15 ms·
A bipartisan plan to end surprise ER bills
- vidanay 8y agoIt's a decent start, but it doesn't really do a whole lot for "transparency", it simply caps the charges against some completely unknown and somewhat arbitrary number.
- djrogers 8y agoThe important point for patients is that those charges - capped or not - would no longer be directly billed; instead the insurance companies would be responsible for paying them.
- MBCook 8y agoHopefully the insurance companies would demand some transparency. At least when it comes to ERs transparency isn’t exactly useful. Most people don’t have time to go shopping around between them, all transparency does this let you know you’re being billed $1700 for a Band-Aid instead of billing code B736.21. This clearly isn’t a fix to the problems of the healthcare industry, but it certainly sounds like a nice step up. While I understand the logistics behind it, the idea that you can go to a place, pay your bill, then have eight different people bill you for the same service just feels like an absolute scam. Yes, one was the doctor, one was the lab, one was the hospital etc. and they may work for different companies and even in different buildings it’s just that they all HAPPENED to be in that one building that one day if that one time. But you don’t go to a restaurant and get separate bills from the establishment and the waiter and the cook and the group which buys ingredients. “We couldn’t have told you how much that Caesar salad would have cost, it depends on complex negotiations with your dietitian. Had it been at least 30 days since your last consumption of Californian arugula?”
- subhobroto 8y ago> At least when it comes to ERs transparency isn’t exactly useful. Most people don’t have time to go shopping around between them, all transparency does this let you know you’re being billed $1700 for a Band-Aid instead of billing code B736.21. Exactly! I link to an answer I wrote about this here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18108870 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18108870 Direct link: https://www.quora.com/Would-a-completely-free-market-healthcare-system-with-zero-government-involvement-and-no-subsidies-for-anyone-work-better-in-the-long-run https://www.quora.com/Would-a-completely-free-market-healthc...
- nradov 8y agoInsurance companies do have negotiated prices with all their network providers for all applicable billing codes. And insurers do often provide those numbers to their plan members, at least partially. The trouble is that you can't always know in advance which billing code a provider will actually submit on the claim, and some providers are out of network without negotiated prices.
- hakfoo 8y ago>The trouble is that you can't always know in advance which billing code a provider will actually submit on the claim, That seems like the billing system itself is conceptually faulty. Like a supermarket where the same gallon of milk costs different prices depending on which shelf you took it off of.
- nradov 8y agoFor a given customer, the "gallon of milk" costs the same regardless of which shelf it comes from. But if you come in to buy milk and end up buying champagne instead the price will be different. Billing amounts are calculated based on specific unique procedure and modifier codes. The coding is typically done by trained coders using the doctor's notes as a reference, and the coders select the most expensive codes that they can legally justify. Many doctors aren't even aware of their billing rates for various procedures. In some cases the doctor won't know which specific procedures will be needed until she gets into it and sees what's going on, at which point it's too late for price estimates. Payers (insurers) are trying to fix the billing system by moving away from the fee-for-service model and toward value-based care (payment for meeting care quality goals) or various forms of capitation (flat payment per patient per year regardless of which procedures are needed).
- Nasrudith 8y agoIt is essentially a "don't be a complete dick" statistical cap. Whenever you hear somebody complaining about excessive regulations remember all of the other cases that resulted against past antisocial behavior like that.
- arkades 8y ago> The policy proposal, which you can read here, essentially bars out-of-network doctors from billing patients directly for their care. Instead, they would have to seek payment from the insurance plan. This would mean that in the cases above, the out-of-network doctors couldn’t send those big bills to the patients, who’d be all set after paying their emergency room copays. I do love "sensible policy changes" that work by extracting money from physicians to cover patient bills rather than actually fixing the systemic dysfunction. If you're the surgeon to hand, you don't get to refuse to do emergency surgery. You have to take care of that patient, ethically and legally. Oh, turns out they're out of network, and their insurer isn't obligated to give you a dime? Awesome, free surgery! Here's a sensible solution: when it comes to emergency-based care, insurers must accept all comers as in-network. There's no such thing as "out of network" emergency-related care. But hey, insurers have powerful leverage and a near-monopoly. What're the odds we'd take a slice off their profit margin?
- godzillabrennus 8y agoPeople should demand an end to private insurers. Makes zero send to have middle men who profit off denying care.
- whatshisface 8y agoThe balance sheets of public insuers would also benefit from denying care.
- lutorm 8y agoHow about everyone gets to bill through the hospital instead of every person who tangentially heard of you one way or another sending you their own bill. If the hospital is in-network, they bill based on in-network rates, and all those "providers" can take up their bill with the hospital (who at least knows they're there, unlike the patient).
- smelendez 8y agoThis seems like a reasonable solution. It's basically how we handle telecom and utility billing.
- MBCook 8y agoHell, it’s how we handle restaurant billing.
- nraynaud 8y agolet's talk about the tip again?
- mcny 8y agoIf it is mandatory, it is not a tip. My old boss told me how he was at a dinner with our Australian overlords (long story) and they said nobody will leave any tip. If a tip is mandatory, it is a service charge. I don't go to the extreme of never tipping but I usually do not tip if the bill has an itemized service charge. Services that are "out of network" are not optional. (warning: may make you angry) https://www.nytimes.com/2014/09/21/us/drive-by-doctoring-surprise-medical-bills.html https://www.nytimes.com/2014/09/21/us/drive-by-doctoring-sur... (2014) archive fo: https://archive.fo/TBmrO https://archive.fo/TBmrO screenshot https://screenshotscdn.firefoxusercontent.com/images/adb38500-3a76-4648-985d-c2059221d966.jpg https://screenshotscdn.firefoxusercontent.com/images/adb3850...
- jjeaff 8y ago
- jlg23 8y agoAs a German who had to take US-americans to the ER twice, once in Germany, once on Curacao, my observation can be summarized as "WTF?". In both cases the patient initially refused treatment out of fear to receive a high bill. Both bills ended up being about 50 USD (a few stitches in the first case, lab analysis to confirm it were kidney stones in the second case). In the first case, the patient's spouse told me not to worry, it ain't too bad. But she would stay with him to make sure he does not fall unconscious ("uhm.. ok...."; I got a taxi to pick them up for a trip to the ER); in the second case I ate my dinner while watching the guy scream in pain - being a doctor's child helps with that .. he finally agreed to let me take him to the ER. Dear US-americans doctors, you lost me. Where again was the exit ethics took during your education?
- 0xB31B1B 8y agoThe doctors don’t create the bills, or even really influence billing. The billing issues are caused by hospital administrators who are mostly MBAs or Policy masters, and they’re negotiating with MBAs in insurance companies.
- ChristianBundy 8y agoDo you think that the doctors or hotel administrators have more power?
- scarejunba 8y agoThe AMA isn't even just complicit. It is pretty nearly a cause. There's plenty of blame to go around and doctors are not passive participants in the process.
- subhobroto 8y agoExcellent! This is action. Not the best action (more below) but anything else is wildly better than the situation we have in the current U.S. Healthcare system Change needs to happen to the U.S. Healthcare system so that surprise billings just stop. This change is not going to happen on its own without people driving change. The issue at hand is that Healthcare costs in the U.S. are all over the place. Same place, same doctor, same procedure on the same person on the same day can yield massively different invoices depending on whether the person is insured, where they work, what kind of insurance they carry! Hospitals wield a lot more power than you and I would guess. An example: https://www.publicintegrity.org/2015/06/15/17474/profit-hospitals-mark-prices-more-1000-percent-because-theres-nothing-stop-them https://www.publicintegrity.org/2015/06/15/17474/profit-hosp... As a person who's extremely passionate about driving change in the U.S. Healthcare system, I communicate a lot with people who have fallen on hard times due to an enormous medical bill. Here are two scenarios for you: https://www.quora.com/Recently-my-husband-visited-the-ER-in-the-US-due-to-almost-bleeding-out-were-citizens-and-have-insurance-The-bill-is-24-000-USD-We-do-not-have-that-kind-of-money-What-can-we-do https://www.quora.com/Recently-my-husband-visited-the-ER-in-... https://www.quora.com/Why-did-the-doctor-charge-me-3600-hr-to-drain-my-swollen-elbow https://www.quora.com/Why-did-the-doctor-charge-me-3600-hr-t... When people ask me what I think is "wrong" with the health care in the USA, my answer surprises them: Nothing is wrong with the health care in the USA. It is one of the very best in the world for those who can afford it. The issue is that one should not have to look unexpectedly to a life completely ruined because they suddenly fell sick or got into an accident - they should be able to pick up their lives when they need to do it the most and go on from there. My hypothesis is that a system where everyone pays the same rate regardless of whether they are insured or not would head us off to a much better direction. I invite your feedback on: https://www.quora.com/Would-a-completely-free-market-healthcare-system-with-zero-government-involvement-and-no-subsidies-for-anyone-work-better-in-the-long-run https://www.quora.com/Would-a-completely-free-market-healthc... https://www.quora.com/In-the-US-the-majority-of-people-under-65-years-old-have-health-insurance-through-their-employers-What-is-the-logic-behind-tying-health-insurance-to-an-employer/answer/Subhobroto-Sinha-1 https://www.quora.com/In-the-US-the-majority-of-people-under...
- Spooky23 8y agoTwo things are the core problems IMO. Defacto price controls and cartel like business processes.
- arcticbull 8y agoStop applying duct tape to a ridiculous system. Its time to offer a public option like every other country in the OECD. That’s how you solve this. This is sheer stupidity all the way down. How are so few of you mad as hell getting the worst deal in the OECD? I’m mad for you. It’s like watching someone hit themselves in the face with bare knuckles, stop and say you know what this needs? Boxing gloves, then it won’t hurt as much. Like, you’re right, it won’t hurt as much, but why are you doing this to yourself? Either this is a free market and we allow the market to sort this out, allowing people to die and go broke in the process, or we say this is a public good that deserves a public solution. A whack-a-mole based patchwork of legal impositions on the market is not a solution to anything. It just encourages the captains of the insurance industry to find the next loophole to exploit (or go out and create them by lobbying) to ensure profits keep going up quarter over quarter, until they’re whacked back down again. Then in 6-18 months were right back where we started.
- Gibbon1 8y agoWe used to have a free market and it sucked. So they took the worst part of it and slapped a national insurance program over it and that's Medicare. And now 50 years later the rest of the market sucks.
- ericd 8y agoHow about a law stating that a medical provider has to charge everyone the same price for the same service? This would eliminate the many-to-many negotiation problem that contributes to absurdities like Duke University Hospital having 1,300 billing clerks for 900 beds (https://www.pbs.org/newshour/economy/why-does-health-care-cost-so-m https://www.pbs.org/newshour/economy/why-does-health-care-co...). It would also make it much easier to estimate costs before going to a provider, because instead of having 1000 different prices, that service will have one price (albeit with some variability depending on what's actually done). If you paired it with a law that mandated that hospitals publish their prices for services in a simple JSON format, such that companies could use it freely to create price comparison tools, suddenly you'd make it much easier for market forces to push prices down to sane levels. It's insane how difficult it is currently to figure out how much even routine and planned operations like delivering a child will cost, and as a result people don't bother to even try, so there's no incentive for hospitals to keep their list prices anywhere near the realm of sanity.
- rsynnott 8y agoI mean, realistically, probably because the industry lobbyists don’t care for the idea. It is completely obvious as a (partial) solution, and isn’t even really anti-market, so should be acceptable to all sides of the POLITICAL spectrum. But the industry wouldn’t like it very much.
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoThe industry isn't going to like anything that works.
- rsynnott 8y agoSo, ban or severely restrict lobbying and corporate donations. I mean, it’s not like this is some absurd pie-in-the-sky idea; most developed democracies restrict both.
- maxerickson 8y agoSo everyone pays Medicaid prices? Medicare prices?
- Crontab 8y agoRadiologist and anesthesiologists are the vultures of the healthcare industry - they are often out of network and they hide behind the scenes at hospitals and outpatient surgery centers.
- plink 8y agoThe anesthesiologist for a family member's out patient tonsillectomy was the sole out of network component in the procedure. When they remonstrated that we should have known, I responded that maybe we should have checked if the orderly, the valet, et cetera was in-network.
- Gibbon1 8y agoI remember one doctor carping that the highest paid doctor at UCSF is a radiologist who works 9-5 and never deals with any patients face to face. Tip: Never use a hospitals radiology services if you can help it.
- mberning 8y agoCare in the US is quite good, but the billing is the most opaque thing imaginable. I went in for a skin biopsy and got a bill from 3 different people. Why? I don't take my car to the shop and get a bill from 3 other shops in town. Ridiculous. I really think the onus should be on the provider to issue a single bill and provide up front pricing.
- paulie_a 8y agoI received a bill 9 months after a procedure. After I had already received a dozen other bills for various other services pretty much immediately and paid immediately. My nuanced argument was "you waited 9 months, fuck off". I never heard anything more about that one.
- JonathonW 8y ago100% agreed here-- on a HDHP (the only option from my employer) and recently had a diagnostic procedure done at an ambulatory surgical facility. Paid the surgical facility up front; later got a separate bill for two separate additional fees from the doctor and from the anesthesiologist (billed together because they're part of the same group, fortunately). And there was no way for me to tell how much any of this would cost me up front, while I was scheduling the procedure. Would it have been cheaper to have it done elsewhere? I dunno; no way to tell.
- InclinedPlane 8y ago> "Care in the US is quite good" Well, now there's a classic example of survivorship bias. Care in the US is good when you can get it, but on average? On average care is quite bad. When you bring in the millions of people with no health insurance into the averages then the picture looks quite a lot less rosy. Things are so bad that there is a multi-decade differential in life expectancy between the top 20% and the bottom 20%. That is absolutely unconscionable.
- TuGuQuKu 8y agoFuck the "bipartisan plan". M4A now.
- SilentM68 8y agoI have not read through the entire article, so don't know if what I'll state is covered, however, I have experienced something similar with Kaiser, though not with ER, but with regular Doctor's visits. They just send me a surprise from time to time, and the latest one is $175.00 for a visit. This is, literally, something that just keeps happening. Somebody on their end messes up, or somebody does some sort of funny business, and patients get unforeseen bills. I wish somebody would investigate them and force them to get their act together. I mean it's convenient that they have all facilities in one place, but they are really expensive and their billing practices are inconsistent.
- qwerty456127 8y ago> So far, things have turned out fine — I’ve only been billed a $150 copayment for my ER trip... Copayment should be eliminated too. Paying for an insurance I want to be sure that if something happens to me I don't have to worry about anything, even about having spare $150.
- BurningFrog 8y agoCopayments are essential to keep bored and lonely people from going to the doctor every day for nothing in particular. AFAIK, only the UK has a zero copayment system among the government run health care systems.
- qwerty456127 8y agoIn the Czech Republic copay is optional (depends on the insurance company and the plan, not really widespread, the majority of people don't have copay) and nobody seems to be misusing this. You can also just buy insurance that is going to cover almost everything (and with no copay) for reasonable money without even having a job (if you actually have a job the insurance costs you and the employer a fixed percent of your salary). Some times the laws change (just to get changed back some years after) and compulsory copay gets introduced but it always is just ~$1 (which would be enough to repel bored grannies and homeless alcoholics that just want to hang out if there actually were any, but in fact there don't seem to be any actually misusing hospitals). Hospitals don't look and feel as fancy and cozy as they do in the USA and a stationary patients' diet is a disaster from the dietary value point of view but in every other aspect everything works amazing.
- BurningFrog 8y agoSo it sounds like the Czech Republic has some kind of private health insurance system?
- qwerty456127 8y agoAll (AFAIK) the health insurance companies in the Czech Republic are private (public actually, but not state-owned) corporations that are regulated heavily but in a very reasonable client-oriented and a little bit socialistic way. Every person is legally obliged to have a paid health insurance but the coverage is the same while the cost is a fixed percent of their income to be paid on monthly basis so poor people pay less and get the same service. People that don't have legal regular local income (e.g. foreign students) must buy insurance approximately the same way tourists do when traveling abroad (everybody else can also go and do this and it's as easy as buying a cellphone subscription, that's almost a free market).
- anon7429 8y agoNon-Americans may not realize: In America, going to the ER, it's possible and often happens that someone can be billed any random, unlimited amount for 10 seconds of interaction: $3,150 for "consultation." Yes. Heck, you don't even need to be seen to be billed. As soon as they collect personal information, despite not being seen, they can and do still try to bill you randomly regardless. One ER in the Bay Area has a security guard whose job it is to collect Social Security or tax identifiers from people before they can speak to anyone in the hospital.
- thomasfedb 8y agoIn Australia ED is free, paid for by state governments. We spend ~10% of GDP on healthcare, the US spends 18%. We have a private system, but it has to compete with free, and that's stiff competition.
- DeonPenny 8y agoThanks god. I hate this so much