agoI assume "Specific time period accounted: 10/15/2013 – 2/15/2013" is a typo, right? The spreadsheet isn't sorted but it looks like the most recent date is 2/15/2016, so that's $5000 for 28 months, or about $178 per month. That's not much. That could cover gas money for one or two band members. An average software engineer earns 2-3x that much every day.
- Arqu 8y agoI somehow keep being fascinated by people think they're ripped off. I mean sure, Spotify is making a decent buck out of it, but it's not like the artists are doing it for free. There's much more to the whole process. Firs to earn something per play there need to be ads that finance it. Then imagine the technical hurdle and cost to host such a platform (ie Spotify cut) and then you actually being worth a damn as an artist. 1M views might seem like a lot, but actually its quite a limited resource for serving ads. The other thing here is that most artists wouldn't have a single view if it wasn't for one or the other distributor. Basically, the barrier is so low to entry and the risk is dispersed across a million other artists so you all get a very diluted value per view. But at least you get value per view. Otherwise, it would have been an all or nothing business, like it used to be. It's the same effect the app stores had for software devs. In essence, you get low fees because those funds pay for the distribution and risk that is dispersed. The general pay scale is a hockey stick with the last couple % making the majority of the money. Since you even got the opportunity to get in front of an audience, use it wisely as you need to pump those numbers up. It's a numbers game and your numbers are too low. You need double-digit millions to make a good living off of it. And that's just what it takes. It's not easy, not everyone will make it above the fold, for whatever reason life, luck, marketing...
- kakarot 8y agoThey are getting ripped off. Many record companies, in their own financial interest, reduced the royalty cost for streams with Spotify in exchange for revenue shares. I would feel pretty ripped off if I made a big, delicious cake, and as a reward I get one tiny slice while I had to watch everyone else eat the rest. Maybe not if making cakes is just a small hobby for me, but definitely so if it's my career.
- ajaimk 8y agoCitation please
- kakarot 8y agoIt's common knowledge. I don't need to provide a citation every time I bring it up. But here, since you're too lazy to look it up or write more than two words: https://www.musicbusinessworldwide.com/heres-exactly-how-many-shares-the-major-labels-and-merlin-bought-in-spotify-and-what-we-think-those-stakes-are-worth-now/ https://www.musicbusinessworldwide.com/heres-exactly-how-man... Interestingly, earlier this year several record companies either mostly or fully divested in Spotify, with some companies like Warner getting over half a billion dollars. Reasons are unclear even though they have made vague public statements.
- mrweasel 8y agoArguably $5000 isn't much for three years and 1 million plays, but I'm also not sure what they where expecting. I believe the issue is that Spotify charges customers per month, while artists are paid by play, so the more Spotifys customers use the service, the less they can afford to pay for each play. Assuming that a consumer spent the money from a Spotify subscription on CDs instead that would, in Denmark, be around 24 CDs in a three year period. When you look at it that way, I can't really see how artists expect to make any real profit of Spotify, the money simply isn't there. Streaming services allow consumers to listen to vastly more music that they ever did before, and from a larger number of artists, but at a lower price, so I can't see why people are surprised that Spotify isn't making them money. What would be interesting to see is: How many time would a fan need to play songs from one artist to make the artist the same amount of money as the sale of a CD. I believe that an artist only makes around $0.5 from the sale of a CD, the rest goes to the label, promotion and so on. So I would assume that as long as each user plays a song around 100 times, the net result would be the same.
- ianai 8y agoI’d rather my monthly fee go to only the artists I play. Say, for some percentage of my fee minus operating costs. That would reward artists according to their draw.
- lowercased 8y agoi couldn't imagine it being any other way really. co-mingling paid listens with 'ad' listens would just be weird.
- hndamien 8y agoThis is the crux of the fairness debate here. The numbers don't seem absurdly bad, but if I was buying CD's - none of my dollars would go towards Rihanna and a good portion would go to obscure bands. Currently, this is the opposite of how my subscription dollars are divided.
- Aeolun 8y ago
- mlthoughts2018 8y agoIn case anyone is interested in alternatives, I think we live in an amazing time for non-streaming music consumption. I run the VLC app on my mobile devices, which allows me to spawn a web server served off the mobile device that I can connect to in the browser on my laptop or desktop PCs. I can upload raw music files (mp3, ogg, etc etc) onto the mobile devices seamlessly, and it categorizes them by album. I only ever buy full album or track digital downloads from bandcamp or Amazon music. Zero DRM, just straight archive files of mp3s usually (bandcamp lets you select which audio file type for a long list of options). For unknown music, you usually pay what you want or pay a small price like $1 on bandcamp, which is almost always worth it even when just testing out some music I’m not sure if I’ll return to yet or not, especially compared with the negative externalities of subscriptions with Spotify. I consume probably 5 different $10 albums per year and maybe another few hundred or so LPs or individual tracks at about $1 each. My music budget is probably about $250 / year, which is roughly twice the price with Spotify premium. I could go on another rant about how Spotify’s content discovery / collaborative filtering offerings are extraordinarily poor and provide genuinely negative value for me when I previously used the product, but regardless I feel very happy to avoid Spotify’s negative externalities. That is well worth an extra $10/month of Spotify-avoidance-fee to do it with non-streaming options.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- stdclass 8y agoAs an artist with 250k streams myself, I don't really think that you should directly compare it to CD sales etc. If you compare it like this: a single play on a popular radio show can get you 250k listeners and you get payed well below 50$ per play. So getting a couple grand for 1mio plays vs. ~250$ for some airtime on the radio seems like a decent deal to me.
- timeseries2018 8y ago>> you get payed you get paid
- yummybear 8y agoSo about half a cent per stream in payout? I have no experience in the music industry but as a consumer somewhere around a cent per song is what I would imagine would be reasonable to charge. So this is in the ballpark of my expectations - as a consumer.
- jondubois 8y agoI've written over 20 blog articles about software development over the past couple of years; each article is typically thousands of words. My blog has had hundreds of thousands of views in total (targeted at developers; a valuable demographic) and I've made $0 from it. I find that writing blog articles is easy and I like doing it. If you want to make money from anything, unfortunately, you've got to compete with people like me who are willing to do the work for free.
- malcolmgreaves 8y agoYour comment has nothing to do with this post. And you come off as a total asshole. Did you read it? The post is about Spotify underpaying artists for their work, which many people (1M+) enjoy. Yours is about a hobby that you do for your own enjoyment. Anyone else read it? Anything close to 1M readers?.
- jondubois 8y agoPublishing blog articles and publishing music or videos are all similar in terms of monetization. Some people will produce music for free and you have to compete with them. It's not unusual to get hundreds of thousands or even millions of views and get very little out of it financially.
- malcolmgreaves 8y ago> Some people will produce music for free and you have to compete with them. Professional quality is nearly always significantly better than amateur quality. Ya get what ya pay for. This whole post is about professionals making a living from their craft. And we're all ok with the distributor, the middle man, Spotify, raking in more money than the content creators. That's my big beef: Spotify is getting their slice from the artist's pockets when they're already not getting enough for their work.
- IshKebab 8y agoI'm going to guess what they are before looking: People that would have bought an album probably would have listened to each track ~5 times, say an album has 10 tracks, this is equivalent to 20k album sales. Apparently typical royalty on an album is ~$0.50 so I'm going to say $10k. ...checks... $5k. Ok fairly low but I think that was a pretty good guess!
- oliwarner 8y agoCompare that to radio royalties. In the UK BBC Radio 2 pays £100/minute in combined songwriter-performer royalties. For 10 million listeners. £300 a song. £0.003 per "stream". Spotify is already paying above radio rates.