6 ms·
>The thing about companies like Honda and GM -- they have a lot of momentum. That means they aren't likely to be on the forefront of innovation, but when they t
by dsfyu404ed 8y ago
>The thing about companies like Honda and GM -- they have a lot of momentum. That means they aren't likely to be on the forefront of innovation, but when they turn towards a new target, they will hit with massive resources and established global production capacity that a start-up can only dream of.
Exactly. It's the difference between a handful of dudes in a speedboat with some explosives and an aircraft carrier. Once the latter is aware of the former you can be reasonably assured who of will win. At most the former can hope to land a good sucker punch before the latter knows they're even fighting.
The core competency of GM, Honda, etc. is building cars. Once they decide what kind of cars they want to build they will do a good job building them as they intend to build them. They don't make rookie mistakes, especially in the logistics of spinning up production lines to build what they want to build. They've re-tool their factories every time a new generation or a new model comes out. They know how to do it right the first time, knowledge that comes from experience.
- leesec 8y agoThey are good at building cars, but I would argue they are not good at building tech. Self driving is a technology issue. If the tech superstars at Waymo/Apple/whoever aren't even close to solving it, why would the software people at GM/Honda be?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago"Hi, this Jane from the procurement department of GM North America. We might be interested in licensing your software. Please give me a call back so we can set up a meeting." They don't need to build tech. They can buy it. GM can write some pretty big checks. They flat out bought Cruise just to cover their butts. When I was an intern at a defense contractor ~1/10th the size of GM my cube was across from procurement. I think a lot of people here don't understand the kind of scale companies like this play at. Your problem isn't "how do we pay for this" it's "will anyone sell me all this all at once or sign a contract to provide it all over the timetable we want". You make bets on how many times around the earth the welding wire you'll buy next quarter will go. GM shipped ~10 million vehicles in 2017. That means they had to sign a contract with someone to supply approximately an Exxon Valdez worth of motor oil and another of ATF just for their factories.
- fastball 8y agoIsn't that exactly what a deal is? This wouldn't be a loss for Waymo if everyone was licensing their software.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- xiphias2 8y agoWaymo is far the best self driving tech and nobody has the money to buy it, as Alphabet is not selling (it's the first real diversification from ads revenue). GM is few years behind, but hopefully those few years are not enough for Waymo to create a monopoly.
- jplayer01 8y agoGM really isn't far behind.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- blackoil 8y agoSelf Driving is not only a technical problem, it will be a people/marketing/legal/political problem. By the time these will be solved, GM/Tesla/Toyota should have competing solutions.
- uluyol 8y agoExactly. Non-Waymo companies have the benefit of Google/Waymo taking care of many of these obstacles for them.
- mikejb 8y agoBut they have the problem of getting solutions adapted to Waymo's strategy. They'll likely push for safety tests and requirements that they can pass; others will have to adapt to that.
- Fricken 8y agoCruise Automation was cofounded by Kyle Vogt, a YC alum who cofounded, built Justin.TV, which became Twitch, and sold to Amazon for a billion dollars before starting Cruise with Daniel Kan, which was acquired in early 2016 by GM. It's a tech company. It employs it's share of tech superstars. Vogt himself participated in the Darpa challenges as a robotics undergrad at MIT, before dropping out to do Justin.TV.
- twblalock 8y agoThe only logical outcome is that the big car companies continue to build the majority of cars when (if) self-driving cars are ready for the mass market. Waymo is not going to build millions of cars a year like GM and Ford and Toyota. Big car companies can buy startups in the self driving space, which is what GM did with Cruise. Or they can license the software from Waymo or other companies who are working on it. Self-driving software can be just another thing car companies buy from suppliers, like transmissions and brakes.
- jacksmith21006 8y agoWaymo parent has over $100B in cash and less than $5B debt. Would expect they will just but a car company or at least a line. They are going to market with a robot taxi service. Shared commercial offering later this year in Arizona and then San Fran and mountain view. Alphabet does not do a dividend or need material buybacks to prop up share price.
- misterhtmlcss 8y agoI think you are oversimplifying. 'Tech' as a commonly applied label typically involves widgets and software. Not large manufacturing and supply chains that involves world trade, weather, regionalism, human resources in the hundreds of thousands and years of planning to work with many similarly configured partners. Tesla for all it's glory isn't the greatest endorsement for Tech as some (not necessarily you) like to claim and I like Tesla. Everyone that says car companies don't move fast seems to be picking and choosing the facts that suit their own bias towards 'traditional' industries. Car companies only look slow on the outside, but they really aren't when you look at the totality of their products scope. For example car companies go through millions of dollars in just testing alone with nearly every country operating their own testing center. They need to be weather tested in so many different environments, they need to meet regulatory hurdles that are different from state to state to State. It's just massive what goes into what they need to do just to get the right to sell their product in a region or country. Yet they do all this with significant upgrades to models that are now coming nearly every 3 years. I remember when it went from 10 years to 5 years. Wow! I remember when the assembly got so complicated that cars were squeaking due to the materials rubbing against each other. So in comes material science guys trying to get that sorted in all weather conditions. I think Waymo is far more likely to be in the sidelines than people think, but we'll see; I could be wrong.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoI fully agree. There's tons of stuff moving fast when you look on the inside. Everyone aware of what the cutting edge is in their field and working to implement that within their own little niche of responsibility. From the outside it's like watching a large military cargo plane. It's so big that it looks slow no matter how fast it's going. That said, GM (or any other BigCo) realizes when it doesn't have a capability and either decides to not pursue it, spin it up themselves internally (like in the case of EVs), license it, or buy someone who has it (e.g. Cruise). >I remember when the assembly got so complicated that cars were squeaking due to the materials rubbing against each other. So in comes material science guys trying to get that sorted in all weather conditions. Was that back when you could look at a picture of a Saturn and tell what temperature it was when the picture was taken? ;)
- forkandwait 8y agoThey are tech, just not silicon valley tech. More engineers per capita in Michigan etc.,etc.
- someguydave 8y agoI would vastly prefer to drive a car that's been tested by engineers in Michigan rather than the precious folk in Silicon Valley.
- wlesieutre 8y agoThe software people at GM aren't a part of GM's existing tech groups. They went and bought a (YC-backed) self-driving startup, Cruise Automation, to get this effort going. I think the combination of Cruise's expertise on self-driving tech combined with GM's on cars makes for a pretty serious competitor, assuming the two can work together effectively.
- fastbeef 8y ago>It's the difference between a handful of dudes in a speedboat with some explosives and an aircraft carrier. That’s uh... one helluva metaphor you got there.
- stevenwoo 8y agoIt's a somewhat infamous tactic used by a US leader in a war game simulation of war with a hypothetical mid east enemy (Iran of course), he used first a wave of cruise missiles, then a follow up attack of many small boats on suicide runs to overwhelm a carrier force (hypothetically) and won a two week planned exercise in one day, so the folks in charge re-ran the simulation and barred the tactics he used. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Millennium_Challenge_2002 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Millennium_Challenge_2002
- hef19898 8y agoTrue that, if could with the pants down a carrier is nothing more than a big target. There is alo an example (no source, sorry) of a German sub surfacing next to a US carrier, within the inner defense ring, suring an exercise. But all that only works of the carrier is caught flat footed. To stay in the metaphor, the carrier "automotive industry" is no longer flat footed. Partol aircraft and choppers are deployed and the defenses are up. By the way, I like that image, fits the business world much bettwr than the proverbial tanker vessel for big co.
- stevenwoo 8y agoSweden produces short range diesel electric subs that were able to sink a US carrier in a similar war game so the US Navy leased one to learn how to adapt to the previously unknown weakness. IIRC China was making these kinds of subs but they have pretty short range, compared to most attack subs. https://www.popularmechanics.com/military/navy-ships/a19784775/gotland-class-sub-ronald-reagan-war-games/ https://www.popularmechanics.com/military/navy-ships/a197847...
- bluGill 8y agoThe point of a simulation is to find vulnerabilities. When something works the correct thing is to rerun it with the assumption that you have mitigated that attack to see what your next vulnerability is. You of course also make sure the mitigation actually happens. Lawyers run practice trials all the time, if their opponent in practice comes up with an argument they can't destroy on the spot they know where they need to focus.
- nostrademons 8y agoThe thing is - self-driving cars fundamentally change the structure of the automobile market in a way that negates many of the advantages of existing automakers. Instead of private ownership of cars, they encourage ride-sharing services, because the car can pick up a different passenger on the return trip and no longer has to park. Instead of internal combustion engines, they encourage EVs, both because of the power-draw of the self-driving hardware and because refueling becomes the responsibility of the service, which can program them to return to base and not pick up any new passengers once they're getting low on charge. Instead of servicing being a huge pain that encourages buyers to put a premium on reliable cars, maintenance is handled by a centralized maintenance department full of professionals. Instead of family cars, they encourage small motorcycle-like "pods" sized for a single occupant (with a smaller number of family cars or trucks available for family trips). Already, that negates the advantages of consumer brand, reliability, dealer networks, internal combustion engines, ergonomics, and bodywork. There's not all that much left to the auto industry, once all that changes.
- hef19898 8y agoEven if you are right with everything you predicted (some of it, all of it is doubtfull), that does not negate the core competencies of traditional car makers. You still need someone to buold cars -> existing car makers EVs are actually easier to built than EVs -> inceeasing the advantage they have on production Maintenance -> to be done locally, there is no way to centralize it on a full continent, car makers and their existing network are king Fleet management -> see above, plus existing fleet mgt serives, only real competition are large rental car companies Ride sharing -> acquisitions, mytaxi in the case of Mercendes, drivenow and car2go in the case of Mercedes and BMW, VW with an in-house solution Self-driving -> acquisition of the provider (GM and Cruise) or sourcing the tech, alternative is a partnership (Jaguar) Traditional car makers slept into these developments, a few years ago I would have bet a lot on disruptors in that industry. Now that changed, the only "tech" (as in software) companies that can compete are the likes of Google and maybe Uber as long as VC money doesn't run out. The same is true for certain smaller manufacturers of automobiles, but this market cleaning is gling on for while now so they are used to it. And let's fave it, the automotive sector is well entrenched in politics (Europe, Japan and the US, Chine, too) and money generally is not a rwal problem. So, yeah, now I would say Google / Wymo might become a major Tier one supplier. But hardly more.
- barrkel 8y agoFWIW, Honda builds more two-wheeled vehicles (scooters and motorcycles) than it does cars. About 19 million motorcycles a year vs about 5 million cars. Their core competency is probably engines, especially small engines. They make more engines than anyone else globally. (I agree with your point generally on momentum. Just saying because I was somewhat surprised to learn it.)