6 ms·
Begging pardon, but is this not the wrong group of people to ask this question? Shouldn't we be asking women who didn't pursue computer science, not women who
by dnautics 8y ago
Begging pardon, but is this not the wrong group of people to ask this question? Shouldn't we be asking women who didn't pursue computer science, not women who did?
- onion2k 8y agoYou didn't read the article. The women are responding to an essay about why women don't want to code. As women who do want to code they're exactly the right people to ask.
- close04 8y agoThey’re the perfect women to ask why they chose to code. Because obviously their reasons not to code weren’t enough to stop them so presumambly not too strong.
- dkersten 8y agoIf you want to get more women to code, asking the ones who already cide why they code doesn’t seem as useful as asking the ones that don’t why they don’t.
- close04 8y agoWhich is exactly what I said... These women can say why they do code. They have no good reason or explanation on why women wouldn’t code. If they had one they’d have another job.
- dkersten 8y agoYes agreed, they are the perfect people to ask why they do — but bad people to ask why others don’t. I’m just saying that imho to get more people you need to ask a lot of the people who don’t why not and not just the people that do why they do.
- close04 8y agoThat’s literally what I said. That they’re good to explain why they code, not so much to explain why other women don’t. So the article is great to justify the passion for coding you already have. I’d rather see some explanations from women who chose not to code. That helps with understanding where the blockage is. Something must have been lost in translation...
- jolmg 8y agoI haven't read the article, but from your comment it doesn't seem dnautics misunderstood anything. > The women are responding to an essay about why women don't want to code. As women who do want to code they're exactly the right people to ask. How are they "exactly the right people to ask"? They're the exact opposite! Can you see the backwards logic in your comment? If you want to know why someone's doing or not doing something, ask them, not the people who chose opposite.
- onion2k 8y agoThe original essay that the article is a response to states "Women don't want to code." This article is about how that hypothesis is wrong. It proves that it's wrong by talking to women who do want to code, thereby demonstrating the original essay is incorrect. You couldn't prove such a hypothesis wrong by talking to women who don't want to code.
- naasking 8y agoThe original essay made a statistical claim, that most women don't want to code, ie. that 80/20 is a natural gender equilibrium of those actually interested in CS. It was not universal claim that no women want to code. Therefore this article is not a rebuttal.
- DenverCoder009 8y agoThe original essay states that some women want to code, but only enough to make up 20% of the CS workforce, and that the author believes this isn't a result of discrimination. You can't disprove that hypothesis by talking to women who do want to code. The argument at hand is if the 20% representation level is a result of discrimination and bias in the field, or something else.
- geebee 8y agoI think both questions are relevant. So while I do agree that we should hear from women and men who considered and rejected pursuing computer science, I am also interested in hearing from women who did pursue computer science.
- blihp 8y agoThey are definitely a group worth talking to as they can speak first-hand to the difficulties they had getting/staying in the field despite having a strong desire to be there/here. Understanding at least some of what they felt they were up against should make clear the most obvious obstacles that need to be cleared.
- Someguywhatever 8y ago>to the difficulties they had getting/staying in the field despite having a strong desire to be there/here Why isn't it ok that they just aren't interested in it? Women have agency and intelligence and if they want to do something then they can and will do it. I find this whole obsession with "Women in X" to be suspicious because nobody is interested in gender disparities in other fields and starting up "Men in X". So it's not a generic effort to understand a gender disparity, it is a specific directed effort to force women (who have agency and freedom) to go into a field that they don't really seem that interested in. Blaming men for women not taking CS degrees either directly or indirectly IMO denies womens agency and is totally unnecessary. I think women are doing what they want to do, and they largely don't want to take CS it seems. Maybe if society stopped nagging them about it the situation might change organically.
- blihp 8y agoIt's perfectly fine for women not to be interested in CS or any other field. There's probably a nature/nurture argument to be made for some of the disparity but that doesn't explain all of it. For example, one of the women in the article referenced a boss commenting about her breasts, another talked about being encouraged to drop out so a more deserving man could take her place... that's not lack of interest, that's actively discouraging those who want to be here. Can any men here seriously recall in a professional context a boss referring to their 'package'? Or that they should leave the field so that some more deserving woman could take their place? To me, that's a problem. If a woman doesn't want to be in a field, sure that's their choice. If they're actively discouraged from it, that's a problem. I've been in more than one professional situation where I was made uncomfortable with how a co-worker or manager was referring to female candidates/co-workers. I'm not talking about good-natured joking around on the job or even flirting, but rather something that in retrospect I can honestly say was discrimination. I also recall that in those situations, I was in no position to do anything about it so it's not like speaking up would have helped... more likely I would have been shortly out of a gig myself.
- lph 8y agoThank you for this live demonstration of how to dismiss the opinions of women in CS. I assume you were doing this ironically.
- jolmg 8y agoThis comment is an excellent example of the kind of thing that causes disrespect for the feminist movement. It's totally counterproductive. If anything, dnautics's comment is in favor of feminism by improving the study. In order to get more women into CS, it would be more valuable to know the reasons of the women that didn't apply, rather than the reasons guessed by the women that did.
- dnautics 8y agothank you, that was my intent.
- volkk 8y agoI dont think the logic here is to assume that OP is dismissing the argument simply because they're women. I think OP just means that because they're already in the field, their opinions and viewpoints are very different from people who went in different directions in their life. One quote from the article is Anna Karlin's where she says "Hence, when they get to college, fewer of the women have been exposed to the excitement of CS," and just that sentence alone is enough to show the bias there. I think we can gather that CS isn't inherently exciting except to a specific sort of person hence why most people choose not to pursue it. I would personally rather hear viewpoints from women who were on the border in college choosing their major or even girls in high school. I want to hear their mindset, not necessarily someone who assumes what others may think.
- 666lumberjack 8y agoI think the best people to be ask would be women who've left CS, either at undergrad level or after being employed for some period of time.
- stcredzero 8y agoI dated a woman for 9 years who has a Masters degree and who certainly can code. She just finds coding to be tedious and could never imagine doing that as a job. My wife has a PhD, an MBA, and is working on another higher degree. She can also code, but she also finds coding to be tedious and tells me she feels sorry for me in my coding job, because she can't imagine how I could feel otherwise. One of my female Computer Science professors used to brag about how she didn't code.
- Paul-ish 8y ago> One of my female Computer Science professors used to brag about how she didn't code. It's not uncommon for academics to stop coding at some point in their career. They basically become managers.
- stcredzero 8y agoIt wasn't that. She was one of those Comp Sci == specialized discrete math people.
- swingline-747 8y agoBTDTBTTS. I know the overachiever psyche a bit too well. Last female unit spoke five languages and was serious about opera and poetry. Personally, I much prefer females of the English or business depts to most engineers or scientists... sorry most of HN, I work and live better with wilder ones. I'll turn my enginerding creds in at the door. Anywho, It's a dangerous topic to compare men to women, the SJWs love to make an example out of anyone with external genetalia that's not in a protected group with something usually of the form "it's men keeping women down with bias, assumptions and force." This is usually followed by statements of equality (literal, numeric group parity) rather than equity (parity for the individual's particular needs and desires). If the idea is to push girls into computer science at every opportunity whom don't want to, while simultaneously short-changing boys, that seems unfair. I can see not assuming stereotypes about anyone. Boys want to cook or knit, girls want to code, weld or rebuild engines, very cool... whomever can do whatever, all Kosher and good. What about the absence of boys to girls ratio in academia? You never hear that talked about by feminsts (except maybe Camille Paglia)... maybe because the majority of modern feminism is inherently sexist. Gasp! Slay the unbeliever! Anyhow, I hope more boys and girls try coding, machining, robotics, chemistry, physics, painting, baking and so on and do it if they want to, rather than being hearded into it like one more multitalented, performing-monkey "prodigy" class like piano, tap, violin, etc.
- bongo662 8y agoAlso, could asking men in computer science why they didn't choose an female dominated industry shed any light on the issue as well? Might shed some light on the issue from a different perspective but I think it would leave out some externalities that women face that men do not.