7 ms·
The sole problem from population contraction, is replacement tax dollars for existing entitlement-type programs that are built on a ponzi scheme approach to eve
by adventured 8y ago
The sole problem from population contraction, is replacement tax dollars for existing entitlement-type programs that are built on a ponzi scheme approach to ever larger inflows of tax revenue to support them over time.
Most of the developed world has the same problem on that front. The desperation by these countries when it comes to figuring out how to patch up the finances of those programs will increase by the year.
Robot (productivity) taxes will be one small answer. Another will be ever higher income taxes, also eventually including heavy wealth taxes (that comes last). Most of the developed or semi-developed world is starting to get hit on demographics at the same time. The weaker economic nations are being forced to respond first, as in Russia having to raise their pension ages so high it starts to cut people off at the life expectancy line (plunging Putin's popularity numbers in a rather startling fashion, which tells you how important the pension promises were). France is being forced to confront similar problems, with Macron trying to dress that up as market reforms. The US is temporarily avoiding it thanks to its ability to run absurdly high budget deficits for now.
- manfredo 8y agoI agree with the economic implications. Countries that experience an ageing population need to face the fact that they either have to raise taxes considerably, or reduce the care and benefits they extend to the elderly. I also disagree heavily with the last paragraph. Creating disincentives for automation is the last thing a country needs when its workforce is shrinking. Automating jobs is a way of expanding the amount of labor available without actually needing more people in the work force. If anything, countries that are experiencing a population decline need to invest in more automation to maintain their economic output.
- amanaplanacanal 8y agoThe US doesn't work that way. Taxes and spending have only the loosest correlation. As long as the US Dollar is the worlds reserve currency, it appears there doesn't have to be anything connecting the two. Someday, though...
- Gibbon1 8y ago> entitlement-type programs that are built on a ponzi scheme approach to ever larger inflows of tax revenue to support them over time. Stop repeating propaganda please. Entitlement programs are just simple insurance programs. There is nothing ponzi about them.
- getpost 8y agoHuh? Social Security, for example, is definitely a Ponzi scheme in the sense benefits paid out far exceed amounts previously collected, saved, and invested. Numerous government programs rely on this logic, which only works if the population of working age people is expanding. Social Security isn't a Ponzi scheme in the sense that there was fraudulent intent. Nevertheless, a lack of political will to finance current benefits does burden future generations. "Adjusting benefits downwards" won't sit too well with people who worked 30 or 40 years and expect to enjoy a certain standard of living. Why Was Social Security Designed Like A Ponzi Scheme? https://www.forbes.com/sites/johngoodman/2015/08/13/why-was-social-security-designed-like-a-ponzi-scheme/#2474944c76c5 https://www.forbes.com/sites/johngoodman/2015/08/13/why-was-... Is Social Security a Ponzi scheme? "Social Security has a funding gap equal to 0.7 percent of GDP over the next 75 years. We could wipe that gap out by lifting the payroll tax cap (right now, payroll taxes only apply to the first $107,000 of income) or by adjusting benefits downwards." https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/ezra-klein/post/is-social-security-a-ponzi-scheme/2011/08/25/gIQA2t0dcL_blog.html?noredirect=on&utm_term=.15de160e7094 https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/ezra-klein/post/is-soci...
- Gibbon1 8y ago> Social Security, for example, is definitely a Ponzi scheme Social Security is an insurance program. That you don't understand how insurance programs work is your problem.
- chrisbrandow 8y agoThe other difference is that a true Ponzi scheme is fundamentally unsustainable, whereas social security is not. It may need adjustments, it’s not like you have exponentially growing divergence.
- TheCoelacanth 8y agoIt's not just entitlement programs, retirement in general is a Ponzi scheme. The only way that anyone can retire is to rely on the productivity of people who are still working. Saving up money for retirement does not avoid this. Your saved up money just lets you buy someone else's future productivity, you can't actually live on it.
- imtringued 8y agoExactly! Imagine a future in which 100% of the population is in retirement. Who is going to run the farms that produce the food? The only way to get food is by stockpiling it during your working age and somehow preserving it for decades until you have reached your retirement age. This clearly isn't viable so instead we have kids that take care of us when we become old.
- 8bitsrule 8y ago"Ponzi scheme approach ..." Like the stock market, then. And pension funds.