8 ms·
Here's something that seems simple and I've NEVER been able to get a straight answer to: If Chinese wealth per capita is roughly 1/10th that of the average US
by onlyrealcuzzo 8y ago
Here's something that seems simple and I've NEVER been able to get a straight answer to:
If Chinese wealth per capita is roughly 1/10th that of the average US citizen -- both in terms of median and mean -- and if Chinese wages are roughly 1/6th that of the average US citizen -- both in terms of median and mean... How on Earth are Chinese houses on average MORE EXPENSIVE per square foot than houses in the US?
My brain just can't understand.
- IkmoIkmo 8y agoBecause you're comparing national average income to non-national housing prices. The average house is not at all more expensive in China than in the US. It is true that in particular cities like Beijing or Shanghai the average sits around $7-9k per square meter (divide by 10 roughly for square foot), far higher than the average in the US. (divide by ten roughly for square foot). That's way more than in the US. But then consider these are megacities with a GDP of roughly half a trillion dollars. About half a million millionaires live in Beijing, Shanghai and Hong Kong. These are the top tier cities of the 22nd century's superpower, prices are going to reflect the notion that property in these cities should keep its value and appreciate strongly. Median wages are already on par in these cities with various eastern-european countries. And income inequality is among the worst in the world, so you've got this small percentage of people who can elevate property prices to ridiculous heights. Only Shanghai and Beijing each have a population equivalent to 25 times San Fransisco, so a few rich people adds up to ridiculous prices. I'm not saying these prices necessarily make sense, I certainly wouldn't buy there. But it's also not impossible to see why they're this high.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoAnecdotally, my wife owns a villa in a fifth tier city (even under another city as a prefecture!), and housing prices there seem comparable to a smaller American city (like say Spokane) of similar size. The median income in Beijing is around 18k RMB/month. The one bedroom we were renting was 7500 RMB/month, which was considered neither cheap nor expensive...it was definitely cheap for what I was making but then I had to forgo a lot of niceties that I wanted (like a real shower). My rent in the states is much higher but I don't have to worry about the same crappiness that even a high-end Beijing apartment has.
- aurailious 8y agoLast time I was in Beijing I was told not to flush toilet paper. Is that still the case?
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoYou can flush it in most higher residences as long as the toilet paper is soluable. I think the reason binning developed was that the Chinese didn't produce soluable toilet paper in the past, and now the habit carried on (my grandma told my mom, my mom told me) even though the tech has caught up. I'm not really sure about squat toilets, though. Never drink the water though. Even boiling isn't that safe anymore, just use bottled.
- voltagex_ 8y agoWhat's in the water?
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoChina's crazy bad water pollution.
- zhte415 8y agoHeavy metals.
- baybal2 8y agoPoop
- LrnByTeach 8y ago>The median income in Beijing is around 18k RMB/month. The one bedroom we were renting was 7500 RMB/month. The median income in Silicon valley California is around $7000/month. The one bedroom rent is $2000/month. so it seems, Silicon valley and top Chinese cities comparable when it comes to expensive housing ...
- zjaffee 8y agoThe incredible thing is that these homes are often not purchased with debt financing either, and when they do, it's with a much larger downpayment than in the US as required by law. Chinese citizens have a much higher savings rate compared to Americans.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoDepressingly, when the Chinese housing market pops, it won't be investors taking the loss, it'll be Chinese citizens losing their life savings.
- dv_dt 8y agoUmm after 2008, the investors in mortgage backed securities didn't take a loss. Their securities were purchased en masse by the Fed via Quantitative Easing programs - about 4 Trillion worth. Edit: it might be interesting to see if there is a recession in China (or globally), how the central bank there might respond in contrast to QE schemes that the US and European central banks used.
- nissimk 8y agoMany investors in mortgage backed securities lost quite a lot in 07-09. Your statement is false. The fed bailed out the big banks but smaller players wrote down many positions to 0.
- dv_dt 8y agoSure, not every dollar of every mortgage backed security was rescued in that way. But the imbalance you reference was yet another way that the rescue really didn't set up the economy for a healthier future - especially larger sophisticated investors were rescued, and both smaller players as well as many people bore the hardest hits.
- adventured 8y agoThe Chinese consumer has leveraged up considerably in the last decade, to keep up with the rapid price increases in the economy. Their debt to household income ratio is quickly approaching the rate you see in the US. They appear to be making the same turn that the Japanese did from ~1998 forward, in going from being a nation of high savers to low savers and high debtors in a short span of time. "By the end of 2017, the ratio of total household debt to disposable personal income hit 107.2 percent. This number is above the level in the US before the 2008 financial crisis. The structure of China's household debt has also diversified. Housing mortgages only increased slightly in 2017. ... But other types of loans, especially short-term loans, increased rapidly last year. One reason for this is that families have to seek other ways to finance their home purchases due to the tighter controls on mortgages. " http://www.globaltimes.cn/content/1115334.shtml http://www.globaltimes.cn/content/1115334.shtml "China’s household finances look more stretched than those in most emerging markets, though the level of household debt remains less than that in most developed economies, Fitch Ratings said in a report on Tuesday. China’s household debt-to-disposable income ratio, a gauge of indebtedness, has jumped 9 percentage points every year since 2015, driven by mortgages and other consumer debts. If left unchecked, the ratio could hit 100 percent by 2020 versus 82 percent at end-2017, Fitch said. That would put China on par with the United States and Japan, whose household debt ratios are estimated to be at 105 percent and 99 percent, respectively." https://www.reuters.com/article/china-economy-household-debt/chinas-household-finances-look-stretched-versus-most-emerging-markets-fitch-idUSL3N1R92WJ https://www.reuters.com/article/china-economy-household-debt... "On the back of a boom in property prices, household borrowing has been climbing for 10 years straight, at a pace that rivals any such run-up in major economies. At $6.7 trillion, and a record 50 percent of gross domestic product, private debt is now approaching developed-world levels and crimping consumer spending power." https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-04-24/the-7-trillion-debt-pile-looming-large-over-chinese-households https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-04-24/the-7-tri...
- soulchild37 8y agoDifferent cultural norm, Chinese are willing to spend 100% of their savings on buying house. And having a house is a prerequisite to getting permission from father/mother-in-law for marriage in Chinese culture.
- jjoonathan 8y agoMost US houses are "cheap." SF and NY are not normal.
- aurailious 8y agoMidwest housing is much more affordable than a coastal megapolis and still provide a good standard of living.
- JBReefer 8y agoThey're smaller? Houses in the US are crazy large (Australia too, apparently) https://www.elledecor.com/life-culture/fun-at-home/news/a7654/house-sizes-around-the-world/ https://www.elledecor.com/life-culture/fun-at-home/news/a765...
- nineteen999 8y agoThe housing market in Australia is very overvalued, having been inflated artificially (in part due to negative gearing - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_gearing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_gearing) over a long period, also partly attributable to artificially created demand. Although prices are starting to come down in the major cities now (ie. the property bubble has pretty much burst over the last 12 months). Another difference is that historically Australia has also had poorer quality of housing as well, eg. inadequate insulation (https://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-01-03/why-bad-housing-design-pumps-up-prices-for-everyone/8158168 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-01-03/why-bad-housing-desig...). But yes we do have some pretty big houses, at least compared to most of Asia, much of the UK etc.
- danans 8y ago> also partly attributable to artificially created demand. What is artificially created demand for real estate? Isn't all demand for real estate "real", whether as a home or an investment.
- nineteen999 8y agoI could have worded that more clearly. In Australia's case, rules regarding foreign property ownership/investment have historically had a fairly big impact on housing demand, pricing etc. The government of the day is regularly lobbied by those who have a vested interest in seeing prices continually rise to relax those rules. I'll leave it at that.
- D_Alex 8y ago>The housing market in Australia is very overvalued, having been inflated artificially (in part due to negative gearing ... But in Australia you cannot tax-deduct the interest on your own home, whereas in the US (IIRC) you can. I would expect the artificial inflation to be higher under the US system. The real causes of the high house prices IMO are: a) poor government policy, from federal to council level, the net effect of which is preventing the market to be adequately supplied with new housing; and b) a range of cultural factors (notably the image of housing as a safe investment, that is being cultivated with increasing desperation by the real estate industry) that results in channeling of investment into established housing.
- drcode 8y agoLocation, location, location, I would think: With more people and larger cities, there's more "prime" real estate at locations with high potential for economic networking. In this kind of situation, it's only natural that people will spend a greater percent of their income on housing (since the benefits of being at a prime location vs remote location are more stark) The other factor is that the Chinese government places very strict controls on where rich people can "park" their money- Since they can't take large sums of money out of the country, they have resorted to using local real estate as a sort of gold substitute for stockpiling their $$$.
- naveen99 8y agoLess property taxes
- megaman8 8y agoNo property taxes.
- onlyrealcuzzo 8y agoBut also no private property, right? Isn't everything a 99 year lease?
- samspenc 8y agoNo private property rights in China, correct, it's 99 year leases. This is why rich Chinese use their money to purchase assets (including real estate) overseas. I'm curious about the no property taxes comment though - does that refer to China or Japan? I thought China had taxes on everything, including property.
- onlyrealcuzzo 8y agoThere is no property tax in China. It's a 99 year lease, so the original purchase is basically a tax.
- thedailymail 8y agoJapan definitely has property taxes (I'm a homeowner there).
- netheril96 8y agoNo, a 70 year lease.
- megaman8 8y agoyes, but functionaly it's the same thing. "Ownership" in other countries is just a legal construct. It's not like you can do whatever you want with it. There are countless rules and regulations you must follow - you can't build on it or touch in anyway without getting permits and your "property" can be confiscated if you don't pay taxes on it. So, I would argue no property rights with 0 property taxes is more like true ownership.
- acover 8y agoDo you have a source? Are the number of people per square foot much higher? I know in Tokyo people's expectations are very different.
- onlyrealcuzzo 8y agoHouses in Tokyo once were considered expensive globally, but currently prices in Tokyo are only about 28% more expensive than in China on average. Japan on average is cheaper than China. And Tokyo compared to Shenzhen is only about 13% more expensive. But wealth is about 2000% higher and wages are 440% higher in Japan. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(nominal)_per_capita https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(nomi... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_wealth_per_adult https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_wealth_pe... https://www.numbeo.com/property-investment/compare_cities.jsp?country1=Japan&city1=Tokyo&country2=China&city2=Shenzhen&displayCurrency=USD https://www.numbeo.com/property-investment/compare_cities.js...
- seppin 8y agowow
- fspeech 8y agoWell prices vary greatly from first tier cities to other cities to rural areas, and your impression is likely formed from the first tier cities. Total Chinese mortgage is estimated at around $4 Trillion https://www.ceicdata.com/en/china/loan-consumer-loan/loan-real-estate-housing-mortgage https://www.ceicdata.com/en/china/loan-consumer-loan/loan-re... , while US residential mortgage totals about $12T https://www.federalreserve.gov/data/mortoutstand/current.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/data/mortoutstand/current.htm
- bordercases 8y agoBecause most Chinese people are in abject poverty and shouldn't even be considered a part of the market where those houses lie. The wealth-per-capita should be normalized to the population where it's actually concentrated, for which I've seen estimates circa ~100million.
- topspin 8y ago> Because most Chinese people are in abject poverty About half of Chinese are peasants, for lack of a better term. Is that 'abject poverty?' They're living primitive lives. I think applying the term 'abject poverty' may be a little inappropriate. Many enjoy a good bit of property, autonomy and are not living drastically foreshortened lives. > and shouldn't even be considered a part of the market where those houses lie ... should be normalized Yes, analysis of China is frequently misleading due to the vast peasant population. Unfortunately attempts to correct for this run into a very serious problem; the US CO2 per-capita figure ceases to be a multiple of China for hundreds of millions of Chinese. A highly undesirable result for a number of reasons. So don't expect that sort of analysis to become a thing any time soon.
- oblio 8y ago> are not living drastically foreshortened lives Compared to who?
- megaman8 8y agothe prices you've heard about are the top of the top. In many other cities in China, you can get much much cheaper housing. I know a family that just bought a 1500 sq ft, 3 bedroom apartment at the top of a skyscraper for a mere (100K in US dollars) - in Yuans of course. And, there are far more remote areas that are much cheaper than that.
- Svexax 8y agoTo add to this, 30 million Chinese actually live in caves. That’s got to have an effect on the mean. http://articles.latimes.com/2012/mar/18/world/la-fg-china-caves-20120318 http://articles.latimes.com/2012/mar/18/world/la-fg-china-ca...
- aurailious 8y agoLiving in China can be massively different, that's crazy.
- onlyrealcuzzo 8y ago30 million!? Hot damn! That's like the entire state of Texas!!
- igravious 8y agohttps://www.voanews.com/a/number-of-homeless-in-america-rises/4152986.html https://www.voanews.com/a/number-of-homeless-in-america-rise... “The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development released its annual Point in Time count Wednesday, a report that showed nearly 554,000 homeless people across the country during local tallies conducted in January. That figure is up nearly 1 percent from 2016. Of that total, 193,000 people had no access to nightly shelter and instead were staying in vehicles, tents, on the streets and other places considered uninhabitable. The unsheltered figure is up by more than 9 percent compared with two years ago.” (To scale, that would be 2.5 million homeless in China which has roughly similar figures: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homelessness_in_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homelessness_in_China). Would you prefer to live in a tent on land you didn't own or in a cave dwelling you did? This is what a cave dwelling is: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yaodong https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yaodong From the article you posted it says, “The thriving market around Yanan means a cave with three rooms and a bathroom (a total of 750 square feet) can be advertised for sale at $46,000.” I have been to Granada in Spain where they have similar dwellings carved into the hill-sides: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sacromonte#Origin_of_the_caves https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sacromonte#Origin_of_the_caves I imagine that cave dwelling is a thing in many parts of the world and, though traditional, it should probably not be confused with destitution. “In the last decade, yaodongs have been brought to the attention of scientists and researchers. These traditional dwellings have been regarded as an example of sustainable design.”
- gvb 8y agoHousing is a investment vehicle in China. From what I've read, a lot of housing is actually empty and is held strictly as an investment. That implies it is a speculation driven bubble that is going to pop when everything else goes upside down in China. Or maybe the Chinese government will achieve a "soft landing." Ref: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Under-occupied_developments_in_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Under-occupied_developments_in...
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoI actually looked through a few peepholes (they didn't even have glass, they just had doors with holes where a real peephole might go!) for some of the apartments in the building I was renting in. These units weren't even renovated, they were just concrete shells! The other way to tell is to count how many lights are on during your night walk. First thing you find is that units with windows facing into the complex are usually more occupied than the outer ones (makes sense, noise is a big problem in the latter). And traffic/parking was pretty bad at that complex, if 25% of the units were unoccupied, I couldn't fathom what full occupancy would actually look like.