6 ms·
Students can get a mortgage without proof of income https://www.theglobeandmail.com/real-estate/vancouver/canadian-banks-mortgage-guidelines-favour-foreign-home
by raverbashing 8y ago
Students can get a mortgage without proof of income https://www.theglobeandmail.com/real-estate/vancouver/canadian-banks-mortgage-guidelines-favour-foreign-home-buyers/article31869946/ https://www.theglobeandmail.com/real-estate/vancouver/canadi...
I can't imagine it can get more blatant than that
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoTypically, the problem is that they have no way of verifying the person's income if they come from abroad. The only other option is not to give them loans at all even if they put up a high down payment. On other hand, this is such a double standard. In China, I couldn't even get a credit card because I don't have a Chinese ID number even though I had a job for 9 years + lots of money in their bank.
- djrogers 8y ago> The only other option is not to give them loans at all That seems like a perfectly reasonable position to take - don’t give loans to people who don’t qualify for them.
- metildaa 8y agoUnder the current messed up ruleset, many people qualify for loans that they likely shouldn't, feeding a housing price bubble that is taking lifes necessities and pricing them out of the reach of most people.
- Joakal 8y agoTo exacerbate the issue. The bank employees can point out that house prices are going up. If person stops paying, they can claw back property and make profit. This makes sense in a bull market. That is until there's a recession and all house prices tank with banks selling at same time. But those previous employees? Made redundant in downturn. Who's fault is it for causing these losses?
- raverbashing 8y agoIt's funny how banks are liberal to give Million dollars loans to someone who has no "official" income. Sounds like there might be a bubble there. > The only other option is not to give them loans at all even if they put up a high down payment. Yeah, I don't see the problem with this.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoYou see a problem with that, the banks might not given their risk models and a chance to make money on the loan. They have shown that they generally as good credit risks, it’s just that they have no idea where their money is coming from (a legal/moral problem vs. a business one).
- charlesdm 8y agoShould banks care? If you put up $300k on a $1m property (meaning a $700k loan), and it gets foreclosed, then the bank will recover all of their money. They shouldn't care, as they're in the clear risk wise.
- selectodude 8y agoMost of these loans are one step further, where the collateral on the loan isn't the house, it's enough cash in the bank to pay off the loan in its entirety. You can get a loan with no credit score if you have the assets.
- charlesdm 8y agoWell, no problem there? However -- I do fail to see the point on why you would put up cash as collateral for a loan. Just to retain liquidity? I get why you would want to put up securities to get a loan, that is a no brainer.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoI wrote that the opposite way I intended it to be. I agree with what you said.
- dleslie 8y ago> The only other option is not to give them loans at all even if they put up a high down payment. That's an excellent position to take. Canada also has a problem with undeclared foreign income.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoWhen I was working in China, the USA had no idea where my income was coming from either. I just declared my foreign bank accounts and filled in certain lines on my tax return, but that’s it. How could they know?
- trhway 8y agoManafort thought the same. And those UBS clients too.
- selectodude 8y agoManafort got dinged because he didn't report the foreign income to the IRS at all. They didn't much care where it came from either.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoThere is huge difference between not reporting income (illegal) and not declaring where the income is from (completely legal, they don’t even ask).
- patio11 8y agoThey probably don’t much care for you or for me, but at least some people will get audited every year, at which point they have the usual remedies: information sharing agreements with foreign governments and financial institutions plus “OK, show us your paperwork.”
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoI'm not really sure how an audit of an overseas taxpayer would work. Uhm...e.g. does the IRS pay for translation from Chinese or does the taxpayer? Paper work isn't even standardized, you aren't getting a W2, it will just be random stuff you collect to prove your income. And even then, the IRS still doesn't care where your money actually came from, just that it is all reported.
- avip 8y ago>The only other option is not to give them loans at all even if they put up a high down payment This is exactly what happens - it's not easy to get a mortgage without a permanent status (that 0% of foreign students would have). A crazy downpayment would be requested upfront.
- fraudsyndrome 8y ago> On other hand, this is such a double standard. In China, I couldn't even get a credit card because I don't have a Chinese ID number even though I had a job for 9 years + lots of money in their bank. I don't get it when people point out double standards when living in different countries as if they should be equivalent in both places. Just because X country offers Y to Z people, why is it normal to expect another country to offer the same thing? Different country, different laws for different people right?
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoHmm, maybe? I mean, being a foreigner in America (USA or Canada) is pretty easy compared to being one in China, I'll definitely give you that! China also has a net emigration rate, so they aren't really geared towards having immigrants. I do like that China at least tries to reciprocate on some things, like 10 year visa durations.
- bonestamp2 8y ago> being a foreigner in America (USA or Canada) is pretty easy compared to being one in China When I moved to the US from Canada, the banks couldn't access my credit file in Canada -- even though they use the same fucking credit bureaus in both countries! I had to give AT&T $500 cash just to get a cell phone account, and another $500 cash so my wife could have an account too... even though we had already bought our iPhones in cash -- we had no debt with AT&T. They literally needed a $500 deposit in case we ran up some crazy bill with long distance calling (text and data were unlimited). With a lot of work, we were finally able to get a mortgage even though we were putting about 45% down. The bank issued us kind of trail credit card that they issue all immigrants. I ran into another consultant at a client site and we had lunch together. He was fresh off the boat from India and when he pulled out his credit card we laughed because I held up the same immigrant Visa card. Easier than China, ya... but it's pretty silly here too. How equifax here can't get my stellar credit history from equifax Canada blows my mind.
- seanmcdirmid 8y ago
- sfifs 8y ago> On other hand, this is such a double standard. China would likely prefer that it be as hard for expat Chinese to get financial access given the sheer amount of capital illicitly flowing out. However, the Vancouvers of the world want that money much like London wants Russian money. So they follow a no questions asked policy.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoTrue, but your linked article states that the down payment must be between 35 and 50 percent. That provides a huge buffer for the bank should they need to foreclose. Of course, that says nothing about where the money came from in the first place.
- pfarnsworth 8y agoI heard anecdotally that they buy a house for cash and then turn around and get a reverse mortgage/HELOC on it, leaving a lot less than 35-50% in the house.
- downandout 8y agoIt doesn't really matter, if you are only borrowing 50-65% of the value, the secondary lender will get screwed, as the first mortgage holder is first in line and gets paid fully before the second mortgage holder gets a dime. Many US banks are similar...if you have 50% to put down, nobody really cares if you make the payments or not. If you make them, great. If not, they'll foreclose, be made whole (plus lots of fees and interest), and have essentially no risk because the equity is so great and they are first in line.
- teunispeters 8y agoIt was amazingly profitable (tax dollar wise) to the previous conservative government ("BC liberals" are a conservative party) so they of course made it as smooth and as easy as possible to launder money in BC through real estate purchases. Casinos are more complex. I think there is a combination of how fast things go with law enforcement response time (bureaucracy can be very slow, especially on "white collar" crime - especially when the bureaucrats have no comprehension of how big the problem is or could be) I left Vancouver because this isn't going to end well - too much infrastructure depends on the laundering to continue, but the laundering is making it unreasonably expensive to live there. Oh, and no I don't blame any particular other country. I strongly suspect a lot of it is income displacement to avoid taxes ... a move only particularly wealthy can do. It's not hard to find some arbitrary person who needs it somewhere, pay them to hide the trail and have them represent - or one of their agents - fronting as a student or the like. Much easier if they're not from the same country who this scam is being done to, or from, I'd think. (but that's pure conjecture on my part. See CBC radio documentary "Sold!" though for a much better precis).