11 ms·
A new way to make steel could cut 5% of CO2 emissions at a stroke
- symplee 8y agoFrom the article: Until the product is actually built and tested at commercial scale, it’s too early to say how well or affordably it will really work. Moreover, merely producing a green version of a product for around the same price won’t be enough to transform the industry, given the billions of dollars in sunk costs in steel mills that can operate for decades. Even if the perfect technology came on the scene today, it’d probably be several decades before we could effectively transition to it Talk about playing the long game... I wonder how much cheaper their method would need to be, given the above. Would it be faster/cheaper to develop perfect scrubbers to retrofit onto existing mills? (Funded through donations, and/or to sell to offset carbon taxes.) Still good to have this new technology available to transition to down the line.
- Gibbon1 8y agoI read a retrospective paper by a Norwegian group that worked on electrowinning iron from mixed sulfide ores. Taking iron sulfide waste and converting it to sulfuric acid and iron sheet. I think they were getting 4.25kwh per kg. Nop idea if that is good or not but at $0.15/kwh that's $640/ton. I thought about that over the last few years because it's aqueous process so should be able to run intermittently. Edit: Paper http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.843.3769&rep=rep1&type=pdf http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.843...
- hectormalot 8y ago640$/ton won’t be profitable as that’s about the current price for high end steels. OTOH, I remember industrial electricity prices to be closer to 7-10cents per kWh, so it won’t be that far off what we have now.
- 46Bit 8y agoI'm amazed how cheap that sounds. Does that mean that for a cost of a decent laptop I could get two tons of steel delivered?
- HeyLaughingBoy 8y agoThat's probably slabs of billet: unprocessed steel right from the mill. Not cold rolled bars or rods, or sheet. I only know a little about steel prices from being a hobby machinist, but I know a bit more about hay prices. For the price of a cheap laptop, you can get two tons of hay delivered :-)
- hectormalot 8y agoActually I was thinking of hot rolled. Turns out the regional differences are huge: Hot rolled in US is 928$ per metric ton Hot rolled in EU is 620$ per metric ton China is in the mid 500s. Unclear to me if the new US tariffs are to blame, gap is larger than the 25% I expected. Source: http://steelbenchmarker.com/files/history.pdf http://steelbenchmarker.com/files/history.pdf
- qbrass 8y agoIt doesn't have to turn a profit, it just has to lose less money than it costs to dump the waste products it's made out of. Depending on how regulated that becomes, it might be worthwhile in the future.
- jillesvangurp 8y agoEnergy prices are going to be key here. The mistake would be assuming they are a constant though. They've been trending down and lately coal has been considered on the expensive end of the spectrum. Those prices have been trending down due to clean energy prices dropping. Both solar and wind are now winning bids on price that used to go to coal plants. Also as coal plants shut down and coal mines are closed, coal might actually get more hard to get (i.e. more expensive). Some recent solar plants are delivering power well below the prices you cite (I've heard prices going as low as 3-4 cents/kWh). I could imagine most steel plants are big enough that they'd want their own infrastructure in any case. So, for a future steel plant based on this stuff with its own cheap energy supply, it might end up being cheaper and cleaner. That could end up being really disruptive.
- cerfirm 8y agoThere are other tests as well. the Hybrit method that will be going through a pilot phase starting this year. Fossil free steel making. Still some issues to solve but it is still interesting http://www.hybritdevelopment.com/ http://www.hybritdevelopment.com/
- peter_d_sherman 8y agoExcerpt: "NASA had offered a quarter-million-dollar prize to the first research team that could figure out how to extract oxygen from the moon’s surface, a precondition for establishing lunar bases. Sadoway proposed using an electrolytic cell—which produces an electric current to break down compounds—to extract oxygen from lunar rocks. The by-product was molten metal, a realization that led him to explore the possibility of using a similar approach to process metals back on Earth." Two for the price of one! (Well, potential solutions to problems that is! One, how to generate oxygen on other planets, and two, how to smelt metals on this one while generating less carbon emissions. Well played!)
- gene-h 8y agoIt's not just metals you can smelt, you can also smelt silicon from rocks. It ends up in a melt of iron and silicon, but one could potentially separate out the silicon and use it to make solar cells.[0] Which can then be used to power more electrolysis units to make more solar cells. [0]https://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/20050110155.pdf https://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/200501...
- wavesounds 8y agoAnother good example of how investing in NASA helps our economy by facilitating the discovery of new technology.
- beefield 8y agoGovernment intervention. Not good. Much better would be letting free markets to allocate more resources to figure out how to get people clicking more ads and development of cryptocurrencies. (This was sarcasm.)
- SomeAmerican 8y ago"In the main approach to steelmaking today, iron oxide is placed into a blast furnace with coke, a hard, porous substance derived from coal... This and other steps in the process pump around 1.7 gigatons of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere annually, ... And that’s before taking into account the fuels required to fire the furnaces." The coke is the fuel that fires the furnaces.
- cauldron 8y agoMaybe it's about the buring needed to make the coke.
- qbrass 8y agoSteel is an alloy of iron and carbon. They mix coke with the iron to add carbon to it. The article is talking about the CO2 released from that coke, and not the coke used to fuel the furnace.
- cauldron 8y agoYou sound like confused, from my limited knowledge, the making of steel is exactly opposite of what you said, they extract carbon atoms from iron, that makes carbon monoxide into carbon dioxide.
- SomeAmerican 8y agoIron ore has no appreciable carbon in it before it enters the blast furnace.
- hexane360 8y agoActually it's 100% the opposite. Look at your iron-carbon phase diagram: https://www.tf.uni-kiel.de/matwis/amat/iss/kap_9/illustr/fe_c_phase_diagram_cast_iron.gif https://www.tf.uni-kiel.de/matwis/amat/iss/kap_9/illustr/fe_... Cast iron contains a high concentration of carbon, which makes it brittle. To make steel you need a heavy oxidizer to extract the (reduced) carbon. This is usually done using a "basic oxygen furnace", which is basically injecting a high pressure, very high velocity stream of oxygen into the metal to game thermodynamics into combusting the carbon without combusting the iron.
- Robotbeat 8y agoOne thing that human space exploration/settlement teaches us more than anything is how to do everything without net carbon emissions. Solar power? Nuclear power? Both essential to and pioneered in part by space exploration. Same for fuel cell tech. On the International Space Station, CO2 is sucked from the cabin air, combined with hydrogen (produced as a byproduct of producing oxygen by splitting water, much of which was recycled from the air and waste water and urine) to make methane and more water. ISS also is getting a plastic recycling machine that will be used to 3D print replacement parts from plastic waste and old parts. Human spaceflight is like the Sustainability Olympics.
- makapuf 8y agoRight, some nice inventions are due to space race but just after two giant boosters worth of propergol were burnt. And making those things that go to space are not completely carbon neutral either.
- Robotbeat 8y agoThe highest performing rocket propellants in common use are hydrogen and oxygen, whose product is water. And NASA and others are working on ways to refuel those using just electricity and water.
- trashtester 8y agoThe coal used by most countries for producing electricity is not that clean though. If anyone is really serious about global warming, shutting down coal plants should be priority 1, natural gas plants priority 2 and transportation emissions priority 3.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoFortunately we can work in parallel. Switching anything from burning whatever it's burning to electricity is a huge win, because electricity sources can be changed independently of electricity consumers. Today's electric cars powered by coal are tomorrow's electric cars powered by solar, wind and nuclear, with no involvement of the car owners required.
- hexane360 8y agoThe steel industry isn't really as "conservative" as is being portrayed here. In the past 30 years, the amount of recycled metal being used has skyrocketed, and entire companies have come to power because of it. Sure, big old U.S. Steel is behind the times, but that's true for any industry.
- bigpicture 8y ago> Sure, big old U.S. Steel is behind the times, but that's true for any industry. U.S. Steel operates integrated mills, which make steel from raw materials. "Mini-mills" make steel using electric arc blast furnaces to recycle existing steel. If you need very high quality steel, you have to get it from an integrated mill. Everyone else can use the recycled stuff. The real benefit that you are talking about is the fact that recycled steel quality is improving enough to be useful in more applications. PS - U.S. Steel is converting their Alabama mill to an electric arc blast furnace (they may have finished by now).
- hexane360 8y ago>If you need very high quality steel, you have to get it from an integrated mill. This just isn't true anymore. Process control has improved a lot since EAF mills were first created. EAF mills also provide more flexibility because they can make much smaller batches. This allows for more niche alloys to become accessible.
- londons_explore 8y agoTL;DR: This is a well known technique, but isn't used because the economics don't work out. This technique looks nearly identical to the technique used to make aluminium from aluminium oxide. The only difference is it needs to happen much hotter (1500C vs 700C). The process uses a lot of electricity, so much that it is the main cost of aluminium production. The process, when used in steelmaking, would use 824.2 kJ/mol of iron(III) oxide, producing 111.6 g/mol of iron. That works out to 7.42 kJ / g, or 2 kwh per kilogram of steel. Price varies widely worldwide, but with the cheapest electricity in europe that works out to about $0.10.[1] Thats lots of electricity for the refining process, and it seems likley that 0.7kg of coal [2] works out far far cheaper at $0.05 [3]. [1]: https://1-stromvergleich.com/electricity-prices-europe/ https://1-stromvergleich.com/electricity-prices-europe/ [2]: https://www.worldcoal.org/coal/uses-coal/how-steel-produced https://www.worldcoal.org/coal/uses-coal/how-steel-produced [3]: https://markets.businessinsider.com/commodities/coal-price https://markets.businessinsider.com/commodities/coal-price
- strainer 8y agoLooking into those calculations, I see the current average energy used to make 1 kg of steel is about 10 thousand BTU [1] - about 3 kWh. 75% is consumed in blast furnace and "About 50% of an integrated facility’s energy input comes from coal, 35% from electricity, 5% from natural gas and 5% from other gasses [2]" Your estimate of 2kWh per kilo would look very promising for this process. Also the comparison of electrical price, with the price for raw coal surely begs some adjustment. [1] https://www.quora.com/How-much-energy-does-it-take-to-produce-steel https://www.quora.com/How-much-energy-does-it-take-to-produc... [2] https://www.worldsteel.org/en/dam/jcr:f07b864c-908e-4229-9f92-669f1c3abf4c/fact_energy_2016.pdf https://www.worldsteel.org/en/dam/jcr:f07b864c-908e-4229-9f9...
- black-tea 8y agoGreat! That means we can make more steel.
- tomatotomato37 8y agoAt a stroke* *Not including the time required to retool the entire Earth's iron smelters into electrolytic smelters and build out associated electric infrastructure needed to accompany the exponential increase of a country's energy intake.
- ajross 8y agoThat's spinning too hard in the other direction. This is a technique for smelting. Once smelted and shipped, the metal is always going to be remelted anyway to mix and cast the final alloy. And in fact in the modern world the bulk of this work is done with electricity already in an electric arc furnace. We're talking about a constant factor on top of a steel industry already very dependent on electrical power, certainly not (sigh) an "exponential increase of a country's energy intake".