14 ms·
Automakers working to transform data from cars into secondary revenue streams
- voltagex_ 8y ago"The automaker is executed tests of some 90,000 drivers across the Chicago and Los Angeles areas from November 2017 through to January 2018 after those drivers gave permission for their data to be processed in this manner."
- dawnerd 8y agoHow was the permission gathered? If it’s anything like what Toyota does then it’s a mailer that you must respond to to opt out.
- GoodDreams 8y agoHyundai wouldn’t let me buy a car without agreeing to data collection.
- bachmeier 8y agoSo how does that work if you sell the car? They'd be tracking the new owner without permission.
- NullPrefix 8y agoIt could be in the original agreement that if you sell the car, you can only sell to someone who also agrees to being spied on. I mean, they could try putting the onus on the seller.
- bachmeier 8y agoThey could try, but ultimately Hyundai is spying without permission. Hyundai could sue the original owner for damages that arise from not being able to spy, but I'm guessing they'd go ahead and keep spying when they shouldn't. The original owner can't be held responsible for that.
- notyourday 8y agoDon't buy Hyundai.
- fsfsfa 8y agoThat could have been for crash reconstruction black box. Which will be (is??) federally mandated now. For a while VW (and the Germans) were the only holdouts.
- automoton1 8y agoWas the car so good that you couldn't find another one that didn't collect your data?
- jhayward 8y agoI'd like to see the IRB report, and the human studies application, and the informed consent form for this study.
- voltagex_ 8y agoI can only find one other source for this news and there's no press releases that I can find. Perhaps someone with access to advertising trade journals could dig something up? https://www.warc.com/newsandopinion/news/general_motors_generates_new_radio_advertising_insights/41073 https://www.warc.com/newsandopinion/news/general_motors_gene... won't load for me. Edit: got it - http://gmauthority.com/blog/2018/09/gm-studies-drivers-radio-listening-habits-for-new-ad-insights/ http://gmauthority.com/blog/2018/09/gm-studies-drivers-radio... - The automaker’s director/global digital transformation, Saejin Park, said at the Association of National Advertisers’ (ANA) 2018 Data & Measurement Conference that the new insights can help serve up better ads.
- ericd 8y agoIs there any index of spyware free devices/products? Or I guess I should say products that haven't been caught including spyware yet. This is getting absurd.
- electic 8y agoI often think the same thing. There needs to be a UL type company that certifies a product or service isn't spying on you.
- snaky 8y agoApproximately 1.5 million NGOs operate in the United States. There is no even up-to-date list of OpenWRT capable home routers. Or of not phoning home (to Chinese cloud) CCTV cams.
- pjc50 8y ago> Approximately 1.5 million NGOs operate in the United States .. what does that have to do with anything?
- snaky 8y agoThere are dozens of NGOs trying to save you from genetically modified crops, or raising awareness about chemicals in your soap, or fighting day and night to save cockroaches from extinction. The only one that absent is the NGO that would make a list of goods spying on a customer and bring it up on some website. Isn't that funny?
- pjc50 8y agoWell, you could start one? I would have thought this was within the remit of the EFF, but then so are a lot of other things.
- staktrace 8y agoMozilla kind of started one last year although I don't know if it's still maintained. https://advocacy.mozilla.org/en-us/privacynotincluded/why-we-made https://advocacy.mozilla.org/en-us/privacynotincluded/why-we...
- alexpw 8y agoAt a minimum, it's nice to read this tracking relies on the 4g wifi from OnStar to be active (included in the higher-tier of their paid service). Nice, because I've cancelled their service. However, even after you've cancelled OnStar, there is still basic tracking enabled, but not this radio non-sense. If they're going to sell our listening habits and whatever else, then at least they can give us the wifi for free. After getting a GM/Chevy recently, it reminded me of removing the bloatware on a cheap Windows laptop, except in this case, I didn't have the option to install a fresh OS. It comes bundled with free trials of OnStar and Sirius, both of which employ tactics to keep you onboard. Sigh...
- stephengillie 8y agoWhat tactics do SiriusXM employ to retain you? When my trial expired, they just sent me a few snail mails begging for money. Easy enough to bin.
- alexpw 8y agoSirius was email, snail mail, and phone calls -- standard stuff, but over the top. OnStar required calling to cancel. They provide a web UI where you can add a new payment method but you can not remove all payment methods or cancel. Once you've convinced the person on the phone that you want to cancel, a new option to remove your payment method appears in the UI. The person on the phone didn't tell me to go back to the UI, I was just paranoid and saw it by accident. I'd read enough horror stories on consumer affairs with, for example, people still being charged after they canceled.
- mmjaa 8y agoI am filled with despair that this is normalised behaviour now. I can't honestly think what its going to take to back off from this direction - younger generations aren't cognisant of the risks enough to want such tracking to be illegal, are they? What's it going to take to put these heinous actions in the grave?
- olex 8y agoWell, I can tell them how I listen to the radio... as soon as ads come on, I turn it off or tune to another station, and return no sooner than in 5 minutes once the ads are done. That is when I listen to the radio at all, which is rare for this exact reason; mostly it's just my own music via Bluetooth.
- stephengillie 8y agoPrevious: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18069875 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18069875
- monochromatic 8y agoIt’s enough to make you want to go build a house on Walden Pond and live there alone forever.
- stephengillie 8y agoThe news mediums do a great job with the FUD. It's how they keep you watching their ads. Gotta stay in business somehow.
- tonyedgecombe 8y agohttps://www.nbcnews.com/science/environment/famed-walden-pond-which-inspired-henry-david-thoreau-being-killed-n863381 https://www.nbcnews.com/science/environment/famed-walden-pon... Nothing is sacred anymore.
- maxerickson 8y agoNot even metaphor.
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoClearly.
- grecy 8y agoCome on up to Alaska/Yukon! You won't regret it. Even after living there for only 4 years it was always extremely jarring to go to Vancouver once a year and catch a train or bus with all the advertising on every surface, people buried on their phones, consumerism, pollution, etc.
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago"X is a beautiful place with low population density and you can get away from most of the world's problems" is exactly the message you shouldn't be broadcasting if you want X to stay like that. I guess you get a little more leeway with the Yukon because it's so far away from major population centers.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jpindar 8y agoI wonder if at some point there is going to be a market for fully built kit cars - that is, newly built cars, but without electronics that phone home.
- snaky 8y agoBy the 3x the cost of the same car - but with the source code (Linux 2.6.1 with binary blobs) for washer and wipers.
- djsumdog 8y agoI doubt there'd be a demand. We are the vocal minority here on HN. I think it's more likely people like us will buy older cars with non 4G/cell based head units.
- KumarAseem 8y agoWe won't be able to buy such cars also in next 10-20 years as by then every manufacturer would have included partial or complete data gathering on their units. If they are doing it so should I so I can stay in business is the concept being followed. This can only be controlled through strict laws, and that is a sorry state of affairs anyway. :(
- volkl48 8y agoLow volume manufacturers are exempt from a lot of regulations from what I know. So there'll probably always be a space for someone to make a low-tech car, just not to sell it by the hundreds of thousands.
- bluGill 8y agoI see 30 year old cars on the road - daily drivers - reasonably often. They are probably maintained by the owner who now knows it inside and out. The average millionaire drives a 15 year old car that they bought new (According to "The millionaire next door"). If you actually maintain your car you will discover that they last a lot longer than most people give them credit for. Some years you put more than the car is worth into it, but other years just an oil change.
- djsumdog 8y agoI'm glad I have a 2006 car without any of this crap with a Pioneer head unit that has no Internet access (although it can bluetooth connect to my phone; but just for audio/calls). Needing to update maps using an sdcard doesn't seem like a limitation at all to me. It's a big advantage! I control when my stereo makes updates .. and my stereo doesn't track me!
- scotty79 8y agoI can't listen to radio while I'm driving. I'm feeling it drains my attention and I feel like I need 100% of it while I'm driving.
- isoprophlex 8y ago_And you can start testing [that] by sending them different kinds of advertising to see some kind of behavior in the [listening] patterns.” These are insights that are then quickly shared throughout GM’s various divisions. _ What the actual fuck. It's a car that you've paid several tens of thousands for. Google pestering you for personal data in return for '''''free''''' services is terrible because they are a monopoly, but in a sense we're to blame by expecting not to pay money for maps, mail, search. But this is about a car, on average one of the most expensive things a person owns. Makes you wonder... How will we look back on this day and age 40 years from now?
- grecy 8y ago> you wonder... How will we look back on this day and age 40 years from now? The cynic in me wants to say we will look back and wish our things still had off buttons.
- froindt 8y agoI'd be happy if my next car had physical buttons. Putting everything on a screen you must look at is one of the most distracting and dangerous things I can think of. I've yet to see a digital display I like better than buttons and dials for volume, tuning, and temperature control.
- hw_penfold 8y agoone of the most distracting and dangerous things I can think of No worries there. You won't actually be driving your own car by then. It'll be driving itself.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ilikehurdles 8y agoSeems like the self driving aspect should have hit before the car-full-of-distractions aspect.
- LeonM 8y agoWho listens to radio anyway? Just use spotify et al, no ads. Sure, spotify tracks my music preferences too, but I don't see any harm in that, it just makes the experience better.
- staz 8y agoand then ignore all that and shove Drake down your throat anyway
- LeonM 8y agoHaven't had that (I actually had to google Drake, never heard of him). It probably depends on how you use the service, I never use the front page or top charts functions.
- shakna 8y ago> It probably depends on how you use the service Not... Really. He was placed on the cover of every album for the front page, top charts, and a hell of a lot of other playlists as well [1], including playlists that didn't feature him (half of playlists, according to Reddit detectives). It was so bad, that Spotify was issuing refunds [0], because they basically had one artist take over the whole site. As my anecdotal example of the insanity of the promo, I had Drake featured in playlists for Symphonic Metal. From Nightwish to Drake... Is a hell of a transition. [0] https://twitter.com/notkaranarora/status/1013862692396781568/photo/1 https://twitter.com/notkaranarora/status/1013862692396781568... [1] https://i.kinja-img.com/gawker-media/image/upload/ds67rbqvl3gopygseidq.png https://i.kinja-img.com/gawker-media/image/upload/ds67rbqvl3...
- ecnal798 8y ago>Nightwish to Drake We really are living in a dystopia now aren't we?
- cuboidGoat 8y agoThis modern tracking stuff will get used for a genocide before we ban it, I guarantee. Previous totalitarian states couldn't have even dreamed of this kind of shit.
- peterkelly 8y agoWhen I was a kid I was promised flying cars by 2015. The industry chose otherwise and gave us spying cars.
- yuhong 8y agoThis is what happens when people are treated as "consumers" to be extracted from. The current debt-based economy encourages this kind of behavior.
- mrhappyunhappy 8y ago“The automaker is executed tests of some 90,000 drivers across the Chicago and Los Angeles areas from November 2017 through to January 2018 after those drivers gave permission for their data to be processed in this manner.” Hey, we’ve updated TOS, accept to continue using this service!
- brokenmachine 8y agoI would love to know the details of exactly how those drivers gave permission, and what the alternative was if they wanted to decline.
- petepete 8y agoPerhaps GM can also use their super fancy studies to realise that having owned my car for 8 years I can recite the navigation system's safety notice from memory and don't need it to be displayed every single time I use it. I don't even use it for navigation most of the time, I just like it to display the name of the road I'm currently on or sometimes my current map position. Having a message pop up that I need to dismiss is so annoying. It's a total clusterfuck of an UX.
- wild_preference 8y agoMaybe it’s required by law since my mother’s VW and now Subaru print a similar message each time as well.
- drewg123 8y agoI imagine it is some best-practice CYA suggested by corporate lawyers. It does not happen on my Tesla
- MrEfficiency 8y agoYou bought a first gen, expect that American cars will have the newest technology at a cost. It was untested at consumer levels at the time. I'm sure if you got a 2017 this problem would be fixed. EDIT: To be clear on what is factual- American Cars are known in the industry to implement new tech before everyone. This isnt an AMERIKA IS BEST, this is how these companies actually act. Euro goes for style, Japanese go for old school reliability. These are not opinions, these are styles and market niches. A car built in 2009 is going to have 2009 technology. The first vehicles with screens are going to have UI problems and be slow. In 2017 this is unacceptable.
- qubax 8y agoGM should name their next model "The Abyss" - "when you stare at it, it stares back at you". Seems like so much of the tech/business ecosystem is now centered around spying on you. Your OS, amazon's echo, social media, laptops, etc.
- decasteve 8y agoThere is no such thing as bad publicity? The article is a marketing piece in any case. There is no actual analysis but lots of nice product photos.
- josefresco 8y ago"GM still isn’t entirely sure where this research will lead them, or what exactly it plans to do with the information." Sounds like they were sold a fancy tracking concept without any actual practical applications.
- sonaltr 8y agoWe need a better way of disabling this physically - by removing the 4G/LTE connectivity in cars. Remove connectivity, and that data collection is moot. I'm looking to buy a car in the coming months / year - and I've narrowed it down to the C43, S60 and G70 and all those cars come with "connected features" that I have no need or want for. (find your car anywhere, unlock and remote start your car, send maps to your car, set climate control, check fuel/servicing etc. via an app / website). I partially blame Tesla for starting this trend. It's absolute madness that we have cars companies that generally don't know a ton about software building technology that's generally insecure, will not be updated and mass producing it at scale and being used by 10000s (or even 100000s) of people worldwide. This is a recipe for a easily avoidable disaster waiting to happen and people who've paid 10s or 100s of thousands of $ are the victims. (and ofc they'll use this as an excuse to add more tech instead of less making it a house of cards - Eg. Oh you want secure features - guess what? we've added 4G/5G/LTE support. oh we'll also take in all your data to pay for it anyways).
- MrEfficiency 8y ago> cars companies that generally don't know a ton about software building technology that's generally insecure Why do you think this is insecure? Because its cars? > I partially blame Tesla for starting this trend. Ford. Ford started with Sync. Mentioning Tesla is a outsider move. Why would you think billion dollar fortune 500 companies wouldnt hire programming and security experts?
- ken 8y agoI've worked at a company which could be described that way (in aerospace). I know by experience that they're terrible at this. They're not a software company, so not only do they lack experience, they lack the company culture. As a PG essay once pointed out (in the context of American car design), if your manager lacks knowledge of a thing, then they also lack knowledge necessary to identify a competent expert to hire. The company is world-class at systems integration. If you want a giant component built in Italy to mate with a giant component made in Japan, they can manage to deliver the specs, have them built and tested independently, shipped to their factory floor, and joined perfectly. And repeat the manufacturing process, every day, for years. If you suggest that the database should use a transaction for saving a crucial piece of data, they're lost. They've got internal policies that work great for bolts and wires (standardize all the things!), but suck for software (every software system must use the same database system, which we selected 30 years ago, i.e., it's no longer maintained). Specs are written like hardware specs which will change only minimally (we need a larger bolt), but of course they change all the time in significant ways (need to add a new core feature to the software which will require a completely different schema). Release cycles are literally measured in months, and they have a culture of hard public deadlines, so most problems simply can't get fixed in time, even if they're identified. It doesn't surprise me in the least that car companies are having problems with software.
- ubermonkey 8y agoPeople still listen to the radio?
- crysin 8y agoEveryday. Being able to turn my car on, have the station already set and not use any sort of data I have to pay / account for is irreplaceable. I also get a variety of information from the morning talk show that I wouldn't have otherwise heard or learned about for the metro area. You also might not believe this but there are also people still using cable for television, crazy I know.
- nimbius 8y agoas an engine mechanic by trade, Ive seen the 4G trend in cars ramp up over the past 5-6 years and its more than a little startling. From what i hear in the customer service office up front, info-tainment universally sucks. There isnt a single manufacturer that hasnt turned the radio and air conditioner into some sort of rube goldberg machine. the switches on the steering wheel also adhere to absolutely no standard, so drivers are either turning the volume up on that classic rock song they love or setting the cruise control to plow through an intersection. To add insult to injury, these systems are all needlessly expensive. a knob or a button will last ten times longer than a screen, especially if the vehicle is light truck/small business or god forbid, a family wagon/minivan. The thing about the 4G interface software is that originally it was a powered accessory in the vehicle, but these days its an integral component. that means if it goes out, or you remove it, the car throws a code in the ECU and a light shows up on the dash. Why? internal combustion doesnt require 4G. in fact most drivers one would argue are better on the road without cellular networks. If you want to avoid this weird 1984 wonderland of cars that spy on passengers, go for an older car. Mileage rarely matters anymore for cars 2006+, and platforms from manufacturers can remain the same for a decade. That means the only thing that changes is the interior cloth or shape of a button. I drive a 2005 Dodge Charger RT, and the only two people who know the music I like are my dog and my husband.
- moftz 8y agoIn no way would cruise control force an attentive driver to blow through an intersection. You hit the brake and cruise control stops. If you didn't hit the brake, you weren't paying attention and you would have go through it anyway. Having controls on the steering wheel are much safer than having someone blindly reaching for a knob or touchscreen. How many crashes have happened because someone has looked down and taken a hand off the steering wheel to adjust the volume knob? It only takes a second for someone to pull out in front of you or for a pedestrian to step out into the street. The less you need to take your hands off the steering wheel and the less you need to look away to control other things, the less you'll be looking somewhere and doing something else when that critical moment happens. Sure, the lack of standards suck. I drove a loaner this past weekend because my car was at the dealer getting work. The new car had similar steering wheel controls but some of the lever switches did things in the opposite direction. But after driving with it for a day, I got used to it and that was that. They aren't too complicated that it takes years of study to figure out. Look at the manual. Try it out while in park and you'll be fine.
- costcopizza 8y agoAs an car enthusiast, driving represents freedom and escape, quite hard to do when you're tethered with this connected junk.
- xj9 8y agoyeah, definitely made the right call opting to restore an 89 Bronco II. i have a lot left to learn about it, but at least its simple enough for me to understand and ford parts (even for old cars) are plentiful.
- kleiba 8y ago...and still not as terrifying as this old news from three years ago: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/road-and-rail-transport/11569453/All-cars-must-have-tracking-devices-to-cut-road-deaths-says-EU.html https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/road-and-rail-transp...
- automoton1 8y agoAre there any startups/new players/existing players that are building cars (2017/2018) that are energy efficient (electric/hybrid) and don't violate your privacy by phoning home?