8 ms·
The title of this article is deceptive clickbait.[1] The problem has nothing to do with the Edge browser, it has to do with search results returned by Bing, whi
by greenyoda 8y ago
The title of this article is deceptive clickbait.[1] The problem has nothing to do with the Edge browser, it has to do with search results returned by Bing, which happens to be Edge's default search engine. If you have a new Windows 10 PC and want to download Chrome, how else could you do it besides "using Microsoft Edge to download Chrome"? So "stop using Edge to download Chrome" is not useful advice. Better advice would be to check the URL and certificate information before downloading anything from any site.
And the problem seems to have been fixed. When I search for chrome download on Bing, the top result is https://www.google.com/chrome https://www.google.com/chrome.
[1] Successful clickbait, too. Writing an article with "download Chrome" in the title apparently got them the top spot in Bing's "News about Chrome Download", so anyone who searches for "chrome download" will see this article near the top of the search results page. Very clever.
- chris_wot 8y agoIt's not irrelevant. Bing is what Microsoft chooses to use a default search engine. Edge does not warn of a malicious website. Chrome and Firefox do. This has everything to do with Edge.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoThis is an ad I once saw on Google Search which worked the same way: https://plus.google.com/u/0/115181074626403443464/posts/fSPmYYLu2pH https://plus.google.com/u/0/115181074626403443464/posts/fSPm... As I noted back in 2017, Edge flagged the destination site as malicious, Chrome did not. Warning on malicious websites is, in fact, done in Edge. But as with Chrome and Firefox, it doesn't catch every one of them.
- flipp3r 8y ago> And the problem seems to have been fixed. When I search for chrome download on Bing, the top result is https://www.google.com/chrome https://www.google.com/chrome. Which could be faked, as seen in the referenced tweet: https://twitter.com/GabrielLandau/status/1055300918101598208 https://twitter.com/GabrielLandau/status/1055300918101598208 Yes, they show the word "Ad", alongside the domain name "google.com" - except the user doesn't end up on "google.com".
- anonred 8y agoPerhaps the ad was using one of the Google redirect tricks? There’s a few google.com endpoints (if I recall) that you can abuse to redirect to arbitrary URLs.
- Sephr 8y agoAt first I suspected this as well, but apparently it was a link to itracking[.]services and Bing pre-resolved the redirect chain. You can spoof any domain you want in Bing Ads without needing an open redirect.
- edoceo 8y ago> You can spoof any domain you want in Bing Ads without needing an open redirect. Is that a bug or a feature? It seems like the kind of thing that could erode user trust
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoIt's a feature, Google allows the same. Basically advertisers want to set the links to be tracking links and stuff which may be through third parties which then redirect to their site. So both ad services allow the advertiser to display one URL while directing users to another.
- adanto6840 8y agoSurely they're doing some verification to ensure that either the redirect lands on the advertised TLD, or alternatively that you're at least "in control" of the TLD you're advertising as (similar to GAnalytics verification -- via meta tag, DNS txt entry, etc)?
- utopcell 8y agoGoogle does.
- beager 8y ago> The problem has nothing to do with the Edge browser, it has to do with search results returned by Bing, which happens to be Edge's default search engine. I think you're slicing this too thinly. This has everything to do with Edge, which is purposely configured to use a search engine that creates a liability for users. I would agree that "stop using Edge to download Chrome" is not useful and probably clickbait-y. A better guide would be "Be careful when downloading a different browser on Windows 10."
- moocowtruck 8y agothis same thing happened to my older co-worker who was using chrome and google to get firefox and he downloaded it from a top ad link that was a malware'd firefox...
- fjsolwmv 8y agoMicrosoft could just as well ship Firefox with Bing as the default search. The problem is Bing.
- saagarjha 8y agoWhy would Microsoft do this?
- Pica_soO 8y agoGlory to the hive?
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Why would Microsoft do this? Because Google Chrome is a greater threat to them than Firefox, so promoting Firefox helps them even if it hurts Edge, as long as it also hurts Chrome. Also because if they preload Firefox with Bing as the default search engine then Firefox users may leave it that way.
- gpm 8y agoI'm really not clear why they don't. Apart from driving traffic to bing, what advantage do they gain by developing edge? How does edge drive more traffic than a customized firefox? The only thing plausible thing I can think of is hoping to execute another round of embrace extend extinguish on the web, putting other desktop operating systems at a disadvantage. With google chrome's dominance that seems unlikely to work.
- Latteland 8y agoIs microsoft: dangerous together better? Microsoft's web infrastructure, including Bing and edge and advertising on their properties are not controlled by Microsoft? They could fix this. One could be pedantic and say the entire Microsoft web stack is dangerous together, if you interrupt the default flow with a different browser, different search engine or different os this wouldn't happen (cause edge is only on Windows and edge defaults to using dangerous Bing). I'm sure it sucks but the all Microsoft combination together exposes you to this.
- dang 8y agoOk, we've changed the title to the subtitle.
- jimmaswell 8y agoIt does come with Internet Explorer too, but I'm sure that also defaults to Bing.
- josteink 8y ago> If you have a new Windows 10 PC and want to download Chrome, how else could you do it besides "using Microsoft Edge to download Chrome"? Simply visit Google.com, Gmail, Youtube or any other Google-site and await the Chrome-spam 100% guaranteed to appear in any browser not Chrome. My favorite one: “Upgrade your browser”. Not misleading at all, eh? How about “no”?
- TaylorAlexander 8y agoThis is a tangent/pile-on, but this is not the only dark pattern google engages in. I absolutely do not want YouTube Red. Any software that respects the user would let you dismiss the offer with an option for “do not ask me again.” And yet, because the software is not respecting the user, YouTube asks me ad nauseum if I want to upgrade to YouTube Red. No. I do not. But I don’t get an option for no. There is something like “yes” and “maybe later.” No google. My answer is no. Please respect me enough to let me make that choice.
- fjsolwmv 8y agoAd-supported software has ads. No liking the ads and refusing to pay for the product isn't a grand moral stand.
- saagarjha 8y agoThis isn’t the same thing. Some people are happy with viewing ads in general, but are not happy with aggressive pop-ups that tell them to upgrad. In essence these alerts are saying their choice is the wrong one, even though it’s a choice that YouTube itself gave them.
- wtracy 8y agoMore specifically: "good" ads aren't modal and don't force you to click through to continue. If YouTube just mixed YouTube Red ads in with all their other ads, I doubt that anyone would be complaining. (Except for the people who want everything to be free without any ads.)
- blotter_paper 8y ago>If you have a new Windows 10 PC and want to download Chrome, how else could you do it besides "using Microsoft Edge to download Chrome"? Use Edge to download Firefox, and Firefox to download Chrome ;)
- broknbottle 8y agoJust use ninite https://ninite.com/ https://ninite.com/
- nickpsecurity 8y agoYou're making it sound pretty difficut. Just tell them to type chrome.com into address bar. Redirects to Chrome download site on Firefox. Many lay people will actually try this on their own since they assume (term).com will often work. A dangerous assumption but wouldve worked here. So, we just spread the word to use the actual URL when possible (been doing that) instead of search and that chrome.com works for Chrome.
- Scoundreller 8y agoI remember having great fun some years ago when my friend's Internet Explorer somehow broke in the Win95/98/ME days. So I tried to guess ftp servers from the DOS prompt. I think I managed to connect to ftp://ftp.opera.com and install Opera. Update: looks like it still works today. Anyone looking for a 2004 BeOS version?
- tinus_hn 8y agoYou could just get a free AOL cd at the gas station, it included Internet Explorer.
- Scoundreller 8y agoMaybe in USA.
- sureaboutthis 8y agoToward the end of the article, he asks the question, "Or is it?". That is an ongoing issue with Bing.
- robteix 8y agoThere are actually two problems here: 1. Bing allowing malicious ads 2. Edge not marking malicious sites Problem #1 has nothing to do with Edge (other than Edge using Bing by default) and I’m sure Google may let malicious ads through from time to time. But problem #2 is entirely Edge. > The malicious URL that Bing is happy to promote can’t fool Google or Firefox. When I simply type the above URL into my Firefox browser I’m faced with a bold red page declaring “Deceptive Site Ahead” completely with details and an option to go back. The recommendation to stop using Edge to download Chrome is indeed wrong though.
- detaro 8y agoEdge does mark malicious sites ("SmartScreen filter"), it just failed to have this in its index.
- dschuetz 8y agoI don't agree with you that the article is "deceptive clickbait". What is true though, whoever uses Bing for searches instead of Google gets served by subpar search results, hence the chances are great to get served malware. That is common knowledge today. Who uses Bing anyway, even on Edge? That's what the article gets wrong.