10 ms·
Tyler Cowen launches fellowship and grant program for moon shot ideas
- samstave 8y agoAren't there a few such projects to fund moon shots? What/where is the best list of moon shots being currently worked on and backed?
- jayalpha 8y agoSBIR Grants are supposed to finance "moon shot" projects. Unfortunately the way they are granted is very "opaque" to put it mildly and without going into more detail.
- chris11 8y agoWhat do you mean? SBIR grants are intended to support early stage innovation projects. They should be able to be commercialized, but too high risk for normal investors. That's not really the same thing as a moon shot program. And individual federal agencies that participate in the program can decide what they are interested in researching.
- jayalpha 8y ago"but too high risk for normal investors." what brings it pretty close to "moon shot", doesn't it? "And individual federal agencies that participate in the program can decide what they are interested in researching." This is true, I never said something different. I just know from people two who got SBIR I and II who discouraged me to apply since they know how the selections process works.
- jnbiche 8y ago> That's not really the same thing as a moon shot program. Matthew Weinberg, former Special Advisor to the SBA's Office of Investment and Innovation, disagrees with you. With respect to the SBIR program, he said: "It’s fundamentally astounding that the federal government—not private venture capital firms or banks—is the entity backing these moonshot investments that end up changing the world[1]." He also wrote an article about the SBIC and SBIR programs entitled, "Your federal government drives innovation by investing in moonshots[2]". (My italics) 1. https://www.fundera.com/blog/sbir-program https://www.fundera.com/blog/sbir-program 2. https://techcrunch.com/2016/07/03/your-federal-government-drives-innovation-by-investing-in-moonshots/ https://techcrunch.com/2016/07/03/your-federal-government-dr...
- jseliger 8y agoThere are many lovely reasons to apply (or ignore) SBIRs: http://seliger.com/Should-your-startup-seek-Small-Business-Innovation-Research-SBIR-grants http://seliger.com/Should-your-startup-seek-Small-Business-I..., but the review process is not particularly opaque. It is true that most agencies receive far more applications than there are awards available, so even "fundable" applications may not be funded.
- jayalpha 8y agoYou are wrong. Unfortunately I know how opaque it is and can not use another word, which I would prefer, to describe the process. I can not, will not, must not give more information to protect myself and others. Trust me, the mathematical chance of approximately 10% has nothing to do with your real chances which could be much lower, or much higher.
- dv_dt 8y agoSBIR grants are more for pursuit of regular technology expansions in foreseeable topic areas as seen by various gov't agencies. SBIR funding stages aren't really setup for moon shot funding, more like lighting kindling hoping something catches fire. The are more fundamental gov't programs for "moon shots" within NASA and DARPA. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NASA_Institute_for_Advanced_Concepts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NASA_Institute_for_Advanced_Co...
- jl2718 8y agoHonestly most govt PMs use SBIR to fund small projects that nobody else would take, or big contracts failed to deliver on. They are often laughably specific.
- A2017U1 8y agoI'm quite excited about the different groups trying to reduce manufacturing costs of antimatter and use it for space propulsion. Positron Dynamics is putting up a cube sat in the near future to demonstrate feasibility. Generating antimatter is easier in space and using it instantly gets rid of storage hassles. The amount needed for a trip to Mars would be around 10mg, the journey time would be measured in weeks. Possibly the best hope there is for constant acceleration spacetravel. https://www.positrondynamics.com https://www.positrondynamics.com https://medium.com/dissected-by-propel-x/positron-dynamics-paves-the-road-to-the-final-frontier-d00e60133b67 https://medium.com/dissected-by-propel-x/positron-dynamics-p...
- viburnum 8y agoThis guy has been on the Koch payroll his entire career. Expect to see a lot of solutions that involve rich people keeping all their power and money.
- whatshisface 8y agoTo be fair, "how can anyone go to the moon," and "who gets the moon when we get there," are two distinct questions.
- taheca 8y agoIt's also funded from the Thiel Foundation.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jamestimmins 8y agoInteresting that the two examples are Satoshi and Jordan Peterson. When I see "moon shot" I typically think of space elevators and such. Perhaps this is a truly unique type of fund but at first glance, I have a hard time seeing the similarity of these two folks other than having initially fringe ideas.
- dnomad 8y agoThe cult of innovation asserts that these new "technologies" are good simply because they are new and provocative and especially impractical. Adherents to the cult aren't really interested in changing the world -- a deeply banal affair and extremely political affair -- it's just the opposite, it's all about peddling the fantasy of change, the drama of change, without much work and zero sacrifice. The delicious irony here is that the real moon shot wasn't the story of a bunch of plucky Randian individualists fighting against the unthinking herd of socialists, rather it was the story of massively expensive, highly bureaucratic, and extremely risky government investment that didn't pay off for nearly a decade. This is of course exact kind of real change-the-world innovation that libertarians like Cowen absolutely hate.
- jl2718 8y agoCan we really honestly say that it did pay off?
- gameswithgo 8y agoJordan Peterson seems pretty useless overall. His climate change views seem to suggests he thinks he is a lot smarter than he is.
- Latteland 8y agoPeterson in interviews even says he is smarter than every interviewer (I've listened to a few of them). He just comes across as pretty conceited. Everyone has their areas of expertise, but the claim that you don't know anything but 'they' do comes across like a certain world leader.
- throwaway834 8y ago“People such as Satoshi and Jordan Peterson have had huge impacts (regardless of one’s degree of enthusiasm for their ideas), and yet in terms of philanthropic funding the world just isn’t geared to seed their ambitions,” said Cowen. I don't understand this quote. Satoshi is a fictional person as far as I'm concerned, who's idea has already succeeded to the extent that it can. I don't even want to know what this Jordan Peterson guy needs funding for. He already has a very vocal, supportive fan base. He can probably raise a lot of money with Kickstarter if he needed to.
- 1123581321 8y agoI saw them as recognizable examples of the type of currently unrecognized thinker he wants to fund. I agree that the fund is not big enough to provide new options to those particular two. I do think both are examples of how constraints and a long, unusual background lead to outstanding results. A fund like this attempts to shortcut that long climb but I think that would prevent the result from being unusual enough to be remarkable. I think funds like this are better for defined needs that are difficult to fund, such as open research questions.
- atomical 8y agoHow is Satoshi a fictional person? Did the software come from AI that traveled in a time machine?
- zawerf 8y agoIt is pretty interesting that he chose two people who don't need philanthropic funding. Satoshi made a ton of money off bitcoin Jordan Peterson is one of the top 10 earners on Patreon: https://graphtreon.com/top-patreon-creators https://graphtreon.com/top-patreon-creators
- agorabinary 8y agoI suspect GMU/Mercatus has a few early crypto adopters given the symmetry of their ideas with crypto political ideals. What does a GMU academic economist do with hodl money? Form a grant program with a heavily libertarian bent.
- freen 8y agoUnless you are able and willing to risk the entire US silver reserve (see the Manhattan project), you aren’t actually funding moonshots.
- dv_dt 8y agoWhy doesn't Cowen fund this through the usual deep pockets Mercatus & GMU donor, the Koch brothers?
- atomical 8y agoHow many times are you going to post this on different accounts?
- thwy12321 8y agoI'm increasingly noticing comments aimed at marketing startups, tech stacks and political agendas on here. It used to be that people just shared their opinion, but at this point there is definitely an effort to sway information on hacker news and other websites by having different user accounts harp on the same opinions.
- atomical 8y agoWhy did you create a throwaway account for this?
- dv_dt 8y agoThat was my first post to this topic. I _have_ posted on other Cowan topics regarding his funding link to the Koch brothers. I think it's relevant as knowing, for instance exactly who funded what political ads in various media channels. In this topic, it's particularly ironic that an organization within the Koch network would be trying to create some sort of counterflow of capital to the systemic inequality caused by many Koch objectives across our nation and government. This initiative wouldn't be needed nearly as much if all the capital weren't already in very few hands.
- HarryHirsch 8y agoIn 25 years we can look back who has had a greater impact on society - the people awarded a McArthur grant or the people awarded an Emergent Ventures grant. My money would be on Phil Baran and Carolyn Bertozzi, not Jordan Peterson and Nakamoto Satoshi. Nota bene: John McArthur was a financier himself.
- barry-cotter 8y agoBoth of the chemists you mention were already wildly professionally successful before they got their MacArthur Grant. The MacArthur Grant was not encouraging success, it was rewarding it. If they’re typical recipients of MacArthur Grants then the Emergent Ventures grantees will definitely look worse on average. Some of them will try and fail. None of the MacArthur grant awards are going to fail and drop into obscurity. They’ve all already reached some level of success. Whatever about Peterson Satoshi Nakamoto developed a financial technology on a par with at least international wire transfers and possibly fiat money. Even if BitCoin as such is insecure and collapses, worthless some altcoun is going to be traded in 100 years. The technology is a big deal.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- gweinberg 8y agoIt's hard to se what Satoshi and Peterson have in common, aside from that they are two people Cowan would have never funded before they were famous.
- Latteland 8y agoJordan Peterson is so controversial, why would you mention him in that interview? "Team" Satoshi actually solved fundamental problems and moved the world forward in cryptocurrency and associated underlying technology like blockchains, but Peterson has just stirred people up.
- majos 8y agoI am also curious about the allusion to Peterson. I am not aware of any huge societal contribution he has made beyond encouraging dueling op-eds. Certainly he has a devoted fan base, but I essentially never hear about him in real life. I'm not weighing in on how good or bad his ideas are. But I see way more of the blockchain in the world than I do (knowingly) of Peterson. What am I missing?
- WaxProlix 8y agoI think you've mostly got it. AFAIK, other academics and such in Peterson's field(s) find his work mostly mediocre to laughable, so my best guess is that the person in question falls into the "avid fan" camp.
- atomical 8y agoCowen wouldn't be funding someone like Peterson for their academic credentials. Vitalik Buterin wasn't a heavy weight in academia when Peter Thiel took a chance on him.
- nexus2045 8y agoI have thoroughly consumed a lot of Peterson content. I can vouch that aside from the political controversy, that he has a powerful message for young men: to find the meaning in life through responsibility and sacrifice, to go out there and make something of themselves. I have no idea why that it is "controversial" to be told to strive for something, and I don't see much alternatives other than self-help books. There are much more troubled, aimless people out there than you think, because if you've lived a fairly decent life yourself, you almost never come into contact with the guys that aren't doing so well and are in need of such a message. He's almost filling in as a father figure for young men where self-help did not suffice. The opposing side likes to attempt to character assassinate him by labelling as a right-wing bigot, but have never bothered to really listen to his message while holding the empathy that more unfortunate people DO need a message like that.
- jtcond13 8y agoIt’s interesting to see the America's most prominent libertarian economist state that capital markets aren’t adequately funding risky business ventures...
- jl2718 8y agoThis is an excellent point, and a place where libertarians and socialists have some agreement, that we have a wealth/power distribution that fails to encourage social innovation. I think the argument is mostly how it got this way, and how it should be addressed. Socialists are concerned with giving more, and libertarians are concerned with taking less, but bureaucrats and plutarchs are aligned in taking more and giving less. And yet we fight each other...
- atomical 8y agoWhat does libertarianism have to do with private funding? I've read two of his books. I don't find his views to be very libertarian. He supported bank bailouts.
- potempkin_TOS 8y agoMany libertarians believe in market failures, and (I think) most believe it's possible for markets to NOT fully capitalize on business opportunities. Of course, Cowen is also a market actor. So, I'm not sure where the inconsistency lies.
- waterhouse 8y agoDavid Friedman (anarcho-capitalist)'s comment on market failures is that they do happen, but what might be called government failures also happen, and are probably a worse problem. "Individual actors usually receive most of the benefit and pay most of the cost of their actions, making market failure the exception, not the rule. On the political market individual actors—voters, politicians, lobbyists, judges, policemen—almost never bear much of the cost of their actions or receive much of the benefit. Hence market failure, the exception on the private market, is the rule on the political market." http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Machinery_3d_Edition/Market%20Failure.htm http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Machinery_3d_Edition/Market%20...
- atrilumen 8y agoThis part of the application is making me nervous because I feel like I'm missing something: > what is one mainstream or "consensus" view that you absolutely agree with? (This is our version of a “trick” question, reversing the now-fashionable contrarianism.) I searched Google for variations on the contrarian inverse of the question, but couldn't find anything that seemed relevant. Can you help me?
- atrilumen 8y agoApplied! Slater Systems LLC Wish us luck (Slater and me)