16 ms·
I like Tim Cook, I think his heart is in the right place and as much as a corporation can, Apple generally does the right thing. I was having lunch with severa
by mark_l_watson 8y ago
I like Tim Cook, I think his heart is in the right place and as much as a corporation can, Apple generally does the right thing.
I was having lunch with several lawyers at my company a few weeks ago. One of them was talking strongly about quality devices and Apple’s strong privacy stance. He literally said that we as a society should be grateful for having Apple.
- compcoffee 8y ago>He literally said that we as a society should be grateful for having Apple. Which is utterly cringeworthy. iPhone user thinks iPhone is best thing since sliced bread. News at 11.
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoI'm not usually one for fanboyism (and I say this as a full time Linux desktop and Android user) but Apple really do seem to be trying to do right by their customers in most cases. Certainly more than the competition. I've been considering switching for a while, but it seems the quality of their hardware and to some extent their software has slowly been going downhill post-Jobs.
- compcoffee 8y agoThe cringe was more related to "we as a society should be grateful to Apple". It's an utterly laughable statement. Not surprised it upset a few worshipers of the Tech Overlords. Apple, the billionaires it produced and the people it employs should be grateful to the rest of society.
- nneonneo 8y agoiTunes wasn't fantastic while Jobs was around, either. The first versions of OS X downright sucked. The build quality and aesthetic of the iPhone X rival anything from the Jobs era in my view, and the recent improvements on mobile performance have been nothing short of amazing. I feel like people get these rose-tinted glasses when they look back on past Apple products, like they were all 100% perfect or something. Truth is - they all had little issues, but they were still often miles ahead of their competition.
- joejerryronnie 8y agoMy concern with a post-Jobs Apple is not their ability to iterate on existing product lines. I'm not confidant Apple can shift paradigms and disrupt whole industries the way the did under Jobs' leadership.
- matwood 8y agoEven if Jobs was still here, I'm not confident Apple could do it again. That kind of thing is hard. One place Apple has disrupted/built an industry is with the smart watch. I was skeptical, but got a Series 2 on sale to try it out and recently got a Series 4. When I got the Series 2 I wasn't sure what I would use it for, but it's something I would miss not having now.
- danaris 8y agoYou know that happened twice, maybe three times, right? The iPod and the iPhone were it (and maybe the iPad). It's not something Apple did twice a week like clockwork while Jobs was alive, then just suddenly stopped when he died. This is exactly the kind of rose-colored glasses nneonneo was talking about.
- joejerryronnie 8y agoHere are some things I can think of off the top of my head that Jobs had a hand in during his career: - Created the personal computer industry (Apple Inc) - Revolutionized the personal computer industry (Macintosh) - Revolutionized film animation (Pixar) - Shifted the electronic device industry to minimalist industrial design (iPod) - Changed the entire music industry's distribution model (iTunes) - Completely shifted the paradigm of a cellular phone and arguably began the adoption of the mobile internet (iPhone) There are several other things people may consider visionary (candy colored iMac, getting rid of floppy drives, OSX, Newton, stuff at NeXT, tech advertising with the 1984 & Think Different campaigns, etc). I'm not even including things like the iPad, Apple Watch, Apple TV, health metrics, etc which Jobs may have been working on before his death. Clearly Jobs had lots of help along the way and is not singularly responsible for each of these things - but he's the one who oversaw and, in many cases, drove the vision. I'm no Apple fanboy and Jobs had a very dark side to his particular brand of genius, but I find it incredibly disingenuous to dismiss the impact that Jobs had on Apple and the industry in general. Tim Cook is a very solid Tech CEO, maybe even a great operational leader, but he is not a visionary leader and my concern is that Apple lost a fundamental element with the passing of Jobs.
- maroonblazer 8y ago> Apple really do seem to be trying to do right by their customers in most cases Another possibility is that they don't have to take advantage of their users' data because their business is largely a hardware business, with the software a loss-leader. It might seem like a distinction without a difference but one has to consider intent when scoring individuals and companies' moral high ground.
- soneil 8y agoI'm not sure it even boils down to doing the right thing for the customer. Apple want you as a customer. Google want you as a user. It's that simple.
- soneil 8y agoThe wording is cringeworthy, but essentially I agree with him. It doesn't need to be Apple specifically, but I'm glad we have competition. If either of Apple or Google were the only real option, we'd be much worse off than we are now. It's a shame it's come down to a duopoly, but at least they both have something to compete on.
- MrEfficiency 8y ago>Apple generally does the right thing. Except make their products affordable to low income people. Or give developers tools to develop(Cant afford the 2,000 USD upfront cost of ios dev) And pull apps off their store because they were competitive with their own apps (or helpful to their customers in a way apple doesnt like)
- leereeves 8y agoApple sells a walled garden that controls what software you can use, forces upgrades by forbidding repairs and slowing down old phones with software updates, and sells more dongles by eliminating features and changing ports in every generation of their products. I admit they are better than Google on the privacy issue, but should we be grateful for having an alternative that abuses us in different ways?
- robocat 8y agoEach of your complaints is because of a well-designed compromise (app quality/safety; preventing abrupt phone shutdown; removing a common failure point). You may disagree with the compromises, sure. PS: I own zero Apple devices (partly because of the reasons you have, not for the way you are misrepresenting those reasons).
- leereeves 8y agoApple's App Store policies are about far more than app quality or safety. Apple has banned many apps for political or financial reasons. Slowing down old phones without notice or permission wasn't the best response to aging batteries. Even Apple didn't deny it was wrong. They apologized, once they were caught. And the MagSafe connector was not a common failure point.
- drivingmenuts 8y agoPersonally, I think the MagSafe connector was bloody brilliant and I'm not giving up my mid-2015 MBP until it absolutely won't function any more, because of that feature (it's saved my MBP several times when I was a bit clumsy or forgetful). Another reason: the multiplicity of ports and bunches of things that all use USB-A.
- reaperducer 8y agoI believe there's a product, or at least a Kickstarter, to add a MagSafe-style dongle to a USB-C port.
- tinco 8y agoPerhaps it is cynicism, but I'm pretty sure this is just Apple exploiting a competitive edge, and does not necessarily reflect his own opinion, he is speaking to benefit the company. Of course, it's very nice that Apple made the decision to pick this edge, but they did it because they could not compete with Google on web services. So now they're publicly speaking to try and take the sting out of Google's edge. And that's healthy competition, the direct result will be that the consumer benefits, and I can agree we can be grateful to have these powerhouses fighting for our satisfaction.
- joejerryronnie 8y agoThis is true but Apple is also vulnerable to the same type of "political" attack. I can imagine Google railing against the evils of employing a workforce of indentured servants to assemble high profit electronic devices. Facebook could begin publicly questioning the wisdom of supporting a technocratic dictator who may be the world's worst offender of oppression through the use of data. Hopefully, Tim is going down this road with his eyes wide open - glass houses and all.
- parthdesai 8y agoI'm always baffled how even the tech-literate crowd here continues to give Apple a pass. This is the same Apple that gave up its encryptions keys to Chinese government for the servers located in China. If it actually had user's privacy in mind, it wouldn't give those up.
- MichaelMoser123 8y agoThey are trying to place themselve as the company that produces hardware versus those software guys who are after your data to complement their income. The argument here is that the hardware guy always has a proper profit margin. Always look at the profit motive, Luke! (Also they have some stake in the data business by following on those apple IDs - i would not bet on the declared principles of their chairman; also Apple is on the stock exchange, therefore under constant pressure to come out with positive growth figures)
- drb91 8y agoI would phrase it differently. I am grateful for Apple, but we should not be—asking companies to have morals is like asking rain to fall upwards. Regulation is the appropriate method for dictating companies to behave in a certain way.
- briandear 8y agoThe market is an appropriate method for dictating companies to behave in a certain way. The market could speak tomorrow and Facebook could be finished. That users are apathetic isn’t a failure of the market.
- drb91 8y agoCapitalism is not the only force in the world, as much as capitalists strain to argue.
- sonnyblarney 8y ago"I think his heart is in the right place and as much as a corporation can, Apple generally does the right thing." Don't assume moral disposition when a CEO is talking his book. Maybe Tim is really a good person, who knows? But if Tim were the CEO of Facebook he'd be singing a different tune. Don't underestimate the ability of CEO's to align their personal views with that of he company. Apple is sensing blood in the water on Google and Facebook, and this is a smart, basic PR move to go on the offensive against those companies. Now - I do think it's likely that Cook does actually believe what he is saying - so I'm not fully calling him a hypocrite or anything. But he is a business guy, and were he to be the head of a company for whom this angle would not apply, I suggest strongly he'd have a different story to tell. When businessmen speak, it's mostly 'just business'. I don't mean that cynically, just pragmatically.
- mikestew 8y agoI agree with you, but is it not better that the "talking head" follow the company line rather than their own moral compass? IOW, whether the CEO believes it or not, the company's moral compass says "we're all about privacy for the time being" and the CEO speaks as appropriate to that topic. But if it's the CEO using their personal moral compass, well, that could change with the next CEO. Additionally, the CEO might say one thing, but have a board fight them tooth and nail over it.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoAgree. The issue though is anyone - CEO or Company - taking a moral position, when really it's just a tactic to benefit themselves. The two can overlap, surely, and in 'good capitalism' they mostly do. But let's not talk about Cooks 'heart' being in the 'right place'. His 'current product strategy' is in 'the right place' :)