10 ms·
I think blaming "intellectual property protection" abstracts this a bit too much. There's real human effort on the other side, not just a concept. Companies no
by majormajor 8y ago
I think blaming "intellectual property protection" abstracts this a bit too much. There's real human effort on the other side, not just a concept.
Companies not wanting things to be repaired is a major inhibitor of repair. Those companies push for those laws, but they often do other things too to make it hard.
- rayiner 8y agoLet's put the blame where it belongs: on the consumer. If there was a market demand for repairable products, companies would make them. It's not like Apple is using IP law to keep you from repairing an iPhone. If people wanted repairable products, there would be demand for them. (I have a dryer I was going to throw away until my father in law spent $50 replacing the belt. Now I have a stupid old dryer that doesn't match my fancy new Samsung washer that I feel too guilty to replace.)
- jacobush 8y agoMake a cost-benefit calculation and maybe you won't feel as bad throwing it out. It will depend on financing and electricity costs which way is cheaper in the long run. :-)
- mmt 8y agoI think you (and the OC) will find that, with dryers, there's really not much room to gain efficiency. It's not as if modern dryers are using a heat pump instead of burning gas [1] or "burning" electricity with resistive heating. [1] and natural gas tends to be cheaper than electric heat pumps, especially nowadays
- jacobush 8y agoThat sounds reasonable, except there is an almost 10 year old Miele dryer in my apartment, with a heat pump. Here's their top of the line current offering in the USA: https://www.mieleusa.com/domestic/tumble-dryers-1575.htm?mat=10666300&name=TWI180_WP_Eco%26Steam_WiFiConn@ct https://www.mieleusa.com/domestic/tumble-dryers-1575.htm?mat... Natural gas dryer I never even heard of, but I am not surprised - when I visited Pennsylvania I saw quite a lot of clever uses of natural gas.
- mmt 8y ago> there is an almost 10 year old Miele dryer in my apartment, with a heat pump. I stand corrected. I'd be curious if it's actually any more efficient, especially if the heat it's pumping comes from gas, oil, or resistive heating (in the winter, assuming cold climate). It can appear more efficient, of course, if one only measures the dryer itself, but that wouldn't be apples-to-apples. > Here's their top of the line current offering in the USA $1800 is an eye-watering price. That'd buy me 3750 hours of 4kW [1] dryer usage, so buying it for long-term savings alone is hardly an obvious choice. > clever uses of natural gas Raising temperature by burning it seems like the least clever use of natural gas (or any combustible). [1] I figure the least efficient resistive heating dryer is 5kW and that Miele is 1kW.
- jacobush 8y agoNo, all fair points. For my case, I figure it has in recent years started to give a return. I had to repair it (myself) with parts for $40 once. It has certainly been running for much more than 4000 hours. Looking at the greater picture, the power mix here is about 50% nuclear and hydro, the rest from burning garbage in combined heat (heats the whole town) and power. You can tell it's not using as much power as our previous dryer, the bathroom would get sauna hot if you closed the bathroom door and also the clothes would take longer to dry - with the Miele there isn't much difference with the door open or closed either in drying time or room temperature. It's also less wear and tear on the clothes. The clothes come out consistently "dry" instead of between "humid" and "extra crisp" with the old dryer. Stepping away even further from the picture, I actually prefer hanging to dry (clothes don't wear out as fast and I actually enjoy the slight stiffness of textiles hung to dry, a childhood thing I guess) but my (soon to be ex-, thank God) wife swears by the dryer, so... a dryer it was. And I have to admit, it's damn useful at times.
- lorenzhs 8y agoYou can buy a heat pump drier for less than $500 in Germany, with the premium brands' models around $700. Their energy consumption is about half that of a condensation drier. At German electricity prices (ca 25ct/kWh), it's not hard to see why heat pump driers have gained significant market share. And for the record, the heat pump is used to dehumidify the processing air. The air is still heated using electricity. It just doesn't waste as much heat.
- abdullahkhalids 8y agoIndividual people would also happily buy cheap cars that are gas guzzlers - yet, governments have made laws mandating car efficiency. This is point of governments. To change the incentives for individuals so markets optimize for global good. This is not a hard concept.
- colemannugent 8y ago>This is point of governments. To change the incentives for individuals so markets optimize for global good. This is not a hard concept. Huh, this whole time I thought the point of governments was to protect individual rights. TIL /s
- adrianlz 8y agoYes it is. And they do that by imposing responsibilities on the same individuals they are protecting. Also there are more rights to be protected than what is trivially obvious from an individual point of view - like the right of our children to breathe air without gas masks (exaggeration intended for emphasis)
- pathseeker 8y agoThat's an excellent example of bad governance though. The government instead should have priced in the externalities of gasoline directly into the gas and then allowed consumers to decide if they wanted to spend money on better gas mileage. Customers would give a significant amount of demand for better gas mileage themselves if gas was $7/gallon. The reason the current approach is a failure is that everyone who doesn't care about efficiency can skirt the whole mandate by buying a truck/suv that gets a whopping 15mpg in town[1]. The popularity of trucks in the US speaks to how bone-headed the approach of mandating efficiency in cars is. The even worse part about not correctly taxing the actual externality is that people think they are doing good things for the environment by buying new high gas mileage cars and then unwinding that whole thing with a cheap flight to Paris or by constantly having things shipped across the country for them. >To change the incentives for individuals so markets optimize for global good. This is not a hard concept. Yep, not a hard concept but the implementation is where everything went completely to shit. 1. https://fueleconomy.gov/feg/bymodel/2017_Ram_1500_Pickup.shtml https://fueleconomy.gov/feg/bymodel/2017_Ram_1500_Pickup.sht...
- convolvatron 8y agoi do fabrication work, and sometimes repair. desperate people wander up to my shop and ask to get things fixed. when they find out it might cost as much as 3 hours at minimum wage, they often wander away.
- Scoundreller 8y agoBy minimum wage, you mean the shop hourly rate, right? Or is your minimum wage particularly high?
- convolvatron 8y agono, I mean local legal minimum wage, not including materials, overhead, consumables, or taxes.
- derefr 8y agoI can't see that being a workable equilibrium-state. In my mind, if there was an uprising in market demand for repairable product, companies would actually unleash a massive industry-wide astroturf campaign to convince customers that repairable products are a bad idea.
- raquo 8y agoLet's not blame consumers for economic externalities, it's the government's job to address those.
- qwertay 8y agoExactly. If it wasn't for the economic systems set up by the government there would be no reason to make repairing things hard because that is simply a byproduct of the current system that is controlled by the government.
- TaylorAlexander 8y agoI’m the parent poster here and I absolutely do not think it is the job of the government to solve problems like this. Consumers need to stop giving money to corporations whose only motivation is profit.
- raquo 8y ago> I absolutely do not think it is the job of the government to solve problems like this Well then, I guess we'll have to watch as this problem will remain unsolved. If you want an unregulated market, people will do what they want, and they happen to want to give money to corporations whose only motivation is profit, because they get direct benefit from those transactions. Like cheap disposable halloween costumes, to take your own example. Government has addressed economic externalities countless times with laws restricting various types of pollution, funding public transit, public health, education, etc. It is most definitely the government's job to fix such externalities by adjusting incentives on third party effects. No one else can achieve that. Maybe you think this disposable-products externality is somehow special, but I don't really see a case for that.
- eiaoa 8y ago> Let's put the blame where it belongs: on the consumer. If there was a market demand for repairable products, companies would make them. It's not like Apple is using IP law to keep you from repairing an iPhone. If people wanted repairable products, there would be demand for them. People make decisions along more than one axis. I'd say there's a demand, it's just that it's not prioritized the most highly. And I don't think this can be blamed on consumers. Have you seen any marketing that touts repairability? Companies have judged that they profit by selling products that are less reliable and less reparable, since that means they can make more sales. I can't find the link now, but I read an article that explained that Whirlpool has a cleverly designed racket to sell unreliable, unrepairable products and keep customers coming back: they own almost all the washing machine brands. If you hate your Whirlpool because it broke down after a couple years, you vow never to buy that brand again. So you buy a Maytag and it's the exact same machine from the exact same factory, just with different markings and styling.
- TaylorAlexander 8y agoI did blame the consumer. We get what we are willing to accept and so far we keep buying unrepairable materials that quickly become trash. I made that statement in my original comment. We must be willing to pay niche creators more for doing work that reduces our impact on the world, and so far people haven’t been willing to do much of that. Sadly though the corporations control our communication mediums and everyone is taught to blindly consume. It’s hard to fight the programming.
- 0xcde4c3db 8y ago> If there was a market demand for repairable products, companies would make them. That sounds very nice, but I see a few practical implementation problems that reinforce each other: 1) Market demand for a product that doesn't exist is an undefined value, and estimating its hypothetical value ranges in reliability from back-of-the-envelope to astrology 2) Economies of scale often require that total demand reach a threshold for a product to even have a chance to be profitable/competitive, i.e. there is some demand below which vendors are effectively forced to round it down to zero. 3) For high-tech products especially, a handful of big vendors agreeing on the way things are done can create massive network effects among suppliers that make it unduly expensive or outright infeasible for an erstwhile competitor to do things any other way. For example, good luck building a smartphone with leaded chip packages instead of leadless (a decision having a great deal to do with concerns about reliability, repairability, and component reuse).
- ay 8y agoI think it colors the happening with the probably inexistent emotion/intent. Think of it in IT terms. Making and supporting a single high performance monolith is easier than taking care of a zoo of interoperable and interchangeable micro services... Or was it supposed to be the other way round ? ;-)