11 ms·
I like to remind people of shit like this when they claim that the United States government is an "oppressive" presence on the Internet. Yes, the five eyes nati
by walrus01 8y ago
I like to remind people of shit like this when they claim that the United States government is an "oppressive" presence on the Internet. Yes, the five eyes nations are actively trying to backdoor crypto, and there is a lot of bullshit going on, but you don't need a license in North America to operate an http daemon. In China you do. The GFW is no joke, and they are seriously trying to bifurcate the Internet.
- schoen 8y ago> In China you do. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ICP_license https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ICP_license It's always sad on the Let's Encrypt forum when someone fails to get a cert and the reason turns out to be that the hosting provider has blocked all inbound HTTP connections because the user's web site wasn't licensed. This is a regular event, most recently reported this past weekend.
- princetontiger 8y agoI will fight and die for the Five Eyes... The best, most sophisticated nations on earth. The Five British Countries: New Zealand, Australia, Canada, UK, US. Everywhere else? Protohuman. The Five Eyes combined with all other European nations are the best places to live on earth. We respect private property and human rights. Anglo Saxons for the win! People don't realize only 15% of the world is free.
- arcticbull 8y agoThis really is whataboutism. Two things can be differently oppressive at once, and if you don't push back actively the line moves on you.
- walrus01 8y agoAnd I equally support bringing the US/Five Eyes SIGINT activities to the attention of as many people as possible, and calling out bullshit like the australian government trying to backdoor crypto: https://www.google.com/search?client=ubuntu&channel=fs&q=australia+backdoor+crypto&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8 https://www.google.com/search?client=ubuntu&channel=fs&q=aus... The counterpoint to your claim of whataboutism is that it is possible to simultaneously denounce both the Chinese government's activities and the US, while at the same time critically and rationally examining their differences in methodology. And documenting where they are the same (NSA/CIA hoards zero-days, Chinese intelligence does the same, etc).
- GW150914 8y agoThe obvious and rational response to what you’re saying is that the US government is an oppressive force on the internet (and elsewhere), just not as much as China, which is the most oppressive except for North Korea. Then I’d ask if being so low on the spectrum is acceptable, when the best that can be said is that it’s better than China and North Korea. Yemen for example, can happily boast that they have fewer guns per capita than the US, by an order of magnitude too! But um... how many people would leave the US for Yemen? Just comparing two countries in a narrow metric while ignoring context is unwise at best, deceptive at worst. Moreover it does nothing to dispel concerns held by people who feel the US is an oppressive force online. They might for example, point out that while China oppresses their own citizens, the US has more of a global impact as a result of their foreign policy and massive corporations. If they then pointed out that you’re essentially comparing apples and oranges, and asked you why you thought that was an appropriate response to their concerns, you would say...?
- mastazi 8y agoI agree. I was living in Italy during the Berlusconi years, every time there was a new law designed to limit personal rights or freedoms, someone would reply "then what about XYZ" where XYZ was invariably what Freedom House would describe as a non-free or partially-free country. No one ever tried to compare Italy to, say, Sweden or Denmark. Once the 'race to the bottom' mentality becomes mainstream, it can do a lot of damage.
- acct1771 8y ago"This isn't like in China."
- paavoova 8y agoForget about state organizations, Google itself is already malware-as-a-service as far as the Android ecosystem is concerned. Regardless of whether or not the user expects it, the fact is most Android phones ship with Google play and this is uninstallable without taking extreme measures like rooting/bootloader unlocking (if even possible). You can pay hundreds of dollars for a device you then own but still have no control over the software and your data. Lets look at what the linked post claims: > It basically sends the IMEI and other phone metadata Google services do this to some degree. Location data, everything. And isn't the IMEI broadcast by the baseband itself? > as well as file hashes, to a server Google checksums and uploads files on both mobile and PC as part of their supposed malware heuristics and prevention. > It also monitors messages sent via otherwise secure apps This is somewhat malicious, and I'm honestly not sure to what degree Google services are able to intercept or "monitor" app communications. > I don't know whether it includes sophisticated anti-tempering features or not Google services certainly do, so much so that projects like MicroG require "signature spoofing" to function. Indirectly, Google has replaced open frameworks with proprietary ones, increasing the reliance of userspace Android on Google services. Google does not want you having freedom and tampering in any way with their ecosystem. To my mind, the state of consumer technology in the West, and the more aggressive measures like China is taking, are two sides of the same coin. But somehow one fosters complacency despite being just as invasive.
- gruez 8y agogoogle might be doing the same thing, but google doesn't have men with guns forcing you to use google play services
- thaumaturgy 8y agoThis sentiment trivially reduces to, "everything the US does is fine until it's the most oppressive presence on the internet", which probably isn't what you mean. The US flexes a lot of political muscle to enforce copyright restrictions, maintain secrets, and expand surveillance around the world. That may not be as oppressive as China, but on a scale from "free" to "China", it's still in the "China" half.
- toss1 8y agoNonsense false equivalency. Yes, in terms of implementing secrets & National Security-related spying there is overall parity, with the US probably a bit ahead of China & Russia. But in terms of being an average citizen, it is night and day. At least for now, the US is an active open democracy, with a large majority of citizens actively engaged in maintaining the governmental and extra-governmental institutions the maintain democracy, e.g., independent judiciary, co-equal branches of govt, elections, independent journalism, free speech, etc. Even though these are imperfectly implemented and under threat by the current administration (w/increasing evidence of significant compromise by Russia), the US remains overly in the OPEN and FREE column. In contrast, China is a straight-up autocracy, and it is openly working to ensure it's citizens do not even know their own history (e.g., Tiananmen, Tibet) or current news (e.g., Uyghurs), and have no capability to independently either obtain accurate information, or to organize to respond appropriately if they can somehow get it. And of course the spyware topic of this article, where ordinary citizens can get stopped on the street for failure to install. This is little different than "May I see your papers please". Russia is not far behind. To falsely equate these regimes and their surveillance & interference levels is tantamount to propaganda.
- adventured 8y ago> Even though these are imperfectly implemented and under threat by the current administration The current administration is providing one of the greatest demonstrations in US history of just how different the US is from the Russias and Chinas of the world. Freedom of expression, freedom of speech, freedom of press, is working well given the intensity of the atmosphere in question. There are routine demonstrations against the administration all over the country, they're not being broken up by thousands of government thugs with clubs and guns, which is what you see in Russia, China and Iran. A solid 90% of all media is entirely stacked against the administration. Celebrities are openly calling for the President to be coup'd, killed, or otherwise just 'taken out.' Even the media has joined in on that at times. The so called deep state (a collection of entrenched, powerful bureaucracies within the government) have been openly acting against the administration at every turn. And come the post mid-terms - which clearly the Democrats are going to retake the house in - there are going to be approximately a thousand investigations. Despite the cynics proclamations, and the current cultural insanity (we've seen it before, the late 1960s and 1970s were far worse), the US system is functioning amazingly well. The current administration has accomplished almost nothing of what it would like to do, and will be a lame duck in a few months. In 2 or 6 years, there will be another administration, and that's that. Life will go on, just as it did after LBJ, Nixon or Bush. There's nothing even remotely comparable to this in Russia or China, and there never has been.
- grouseway 8y agoThat's a bit of a straw man. The concern is the western countries taking actions to become more like China rather than less like China. It's natural to worry about convergence because eventually these things just become run away systems that are too entrenched to change. Think about how we used to differentiate ourselves from the totalitarian regimes of the world in the post war communist fighting era. This pool of attributes is shrinking. Indefinite imprisonment without trail, national security letters, labelling the media as traitors, labelling companies that enable encryption as traitors, an omnipresent eavesdropping apparatus, etc...
- moltar 8y agoAt least in China they are open about.
- seppin 8y agoThat's somehow better?
- __d 8y agoYes. Doing something bad openly is better than doing it, but trying to hide the fact that you do it, while pretending in public to be innocent or worse, encouraging condemnation of others who do the same thing openly.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoMany of the laws that govern internet usage in China are considered state secrets, hardly open! The list of websites blocked by the GFW is a state secret, for example. Not only that, but regulations are enforced arbitrarily and often even retroactively. To top it off, the Chinese constitution garauntees freedom of speech, press, religion, but is just an ignored document. In a country where rule by law is more prominent than rule of law, this shouldn’t be weird.
- bunderbunder 8y agoIt's worth keeping a sense of perspective, but, at the same time, I don't think pointing out X is unambiguously more oppressive than Y does anything to address the original assertion that X is oppressive. That'd be like responding to someone claiming that Seattle is rainy by lecturing them about Bangladesh's climate.
- codedokode 8y agoUS is not perfect too (but nowhere near China). For example, it is incredibly difficult to become an independent president candidate: you need to get ballot access in all states, and every state has its own rules.
- brianmurphy 8y agoYou can't be serious. The challenge of filing presidential candidate paperwork in the US versus the challenges of having a contrarian political opinion in China are nowhere near each other in level of hardship.
- NullPrefix 8y agoSo Chinese NSA is "no joke", because they are manually installing apps instead of using baseband backdoor?
- sbmthakur 8y agoThe worst part is this might also motivate other nations to develop their own "internet" and strictly control what goes out of their borders.