5 ms·
It's not as complicated as people are making it. Look at the history of civilization and the history of reserve currencies. When Britain had the reserve curre
by ilaksh 8y ago
It's not as complicated as people are making it.
Look at the history of civilization and the history of reserve currencies. When Britain had the reserve currency, how did we describe that? It was called the British Empire. When Spain had the reserve currency, what did we call that? It was called the Spanish Empire. Go back for thousands of years, the history of reserve currencies is the history of empires.
Until, supposedly, we get to this great break in history with America's dominance. Which supposedly is not an empire but is based on some superior ideology or system. Is it not remarkable that up until now history was one way, and now the age of empires has gone away. And only America's luck, or ideology, or democracy, or some technical economic bullshit has supposedly created the massive advantages for America and American citizens.
There has not been a break with history. The United States is the most dominant, powerful, and yes brutal Empire the world has ever seen. Reserve currency status has been maintained by rigorous continuous ongoing military campaigns involving both overt, covert and financial means. Libya is one extremely obvious example.
The question is not something like, are we being nice enough, or are we 'leading the world'. The question is can and will any group really take geopolitical action against this domination by force? If and when they think that it is safe enough to do so then they will.
- matwood 8y ago> If and when they think that it is safe enough to do so then they will. Which is exactly why the US should and will continue to project power all over the world. What you're really saying is that given a power vacuum, other countries will try to step in. Are there any other countries you would prefer to be projecting power?
- ilaksh 8y agoI would prefer that we make an effort to transition to a sane world. Even though it is very unlikely, the goal should still be a fair and safe planet. Its hard to speculate, but the next situation may not be controlled by a particular country per se. It may be some AI blockchain distributed political system that goes through an app that becomes popular in China but the Chinese government hates it. I think general purpose AI and distributed technologies will factor into geopolitics in some major way. Possibly. Aside from the speculation, I do know that we're not going to get into a better situation if we keep bullshitting ourselves about what's really going on.
- emodendroket 8y agoWhat if we actually tried to follow through on the multipolar vision that the UN is supposed to represent, rather than paying lip service to it and seeking world domination? How much do you think your personal safety is threatened by, say, the Houthis?
- legulere 8y agoThe US dollar and many other international currencies are named after the Joachimsthaler, which were printed by the counts Schlik of Sankt Joachimsthal/Jáchymov, and became so important to have several currencies named after them. But there was no empire.
- pigscantfly 8y agoHow do you square the assertion that nothing has meaningfully changed in recent times with the availability of information, education, travel/cultural exchange, disposable income now versus all of history? And in what way do you see the putative 'American Empire' as more brutal than the Soviet Union (for example)?
- pkhagah 8y agoBut, are the meaningful changed regarding information, education etc. caused by US or inspite of US? Technology and Science improving tremendously in 20th century had more to do with these changes. I would say WWI and WWII caused more of these technology and travel being available.
- i_made_a_booboo 8y agoHuman nature is remarkably constant.
- gowld 8y agoHow does this analysis explain all the wars and international influence initiated by countries that are NOT the USA? (for examples: Russia->{Georgia, Ukraine, Turkey}, China->{North Korea, African countries}, Saudi Arabia -> Yeme, Sudan civil war, Germany->Greece)
- emodendroket 8y agoI don't know why it has to? There are various regional powers South local spheres of influence, but there is only one global hegemon. And many of your examples did involve substantial US involvement (for instance, Saudi Arabia's campaign against Yemen could not continue without US support, and China entered the Korean War because Americans fought all the way through the Korean Peninsula up to their border... I'm not going to pick apart every single one here unless you think it would be instructive).
- friedman23 8y agoI have to roll my eyes Just this statement > and yes brutal Empire the world has ever seen shows how little knowledge you have of history. How anyone can say the US is the most brutal empire the world has ever seen when not even 100 years ago the Belgian Congo existed is beyond me. These "tyranny of the US dollar" articles always bring out the worst conspiracy theorists. The US dollar is the most popular currency simply because the US is an extremely stable country. Few countries exist that have had the same government for more than 200 years. No countries exist that have similar clout to the US and have had a stable government for 200 years. When you trade something for US dollars you know exactly what you are getting. An asset that will depreciate at a fairly consistent 2% every year. Few currencies can claim that.
- ilaksh 8y agoNagasaki is the most obvious example. But see the effects of bombing in general. EDIT: oh how silly of me to think that atomic weapons would be considered brutal. It is true that such action had to be rationalized in order to support a fictional world in which America rules by virtue rather than deadly force.
- friedman23 8y ago> Nagasaki is the most obvious example The most obvious example of what exactly? Are you going to give comparisons to other atrocities that show that the US is the worst and most brutal empire in history? Also how does "Nagasaki" even qualify as imperial activity? >EDIT: oh how silly of me to think that atomic weapons would be considered brutal. You claimed the US was the most brutal empire in history not that the bombing of Nagasaki was brutal...
- ThrowawayR2 8y ago> Nagasaki is the most obvious example. But see the effects of bombing in general. It's hard to take that as a serious argument for US imperialism since that particular war wasn't even started by the US.
- outside1234 8y ago
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 8y ago> and yes brutal Empire the world has ever seen More brutal than the Assyrian Empire and the Mongol Empire? 5% of the world's population is estimated to have been killed by the Mongol conquests. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Destruction_under_the_Mongol_Empire https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Destruction_under_the_Mongol_E... and even in absolute numbers, the Mongol Conquest is only behind WWII in absolute numbers of people killed. The United States has its moral issues, but being the most brutal empire in history is not one of them. In fact, of all the global empires in the history of the world, the United States "Empire" has probably been the most benign and benefited the most people. Also remember, at the end of WWII, the United States was the sole possessor of the atomic bomb and had the best developed long range bomber fleet. They could have easily used that advantage to outright conquer a massive empire, but they did not.
- ilaksh 8y ago> sole possessor of the atomic bomb which they did use to kill more people at one time then ever before in history
- rmah 8y agoThat is factually incorrect.
- emodendroket 8y agoI think this kind of comparison is silly, but the US has been at war essentially non-stop since WWII and carries out overt and covert military action in scores of countries every year. We're currently bombing seven countries. We've also empowered numerous client states as they slaughtered their domestic opposition or regional rivals and armed various violent rebel groups in the hopes that they'd overthrow unfriendly governments. Sanctions, a de rigeur form of punishment against hostile governments, is specifically intended to gin up internal unrest by subjecting civilians to privation, and they literally kill people (especially children). I'm not sure we can call it the most violent ever to have existed, but the least violent seems like a stretch.
- Bendingo 8y ago
- emodendroket 8y agoIn fact, the post-war US leadership were proud that they were, as they saw it, taking up the mantle of Anglo-Saxon world rule from Britain.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- i_made_a_booboo 8y agoBingo.