6 ms·
RISC-V: More Than a Core
- microcolonel 8y agoThat IBS chart seems a bit baloney, why does the cost and cost share of software grow so dramatically at smaller nodes? It seems like most of the cost share increase would come from validation and physical design. I personally think that at this point, success (and hardware interest) in commodity RISC-V server hardware is mainly contingent on the availability of major compilers and runtime libraries, but that is necessary regardless of process technology. I don't know of many operators/users of server hardware who have any considerable investment in any ISA-locked software (except the odd proprietary package which would not honestly be too difficult to convince vendors to basically just recompile).
- mrob 8y ago>why does the cost and cost share of software grow so dramatically at smaller nodes? My guess is that the main reason is market segmentation. If you're willing to work at a smaller node, then you're willing to spend more money, and the software vendors can charge more.
- IshKebab 8y agoI'm pretty sure that is the development cost for the compilers, etc. You're not paying some other company to do that.
- microcolonel 8y agoYeah, I initially got the impression they were talking about the design automation software for the node, but I'm not really sure if that's the case.
- deepnotderp 8y agoThose "chip design estimates" are nearly always bs. For example, their "estimate" for what a 7nm chip would cost to develop was the next gen nvidia GPU. Literally one of the most complicated and expensive chips to design and yet for some reason they chose that to be representative of average.
- inamberclad 8y agoThis site managed to disable right clicking?
- tyingq 8y agoYes...annoying. It's in the main html as an embedded script: function nocontext(e) { return false; } document.oncontextmenu = nocontext; You can paste "javascript:void(document.oncontextmenu=null);" into the address bar to get it back.
- kevincox 8y agoIn Firefox Shift+Click bypasses this shenanigans as well.
- a_wild_dandan 8y agoI'm seeing no shenanigans in Firefox. The context menu works for me.
- devcpp 8y agoAnd it works for me on both Firefox and Chromium, uBlock disabled. I can't find the function in the HTML either. Was it just removed?
- tyingq 8y agoYes, looks like someone removed it. It's still in the source on the wayback machine cached copy: https://web.archive.org/web/20181015143110/https://semiengineering.com/risc-v-more-than-a-core/ https://web.archive.org/web/20181015143110/https://semiengin... That cached copy also seems to show the site was hacked for a while. Search the source for strings like "provigil free trial coupon". Edit: It's still hacked. See https://www.google.com/search?q=site%3Asemiengineering.com+viagra&oq=site%3Asemiengineering.com+viagra https://www.google.com/search?q=site%3Asemiengineering.com+v... Clicking on any of the results takes you through a redirect to a shady pharma site.
- Lind5 8y agoWhile RISC-V continues to grow, there are still gaps that may limit where RISC-V is used in designs https://semiengineering.com/risc-v-inches-toward-the-center/ https://semiengineering.com/risc-v-inches-toward-the-center/
- microcolonel 8y agoSure, but filling those gaps is the ongoing work of the foundation. The vast majority of ARM penetration is highly generic, ditto MIPS and Tensilica (e.g. my aftermarket camera lens has some 32-bit MIPS core in it, and doesn't call into MSA; this code could be compiled, assuming equivalent peripherals, to run on a standard RISC-V today and perform the same task).
- pdimitar 8y agoThe article says: > One of the big benefits of RISC-V is that the architecture is open source. To which I reply: ...Yeah, until Intel / AMD / Qualcomm / WhatHaveYou Corp.™ say that the implementation below is proprietary and must be defended with a copyright law. And probably compilers for Intel RISC-V CPU and AMD RISC-V CPU will be different because of a vastly different microcode. :( I want to believe in RISC-V but I am afraid the current incumbents will find a way to capitalize on the idea without showing any goodwill or actually working together... in just a few short months. Never underestimate a team of expert lawyers and marketers I guess. And I really wish that I am wrong. I will follow any RISC-V news eagerly.
- IshKebab 8y agoI think that's a far smaller risk than fragmentation. Without one company to control the ISA are we going to end up with a gazillion variants and extensions? How do you compile a program for that? Hell there are already a ton of variants defined in the base standard. I guess at the moment they are targeting embedded systems where it's reasonable that you compile your program specifically for one chip. Hard to imagine that working on the desktop though.
- agalunar 8y agoI suppose “variants” is not an inaccurate description, but it feels misleading (although you could argue about intention vs reality). The spec calls them “extensions”. Support for an extension can be checked at runtime, and unsupported instructions can be trapped and emulated. The base ISA is frozen, and the common extensions (floating point, atomics, vectors) are standardized. The spec also defines a subset of the extensions that general purpose processors are expected to support. It may be a hope born of bias (I’ve worked with the architects of RISC-V), but I don’t expect fragmentation to be one of the primary issues that RISC-V will face.
- pdimitar 8y agoI am no expert but... > Support for an extension can be checked at runtime, and unsupported instructions can be trapped and emulated. ...isn't that exactly fragmentation?
- bhasi 8y agoI see a sound byte from SiFive. Would have been nice if they had reached out to Shakti for their comment as well.
- chubs 8y agoI'm concerned that the many RISC-V projects seem to be stalling, I'd love to be convinced otherwise? * It's been almost 2 years since SiFive released their arduino-ish dev board and it hasn't been updated, surely there are huge gains in 2 years in such a fledgling ecosystem? I feel this is important because this board seems the obvious entry point into the RISC-V ecosystem for enthusiasts. * The 'BOOM' processor which showed many efficiency gains doesn't seem to be getting anywhere further than last time i checked on it which was perhaps a year or more ago. -edit- looking on their github releases, 2.1 was 6mo ago, and 2.1.1 was recent but shows minor changes, the project unfortunately looks stalled to me. * LowRISC which has one or two of the RaspberryPi co-founders on board, which seems to be a good sign as far as 'getting something out the door' - i can't seem to see any output from their project? Please prove me wrong, i'd like to get involved somehow but i have to be careful where I invest my time :)
- pippy 8y agoThere has been a decent amount of projects recently. Andes Announced 1.2 GHz CPUs made on 28nm die, and a Chinese company are taking orders for a 400MHz dual-core AI chip. SiFive at the start of the year did start selling HiFive Unleashed, but it is very expensive. The Berkeley processor is mostly a research CPU for FPGAs. I would however love to see it on actual silicon. At a guess i'd say it will be a few years until we see RISC-V popping up in more places.
- tyingq 8y ago"I would however love to see it on actual silicon." Qty 1, but... https://mobile.twitter.com/boom_cpu/status/1032447070928396289 https://mobile.twitter.com/boom_cpu/status/10324470709283962...
- chubs 8y agoNo kidding, that's impressive! That was a couple months ago now, i wonder if they've got it connected to a board/RAM and working ?
- phkahler 8y ago
- sitkack 8y ago> A previous project, open core 32, was a vibrant open-source hardware group in Europe. But what they made open was an implementation of a processor. With RISC-V, what is open is the instruction set, and you can use that to implement anything from the smallest IoT device to server-class processors. So open core 32 was an open implementation, RISC-V is an open idea. Sometimes an idea travels farther, faster, if it doesn't have an implementation. And the implementations that do exist, have a huge population of creators (rapid fans) to assist in its spread and usage. Brilliant. RISC-V isn't the Linux of hardware, it is the Unix.
- listic 8y agoThis one? https://opencores.org/ https://opencores.org/