9 ms·
The program to build NASA’s moon rocket could double in price to $9B
- neonate 8y agohttp://archive.is/aEJbG http://archive.is/aEJbG https://outline.com/k7bktY https://outline.com/k7bktY
- Jaruzel 8y agoI don't get it. NASA should re-vector as an overseeing space administration for US based space projects, and let the commercial sector do the actual building, testing, and flying. Think of all that money saved that can be used for a better purpose elsewhere.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- wefarrell 8y agoThe purpose of NASA is to dish out pork to congressional districts.
- losteric 8y agoThat, and decades of world-leading scientific research.
- Rooster61 8y agoUnderfunded, bureaucratically neutered, glacially slow world-leading scientific research.
- oh_sigh 8y agoI have neither the time nor the inclination to explain myself to a man who rises and sleeps under the blanket of the very science that I provide, and then questions the manner in which I provide it! I would rather you just said "thank you" and went on your way, Otherwise, I suggest you pick up a gyroscope and stand an experiment. Either way, I don't give a damn what you think you are entitled to!
- Rooster61 8y agoI may or may not have laughed out loud in my cube. Well played, sir
- orf 8y agoDo you like your microwave?
- Rooster61 8y agoUhh, sure? Not sure how this is relevant.
- orf 8y agoThat came out of some NASA research. A lot of stuff did, some mistakenly attributed, some invented before but improved a lot by NASA https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/NASA_spinoff_technologies https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/NASA_spinoff_technologies
- Rooster61 8y agoI don't think the microwave applies here. Folks were nuking food with radio waves as far back as the 30's, long before NASA was even close to being around.
- philipkglass 8y agoThat page does not contain any mention of the microwave oven. The use of microwaves for heating food was patented in 1945 and first commercialized in 1947, well before NASA: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Percy_Spencer#Career https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Percy_Spencer#Career https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microwave_oven#Commercial_availability https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microwave_oven#Commercial_avai...
- pfdietz 8y agoNext you're going to tell us NASA invented sliced bread, the wheel, and fire.
- snackbugs 8y agoNo, I don't.
- mturmon 8y agoThis seems to be a dig, but it has no content. I mean, sure, if the funding was greater, the speed of research would quicken in many cases. But you can't criticize from both directions. Do you want cheaper, or faster? Also, "bureaucratically neutered" is an odd phrase. It's the government, so of course there is oversight and politics at an agency level. But OTOH, the agency's record at not interfering with discrete science findings is actually very good. What point are you trying to make? [Disclosure, I have published research while funded by NASA.]
- Rooster61 8y ago> But you can't criticize from both directions. I can't say I understand how that's criticizing from both directions. The research is underfunded, and as you noted more funds generally increases the speed of the research. There are layers of bureaucracy, which naturally slows down the rate of research due to waiting on various aspects of the research to get reviewed and deemed useful to the agency. How is that attacking it from two sides? And your take on what I mean by "bureaucratically neutered" is fairly accurate, but I stand by it. I am referring to having non technical bureaucrats in the agency calling shots about research they may not understand based on non-related pressures (pork funds drying up due to political shifts, undesirable media exposure for research with uncomfortable results, sudden change in leadership that may not think the research is necessary after all, etc). All this said, I have indeed never been involved with the agency so you might have a better perspective on the matter than I.
- mturmon 8y agoIn my experience your comment has very little grounding. I have an extensive science publication record from research supported by NASA. Aerospace and aerospace technology (as opposed to science) is more sensitive to top-level agency strategy changes.
- Rooster61 8y agoA fair distinction I failed to make, and a point well taken. To also be fair though, I think generally when the layperson (me included) considers NASA and things under its purview, it's easy to blindly scope it within the context of aerospace, especially beside the context of this particular article. Also, I'd think at JPL you guys would have a bit easier time getting funding/latitude to do the research you do vs a lower profile lab, given JPL's track record.
- wolf550e 8y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EaNKtIY6JpQ&t=289 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EaNKtIY6JpQ&t=289 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cJCenuebAa8&t=1089 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cJCenuebAa8&t=1089
- garmaine 8y agoThe amount spent on world-leading scientific research pales in comparison to the pork.
- walrus01 8y ago> The purpose of defense contracting is to dish out pork to congressional districts. Edited to reflect my opinion of reality... If you look at how the individual subsystems and subcontractors for the F-35 program were spread around various states and congressional districts, creating jobs in various places, they intentionally designed it to be unkillable.
- londons_explore 8y agoThis is what they do already right? NASA doesn't actually build any rockets anymore - it's all contracted out to various companies.
- Latteland 8y agoThere is billions of spending on projects they don't need, forced by congress, like SLS. It's mostly not independent systems - space x is far more separate than boeing and other companies.
- moreira 8y ago"There is billions of spending on projects they don't need" On the list of governemnt expenses... NASA is almost a rounding error ($18.4 billion in 2011, about 0.5% of the $3.4 trillion US budget). Perspective is important.
- pc86 8y agoI think their point may have been (and if it wasn't, mine is) not to cut that funding but to reallocate it to more oversight so the overall pace of space production and research can be expanded.
- Latteland 8y agoYes my point is not that nasa is a bad thing - I want to increase spending at nasa. But I don't want it to be wasted on basically congressional district earmarks. There's always been some of that going on, unfortunately, but the SLS is a major drain on other things at Nasa. They can't afford to waste money on this. SLS may never fly, it's at least a big rocket looking for a use case.
- ethbro 8y agoThe problem seems inherent in large engineering projects (> 2 terms worth of work) and the ephemeral nature of politicians. I feel like there's probably a "law" using a constant that states "As a project's ETA approaches T, the actual delivery date approaches infinity." Where T is ~10 years.
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoIt's politics. The SLS is not about space. It's been referred to as the Senate Launch System for years now and that's very accurate. It started back in 2010 and still isn't going up anytime soon. For comparison the first time we sent anything into orbit (a probe) was 1958. The first time we put a man in orbit was 1961. In 1962 Kennedy would give his famous space speech. In 1968 we sent a man around the moon. In 1969 we put a man on the moon. Compare the timelines and it's simply pathetic. But what the SLS does provide is an immense number of jobs, votes, and support for the congressmen that keep it funded. The last chief of NASA, Charles Bolden, was the person you want on paper. A decorated and high ranking military officer who was an astronaut with a STEM education. What he was not was a political player, and I think NASA has suffered under him. The person that has replaced him is, at a glance, is the exact opposite of who you want. Jim Bridenstine is an MBA, career politician, and has no technical background whatsoever. But he does have a genuine interest in space which he has worked to support for years, and he is, for better or for worse, a political player. And I have hopes and expectations that he will change the direction of NASA into the far more logical direction that you, and just about everybody, sees would be more productive. And I think we're already seeing this. Recently NASA released a scathing report against the SLS which said, without mincing many words, that they're not going anywhere anytime soon if they have to rely on the SLS. The lengthy report is here [1], here [2] is a random media report on it to give some sort of cliff notes. This is the sort of stuff that Bolden, for whatever reason, did not have the capability or will to push through. That report didn't say anything that everybody didn't already know, but actually stating those things was speaking what must not be spoken - and is now something that demands action. [1] - https://oig.nasa.gov/docs/IG-19-001.pdf https://oig.nasa.gov/docs/IG-19-001.pdf [2] - https://www.extremetech.com/extreme/278656-nasa-report-blames-boeing-mismanagement-for-sls-delays https://www.extremetech.com/extreme/278656-nasa-report-blame...
- phkahler 8y agoWhile I agree with you about NASA funding pork projects these days, there is another side. I don't think people realize how important pork might be (I'm speculating this isn't a firm belief for me). Without pork projects, we could have even more wealth disparity in the US. What would happen to Alabama if the NASA funded aerospace programs went away? What would happen to the low cost of living areas dominated by retired persons is social security payments went away? I believe this is why the EU has had problems - they're all on the same currency but countries are not permitted to print their own money and they don't have international money redistribution programs. In such an environment any country with a trade deficit will eventually suffer - see Greece. I'm not advocating such pork distributions but I think they may actually serve a purpose other than getting votes. OTOH some places get pork that really don't need it even for the reasons I outlined above.
- snackbugs 8y agoThat is currently how things work, and if you were to topple the current system and try to do the exact same thing over again you will get the same result in a couple of decades: a few entrenched aerospace firms with deep connections to congress on corporate welfare and eye-popping flight cycle costs.
- JamesBarney 8y agoThis is exactly what they're doing. Boeing is the commercial sector that's having cost overruns.
- skookumchuck 8y agoHow you make money with government contracting is to bid low and then have huge cost overruns.
- inamberclad 8y agoNASA's job comes from NACA's: to be at the bleeding edge of aerospace research and actually do the things that aren't economical for the corporate world yet.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoTechnically it's NASA's second moon rocket. Also the timing here is really lucky. This will get buried under today's aborted launch.
- adventured 8y agoIt was all over the news yesterday. It didn't get buried. More likely, today's event provides some positive increase to the political argument in favor of plowing billions more into getting all the new US launch systems up to where they need to be.
- Tuna-Fish 8y agoSLS will necessarily cost ~1B per launch. It will definitely never ferry people to ISS.
- craftyguy 8y agoMost people reading the news won't understand these valid points you are making. To them, any US-made rocket is sufficient for "doing necessary space stuff that the government tells me they need to do."
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Rooster61 8y agoBoeing: “[We have] restructured our leadership team to better align with current program challenges, and we are refining our approaches and tools to ensure a successful transition from development to production.” Sounds to me like utterly worthless corp-speak for "shit isn't going so hot, but we are going to fix everything, just you wait". I think there might be trouble in paradise among Boeing's top brass. In no way surprised to hear this, especially after seeing Boeing spreading FUD here recently (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18139146 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18139146). They must not be comfortable with all of the other upstarts in the industry threatening their comfy spot as one of NASA's go-to contractors.
- ProAm 8y ago9B is nothing when you look at how much waste is spent in the military, like the the Abrams tanks that the military consistently says it doesnt want but always gets [1] [2] [1] https://www.military.com/daily-news/2014/12/18/congress-again-buys-abrams-tanks-the-army-doesnt-want.html https://www.military.com/daily-news/2014/12/18/congress-agai... [2] https://www.military.com/daily-news/2016/02/11/ohio-wins-again-in-armys-budget-for-more-m1-abrams-tanks.html https://www.military.com/daily-news/2016/02/11/ohio-wins-aga...
- madeuptempacct 8y agoWhy wouldn't you want an Abrams? It does all the things. Sure, it's pigfat, but it's a proven design and it's not hard to stick an APS on it. Honestly, the Abrams is kind of like the A-10 and the F-22, even if you are trying to make fun of the US military, there is just nothing to latch on to with those platforms. They do what they are supposed to do, even when taking cost into consideration. Edit: I admit to not reading the article and not knowing about the over-production.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Why wouldn't you want an Abrams? It does all the things Because you haven't fought the kind of war that heavy armor is useful (particularly on an effectiveness to logistical burden analysis) for in decades, and don't expect to in the foreseeable future.
- madeuptempacct 8y agoAbrams lit up Iraqi T-72s recently. Absolute air superiority isn't a thing in a real war, even for the US. ATGMs will lose their deterrence factor if APS systems end up working as advertised, so tanks will regain their relevance. Also, tanks support infantry in cities. When properly utilized, they don't end up on fire like T-80s in Grozny. Again, during the Iraq war, marines were supported by tanks in cities.
- pc86 8y ago
- maxxxxx 8y agoWhat do they actually plan to do with the SLS? I only hear that it's really needed but they are pretty vague about what for.
- stetrain 8y agoCurrently the main plan is the lunar gateway station: https://www.nasa.gov/feature/nasa-s-lunar-outpost-will-extend-human-presence-in-deep-space https://www.nasa.gov/feature/nasa-s-lunar-outpost-will-exten... The Europa Clipper mission is also currently scheduled to launch on SLS: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Launch_System#Missions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Launch_System#Missions
- garmaine 8y agoIt is really needed to ensure that NASA still exists as a funded agency.
- craftyguy 8y agoTechnically, it is not needed to ensure that NASA is funded. Congress and the current administration think it is needed, because they're stuck in the 1960s and think the space race is still a thing (meanwhile ignoring/underfunding crucial planetary and Earth climate sciences that NASA also performs).
- garmaine 8y agoIt was sarcasm. The jobs in key congressional districts would disappear if NASA was allowed to do what makes sense for an effective space exploration program. So congress has taken over mandating what NASA's goals should be, to make sure that their key constituents remain employed on government contracts.
- vat 8y agoheard they were free under fully automated luxury gay space communism
- InclinedPlane 8y agoThis is one of the nasty legacies of the Apollo program. NASA crewed spaceflight has always been a lot messier, a lot more political, and a lot more pork-barrel oriented than robotic spaceflight. That goes back to the Johnson administration and the extensive politicking he did to make Apollo happen. He very cleverly figured out how to locate NASA centers and contractor jobs to areas with a lot of political power in congress. However, that legacy has outlasted the Apollo program and today we have the SLS, which has the primary purpose of funneling government money to several very specific corporations in very specific congressional districts. Results are, at best, a secondary objective.
- topspin 8y ago> NASA crewed spaceflight Fixating on the troubles of NASA's crewed programs might make sense if NASA were doing well with their uncrewed programs. Except they're not[1]. [1] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/is-the-james-webb-space-telescope-too-big-to-fail/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/is-the-james-webb...
- InclinedPlane 8y agoJWST is just one program among many. Also, it may seem that it matches the level of problems of crewed spaceflight but it really doesn't. The JWST program's enormous budget is small (in per year amounts) compared to things like Orion or SLS. If JWST was burning through money the same way SLS was it would be a $40-50 billion program. Additionally, there is a huge number of highly successful robotic missions that have been running or are in the works. Just now in terms of active programs there is the Curiosity rover, the Juno Jupiter orbiter, the Parker Solar Probe, New Horizons, InSight, Dawn, TESS, Osiris-REX, MRO, Fermi, STEREO, and many more.
- thinkcontext 8y agoShould NASA scrap it and save some money by chipping in to SpaceX's efforts?
- sorrymate 8y agoIt seems like no one is hold Boeing accountable for completing the project with the given budget. And to add insult to injury, Boeing is being improperly awarded tens of millions of dollars for performance fees the company has not earned [1]. If a project is failing, just cut your loses and scrap it. This political pork spending doesn't help anyone excited about space exploration. [1] https://arstechnica.com/science/2018/10/theres-a-new-report-on-sls-rocket-management-and-its-pretty-brutal/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2018/10/theres-a-new-report-...
- Rooster61 8y ago> This political pork spending doesn't help anyone excited about space exploration. Nope, but it keeps asses in congressional seats and the pockets attached to them full.
- InclinedPlane 8y agoNASA has little say in the matter, this is a congressionally mandated project. NASA didn't want it, but it turns out to funnel money into mostly the same companies that were getting money for the Shuttle program, and congress loved that so now NASA has to make do with what they are given.
- bilbo0s 8y ago>by chipping in to SpaceX's efforts... What guarantees do tax payers have that the money won't be wasted at SpaceX just as it's wasted at Boeing? Why not scrap it, and just save the money. Full stop. If Boeing and SpaceX are not able to do their things without NASA continuously pumping new billions into them, then we should take a step back, reevaluate, and consider a total rehaul of the future roadmap. Because obviously things aren't working. But we're not at that point yet. The only thing we've proven thus far is that giving out lots and lots of money does not seem to solve the problem of project setbacks.
- anovikov 8y agoMeanwhile, Falcon 9 became the world's most reliable launch vehicle today (after today's Soyuz-FG launch failure): http://www.spacelaunchreport.com/log2018.html http://www.spacelaunchreport.com/log2018.html Vehicle /Attempts Est* 95%CI* Succes Fail ================================================================ Falcon 9 v1.2 42/42(D) 0.98 0.90-1.00 42 None 2015- Atlas 5 77/78 0.98 0.92-1.00 68 06/15/07 2002- Delta 4M(+) 27/27 0.97 0.85-1.00 27 None 2002- Soyuz-FG 54/55 0.96 0.89-1.00 0 10/11/18 2001- Ariane 5-ECA 65/67 0.96 0.89-1.00 2 01/25/18 2002-
- jayzalowitz 8y agoI mean Soyuz-FG did just fail and not kill its occupants, so good on that team!
- Rebelgecko 8y agoIt seems weird that the Falcon 9 only includes numbers for "v1.2"(I'm assuming this is block 4/5?), while other vehicles don't have the same granularity. Also IMO it should count as a failure to blow up on the pad and destroy your payload, even if it's before the launch.
- jccooper 8y agoAll of the OP's vehicles have specific versions, which are (mostly) the latest flying iteration. They just use different nomenclature.
- npongratz 8y agoPerhaps you mean world's most reliable currently active launch vehicle? At your link, I see the retired Atlas 2/2AS also had a perfect record, with more attempts (63 successes of 63 attempts).
- anovikov 8y agoThat's correct. Recently retired Delta II also had a great record. Only active ones count.
- nwah1 8y agoIf Trump is good for anything, it is for complaining about contractors charging too much money. Hopefully he complains.
- InclinedPlane 8y agoSpoilers: Trump is not, in fact, good for anything.
- mfer 8y agoFWIW, going far over budget is pretty typical on gov contracts like this. Often times everyone knows this is going to happen from the start. It would be surprising (out of character) if this didn't happen.
- ardfie 8y agoThis is a good interview on the subject you mention http://www.econtalk.org/bent-flyvbjerg-on-megaprojects/ http://www.econtalk.org/bent-flyvbjerg-on-megaprojects/
- TheOtherHobbes 8y ago$9B? Over a decade or so? $900M a year? That's something like 0.15% of the annual military budget of the US. For comparison, the F35 program has already cost nearly $500B and is going to cost at least $1.5T over its lifetime. $9B - for a Moon rocket - is pocket change. Sure, cost overruns = bad. But let's at least have some perspective here.
- autokad 8y agoI agree, sounds pretty affordable for a rocket. I think the Hubble costed around ~ 4.5B. color me surprised if it doesn't end up to at least 15B. Now for cost over runs for something I am pretty sure isn't going to work? James Webb tele.
- xoa 8y ago>But let's at least have some perspective here. Yes, let's have some perspective, starting with you. The perspective is not some "waste on military" like so many in this thread claim, the actual relevant comparison is what the $9 billion could have done invested in other rocket companies. You've set up a "big entrenched corp player only or else nothing" dichotomy that was possibly relevant for the 1960s-2000s. But it was obsolete at least as of 2010 with the successful launch of the Falcon 9. If we're talking billions for relatively blue sky research, there are now more players, and players with far more proven capability to deliver and far, far superior designs and ambitions. The SLS even if realized as planned is garbage at this point, to have a sustained lunar presence requires far better economics then it could ever offer. It's not the 60s anymore, and NASA's (and the US government overall) own stated goals the point is not merely to get people back on the moon for a bit then leave but rather to develop something more permanent and useful. A fully reusable methalox stack is just a fundamentally better goal there. Should NASA continue to support R&D? Absolutely! And I'd fully support putting even more billions into that. But just because it's a "rounding error" to the US budget doesn't make billions "pocket change", it's still completely reasonable to expect value for the money. The same is true anywhere else, just because some people are spending more and have higher budgets doesn't mean they want to piss that budget away. I'd love to see NASA pouring billions into the BFR and Blue Origin's efforts or even more blue sky stuff like going back to some older experiments with a modern twist and working on methalox linear aerospike engines, and then making all that available to US businesses. NASA doing both science and also risky but potentially big payoff basic rocket R&D would be awesome and valuable, and well worth billions. NASA flushing billions down the Boeing drain is not equivalent, in fact what makes it so enraging is precisely that it could be working towards space exploration and development so much more effectively (still providing American jobs even!).
- woodandsteel 8y agoThe big danger for the SLS will be when SpaceX's BFR starts flying. Not only will both stages be reusable, but for flights beyond the Earth a BFR will first go into orbit, and next be refueled there by another BRF, and then take off with full tanks, instead of the almost empty ones as will be the case with SLS. The result is the BFR will be able to land 10+ times as much cargo on the Moon or Mars as the SLS, and at maybe 1 percent the cost per ton. I think what is going to happen is the tax payers will finally wake up to how they are being ripped off, and the SLS program will be canceled.
- tabtab 8y agoWhy so pricey? It's not like it's rocket science ... oh, wait