22 ms·
Leaked Google briefing, admitting a “shift towards censorship”
- adamrezich 8y agoThe watermark makes it really annoying to read, but unless it gets refuted by Google, it has to be real, right? (That's how these things work these days...?)
- p1necone 8y agoThe Breitbart watermark makes me very suspicious, I would treat it as probably worthless until we see more reliable sources.
- tropo 8y agoWhy? It's no different from the logo on a TV network news video feed. It's just a news agency trying to make things painful for competitors trying to steal a story without credit. If not for Breitbart being censored (fitting this story...) by Hacker News, the original article might have been linked: https://www.breitbart.com/tech/2018/10/09/the-good-censor-leaked-google-briefing-admits-abandonment-of-free-speech-for-safety-and-civility/ https://www.breitbart.com/tech/2018/10/09/the-good-censor-le...
- gugujbh 8y agoSo basically HN is subverting copyright laws because of misguided moderation principals. Way to go.
- shittyadmin 8y agoThey're definitely not the most reputable news source and many of their opinion pieces definitely step into fake territory, but I think outright falsifying an entire document like this would be a very extreme move, even for them.
- batiudrami 8y agoMore likely that someone else falsified it and they didn't fact check correctly. But Google's statement appears to confirm that it's real.
- spangry 8y agoThe Breitbart article states: "Responding to the leak, an official Google source said the document should be considered internal research, and not an official company position." So I suppose that's confirmation of authenticity (sort of). The article can be found here: https://www.breitbart.com/tech/2018/10/09/the-good-censor-leaked-google-briefing-admits-abandonment-of-free-speech-for-safety-and-civility/ https://www.breitbart.com/tech/2018/10/09/the-good-censor-le...
- jhabdas 8y agoSo where's the video? Or was that censored too?
- tropo 8y agoI think you mean the video of Google executives showing partisan behavior at a meeting. If so, it's on this page: https://www.breitbart.com/tech/2018/09/12/leaked-video-google-leaderships-dismayed-reaction-to-trump-election/ https://www.breitbart.com/tech/2018/09/12/leaked-video-googl... The group hug at 0:16:50 is seriously creepy. Grabbing your coworkers is considered inappropriate or worse in normal American workplaces.
- plaguuuuuu 8y agoHugging people, literally the worst thing that has ever happened
- mc32 8y agoI wonder if the same internal people who protested "project dragonfly" would object so vehemently to this "research" project as well. I would hope that they would, but I'm a bit hesitant to be sure --which is a bit frightening as it kind of would confirm people can hold two opposing views simultaneously as long as it fits their framework.
- eksemplar 8y agoWhy would it be real when it was leaked by breitbart? Are the lizard people also real? Is the earth flat? Do vaccines cause autism?
- zaroth 8y agoYou obviously don't read Breitbart.
- eksemplar 8y agoNot after reading about the Clinton’s on it, no. I don’t particularly like the Clintons, but unlike breitbart, I do consider them to be human beings.
- tylersmith 8y agoBreitbart has claimed that the Clintons are not human beings? Or is that made up hyperbole for what they actually said?
- gfodor 8y agoThe underlying premise of this, if real, is that these companies and their centralized platforms ought to exist. "Never expect a man to understand something his salary depends upon him not understanding" and all that.
- noobermin 8y agoWell, given that it's done by Google employees of course they'll want to continue to wield their power. For example, they mention "regulation" as a punch-line, IOW, the assumption is that regulation of any form is bad.
- jhabdas 8y agoToday I learnt OogleBot is ignoring the robots.txt file on my private Gitea server: git[dot]habd.as/robots.txt A quick search for "after dark habdas" reveals the second of two rules in the robots file, which explicitly blocks Oogle at the site root, is clearly being ignored. Of course I created this rule before putting this server online and Andex is the only webmaster console I registered this site with. But that's besides the point. There's obviously a lack of respect for the robots file or a gross error in OogleBot as far as I can tell. So now you know.
- throwawaycxn12 8y agoYou're doing it wrong, not Google: You're blocking the wrong bot user agent. You want "Googlebot", not "Google". Google documents this...
- manukin 8y agoWhy did this have to be leaked? Seemed like a good summary on why things are the way it is with social media v moderation. A whole lot of platforms could do with the conclusion. Be consistent, be responsive and be transparent. Who wouldn't love Google to be more transparent?
- wslack 8y agoThe most annoying part of this document is the watermark. It seems like a cogent summary of different ideas in the space - and doesn't advocate for "good censorship" (I think the title of the deck is provocative and unhelpful).
- evilturnip 8y agoI'm actually glad to see the conclusion. Everybody wants to censor what they don't like. There are people who believe free speech is not the ultimate value, but rather to protect people from 'harm'. In this case 'harm' being ideas they don't agree with. The best stance is not to take a side, but to make sure both sides are civil in the expression of their beliefs.
- mc32 8y ago>The best stance is not to take a side, but to make sure both sides are civil in the expression of their beliefs. I agree with that. It would help if these companies stopped seeking "virality" and "eyeballs" or whatever metaphor you want to use of user engagement and "notoriety/reward". Otherwise, this is exactly the same argument China's (or Russia's) censors would make. Absolutely not different in any way.
- eksemplar 8y agoWhat both sides though? The alt-right isn’t in opposition to anything mainstream, they are anti-democratic and should be treated the same way antifa, farc, isis and others are. Every time democracy fails to shut down movements like the alt-right, things end badly for democracy itself. The most used throve is stuff like nazism and fascism, but history actually have a lot of better examples. Because both Napoleon and Caesar effectively ended democracy with applause, unlike Hitler. I think it’s extremely dangerous to treat anti-democratic forces as equal to democratic ones. I’m a conservative by the way, so it’s not like I’m not conserved about the liberal bias in the tech sector. But the debates we have these days, about forcing platforms to include outright anti-democratic values is crazy.
- evilturnip 8y agoThe problem is that then you have to decide what's 'anti-democratic'. You won't find 50 opinions that differ from your own. On top of that, it can then be used as justification to censor almost anything you don't like. Sure, right now you'll think there is a clear criteria. But in 25, 50, or 100 years from now, people could have easily twisted it to mean whatever they disagree with.
- wstrange 8y agoThe presentation seems quite balanced. Probably not the spin that Breitbart was hoping for.
- stochastic_monk 8y agoI agree, assuming that it's real. (Which, considering Breitbart's history, could not be the case.)
- noobermin 8y agoBreitbart wouldn't benefit from faking it. If they did fake it, they would have made it look much more unbalanced whilst justifying more censorship.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- zaroth 8y agoBrietbart found quite a lot to take issue with in this presentation, if you care to read their article. Some of the points you might even agree with, or lead you to take greater pause when a company like Google starts down the path of censorship. Weighting results toward “authoritative voices”, delisting results which could damage their advertising revenue, or as they claimed in the infamous all-hands meeting, bending the curve of political discourse in the country to suit their personal world view. Given the power inherent in Google’s near-monopoly on search, I’m personally a lot more critical of potential political or editorial influences over Google’s methods for listing, ranking, and delisting content.
- charlesism 8y ago> Probably not the spin that Breitbart was hoping for. It's a leaked Google document with "Censor" in the title. It doesn't matter what it contains. Breitbart can spin it however they want. Their readership will hear what they want to hear.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- beaner 8y agoHN seems super strongly opposed to Google providing censorship in China. Do they feel the same way about Google applying it to the rest of the world?
- Kaveren 8y agoThere's a strong difference between state mandated censorship and a company voluntarily censoring content on their platform. A company has the absolute right to prohibit any content on their platform that they so choose. There's freedom not to use Google services. Calls to regulate independent companies are purely ludicrous. If Facebook said tomorrow that any positive mention of, say, Paul Graham, would result in immediate account deletion, that'd be their choice. Very valid criticism from the perspective of a user would be warranted, but that's where it should end.
- bzbarsky 8y ago> There's freedom not to use Google services. Using Google services is now required by many public schools in the US. That's where all the homework is posted, for example. Now in the US there's freedom to not attend public school, of course, so technically you have the right to not use Google services. But in practice the vast majority of people would not be able to exercise that right in this case. Similarly, a number of schools are starting to do communications with parents purely through Facebook. And I expect this trend will keep getting worse before it gets better. > Calls to regulate independent companies are purely ludicrous. If they're really independent companies, yes. If they're government-sponsored monopolies, on the other hand, the calculus is quite different. And we're quite close to that line, if not over it. You could argue that the right solution is for governments to not enshrine these companies in these monopoly positions. That would be lovely, obviously. Too bad the companies are spending all this money to get into those positions (see Google Classroom).
- Kaveren 8y agoI'd find a private school / homeschool argument disingenuous, so I'm with you that far. Google Classroom is a fair point (schools also use Google Docs and the like as well), but I don't believe it holds water. Governments would be well within their rights not to award contracts to, or use the services of, companies they felt were not respecting the values of free speech. The difference between this and active regulation are that one is voluntary for the company (must obey this term for eligibility for extra reward) and one is mandatory (must obey this term or be punished by the law). I don't have much to say about communicating to parents through Facebook, other than that they should still offer optional email communication.
- adamrezich 8y agoI just finished skimming the whole thing—did Google just trick Breitbart into publishing propaganda for them? (I'm reminded of the Valve "employee handbook.")
- shadowmore 8y agoNot really. It'll have the same result as literally every other revelation in the media. The side completely, 100% opposed to any restrictions on speech (including "policing tone" as outlined in this presentation) will see this as corporate meddling in people's expression. The side that supports speech regulation will see this as a structured plan to curb the kind of speech that's considered "harmful" or whatnot. This presentation doesn't contain anything outside the current ideological dichotomy, no original or unorthodox thoughts or ideas.
- throwaway5250 8y agoIf they did, it was a serious own goal. For the last year, everything coming out about Google has been pretty negative, and this seems to fit the pattern.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- twmb 8y agoI caution against latching onto the title and making assumptions. The bulk of the content is analyzing where the current censorship position came from and the conclusion is for Google to be more open with their stance and also be more equal with applying it. As for the why: Why the shift toward censorship? - User Demands - before, In the absence of rules, bad behaviour thrived - now, Appease users, maintain platform loyalty - Government Demands - before, Governments were unhappy to cede power to corporations - now, Respond to regulatory demands, maintain global expansion - Commercial Demands - before, It’s impossible to neutrally promote content and info - now, Monetize content through its organisation, increase revenues - before, Advertisers were wary of unintended placement and endorsement - now, Protect advertisers from controversial content, increase revenues As for the conclusions: Don’t take sides Police tone instead of content Enforce standards and policies clearly Justify global positions Explain the technology Improve communications Take problems seriously Positive guidelines Better signposts Most of the document is non-controversial. There are places where it can be seen as obviously left leaning, but there are also places where it acknowledges that sometimes the right has been treated worse: “[Richard] Spencer doesn't get to be a verified speaker; Milo gets kicked off, but I know plenty of pretty abusive feminist users or left wing users, expressing themselves in exactly the same way that the right is being penalised for, who are permitted to perform certain kinds of speech. That’s going to get Twitter into
- shittyadmin 8y agoYeah, honestly I don't think Breitbart and similar can really play this as negative for Google when it acknowledges many actions have been taken even against right wingers unfairly and encourages "Don't take sides" as a top point. The biggest thing to complain about would probably be the title... they couldn't have picked a worse title.
- adventured 8y agoThere's a larger question that Breitbart is raising: should we tolerate Google - or any company - as a monopolist with censorship power over information distribution. In this case, they're an extraordinarily powerful, expansive monopolist at that. Who decides the degree to which they censor, who gets censored, what information gets censored, etc. Google isn't just a company policing its own platform. Imagine Microsoft aggressively censoring what people could browse, upload to the Internet or write on its operating system in ~2001 (or any time during peak Windows monopoly): it'd be an obvious monopoly abuse, harm to consumers, and as an extension of that monopoly position a form of censorship. Google, through the leverage of its multiple monopolies (search, YouTube, Android), is pushing toward that sort of behavior.
- zaroth 8y agoUnderpinning the whole question of censorship; “Under section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, tech firms have legal immunity from the majority of the content posted on their platforms (unlike ‘traditional’ media publications). This protection has empowered YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and Reddit to create spaces for free speech without the fear of legal action or its financial consequence.” Censoring content is suspiciously like editorializing content, and steps social media a lot closer than they want to being publishers and not platforms. Proceeding with censorship seems to carry the risk of losing immunity under Section 230.
- spangry 8y agoWhat would be the practical consequences of losing this immunity?
- simula67 8y agoIANAL You can sue Google for damages if someone uploads a copyrighted movie to youtube. You can sue Google for libel or slander if someone posts disparaging statements about an individual to Blogspot or Youtube Since Google has a lot of money and the people who publish this content may not have too much money, Google would become the target for many lawsuits
- joshuaheard 8y agoThis is true, and some have said they have already crossed the threshold and should be regulated by the government.
- adamrezich 8y agoThis was the subject of one of John C. Dvorak's last PC Mag articles: "Twitter and Facebook Are Publishers, Not Platforms" https://www.pcmag.com/commentary/363100/twitter-and-facebook-are-publishers-not-platforms https://www.pcmag.com/commentary/363100/twitter-and-facebook...
- ubernostrum 8y agoProceeding with censorship seems to carry the risk of losing immunity under Section 230. Nope. The whole point of Section 230 is platforms can make and enforce rules, and still have a safe harbor. Otherwise, they all would have lost their safe harbor decades ago.
- adventured 8y agoThe monopolists becoming ever more aggressive censors, is the strongest argument there can be for ending their monopolies. Once a company acquires a monopoly over a critical means of public information distribution (search, social, etc), their policies of restriction formally become censorship. They've become an impediment to functioning democracy. Freedom of speech is too important to leave to the monopolies of Google and Facebook to decide what qualifies and what doesn't.
- claydavisss 8y agoSo we're all supposed hope and pray Silicon Valley elects to honor free expression? We need a new internet
- __initbrian__ 8y agoInteresting Quote of Current President (Pg 48) """When it comes to users, all of this bad behaviour and mismanagement... Breads Conspiracy Theories "Google's search engine was suppressing the bad news about Hillary Clinton" - Donald Trump, 2016"""
- shard972 8y agoI wonder how many conspiracy theories about Trump have been censored by google?
- shard972 8y agoGot downvotes but I can't explain why the conspiracy that trump is a russian agent is not a conspiracy theory that should be censored and it would be nice for someone to explain how that works.
- chaosite 8y agoThis is a really good document, mostly describing current events and trends in censorship. Most of the policy it advocates is basically being consistent and open about how Google is handling issues, and how censorship is being applied. The title is click-baity, but that's not so bad.
- chrisco255 8y agoHere in 2018, I'm not that worried about Google's position as world's information arbiter and how it chooses to censor content. But I do worry a bit, as the path to hell is paved with good intentions. How will this evolve over the decades to come? Where does the line between "hate speech" and legitimate criticism get drawn? Criticism is often crude. Humor is often crude. Sometimes humor, even crude humor, cuts to the core of an issue better than any intellectual discussion or essay could possibly yield. The U.S. itself has a long tradition of pointed, sarcastic political cartoons, as an example. We need not reach back too far in memory to find an example of grey area between "hate speech" and "free speech": The Dutch cartoonist Kurt Westergaard and his infamous Muhammad bomb cartoon. I think Google and other social media giants will find themselves in an impossible situation, if they haven't already. To be a good censor is to declare the "rightness" and "wrongness" of content in a consistent manner. However, in order to do so, you have to stake a position. However, these companies sprawl too far and too wide to stake a position without alienating huge swaths of the population. And without making it all too easy for factions to believe that their side is being discriminated against.
- Karunamon 8y ago>Here in 2018, I'm not that worried about Google's position as world's information arbiter and how it chooses to censor content. Why, if I might ask? "Google" has entered the common lexicon as a generic term for "search the internet for something". The amount of power they wield, ignoring all other power aside from the ability to rank the search results of most internet users, is massive and I think this cannot be overstated or minimized. This is a non-fallacious version of the slippery slope. Just because you're okay with the "do the right thing" nee "don't be evil" Google of today does not mean you'll be okay with the Google of tomorrow having that power. Consider very carefully whether you want any one particular company to have that power, and what the remedies are if Google ever does go full evil. On a side note, it absolutely reeks of double standards on many of the commenters here to castigate Google for their Chinese censorship while giving them a pass for what is described herein. Censorship is only bad when done at the behest of a state? I don't understand this sentiment. I want no third party deciding for me what is "hate speech" and deciding I shouldn't be able to see it as a result. With a special emphasis on the second part of that phrase.
- breitshart 8y agoExcellent leak/scoop by Allum Bokhari & co-- that can be true AND Breitbart is still garbage. Some choice Breitbart articles: This is a fun one: https://www.breitbart.com/big-government/2016/07/15/obama-globalist-chronic-problem/ https://www.breitbart.com/big-government/2016/07/15/obama-gl... Yarmulke-sportin' Ben Shapiro was absolutely OUTRAGED about Google's & Easter: https://www.breitbart.com/big-government/2013/03/30/google-features-chavez-on-easter/ https://www.breitbart.com/big-government/2013/03/30/google-f... ------- Keep an eye on this one & the kook-right in the United States: when right-wing folks inevitably rake Goog & co over the coals, you get one bingo space if it somehow magically transforms into their grievance/we-get-stabbed-in-the-back/work-the-refs No need to shoot the messenger, just don't take all the offerings of this particular messenger too seriously. True for anything but most especially the kook-right
- toomanybeersies 8y agoSlide 66 is particularly interesting, and articulates an observation that I've made: > Tech firms are performing a balancing act between two incompatible positions > 100% commit to the American tradition that prioritises free speech for democracy, not civility > 100% commit to the European tradition that favors dignity over liberty, and civility over freedom It is a very American view that unrestricted freedom of speech is a requirement for a well-functioning democracy, and that any restriction of this beyond censoring direct calls to violence is evil.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- est 8y agoIs "against freedom of speech" a freedom of speech?
- tylersmith 8y agoBeing against freedom of speech is absolutely a freedom of speech. Preventing people from expressing their freedom of speech is not.
- pathseeker 8y agoYes, talking about it is. Restricting it at the government level isn't. Freedom of speech is a right protecting you from the government, not companies.
- VonGallifrey 8y agoAre you confusing the american first amendment with the concept of freedom of speech? Freedom of Speech is a much broader concept then just the first amendment.
- kodablah 8y ago> It is a very American view that unrestricted freedom of speech is a requirement for a well-functioning democracy It is similarly a very American view that unrestricted freedom of speech is a requirement for a well-functioning internet (well, not completely "unrestricted", but we're not here to argue nuance). Avoiding the obvious debate on which is better, the problem of choice exists in a global medium. Lest it become balkanized, you will have to choose an approach both as a company and as a set of laws. Wrt laws, restrictions are added much more often than they are removed so we should probably err on the side of fewer/limited-scope restrictions. I think most would prefer the greatest common factor of freedoms vs the lowest common denominator of restrictions.
- YouOkOrNot 8y agoIt's ironic that Wikipedia has a 'Censorship by Google' article that would benefit from the addition of a paragraph or two about this memo, but due to Wikipedia's censorship of Breitbart as a source and Breitbart being the source on this, that won't happen. It's a shame when legitimate journalism is stifled by censorship.
- sanxiyn 8y agoThe presentation mentions "global inconsistency" as a problem, but I disagree. Communities have different community standards, so they should have different moderation. As an example, it is rather unfortunate that American obscenity standard is enforced against the world at large.
- gufufusfjc 8y agoI think the thing that is missing from the presentation is that Google is positioning itself to take a tone policing position, but that completely ignores damage to actual people. People injured by the powerful and the state will be angry, will go viral, and will likely violate tone policed policies. People that drop white nationalist (genocidal) rhetoric with a smile get to push their case. Furthermore, the economics of the situation mean that Google et al are structurally incapable of reforms that dilute their power or reduce engagement. The alternative that preserves their power is to exert overt censorship as they will do in China. Thankfully, we are not there yet in the US. Tone policing generally favors knocking down the left anyway, which is favorable to elites whom are the targets of their ire.
- mherdeg 8y agoThis presentation briefly mentions but then seems to mostly forget about "Elsagate" which they call the "Peppa Pig scandal". James Bridle argues convincingly that the genre of bizarre YouTube videos which appeals to the toddler reptilian brain ( https://medium.com/@jamesbridle/something-is-wrong-on-the-internet-c39c471271d2 https://medium.com/@jamesbridle/something-is-wrong-on-the-in... ) is not created by hostile or evil actors but instead has evolved orgnically based on what stuff toddlers want to click on. Kids' click patterns reward more video themes like "Elsa tied up on train tracks kissing Spiderman", so the content industry crams more of that stuff into its new content. The result, after a few iterations, would not have passed editorial controls at 1990s Nickelodeon (!), which would normally have halted the feedback loop, but with no one at the helm -- to "censor" or otherwise exert editorial control -- YouTube's kid-targeted videos are just a whole forest of weird. Does YouTube want to allow their platform to become a laboratory for rapidly discovering local maxima in very young children's fantasy worlds? Do they have any choice? Should they step in and publish rules for what children's content is allowed? Should they hire some kind of human curator or editor to enforce those rules for child-focused videos? Should Web platforms act in loco parentis? In this cases, in "the Peppa Pig scandal" style situation, the producers are machine-generating content that gets clicks and the consumers are children. When the issue is the viral proliferation of "fake news" and hate speech, the content producers are people or state propaganda apparatuses, and the consumers & re-sharers are grown adults. It seems like it's a different topic with maybe different guiding principles to decide how & whether to censor these different groups of consumers & producers.
- fapjacks 8y agoSo "think of the children" when it comes to censorship. Got it.
- pm90 8y agoI realize its an often misused excuse for passing various bogus regulations. But your dismissive one liner is disparaging the comment while completely ignoring the massive context and reasoning provided; this is not the kind of conversation we expect of here.
- est 8y ago> The Arab Spring was the the high point of this positivity - a visceral example of the power of digitalised free speech. Yes, millions of refugees is obviously not the consequence at all.
- rdtsc 8y agoEverything else was rather unsurprising, pretty much what I expected. But that was the part that I had to read again. Hoping they just copied that from a 2013 pamphlet. If they consider Libya's slave markets ( https://www.cnn.com/2017/11/14/africa/libya-migrant-auctions/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2017/11/14/africa/libya-migrant-auctions... ) and Sirya the high point of positivity, I'd wonder what they consider the low point.
- zethraeus 8y agoThis is a reasonable point to make as a consequentialist with 20/20 hindsight. But it's fair to value the act of getting freedom from oppressive regimes as a good in itself independent of the power vacuum it creates. And it's fair to assess a movement based on its priors of a possible positive outcome, rather than the purely retrospectively once they haven't come to pass.
- Aunche 8y agoIt's interesting that this document calls Arab Spring "the high point in positivity" of the internet. From what I understand, most countries are even worse off now. Libya in particular is still stuck in civil war to this day.
- marricks 8y agoI think that’s the point. Arab spring, the chance of positive change around the world because of it, pre Snowden(!). It’s not that things weren’t awful then just people didn’t know what was going on or how things would turn out, so we were all upbeat about the internet.
- Aunche 8y agoI disagree. People know how awful their lives are by their well being. The internet offered people the ability to organize and topple their corrupt government, but that doesn't mean that the new people in charge are going to be better.
- marricks 8y agoDefinitely. The awfulness that I implied was meant to be mass surveillance. That people could organize and resist was great, needs to be way more of that, not less. Still, that moment has passed so people aren’t positive about our connectedness in the same way cause it doesn’t seem to be causing any progressive/democratic changes.
- shard972 8y agoBecause real centrists like google know all that Libya stuff was a right wing conspiracy theory to prevent hillary from running for president /s In all seriousness, it's quite abhorrent how foreign policy interventions by progressive leaders are shoved down the memory hole while we are always wide awake when a conservative does something.
- jayd16 8y ago
- etchalon 8y agoI can understand why Google, as an engine, should err towards neutrality of information, without arbitrating even hideous content. But I've never really understand why social networks can't, or shouldn't, say "This is the type of community we are, and what content we find acceptable."
- mkeyhani 8y agoBecause Facebook, unlike say a subreddit, is not a a community formed around a certain topic. There is no 'we' in particular.
- etchalon 8y agoIsn’t the “we” whoever developed and hosts the service? The idea that you can only limit a community if it’s dedicated to a specific topic is non-sensical.
- mkeyhani 8y agoI am not sure if I understand your argument. If whoever develops and hosts the service gets to limit what is allowed, then why Google shouldn’t censor its search results?
- finnthehuman 8y ago>or shouldn't, say "This is the type of community we are, Well, for starters, they're not communities. And people shouldn't lie.
- vhakulinen 8y agoHas anyone else ever wondered how some of the numbers about internet compares to a real world? Like, * "2.6 million tweets contained anti-Semitic speech during the US presidential election" - how many conversations there where, in real word, about the same topic and contained anti-Semitic speech? * "26% of American users are victims of internet trolling" - how many are victims of trolling in real word? Or in schools? * "40% of internet users have been harassed online" - how many persons have been harassed at work places? Bars? * Governments under cyber attack? How many of them are targets of espionage? Or have many companies are targets of espionage? I'm not saying that these are not bad things, nor that those shouldn't be addressed - I'm just wondering if these things are as bad as they might seem to be, when compared to "the real world".
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y agoIn what sense is what happens online not part of the real world? If nobody reads a tweet, did it really happen? If nobody hears me hurl racist abuse at my lawnmower, did it really happen?
- vhakulinen 8y ago> In what sense is what happens online not part of the real world? This is mainly the reason why the last "real world" was in quotes. When you take statistics of something, you usually want to compare them to something. For me, a natural comparison for internet statistics is some physical places like offices, public streets, schools, bars. "a real world" - I'm not saying that the internet is not part of it.
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y agoRighteo, fair enough. Thanks for taking the time to clarify.
- woodruffw 8y agoI took that to be the point -- we tend to be at our worst online, thanks to the unique combination of anonymity (I can say whatever I want with as many accounts as I want, without meaningful consequences) and absence of social cues (there's nobody around me, so I have no incentive to soften my language or weaken my opinions). In other words, the way we talk online is not normal. Even outside of the free speech debate, it's worth noting that.
- kodablah 8y agoQuite a neutral and concise briefing I think covering all sides. The unfortunate part of the debate is viewing freedom/liberty vs diginity/civility as exactly opposing forces. That these are seen as opposing forces justifies the view of resting in the middle as though it exists. Instead of thinking so linearly along these two dimensions, I would suggest using a wider lens. Instead of striving for some of both in a common platform, we should strive for some of both concurrently. I was encouraged by the example of Twitter unverifying accounts, but not banning them, but even that suffers from the single platform effect since unverification is objectively harmful. Those with qualms concerning unfavorable content should ask themselves whether the concern is that it's promoted/visible by default or that it exists at all. The latter is too hard line of a stand to be seen as anything but censorship and should only be applied in the most extreme cases. But the former is something we can tackle. Simply default to safe and let the user opt in to increasing levels of unsafe. You'll always have the problem of being the arbiter of what resides at which levels (granted you can ask content creators to self-categorize with threats of violation for clear miscategorization) but at least it's better than outright banning/deleting. Just make sure that whatever level the user has set, content that is visible is all treated equally under the algorithms (i.e. no demotion). I personally would turn favorability filters off and encourage others to do the same, but at least defaults exist and levels of moderation can be chosen. Finally, to shift the rant a bit, I just want to say I welcome self-imposed solutions over legal requirements. I am encouraged to know that, while it's hard to compete with a behemoth (why would you try), you can still legally publish your own content sans filter on your own site or a site with similar views towards your own. We might prefer all the popular sites respect our views on what is allowed, but since that's obviously impossible in a global medium due to cultural subjectivity, don't attempt codify it legally.
- erikb 8y agoAll these "let's be more inclusive by focussing on what/how we can exclude" activities these days are really scary. You can't be inclusive by being exclusive.
- ronilan 8y agoI read the whole thing, all 85 pages of it. Based on the content, and based on how I read it, I’m now almost 100% sure, not completely, but almost sure, that it is, indeed a Breirbrat News Exclusive. I think it actually says so somewhere on the pages.
- rdtsc 8y agoIt would be good for them to be more honest and transparent, and this leak is a nice step in that direction :-) But to be serious, something like "We take these positions and stand behind these values and we're proud of it" would seem better than claim they are a neutral platform and they welcome all points of view and let users create and share whatever content. This didn't even have to be a leaked document. They should have posted it in their "about" section right on the front page. If anyone doesn't like it they can go and make their own Google and share content there instead. There was the leaked company meeting video after the 2016 elections with people crying and saying "we lost" and then users are supposed to believe those executives will turn around, wipe their tears, walk back to their desks and be unbiased when it comes to moderating news, search results, Youtube videos, charities they sponsor, etc? That's probably unrealistic... So why not drop the pretense and come out and be proud of what they support. Nobody will be surprised and many will welcome it including most of their employees.
- 0xBA5ED 8y agoCensorship alone is not evil. The problem is, once you have infrastructure in place to make it easy, it will be abused. And if that infrastructure is centralized, the stakes for abuse are much higher. It's the same old problem of "who regulates the regulators". Rather than the issue being about "censorship bad / free speech good", I think the heart of it is: There's simply a lack of confidence that tech giants like Google are part of a larger system with checks and balances, and they appear to be making unilateral decisions behind closed doors.
- raxxorrax 8y ago> Censorship alone is not evil. Restricting access to information generally is until a good reason is given. That could be the protection of personal information for example. But without justification I would heavily disagree with that statement.
- 0xBA5ED 8y agoI'll point out that I didn't say "Censorship without justification is not evil."
- princekolt 8y agoThere seems to be justification though. If a "news" website is constantly publishing stories that are objectively false, or based on some factual event but distorted beyond any verifiable aspect, then Google has the right (and I'd argue the duty) to remove that content from its platform, especially if that content is targeted at individuals.
- hef19898 8y agoIn a nutshell: Google, Twitter and Facebook followed a very liberal definiton of what they are, created a platform to promote free speech to get free content from users. Being a platform, they did nopt have to edit content like print media has to. This created traffic and drove ad revenue. And everything was fine. Then some bad stuff happened, advertisers, not users, complained by withdrawing money. And who would have guessed, that was an issue. The situation these companies re now in sucks, either they start editing (which is not censorship) and risk being treated like traditional media eliminating their competitive advantage. Or they don't and risk loosing ad revenue. IMHO the underlying reason is that free speech and free press offline is lot easier because there are a ton of different outlet, all with a somwhet limited reach. People like Rupper Murdoch already put these limitations to a serious test. Online it's much worse with a couple of global de-facto oligopols. I wouldn't be surprised if societies and governments are moving to regulate that one day. That being said, the fact that all these companies, leaning apparently heavy on " 100% commit to the American tradition that prioritises free speech for democracy, not civility", are at the same time more than happy to ignore that stance in certain countries to maintain a global foot print (p.47 of the Google doc comes to mind). It seems, after all, that money is king and everything else secondary. Admittedly, FB is much worse that Google in that regard. EDIT: All of the above points are more or less cited from Googles own document. Except the part with e oligopol which is my own conclusion.
- growlist 8y agoI think there is a massive market opportunity here, and all the competitor has to do is build Google from 5-10 years ago - when you could actually still get decent results for your search, warts and all - as opposed to the wildly unrepresentative kindergarten/pollyanna picture of the internet they currently return.
- tomohawk 8y agoAll this shows is that Google has become a zombie company. It is more interested in building moats and pleasing politicos to solidify their position than in actually doing useful things.
- odessacubbage 8y agodignity/civility should be a self determined value rather than one instated by authority. it is impossible to create a universal standard of conduct that will be adequate for everyone and we don't need to. you can call me a faggot or tell me to kill myself as much as you like and i really wont care at all, i want to see everything short of direct and malicious efforts to cause me real life harm (and arguably i want to know about those too). on the flip side you have older users who may be completely averse to course language or any interaction that falls beyond tv standards of etiquette, things that are relatively tame by internet standards may be completely offensive to them. how do you create a set of standards across your product that are adequate for both use cases without artificially limiting appeal to a single audience? empower users with the tools to define their own experiences and, if they so choose, filter out what they don't want without assuming what that is. perhaps you could even let users display their version of a content rating so that others could see what content they will and will not filter rather than the communication breakdown that emerges when some messages are opaquely censored. you could even use an honorific system to better determine what is an adequate level of filtering between two users. you might not want to hear 'i'm gonna fucking kill you' from a total rando, but if it comes from your spouse you probably should. don't tell the customers what they want when you don't know the answer.