8 ms·
Tidelift wants open-source developers to get paid
- briandoll 8y agoTidelift is insanely exciting and I can't wait for this to be the primary way open source software is built, sustained, and matured. Funding for open source is a crucial topic for everyone here. Nadia Eghbal's lemonade-stand [1] - A handy guide to financial support for open source - shows the myriad of solutions that have existed over the years, and none have really stood out. Unlike foundations who spend significant portions of their funding on executives and other services for a narrow subset of the OSS ecosystem, Tidelift is doing something novel by doing something simple. Make it easy for companies to buy a subscription to open source software that carries added commercial benefits [2] and then take that money and pay the maintainers. That's it. For companies and maintainers alike, this seems ideal. [1] https://github.com/nayafia/lemonade-stand https://github.com/nayafia/lemonade-stand [2] https://tidelift.com/subscription https://tidelift.com/subscription
- sleepychu 8y agoThey're proposing to guarantee 50% of the money in to be paid back out. They've not answered other questions I asked a while back... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17957901 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17957901
- hp 8y agoApologies, I didn't see that comment before. The target customer is large organizations and the pricing is typical for that. We'll be getting a pricing page up that explains the details. There are conditions and commitments for maintainers, see: * https://tidelift.com/about/lifter https://tidelift.com/about/lifter * https://tidelift.com/docs/lifting/tasks-overview https://tidelift.com/docs/lifting/tasks-overview * https://tidelift.com/docs/lifting/agreement https://tidelift.com/docs/lifting/agreement This is a commercial transaction; subscribers are paying for value, and we are paying maintainers to help us provide the value. It is not a donation model. We think it is a favorable transaction for maintainers because it is royalty-style rather than hourly-consulting-style. The same amount of work can be sold N times. For donations there are a number of existing solutions and we would encourage people to use them also!
- sleepychu 8y ago> This is a commercial transaction; subscribers are paying for value, and we are paying maintainers to help us provide the value. That's just not what your branding/advertising is telling me. I understand that's what's happening but the way you're billing it comes across like you're Patreon for open source.
- Jyaif 8y ago50% !?!?!?!? What. The. Fuck. This is absurd.
- StefanKarpinski 8y agoNon-engineering spend at open source companies like RedHat or Anaconda is typically much higher than 50% of revenues. That includes sales and marketing, getting through the IT approval process at big companies, etc. all of which is difficult and pretty expensive.
- hobofan 8y agoI also hope that in the future more open source development will be funded in a sustainable way, but as it stands right now I very much hope that it's not via Tidelift. Of all the approaches I've seen so far, Tidelift is among the most intransparent ones, and with that a very bad fit for open source in my opinion.
- anarcat 8y agoTidelift was previously discussed here in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17957744 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17957744
- ndnxhs 8y agoI'll put this on the list of things to keep an eye on. I have dedicated a fair bit of time to an open source project I started a few months ago. I have no idea if it will ever make me money but I'm hoping to at least be able to pay for server fees through donations. My current plan is to go with patreon and I'll see how that will work out.
- greglindahl 8y agoThat appears to rarely work out for anyone, so I'd recommend trying to find some free server hosting because your project is open source.
- _frkl 8y agoMaybe also look into https://licensezero.com https://licensezero.com. Even if you don't like the licenses (I think they are good), there are lots of interested articles in the blog.
- aportnoy 8y agoWhat are the incentives on the user side to pay the fees to Tidelift? How would Tidelift prevent free riding?
- JoshTriplett 8y agoTidelift tracks down all the individual developers and gives those "subscribing" a single point to pay. That's their primary added value.
- thecatspaw 8y agobut what is the value in subscribing? What is the gain for a company in doing that?
- hasahmed 8y agoSupposedly it's a promise that the code will be maintained
- aequitas 8y agoFor me it would be the convenience of not having to choose which project I do and do not donate to (as each project has a baseline donation amount (even $1) to make it cost-effective (ie: paypal fees), so I have to make a choice to divide the amount I'm willing to donate each month. I can thus dispose some money each month and feel that I'm donating (even if it's just a few cent) to every project I use. If more people find this easy, a lot of small donations will make a big one.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- usrusr 8y agoCorrection: I appear to have misread some of sales copy to potential subscribers, there is no promise of individual support involved, just continued maintenance. -- Tidelift is promising them the stars about services while not being involved at all in their fulfilment (no: see chevron above), except for maybe threatening to kick out their "lifted" projects if they don't deliver. (or maybe even sue whoever pressed "lift your package"?) The more benign interpretation, as in a peer comment, is "allow me to donate without figuring out the distribution myself". That sounds perfectly reasonable, but it would be much more convincing if they had less promises in their pitch to subscribers and a "pay as you like" option (here's n $, please figure out the appropriate distribution for me while taking your cut"). Also, with the well established "failure or unbounded financial success" model of VC funding, how could one ever expect tidelift to not eventually abuse their position by taking seen ever higher cut? Maybe if it was a bootstrapped business, one could reasonably hope for a promise of only taking what is needed to be held up, but anything with actual investors needs a more formal arrangement. Maybe a charity/coop/nonprofit/foundation with clearly defined and enforceable bylaws that transparently buys implementation, operation and services from an associated for-profit might do, but "trust us, we have cute toddlers and pets" just isn't enough.
- tomcooks 8y agoYou cannot put a bazaar in a cathedral.
- ant6n 8y agoI think you're conflating two meanings of the word 'bazaar' in this context.
- cheeze 8y agoI can't help but feel that "Netflix for X" is an incredibly trite and poorly chosen phrase. Nobody is the Netflix of Open Source... maybe Netflix is? A subscription model doesn't make one "the Netflix of $industry". A p2p 'sharing' model doesn't make "the Uber of $industry" either. /rant
- rhplus 8y agoPerhaps "ASCAP for Open Source" might be a closer analogy? https://www.ascap.com/music-users/licensefinder https://www.ascap.com/music-users/licensefinder
- greglindahl 8y agoExcept ASCAP sues people, and also mislays most of the money that flows through them. One hopes Tidelift does neither.
- stingraycharles 8y agoI agree with you, it took me a while to understand this was not about videos at all. Nor about Netflix-like opensource efforts.
- cheeze 8y agoAt least "Uber for X" is obvious. But Netflix is just a subscription service... The {Amazon Prime, Netflix, New York Times, Adobe Cloud, Cable Television, Electricity, MoviePass, Leggings of the Month Club} of X!
- kashyapc 8y agoIt's the result of people writing "articles" in a hurry, and going with the nearest and stupidest cliché that occurs to them.
- dang 8y agoIt's inevitably going to distract the discussion, so we've taken Netflix out of the title above.
- franzwong 8y agoMany paid users will think they have the "right" to request non-sense features or trivial supports. How about asking Apache to fund those projects?
- manmal 8y agoWho defines what non-sense is? The dev? Tidelift? You?
- thecatspaw 8y agothe devs. its their project, they own it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- michaelmrose 8y agoWhomever wants to do the work I suppose.
- doubleorseven 8y ago"When a customer signs up with Tidelift, the company analyzes the customer's code to see what open source software it depends on, and what open source projects those programs depend on. Tidelift then charges a subscription fee based on the number of participating projects a customer relies on." Sure, just run `npm install` and try to come up with a reasonable number that will look like something i'll be willing to pay for.
- mpolichette 8y agoYeah cause our companies love to let third parties “analyze” our code.
- hp 8y agoIt's analogous to something like Code Climate, Coveralls, TravisCI, etc. Some companies require an on-premise version or want to run the scan themselves and only call an "upload my dependencies as JSON" API, which is fine. The scan is only to get the list of deps and their versions, it doesn't care about the actual source code.
- DannyB2 8y agoFor a Java program, just gather the "import" declarations from every single source file. Consolidate those into a single file, removing duplicates, sort them. You now have a list of everything used by your program. Remove all of the internal imports. That is imports from other parts of your own software. (Hint: this is easy since they are sorted by package name.) Now you have a list of all third party software used. I suspect this same procedure works for C / C++ / Python and probably other languages. You don't have to give anyone your source code to discover what third party and open source software you are using.
- cheeze 8y agoThe sheer amount of open source code that pretty much any software out there runs on is absolutely astonishing. Especially when you start taking into account transitive dependencies. Say I'm running Java... Someone had to compile the JVM and it was probably done on an open source compiler. Crazy to think of how many thousands of man hours have gone into something as simple as allowing me to argue with someone over the internet.
- xiconfjs 8y agoThe title made me think tidelift is an alternative to plex or kodi...
- therealmarv 8y agoPercentage cut? I think the better title would be Patreon for Open Source (which is also itself used for Open Source, e.g. Vue.js). Seems like a huge win for Tidelift.
- aequitas 8y agoThe one thing I dislike about Patreon (which I notified them about as well) is that I need a subscription for everything. Say I have a few dollar of disposable income I just want to donate to opensource indiscriminately I need to make a choice of which. And there are only so many levels (each with a baseline) in Patreon that a lot of smaller projects get left out. I would like to have just one amount per month that gets withdrawn that I don't have to think about any further. And that just gets distributed over projects. With the idea that a lot of micro payments make more than a few big payments.
- chimprich 8y agoI'd be happy to chuck some cash at free software. Things like Emacs are far more valuable to me than software I've actually paid for. I know a few developers are on Patreon but that requires figuring out who deserves it the most or a fair bit of admin to spread out payments. Maybe the FSF or someone could distribute cash but they don't seem very interested.
- icebraining 8y agoI preferred Flattr's model - you just donated a fixed amount per month, and they divided it by project. But it wasn't indiscriminate - you had to click on a button for each project. Now it seems they use a "smart, privacy-friendly algorithm [which] measures attention on websites", which is a no-go for me. The problem with indiscriminate is that there are many, many, many OS projects out there. You need some curation, and that opens a can of worms. Maybe they could allow people to share and use lists?
- trextrex 8y agoFlattr's model seems really well suited for conveniently contribution back to open source. Does Flattr not work for software anymore? I'm trying to figure out why it's not more popular as a way to contribute to open source software.
- Aeolun 8y agoWhile this sounds like a great idea in theory, I think there’s a fuckton of traps to run into here.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- VirenM 8y ago> the company analyzes the customer's code to see what open source software it depends on, and what open source projects those programs depend on. I'm sure fortune 500 companies will be alright with Tidelift analyzing their proprietary code.
- justincormack 8y agoPeople already do to make sure they are complying with licenses and not using licenses they dont approve.
- pwang 8y agoYep, F500 companies bring in all sorts of external tools to look at their source code, for compliance, security, etc.
- empath75 8y agoA lot of open source software is written by company employees on company time. I suspect most projects that are most useful to most companies are built and maintained that way.
- greglindahl 8y agoThis is very true, and somehow I'm not that surprised to find this comment near the bottom of the discussion... seems that many people don't realize it, including HN readers!
- da_murvel 8y ago"That was risky, because Babel is open source—meaning it is freely available online, and users don’t have to pay for it." I don't get why many seem to think that Open Source = No cost for the user. Now I haven't read up that much on the OS philosophy so that might be why, but I have read a bit about free software, like Free Software, Free Society: Selected Essays of Richard M. Stallman[0] for example, how anyone could mistake free software as software at no cost is beyond me. You can of course make it available at no cost, but then, it's your problem if you're not getting paid. Free software basically means that you're free to review and edit the software as you wish, (with some other implications as well if you read up on the GPL-3.0 license) and as far as I know, that's basically the purpose of open source as well. I thought companies, or developers, made their code available to get feedback, find bugs and issues more quickly, show the rest of the world that they have nothing fishy to hide etc. But I had no idea that it also meant that code automatically became gratis for everyone. [0]https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/fsfs/rms-essays.pdf https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/fsfs/rms-essays.pdf
- profalseidol 8y agoIt's like thinking of Free Market as something beneficial to you as a pleb with a meager capital.
- dingo_bat 8y ago> But I had no idea that it also meant that code automatically became gratis for everyone. I think it's common sense. If I sell you a software and provide you the source code with a GPL license, you are free to publish the code online for everyone to download free. So yes, open source invariably implies no cost to end user.
- icebraining 8y agoYou are free, but won't necessarily do it. At a previous company, 90%+ of the code I wrote was (A/L)GPL licensed, yet we sold it (to companies) and our clients never redistributed it. The only code available publicly was the one we purposefully shared. This probably wouldn't work in many cases (particularly consumer software), but a trucking company or a clothes manufacturer has no interest in becoming a software distributor. They just like not being locked-in to us.
- anonymous_i 8y agoI am oblivious to some or many aspects of Tech. business. It is probably going to cringe a lot of people, but the question in my mind is, Why cant Dell or other OEM's pay for developing or customizing Linux to their specs, so it is more reliable. That way they don't have to depend on Microsoft for OS and can optimize their hardware performance, just like Apple does with OSX? I know it sounds like a dumb question, but I don't know any other place on internet that provides a better answer than here.
- m12k 8y agoI don't think that's at all impossible for Dell or the other OEMs to do (and I think some of that might already be happening a bit) but overall I don't think they particularly mind using Windows for their computers. There's a whole class of customer support issues that another company has to deal with for them, they avoid the "why can't I install this program that my daughter sent me?" type problems and overall they just give their "learned about computers in the 90's"-business segment exactly what they expect.
- mprev 8y agoThey do pay for drivers and other engineering work. I don’t know how it is now but Canonical was in that business. As for why OEMs don’t do it more, or why they don’t do it instead of paying for Windows licences: custom dev, testing and certification for each model variant is a significant cost. Even if the OEM saves that money of Windows licences, the market mostly demands Windows. System76 is a company that produces laptops and desktops with their own custom Ubuntu variant, if you want to see an example of one company going the full Linux route.
- cthulhuology 8y agoThey do already and have been for a couple decades. Dell in particular has had a long history of doing so. Personally, I have worked for a couple companies that have done just that. Now when you look at certain classes of machines for specific workloads you will see engineering specifically for Linux. But when most people look at MSFT & Apple they are thinking about the desktop. And if you look in certain corporate environments, you will find Linux thin clients, but those tend to be very specific highly regulated environments.
- dustinmoris 8y agoWhy should I as OSS maintainer give a cut to Tidelift and even let my revenue be solely dependent on their algorithm when I could just put a onliner in my project stating that usage for other OSS is free and commercial users need to buy a license with a link to an online payment page where I control price, duration, etc.?
- hasahmed 8y agoSome people dont want to deal with that aspect of the business. Anyone that does is free to
- dustinmoris 8y agoSetting up a payment page and writing one line to the license, even if I outsource that one time effort, will be indefinitely cheaper than having my revenue at the mercy of some random algorithm which doesn't even take into account how important my software might be to a company and giving a huge cut to a third party which really doesn't do anything other than profiting of my hard work. I struggle to see the appeal for OSS maintainers.
- detaro 8y agoFor one thing, Open Source software can't require commercial users to pay. The common way is AGPL then, in the assumption that it's unacceptable for companies to comply with, and selling a different license too. It's also a hurdle to take that someone makes a decision to pay for your thing specifically (and doesn't go search for a free replacement). Lots of still quite valuable components don't really meet that hurdle, and you severely limit your adoption by using e.g. AGPL. If (and that's a large if) tidelift gets somewhat widely adopted, it'd trickle down to all parts of the ecosystem, not just the few standout pieces being able to get paid otherwise.
- greglindahl 8y agoThis "charge for commercial use" model was tried -- shareware -- and was an economic failure. It's advocated against by most organizations, like FSF and Creative Commons. At most you see a "this is GPL but I wrote it so I'll give you a license to not follow the GPL for my code". Which is a quite different thing.
- toddsby 8y agoI needed a good laugh. Thanks for that Wired! “How can I make money off all the hard work that developers do for free via open source.” I got it, let’s sell the free software back to large corporations, and take a 90% commission all the while making empty promises and giving the actual developers pocket change for the privilege. Thanks but no thanks.
- Radim 8y agoI couldn't find any numbers (incl. your "90%"), more clarity would be appreciated, though I understand Tidelift is still an experiment. But this explanation [0] caught my eye: > How we compute how much to pay > A weight. …based primarily on code size with some adjustments… So, payments based off a clear (and clearly silly) metric that's easy to game. What could possibly go wrong? [0] https://tidelift.com/docs/lifting/paying https://tidelift.com/docs/lifting/paying
- Derbasti 8y agoLet me fix that: Tidelift wants high-profile JavaScript developers to get payed. Their scanning process does not even think of anything non-web. Boohoo for us Pythonistas and Emacsens and Lunatics.
- pwang 8y agoNumPy and other things in the Python ecosystem are certainly part of what they're considering. The founder/CEO of Tidelift is actually participating in a keynote panel this morning at the NumFOCUS summit. I get it, it's fun to be cynical about things, but these are folks that are legitimately trying to help.
- hp 8y agoOur ideal is that if a subscriber is using it, we can sign up its maintainer. The Tidelift platform is built on an OSS project called libraries.io which supports many package managers: https://libraries.io/platforms https://libraries.io/platforms Here's what's involved in adding more: https://github.com/librariesio/libraries.io/blob/master/docs/add-a-package-manager.md https://github.com/librariesio/libraries.io/blob/master/docs...
- 0xcde4c3db 8y agoI work on a product that uses Buildroot, which doesn't really act like a "package manager" in the sense that libraries.io seems to want. We also have a handful of FOSS projects that are just copied into our tree and applied on top of the base system. Is there any anticipation of support for that kind of situation?
- hp 8y agoI think there's a clear mapping of the Tidelift model to this, and there's also some customer demand from people building embedded systems. As a practical matter it's a bit different from what we built first, both in terms of what customers are looking for / who the customers are, and in terms of the technical details of how we'd analyze dependencies. So we don't have support for it yet. But I would like to figure it out when we have enough team bandwidth.
- therealmarv 8y agoWould be cooler to have an open source/license framework for handling payment processing, easy industry wide contract templates: why not make a X,Y,Z (like MIT, BSD for licenses) thing for contracts with open source vendors AND then if the open source developer does not want to handle all this stuff himself give him the opportunity to choose a service like tidelift with a certain percentage cut.
- hp 8y agoFor large companies to buy something, there's considerable overhead: legal review, finance review, management, budget, etc. That's _after_ someone at the company has figured out what the product is and that it makes sense to buy. We wouldn't want all of this overhead involved every time a developer adds a new package to an app. And if it were involved for all the thousands of deps most teams have these days, there would be a whole second team just managing the purchases. As a practical matter, software teams need to buy dozens rather than thousands of products. By grouping a lot of packages together, Tidelift lets those thousand transitive dependencies benefit, while previously only the largest high-profile projects had a chance. This reality (that buying stuff has a lot of friction) also explains why Tidelift builds "fund a sales team" into the model. Here's an interesting article from patio11 on enterprise sales and purchasing: https://training.kalzumeus.com/newsletters/archive/enterprise_sales https://training.kalzumeus.com/newsletters/archive/enterpris...
- _pmf_ 8y agoRead: they want a cut of the meagre income of FOSS developers.
- pwang 8y agoFalse. They're trying to create a new marketplace where commercial users of OSS can actually give money back to FOSS devs. Many FOSS devs live a life of poverty because they have no idea how to actually sell things of value around their free artifacts and free labor. It turns out that selling stuff is hard, in general, and feels almost nothing like coding. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- ognarb 8y agoIdelift doesn't seem to be open source.
- hp 8y agoThe open source part of our implementation is here: https://github.com/librariesio/libraries.io https://github.com/librariesio/libraries.io https://github.com/librariesio/bibliothecary https://github.com/librariesio/bibliothecary
- buboard 8y ago> Unlike Red Hat, Tidelift doesn't offer technical support, And that s why it is probably a failed model. On the other hand, they could offer open source tech support, or pay people to do tech support gigs, or perhaps give developers a way to make money by tech supporting their own open source product.
- jkingsbery 8y agoI'm honestly confused, would love someone to explain: From Wired: "Tidelift doesn't offer technical support" From Tidelift site: "The professional support you need." So, which is it? From Wired: "[Tidelift] doesn't employ the developers who maintain open source projects." From Wired: "[D]evelopers can focus on code instead of sales and marketing." If they aren't employees, what are they? Contractors? I can see how it simplifies things to have to deal with 1 party instead of N, but if they aren't paying you a full salary it seems like a developer would still need to deal with sales and marketing.
- hp 8y agoThe issue here is that "support" is an overloaded word. Tidelift does not ask maintainers to be a help desk where subscribers can call them up directly. But we do provide certain assurances and help with open source dependencies, through a combination of our own efforts and that of participating maintainers. Maintainers who sign up are contractors (here is the contract: https://tidelift.com/docs/lifting/agreement https://tidelift.com/docs/lifting/agreement ). It's not that developers don't have to think about sales and marketing _at all_, but it's much reduced vs. starting one's own company from scratch. All those jobs that sales, marketing, finance, operations, etc. are normally doing at a company are things that Tidelift takes on.
- dx87 8y agoFrom what I've gathered, the developers don't work for Tidelift in any capacity, Tidelift just collects money on their behalf whether they want it or not. If you agree to Tidelift's terms, you get a portion of the money they collected. I still don't see how they're helping open-source developers though. They keep saying that it'll be easier for big corporations to have a single place to pay, but they're going to take a huge chunk of the money for themselves instead of giving it to the developers, and the amount the developers get is based on some secret formula. I really don't see how this benefits anyone except themselves and big corporations wanting to say that they're helping OSS, but not really caring where the money goes.
- hp 8y agoI would say that we collect money on behalf of the companies who buy an enterprise maintenance subscription from us, and we agree to provide those maintenance services. So far this is what many OSS businesses do. But while existing OSS businesses hire 100% their own staff to then provide the service, we split our revenue with interested maintainers who want to help provide the service. We are creating an opportunity for upstream projects to participate directly _if they want to_. If they don't want to, then no problem! The beneficiaries are: subscribing companies get an enterprise maintenance service for their dependencies; participating maintainers get paid a revenue share (royalty-style model) for doing work on their project. Tidelift's share of revenue mostly is not profit. It's analogous to what any software vendor would pay for the nontechnical roles at the company. https://tidelift.com/docs/lifting/paying https://tidelift.com/docs/lifting/paying goes into more detail on that. It is worth spending money on sales, because even though it lowers the _percentage_ of revenue going to engineering, it increases the _amount_ of revenue going to engineering. Businesses spend money on sales/marketing/finance/ops because it results in more money overall. The same math applies to Tidelift. All other open source vendors give maintainers a 0% cut, though the best ones do add a lot of "in kind" value in the form of contributions, those contributions often actually create more work for the primary maintainers, and everyone ends up bottlenecking on those overworked maintainers. Tidelift is not a money transfer or donation system. It's a commercial service provided in cooperation with interested upstream projects.