22 ms·
US Announces Withdraw From Postal Treaty
- godzillabrennus 8y agoA friend helped the Wall Street Journal expose the damage this treaty was doing to his small business in the United States as it tried to fend off counterfeiters. https://www.wsj.com/articles/this-subsidy-for-china-is-dumb-as-a-post-1517963275 https://www.wsj.com/articles/this-subsidy-for-china-is-dumb-... Seems like a win for American innovation if you care about that thing. Seems like China is going to get hurt by this change which is bad for globalization if you are into that thing.
- paulsutter 8y agoGlobalization is about an even playing field, not one-sided concessions and subsidies
- colechristensen 8y agoThe idea of free trade/globalization is everyone benefiting from the efficiency of each place doing the work it can do most efficiently. Iowa corn and Swiss fine machinery and Arab oil and all sorts of things where one place can do something better and cheaper because of the nature of the place. Poverty (cheap labor) and treaties (cheap postage) shouldn't be the drivers of this efficiency because they aren't caused by fundamental differences, just political ones.
- raquo 8y agoBut the issue here is not the differential in efficiencies. It's China receiving subsidies from the US because it was considered a developing country in 1969. It's not anymore, it's a global superpower now, it can pay its own postage.
- baldfat 8y agoNo it has no bearing on China. It is the same policy with Switzerland. You get the international package to America we pay for the final delivery. Pay for a package to Switzerland and Switzerland pays for the final delivery. It was suppose to be a wash for both parties. China just got a much better deal. Cost me more to mail a package the next state away then for me to get a package delivered from China. Now you have to pay for Switzerland delivery and then the domestic cost. Wish and EBay from China is now bye bye.
- nkurz 8y agoEBay from China is now bye bye. Why would this change the be end of direct shipping from China? Currently (rounded off numbers) the cost of shipping a 2 lb (1 kg) package within the US is about $7, and the cost of shipping such a package from China to a US address is about $2. The obvious solution would be that the Chinese shipment ends up costing $9 (current Chinese rate of $2 to the US border, plus $7 standard US shipping). The Chinese shipping would thus end up $2 more than the US. Presumably there would be lots of cases where the $2 greater shipping is offset by lower price of the item?
- baldfat 8y agoI can order 8 recycling batteries for $2.99 and have them shipped to my house. That is a loss of $4. They are looking at an increase of $7 at least. BTW when I ship a small box 2 pound of cookies to my son from his mom it cost me around $10.
- nkurz 8y agoSure, certain things will no longer be feasible. My doubt was that these less-than-the-cost-of-shipping items were the bulk of the current direct-from-China Ebay orders, and even if they were, I was doubting that there was not a market for slightly more expensive items. For the US cost, a "Priority Mail Small Flat Rate Box" is $7.20 between any two US addresses, and a "Priority Mail Flat Rate Envelope" is $6.70. If you don't use one of these, the postage will likely will be slightly more.
- breerly 8y agoCan’t have real free trade with central-banking and fiat, must have hard global money.
- wbl 8y agoThe biggest reduction in global poverty we've seen is due to outsourcing to China. Don't you care about starving Chinese peasants?
- pkaye 8y agoI'm sure there are plenty of billionaires in China that can do more for them.
- jarfil 8y agoDepends. Are they so desperate that they want to go to war, or are they rather becoming more of a middle class that wants to play the newest video games?
- tomohawk 8y agoBefore WW I, France and Germany were each others largest trading partners. Trade and prosperity are orthogonal to war.
- notfromhere 8y agoTrade wasn't anywhere as big as it is now; most trade was within internal colonies, not externally.
- Tsubasachan 8y agoHow many wars has China instigated in the last 30 years though? Seems to me the region is shifting to accommodate the new power balance quite nicely.
- oblio 8y agoI'm not sure about video games, but they do seem to crave mobile phones and luxury goods :D
- baldfat 8y ago> due to outsourcing to China No it is the demand for better working conditions and wages. That helps the local Chinese and American workers. Oh that's right labor unions are evil????
- dTal 8y agoAnd yet, if the profits can be prevented from all floating to the top, globalisation would appear on the surface to be an excellent way of redressing global inequality. Massive international wage gaps will be perceived by the market as an exploitable inefficiency, which over time will be ironed out. Or, to put it another way, if two people wish to trade, it must be in both of their interests. If I, as a westerner, go to a third world country and buy a bunch of stuff that from my perspective is cheap but from their perspective is expensive, we both end up happy. What's so terrible about that? (Of course where it falls down is where labor is cheaper because of poor worker protections and exploitative practices, in which case it constitutes an end-run around the labor laws of the richer party. But they are the ones that should be upset, not the poorer party, whose labor laws would be terrible regardless of exploitation)
- anonuser123456 8y ago'Labor laws' is a bad argument, particularly in poor developing nations. If you enforce labor laws in developing countries, the cost of production will be high enough that industry doesn't develop. At that point, the people there have no industry and are much worse off (e.g. a sweatshop is better than subsistence farming). A better argument is 'labor choice'. Individuals need to have the ability to choose their circumstance. If they can choose, and choose freely, over time the whole society can ratchet up their standard of living by making these choices at the margin.
- kingraoul3 8y agoThat rosy picture is totally divorced from the actual historical course of Capitalist development.
- icebraining 8y agoOn the contrary, it's debunking the rosy picture that developing economies can afford developed-economy levels of worker protection.
- 8y ago
- Tsubasachan 8y agoI want to remind everyone that Chinese economy became what it is today because European, American and Japanese companies invested trillions in China. It was a Republican president who kicked it all off. A policy decision of pure capitalism.
- boomboomsubban 8y agoThose areas made far more than they invested, and China needed that huge investment because those three areas had already spent a century exploiting it for profit.
- JPKab 8y agoNo, China needed that investment because Mao and his communist policies held China back for decades. But feel free to mouth the CCP line of China being a great victim.
- boomboomsubban 8y agoFor a start, things before 1950 still happened. Even during the decades you admit happened, those areas refused to acknowledge the existence of China, making trade impossible. Early Maoist policy hadn't helped matters, but it's pretty hard to argue American, Japanese, and European policy hadn't already left them in an incredibly shitty position.
- awnfuron 8y agoAre you saying that China was not a victim? They literally had millions of civilian deaths in WWII. I've seen figures from 14 million to 20 million. Never mind the destructive effects of western imperialism up to that point. As for Mao holding back China, no doubt there were big problems. But the greatest increases in life expectancy at birth came under Mao [1] and his push to greatly expand access to medical care and education in rural areas. That was itself an investment which set the stage for future growth. (It's a lot easier to get things done when your people aren't dying at age 45.) [1] https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.LE00.IN?locations=CN https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.LE00.IN?location...
- jamesknelson 8y agoI’m not sure if Swiss fine machinery is the best example here. What is it about the nature of Switzerland that makes it a more natural place to create fine machinery then anywhere else? Similarly, using American corn as an example of how free trade should work is pretty underhanded. There’s a ridiculous amount of subsidies there, and the US doesn’t have any qualms with dumping the resulting product on international markets.
- unfunco 8y agoThe nature of the place in the context of Swiss watches could mean the établissage system.
- yourapostasy 8y agoI had to look up that term [1], thanks for introducing me to it. I'm still not sure how Switzerland the geographic place intrinsically leads to more efficient watch-making, as Shenzen and other Chinese factory cities make copious use of établissage in many different industries. Also, Apple's offshored Chinese manufacturing demonstrates that extremely high quality hardware manufacturing is not ethno-culturally-bound, and can be successfully transmitted through a corporate culture. Ricardo's comparative economic advantage in Net age-birthed industries seems increasingly more hand-wavium the further away I get from intrinsically geographically-tied economic inputs like mineral resources, fresh water, salt water fish migration paths, or latitude-dependent agriculture, etc., and the further one transits away from historical network effects like Swiss watch-making, Silicon Valley software-writing, or Belgian diamond-polishing, etc. The mathematical and empirical analyses of comparative advantage [2] [3], as well as great explanations about it [4], don't seem to address extremely complex goods with very high cognitive input factors, like semiconductors, industrial machinery, bio-pharma products, avionics, spacecraft, high-end electronics manufacturing, fracking, cloud services, search engines, e-commerce, etc., and I suspect comparative advantage breaks down as we evolve those and similar economic areas because ceteris paribus, there is no natural, lasting advantage one nation comparatively holds over another on human cognitive power (which I celebrate). In all those areas, there are leaders, but not so much and to such a comparative degree that they decisively elbow out other nations from economically attempting to enter those industries now or in the future. The Sudan might be a cognitive desert right now compared to Palo Alto or Shenzen, but there is nothing structurally preventing them from turning into a powerhouse in the future (on a multi-generational timescale) to contend with, as say there is with them turning into the next corn-production hub like Iowa, or oil-producer like Saudi Arabia or the fracking Permian Basin. [1] https://www.watch-wiki.net/index.php?title=Etablissage https://www.watch-wiki.net/index.php?title=Etablissage [2] https://www.dartmouth.edu/~rstaiger/Bernhofen%20and%20Brown%20AER.pdf https://www.dartmouth.edu/~rstaiger/Bernhofen%20and%20Brown%... [3] https://www.nber.org/papers/w17969 https://www.nber.org/papers/w17969 [4] https://www.pauldeng.com/teaching/intecon/IE_Fall2011_Lecture%202.pdf https://www.pauldeng.com/teaching/intecon/IE_Fall2011_Lectur...
- anonuser123456 8y agoCheap labor/poverty should absolutely drive free trade, at least if you are interested in improving the human condition. People in impoverished nations choose to work in sweatshops because the alternative is so much worse; prostitution, indentured servitude, being completely destitute etc.
- icebraining 8y agoAgreed; though that must be actually a choice. There have been cases where governments have made the alternatives worse to push people into "progress".
- justinmchase 8y agoI disagree. This incentivizes the fostering of an environment where these are the only choices available to people. It does not help laborers anywhere in the world to exploit labor and further weaken places where labor has already organized and achieved protection. This is a fundamental failure of capitalism and a particularly harmful neo-liberal belief.
- zanny 8y agoIts the only choice available because the previous means of survival was at best subsistence farming. And it isn't guaranteed to happen, but impoverished countries will never enter modern society if they are just isolated from it for labor protections sake. The trickle of money from the pockets of capitalists into the dictators of Indochina in exchange for functionally slave labor is still better than if these countries had nothing to offer the world at all. You would want the optimistic capitalist means to uplift the third world to be simple investment - you take a country with nothing to offer and no resources, invest money in it to educate its people and develop its infrastructure, and then you would have their substantially improved productivity to profit off. But that has never happened on just the backs of dollars because there is no way to risk manage that kind of arrangement. It almost always comes second to bombs or prophets as a way to provide that collateral - even if the country fails to recoup the investment, you can pillage the natural resources or convert its people into adherents of your own culture. Because those acting in self interest are approaching a scenario where the other party has nothing to offer (except idle hands) and you have everything.
- complexmango 8y agoI once believed this as well, via one of my degrees (economics). It turned out to be contradicted by reality. Ricardo and Adam Smith argued that the consumer surplus gains of free trade for the higher labor market would be greater than the losses sustained in producer surplus in the same market. I.e. that American consumers reap more $$ from imported foreign cars than American workers/business lose. However, since then its become obvious that the population that loses jobs cares a LOT more than consumers do about their cars being a few $$ cheaper (e.g. Donald Trump won Michigan and Ohio). In other words - political differences DO matter. Perhaps economics should return to its previous name - Political Economy - in order to actually describe the real world again.
- awakeasleep 8y agoSquare that idea with the differences in national labor law for us, please?
- adwhit 8y agoGlobalization is a hegemonic project of the West, best understood as a means to transfer capital from the economic peripheries to the imperial core, and has tended to wreak havoc on developing countries that have exposed themselves to it. China has been very sensible to ignore the dogma about free trade and to exploit weaknesses and loopholes in trade treaties when they find them.
- secfirstmd 8y agoVery true. In reality this is following the model South Korea, Japan took.
- kingraoul3 8y agoAnd the U.S.!
- krona 8y agoHmm. It might be possible for one person to create wealth without another person losing it. Almost as though it wasn't a zero-sum game. Just a theory.
- adwhit 8y agoThis is true. Nothing to do with what I said, but, it is true. It isn't what happens at the moment. Every dollar of growth worldwide is subtracted many times over from our environmental commons. At the moment the global economy is a heavily negative-sum game.
- CodeWriter23 8y agoPlease illustrate one example of how someone (not the Fed firing up the presses) can make money without someone else giving them money.
- krona 8y agoI didn't mention money. You don't need to have read The Wealth of Nations to know that it's possible to increase the GDP of a country without decreasing the overall savings. Service driven economies are the best example of this.
- A2017U1 8y agoYou would have to eliminate all government policy to get rid of subsidies. There a million ways around every clause in a 1000 page free trade agreement. It's just not possible. I'm a supporter of liberal trade between all countries but you've got to be honest that pure "free" trade just ain't happening while there's a few hundred individual countries on Earth
- ryanmarsh 8y agoI hear you but if it costs $3 to drop ship something from China to CONUS but $4 for me to send it within CONUS I’m not sure how we can say it’s “not one-sided concessions and subsidies” I get the argument of globalization but I just don’t see it playing out how people say it’s supposed to.
- GlobalFrog 8y agoThat is the theory. I might be pessimistic, but it looks to me that everyone claims that one want that even playing field and at the same time, hides as much subsidies as possible to be able to protect ones own industries. Europe is heavily subsidizing its agriculture. The US are heavily subsidizing anything that has a link to anything military and oil. And others are doing the same. True, a few markets have been freed and commerce has increased, but an enormous amount of industries are helped by governments who like to criticize the subsidies of the others. By the way, there was a nice article last year about how the US are subsidizing the oil and fossil fuel industries in two ways: first by direct subsidies (about $20 billions each year and the "hidden" one about the cost of carbon emissions which can be estimated at $200 billions per year (which is real money on the carbon trading market : the government pays for the carbon emitted by its industries). (https://www.forbes.com/sites/ucenergy/2017/02/01/the-200-billion-fossil-fuel-subsidy-youve-never-heard-of/#3f18de56652b https://www.forbes.com/sites/ucenergy/2017/02/01/the-200-bil...) It is interesting to see that the "Clean Power Plan" of the previous administration was made to allow for levelling the playing field more or less by removing those hidden subsidies, and that the current administration destroys it. And that is not even including the costs of global warming that will impact the future for todays actions. So to sum up, the supposed efficiency of the markets seems to me like an illusion, or at least, an ideal that will be never reached because it allways allows for cheating. Same for the postal union of this topic : for years, the US had a net gain financially from it and it didn't seem to bother them. Now, it is China that has this net gain and they are not behaving differently than the US did for many years by trying to preserve this advantage.
- neltnerb 8y agoI don't think anyone sensible would fault China for taking advantage of something that is advantageous for their businesses, nor for them to advocate for it. It would be irrational for them not to, the subsidies exist so obviously any reasonable business would use them. Nonetheless, it's clearly not in the interest of US businesses. The US is not obligated to provide subsidies that, due to the scale of trade using this tool, demonstrably favor Chinese small businesses over those in the US and distort the market. I'd much rather see the market made more balanced by charging the same prices for shipping than by tariffs. At least that's a real cost. Though I have the ulterior motive of thinking charging full price for air freight will reduce carbon emissions and inefficient supply chains.
- justinmchase 8y agoI may be cynical but I don't believe this. I think its more about producing goods using more exploitable workers and resources. If all countries had the same worker and environmental protections and same degree of unionization, aka an actual level playing field, then maybe. But instead its more about exploitation and breaking organized labor unions.
- tmaly 8y agoI kept hearing the claim that the US Post Office was losing money on items shipped by Amazon. So I asked the Postman delivering my Amazon package on a Sunday, and he confirmed that indeed the Post Office was being paid far less on a per package basis for Amazon deliveries than the regular rate. In the case of this Postal Treaty, it seems like the Post Office is losing money on delivering these <= 4 pound packages from China. The US Post Office is struggling enough, I think pulling out of this treaty is a good thing if it can help them.
- CodeWriter23 8y agoThere’s a little more nuance to it. The Postal Accountability and Enhancement Act of 2006 [1] is the major contributor to USPS’ ongoing financial issues. That act requires USPS to maintain a 75 year reserve for retirement and medical benefits. Other agencies including the Armed Forces max out at 20 years by comparison. 1. https://www.congress.gov/bill/109th-congress/house-bill/6407 https://www.congress.gov/bill/109th-congress/house-bill/6407
- geezerjay 8y agoWhat about customers and companies not located within the US or China? It seems that the extra cost of doing business will force all of us to do business elsewhere.
- fzeroracer 8y agoWhat about American innovation that relies on certain parts from China, such as the entire electronic industry which we operate in?
- nostromo 8y agoThey should pay the cost of shipping their parts from China to the US without a subsidy from the US taxpayer.
- keithnoizu 8y agoseems like this will backfire if we ever want to access the emerging Chinese consumer market.
- gruez 8y agoI find it sad how the US will be "punished" for righting a wrong, because Chinese has gotten so used to the status quo of "wrong".
- mistermann 8y agoThis has been a big part of the motivational story all along, but what would we sell to the Chinese, and how does that compare to what they sell to us (with or without unfairly subsidized shipping)?
- turtlecloud 8y agoChinese will not want to buy foreign stuff. If looking at history, the British had to force opium down the Chinese in order to get them to trade tea. The main exception is in luxury products like Gucci bags, iPhones and LV.
- fzeroracer 8y agoOf course you realize that this change will likely disproportionately affect the poor and middle-class (who will see a sharp rise in shipping costs) as well as smaller businesses who rely on thin margins to survive. The cost of $300 million per year as quoted in the article seems like peanuts compared to some of the other actions this administration has burdened tax payers with.
- Abishek_Muthian 8y agoWould the outcome of these negotiations at-least end up creating a path to coin a universally accepted definitions of 'Developing Country' & 'Developed Country'? Is it HDI, industry or by Military Strength Index? If MSI is taken into account, then India & China are among the most developed nations!
- sgift 8y agoI wouldn't hold my breath. The discussions about developed/developing are probably as old as the distinction itself and (as evidently shown here) many people have to win or loose depending on the classification of a country.
- matt4077 8y agoNo, they won't. These terms just aren't used any more. That's partly because of the euphemism treadmill, and on the colonial history of these terms. More importantly: the real world does not conform to any such arbitrary differentiation into a single binary variable. There just isn't any need for such a classification anyway. If you want to index something to a country's wealth, just use any per-capita economic measure and be done with it. GNP is fine, I'm sure it wouldn't make much of a difference if you used iPhones/per million or the Big Mac Index, instead.
- jscholes 8y agoDoes your friend get anything if I pay to read the article?
- Theodores 8y agoIt helps to understand the history of the postal system, which was archaic and impractical until Sir Rowland Hill came along with The Penny Black: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rowland_Hill https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rowland_Hill The basic principle is a simple one, a letter could be sent to any address in the UK at the universal rate. There would be no surcharges just because you lived in a remote part of Wales. Equally there would be no discount because you lived next to the sorting office in London and wanted to send a letter to the next street. In the UK we did celebrate Rowland Hill and his work, sadly times have changed and successive Conservative governments have undermined the universal postal service by privatisation and trying to make it 'better' with 'competition'. Hence, rather than one Royal Mail van delivering letters and parcels there is now a small fleet of other delivery vans and outsourced casual labour 'gig economy' type delivery options. It is not more efficient to send six different vans out to a small village, each of them delivering one or two items when you could have just the one Royal Mail van carrying a few dozen parcels. Moving on from 1837 to today where ecommerce and email has changed things, there is the 'ePacket', not very well understood by most end consumers. Here is an article on Shopify that helps explain the fundamentals: https://www.shopify.co.uk/blog/epacket-delivery-explained-everything-you-need-to-know-about-epacket-shipping https://www.shopify.co.uk/blog/epacket-delivery-explained-ev... Now I am no fan of the 'evils of global capitalism', however, I believe that the work done by China Post and their partners in 30+ countries is very much in the spirit of 'the Penny Black'. If your business in the West does have product made in China for good reasons, e.g. that is where your supply chain is, then you want to get your products to customers in good time. Why send a crate of product to your local warehouse to then have people then resend that on to customers when you can have a pick and pack operation in China? This is particularly the case if you are wanting to offer your product to people internationally. For instance, Australia. If you have production facilities in China and then have a head office and warehouse in the UK, you can't realistically sell to the Australian market if it takes weeks for your parcels from the UK to get there, inevitably spending a week doing nothing in the Netherlands en-route. It makes customer service a non-starter. What you really want, and what your customer really wants is the China Post ePacket service and no extra trip for your products around the planet. This applies for premium products people want, not the forged knock-off product that people berate Amazon for. ePacket helps the small to medium sized business compete against the giants of industry that can afford their own planes. There is no 'win' for American innovation here, this is like a 'tariff' in that it is actually a 'tax' on American consumers. ePacket was as bit as innovative as 'the Penny Black' and it facilitates trade on a level playing field. I am sure that knee-jerk reactions will mod-down my opinions on this, however, the ePacket and how we got here is not understood that well and going Donald Trump on parcel delivery is not going to solve the problems and frictions that genuinely exist with the status quo.
- baldfat 8y ago> bad for globalization No it just was a bad policy. It has to be a win/win for both sides. Currently this was a bad deal for America. Prepare for things to cost much more now in regards to electronics.
- atomi 8y agoThis is a nice anecdote. But what about the mass of consumers who will now have to pay a markup for the exact same product from an importer?
- Loic 8y agoThey will pay more because currently the cost is partially covered by the USPS. Such treaty makes sense in two cases: - the cost of recovery is high. 140 years ago, doing the accounting for all the parcels, letters sent from France to the US would have cost and from the US to France to then "balance" the accounts would have been way higher than the recovered money from one party. - the traffic is balanced, that is, both countries send/receive approximately the same numbers of parcels/letters each way, each year. Once these two assumptions do not hold any more, it makes sense to reconsider the situation. This is a question of balance.
- _red 8y agoThat cost is now just properly being paid by those wanting those goods. Previously that cost was being subsidized by all USPS users (and taxpayers via bond underwriting, tax breaks given to USPS, etc).
- SilasX 8y agoIt is 100% reasonable to have to pay more for shipping when a good has to travel a farther, less convenient voyage and go through customs. Anything else viciously incentivizes overuse of transportation and puts an uncompensated load on border protection.
- SilasX 8y agoI would love to hear a reasonable counterpoint on this.
- justinmchase 8y agoThey will be incentivized to pay for similar American goods and services which will be better for the economy in general.
- 8y ago
- api 8y agoThe Chinese are nationalists. Xi Jinpeng is more nationalistic than Trump. They're not globalists. They've been pretending to play the globalist game to build their economy. You can't really blame them for it, but the rest of the world (not just the USA) is waking up to it. (Fairer trade is literally the one thing I agree with Trump on...)
- forapurpose 8y agoIt will hurt everyone, as a basic fact of economics: 1. American innovators buying components from overseas, which include many on HN and in SV, will now have to pay more, reducing their ability to innovate. 2. American consumers will have to pay more. 3. American consumers will have less innovative products, as their ability to get innovative products from other countries will be reduced, and as innovators in both the U.S. (see #1 and #4) and in other countries will be hamstrung. 4. American innovators will face less competition, which is certainly not what leads to innovation; it leads to profit-taking based on market power, not meritocratic competition. 5. Reduced international cooperation and trade will reduce American innovators ability to sell abroad; the U.S. is only 5% of the world's population; the other 95% of the market is elsewhere. Cooperation and trade will not only be reduced as a direct effect, but also as a result of the U.S. appearing to be an unreliable partner, and as a result of other countries responding in kind by pulling out of treaties when they find any problems. 6. As reduced trade hurts economies here and abroad, Americans will pay more, have fewer people to sell to, resulting in lower wages and fewer jobs. Finally, the greatest American innovation is democracy, the belief that all men are created equal and that's what leads to prosperity. That innovation has resulted in an explosion of peace and liberty unlikely anything the world has ever seen, and it has, as a secondary side effect, brought an explosion of prosperity unlike anything the world has ever seen. The U.S. is now purposefully killing that innovation.
- malvosenior 8y agoThis is the removal of market manipulation (subsidies on shipping). We should see more innovation because the market can act freely now. For instance, now that China will have to pay for their full shipping, some product may increase in cost to the point where they could be manufactured and sold in the US, spurring innovation. The fewer artificial market constraints the better. > Finally, the greatest American innovation is democracy, the belief that all men are created equal and that's what leads to prosperity. That innovation has resulted in an explosion of peace and liberty unlikely anything the world has ever seen, and it has, as a secondary side effect, brought an explosion of prosperity unlike anything the world has ever seen. Yeah, I don't know about that. Maybe in the US we've had a decent run of peace (with 50 years of nuclear holocaust hanging over our heads), but we've definitely dropped a lot of bombs on people. Enough that I think we can say that US democracy has not "resulted in an explosion of peace and liberty unlikely anything the world has ever seen".
- nakedrobot2 8y agoThis is absolutely a good idea. Whoever thought it would be advantageous for packages from China to cost less to ship than equivalent packages within the USA, is beyond me. I hope there are positive economic and environmental results from this move. What will be the unintended consequences I wonder?
- plugger 8y ago> Whoever thought it would be advantageous for packages from China to cost less to ship than equivalent packages within the USA, is beyond me. As a consumer I think it's advantageous. I'd much prefer to pay no shipping when compared to paying significant amounts for shipping, regardless of where the package originates.
- nostromo 8y agoYou’re paying the costs, just indirectly via taxes and artificially higher US shipping costs.
- plugger 8y agoIncorrect, I live in Australia. This kinda reminds me of the conversation I had with my brother in law regarding the likes of SingAir, Emirates, and Qatar and just how much better they are when compared to US carriers that charge more on the same route despite providing an inferior product comparatively. He started on about how those air carriers are government subsidised, it's not fair, and I shouldn't be flying with them because of that. I told him I didn't care about the underlying business model, I want new aircraft, well trained staff, good quality food as well as service. Every one of those government subsidised carriers over deliver on every one of those metrics when compared to their US equivalents. Sure, some people will take a stand because they feel the need to do so. But in general I don't believe most people care how their goods and services are subsidised, only that they believe they've received a better deal when compared to similar offerings from other providers.
- 8y ago
- devoply 8y agoSay goodbye to AliExpress in the US. This will more or less kill the business model that AliExpress relies on in the US for most cheap products.
- adrr 8y agoAlso ebay and etsy have significant China-based Merchants.
- pishpash 8y agoAmazon won't be spared, either.
- adventured 8y agoAmazon is a very big fan of this change. They've been arguing in favor of this for years. The postage welfare program enabled Alibaba et al. to inexpensively lob attacks into Amazon's primary shopping market, from China, where Amazon can't go to compete. It's a big win for Amazon and most domestic US manufacturers and retailers.
- com2kid 8y agoI imagine Wish may also be in trouble. There are quite a few other online retailers that depend on this law. For those who enjoy cheap odd tablets, now is the time to stock up.
- dawnerd 8y agoOr they’ll pull a DealExtreme and open US warehouses.
- 0xfaded 8y agoAmazon fought state sales tax until the writing was on the wall, then Amazon caved and we got overnight shipping instead. I wouldn't be surprised if something similar happens. In Europe hobbyking, banggood et al opened European warehouses once VAT enforcement became a problem. The big chinese retailers will start competing with Amazon, which is somewhat ironic since Amazon already acts as the US warehouse for many Chinese products. Good riddance to dropshippers though.
- derekmhewitt 8y agoNot weighing in on if this is a good or bad thing overall, but I did listen to a pretty good NPR podcast a while back that explains a little more about this treaty and how it was affecting businesses in the US. https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2018/08/01/634737852/episode-857-the-postal-illuminati https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2018/08/01/634737852/epis...
- forrestthewoods 8y agoI came to the comments to post this exact podcast! It's a great listen. Such a good feeling when a seemingly crazy conspiracy story turns out to be pretty much spot on the money.
- rprenger 8y agoI really liked that podcast as well. If I remember correctly, one take away from the podcast that is relevant to a lot of comments below was that the U.S. used to get a net benefit from the weird international mail system. It was more recently that the import/export by direct mail balance shifted to make it a net loss to the U.S. Though it didn't sound like who the net winners and losers would be was strongly considered when the system was designed.
- mercutio2 8y agoYeah, it was a great episode. Generally speaking, I’m in favor of the US exiting this treaty, it really does seem like a clear distortion of the retail shipping market. But I think it’s going to worryingly contribute to the dynamic where other nations, with quite a bit of justification in this case, see the US as playing a “heads I win, tails you lose” game with the world. I also think people are fooling themselves if they think high-wage, low-skill manufacturing jobs are going to come back to the US because of this. Those jobs are gone, and automation is going to keep them from coming back. This will mainly help highly automated manufacturing shops in the US, and online resellers with warehouses in the US. Basically, I see this bringing more Amazon warehouse jobs, not many more much-mythologized blue-collar manufacturing jobs.
- jonsbu 8y ago
- iask 8y agoFinally!!! Moves like this will help small and medium businesses compete...finally we won’t have to pay 25.00 to mail a small book to China.
- onion2k 8y agoYou'll still have to pay that price, but now a Chinese company will have to pay 25.00 to mail a small book to the US as well. This is just going to limit the sale of small goods internationally.
- XorNot 8y agoAlso small volumes of the type small businesses deal in. In every way this benefits mostly large stateside enterprises who source their products in bulk.
- keithnoizu 8y agoYou would have to pay more actually. The cost for both the USPS and for China Post.
- dragonwriter 8y agoWithdrawing from the UPU will allow the US raise the rates Chinese mailers pay to mail into the US, but won't lower (and, depending on how China responds, may raise) the rates US mailers have to pay to mail into China. It's potentially an extension of the existing trade war in that respect.
- nemo846 8y agoTrade war or not. This particular move makes sense though. There is no reason to continue giving China - an economic superpower - a discount on mail.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> There is no reason to continue giving China - an economic superpower - a discount on mail. Yes, working to negotiate a change to that particular element of the UPU price structure makes sense (which is why Canada already did it for China-Canada mail.) Whether rage-quitting the UPU makes a lot of sense (even as a negotiating tactic), is a different question; the UPU is more than a Chinese discount.
- noobermin 8y agoWill this affect the myriad of businesses that assemble products in the US?
- adventured 8y agoNo, generally speaking those businesses purchase their orders in large quantities that don't arrive by individual small packages. This would end an absurd international postage welfare program that China benefits from, pretending to be as poor and developing as they were 30 or 40 years ago.
- sschueller 8y agoWe have the same issue in Switzerland with cheap packages from China which are received as mail but do not fit through the automated sorting system. This requires a lot of manual labor which increases the costs for the postal service. This is why sometime this year people who receive such mail will be billed additional fees increasing slowly over the next few years. The treaty allows under developed nations to ship at a much lower rate. China and a few others should simply be reclassified. This does not require having to leave the treaty.
- adventured 8y agoIt does require having to leave the treaty - if the UPU Congress refuses to reclassify China. The threat to leave, is meant to apply enough pressure to finally get that reclassification accomplished. They've been intentionally dragging their feet on this matter over time and they only meet under normal circumstances every four years (they can of course hold emergency sessions). It's the exact same problem the US has had with the WTO, it has refused to do anything about China's dramatic state sponsored dumping for more than a decade. These are global bodies that are invalidating themselves by refusing to normalize rules for China now that they're a massive economic power.
- the_mitsuhiko 8y agoI heavily dislike that america just leaves treaties it does not like instead of improving them. Most smaller countries cannot use the same method. If my country for instance were to do thay nobody would ship there any more because the billing system would be too complex and expensive and the market is just too small.
- eksemplar 8y agoThe headline made it sound sort of bad, but reading this and the WSJ article, it makes you wonder why it wasn’t done sooner.
- Tim_Norton 8y agoBecause Trump is scary!
- jrnichols 8y agoThat's what I've been gathering too. Trump signed a few bills recently, and while they weren't his administration's bill in the first place, that hasn't stopped the media (and definitely social media) from trash talking Trump constantly. It's almost as if people that hate Trump with the ferocity that they do are incapable of reporting anything positive and just saying "Ok, this was a good thing."
- tartuffe78 8y agoSomeone I worked with once told me that putting anything he does in a good light risks "normalizing his behavior". Shows how polarized these times are.
- ceejayoz 8y ago> Trump signed a few bills recently, and while they weren't his administration's bill in the first place This is a bizarre statement. If he's signing the bill, his administration - and him specifically - is explicitly endorsing it. That's the whole point of the thing.
- jrnichols 8y agoI don't think it's a bizarre statement to note that a few of the bills that he has signed did not originate with the Trump administration itself.
- 8y ago
- dang 8y agoUrl changed from https://hackaday.com/2018/10/17/us-announces-withdraw-from-postal-treaty-international-shipping-prices-expected-to-rise/ https://hackaday.com/2018/10/17/us-announces-withdraw-from-p..., which points to this.
- megaremote 8y agoI bought a button from China for 3 cents once, after reading an article about it. This is too Australia. The package was worth more than that here.
- the_mitsuhiko 8y agoWhy does the US have to withdraw instead of negotiating? The US are not the only country that is unhappy about the shipping rates with China. The postal treaty however is hugely important for smaller countries. I don’t want a world where the US destroy the entire postal system for the rest of us.
- irrational 8y agoThe article says that withdrawing takes a year and they want to negotiate during that year so the withdraw doesn't happen.
- dgellow 8y agoThe threat of withdrawal is part of the negotiation as far as I can tell.
- dragonwriter 8y agoIt's not a threat of withdrawal, it's an actual withdrawal, which takes time to take effect (like Brexit), with the idea that if negotiation is satisfactory, the withdrawal might be cancelled.
- pluma 8y agoEither the Brexit example is a simple mistake or you're confused about the mechanics behind it, so I'll elaborate to avoid people thinking it's a sound analogy: The Brexit referendum was non-binding, so at that point nothing legally relevant had happened yet. The UK government then decided to honour the will demonstrated by the 37.5% of the population that cast a vote in favour of leaving the EU (51.9% of the result at a 72.2% turnout). Again, this decision didn't mean anything legally relevant but the government announced its commitment, setting expectations. At that point the UK government could have negotiated with the EU and sought alternative solutions (not that there was much left considering "do this or we'll leave" had been the negotiation strategy for quite a while). But then on 29 March 2017 the UK government decided to start an "actual withdrawal" by triggering Article 50 of the Lisbon treaty. This set its membership to auto-destruct within two years time and was legally binding. The problem with Article 50 is that the UK now had a mere two years until all existing treaties it was part of via the EU would simply end and nobody had bothered to prepare for negotiating any replacements yet. As of today there are still hundreds of incredibly complex treaties that haven't been sorted out yet, the most obvious problem being how to deal with Northern Ireland's chaotic land borders without upsetting the DUP (the political party that enabled the Prime Minister to stay in office after her botched early re-election). However unlike the US and the Postal Treaty, the UK can't simply cancel its withdrawal from the EU. If it wants to revoke its invocation of Article 50, it has to get approval from every single of the EU's (other) 27 member states -- some of which don't particularly care much for the UK for various reasons. It's like giving your boss the finger and handing in your signed three weeks notice (after using the threat of quitting during salary renegotiations for decades) and then coming back two weeks later asking them if they can please let you stay. Except you don't have one boss but 27 of them and all of them have veto powers and some of them really don't like you. However Scotland (where a majority voted against leaving in the first place) brought forth a case that will decide whether maybe the UK could still unilaterally revoke its invocation after all. The only problem is that a ruling might take months and may come a little too late. Even if the court rules in favour of Scotland and the UK pulls off a full 180 at the last minute, the entire ordeal would leave the UK in a worse position by having called its own bluff and shown that leaving is not actually an option they're willing to follow through on. tl;dr: the biggest difference is that (unless the ECJ rules differently) Brexit "took effect" immediately when Article 50 was invoked, it just includes a 2 year "migration" period during which the membership status remains in effect.
- mcantelon 8y agoCanada did the same last year, by the looks of it: https://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/canada-post-phasing-out-controversial-shipping-discount-for-chinese-goods/article36883687/ https://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/canada-po...
- dragonwriter 8y agoNo, Canada negotiated changes within the treaty framework. The US could do that (and some of the coverage have indicated that the withdrawal is a negotiating tactic to provide more leverage for that, with the plan being to leverage the time it takes to go into effect to negotiate changes and then cancel the withdrawal before it is effective; Canada didn't have to do that to negotiate changes, though.)
- abricot 8y agoThey could, they did[1], and it didn't work out. [1] "U.S. officials said the administration sought to revise the treaty in September and was rebuffed by other nations, prompting the decision to withdraw."
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- basicplus2 8y agoall i know is i have to pay an ENORMOUS amount of money to pay for freight from US to Australia So is this going to make it worse? Because this is an enormous incentive NOT to buy any US goods
- chippy 8y agoIt's not going to make it any cheaper. This will mainly effect the cost of others shipping goods to you.
- eigenvector 8y agoI used to use a US parcel forwarding service to shop online and have things forwarded to me in Canada. One of the services they offered was first shipping the US origin package to their warehouse in China (presumably via some kind of discounted or chartered freight service) then forwarding it on from there to the destination country via China Post. This could actually be cheaper than mailing something directly from the US to, say, Switzerland due to the low UPU rates out of China.
- mistermann 8y agoThat this level of physical inefficiency is a sound business model well illustrates how unfair this shipping subsidy is.
- basicplus2 8y ago"Under the treaty, a UN body sets lower international rates for packages from certain countries, a move originally designed to support poorer nations." i presume this is code for making it easier for rich players to exploit cheap labour to make alot more money no matter the consequence for local manufacturing and sovreign security.
- fyfy18 8y agoif China loses its status as a developing country, all that's likely to happen is the items will end up being shipped from a neighbouring country that still has the status. When you buy items from AliExpress often they have the option of being sent by Singapore Post. I'm not exactly sure how that works (Singapore isn't that close to China), but although the item comes from China, to the postal service it doesn't.
- csdreamer7 8y agoLikely China won't be the only country that gets reclassified. Still, if the US leaves the treaty it won't matter to Americans in a year.
- TorKlingberg 8y agoI have been getting a lot of items shipped from Thailand. And one cheap item from the Solomon Islands. I have no idea how the last one happened.
- sam_goody 8y agoI had a chat about this with one of the sellers on AliBaba. He claimed that the items are still being shipped from China, and that he is just witing Singapore / Czechoslovakia / any other developing country on the package (he said it is part of the tracking code), and he gets the benefit of the country whose code he used. He said the main reason they do that is that the laws differ as to what can be shipped from each country, especially vis a vis things that use radio frequencies. By choosing even distant countries they can be caught breaking minimum standards and are not prosecutable. He said that the down side is that things can never be returned to sender, since the sending address is fictitious. This last sentiment has been echoed by many sellers. Have no way to verify, but it is an interesting claim.
- baybal2 8y agoDeveloped countries have a moral duty to support developing nations, that includes China.
- andun 8y agoI know your comment is in jest, but no, developed countries don't owe developing countries shit.
- rswail 8y agoWell actually, current developed countries owe developing countries for not paying for the externalities (pollution primarily) now causing climate change that were not paid for by the developed countries while they became developed. That's a purely economic argument and leaves out the exploitation of developing countries by government supported corporate entities over the entire period of colonization. So actually, you're right, they "don't owe [them] shit." What they owe them is getting rid of the shit that was created in the first place.
- pknerd 8y agoLet's see how long Trump's economical orgasm last.
- jayd16 8y agoDo people in this thread realize the USPS is almost entirely self funded? I see a lot of talk about tax dollars etc. The USPS doesn't work that way.
- qqqwww 8y agoIf that is true, then American consumers subsidize Chinese shipping via higher costs of domestic shipping rather than through higher taxes.
- jayd16 8y agoPerhaps. However, that's not the same as taxes and its not a hidden cost like a tax. It's not factored into the price of US goods as US companies would use a private shipper if the this law significantly effected shipping costs. At worst it hurts USPS revenue and increases the cost of first class mail as market forces can't compete for first class mail. My point is a lot of the comments are misleading about the scope of the costs involved here.
- cascom 8y agoIf you call losing ~$1B+/qtr self funded, yeah they’re “self funded” https://about.usps.com/who-we-are/financials/financial-conditions-results-reports/fy2018-q3.pdf https://about.usps.com/who-we-are/financials/financial-condi...
- ceejayoz 8y agoThat's not really their fault. https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2018-04-04/congress-not-amazon-messed-up-the-u-s-postal-service https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2018-04-04/congress-... > The law requires the Postal Service, which receives no taxpayer subsidies, to prefund its retirees' health benefits up to the year 2056. This is a $5 billion per year cost; it is a requirement that no other entity, private or public, has to make. If that doesn't meet the definition of insanity, I don't know what does. Without this obligation, the Post Office actually turns a profit. Some have called this a "manufactured crisis."
- a_imho 8y agoOff-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon. Videos of pratfalls or disasters, or cute animal pictures. If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic.
- sparkpeasy 8y agoI always wondered how Chinese sellers on Ebay could sell small toys and trinkets for less than a dollar with free shipping that took several weeks to arrive. It would cost more than that to send a small empty box between two addresses in the US.
- coliveira 8y agoThe US is engaging in protectionist policies that will bring back inflation and reduce the purchasing power of the population. The country should better be prepared for the consequences of these policies, because it will be much more costly than the $300 million spent in the postal service.
- empath75 8y agoI agree with this in general but in this particular case we were actively subsidizing shipping costs from China.
- Animats 8y agoOh, the terminal dues issue.[1] International mail is delivered in the destination country but paid for in the sending country. The UPU has rates for this, and they vary with the development category of the sending country. The problem is that China is still getting the rate for underdeveloped countries. In 2021, that's scheduled to change. Every 10 years this gets looked at. [1] https://www.lexingtoninstitute.org/terminal-dues-time-end-drain-u-s-economy/ https://www.lexingtoninstitute.org/terminal-dues-time-end-dr...
- gaff33 8y agoSweeden had a much more interesting solution to this problem. Usually small packages like this avoid VAT because it's not worth the administrative hassle to deal with them. Sweeden decided that such packages should be liable for tax, plus a $15 admin fee to cover the costs: https://www.thelocal.se/20180119/your-cheap-imports-from-china-are-about-to-get-more-expensive https://www.thelocal.se/20180119/your-cheap-imports-from-chi...
- kwhitefoot 8y agoThat's not a proper solution and I hope it isn't the one that my country of residence, Norway, will choose. It is simple protectionism. And it is extremely regressive. If they want to figure out a way to efficiently charge the VAT that would be different (even though VAT is also a regressive tax). Charging a USD 15 fee to apply the USD 1 VAT to the USD 4 cost of the goods I have just received from China is absurd.
- apexalpha 8y agoFor anyone not up to speed with the Postal Treaties and its (dis)advantages, this video is a good summary: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DkckYLBCNfI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DkckYLBCNfI
- cableshaft 8y agoConsidering pretty much all board and video games are manufactured in and shipped from China, this probably means they're all going to become more expensive. Yay. It still might be a good thing overall to do away with this treaty, I don't know, but this is probably not going to be great for those industries.
- chrissnell 8y agoManufactured goods are not being sent to distributors and dealers in bulk by postal mail. That stuff comes in a shipping container. This is targeted at the typical AliExpress shipment.
- ilamont 8y agoNot noted in the article: The U.S. attempted to revise the treaty last month and was shot down (1). Hence the new announcement. 1. https://www.caixinglobal.com/2018-10-18/trump-to-withdraw-us-from-postal-treaty-squeezing-china-101336196.html https://www.caixinglobal.com/2018-10-18/trump-to-withdraw-us...
- bovermyer 8y agoWhile you can count on me to be hostile to just about everything Trump does, this seems to be a good idea. Thanks to everyone posting links to further information.
- exabrial 8y agoChina still has developing nation status? This seems more than reasonable to renegotiate.
- freddie_mercury 8y agoIn Shanghai and Beijing the average household income is $7,000 a year. If it isn't a developing economy, what would you call it?
- lightbyte 8y agoThat isn't enough information, what is the cost of living?
- collyw 8y agoI am curious how that translates. Cost of living will be substantially lower, I am not sure by how much but 5 times wouldn't seem unfeasable. That would translate to $35k per year which sounds similar to plenty of European countries, so might buy a reasonably comfortable lifestyle there. Anyone with any more knowledge care to comment on this?
- z2 8y agoFrom my armchair--it could be somewhere in between what's considered purchasing power parity and the actual exchange rate, because goods aren't exactly comparable when the entire supply chain is less advanced. You may pay less for a washing machine in a developing country, making your money go farther, but that washing machine may also have a greater chance of electrocuting you due to lower quality control. It's hard to measure quality of life through qualitatively similar goods. Is a jar of tomato sauce from a developed country that's vacuum sealed in a sterilized glass jar the same as a tin can of tomato sauce made under questionable conditions? Edit: For Shanghai, cost of living is closer to 1:1 to 1:3 from here: https://transferwise.com/gb/blog/cost-of-living-in-china https://transferwise.com/gb/blog/cost-of-living-in-china
- exabrial 8y agoHow does that compare to the average income of a Chinese Communist party leader?
- AtlasBarfed 8y agoIF From what I've heard of the postal treaty is true, this is an unreasonable subsidy for imports and offshoring. And it's not without environmental consequences: it offloads the carbon impacts of shipping and further enables arbitrage and cherrypicking of lax environmental regulations for production undermining the global common good. While I don't like most aspects of the Trump administration and it's pandering policies, this one is probably good for the world, even if the people trying to do it care nothing for our environmental future.
- PeanutNore 8y ago"Even a broken clock..." and all that.
- rc_mob 8y agoStill.. Wtf Obama, why couldn't you fix this?
- forapurpose 8y agoImagine your CTO said this: 'I found a bug, therefore we should discard the entire system'; imagine it's a mature, complex, functioning system. If your CTO did it, you'd seriously doubt their leadership. The real question is, what are the outcomes we are choosing from? What is the outcome if we keep the system, and what is the outcome if we discard it? What would we replace it with - are we going to try to build a complex system from nothing? Are there third or fourth better options, perhaps improving the existing system? The politicians have explicitly and repeatedly expressed their goals (see Trump's UN speech, for example): Undo international cooperation and jointly made rules, and create zero-sum geo-political competition based on power. It's fundamentally undemocratic and against the belief in the fundamental equal rights of all people ('all men are created equal') - i.e., that others should have an equal say. It also has a long and proven track record of leading to war, the experience of most of human history until the rules-based international order was built amid the ashes of WWII. In this case it's backed by typical political talking points, designed to give people the impression that international treaties are generally bad and to rationalize the step they are taking toward their strategy. But as I said, it's should be transparent (and expected, though you never know which agreement is next).
- jchb 8y ago> complex Complex is an understatement. The Universal Postal Union constitution (1) from 1964 is some readable 11 pages, setting the scope to "... a single postal territory for the reciprocal exchange of letter-post items" and international collaboration to improve postal services including facilitating technical assistance. Fast forward to 2018 and there is a a list of UPU activities (2) that really stretch that constitution to its limits. Then some two hundred pages of regulation (3), including a bunch of country specific rules and exceptions. "Not withstanding article 17-107.5.2, Azerbaijan, India, Indonesia, Lebanon, Nepal, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, Ukraine, Uzbekistan and Zimbabwe shall admit sound recordings as items for the blind only if these are sent by, or addressed to, an officially recognized institute for the blind" That doesn't yet include the elaborate classification of countries into different contribution groups. Those classification documents are hidden behind a login screen on the UPU website - only accessible to "select partners". Although with a bit of Google-fu you can find them from the US Postal Regulatory Commission (4). There you can see that the US is classified as group I, China as group III. A complex world may need complex regulation, and the activities the UPU undertakes are not necessarily bad. But just a brief look at this thing reminds me of a quote from the "The CumEx-Files" article that is currently on the HN front page: "the German tax law has grown so complex that those who have written the laws no longer understand it themselves". (1)http://www.upu.int/uploads/tx_sbdownloader/actInForceIndefinitelyConstitutionEn.pdf http://www.upu.int/uploads/tx_sbdownloader/actInForceIndefin... (2)http://www.upu.int/en/activities.html http://www.upu.int/en/activities.html (3)http://www.upu.int/uploads/tx_sbdownloader/actRegulationsConventionFinalProtocolEn.pdf http://www.upu.int/uploads/tx_sbdownloader/actRegulationsCon... (4)https://www.prc.gov/docs/96/96632/Attachment%20B.pdf https://www.prc.gov/docs/96/96632/Attachment%20B.pdf
- forapurpose 8y ago> foreign packages cost the US about $300m (£228.5m) each year, according to administration estimates. Is that even a rounding error? How much annual trade is there with China? How much is done via the Postal Treaty?
- ElBarto 8y agoLest we forget that the USPS seems to have been quite OK with how things worked: http://about.usps.com/news/national-releases/2010/pr10_058.htm http://about.usps.com/news/national-releases/2010/pr10_058.h...
- joshe 8y agoAt most the subsidy reduces prices by 0.1% for goods from China. If all foreign packages only cost the US $300 million a year (from article), China's portion has to be less than that. We buy $462 billion in goods from China. It's also worth remembering that the subsidy goes to both the American consumer and the Chinese supplier. Eliminating it helps the American supplier and hurts the Chinese supplier and American consumer. Probably no one bothered to fix it because it's such a minor issue. It's also difficult to change treaty agreements, oddball stuff tends to stick around for awhile just because the cat herding is so difficult. It's reasonable to remove this subsidy, and probably good to do so before more people take advantage of it. This is a big emotion story but it's not that important.
- onemoresoop 8y agoI think Chinese shippers can send items in bulk to a us destination and resend locally the individual items from there ...
- kimsk112 8y agoNPR Money has a good podcast about this couple months ago. https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2018/08/01/634737852/episode-857-the-postal-illuminati https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2018/08/01/634737852/epis...
- remote_phone 8y agoI hate to say it because a Trump is an embarrassing, non-presidential, ignorant buffoon, but some of his policies are very good and are actually helping small businesses. This is an example of it. He is willing, whether he fully understands it or not, to touch the third rail and do things that wiser politicians would never do, but is incredibly frustrating. This is a perfect example of this. I have two friends who are impacted by this and have been complaining about this for years.
- c789a123 8y agoWhile it is very easy to buy stuff directly from China on websites like amazon or even Chinese web sites, it is almost impossible for people in PR.China to buy US products via WWW the same way. The Chinese CCP party intentionally blocks outside products to sell easily in China and keep the profits they got from US to the families of party leaders. Thanks Trump for acting on it!
- nil_pointer 8y agoThis video does a good job explaining the bad position we were in prior to leaving the treaty: https://youtu.be/DkckYLBCNfI https://youtu.be/DkckYLBCNfI
- gmiller123456 8y agoEven if we assume the information in that video is correct, just charging the extra $1 or so for delivery would not cause any significant number of jobs to the US. Firstly, the movement of jobs from the US to China pre-dates consumers wide availability of ordering packages straight from China. Secondly, factories in China shipping a lot of products aren't going to be sending their entire inventory in the small $2-$3 packages mentioned in the video, they'll be making larger freight shipments not involving the USPS at all. Thirdly, the cost of shipping is just one thing that's cheaper for China, their labor costs are also so much lower, that just charging an extra $1 per package won't make it cost more than it would to make in the US. Lastly, the assumption the video makes is that the USPS loses $1 per shipment, without backing it up with any evidence. The exact amount it costs the USPS to deliver a package is competitive information and likely very closely guarded against public disclosure. If you pause the video where they show the US vs China price chart, you see the China cost is about $1 less for each. So it seems they assumed the US cost was the exact cost with no margin. The other way of assuming, is that the China cost is the exact cost, and the US cost is just extra profit to the USPS because the market will bear it. And the $1 the USPS "loses" is just extra profit they didn't make. Additionally, other countries also benefit from the same price China does, but it has not benefited them as much as China. So there's a lot more to the economics than just $1 per package that the video seems to lead to.
- nil_pointer 8y agoTo clarify, it has cost the Post Office nearly $60 billion dollars, which falls onto US tax payers.
- gmiller123456 8y agoThe USPS does not receive a single penny of tax dollars[1] [1]https://facts.usps.com/top-facts/ https://facts.usps.com/top-facts/
- m-p-3 8y agoI guess this will hurt businesses like Alibaba and etc?
- swamp40 8y agoAlthough this is a good move, small US Postal shipments from China to US households are a drop in the bucket compared to DHL deliveries from China to US companies. And that cost is being massively subsidized by the Chinese government. I think the money goes directly from the Chinese government to the Chinese companies, who then pay DHL - so I doubt there is much the US can do to stop that.
- nojvek 8y agoCredit where credit is due. This is very much a “America First” move and deserves kudos. I no longer consider China a developing nation.
- lancewiggs 8y agoPostal Services have a large fixed cost component - reducing the flow of goods coming into the country puts the entire USPS system at risk. That may be the point.
- forapurpose 8y agoDo I understand this correctly: The U.S. President claims to withdraw from the Postal Treaty with the entire world because he objects to one provision with China that he says costs the U.S. around 0.06% of its annual economic output?
- morpheuskafka 8y agoInteresting, on October 15 the USPS OIG release a redacted copy of report SAT-AR-18-002, "Use of Postal Service Network to Facilitate Illicit Drug Distribution"[1], which commented on the Universal Postal Union requiring the USPS to accept all international mail from UPU members[2] (basically everyone) that don't want to comply with the US requirement of Advance Electronic Data (basically Secure Flight for mail/packages, the idea is that CBP can identify suspected drug packages just as they do passenger flights, as mail can only be screened without a warrant by CBP at the mail port of entry). Footnote 25 notes that as recently as September 1 of this year, the US moved to require AED on packages sent through UPU's EMS program[3], the partially redacted next sentence appears to indicate that some countries pushed back or had plans not to comply. Sent in a FOIA for the report, so we'll see what exceptions they were claiming, if they actually claim it as non-disclosable under FOIA law. Also interesting that the WHPSEC statement[3] notes that Trump is willing to abandon plans to leave if unspecified goals are met in negotiations. Edit: A conservative think tank recently complained about the UPU and drugs as well: https://www.aei.org/multimedia/universal-postal-union-and-mail-order-opiates-viewpoint/ https://www.aei.org/multimedia/universal-postal-union-and-ma... [1] https://www.uspsoig.gov/sites/default/files/document-library-files/2018/SAT-AR-18-002.pdf https://www.uspsoig.gov/sites/default/files/document-library... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Universal_Postal_Union_membership.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Universal_Postal_Union_me... [3] https://www.ems.post/en/about-us-contacts/about-us https://www.ems.post/en/about-us-contacts/about-us [4] https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefings-statements/statement-press-secretary-38/ https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefings-statements/statement-pr...