7 ms·
Waymo’s driverless cars have logged 10M miles on public roads
- deepnotderp 8y agoInterestingly enough, the new version is supposed to have a completely revamped sensor suite including a new LIDAR, new cameras and radar. This suggests two interesting things to me: 1) Google/Waymo, the "software and ML can solve this problem" company is admitting that hardware is important to solving the problem. 2) They are likely much further away from L5 or even public release than some believe given that they are now completely revamping their sensor suite.
- 303space 8y agoNot sure where you got the idea that Waymo doesn’t value hardware development - their whole lawsuit saga against Uber was over lidar trade secrets (google “laser is the sauce”). Maybe you were thinking of Tesla who has insisted their existing video/radar stack will be competitive with enough ML? For all the other major SDV companies I’m familiar with, affordable and peformative lidar is a huge focus.
- deepnotderp 8y agoWaymo handed out pcbs as earrings and their patents were bs. Most companies want lidar to get cheaper not better. Very rarely has the solution to a perception problem been "better sensors" as opposed to "more ml".
- vntok 8y agoI interpreted it as the exact opposite :) If Waymo can revamp the car's sensor suite this late in the process, all the while ramping up their fleets and consumer services, it suggests to me that their software is sufficiently powerful and flexible not to need massive and costly retraining; basically I think they have "solved" the problem on the software side (given appropriate constraints such as good weather, excellent mapping, etc.) and are now working on rationalizing the hardware costs.
- scoggs 8y agoI think it's safe to say they wouldn't be logging anywhere near 10M miles if that weren't the case. Especially when the graph shows that they've completed 6M of those 10M in the last year! (https://www.theatlas.com/charts/S1uAcpj97 https://www.theatlas.com/charts/S1uAcpj97)
- thecopy 8y agoCan these systems reason? If a driverless car went on a road that started spiraling so that the road would be upside down, would the car just keep following the road, not realizing it will fall down or would it realize it cannot continue?
- Judgmentality 8y agoI'd bet humans would handle a corkscrew road that makes the car do a barrel roll (I think that's what you're trying to describe) worse than a robot would. Luckily that type of road doesn't exist, for numerous reasons that have nothing to do with robots.
- scoggs 8y agoI know it's a serious conversation but... > Luckily that type of road doesn't exist Speak for yourself. In more related news I have a friend who helps out on Waymo and he's ALWAYS posting great articles about Waymo tech, always showing off amazing pictures of what he's working on, and he's always positing about how great things in the future could be. He's not the type of dude to over hype something, he's not the type of person who over exaggerates things either. He's not insanely fanboy-ish about it but he's definitely borderline. But, I guess when your vehicles are blowing the competition out of the water you'd be excited too?
- jobigoud 8y agoThere will be fun attacks/pranks on driverless cars. Imagine waiting for it to enter a roundabout but your friends are at all the exits holding big wrong way / no entry signs.
- nickwalton00 8y agoBut then the car has full video footage of everything your doing to hand over to the police...
- jedberg 8y agoI've seen a huge uptick of Waymo cars on the road lately. I live in Cupertino (the next town over from Mt. View) and yesterday I saw three within the span of one light cycle, each going in a different direction. At this point I see at least one if not a lot more every weekday.
- aqzman 8y agoIn your experience do they drive differently than any other car on the road? If a vehicle around you was powered by Waymo with no markings stating as much would you know (ignoring the fact of an empty driver's seat)?
- jedberg 8y ago> In your experience do they drive differently than any other car on the road? For sure. They drive like the most conservative driver you'll meet, to the point of being a bit dangerous. They come to a full stop at every stop sign, which here in California is unexpected, and unexpected means dangerous. They also slam on their brakes a lot, without regard to how far away the person behind them is (as opposed to when I have to slam on the brakes, I check the rear view and if possible cut it a little closer to the car in front if the car behind is really close). They putter out of stop lights, which is mostly just annoying, and they generally follow the speed limits, even on roads where all the rest of the traffic is typically 10mph over. To be fair, they are doing what in theory is much safer, but since they don't act like a human, it makes them unpredictable. > If a vehicle around you was powered by Waymo with no markings stating as much would you know (ignoring the fact of an empty driver's seat)? Well the massive LIDAR unit on top is a big giveaway. :) Actually that's the biggest giveaway. The cars are unmarked otherwise, and there is always a driver in the seat. They just may not have their hands on the wheel, but that's hard to tell from outside. And of course all of the aforementioned strange driving habits.
- snrji 8y ago> Waymo cars reportedly have problems turning left, a flaw the Information calls “the Zoolander problem”: local residents reported waiting behind Waymo cars for minutes at a time as the algorithm hesitates to turn into traffic. UPS drivers are told not to turn left for a reason. Couldn't Waymo do the same?
- jedberg 8y agoI think that only works for UPS because everyone else is turning left. But imagine a world where no car will turn left. I wonder if traffic would flow better or not. I suspect not, because if that were the case, cities would outlaw left turns, and as far as I know, no city has done that.
- snrji 8y agoFair enough.
- TekMol 8y agoThere is a difference between individual behavior and the law. Imagine a world where no person drinks alcohol. I wonder if it would be more peaceful. I suspect yes. Even though outlawing alcohol is not a solution that would lead to this world.
- Piskvorrr 8y agoThe issue is that "avoid left turns if possible" adds extra mileage and extra traffic on those streets that are used for a set of right turns; plus it's a SHOULD, not a MUST [RFC2119] - sometimes the right-turn detour would be just too long. UPS has a slight advantage here as it has a set of points to visit, not necessarily in a given order - more routing options, as compared to an A-to-B route.
- jobigoud 8y ago> But imagine a world where no car will turn left. I wonder if traffic would flow better or not. We have a ton of roundabouts in Europe and if you ignore the merge into the roundabout, it transforms any turn into a right turn.
- erikig 8y ago> "Competing with other companies with autonomous-vehicle programs like Uber, Tesla, Apple, and GM’s Cruise, Waymo is leading the pack in terms of road miles driven." I'd think Tesla would be leading in terms of autonomous mikes driven given that they have sold 100k+ vehicles with Autopilot.
- maxerickson 8y agoDoes Tesla Autopilot navigate controlled intersections on it's own? If not, it's kind of a silly comparison.
- milesokeefe 8y agoIt doesn't. It's just RGB camera + front-facing radar based lane keeping and traffic aware cruise control. It will also change lanes when you signal, but that's just augmented lane keeping. It's frustrating and dangerous how many people don't realize the massive difference there is between Autopilot and autonomy. It's mostly Tesla's fault in how they market it IMO.
- slivym 8y agoNo, if you want to compare autonomous miles driven by that definition the Chevrolet Cruze is leading in terms of autonomous miles driven given that they sold the most vehicles in the US with cruise control. If you want to talk about real autonomous driving then it's Waymo.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoDo Cruze vehicles supply data back to GM constantly that is used to improve self driving models? Updated models which are pushed back down to vehicles?
- glenrivard 8y agoHere is the pace. 2012 miles per day 240 2014 miles per day 636 2017 miles per day 4,630 Feb 2018 miles per day 10,753 June 2018 miles per day 16,494 July 2018 miles per day 25,000
- ksec 8y agoIt doesn't say 10M miles by how many cars though? Could they start trialing discounted Taxi Ride on a massive scale? How many more miles of testing do we need before this can be rolled out commercially?
- londons_explore 8y agoThe USA has 7.1 fatalities per billion km driven. Thats 1 fatality per ~100M miles on average. So presumably Waymo would have to drive a few hundred million miles without a fatality to conclusively be able to say 'we are safer'.
- imtringued 8y agoYou're assuming that the only thing an accident can result in is loss of human life. Injury statistics are far more interesting because they occur more frequently. [1] At a rate of 24 injuries per 100 million km waymo cars should have resulted in quite a few injuries already. [1] https://www.transport.govt.nz/resources/tmif/safetyandsecurity/ss014/ https://www.transport.govt.nz/resources/tmif/safetyandsecuri...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- londons_explore 8y agoWaymo has already had some injuries. > There was an occupant in the driver's seat of the Waymo vehicle who suffered minor injuries, Tyler added. https://phys.org/news/2018-05-waymo-self-driving-car-collision-arizona.html#jCp https://phys.org/news/2018-05-waymo-self-driving-car-collisi...
- twiceaday 8y agoA human drove into a Waymo car. I would not classify that as Waymo having some injuries. The driving safety statistics should only cover decisions made by the auto-pilot. If not simply because the same auto-pilot will be used in the future but not the same vehicles / vehicle seating arrangements and related safety measures.
- oldgradstudent 8y agoWhen did the meaning of the adjective "driverless" change from "without a driver" to "with a safety driver, engineer and a remote operator"?
- lawrenceyan 8y agoWhere did they say that anywhere here?
- oldgradstudent 8y agoIt is quite clear from recent press reports that the vast majority of Waymo's 10M miles were logged with a safety driver, and some with an additional safety engineer, but the title talks about "Waymo's driverless cars". So obviously, the adjective driverless no longer means without a driver. The part about an additional remote operator is tongue in cheek. https://www.theinformation.com/articles/waymos-big-ambitions-slowed-by-tech-trouble https://www.theinformation.com/articles/waymos-big-ambitions...