43 ms·
Ask HN: What can be done to prevent a climate catastrophe?
It seems to me that governments can be counted out of taking the leadership needed to solve this within 12 years. If anything they seem to want to act against solving this issue in some cases.
So what can we do so our children don't live in some ghastly hothouse world?
The scientists have told us its our final chance.... not to start within 12 years, but solve it within 12 years.
I feel like the young people need to take charge of the world because the older generations have had their chance and not fixed it.
Maybe corporations are the ones who can be pressured to take the lead.
- natch 8y agohttps://www.drawdown.org https://www.drawdown.org
- josho 8y ago> Maybe corporations are the ones who can be pressured to take the lead. Yes. They absolutely will. But only after they have the right incentives. Those incentives can be created over night by having governments put in place a carbon tax. It gets even worse. If a large group of people reduced their energy consumption to help climate change it has the consequence of reducing demand and therefore energy costs will come down. That will make green energy cost uncompetitive and slow down the transition to green fuels. This change really does need to come from government. So get politically involved.
- jlj 8y ago> If a large group of people reduced their energy consumption to help climate change it has the consequence of reducing demand and therefore energy costs will come down. That will make green energy cost uncompetitive and slow down the transition to green fuels. Another way to look at it is, as more people demand green energy, the supply will increase faster to meet demand. As the supply increases, economies of scale reduce the cost, making it more competitive with fossil fuels while at the same time wind and solar efficiency will increase further reducing the cost per unit. Eventually the supply with the lowest cost will win and the others may become obsolete. Whether or not that can happen fast enough is another question. Taxation of fossil and subsidizing of renewables seems like a logical conclusion. The likelyhood of a massive win-win solution of that nature with no game theory cheats on a global scale seems much less probable than innovating our way out of it. I don't think government on a coordinated global level can do it. It would be like diverting the same level of national resources as a war into a peacetime effort. Would need a way to demonize climate change so it becomes a common global enemy. But on the other side of demonizing is half or more of humanity, so it is really a new level of war over new types of resources being shoreline, water supply, and probablilty of destruction or famine by natural disasters. I hope for no war and don't believe all that will happen. But it could. And I think investing in time, money, and peace seems like a valid approach to get behind vs trying to get government to do it.
- kebman 8y agoHaha, sure! :D Carbon tax. Sounds legit! Here's what's gonna happen: Corporations just jack up prices accross the board according to the tax, and then everybody else gets to pay. And then nothing changes. It'll be like the sugar tax in Norway. Do you really think people are buying less sugar over here because of it? Get real! :D We're well past incentives. The change has to be law, and the law has to be protected with the threat of force. (Force sounds so much better than violence, don't you think, but all this is gonna end in the latter, eventually, if we just let it slide, because when people get hungry, they also get desperate.) And where people don't respect the law, force has to be actually used. However, nobody in their right mind is willing to do that as long as we're boiling frogs... So I guess we'll just die then. We had a pretty good run, though. :)
- fallingfrog 8y agoTo solve this crisis in 12 years would require overthrowing the government of every country with an industrial base and replacing them with much more progressive people. You can try if you want but I don't see it happening. As far as actually convincing people of global warming, the older generation will absolutely never believe it no matter how much evidence you present. They are truly lost. Change will only be possible after they have died. This is going to be a sad, tragic period in human history, and nobody in the future is going to understand why we made such self destructive decisions. It will pass though. Hundreds of years from now the climate will slowly begin to return to normal. Despite the fact that the fight is hopeless, though, I'll continue to try.
- xupybd 8y agoI don’t think the result would be good. All that would do is destabilise the world crash our economies and set back our green tech.
- adrianN 8y agoCrashing the economy has historically been the most efficient way of reducing CO2 production.
- qsdevacc 8y agoAnd ensuring mass depression, deaths and misery.
- xupybd 8y agoI'm not sure. It might wind things back a bit for a short time. But during a time of economic down turn the environment becomes a low priority for a lot of people. Then when things recover there is no guarantee that things will be done any better. I'm of the opinion that we need stable governments and economies to tackle this problem.
- Radim 8y agoRight. Toppling elected governments coupled with an age-based genocide would be a wonderful solution. It's the "young and progressive" who know best! People with life experience are truly lost. /s
- verroq 8y agoCan’t see it happening when a large portion of the population insists that climate change isn’t real.
- f_allwein 8y agoYes - education, lobbying and advocating would all have to be part of the plan. Edit: look at https://transitionnetwork.org https://transitionnetwork.org - grassroots network in the UK that seems to be doing well at getting people to engage.
- vixen99 8y agoIn terms of education, why not start at the top by educating Richard Lindzen, ex-MIT professor of atmospheric physics, author of 200 papers, who reminds us of the popular narrative that " the climate, a complex multi-factorial system, can be summarized in just one variable - the globally average temperature change and primarily controlled by a 1-2% energy budget due to a single variable - carbon dioxide - among many variable so comparable importance". Lindzen's view is that this claim is based on reasoning that borders on magical thinking.". Should Al Gore and John Kerry put him straight on his basic physics? https://wattsupwiththat.com/2018/10/09/richard-lindzen-lecture-at-gwpf-global-warming-for-the-two-cultures/ https://wattsupwiththat.com/2018/10/09/richard-lindzen-lectu...
- shard972 8y agoMaybe if the media managed to actually present the issue in a balanced way we wouldn't be here. Maybe if every dire prediction wasn't presented as fact and every criticism labeled as conspiracy theory and vica versa for a-lot of other outlets. Maybe if solutions like geo-engineering were at least discussed instead of the chorus of the media/politicians telling people that taxes and fees are THE ONLY SOLUTION to the crisis. Just my 2cents, but we would be so much further ahead if the conversation has some actual balance instead of these-days where people are complaining that having a 5/95 skew in favour of the armageddon scenario if we don't have a global tax on carbon, move to 100% renewables and electric cars as being too generous to the critics of this plan.
- richardknop 8y agoThe obvious solution would be to decrease the population globally to more manageable level. That is not possible because humans are hardwired to breed and multiply. The next best thing we can do is try to do some big action on government levels. Again very difficult because it would mean decreasing standard of living (more expensive fuel, for example, to discourage inefficient cars, higher taxes on products dependent on fossil fuels), so you would be asking people to vote for decreasing their living standard and making their life worse off short term. Nobody is going to vote for a politician who promises to make your life worse and products you use daily more expensive thus making you poorer.
- shard972 8y ago> That is not possible because humans are hardwired to breed and multiply. Wait a second, then why is it that almost every western country is currently seeing negative population forecasts without immigration? Seems like western countries were already heading towards population decline but have been propped up in recent years with the call for more economic growth and I don't think those calls are hardwired at all.
- richardknop 8y agoI think western countries are not representative of the world as they represent a small minority of world's population (10% or so). I have read some predictions about world population continuing to increase to around 12 billion and stabilising at that number. Let's say that happens. Then you run into the problem of people in western countries consuming many times more resources and energy per capital as developing world. Then in order to avoid climate catastrophe it would mean you have to reduce standard of living for the minority that consumes the most fuel and energy, also standard of living of those in developing world could not catch up. Basically the argument I'm trying to make it that it won't be sustainable to have 1 or 2 cars per family like it is normal in the West, and other similar luxuries.
- shard972 8y agoYour assuming that developing countries don't develop in that time which would be quite the prediction. Also I don't think 1-2 cars will be the issue, more along the lines of: - Can you own a car? Or must you bike to work? - Can you access goods outside of your state? Since no trucks/planes for long distance shipping - How much Heating/Cooling in the Winter/Summer will you be allowed? If any? That or we could look into geo-engineering maybe?
- legionof7 8y agoDon't just vote, run for office.
- cletus 8y agoSo I'm honestly not as concerned about this as I once was. Don't get me wrong: the climate is going to change, arguably we're in a mass extinction event already and people aren't going to suddenly start acting in the collective long term welfare of humanity. One of the things I like about futurism is the levelheaded optimism and pragmatism you tend to get. And I'll call out Isaac Arthur as a well-known example of this. Think there's too many people? You can easily show that the world could easily produce enough to feed a population 10 times what we have now in the very near future, thanks largely to automation. Think we're dumping too much CO2 into the atmosphere? We no doubt are but that problem basically goes away immediately if we ever get economic fusion power. Even if we don't, the plummetting cost of wind and solar may solve that anyway (by "solve" I mean that as soon as non-fossil fuel power production is cheaper than fossil fuels it becomes economic to remove CO2 from the atmosphere and turn into hydrocarbons). Too expensive to get to space? Eventually the cost of this will go down to dollars per kilogram. Worried about how we'll produce all that power? When getting stuff into orbit is sufficiently cheap it'll become economic to put solar collectors in orbit and beam energy back to Earth. And all you need for this kind of optimism is the kind of technology we're widely expected to have this century. So it's kind of sad that a lot of the larger fauna is doomed but you're not going to change people's appetites for rhino horns, fish bladders, tiger oil or pangolin dishes. Then again, maybe future genetics can restore some or all of those species. The Earth has also been a lot warmer than it is now so I have trouble believing the doomsday scenarios of runaway climate change that'll turn the Earth into Venus just because the Earth has been here for 4-5 billion years, has been hotter than now and hasn't become Venus yet. We also seem to have a pretty poor history of predictions when it comes to climate change too. Fundamentally this also seems like a "betting with the Mayans" type scenario too. Either the doomsayers are right and we're screwed. If so, you'll be right but who cares? We're still screwed. You're probably better off just hoping things will work out because, honestly, I think there's a pretty decent chance they will.
- annadane 8y agoAnd before someone replies with "How can you possibly say that", you can do both - be optimistic about the future and also change your own personal habits and become educated on the topic in general anyway.
- DocSavage 8y agoGeoengineering: https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-05357-w https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-05357-w https://news.vice.com/en_us/article/a38zve/watch-the-trailer-for-vice-on-hbos-engineering-earth https://news.vice.com/en_us/article/a38zve/watch-the-trailer...
- jonstewart 8y agoGive money to Democratic candidates challenging Republican incumbents, right now. If we believe in evidence-based science, then all evidence points to Republicans being anti-science. You don't have to be a committed lifelong Democrat to see that the current Republican party is fighting climate change efforts at every turn and needs to be displaced in order for political progress on the issue to happen.
- xupybd 8y agoMaybe trying to win over republicans would be better? The culture wars don’t help this issue.
- cthulha 8y agoWhat would win over republicans? I mean, if the survival of human civilisation isn't enough, what can you propose?
- roryisok 8y agoRepublicans (and the equivalent rich conservatives in other countries) believe that climate change is happening anyway, and that anyone who doesn't try to make money off it is an idiot. They don't buy the survival of the human civilization bit - they think it'll affect only poor people, and that the rich will be safe. And honestly, they're right, at least for what we'll see in their lifetimes. Poor people are going to die in their millions in the coming decades, and rather than seeing themselves as the cause of this they see themselves as protecting themselves and their friends and families against it by insulating themselves with money. That's my theory anyway.
- xupybd 8y agoWell there is a lot of false information out there about climate change and it's probable influence on the planet. Things have gotten out of hand with how polarised this issue is. Many people on the right don't believe in climate change. A little of this is because the time scales were off in some early predictions such as An Inconvenient Truth. This was a good wake up call to many but it also exaggerates the rate of change to the point that many of the predictions should have already had massive negative impacts. This leads people to think they've been lied to. Screaming at them and telling them they're ignorant climate change deniers does little to encourage this. To think they don't care about the survival of the human race is not accurate. They just don't think it's at risk. IMHO the truth without the us verses them stuff is the key. I think 13 Misconceptions About Global Warming by Veritasium on YouTube is a perfect example of this. Yes it's easy to get mad at people when the fate of the world is on the line but that's not as productive as trying to understand them and reaching out to them.
- tobr 8y agoFundamentally it is a political problem, not a technological problem. We need high carbon taxes, we need to end fossil fuel subsidies, and we probably need to change our economic system to something that addresses the tragedy of the commons. But we’ve seen in recent years how technology can influence politics. I’d quote a tweet from Tristan Harris from the other day [1]: > In an hypothetical world, if Facebook were re-designed entirely into a global coordination tool for billions of people to take the most meaningful and significant steps to fight climate change -- what would it look like? 1: https://twitter.com/tristanharris/status/1049177712227573760 https://twitter.com/tristanharris/status/1049177712227573760
- xupybd 8y agoIf we can get renewables cheaper than fossil fuels and get reasonable energy storage politics won’t be a problem.
- philipkglass 8y agoI thought that all we had to do was develop non-combustion energy sources cheaper than fossil fuels, and everything else would fall into place. I think that's still mostly correct. But I underestimated how long people who are economically dependent on fossil fuel industries, and their political allies, could delay the transition. I think that those sorts of delay-and-obstruct tactics are going to ensure we far overshoot CO2 targets before (hopefully) beginning to correct them. That's even while the technologies of low-carbon energy continue to advance at a rapid clip.
- pjc50 8y agoThis absolutely can be a problem, because infrastructure needs political approval. Worst case is a ban on renewable generation to protect fossil fuel profits, for example.
- xupybd 8y agoYou are correct but if we can get to the point that economics drive green energy the political opponents will have trouble stopping it. There is a tipping point in there that we could be prevented from hitting, but I really don't think that will happen.
- cstejerean 8y agoAbsolutely nothing. As long as solutions require major changes in lifestyle for most people absolutely nothing will happen. Our only hope is to invent technology to mitigate the problem (sequester carbon from the atmosphere, get cheaper alternative fuels, protect cities from rising ocean levels and reinforce infrastructure to better tolerate extreme weather). Anything else is just wishful thinking that places much more faith in the ability of people to value their long term interests over their short term comfort than evidence suggests is warranted.
- Waterluvian 8y agoI like polar bears so it's sad to see those go. It will be disturbing to see coastal cities founded next to sunken cities. Storms are fun but only when they're occasional. I already miss the insects. We worry about losing languages, cultures, artwork to the unyielding entropic horror named time. Not because we have a pragmatic need for them. But the future is scary when you can't bring the past with you. My culture is my security blanket. Maybe my kids are going to grow up in a world not defined by technology but by the change in daily regimen of existence. Humans adapt really well to just about anything, so I bet my kids will feel right at home. They'll roll their eyes on cue when I insist that the future wasn't supposed to be like this. I've always kind of wondered how someone as liberal as me can possibly turn into an old curmudgeon. Maybe this is how. Maybe I'll be disquieted not by being overrun by the creep of new gadgets, but by looking around and seeing a completely foreign anthroposphere.
- sosense 8y agoPolar bear populations are fine, sea level had been rising at the same rate for much longer than we've been industrialized, storm rate isn't changing, and where do you live that there are no insects?
- adrianN 8y agoPolar bears can swim all summer while they wait for the ice to return.
- therealdrag0 8y agoI'd be surprised if you have any evidence for this. Adult bears can swim surprisingly long (many days, not months), but cubs cannot and die.
- chimprich 8y ago> where do you live that there are no insects Relevant paper. 75% recorded decline in insect biomass: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0185809 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tomjen3 8y agoInvest in co2 scrubbers and nuclear power. But they also said ten years ago that ten years would be the absolutely longest time we had to prevent catastrophic climate change. They also said the world would be overpopulated and we wouldn't be able to feed everybody by the end of the sixties so who knows.
- roryisok 8y ago> They also said the world would be overpopulated and we wouldn't be able to feed everybody by the end of the sixties so who knows. Thanks to the green revolution, we figured out how to massively increase crop yield, otherwise we would have seen problems supplying enough food. In fact that's kind of the root of many of todays problems. The population of earth has doubled since 1980, when GHG levels were safe. If we couldn't feed another 3.5 billion people they wouldn't have been born and we wouldn't be in this mess. We'd be in a much different mess, where rationing and population control are common, but at least we wouldn't also be cooking ourselves
- DoreenMichele 8y ago"It's the end of the world as we know it, and I feel fine." Y2K was supposed to be a global catastrophe. It got quietly fixed. No one (but me) wakes up today and goes "Oh. Thank. God. We aren't living in the Y2K post apocalypse!" In fact, I have been told that most people laugh at the idea that we ever worried about it because it turned out fine, so we must not have been in real danger. The Kuwait oil wells were supposed to burn for years and be a global catastrophe. Crack teams converged on the country and put them out in a mere 6 months. No one is saying "Hallelujah!" about that either. It is also forgotten while we are on to bellyaching about our next catastrophe. Don't get me wrong. I'm an environmental studies major and I have lived without a car for more than a decade and I would like to do more to mitigate this problem. But I'm pretty damn sure that if I actually fixed it, A. I would likely get zero credit and B. The very next morning the entire world would be focused on some new problem rather than dancing in the streets to celebrate this triumph. In the mean time,let me recommend that you pee on a tree. (Website possibly coming soon.)
- jandrese 8y agoTo me the scary part about climate change is the sheer scale of the problem. We burn something like 4.4 billion tons of oil each year. Eventually we have to basically un-burn all of that oil. That's a staggeringly huge amount of work and we have barely begun to stop digging ourselves deeper into the hole.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoWalk more. Eat less meat. And pee on a tree. Do that every day. Track it if you need to. Spread the word if you like, though leading by example is more powerful than trying to lecture people. We are all just dust in the wind anyway. But you can choose what your little speck gets up to, at least to some degree.
- roryisok 8y agoWhat is this thing about peeing on trees
- trymas 8y agoEDIT: downvoters, feel free to add your opinion, what seps we can take in 12 years to prevent climate change. I will gladly hear any opinion, especially if it is not as drastic as mine. 1. Drop coal and gas as energy sources immediately. Use renewable and nuclear energy as main power sources. Phase out nuclear after couple decades, when we hopefully can get all our energy needs from renewables. EDIT: forgot to add in fusion. 2. Eat less meat. I am not saying to go full radical vegan, just have less of it. Most people I know have meat for every main meal of the day (breakfast, lunch, dinner). We can definitely eat less of it. Meat production generates extreme amounts of CO2 and consumes too much of valuable land. 3. "Global one child policy". Sounds extreme - but we must lessen global population of humans. I know that western countries have negative growth already, problem is how to solve overpopulation in non-western countries and do it fast (ideally in one generation). Even with technological advances, IMO having 10-12+ billion people on Earth won't do any good for anyone.
- realusername 8y agoThat's about right. I would add a 4th action to this list: Financing of carbon negative research & companies though a carbon tax on the worst offenders. I don't think even reducing drastically is enough personally, we need to go negative.
- pjc50 8y agoNuclear isn't feasible within that timeframe - takes years to even build the plants! Not to mention the unpopularity of putting fission plants in the less stable countries of the world. The other two are even more infeasible.
- realusername 8y agoAny electricity grid change takes years anyway, and I don't see how the other two are not feasible. As an example, we managed to reduce smoking by a good margin nowadays, which was an even more unrealistic battle than meat consumption.
- trymas 8y agoIMO for infeasibly tough problems we must go to infeasibly tough actions (believe me - I do not have any hope for any of these points to come at least 1% true). It's a theoretical list which would greatly reduce our impact on climate in utopian world. #3 is extremely infeasible I would not agree that #1 is impossible (it's just a problem with stigma and politics), though I agree that it is very unlikely and needs great dedication from governments of powerful countries, to make it happen in 10 or even 20 years. Though what's the problems with #2 to make it "more infeasible"? I am not vegan/vegetarian, but I have no problem eating 10 times less meat than I did 5 years ago.
- starpilot 8y agoDoes anyone have any views on buying carbon offsets through services like TerraPass and Carbonfund? I drive a pickup truck so I'd like to reduce my impact, but don't know if the efficacy of carbon offsets have really been evaluated.
- konschubert 8y agoI don't think that these services take carbon out of the air and turn it back into fossiles. I guess that they mostly finance re-forestation. Then, you have to ask yourself: Would the new forest happened anyways and they are just taking your money as a bonus? Is the new forest going to be permanent or will it be removed and re-forested again in 30 years?
- thedevindevops 8y ago>Would the new forest happened anyways and they are just taking your money as a bonus? Is the new forest going to be permanent or will it be removed and re-forested again in 30 years? Perhaps, in decades/centuries a new forest might happen naturally. I should hope - if you're paying for it - that it not be permanent, carbon capture in trees happens fastest at the beginning of their lifecycle so by harvesting and re-foresting it functions as a renewable resource and has greatest efficacy as a carbon sink.
- konschubert 8y agoIf you harvest the wood and burn it/let it rot then the carbon will be released back into the atmosphere. Of course you might make furniture from the wood, but it will replace other furniture that then gets burned in place. A forest only holds carbon, it doesn't continuously remove it.
- jogjayr 8y ago> I drive a pickup truck so I'd like to reduce my impact You could...drive it a lot less :-)
- 8y ago
- starpilot 8y ago> The best thing a bright young person can do to help rid civilisation of fossil fuels is get an education in engineering. The Economist, 2009. https://www.economist.com/news/2009/11/13/wanted-green-engineers https://www.economist.com/news/2009/11/13/wanted-green-engin... I'm guessing the most relevant fields would be chemE and materials science.
- xupybd 8y agoIs this 12 year timeline correct. What degree of catastrophe are we looking at?
- roryisok 8y agoIt's generally accepted that if we don't zero our carbon emissions in 12 years we'll see 2 degrees warming minimum. Best case scenario is drought, heatwaves, forest fires, lose half the wildlife in the world, all the coral reefs, most of the fish, reduced crop yield, flooding, storms, sea level rise, and parts of the world are inhospitable, and the populations of those regions migrate north. BEST case. WORST case is runaway warming when all the methane in the arctic is released and the forests that soak up our carbon burn down and the ocean stops absorbing it, and the earth gets so hot that humans literally just drop dead from hyperthermia. I refuse to believe in the worst case, because the majority of scientists are not going that far, and because it could make a person crazy just thinking about it. Besides, the best case is bad enough already.
- xupybd 8y agoI honestly think there is no way we can zero emissions in that time. But I'm hopeful the rate of technological progress can out pace our predictions. I'm also hopeful that we may one day find a means to reverse the problem through Geo engineering. People are far more motivate when the problem is already at the door. I just hope it's not too late by then.
- roryisok 8y agoI agree, on both counts. Rereading my post now it seems hopelessly pessimistic, and negative. I was mostly just trying to explain what we can expect to see as we approach 2 degrees of warming. We won't get to to zero carbon in the next 12 years and we won't avoid at least 1.5 degrees warming. But I honestly DO believe that we WILL see a downward trend in he next 12 years. We won't hit zero but i would hope we'd hit pre 2000 levels. And I also believe that even though we're going to suffer, technology like carbon capture and geo engineering will play a role in the future. A recent study suggested painting rooves and footpaths white in hotter countries would have the equivalent cooling effect of taking every car off the road for 50 years. Measures like this will help. Fusion power works. ITER in France will generate 500Mw when operational in 2025, and pave the way for more fusion globally. I think we can fix global warming, but its to our eternal shame that we're going to be fixing it rather than preventing it
- odessacubbage 8y agoanything that dramatically reduces the population or renders our post-industrial revolution economy inert. there's still plenty of time for a solar storm, a massive pandemic or a particularly violent nuclear war. barring that, suicide is an an increasingly pragmatic and attractive option.
- roryisok 8y ago> suicide is an an increasingly pragmatic and attractive option. Don't think that way. Climate despair is real. People get seriously depressed about it and a lot of people probably consider suicide. Messages like this are irresponsible and can push people over the edge. If you feel that urge, talk to someone. Reach out. Get better. If you're this worried about climate change then THE WORLD NEEDS YOU.
- odessacubbage 8y agowhile your heart is in the right place, i feel this sort of canned response will only become increasingly inadequate as a means of confronting what the world is going to become and what that means for the people within it. even the most utopian of the potential futures we face present the sort of existential nightmare to which 'opting out' of these terms and conditions will become an entirely rational response. >Messages like this are irresponsible and can push people over the edge. this is a very naive view and one that i would argue, with all due respect, is falsely empathetic without truly understanding the mindset and circumstances of someone who chooses to stop living. we need to have a truly honest conversation about self determination as it applies to the right for individuals to end their own lives and safe/ethical means of achieving that end. anything less is an illusion of compassion and a very cruel one.
- T-1000 8y agoI believe that a small minority could turn things around. If about 3 % of the population in the rich world would donate $100 per month, we could use that money to force the other to change. How? One example is to remove all coal power plants (which are responsible for 25 % of the greenhouse gas emissions) by building wind farms. This would drive the price of electricity down and make coal unprofitable.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ru999gol 8y agoTo have any meaningful impact on global warming there would need to be a massive rapid global economic shift, we would also would need to reduce world population otherwise anything we do will just be nullified by increases in population. I think to even suggest that the people in power (politicians and capitalist corporations) will actually be willing and able to solve this problem is incredibly naive and I have no idea where anyone gets this optimism from? No in reality we will see a slow increase in extreme natural disasters, island states and all coastlines becoming uninhabitable, permanent drought in most parts of the world, drinking water crisis, famine, massive unprepared forced migration, global economic collapse, permanent wars about remaining resources. I actually don't think humanity has any realistic chance to survive beyond 2080 and that number is actually quite conservative given the research.
- roryisok 8y agoWe're all tired of hearing "eat less meat" etc. But honestly these things would make a difference. We need to switch everyone who drives a fossil fuel car to electric, or no car at all. So make the switch. Buy an EV. Nissan leaf is affordable. Work remote if you can. Switch your home heating from oil or gas to solar or a heat pump. It's not just about people making little changes anymore. Every household needs to get rid of their oil burning machines, be they the home heating or vehicle kind. We can't do anything directly about trucking companies etc but they will follow. Recharging costs pittance next to refuelling and range goes up every year. The EV you buy now will save you money. The next one you buy will run rings around your old gas guzzler. The best, least depressing and least defeatist way to think about it is that the world is changing in the next 12 years and we're the early adopters. And if you don't offload that gas car now it'll be unsellable in 6 years
- kgabis 8y agoWouldn't replacing every ICE car with electric one be extremely wasteful? Cars cost resources and energy to produce so it makes sense to keep driving them for as long as possible. Focusing on emissions from driving doesn't account for the whole picture. Also, in many countries majority of energy production comes from burning fossil fuels so switching to electric cars doesn't magically solve CO2 emissions problem.
- roryisok 8y agoCars cost resources and energy to produce, but right now new fossil fuel cars are being produced every minute. We don't stop that process by continuing to drive a car that belches out CO2. Sure, if everyone continues driving their 10 year old Volkswagen and all car companies stop production tomorrow it might have a more immediate short term effect than changing to EV. But even in this impossible scenario, long term all those cars are still emitting CO2. I do take your point that transportation is not the whole picture, but we can't do anything on a personal level to close a coal plant, other than write to our local representatives in government. It's also worth pointing out that if all the power for EVs is generated from coal it's still less carbon than petrol and diesel cars on the road, because of how power plants are run at optimal efficiency, where as cars have to speed up and slow down, idle in traffic etc
- otabdeveloper2 8y ago> We have 12 years to prevent a climate catastrophe I don't know how old you are, but those of us over 20 remember that we had '12 years' 20 years ago. Somehow the prophesied catastrophe never arrives and the date gets perpetually pushed into the future. Looks like a secular Seventh Day Adventists.
- DoreenMichele 8y ago^ Though I imagine you will shortly be deluged with comments advising you that you simply don't understand the seriousness of the situation. Etc
- jogjayr 8y agoThings have gotten worse over the past 20 years though. The predictions might've been wrong about the rate of change (and I'm assuming this was a reputable source making the prediction, not cherry-picking the most extreme doomsayers). I hope more than anything they're still wrong today. But they weren't wrong about the actual direction of the change. People 20 years ago ignored the warnings, we must do better.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI never finished my degree, but I'm an environmental studies major. A cartoon in one of my books showed oxygen producing microbes that created earth's oxygen atmosphere organizing to stop the creation of this poisonous oxygen atmosphere as it was killing them. I was watching a TV show that said "If this spider were alive today, it would be hunting animals the size of house cats." and I blurted "No, it wouldn't. It would be on life support." Those giant dragonflies with 4 foot wingspans or whatever? They couldn't exist today. The atmosphere isn't dense enough. For that reason, movies like Jurassic Park are probably completely unrealistic. Dinosaur physiology probably is wholly unsuited to the modern atmosphere. Yes, absolutely, things are changing. But there is an unprecedented 7 billion people on the planet and life expectancy is going up, generally speaking. Could we see a dramatic population crash? Absolutely. Population crashes of various species in various places are a known phenomenon. That could happen. But we keep making these dire predictions about the end of the world and they keep failing to come true. We have been making them for at least a thousand years. The turn of the first millennium was predicted to be The End Times. More recently, the end of, I think, the Mayan calendar was supposed to be the end. Post WW2, everyone expected to die in nuclear war. Today, there is all kinds of post apocalyptic dystopian fiction, often involving antibiotic resistant infections. There are solutions for such things, though people who know of antibiotic alternatives are often dismissed as crackpots. Yet, we continue to quietly problem solve. That gets largely ignored in favor of making new predictions of how The End Times are at hand -- this time for realzy realz, I'm serious man, this is not like all those other silly predictions in the last 1000 years. And if you voice skepticism, you are advised you are a fool who just doesn't get it.
- vjsc 8y agoIn my opinion, the large corporations behind fossil fuels have too much of an economic clout. The governments around the world are dependent on them for a considerable amount of their respective national economy. So yes you are right about government not doing much about this. Ultimately, unless there is a relatively quick mass extinction event, no government is going to be bothered into action. Climate change and the devastation it's going to cause, is going to play out slowly over the years. The most affected would be the poorest of the world. They are going to die first. The rich will have enough resources to be able to not only survive, but also thrive on these events as new business opportunities are going to be created. Ultimately, Earth maybe a very different place 100 years from now, but the rich of today are surely going to have their descendants living quite comfortably. The only thing an individual can do is to strive to get as rich as possible, because that is the only security that's going to save you and your family in the bleak future that lies ahead of us.
- raquo 8y agoWell, as comfortable as you will be able get with global wars, refugees, food shortages, etc. going on. Governments and countries are not very stable under these conditions. Probably shouldn't expect your wealth to crisis proof your life in this scenario. Won't hurt but we'll all be much better off organizing to avoid this future.
- doon123 8y ago>> Well, as comfortable as you will be able get with global wars, refugees, food shortages, etc. going on. I think the crisis will be contained to the poorest parts of the world. Especially the tropics. This area is going to be the first to bear the brunt of climate change related problems. I dont foresee Global wars happening. The politicians are too smart for that. They will try to contain the damage to the extant that the richer countries ( US, Europe, Australia ) are not affected much. Ofcourse there will be shortages as global supply routes are going to be disrupted. The most thought provoking scenario here is going to be what will happen with China. Maybe not being a democracy will prove to be a blessing in disguise for it. Having a pragmatic group of men leading the country is the best option in the face of upcoming doom. China may shed a lot of weight ( population), but it may just survive, because of its largely monoculture and more or less obedient population. I see much of Africa, SouthEast Asia to completely gone by the next 100 years. They will be left alone by the rest of the world to fight the battle of survival, and the odds wont be great. MiddleEast is already ravaged, but they may continue to survive because they have oil. Most rich countries ( the leaders I mean ), may not be very displeased with the fate of the poorer nations. Because as far as they are concerned mass deaths in poorer nations is only going to reduce the carbon emission load on our planet.
- networkimprov 8y agoStratospheric Aerosol Injection: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stratospheric_aerosol_injection_(climate_engineering) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stratospheric_aerosol_injectio...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- yboris 8y agoThank you for sharing this. It's a dangerous geoengineering project, but it's also a quick solution to a part of the problem. Dangerous: we don't know how the nonlinear weather systems will behave. This may also compound the problem in the future - lots of unknowns. But very quick: We can cool the earth down rather quickly using this method.
- networkimprov 8y agoWe do have case studies from specific volcanic events, e.g. Mt. Pinatubo.
- King-Aaron 8y agoUnfortunately at an individual level effecting change, I feel the boat has long since sailed. It's pretty obvious that in western democracies, it's not so much the politicians who control the scene, but the corporates that sponsor their election campaigns in return for industry specific kickbacks. While we have vested interests such as coal, oil and gas producers sponsoring your only valid political choices, you're going to end up voting for parties that are only there due to those companies. I don't see that changing any time soon. I think it's best to just prepare for the most realistic current scenario, which is an average temperature rise in the area of 1 - 1.5 degrees C. Not so much dooms day preparation, but maybe don't be that little pig who builds his house out of straw.
- jsingleton 8y agoThere is lots of action still required to reach your realistic scenario. Don't give up. You can help. Hopefully this can motivate people in an optimistic way: https://unop.uk/how-to-help-with-a-big-global-problem-as-a-technologist-part-1/ https://unop.uk/how-to-help-with-a-big-global-problem-as-a-t...
- buboard 8y agospace mirrors
- explainplease 8y agoWhat could possibly go wrong?
- ForHackernews 8y agohttps://www.drawdown.org/ https://www.drawdown.org/ has a nicely presented list of things that will help with global warming. Honestly, I think it's too late. There's no way the entire world economy will be restructured in less than 12 years. Future generations will suffer for their ancestors' obstinacy.
- brylie 8y agoAs we have become adults, we learn time and time again about personal responsibilities. Some of these lessons take many years, and some are emerging. We are awakening to the fact that the Earth's climate, like bills and taxes, is both our personal and collective responsibility. This means we need to take personal, financial, and political steps to lower our resource usage and carbon footprint. We can look around at our daily lives - the food we eat, our careers, where/how we live - to find areas where we can shed a few kilos from our carbon budget. Likewise we can boycott, divest from, and sanction the major sources of corporate, meaning collective, greenhouse gas emissions.
- jsingleton 8y agoI wrote a trilogy of long posts on this topic very recently so I'll just link to that. https://unop.uk/how-to-help-with-a-big-global-problem-as-a-technologist-part-1/ https://unop.uk/how-to-help-with-a-big-global-problem-as-a-t... In summary, it's not somebody else's problem. It's our problem and we need to take responsibility and fix it. We already have all the core technology required to solve this and we just need to make it happen. Everyone can help, particularly the talented crowd on here.
- nicolaslem 8y ago> Everyone can help, particularly the talented crowd on here. I've been thinking about that for a while, is it possible to have a positive impact on the environment writing software?
- perfunctory 8y agoBret Victor wrote on the subject: http://worrydream.com/ClimateChange/ http://worrydream.com/ClimateChange/
- jsingleton 8y agoThis was the main inspiration for the posts and I refer back to it. Software is everywhere and can absolutely make a difference. Hopefully this will inspire others too.
- torgian 8y agoNothing will be done because it’s not profitable. More people will die from water shortage in the coming years before starvation.
- filoeleven 8y ago> This is aimed at people in the tech industry, and is more about what you can do with your career than at a hackathon. I’m not going to discuss policy and regulation, although they’re no less important than technological innovation. A good way to think about it, via Saul Griffith, is that it’s the role of technologists to create options for policy-makers. http://worrydream.com/ClimateChange/ http://worrydream.com/ClimateChange/
- aoner 8y agoIf you look at the recent IPCC reports, people are heavily betting on putting carbon back into the stable form. That can be in the form of carbon capture storage, or creating new building materials or other stuff out of it. I think in the near future, people will pay a hefty premium for carbon storage due to carbon taxes (Check out this great GIF that illustrates carbon tax scheme growth: https://www.sightline.org/2017/06/06/map-the-future-is-carbon-priced-and-the-us-is-getting-left-behind/ https://www.sightline.org/2017/06/06/map-the-future-is-carbo... ). Together, these carbon pricing initiatives cover about 7 gigatons of carbon dioxide equivalent (GtCO2e), or about 13 percent of annual global GHG emissions. I think this will create a huge business, so if you are an engineer, I think it makes sense to get involved. Personally the state of the world has given me a lot of negativity, but I've turned that around after doing a lot of research. There is a lot of awesome work being done. There are a couple of good resources to see what everybody else is already doing: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1xc6lkrIv1XORl7b31ARqFXImwhjcm8MQHG1vfoz5G0M/edit#gid=1946455755 https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1xc6lkrIv1XORl7b31ARq... https://www.thirdway.org/graphic/carbon-capture-projects-map https://www.thirdway.org/graphic/carbon-capture-projects-map http://www.airminers.org/explore http://www.airminers.org/explore I'm very interested in this space, and think there are a lot of other people interested (just as Ycombinator is in its request for carbon removal technologies: https://www.ycombinator.com/rfs/#carbon https://www.ycombinator.com/rfs/#carbon ). I have more resources if people are interested. (On a personal level, I've also made a lot of changes. I stopped eating meat, and renovated our home to be sustainable, by adding a air to water heat pump, solar panels, a solar boiler, an heat recovery system for our shower, ventilation based on CO2 levels so only the necessary heat escapes and of course better insulation. I'm also thinking about creating an excel of my carbon footprint yearly and trying to reduce it/compensate it)
- lozenge 8y ago"If you look at the recent IPCC reports, people are heavily betting on putting carbon back into the stable form" This is more due to its political palatibility than its scientific value. It allows conclusions like "12 years to save the world" (not actually what the report says, but what the media was able to spin it as, and OP's interpretation) instead of a more honest assessment. As for the EU's carbon trading scheme, it's a joke and efforts to strengthen it have failed due to lack of political will.
- maym86 8y agoOn a personal note, don't have children. I'm not being facetious. It seems like we've had opportunities to do the right thing and consistently haven't so until the outlook looks better and we start taking action it's not a great idea to create offspring that will have to deal with the consequences.
- claydavisss 8y agoBut people without children have even less motivation to care about the future. Even moreso for people who aren't married....why shouldn't they let their SUV idle in the driveway?
- maym86 8y agoI don't think it's a solution to climate change, it's just a personal choice. The solutions are out of my reach and ideling the SUV is much less of a problem than selling the SUV in the first place. I don't think we're doing a good job handling the issue on a policy level so creating a child who will potentially have to deal with the worst of these problems directly seems unnecessary, avoidable and selfish.
- hycaria 8y agoBest solution : One child less.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoThis is especially true if you are in a developed country. I did a college paper for an Environmental Law class. American children consume about 200 times the resources of children in developing countries. I originally wanted three children. I stopped at two for various reasons. I think I did the right thing.
- haihaibye 8y ago>> American children consume about 200 times the resources of children in developing countries So one less immigrant is 99.5% as effective at reducing co2 as one less child?
- DoreenMichele 8y agoSince I haven't researched that in specific I don't know for sure, but I'm guessing the answer is "No." Immigrant children from developing countries typically remain relatively poor by American standards and continue to use substantially fewer resources. They don't promptly leap up to middle class American consumption levels. We would probably be better off, environmentally speaking, to aggressively try to convince American citizens to have fewer children while having more liberal immigration policies than to aggressively try to keep immigrants out while claiming that condemning children who already exist to a life of hardship is the moral equivalent of Americans choosing to have fewer children for environmental reasons. They aren't morally equivalent anymore than "Eat the rich" is some kind of moral high ground.
- chr1 8y agoWhen talking about climate change it is important to remember that climate on earth is pretty bad already and we need to learn to control it anyway. High (~5km) solar updraft towers look like a very promising way to do it. In addition to generating electricity they can generate rain, prevent storms by reducing the amount of energy in the atmosphere, and reduce the temperature by improving the convection. Large number of such towers will give us fine grained control over the climate, and reduce the rise of sea level by moving a large part of the water to groundwater in the deserts.
- samatman 8y agoI would love to see Australia take the lead on this. It's a majestic notion and we should be trying it right now.
- DyslexicAtheist 8y agoWe are past the point where we we can fix this with discussions & civil discourse. Not to say that we shouldn't try. But a leaflet campaigns and discussions aren't going to reduce emissions. The best solution would be not to have kids (too late for me) and adopt instead if you must, not to own a car, try to own as little as you can (it will make you happier too). Plant stuff, pick up gardening, go offline and go outside to reconnect with where you come from. Anything that contains batteries is probably toxic. Most shit we don't need we just are brainwashed into thinking we do. An interesting read is Technological Slavery The Collected Writings Of Theodore J. Kaczynski, A.k.a. ' The Unabomber' which has been mentioned in Bill Joy's famous post "Why the Future doesn't Need Us" and my guess is that despite his infamy he might be heralded as some kind of "hero" in 50-100 years time. Humans and society is in deeper in trouble than we think and stand "no chance of being saved". If you are of sound mental state, I suggest Thomas Ligotti's "The Conspiracy against the Human Race" https://www.wired.com/2000/04/joy-2/ https://www.wired.com/2000/04/joy-2/ https://archive.org/details/TechnologicalSlaveryTheCollectedWritingsOfTheodoreJ.KaczynskiA.k.a.TheUnabomber/ https://archive.org/details/TechnologicalSlaveryTheCollected... https://www.amazon.com/Conspiracy-against-Human-Race-Contrivance/dp/0984480277 https://www.amazon.com/Conspiracy-against-Human-Race-Contriv...
- marmaduke 8y agofrom the Joy article, > Eventually a stage may be reached at which the decisions necessary to keep the system running will be so complex that human beings will be incapable of making them intelligently. At that stage the machines will be in effective control. doesn't that describe our financial markets already?
- wrinkl3 8y agoPersonally, I don't feel like me rescinding my earthly possessions and refusing to procreate will do anything to help anyone, other than maybe quench my own conscience. That whole approach is referred to as hair-shirt environmentalism, I believe. Bruce Sterling once observed that if you're trying to combat Climate Change solely by minimizing your individual impact, the logical conclusion would be to stop living altogether.
- panic 8y ago> Maybe corporations are the ones who can be pressured to take the lead. Yep. We need to somehow put pressure on every polluting institution (corporations, militaries, and so on) to either radically change or stop existing. Individual action won't work. Here are some companies to start with: https://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/2017/jul/10/100-fossil-fuel-companies-investors-responsible-71-global-emissions-cdp-study-climate-change https://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/2017/jul/10...
- pedro1976 8y agoOn the topic of geo engineering, I want to share a quote [0] from the physicist Joshua Bach: "As long as we are still burning fossil fuels to generate energy, the idea of capturing the CO2 from the atmosphere is a joke. It would require more than all the energy we have generated since the beginning of the industrial age. Or millions of years of growing non-rotting trees." [0] https://twitter.com/Plinz/status/1041881894995013632 https://twitter.com/Plinz/status/1041881894995013632
- avmich 8y agoI wonder why he thinks so. What are the calculations? Why can't we use green energy to separate CO2 in atmosphere from clean air and do that faster than we as civilization add CO2 to air, thus buying some time to apply non-technical solutions?
- Juliate 8y agoIndirect action idea (I wonder about it). Gather with other persons to invest a few shares in the major groups responsible for CO2 emissions. Not to have weight per se, but to be invited in shareholders assembly. And to be regularly loud about the topic of the group's responsibility. It's enough for 4, 5 distinct individuals to bring up related questions in the same assembly so that it bothers other investors. Bothering from within is a start.
- questionasked 8y agolmao how is paying the companies responsible for this possibly a good idea?
- Juliate 8y agoYou're not paying the company, you're buying a share of its capital. That's not the same thing at all: in exchange, you get a right to get shareholders information and to participate in general assemblies, a right you may sell back later. Plus, 1 share is enough to be invited to the shareholders meeting to get to ask questions. That's not out of touch. (edit for clarification)
- wohlergehen 8y agoAt least in Germany, this exists [1]. Sorry, but the page is not in English. They target fossil energy, chemical and arms manufacturing industry mostly. You should check if this exists in your country (I can't believe it doesn't) and get involved. This approach does work. 1: https://www.kritischeaktionaere.de/ https://www.kritischeaktionaere.de/
- monktastic1 8y agoIf I'm driving the demand they're fulfilling, I'm probably not a good choice to complain. So I guess we have to find the guiltless ones first....
- Juliate 8y agoBeware, that's a trap. Guilt is not a valid reason not to object to, to criticise the compromission. Would I be drunk, that wouldn't disqualify me from criticising all of: my own responsibility, alcohol, policies regarding liquors. (in the same way, would I be a believer, that wouldn't make it impossible or irrelevant or even hypocritical to criticise faith, religion, church, customs, etc.). That's the good thing with reason: you are allowed and you can detach from what you're talking about.
- kebman 8y agoPrevent? Haha, guys! Very funny! :D You had until 2016.
- marmaduke 8y agoRelated question: where could one find jobs related to climate change efforts? beyond walking, eating less meat, etc I might want to put my working hours in as well, but no idea who/what to look for.
- clabauterman 8y agoThat's actually something I want to know as well. I would like to work as a Developer to do good in the sense of avoiding climate change or saving nature. That's hard to find!
- CalRobert 8y agoWell, we _could_ build a world where the majority of people: * Live in a very well insulated flat in the city that isn't made of concrete * Have meat and dairy only as a luxury item * Use solar and wind power for your heat pump and AC * Ride a bike or walk to work, or take electrically-powered public transport * Use non-luxurious sea transport to go on foreign holidays we'd be about there. But boiling today's young people for the sake of cheap gas has proven more politically feasible.
- JBReefer 8y agoPeople on HN seem to believe the default state of humanity is driving everywhere and living in the suburbs, when that's only true in particular parts of the US for the last 80 years or so. A frequent question I see about not owning a car is "well how could I possibly get groceries otherwise??" The only way we can address our individual footprint and our isolation crisis is to build real towns and cities again, but I'm doubtful. Don't have a lot of hope for this one, people are willing to tell others to change their patterns but will rarely change their own. That way, you get woke points but don't have to do anything. Plus that Tesla looks GREAT in the driveway, especially when you consider that climate change is all everyone else's fault.
- CalRobert 8y ago"People on HN", to me, seems like it should be "People in the US". There are plenty of urbanists on HN. Anecdotal, but I swear if I post something like "your free parking is just welfare for car owners" it will be upvoted most of my workday, and then downvoted as Americans come online. But I don't have hard data for this (wonder if HN has a way to pull the comment score history over time...) For what it's worth, my Brompton looks pretty cool at my desk, too, but that's less visible. And yeah, all new cities are garbage. Absolute dystopian nightmares of design where letting your three year old play in the street is a death sentence. Never mind that when cars were new a NYC judge decried the possibility of kids being banished from playing in the streets, which of course was perfectly normal.
- DanielBMarkham 8y agoThe definition of terms becomes critical here. "Catastrophe" is an alarming word. If 25% of the human population died, it would certainly be a catastrophe. But the planet would still be around. Humans would still be around. A thousand years from now, it might be remembered as "that really bad time" Planet-scale change is truly Brobdingnagian. Anything in your life is insignificant compared to that. You have to frame this discussion before you even begin. Are you talking about stuff you can do that you can see the result of? Or are you talking about stuff you can do that will make things look different a thousand years from now? The first one is doable. The second one? We've had tens of billions of people live on this planet. I don't know of any that managed that. Maybe a dozen or so? If I wanted to enact change, I would create acceptance criteria before I started. Am I in this to feel good? To change my local government to do X? And so forth. If your goal is something like "I want the world to be a better place!" then that's a great goal, but it's a feeling, not a goal. Goals you can measure. Goals have numbers and measurement criteria. If you just want to be upset and vent, fine. That's a perfectly fine thing to do. After all, things suck. A lot of things suck. It's actually a more honest and healthy goal than any of the others I've discussed. We are a social species. We adapt through conversation and persuasion.
- picsao 8y agoI have my shares in Somali pirates sinking coal and oil tankers.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- interfixus 8y agoI read 2001: A Space Odyssey when I was 11. That would have been 1971. The Moon shuttle, the space station, and the elctronic wizardry were okay by me. Even the monolith, though things did turn too weird for my taste towards the end (and I still agree with my younger self here). But one fundamental premise completely toppled my suspension of disbelief: That humanity would still seriously be here by the turn of the century. Clearly, ww would by then be overwhelmed, struggling against or exterminated by ... pollution. Which is what all doomsday was about then. Some years later it was all-out nuclear war. Ask me by the beginning of the eighties, and I shall tell you confidently that I - and you - won't be around by the year 2000. As we now know, I nearly got that one right during the next few years, but today I really no longer believe it would have moved far beyond megadisaster - not into actual extermination. So, these days it's the climate, and I am old and cynical and jaded. Sick to puking level of being called a denier. Noone in his/her/its right mind can deny that climate is changing. Always has, presumably always will. And of course we influence the damned thing. Every living and species does, and we clearly to a very high extent. If we don't - collectively - like the way things are going, by all means, we ought to take steps to shift the course. We may even be in for rough times. Maybe very rough. And then again, maybe we won't. If someone can give me a plausible scenario for the year 2100 - as seen from the perpective of someone actually living there and then - I'm all ears. I have zero idea wheter that scenario in that perspective will be on the black or on the white side. I shall, however, be extremly surprised if climate will have actually killed or ruined us, downvotes be damned.
- seren 8y agoI understand your sentiment, but it boils down to : past catastrophic predictions were wrong so future catastrophic predictions are also going to be wrong. That does not reassure me one bit. Let's that the doomsday future is 100 millions people living in the Arctic circle. Maybe it is not that bad for people living in 2500, with AI, agricultural drones, floating cities. They might even have fusion and a moon base. But I cannot imagine how we can go peacefully from a few billions people living around the globe to another stable state. This is going to be a very rocky transition, and we, or our children, are going to experience it fully.
- 8y ago
- loriverkutya 8y agoReading these answers make me realize, that we are doomed.
- dougmwne 8y ago“It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it.” Which is exactly what I see here. Many of the brightest people gathered together in one place on the internet. Working in an industry that is scary good at creating products that change behavior and even culture. Together creating all manner of logical loops and justifications, "this is why I don't really need to change anything personally" or "I've made this symbolic change, so I've done my part." Every one of us could begin donating a significant portion of our revenue to climate change lobbying. We could work for existing climate advocacy organizations. We could found new organisations. We could take every lesson learned in the rush to get users to click on more ads and apply it to climate advocacy. American politics and policy is absolutely for sale. We could buy it. Shame on us all. Will that money bring you comfort while the world burns?
- crc32 8y agoIf it's up to us, it's up to us: - Invest in (or even set up, if you've got the skills) crowd funded solar projects like http://www.burnhamandwestonenergy.co.uk/ http://www.burnhamandwestonenergy.co.uk/ - as a charity or "community interest company" - Donate/contribute to charities supporting reforestation - for example https://onetreeplanted.org/ https://onetreeplanted.org/ or buy land, something like this: http://www.buybrazilland.com/rainforest-property-for-sale/ http://www.buybrazilland.com/rainforest-property-for-sale/ So there are existing organisations which offer these kinds of services; but there's no reason why a "charity startup" couldn't form to provide these kinds of services in a different way; more focussed on the climate change issue and with more of a social/viral element; to try and build the scale that would be necessary. If every twitter user contributed $10...
- pimterry 8y agoIf you're concerned about this, help fix it directly: * Go Climate Neutral: http://goclimateneutral.com http://goclimateneutral.com. It's much cheaper than you'd expect (~$10/month, depending on your lifestyle) to improve the world's energy efficiency enough to cancel out all your own impact. * Donate to other efficient climate change charities: https://www.givingwhatwecan.org/post/2013/11/less-burn-for-your-buck-part-ii https://www.givingwhatwecan.org/post/2013/11/less-burn-for-y...
- Carpetsmoker 8y agoPoliticians say that business must self-regulate or that consumers must choose different. Businesses say that they are following the laws made by the politicians and are meeting consumer demands. Consumers say the government should regulate things better and that businesses should be more environmental friendly. In others words, everyone is looking to everyone else to do something; thus no one really does something. Sure, there are some token efforts here and there. But the actual sweeping changes that we need aren't happening. Not a new phenomenon, and also not isolated to just climate change. It just happens to be the most pressing problem. The solution? I don't see one, save for a fundamental refactor of our democratic institutions. I don't see that happen in the next 12 years. So what can be done? Many things can be done technically. What can realistically be done given the current state of affairs? Quite little, I think. Stuff like going to work on the bike is cute – and something I do – but not really making a massive impact. Vote for your local green party? In some places that's fairly useful; in others it's about as useful as wiping your arse with the ballot (US and UK being prominent examples) :-( Honestly I think nothing serious will happen until it's too late. Maybe not even then. C'est la vie I suppose?
- GrumpyNl 8y agoCould we have prevented the extinction of the dinosaur with the knowledge we have now? If not, why worry?
- daedlanth 8y agoDo something about YOU; protest insanity by not being insane. It's actually quite simple.
- kapauldo 8y agoVote
- bansheehash 8y agoThere's a lot that technology can do to fight climate change. I came across Treetracker (https://www.greenstand.org/ https://www.greenstand.org/), an app that tracks tree planting and pays planters per tree after verification. Spinning up multiple crowdfunded instances of apps like this across the world could really bring back a lot of the green cover lost over the years.
- pauldjohnston 8y agoWell, having done some research into this recently, the tech world has something it can do right now. Switch to sustainably powered Cloud and move to renewably powered/offset Data Centres. e.g. Google (100% carbon neutral), Azure (100% offset), AWS (Oregon, Montreal, Ireland, Frankfurt regions are 100% carbon neutral) Cloud/Data Centres emit around 2% of Greenhouse Gas Emissions (bet you didn't know that). There is also research showing that we're going to increase our Data Centre usage by 5x in the next 7 years. So change that 2% to something much much higher... because that much compute requires that much more energy and we don't have the worldwide renewables infrastructure at scale to cope with the extra capacity. https://bit.ly/2024wp https://bit.ly/2024wp https://www.change.org/p/sustainable-servers-by-2024 https://www.change.org/p/sustainable-servers-by-2024 * Sign the pledge please * (if you agree with it of course) It's almost the simplest thing we can easily do, and it should put pressure on tech companies to switch to renewables. If we believe the tech industry is an innovator and a force for good, why not start with the means of production - the energy industry? Sign up... switch... go! PS I wrote the whitepaper with Anne Currie - we have not been paid for the work and was entirely voluntary. I used to work for AWS up until June this year.
- aecurrie 8y agoAgreed, this is one for commercial votes ($). We're a rich industry that uses loads of electricity, most of which is fossil-fueled. We need to choose to run our servers 100% carbon neutral and that would make way more difference than individual action. That will get more spending on renewable generation. Our industry has the money and we can personally just choose to host somewhere carbon neutral (as mentioned, Google, Azure or the 4 sustainable AWS regions: Oregon, Montreal, Ireland, Frankfurt right now)
- EeThahs2 8y agoOr if you're hosting in-house, ask corporate leaders whether the company is buying renewable energy. That should be the case anyway.
- antoineMoPa 8y agoI wonder what percentage of CO2 comes from programmers commuting to work.
- barrkel 8y agoIt's a collective action problem and there's almost no way it can be addressed politically in today's world. There's too much win for populists to say to their population, "screw those foreigners / globalists / westerners / elites telling us what to do, we're going to look after ourselves". This is a hard message to compete with in domestic politics. And everybody ends up worse off because everybody else has the same dynamics. So IMO we'll need to deal with mass migration and political instability in poor countries. That's the next battle; parts of the world with subsistence agriculture will become unsustainable, and there will be large migrations of population to elsewhere. That needs to be dealt with rationally, because if it becomes irrational, we'll get into the realms of fascism and genocide. I don't think the whole planet is going to die, FWIW. Instead, I think we're going to see a shift in ecosystems, where the relative balance of flora and fauna will alter. Some may be edible, some less so. Prices will change and people will adjust, but adjustment will be much harder where there's subsistence agri. I don't think humans are seriously at risk of being wiped out - we're pretty adaptable and we have a lot of technology we could apply when prices rise enough for it to make sense. But food prices may rise generally, and some specifics may become very expensive. This too will lead to political instability and migration.
- brown9-2 8y agoVote for representatives that take the threat seriously.
- perfunctory 8y agoAmong other things, stop using cryptocurrencies.
- dane-pgp 8y agoShould we also stop using cars given that walking exists, or stop using computers when we could use a pencil and paper? Is there an amount of energy that the traditional banking system could use beyond which you would recommend people stop using banks? You may not think that cryptocurrencies provide any benefit to the world (and I admit that I don't own any either), but their energy usage should be evaluated like any other technology or asset: Does the energy they require cost more than the amount of value they create in the market? If it did, then no one would mine cryptocurrencies. The market value for cryptocurrencies may seem irrational to you, but there are probably lots of things that people value that seems irrational or unnecessary to outside observers. I personally think that a global, low-cost, uncensored means of transacting between strangers is revolutionary, and I look forward to future innovations that will make it more energy efficient (for the same level of usefulness and security).
- otikik 8y agoI don't think we should, but here's some things that I think we're capable of: * We could use atomic power, but not to replace oil: we irradiate or directly bomb the main global oil reserves so they are rendered unusable. Both Russia and the US have the power to do this many times over. That would mean World War III, probably. Which would also lower the CO2 levels. * We can inoculate 10 or 20 people in densely populated areas with highly contagious virus, trigger a pandemic and see the numbers go down. * We can simultaneously fund anti-vaccination groups, and decrease the funds for the public health organizations like the U.S. Food and Drug administration, worldwide. That could have the same effect, depending on how vicious the viruses we get are in the next 10 years. Super-flu would be fatal enough.
- qubax 8y ago> So what can we do so our children don't live in some ghastly hothouse world? How about stopping with the apocalyptic hyperbole? > The scientists have told us its our final chance.... And "scientists" have been telling us that for decades now. > I feel like the young people need to take charge of the world because the older generations have had their chance and not fixed it. Or the old have lived long enough not to buy into hysteria. Maybe the older people are just wiser, better educated and have more experience? Or we could let the young people, who know nothing about anything, take charge. > What can be done to prevent a climate catastrophe? Nothing. No more than we can prevent solar flares, tornadoes or volcanic eruptions. We simply have to deal with it. Climate change occurs naturally. It has existed before the industrial revolution. It has existed before humans. It will exist after humans. Trying to prevent climate is like trying to prevent the sun from rising in the east. Is there room for us to mitigate human contribution to climate change? Sure. Would that matter. Probably not. Are there other areas we should be concentrating on? Yes. Environmental preservation ( forests, rivers, oceans ... ). Species protection. Build better and walkable cities. Global warming ( rebranded by PR firms as the silly "climate change" ) isn't the first apocalyptic hysteria by "scientists" ( and by "scientists" I mostly mean politicians, corporations, lawyers, etc trying to profit ). Here are some of the "end of the world" events cassandrized by "scientists" Climate change. Global warming, Global cooling ( from 1940s to 1970s ). That's right folks, before we were going to boil to death, we were going to freeze to death. Of course there are the supervolcanic eruptions. Asteroid strike. Of course dire warnings of nuclear holocaust. Then there was malthusian prediction of death by population growth. Boy was he wrong about that one. "Scientists" even warned of extinction of humans by race mixing - look up social darwinism. Now we laugh at that. So take a deep breath. The world is not going to end anytime soon. Climate change happens with or without humans. We'll adapt like we always have.
- codingdave 8y agoDon't forget that the small things add up -- small things on their own won't change the world, but they change the lifestyle of one family at a time, and it helps both a little in the short run, and more as children raised in climate-aware homes grow up. If everyone starts making small changes, it will change demand, which changes markets, which changes politics. Some small examples: Walk to the grocery store every other day instead of driving once a week. Use mass transit. Recycle. Use products made from renewable, recyclable materials. Go ahead and put up a solar electric system, even if the costs aren't perfect, nor is the tech, or even always the carbon offset.... but it moves demand in the right direction and sends a message. Turn down your heat in the winter, and your AC in the summer. Turn lights off when you leave a room. Be aware of your energy burn. As another commenter said, don't write or use cryptocurrency. Produce and buy local goods. And for cryin' out loud -- VOTE, for people who will be on the right side of this issue.
- bluGill 8y agoWalking to the grocery store means you live within walking distance. That means zoning codes that allow a grocery store in your neighborhood. Most do not allow that.
- codingdave 8y agoTrue, but "Walking distance" is a nebulous measurement at best. How far can you walk? I walk 1.5 miles to my grocery store. Most of my neighbors say that is not within walking distance, but clearly that is a personal judgement, because I do it. And if we are talking about what changes we can make to our lives, expanding your perspective on "walking distance" is not a bad place to start.
- zamalek 8y agoElectric bicycles and boards have absurdly low energy consumption.
- gonmf 8y agoWe do nothing of the sort. We wait for the sea levels to rise and we build dams and walls. And we reinforce our buildings against natural disasters. And slowly the public demands changes on greenhouse gas emissions, recycling, etc, and it slowly will slow down the worsening effects. That's the most likely scenario, nothing will change because the HackerNews netizens change cloud providers and start recycling more.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoCollapse comes that way. Its not about beach houses. Its about food chain collapse, refugee storms that overwhelm public infrastructure, the 'ring of fire' of expanding collapse that can (and has) destroyed civilization before
- ManlyBread 8y agoThe greed of the 1% most wealthy people in the world has caused this problem so they should pool their resources and fix it.
- gldalmaso 8y agoBut they won't, and they will be fine even if comes to living in a bubble. As it has always been, the poor will carry the burden of humanity.
- RickJWagner 8y agoIn the final analysis, it seems that a smaller population base is the answer. People are not easily motivated to give up creature comforts. (Though they often tell others they should.) Fewer people == fewer negative influences on the earth.
- haihaibye 8y agoIf altruism is heritible (like almost every other personality trait) won't this just select for a world of selfish people?
- alex_duf 8y agoAt a personal level, switch energy provider, change your diet, cycle / use public transport and drive electric if you must drive (it's more complex than that depending on if you have a car or not). If you have the chance to own your property and the cash to do so, ensure it's insulated. On a financial level, divest from fossil fuel, invest in renewable energies and sustainable technologies On a professional level, if you have the privilege do be able to choose your job, try to find one that do no evil. Happy to hear about more suggestions
- nazgulnarsil 8y agothere are already a billion people advocating for collective action ie someone else should do something. Donors need to take it upon themselves to fund and assist geoengineering moonshots.
- nmeofthestate 8y agoAs far as I can see, nuclear is the only existing technology that can now be used to rapidly transition to low carbon energy. We then solve the problem of nuclear waste (if indeed it is a big problem - I suspect not) afterwards. It's either that or not solving the problem.
- oytis 8y agoJust invent a way to get lots of cheap energy without burning stuff and we're fine. Not nuclear plants, nuclear energy is evil, we all know that.
- TheAceOfHearts 8y agoWhat's your source for this 12 year figure? What exactly happening in 12 years? What scientists are saying it's our "final chance"? I don't think being hyperbolic is constructive or helpful in the slightest when you're looking to have a serious discussion. To be clear, I'm not saying there isn't a problem. I agree that there are a multitude of problems and that we must take action to address them. But over the last few decades a few people have made a name for themselves by making crazy allegations, and I believe this has done nothing but make people take the issue less seriously than they should. I'm happy to be corrected on this, since I'm not an expert and I haven't done that much research. When I last looked into this topic it didn't seem like there was consensus among the scientific community about the predicted timelines for future climate events or even a clear understanding of what those events would be. Again, I'm very happy to be corrected on any of this, as I take the topic of climate change incredibly seriously. It is my belief that allowing climate change issues to run loose is one of the biggest risks to our civilization.
- berkoab 8y agoFor a balanced view, this is a must read from Professor of Meteorology Richard S. Lindzen at MIT: https://www.thegwpf.org/content/uploads/2018/10/Lindzen-2018-GWPF-Lecture.pdf https://www.thegwpf.org/content/uploads/2018/10/Lindzen-2018...
- UncleMeat 8y agoThat's not balanced. The overwhelming majority of experts in the field disagree with Lindzen, who is largely famous among laypeople because he is one of the few academics that deniers can point to.
- berkoab 8y agoExperts? That's exactly his point. They're far from being experts. What I meant by balanced was as a balance to all the views being expressed here. I probably misused that word.
- UncleMeat 8y agoI'd describe people with PhDs in atmospheric science who have published papers on climate change or other climate modeling as experts. These people largely disagree with Lindzen.
- explainplease 8y agoFrom the paper: > Richard S. Lindzen was Alfred P. Sloan Professor of Meteorology at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology until his retirement in 2013. He is the author of over 200 papers on meteorology and climatology and is a member of the US National Academy of Sciences and of the Academic Advisory Council of GWPF. Does meteorology count as "atmospheric science"? Does climatology count as "climate change" or "climate modeling"? Does 200 papers count as "published papers"? Does being a professor at MIT count? By your own criteria, he is an expert. Therefore, by what reasoning do you dismiss him? Religion.
- davidw 8y agoEnd exclusionary zoning in the US, so that people can live closer to the things they need, and denser, if they so choose
- pimmen 8y agoUrbanization is a big thing too, it makes far more climate sense. Instead of driving to ten places to serve a hundred people on each stop a truck can drive to one and serve a thousand people. Also, heat in high rises is used more efficiently than in single family homes because all that excess heat from bottom homes rise to the ones on the upper floors. This is thankfully a trend right now, with people moving to bigger cities to find better jobs, but in some Western countries we have a lot of hurdles to make new houses and an overconsumption of existing housing. If you own a home already, that might mean you have to sacrifice something (higher property taxes to incentivize people to choose smaller properties, for example). Also, making the cities more accessible without a car does wonders for this too. I'm convinced there's some way tech can help with this too. Airbnb makes sure excess or unused living area can be allocated more efficiently, for example.
- vbezhenar 8y agoThere's no climate catastrophe. Nothing have to be done about preventing imaginable things.
- scalesolved 8y agoWould you mind expanding on this?
- vbezhenar 8y agoI think that the whole human-changing-planet thing is huge fraud. There are legitimate concerns, like bad air in the cities because of cars, but global warming, if it exists at all (which I don't observe because winters are as cold as they always were), is because of planetary cycles, not because human affected anything significantly. Concentrating on green energy is stupid, humans should invest more money into nuclear stations and potentially thermonuclear technology.
- chrisgray1497 8y agovote against ethanol biofuels. From a thermodynamic perspective they will never be sustainable. We're literally dumping energy into growing extra corn that we burn. It's a farmer subsidy and nothing more. Just pay the farmers the money. Stop wasting the land, nitrogen, greenhouse emissions and retooling cars for this nonsense.
- chriskanan 8y agoAs a political solution, I doubt there is much we can do. The young people are not that politicaly active (as in actualy casting votes). I'm very happy that Tesla has made automakers take electric cars seriously, and renewable electricity is doing well. Unfortunately, that's not going to be enough. Geoengineering research is currently fairly taboo and hard to get money for. It involves developing methods to alter the environment to compensate for what we have done. Many say we should just reduce greenhouse gasses, since if we mess up geoengineering we could really mess up the planet, but I think it should at least be very well funded and studied. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climate_engineering https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climate_engineering
- jerkstate 8y agoFirst world citizens need about 600-1000 adult trees to offset their carbon footprint. Go plant a lot of trees. Also, buy fewer things manufactured in countries that use primarily coal power, and travel a lot less (especially by airplane)
- ada1981 8y agoI watched a film recently called Pandora’s Box about Nuclear vs solar. They make the case nuclear is the best solution for environmentalists (the guys who made it were hard core activists) and that things like solar are toxic and leaching heavy metals. They say Nuclear is the safest and cleanest solution and is the only viable solution if we want to solve climate change.
- vbuwivbiu 8y agoit exchanges one set of problems for another, and again its our descendents who'll have to deal with it traditional solar can be made cleanly and there are advanced biological systems on the way
- ojhughes 8y agoZombie apocalypse
- kpmcc 8y agoReforestation. Stop eating meat. Stop burning fossil fuels. Use less energy unless your energy is 100% "green". Overthrow capitalism.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoKind of the 'eco-theatre' top-tunes list. But which are doable? And aren't other non-theatre items more effective? At least recycling wasn't in the list, which can be an energy sink and actual climate harm.
- curtas 8y agoReduce carbon emission by working remotely. Should be the default. Massively reduces carbon emission on large scale.
- chefkoch 8y agoNot if you walk or bike to work.
- midworst 8y agoThe first thing we need to do is change the marketing strategy. It should be “Save the people” rather than “Save the planet” or “Stop Climate Change”. The goal is saving the people, the method to do so is stopping climate change.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mahasvin 8y agoThere is a joke "Scientists are telling us that our civilisation stands on the border of the abyss, and propose themselves to take leadership, and make a move forward". Seriously speaking, last year I looked into summary of glacial core data from Greenland. You know, what, climate always changes. This one is no worse then a Pleistocene. May be some cool animals will emerge in a million years from now.
- quadcore 8y agoOn a high level, I've found the best way to prevail on big issues is to start by saying Thank You. We are given a chance to better ourselves, let's be excited about it. On the contrary, guilt, fear, finger-pointing and violence have never solved anything. It seems to me that governments can be counted out of taking the leadership needed to solve this within 12 years. The way I see it, you have to think of solutions that work within corruption, selfishness, etc, and most importantly, with everybody. People who do that are politicians. It's a voting problem at its heart to me. I feel like the young people need to take charge of the world because the older generations have had their chance and not fixed it. Young people aren't less selfish and corrupted than their elders (I mean, maybe, but we don't know that, do we).
- waylandsmithers 8y agoAs a meta-comment, it's interesting to me that this is so highly upvoted and responded to here on hacker news. As a consultant I often find that clients who are brilliant experts in their own field often assume themselves to be experts in _every_ domain, including my own area of expertise which is software design and development.
- platz 8y agoWhat is the likelyhood of a runaway feedback loop occuring?
- explainplease 8y agoZero. The hotter the planet gets, the more water evaporates from the oceans, which condenses into clouds, which reflect sunlight, which cools the planet.
- platz 8y agoAccording to statistical mechanics, even boltzmann brains have a higher probability than zero. I find your absolute certainty disturbing.
- explainplease 8y agoEarth is 4.5 billion years old. A runaway, climate chain-reaction hasn't happened yet. I find your lack of faith disturbing.
- platz 8y agoI think you're confusing a complete boil-off of the atmosphere with a slightly less extreme event that simply eliminates 90% of life on the planet, which has in fact happened before
- explainplease 8y agoI think you're conflating a "runaway feedback loop" with "a slightly less extreme event that simply eliminates 90% of life on the planet," which says nothing about whether it was caused by a runaway feedback loop.
- platz 8y agoTherefore, by this logic, zero percent chance... qed
- revel 8y agoPractically speaking, the single biggest area of low hanging fruit is clean shipping. Right now the largest 15 cargo ships emit more greenhouse gasses than all the cars on the road combined. The US could take the lead on this issue by modifying the Jones Act, a peculiar piece of legislation that forces maritime commerce between US territories to use US ships with an American crew. If the Jones Act were modified to include incentives for zero emission ships it would heavily incentive investment in this critical area. This single change in legislation would reduce the cost of goods and services in Hawaii and Puerto Rico, increase trade, and provide a powerful economic carrot to reduce carbon emissions.
- mikeash 8y agoThe largest 15 cargo ships emit more sulphuric dioxide than all the cars on the road combined. That is not a greenhouse gas, and actually has a cooling effect, although it’s not healthy locally.
- revel 8y agoSo I looked into this more and you're right that it's sulphuric dioxide that I was thinking of. CO2 emissions from shipping are 800m tons per year and, if taken alone, would constitute the 6th heaviest source of carbon emissions in the world.
- mikeash 8y agoHow are you dividing up other sources such that shipping would be the 6th heaviest source? At roughly 2% of total global emissions, it seems like you'd have to lump other sources together in a strange way to come up with that ranking. For example, looking at: https://www.c2es.org/content/international-emissions/ https://www.c2es.org/content/international-emissions/ Taking shipping as a separate thing, it would rank 7th in the chart of total emissions and 6th in the chart of energy-related emissions, but only because those charts only contain 6 and 5 entries respectively.
- lost_my_pwd 8y agoThere's a good Planet Money podcast all about the Jones Act: https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2016/08/05/488869138/episode-524-mr-jones-act https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2016/08/05/488869138/epis...
- WhompingWindows 8y agoWe'll definitely need geo-engineering to artificially cool our climate while we work out how to effectively remove CO2 from the air and store it for 1000's of years. It may require mass reforestation or putting carbon dioxide into concrete; whatever the answer, if we do not employ it on a massive scale, it won't matter if we transitioned quickly off of fossil fuels, which by the way we haven't. So, we will DEFINITELY need to artificially cool our planet.
- andyb11 8y agoYou could sign up for climateprediction.net (CPDN). CPDN is a volunteer computing, climate modelling, academic project that runs climate models on people’s home computers to help answer questions about how climate change is affecting our world.
- wtmt 8y agoDon't wait for others to do things or take decisions. That's going to be an uphill battle if you really want changes quicker. Start with yourself, and then push others (including friends, family, colleagues, corporations, politicians, etc.). A lot can be done if people take up changes on their own instead of waiting for politicians or corporations or "those other polluting countries" to "just do something" about it. Here are a few things you can do yourself and encourage those you know personally to follow: 1. Eliminate/reduce throwing or wasting food. Don't buy anything you wouldn't finish eating. 2. Eat only plants, or make plants the largest part of your meals while eliminating or reducing the consumption of animal products. Make sure you read up on nutrition and/or join some support groups. 3. Walk as much as possible and avoid fossil fuel based transport for yourself. Or try cycling. If necessary, take public transport. 4. Promote and use renewable sources of energy, like solar and/or wind, wherever possible. 5. Have fewer children or delay have children a little bit. This may have some other side effects depending on where you live and how the population demographic looks like. If you think of yourself as committed to this cause and yet you see issues or barriers with the above, that's only a sign of how these things seem impossible to others who don't care enough. Work with (and on) yourself first. Don't be shocked or surprised: you will see a whole lot of apathy all around you. People will even try to discourage you from doing anything and try to convince you that whatever you do just doesn't matter. Stop looking at them or listening to them.
- unit91 8y ago> Have fewer children...think of yourself as committed to this cause...People will even try to discourage you...Stop looking at them or listening to them. This sounds a lot like a cult religion to me.
- JabavuAdams 8y agoDon't worry, it's not going to spread.
- jbattle 8y agoThere's no way we're going to make a meaningful positive impact on the climate without doing things that make people uncomfortable. The sooner we start, the less dramatic that discomfort will be
- CyberBoom 8y agoThis is a strictly political issue. Most people think humans can’t destroy the planet’s atmosphere. That’s hubris, and based on your politics. “Science” always thinks it’s proven right until it’s proven wrong.
- pier25 8y agoNot really. It's about irrational humans and magical thinking.
- kisstheblade 8y agoThe green parties around the world are to blame for this. The only worthwhile actions to combat this are 1) Using nuclear power (on a massive scale preferrably) 2) Stopping globalisation (because transport is such a large contributor to CO2 emissions.). Local manufacturing would be much better for the environment (reduced transportation needs and also the western countries factories are much more sustainable than in third world countries and china) Also reducing immigration helps, people in Africa use much less resources than the same people eg. transported to the cold north.
- korantu 8y agoThe only solution to rapid reduction in co2 emissions that can be deployed right now at sufficient scale is nuclear. There are passively safe designs built right now. It can provide electricity, heat and desalination if lack of water is an issue. There is enough nuclear fuel in sea water to consider it an infinite source as far as humans are concerned [1]. Further, USA alone can be powered by its existing nuclear _waste_ for many years. Surprisingly, nuclear is almost never mentioned as an option. [1https://spectrum.ieee.org/energy/nuclear/nuclear-fuel-from-the-sea https://spectrum.ieee.org/energy/nuclear/nuclear-fuel-from-t...
- Retric 8y agoNuclear still costs far to much vs Wind and Solar. If all greenhouse gases came from electricity generation then doing the France model might work, but it's much better to cheaply go 95+% renewable and use the savings to cut down on transportation and home heating etc. PS: Grid scale solar is rapidly hitting 2 cents per kWh in sunny places. Nothing else is anywhere near competing with that.
- korantu 8y agoIf you factor in cost of storage required to provide continuous power, then you get way more expensive and less reliable. Now this problem is solved by, surprise, fossil fuels. [0] Ofcourse solar is cheaper when it is sunny, provider might even need to pay consumer to get them to consume. [1] [0] https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaelshellenberger/2018/05/15/solar-and-wind-lock-in-fossil-fuels-that-makes-saving-the-climate-harder-slower-more-expensive/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaelshellenberger/2018/05/15... [1] https://www.businessinsider.com/renewable-power-germany-negative-electricity-cost-2017-12/?IR=T https://www.businessinsider.com/renewable-power-germany-nega...
- Retric 8y agoContinuous aka base-load power is considered a defect as it's not load following. You can load follow with nuclear but then it becomes ridiculously expensive. France gets around this largely by buying and selling to other countries, but that does not scale. Really, going 100% nuclear takes either massive over supply or large scale energy storage just like solar. Wind however can supplement solar while still costing less than nuclear and allowing you to more closely match the demand curve. A little peaking power allows you to avoid significant grid storage at very reasonable costs, and as I said fix transportation etc. PS: The need for grid electricity storage is overblown. Storing energy for more than 1 day means you very rarely use that stored energy making in non-viable. When you can have 2x as much solar and still only pay 4c/kwh that's pointless. Within the day it needs to compete with an over supply of energy most of the time.
- thewhitetulip 8y agoPlease start using Solar and wind as much as possible. We have amazing products available now. I have fiur solar lanterns, one flashlight, a 20k mah powerbank and a 14w suaoki foldable solar panel In a few years ehen I buy a vehicle, I'll buy an electric moped, a 60w suoaki solar charger and a 150wh suoaki power generator. That way, I will be using my vehicle on renewable energy at all times. We need to do this and fast.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoI'd like to agree, but numbers don't add up. All the solar their is, amounts to 1% of energy use. Its not about mopeds, its about steel plants and oil refineries and shipping and heating and cooling. We're talking Terawatts, not Watts.
- thewhitetulip 8y agoI totally understand and agree. But we can't afford to not do something. Imagine if everyone planted a tree in a pot in their homes. It isn't about the 1w electricity I used from Solar, it is a momentum. Slowly, 1million people will use solar and it'll be 1 million watt electricity! It is in the scale
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoYes, but 1MW is one millionth of the problem. Its very hard to get individual effort to matter. Its the industrial infrastructure that has to change?
- thewhitetulip 8y agoThat still doesn't mean that we do nothing at all
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoWhich is the origin of the term 'eco-theatre'. Doing something, just to be doing something. I know, everybody can't be a lobbyist etc.
- nicholast 8y agoAs the economics continue along Swanson's law (the photovoltaic solar panel equivalent to Moore's law of ever decreasing costs) I expect the biggest obstacle to large scale transition to a distributed grid of majority local generation resources will be regulatory hurdles by legacy utility industry to protect their business model. Some of these initiatives may even be channeled outside of the legislative process such as some DOE proposals under current administration to protect coal generation. Sorry this might go counter to the intent of this question but I think I'm getting at is that the single biggest factor will be political, and that the voting box is our strongest lever.
- crispinb 8y agoThe collapse of the dynamically stable climate on which agricultural civilisation is founded is vanishingly unlikely to be prevented at this stage - no-one has ever even outlined, let alone detailed, even one remotely plausible political route from business-as-usual to where we need to be. As others here note, it's fundamentally a problem of world politics, howevermuch a proportion of HN readership may wish to suck at the corner of their technological comfort blanket. As we have no meaningful world polity, it's unsolvable. Our civilisation will almost certainly descend into chaos & war as the early effects of climate collapse roll in this century. Look at the convulsions flowing from a tiny trickle of refugees into Europe in 2015-16. That was barely a taste of what's to come. It's hardly surprising - nothing in H. Sapiens' constellation of seemingly unique traits (cognitive flexibility, sociality, cultural transmission through language etc) equips it to make collective decisions on a global scale. It's kind of telling that just as it's becoming most blindingly obvious that all our major challenges are planetary, there is a general retreat from commitment to global decision-making. We're not adequate to to the task. This isn't anyone's fault - it's just biology.
- Comevius 8y agoI like this comment a lot. Got goosebumps reading it.
- tomwhipple 8y agoStart by voting for candidates who believe in science. It seems odd to need to say this in 2018, but disbelief in clear scientific evidence should be a disqualification from holding office.
- Tempest1981 8y agoWe should focus our efforts where there is the most bang per buck: - Cleaner energy for developing countries, esp. China and India. Pay for their solar panels, to prevent new coal plants. - Research clean energy technology — solar, wind, hydroelectric. Drive maximum efficiency, and minimum cost. - Raise awareness worldwide. Keep talking. This documentary was informative: https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/an_inconvenient_sequel_truth_to_power/ https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/an_inconvenient_sequel_trut... (2017, 10 years after the original) 2018: https://www.eco-business.com/news/coal-is-in-decline-globally-but-asia-is-driving-new-plant-development/ https://www.eco-business.com/news/coal-is-in-decline-globall...
- startupfounder 8y ago"...governments can be counted out of taking the leadership needed to solve this within 12 years." This is the issue.[0] Governments are the middlemen between citizens that we the people decide to put in power through voting to represent us and our issues like climate change. But democracy has been hijacked by putting additional middlemen between we the people. The second middleman is the capital election, specifically ~132 Americans who donated 60% of the SuperPAC money. So our representatives spend a significant portion of their time in office calling these people to get funding for the next election cycle and when they vote on issues they think of these donors. Follow the money. Yes we can fix data centers or cargo ships or deploy nuclear power or utility regulation, but at some point regulation for these as well will be dependent on the people we vote to put into power to represent us. At the end of the day, corporations have a fiduciary duty to their shareholders to maximize profits and shareholder value. If leaders lead, companies will follow. I have an idea! Why don't we, the very large community of Hacker News with 3-3.5M+ monthly uniques[1] petition one of the most innovative and powerful institutions to fund more projects that will fix broken governments around the world? "Government" is only mentioned one time in the YC RFP[2], maybe it should have it's own category. Send them an email: hn@ycombinator.com or http://www.ycombinator.com/contact/ http://www.ycombinator.com/contact/ or contact your friends who are in the YC network. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mw2z9lV3W1g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mw2z9lV3W1g [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9219581 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9219581 [2] http://www.ycombinator.com/rfs/ http://www.ycombinator.com/rfs/
- patagonia 8y agoI honestly believe there are 1000 paths to safety, that there only a few to dangerous climate change, but that we will take a path to dangerous climate change. Because it is easier. It requires not making hard choices. It requires not working together. It requires less sacrifice. It will be the path of human nature and behavioral inertia. “So what can we do so our children don't live in some ghastly hothouse world?” We are going to have to explain to later generations why we thought the 6th great extinction was an appropriate price to pay for having elaborate, throw-away Halloween lawn decorations which were made by and the most costly to the most vulnerable citizens of the planet. I don’t say any of that lightly.
- seymour333 8y agoWhat can be done to prevent a climate catastrophe? Start an economical catastrophe. We need to immediately, and meaningfully, move away from oil, gas, and other carbon heavy industries in any way that we presently have the means to do so. If everyone who is presently in the market for a new vehicle could afford to buy an electric one, we'd probably be in better shape. If every household could put solar panels and take a load off of the grid, we would be moving in the right direction. The problem is these technologies are new, and expensive, and they can't be effective at solving the problem they set out to solve without mass adoption. Mass adoption won't even _begin_ to happen until the average person can pick up a used Model 3 for around $10k. Where populations heavily use mopeds and motorcycles we need a flood of affordable electric alternatives. Both of those scenarios are at least a decade out. If we need to solve this in 12 years we're screwed. Best bet is to move somewhere cold and inland. Then at least you can be somewhat comfortable while the whole thing goes down. Although the process of moving the world's economy away from oil (to whatever extent that can be achieved while still producing plastics etc.) is going to make life miserable no matter where you are.
- Comevius 8y agoElectric cars tend to put out less CO2 compared to gasoline cars only if you drive them for more than 5 years and don't replace the battery. https://www.ucsusa.org/sites/default/files/attach/2015/11/Cleaner-Cars-from-Cradle-to-Grave-full-report.pdf https://www.ucsusa.org/sites/default/files/attach/2015/11/Cl... And yes, 12 years is nothing. Countries could start replacing all cars with electric ones for free right now, CO2 would just go higher and higher. The answer to this environmental catastrophe is not manufacturing new cars. If we would have stopped buying and using cars 40 years ago... https://mayerhillman.com/transport/key-publications/ https://mayerhillman.com/transport/key-publications/
- roryisok 8y ago> Countries could start replacing all cars with electric ones for free right now, CO2 would just go higher and higher. How? I wish people would stop fixating on this magical 12 years figure. It's not a countdown. If we keep our current carbon emissions the same for 12 years we'll see 2 degrees of warming. If we do nothing. If we continue to do nothing after that point it doesn't stay at 2 degrees. It gets hotter and hotter, and the effects get worse and worse. If countries start replacing cars with electric ones for free now, and we still don't reach zero emissions in 12 years, we might see 2 degrees. But we might avoid 3 degrees, or 4 degrees. We don't have 12 years left and then game over. We have 12 years until things start to get really bad. And then the UN will come out and say we have 12 years left to act to avoid 3 degrees, and we'll all have these same fucking stupid arguments on the internet again in between news bulletins about famine and the various migrant crises.
- CSstefan 8y agoThere is a highly distributed plan. https://www.drawdown.org https://www.drawdown.org
- CSstefan 8y agoThere is a plan already in action... https://www.drawdown.org https://www.drawdown.org
- roryisok 8y agoThis is not a plan in action, it is a list of ideas
- pisteoff 8y agoPlant lots and lots of Azolla. Like a lot of it. In addition to all the other stuff that people talk about.
- tmaly 8y agoIf we could get fusion rolled out faster, or really try to invest in something like Thorium reactors and then drastically improve battery technology, we could substantially reduce the need for fossil fuels. It would also help if certain countries would not use CFCs that were banned due to the way they destroy the ozone.
- motiw 8y agoI think it is mostly a marketing challenge, once most people realize the risk, it will gain momentum and solutions will follow.
- super-serial 8y agoI've mentioned it here before, but my favorite is crushing and spreading olivine rocks: http://www.innovationconcepts.eu/res/literatuurSchuiling/olivineagainstclimatechange23.pdf http://www.innovationconcepts.eu/res/literatuurSchuiling/oli... It's a natural process and we just have to mine as many rocks as we dig up oil. We just need to catch up for the last few hundred years where we only dug up oil and no rocks. Just US $200 billion per year to offset all of humanity's carbon emissions. If I was a billionaire I'd already have started developing robots to mine and grind up rocks for accelerated weathering.
- halis 8y agoI feel that unless we make some major breakthroughs in atmospheric carbon capture in the next 30 years, we are going to be royally screwed.
- amanaplanacanal 8y agoHere is my take: Rich people in rich countries will pay what it takes to adapt to the changing climate. Poor people in poor countries are basically screwed, just like always. With some luck, the rich people in the rich countries will donate some of their excess wealth to help the poor people adapt too.
- bskinny129 8y agoGreat timing! I also believe it takes personal actions, not waiting on someone else. My personal pledge is to balance the negative impact of my driving and flying. If you are interested, check out the app I'm building for it: https://www.producthunt.com/upcoming/pledge-balance https://www.producthunt.com/upcoming/pledge-balance
- RaceWon 8y agoWe (USA) don't even do the little things that would add up: virtually every super market has wide open refrigerated sections. Every house built has No insulation on hot water piping (less so in commercial buildings but only because the architects get a percentage of the total job cost so they spec insulated Hot and Cold domestic water lines). Look at cars; anyone here make any solar powered products to keep cars warmer in winter and cooler in summer to reduce idling time to heat and cool the interiors for the occupants... NOPE no one does (a good business idea btw). Speaking of solar; why is my laptop plugged in right now (beside the fact that its a Dell and meh battery life)?... Oh yeah; IDK of any solar boosters that would either run it or at least help eliminate the drain... build that, market that. All these things would help. Are cows put into enclosures at night that capture and scrub the CO2 they emanate... NOPE they're not. These are just a few things based on my experience in the construction industry and casual observation. Let's buy some time until the issue can be solved in a financially viable way.
- flockonus 8y agoLivestock is responsible for a large fraction of grains (and therefore clean water) consumption, while emitting an equally large amount of CO2 and methane into atmosphere. So largely reducing animal intake would be of huge help. This large scale habit change don't require gov. aid, it can be tackled by for profit businesses and research institutions alike.
- pkrein 8y agoFor the past 40 years we've viewed climate change as a political problem (see "Losing Earth" from the NY Times for a history of this [1].) Like you, I no longer have any faith that politicians will be able to solve the problem. As the NYT research revealed, politicians generally only take on a cause when there is a viable solution... and frankly there isn't a great solution yet. Solar and wind help a good bit. Nuclear would be a fine option but as a society we are apparently uncomfortable with it... Our politicians don't really have a good enough, complete enough option. At Charm Industrial [2] we started with a different question that at first seems silly: is it possible to sequester carbon dioxide from the atmosphere at a profit? We assumed the answer would be no, but to our surprise we couldn't convince ourselves of that. We found a pathway (purpose-grown biomass --> gasification --> hydrocarbons + geological CO2 sequestration) that seems to have high-scale profit potential. And if you can be profitable, then effectively unlimited amounts of private capital are available. If you're interested in following our progress, you can subscribe to our newsletter here: https://charmindustrial.us18.list-manage.com/subscribe?u=aafd4c7577e4bc2bfc20baa47&id=3e4a6db592 https://charmindustrial.us18.list-manage.com/subscribe?u=aaf... And we'd love to see others tackle the problem from the perspective of high-scale, viable economics. Is it possible to sequester carbon dioxide from the atmosphere at a profit? [1]: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/08/01/magazine/climate-change-losing-earth.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/08/01/magazine/clim... [2]: https://www.charmindustrial.com/ https://www.charmindustrial.com/
- wglb 8y agoSo my thoughts are how this is a problem of a highly dynamic system. There has been this massive injection of CO2 that has pushed the chaotic system to a whole new cycle. So my question is what exactly is the right amount of change that won’t push the dynamical system to a point of even more instability. I haven’t seen any discussion about this. That also concerns me.
- ed_balls 8y ago- cycle to work, work from home, car pool in a plugin hybrid/electric car - improve the energy efficiency of your house (aircon, heating) - eat less beef - invest in solar panel/sun thermal collectors - pick train instead of a car for a trip - reduce waste and buying unnecessary stuff - Lobby for certain regulations like more charging stations for electric cars, more bike lanes, electric cars to use a bus lane, property tax that takes home energy efficiency into account
- giantsvseagles 8y agohttps://tvvspclive.de/giantsvseagles/ https://tvvspclive.de/giantsvseagles/ https://tvvspclive.de/giantsvseagles/ https://tvvspclive.de/giantsvseagles/ https://tvvspclive.de/giantsvseagles/ https://tvvspclive.de/giantsvseagles/ https://tvvspclive.de/giantsvseagles/ https://tvvspclive.de/giantsvseagles/ https://tvvspclive.de/giantsvseagles/ https://tvvspclive.de/giantsvseagles/ https://tvvspclive.de/giantsvseagles/ https://tvvspclive.de/giantsvseagles/
- poloolop 8y agoThere is no single silver bullet. One mechanism which can have lasting impact is applying William McDonough's "Cradle-to-Cradle" philosophy to large sectors. Apple seems to be trying to do that. It needs better support and awareness from consumers, to reward the corporations who deliver on these parameters.
- m1573rp34130dy 8y agocurrency should be somthing physically valuable, barrels of oil, metal ingots, first born, atmospheric oxygen etc. major educational overhaul that amounts to sedition is required, peoples ideals and aspirations must be re-tooled... civilization as a global whole must profoundly change... this seems to point at pockyclypse far and wide, with the subsequent social reordering... what sort of mythos needs to be promulgated in hopes of preventing a surviving culture from being so distracted and tunnel sighted as to screw it up all over again? the tesla tunnelings and others must continue, we wont make an easy transition and will have to rely on subterranean refuge. the tesla tunnels [et.al.] are not for today or tomorrow only, as they will persist into the future millenia...
- ace_of_spades 8y agoCampaign, advocate for and support clean meat as a viable alternative to conventional factory farmed animal products. Factory farming is one of the biggest source of carbon emissions worldwide and a switch to clean meat can – due to higher efficiency of the meat generation process – have a huge impact here. It’s just one aspect of a possible solution but one that is often overlooked. Steps you can do right now: If your skills are applicable in this area think about changing the industry or maybe consider donating to the Good Food Institute: https://www.gfi.org https://www.gfi.org.