13 ms·
Edward Snowden says a report critical to an NSA lawsuit is authentic
- raprp 8y ago> U.S. prosecutors charged Snowden with espionage. Was anyone of the US Government criminally charged for this whole thing or they only bothered to charge the guy who exposed the crime?
- c3534l 8y agoTake a wild guess.
- clubm8 8y ago>Was anyone of the US Government criminally charged for this whole thing or they only bothered to charge the guy who exposed the crime? Laws apply to commoners, not lords.
- geggam 8y agoQ: Why do you think the lords wish to disarm the commoners ? A : Bullets don't care how much power or money they have.
- masklinn 8y agoIn the history of the United States, bullets have mostly if not solely been used for the protection of the lords, often by commoners either paid to do it and not caring, or convinced the issue was other commoners. After all a common thread of US History is this LBJ quip: > If you can convince the lowest white man he's better than the best colored man, he won't notice you're picking his pocket. Hell, give him somebody to look down on, and he'll empty his pockets for you.
- nsajko 8y agoI agree with your comment (it reminded me of the times the Pinkertons or the deputized sheriffs shot at strikers long ago), but I think that every citizen being armed would be a good guard for the society's freedom, and thus that it would be worth it.
- masklinn 8y ago> I think that every citizen being armed would be a good guard for the society's freedom, and thus that it would be worth it. That would be a pretty big change from them dynamiting and firebombing Greenwood, or taking over and thrashing Malheur. Somehow I'm doubtful. That's just not how America has used guns ever. And that's not how it uses guns to this day.
- mcny 8y agoMore than guns (or in addition to guns), it is important that people know how their government works and make their support indispensable if a ruler wants to stay in power. In other words, increase the number of "keys" like this YouTuber explains https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rStL7niR7gs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rStL7niR7gs What I struggle with is how does one make the leap from being a democracy to being a democracy which protects the rights of minorities? This doesn't have to be a gender or race thing. For example, here in the US we clearly don't do enough to protect incarcerated people from {sexual, physical, mental} abuse (by staff or by other inmates).
- brobdingnagians 8y agoThat was part of the idea of the Constitution; the founding fathers knew that uninhibited democracies were a bad idea (even the Greeks experienced some bad things with mob rule) and specifically tried to create a democratic republic restrained by a written set of rules protecting citizens from arbitrary exercise of power by a majority to avoid some of the worst. They lived through quite a few things we are seeing now, but I think a large part of preventing it depends squarely on culture. Having a culture that fundamentally believes in justice and equality will stave off tyranny and oppression, but it doesn't matter what laws you have in a society that doesn't value those. When I took Chinese philosophy there was a philosopher (can't remember which one) who basically said that it is good men who make the laws, but laws without good men will not be enforced.
- sametmax 8y agoYeah, your gun is very helpful against trained soldiers with hi tech equipements and drones. And not harmful at all in your daily life.
- geggam 8y agoSeems to work for the Afghan people. In my daily life a gun does little. People sometimes use it for good or for evil. Like any other tool
- sametmax 8y agoThey don't have a gun, they have army supplies regularly provided by other interested party, with additional military and tactical training. You don't stand a chain with your desert eagle if the marines decide you should go down.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- boomboomsubban 8y agoThe Government doesn't admit it did anything illegal, any court cases trying to show otherwise will take a decade as this one has, and currently the only one I'm aware of was dismissed as the courts ruled they could not prove damage had been done. Though, even if found to be violating the law I find it hard to imagine any prosecutors trying individuals involved.
- monocasa 8y agohttps://www.cnn.com/2015/05/07/politics/nsa-telephone-metadata-illegal-court/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2015/05/07/politics/nsa-telephone-metada... But you're right about not prosecuting individuals.
- CogitoCogito 8y ago> Though, even if found to be violating the law I find it hard to imagine any prosecutors trying individuals involved. Well except for Snowden of course. And frankly Clapper's testimony to Congress was obviously perjury. The prosecution of only Snowden is rank hypocracy.
- nabla9 8y agoElizabeth Goitein (Brennan Center for Justice): > The whistleblower laws for intelligence community members pretend that there’s no such thing as agency level misconduct and we know that that’s not the case... If what you’re talking about is official misconduct that has been sanctioned by the agency, then obviously reporting that misconduct to that agency is not going to help. So internal channels are useless for things like torture, warrantless wiretapping, any of those major systemic abuses, like the ones we saw after 9/11. https://pen.org/sites/default/files/Secret%20Sources%20report.pdf https://pen.org/sites/default/files/Secret%20Sources%20repor...
- scoot_718 8y agoHe stole credentials to download and give data en masse. This wasn't a guy exposing a single program. It was a guy just releasing everything he could get his hands on.
- mcny 8y agoWe're talking about Snowden, not Manning.
- macspoofing 8y agoSnowden as well. He promised he destroyed all the data that had nothing to do with internal spying programs when he landed in China but before he defected to Russia. And he must be telling the truth because he said he's telling the truth.
- TazeTSchnitzel 8y agoHe didn't defect to Russia. He was on a flight that had a layover in Moscow airport, but the US revoked his passport, so he got stranded there until Russia eventually granted him asylum.
- hvdhh7 8y agoHis passport was revoked while he was in Hong Kong. Somehow he was allowed to board the flight to Moscow with a revoked passport, but not the flight from Moscow.
- ryanlol 8y ago>Somehow he was allowed to board the flight to Moscow with a revoked passport Your passport doesn't magically cease to work after someone somewhere says it's been revoked.
- macspoofing 8y ago
- macspoofing 8y agoWhat crime are we talking about? Because the surveillance programs have been sanctioned and overseen by all three branches of government. In other words, they were perfectly legal government programs. So Snowden didn't actually whistleblow any crime. You may argue about the public right to know about these programs, and I would be friendly to that view, but Snowden stole much much much more than that, took it to China and asked us to trust him when he said he destroyed that data (though he changed his story quite a few times)... that's why he is a traitor.
- liftbigweights 8y ago> Was anyone of the US Government criminally charged for this whole thing or they only bothered to charge the guy who exposed the crime? For the same reason no one was charged for hiroshima or nagasaki. Or the illegal iraq war. It was sanctioned by the government. For there to be criminal charges, someone in the government has to be willing to prosecute. Good luck with that.
- xupybd 8y agolegal question: How can Snowden submit a declaration while he is effectively considered a legal enemy of the state?
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> while he is effectively considered a legal enemy of the state? We don’t really describe people as enemies of the state in America. Snowden is accused of certain crimes, and has the right to communicate with legal counsel. Such counsel could provide this attestation to a court.
- ry_ry 8y agohttps://mobile.twitter.com/realdonaldtrump/status/457314934473633792?lang=en https://mobile.twitter.com/realdonaldtrump/status/4573149344... Were he to try to return to US soil, I'm not sure Snowden would be able to rely on that being much more than a legal technicality. Especially with the current Russian climate. He has enemies within the state department, which amounts to the same thing, and any public trial would be at best politically charged.
- mikejb 8y agoThat's orthogonal, but yeah, whistleblowers aren't very well protected. They're often still charged with laws aimed against spies, which is ridiculous. The state's aim in these cases is to set an example, and avoid people being inspired to do the same. (My 'favorite' example is John Kiriakou - the only person (I'm aware of) to go to prison for the US' torture program. The one who publicized it.)
- DKnoll 8y agoA person (and other entities) can be legally considered an enemy of the state if they engage in 'hostilities' towards the US per 50 USCS § 2204. Although I think this would include people like Osama Bin Laden rather than Edward Snowden.
- xupybd 8y ago
- Theodores 8y agoThe thing is that people are no nearer to understanding why it was that this spying on the general public had to happen. Capitalism - and any other system - has to have bogeymen and terrorism as a fear, the thinking being that anything outside the system is a fate worse than death and therefore the system, in this case capitalism as we know it is better than the alternatives. We all know there aren't any 'al-qaeda' terrorists really, it certainly is not necessary to monitor everyone's phone just because of that. Going through the courts to discern whether these Stasi style systems were/are constitutional or not is noble and good on the EFF for doing these things. However we have not acknowledged why these things had to happen, we still go along with the 'al-qaeda terrorist fear' meme. The point of surveillance and letting everyone know that they are under surveillance is to stop people communicating in a way tantamount to dissent. The Catholic Church and the Stasi had these things in place, not to root out protestants or Western spies, it was always to keep people in line with their system of rule. When it comes to our own Western surveillance we somehow believe the authorities that it is to catch the terrorists, a noble cause that nobody could possibly argue with. Yet really it is to keep people in line and not dissenting. In the Bush years the powers-that-be were genuinely concerned they might have a Berlin Wall moment where people just see through the lies and decide not to stand shoulder to shoulder waving flags. Their fears were seriously unfounded though, people really were deeply wedded to the system to the point of being indoctrinated and brainwashed. No matter how feeble the phantom enemy was people went along with it, it sold newspapers and meant people didn't even dream of getting organised in some revolutionary way. Occupy Wall Street was about it, a very damp squib. Whether the details of the mass surveillance infrastructure were technically constitutional or not does not answer the bigger question regarding what the Bush government were so scared of.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoI don't think this situation requires any level of intentional conspiracy. Intelligence agencies always want to know more secrets, law enforcement wants their job to be easier, and digital media were trivial to wiretap since early beginnings. Surveillance systems like NSA's seem like something that would naturally evolve - and accelerate post 9/11, as there was suddenly lots of money available to anyone uttering the words "fighting terrorism" and "national security".
- Brotkrumen 8y agoGermany had something similar: a fact-finding committee tried to figure out what to do about NSA and our local spies spying on Germans local and abroad. Pro privacy parliamentarians wanted to rely heavily on Snowden docs, ruling party and anti-privacy required an in-person interview in Germany of Snowden to admit the docs as evidence. Of course tthey didn't wwant to guarantee Snowdens freedom while here, so that interview never happened and the docs were ignored. I bet that's going to be the NSAs play here too