13 ms·
Doctors warn of alarming C-section 'epidemic'
- jsoc815 8y agoFind it interesting that the article seems to place the blame on the women, when it's long been said that the docs and hospitals, ever in search of time compression and profits, were encouraging c-sections versus vaginal birth. That, to my knowledge, is the likely cause of the procedure appearing "fashionable" and "modern."
- siculars 8y agoBlame definitely on the docs (liability). That being said, most new obgyns are women. So ¯\_(ツ)_/¯.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI actually think it is probably more insidious than that. We have a lot fewer full-time homemakers. Women are much more likely to have paid jobs. The only way to schedule the birth is by scheduling a C-section. Waiting for the baby to show up when it decides to do so is a very organic, let nature take its course, humble thing to do and it is pretty alien to how most people live these days in developed countries. Historically, we farmed. We had to figure out how to respect nature and work with it. Most jobs today don't really do that. We think we are in control.
- cellis 8y agoActually historically, we foraged and hunted. After reading Sapiens I’m convinced that farming actually set humans on the path towards this very suffering. Large scale war, famine and pretty much every post agrarian revolution ill, is a direct consequence of having food surpluses.
- thewizardofaus 8y agoSapiens is a great book! We became domesticated by wheat.
- newnewpdro 8y agoIf you've never watched James Burke's series Connections [1], you'd probably enjoy it. I binge watched it years ago on youtube, and walked away with the distinct impression that our path to calamity started with the plough. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Connections_(TV_series)#Connections_(1978) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Connections_(TV_series)#Connec...
- laythea 8y agoI haven't had my first coffee in the morning yet, so it may be me, but I'm struggling to see the link between food surplus & farming and war?
- legulere 8y agoFarming first leads to food surplus, but also to a food supply that occasionally collapses without alternatives. It also leads to large hierarchical society structures and problems around ownership of land/resources, which basically is what war is about.
- jessaustin 8y agoHunting/gathering/swiddening tribes may have wars but they're just tribal wars, which are more like random murders. Lots of regret but those left alive can move on. In order to get awful generation-destroying authoritarian war wars, you have to have a sovereign. A sovereign requires what James C. Scott has called "legible" surplus. This is a surplus the sovereign can expect at regular intervals in the same locations. That is, fixed agriculture, preferably of grains or similar crops that don't spoil easily but require lots of related industry in order to support life.
- jrs95 8y agoWithout agriculture we'd still be hunter gatherers with little to no technology and everyone would be struggling just to survive. Sure, there are unpleasant side effects that come along with technological development but quality of life is still vastly better as a result.
- ant6n 8y agoCivilized countries have parental leave, where this is not an issue.
- jsoc815 8y ago> The only way to schedule the birth... Wow! Hadn't considered that at all. But, yeah, I guess, that would align w/ some other things I've heard(, but never actually experienced). Yikes! > We think we are in control. Yeah. (Thriller laughs) (edit) Btw, one of my college profs used to send a lot of time in rural India. He said women there would go into labor while in the field, leave and give birth, and then pretty much return to work immediately.
- sambe 8y agoAre you talking about the US? Many countries with state/cheap healthcare also have high rates (Europe). In the UK, I’d say there’s a bias towards “the natural way” (not offered epidural, counselling for elective CS, NCT antenatal courses tend to focus on natural methods etc). Eg https://www.rcm.org.uk/news-views-and-analysis/analysis/maternal-request-for-caesarean-section https://www.rcm.org.uk/news-views-and-analysis/analysis/mate...
- ertand 8y agoI wonder what its correlation with induction is. Artificially inducing labor does not tend to give the body enough time to adjust and progress.
- sambe 8y agoI don’t think c-section after successful induction is common. There are some number of failed inductions (i.e. nothing happens) which result in c-section. Bear in mind that this is generally done - like the original induction - because “giving enough time” after 42 weeks costs lives. This review finds the rate is actually lower after induction, contrary to popular claims: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4049989/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4049989/
- KaiserPro 8y ago[citation needed] induced labour happens in so many different ways, that broad statement is not going to fly. Also there are many way to induce labour, none of them are quick. Some take a few hours, others days. For example a "sweep" is where someone goes in and stretches the cervix, with their hands. There are pessaries too. None of it is quick.
- ertand 8y agoSorry for not being clear, I was specifically talking about pitocin level induction.
- dabbledash 8y agoElective induction of labor at 39 weeks results in a lower c-section rate than expectant management (waiting to see if labor will start naturally). https://www.nih.gov/news-events/news-releases/induced-labor-39-weeks-may-reduce-likelihood-c-section-nih-study-suggests https://www.nih.gov/news-events/news-releases/induced-labor-... https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4049989/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4049989/ Normally though, induction happens because there is some problem or because the pregnancy has gone past the due date, and in these cases your risk of a c-section is already elevated.
- grecy 8y agoMy sister-in-law just had her first baby, and got very into all of these statistics and the "medical industrial complex take on childbirth" I believe the WHO recommends around 10-15% of births should be C-Section in a healthy population, but the figures in first world countries are at least 3-5 times that. There are about 3 million stories of ladies "booking in" their birth a month or three in advance. I.e. I want my baby on the 3rd of May, lets schedule a C-Section now. It's more convenient that way. Also tons of stories of doctors wanting to go home for the weekend or to play golf, so they do a C-Section after only an hour of labor so they can hurry it up. It's horrifying that hospitals will market a "natural birth" as anything that is vaginal. i.e. it doesn't matter how many drugs they give you, it doesn't matter what drugs they give you to speed up the afterbirth, etc. etc. It's still "natural".
- harry8 8y ago"natural" like half of women dead in childbirth natural?
- Synaesthesia 8y agoWhen there are problems, you operate. Otherwise it’s preferable for natural birth for mother and baby, for reasons mentioned above.
- KaiserPro 8y agono. There are a whole host of reasons for having a c-section. The risk of having a massive tear (ie vag to arse(4c tear), or literally tearing a new arsehole) is 1 in 4. This has long term life altering consequences. An "elective" c-section is not the same as "booking in". The less "identity politics" that are wrapped up in this, the better.
- iforgotpassword 8y agoNo. > The risk of having a massive tear (ie vag to arse(4c tear), or literally tearing a new arsehole) is 1 in 4. Yes and it usually heals very well. The tissue there is made to deal with that. My sister had that happen 5 years ago, it even continued into her gut for a few cm. So that was a very bad case, but it still healed perfectly, although it took about 3 month.
- harry8 8y agoOk so no mention of the health implications of so called "natural" childbirth, which aren't trivial and have an increasing risk as your age. No mention of the rising age of mothers in wealthy countries. No mention of different trade offs for fit 19 year olds and less active 35 year olds. A lot of 30+ women decide they don't want to piss their pants and have painful intercourse for the rest of their lives. Word gets around and it undermines trust in doctors advice when they don't even mention the issues. A higher proportion of doctors make the c-section choice. They're kind of educated, doctors, less likely to be bullshitted into higher, unnecessary fees too. But you're not an idiot so you want the actual numbers. So did I. Not available, no research done and/or no doctors know of it and can hand you print outs of the papers. So much for evidence based medicine... There's an epidemic of women not just doing what they're told! FFS Lancet. How's their credibility nowadays? Taking hits?
- sergers 8y ago"A lot of 30+ women decide they don't want to piss their pants and have painful intercourse for the rest of their lives." Not specifically only for those reasons, my wife always wanted a c-section birth due to the risks with vaginal birth and recovery times.
- vladgur 8y agoI would imagine the recovery times for c-section are longer
- KaiserPro 8y agoDepends. If you have a tear (1/4 chance) it can take longer to heal, but it's not as debilitating in the short term. It doesn't affect your ability to get out of bed, as much. However a bad tear will have long lasting impact on your life. Incontinence, infection, painful sex, amongst a whole host of other problems. C-section has a higher risk of infection, There is significant muscle damage to, which limits your ability to lift and sit up. In terms of pain (emergency c-section compared to a 4b tear, the wife says the c-section was easier to recover from. )
- snapit 8y agoMy opinion based on living with a midwife for most of my life. Not fair to blame the women for this The reason is more to do with the doctors or medical staff being cautious about complications from a normal birth than caused by the preference of a women for chosing a c section.
- tth3uoku 8y agoDecisio Health has created real time dashboards that identify sepsis early so that care teams can start treatment protocols and monitor what has been done when a new shift comes on. It seems like something like that would be helpful for birthing. Midwives and doctors rely on their knowledge of past births and patients' health to make decisions during the birth. There's room for bias and error. If they could have access to more data about similar patients and outcomes as well as real time information about the patient, maybe the software could predict or confirm a decision about which high risk patients were going to need to be transferred to a hospital earlier into a birth. Hopefully it would prevent unnecessary cesareans for women they can confirm are progressing fine.
- basicplus2 8y agoThats nothing.. perth western australia has been the csection capital of the planet Heres 2012 figures https://www.birthsavvy.com.au/caesarean-section-rates-perth-2015/ https://www.birthsavvy.com.au/caesarean-section-rates-perth-...
- lathiat 8y agoHello from Perth. Just recently had our daughter at SJOG Murdoch but was not a Caesar. However we went with our obstetrician partially because he was less likely to push towards Caesar and that ended up being our experience. He was happy to wait and deliver late. We had some non trivial complications though from going natural. There was however clearly a high rate of those around us but I think basically it’s one of the more well known private hospitals for people to visit where you get the choice so plenty of people are just choosing to go that way for various reasons. also we are 30 but most of the people in our prenatal class were older except one.
- sambe 8y agoSeveral papers were released as part of a series, and are available currently in full text form: https://www.thelancet.com/series/caesarean-section https://www.thelancet.com/series/caesarean-section The more sensational language being reported appears to come from the FIGO position paper rather than the research. I’m not sure about the relationship between the two but they look to have been published together.
- danw1979 8y agoWomen feel enormous pressure (at least here in the UK) to give birth naturally, from both their peers and health professionals. How a baby is delivered is none of anyone's business but the mother herself. My wife (an epidemiologist) deliberated for months over having our second by VBAC (vaginal birth after csection) and opted to go for it, due to the overwhelming expectation from everyone around her that she should do it naturally, and despite having read an Australian study indicating higher rates of stillbirth during VBAC [citation needed]. Sadly, our daughter didn't make it through the labor. Needless to say, the csections that safely delivered my first, and recently (yay) third children seem like a miracle of modern medicine to us both. Even before this personal tragedy, I was astounded by the sheer force of opinion surrounding the cesarean section and childbirth in general. This is creating an environment where women are not able to make their own choices and I fear that the doctors in this article, however well meaning, by warning of an "epidemic" are only adding fuel to this fire.
- DanBC 8y agoJames Titcombe and others are campaigning pretty hard on this. Women need to be given correct information, but their wishes also need to be respected. These campaigners have persuaded the CQC to stop pressuring trusts over rates of C-section or normal birth, and to get the NMC to stop paying normal birth so hard.
- qrbLPHiKpiux 8y ago> How a baby is delivered is none of anyone's business but the mother herself. Try telling that to some of those here, in the US. The mantra is "do what I say, not what I do."
- Angostura 8y ago> How a baby is delivered is none of anyone's business but the mother herself. I'm sorry for your loss. Caesarian's costs the NHS around £1,700 a time compared with £750, for a normal childbirth and women also stay in hospital for twice as long on average. There is a general presumption in the UK that avoiding what is an invasive operation is preferable for both baby and mother alike, in the absence of other factors. I would argue that clearly How a baby is delivered is other people's business since other people are involved. However the ultimate choice should be the mother's.
- SigmundA 8y agoThis really seems like one obvious way in which we are effecting our own evolution and would not be surprised if in a short time (on an evolutionary scale) that humans will require c-sections for successful birth. This may not be a bad thing, the reason child birth is so difficult for humans vs most other animals is our head size vs the female pelvis. C-sections bypass the evolutionary constraint allowing more large headed babies to smaller pelvis women which could allow greater head size and perhaps even more intelligence. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Obstetrical_dilemma https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Obstetrical_dilemma
- aklemm 8y agoDo babies with too-big heads regularly die at birth if C-section isn't available?
- evgen 8y agoIn the world of modern medicine where complications like this would lead to an immediate c-section? No. Roll the clock back a couple of centuries or so and both mother and child would die.
- analognoise 8y agoYes, and it can kill the mother as well. I don't have statistics, but my wife and/or son wouldn't have made it without a csection.
- stordoff 8y agoAs far as I know, no, because emergency Caesareans are available (I was an emergency Caesarean - my mother was told I was 'small', and I ended up being close to 13lbs[1]), but it can cause other complications - my sister still has a small scar from a forceps birth, and the recovery time was longer for my mother. [1] The entire pre-birth care was flawed - at one point they couldn't find a pulse for over 24 hours and they were telling my mother to induce labour (because I was dead...). Edit: spelling fix
- JoshMnem 8y agoI think it's more likely that it's a bad thing. Babies are supposed to get seeded with microbes, which probably affects the immune system. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3110651/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3110651/
- rayiner 8y agoRelevant counterpoint: http://www.skepticalob.com/2018/03/what-if-c-sections-are-better-and-safer-than-vaginal-birth.html http://www.skepticalob.com/2018/03/what-if-c-sections-are-be.... The article doesn’t actually say why C sections are bad, it presupposes that fact, and assumes that rising C section rates must indicate some sort of “epidemic.”
- gdubs 8y agoThis page from the university of Utah suggests that C sections have a higher mortality rate, and are more expensive — while necessary in roughly 15% of deliveries: https://healthcare.utah.edu/the-scope/shows.php?shows=0_w7uql6a0 https://healthcare.utah.edu/the-scope/shows.php?shows=0_w7uq... Edit: This Time article points out that while maternal mortality rates have dropped significantly worldwide, they have actually risen in the US by 27%. They list numerous possible factors, a rise in unnecessary C Sections being one of them: http://time.com/4508369/why-u-s-women-still-die-during-childbirth/ http://time.com/4508369/why-u-s-women-still-die-during-child...
- amykyta 8y agoI would describe that post as propagating junk science. It’s cherry picking stats and skewing them. Odds ratio difference for pelvic organ issues for women who have a C section vs natural delivery. That’s just establishing strength of association. It’s surprising that there is any association for women who have a c section. The ‘safer for babies’ paragraph makes the claim that 692 babies would be saved if 1 million women chose c-section over natural delivery. So 0.069%? I hear you about wanting to be skeptical but there is conclusive research on negative effects to children who are delivered via c section. https://www.economist.com/science-and-technology/2017/10/14/more-evidence-for-a-link-between-caesarean-sections-and-obesity https://www.economist.com/science-and-technology/2017/10/14/... Not to mention that it’s a massive surgery for the mother with all the inherent risks of one.
- tptacek 8y agoCaesarians are way more dangerous than vaginal births. A C-section patient can die of pulmonary embolism from the blood clots from the procedure, directly from bleeding (the surgeon can nick an artery or the incision can lacerate during the actual birth), the wound can get infected (it's quite a large wound), and, of course, it's major surgery, so the anaesthesia can kill you (even if you're not all the way under; my wife had a near miss when our first was born). The risks get worse in subsequent Caesarians.
- JustSomeNobody 8y agoYears ago c-section rise was due to medical malpractice lawsuits from people like John Edwards, now it’s a fashion trend by the well to dos. Wow.
- lanius 8y agoI'm surprised C-section rates are higher among wealthier, education women. I would assume educated women are more likely to understand the risks associated with C-sections.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- noisy_boy 8y agoJust because they are wealthier or educated, doesn't mean they will make the most scientific decision; otherwise no doctor would ever smoke. Background/nurturing/societal norms also play a role. I have heard multiple well-off/educated women say, "no way I would put myself through so much pain when I can have quick c-section". Note that I'm not passing any judgement as it is their body and they are the one who will experience the pain so it is their decision.
- v_lisivka 8y agoHeads of their babies are larger, while vagina is same, so higher risk to rip vagina and die, so higher C-section rate.
- chongli 8y agoIt's not the size of the vagina that's the issue, it's the size of the pelvis. The vagina is extremely flexible. Bones much less so.
- watwut 8y agoHighrr age of mother during first childbirth and money probably make difference.
- epmaybe 8y agoInteresting article. I also thought that encouraging cesarean sections was something obstetricians did often to avoid the time spent waiting for delivery. However, in my training I witnessed quite the opposite. My resident and attending physicians were very cautious with going forward with cesarean sections, and would do whatever they could to continue with vaginal delivery when the mother wanted that, and also encouraged patients that wanted cesarean to consider vaginal delivery. Obviously this is one hospital, but it did help me not be as cynical of the profession, and will probably help serve as a reminder to do what's best for my future patients.
- learc83 8y agoDid you find that obstetricians encouraged inducing labor as a way to avoid spending time waiting for deliver?
- epmaybe 8y agoYes and no. I can only speak for this one hospital, but most of the time we would only induce if there was indication for doing so (twins is one example that comes to mind) or if the mother truly wanted induction. I don't recall specifically encouraging for reducing time, though the residents would joke about wanting to do so instead of waiting. I wonder if this is more common at teaching hospitals, so that attendings can hand off the waiting to the residents in training.
- e40 8y agoWith the birth of my son, we switched obgyn's because she basically told us it was pretty certain we'd have a c section, because she didn't have time to wait. We switched doctors and it was the first question we asked when interviewing prospective doctors. This was in 2000.
- lostlogin 8y agoI had no idea that interviewing doctors for delivering your child was a thing. Do they charge for it? Is it common?
- StreamBright 8y agoC section saved the life of my child. I do not care if there is an "epidemic" (what a heck does it mean in a context of a surgical procedure at all???).
- gdubs 8y agoIt means that in some cases the procedure is life saving, and in other cases unnecessary and potentially riskier than vaginal delivery. (Happy for you and your family that your child made it out OK — don’t know if it was recent, but congrats nonetheless!)
- StreamBright 8y agoWell I was kind of interested how can somebody use epidemic as a noun for a surgical procedure. There are many factors to this but c-section is often safer for the child than normal birth. I am not sure if there is any problem with c-sections, in my country it is widely used even as an elective option without issues. It is hard to see the downside.
- techsin101 8y agoAgain, study is pointing out that c section is being performed more than necessary, in fact so much more that it's epidemic. From data WHO calculated that about 20% deliveries should require c section. But numbers are reaching to 45%. Bad Effects in children born with c section are un clear and major surgery has risks for mother as well. Doing a surgery when not necessary is always a bad idea. So if you had a good out come, good for you. But understand you're one data point and can not be reflective of what should be.
- amalag 8y agoMy mother was in labor for over 36 hours (maybe more, she told me but I forgot) in 1976. You know that would be a C-section nowadays. She had two more children after that. I don't know how long her labor was for those but I assume it wasn't as bad.
- zrail 8y agoMy wife was in labor for 40ish hours in 2016. There was never any pressure for a c-section.
- hypertexthero 8y agoInteresting perspectives from cesarean born people: https://cesareanvoices.com/ https://cesareanvoices.com/ See in particular this presentation by Jane English: https://cesareanvoices.com/SHOW-small.pdf https://cesareanvoices.com/SHOW-small.pdf
- kuwze 8y agoI know most people on HN are guys, but I've heard a lot of women talk about the peer pressure. In fact some women look down on those that have children via a C-section. It's despicable.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- watwut 8y agoC-section all in all hurts more and you heal longer after that and you need more help afterwards. Plus it limits how many kids you can have safely. The dominance of guys shows up mostly by completely ignoring practical considerations.
- jaclaz 8y agoIn 2015 the WHO has issued this [0] [1]: >Conclusions Based on the available data, and using internationally accepted methods to assess the evidence with the most appropriate analytical techniques, WHO concludes: 1. Caesarean sections are effective in saving maternal and infant lives, but only when they are required for medically indicated reasons. 2. At population level, caesarean section rates higher than 10% are not associated with reductions in maternal and newborn mortality rates. 3. Caesarean sections can cause significant and sometimes permanent complications, disability or death particularly in settings that lack the facilities and/or capacity to properly conduct safe surgery and treat surgical complications. Caesarean sections should ideally only be undertaken when medically necessary. 4. Every effort should be made to provide caesarean sections to women in need, rather than striving to achieve a specific rate. 5. The effects of caesarean section rates on other outcomes, such as maternal and perinatal morbidity, paediatric outcomes, and psychological or social well-being are still unclear. More research is needed to understand the health effects of caesarean section on immediate and future outcomes. [0] https://www.who.int/reproductivehealth/publications/maternal_perinatal_health/cs-statement/en/ https://www.who.int/reproductivehealth/publications/maternal... [1] (PDF) http://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/10665/161442/1/WHO_RHR_15.02_eng.pdf http://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/10665/161442/1/WHO_RHR_15...
- nickwalton00 8y agoWell said, I think where all things indicate it will be healthy normal births should be the default, but when medical risks indicate otherwise than c sections can provide life saving help.
- jaclaz 8y agoYep, if you think about it, the above advice is nothing but "common sense" and good medicine practice. The point is that the decision between a normal birth and a C-section is to be taken on a case by case basis by a (hopefully) competent doctor and not "planned" (one way or the other) in advance or decided because of other reasons. Anecdata, my uncle was a surgeon and he always repeated us that "if it is really-really, and I mean really needed, than go for it, but otherwise never let anyone cut through your body".
- giardini 8y agoC-section babies are prone to certain ailments later in life: "Giant study links C-sections with chronic disorders" - http://sciencenordic.com/giant-study-links-c-sections-chronic-disorders http://sciencenordic.com/giant-study-links-c-sections-chroni... My guess is that this is tied to the reduced exposure to the mothers' vaginal and anal microbiome that occurs during vaginal delivery but which is absent in C-section. Much as childhood exposure to animals reduces autoimmune disorders in later life, natural birth also likely does the same. "Study: Children who grow up on family farms and drink raw milk have fewer allergies, autoimmune disorders" https://www.naturalnews.com/035802_raw_milk_farms_allergies.html# https://www.naturalnews.com/035802_raw_milk_farms_allergies....
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- nemonemo 8y agoAs the article says, the cause is not certain. From some study, higher c-section rate correlates with higher income, so my guess is that it could just be an outcome of better hygiene according to the hygiene theory.
- acd 8y agoBabies ingest vital microbes during natural birth helping kick start their immune system when exciting from the mothers vagina. It also helps to get the babys breathing started. The microbes that babies get in contact with during natural birth help form their gut microbes. Gut microbes are essential to human health. If we eat food from animals that have been given antibiotics or we take antibiotics, we mess with the gut microbe system that prevents us from getting sick. To clean environment is not good for humans. Ie with a little dirt our immune system is better. That is why for example people growing up on the country side has less allergy. https://www.wired.com/2014/04/missing-microbes-antibiotic-resistance-birth/ https://www.wired.com/2014/04/missing-microbes-antibiotic-re... The Normal Gut Microbiota: An Essential Factor in Health. Article https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3983973/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3983973/
- kdowining 8y agoEvery article I read on c-sections misses some really important facts: 1. c-section mortality and complication rates are often not separated between the women who get c-sections pre-scheduled and women who get them after hours of damaging labor and something already going horribly wrong. In fact, when I looked at the data for my own c-section, it seemed to indicate that scheduled c-sections were as safe if not safer than vaginal birth. 2. Vaginal birth leads to lifelong incontinence and sexual dysfunction in many women. Would I take a miniscule chance of death in exchange for not peeing my pants for the next 50 years? Yes. In exchange for having a way higher chance of a pain-free sex life again? Yes. Quality of life matters. Your relationship with your partner and with your own body matters. So many of these studies basically end in the hospital - i.e. did mom and baby survive, but then do not look at long-term outcomes of the MOM at all. I know many women with these issues. Women with horrific tearing and scarring, too. They're still dealing with it years later. It's not trivial even though these studies make it sound like the only thing is whether you live, not how you live. 3. c-sections do not carry the risk of baby being deprived of oxygen during birth. No risk of cord getting stuck around the head, etc. The people trying to convince me that I shouldn't have a c-section because of very ambiguous studies dealing with asthma or allergies are totally missing the forest for the trees on this one. Lastly, and this is an experiential point from someone who has actually had a c-section: the whole thing was completely painless. I was on my feet the same day. I only had a bit of trouble going from laying to standing in the first couple of days, but I otherwise was in pain and could walk, sit, take care of the baby, everything else. By the time I was out of the hospital on day 5 I felt completely back to normal and could do anything and everything. Is it major surgery? Sure. But I can tell you that women who had vaginal deliveries were still in pain weeks after the delivery and for months if they had extensive tearing or episiotomies. Most of my friends on the "natural" train, now having done that and seen my experience in comparison, wish they hadn't gone that route because they're still dealing with the damage it caused them.
- kdowining 8y agoOtherwise not in pain.