17 ms·
Poor mental health at work 'widespread'
- epx 8y agoDidn't like the sentence 'Poor mental health affects half of all employees', as if employers were responsible.
- kneel 8y ago'Work culture' is an unnatural form of menticide that has increasingly encroached into our lives. Many employers try to hold it back but the general trend has been to select for self sacrificing drones, despite the effects on mental health. The labor strikes have been glossed over in history but they happened for very good reason. IMO they'll happen again.
- flipTrain 8y agoThey are legally referred to as employees. You are tying 'employers' out of thin air. I find that fascinating!
- acct1771 8y agoThey're also legally referred to as citizens of a society.
- onion2k 8y agoIn the context of stress at work, who would be responsible if it's not the employer? For the majority of people their employer wants to pay them as little as possible and get as much effort back as they can, with rigid and bureaucratic rules in place because there's basically no trust in the business. That's stressful. I think the majority of us here on HN are very fortunate in the sense that we either work for an employer who's invested in making sure we're not overly stressed (startups and tech companies are way better than most businesses), or we are the employer and we get to choose how much stress we take on. For the majority of healthy people, especially without kids, work and their employer is their primary source of stress.
- epx 8y agoThis is almost a tautology; of course not working, not doing anything at all would be less stressful. But work is way less stressful today than, say, two generations ago, yet people are falling like flies. I don't deny the problem but the problem is elsewhere.
- onion2k 8y agonot doing anything at all would be less stressful On the contrary, people who are out of work find the loneliness, isolation and lack of feeling like a productive person incredibly stressful.
- adrianN 8y agoTwo generations ago one income was enough for a family and work-work and family-work were split among a couple. Today people are expected to just do both.
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoIn my opinion, a lot of is going to boil down the social issues we've collectively headed towards. Before getting there you really have to consider how much vastly better the work situation is for most Americans today than practically ever before. Today the average American only works 1,765 hours a year. [1] That is less than practically any time in our history. And real compensation is also higher than it's ever been. [2] You'll find the sensationalistic articles constantly reference only real median wages. That misses the great increase in compensation - bonuses, matched retirement/investment plans, insurance, profit-sharing/equity plans, paid time off, paid sick leave days, etc. Only considering the hourly wage by itself, and median at that, is not informative and even disingenuous. The point is we work less and we get more. If you transplanted these conditions back to previous eras, it'd be like imposing a utopia on people! But what else has changed? Now literally the majority of Americans remaining single. And there are also more people living alone than ever before. And when there are married households most have both husband and wife away at work each day. I don't really understand how people manage to live like this, and it seems to me the answer is that they aren't really managing to! A wife is somebody you can rely on, and you somebody they can rely on, in a way far different than a friend or fling. It'd sound metaphorical but perhaps it's quite accurate to say you both literally keep each other sane! Countless studies have shown greater mental health and even greater life expectancy among married couples. We've gone from a hardworking childbearing married nation, to a nation of single childless households working fewer hours than ever before. And this has been, at least in part, precipitated by a variety of social changes we have mostly supported. In any case, not something I'm going to blame on employers. [1] - https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/AVHWPEUSA065NRUG https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/AVHWPEUSA065NRUG [2] - https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/COMPRNFB https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/COMPRNFB
- imperio59 8y agoThe survey is done by a charity that accepts money from corporate sponsors. Dubious source at best, paid shills at worst.
- mc32 8y agoThere is lots wrong with this article, including what you mention, but also, they fail to define what they mean by the terms they use such as: "experienced problems with stress, anxiety or low mood". That can pretty much cover a lot, if not well defined.
- megous 8y agoIt's a PR article to get you on their website, not a scientific study. ;) There you'll probably find more indepth info. Though, I didn't last long on their website. I don't have patience for video/audio, and I couldn't quickly find content on "what is mental health," to them.
- cryptozeus 8y agoYC community at its best :)
- onion2k 8y agoAre you suggesting that there are corporations paying 'shills' to say that workplaces are bad? Why would they do that?
- jquast 8y agoThe very charity that conducted the survey that concludes that "half" of employees have mental health issues, also happens to be a charity to help address mental health issues. Also, they need more money! https://www.mind.org.uk https://www.mind.org.uk > We won't give up until everyone experiencing a mental health problem gets support and respect. In a perfect future where everyone with mental health problems got support and respect, I'm certain this charity would re-define mental health to a more broad definition, so that they could demand to continue funding, rather than voluntarily shutting down after having met their original goals.
- village-idiot 8y agoYeah, no shit. In case you haven't noticed a few of the post-industrial nations are slowly (or quickly) going neurotic.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Ricardus 8y agoPeople certainly seem to be unhappy on incredibly large scales these days. I read an interesting piece in what I think was the Atlantic 6-ish months ago, and it basically boiled down to: We're not broken, our culture is. I wish I could find it again, but I haven't been able to, because it expresses perfectly ideas that I had been meaning to write, for some time.
- usepgp 8y agoI would assume that most people have been unhappy for as long as there have been people.
- danieltillett 8y agoExactly. It seems the better our lives get the more focused people become on trivia. When you are struggling to earn enough money to keep your family alive then concerns like having a fulfilling job are not at the top of your concerns.
- furi 8y agoIt looks to me (really little more than a hunch) more like we've bettered our lives immensely in most physical ways (removing disease, hunger, cold, etc.) but pulled the rug out from under our feet on the social/fulfillment end of things. We've taken an axe to most forms of community (to some extent family as well) and sucked all the necessary social interactions out of every day tasks. It could just be me idealizing a past I didn't have to actually live through, I'm not old enough to have experienced anything else, but it seems like that is where a lot of human happiness and fulfillment comes from.
- danieltillett 8y agoWe tend to idealise the past like it is some sort of costume drama - in reality the community of the past was very restricting. You did whatever your father did if you were a man and raised a dozen kids (most of whom died) if you were a woman. Forget about choice or living the life you wanted. One thing I think many are missing today from our lives is some sort of painful rite of passage struggle to give us perspective. When nothing has gone seriously wrong in your life it is all too easy to focus on the trivial.
- elvinyung 8y agoHere's a possible hot take: when will we start treating this as a systemic and structural issue? When will we stop privatizing the issue of mental health, treating it exclusively as basically chemical imbalances within individual bodies, and start recognizing that there must be something deeper, something perhaps cultural or political, at work here?
- retube 8y agoNot to trivialize people with genuine issues, but experiencing "stress, anxiety and low mood" is completely normal and natural. In fact not experiencing these kinds of emotions from time to time would indicate an issue! I do wonder whether the scope of what's deemed "mental illness" is being widened
- spiritcat 8y agona internet done made us all crazy
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kneel 8y agoPretty sure this study took normal mood fluctuations into consideration. Poor mental health probably means poor mental health.
- frabcus 8y agoMental illnesses have psychological (eg issues from childhood), chemical (eg neurotransmitter balance) and yes social (communication and meaning) aspects. It's easy to pay attention to only one (a definition shift would be social/communication), but all three matter. These illnesses are failure modes at a mid level in the most complex information processing device in the universe. There's a lot going on - it's not so much definition shift, as this is complex, and yes it is a communal cry for help in part.
- mirimir 8y agoMaybe I'm projecting, but what this translates for me is "many people hate their jobs". And of course they often try to hide it, because they need the money. Or the reputation, acknowledgment, or whatever. I've never done well at work that I don't enjoy. Indeed, at work that doesn't show up for me as play. So much so that I've been homeless (or very close to it) at times. But for stuff that I do enjoy, I've tended to get obsessive and driven. Because it's been so much fun, and/or so much of a challenge, and such a rush when things worked out. In other words, I tend to be a workaholic. But otherwise, if it wasn't (or was no longer) fun, I've found myself focusing on something else that was fun. And in many cases, that became my next career. At least four times. For example, I spent several years working as a data geek. But how that started was managing snailmail lists for community groups. In Reflex, an early semi-relational database in DOS. And over a few years, I migrated through Access and eventually SQL Server, and was doing basically forensic accounting on enterprise-scale data. At home ;) My point is that I've been lucky. But many seem to get stuck doing stuff that they can barely stand. Because they're constrained by obligations to family or whatever. And in any case, there are lots of jobs that need done, which too few people would really consider fun.
- flukus 8y ago> And of course they often try to hide it, because they need the money I suspect this is behind at least some of it, there's an expectation that we pretend to love our jobs and pretend everything is great, lest we be branded "not a team player". It's an extra mental tax with no benefit every day of work.
- lettergram 8y agoI've been contemplating this problem since I first met Greg Baugues at UIUC, when he was giving a talk[1]. The thing is, I feel employers actual would / do care about mental health (generally); at least to a point. We're all humans... It's just an uncomfortable topic for pretty much everyone involved. As an employer how do you approach the problem? Ideally, you could identify improvement methods, and implement them. This would make employees happier and work harder; while at the same time make employees have a better life (win-win). This makes me think it has likely more to do with the interaction between the people/employees or the lack of long-term strategy of a business. [1] https://www.greaterthancode.com/2017/05/17/episode-033-mental-illness-with-greg-baugues/ https://www.greaterthancode.com/2017/05/17/episode-033-menta...
- mockingbirdy 8y agoI can recommend Erich Fromm's "The Pathology of Normalcy" - he's a well-known psychotherapist and author of the 20th century. He argues that we have a systematic problem and that treating mental health problems on an individual level is not going to solve the root problem. Basically, the structures we live in make us sick mentally. This book is a great read and shows ways to solve this problem.
- frabcus 8y agoThe news article (and hence the headline problem description figures) are to market the charity's new site which brings together resources for helping with mental health at work. https://www.mentalhealthatwork.org.uk/ https://www.mentalhealthatwork.org.uk/ It looks useful - stuff for line managers, policy stuff, stuff specifically about alcohol etc. Mind are a well respected charity in the UK.
- danieltillett 8y agoThis is what happens when you make the definition of mental illness so loose that almost everyone is captured. While it might help those with an axe to grind or a vested interest in ramping the numbers, it doesn’t help those with serious mental illness problems.
- mirimir 8y agoThat's a useful perspective, I think. I mean, isn't it useful to distinguish between "poor fit for job" and "mental health issues"? Would we expect mentally healthy people to do well, and be happy with, any arbitrary sort of job?
- danieltillett 8y agoThe supposed aim of all this trivialization of mental illness appears to be to destigmatize mental illness, but in practice it just prevent us from helping those who really need help. When 75% of the population is labeled as having a mental illness then we can’t find those who really need help - the finding a needle in a pile of needles problem. The reality is most people are unhappy with their lives (at times) and always have been and only a small percentage are seriously unwell.
- projektir 8y ago> The reality is most people are unhappy with their lives (at times) and always have been and only a small percentage are seriously unwell. If you ask me most people being unhappy with their lives is a problem.
- mirimir 8y agoIsn't that rather a symptom of modern society? As others have noted. Still, it's certainly not that modern society is horrible. Far more people (especially in "developed" countries) live far better lives (materially, anyway) than at any time before. But maybe what's missing is meaning. Family and other social connections. Like "Why am I doing this?" Maybe it's just an unavoidable consequence of the extreme specialization of labor in modern society. And that there are many important jobs that just aren't much fun. Or at least, aren't acknowledged or rewarded well enough. Don't come with enough status.
- cyberjunkie 8y agoIt must be said the influx of mis-information, now over-inflated egoes, greed and terrible mental health of the masses creates a society that is mentally sickening towards others. Every time someone with clarity and genuine intent points that out, society points a finger back, saying nothing is wrong with society. Something is wrong with your attitude. Therein lies the reason for this degrading mental health of the masses.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoMy hot take: This is "patriarchy" at work in an unchecked fashion. Studies of primate groups suggest male leaders protect the group from external threats, such as carnivores or war with other groups. Female leaders protect the group from internal threats. As a woman who is probably some kind of alpha female, I couldn't find any role models that worked for me. I was a full time wife and mom for years and all our leadership models are male models that we expect women to somehow emulate and I could never make sense of it. Reading up on the role of alpha females in primate groups helped me feel functional and not crazy or broken. It gave me a model I could relate to. Women with careers tend to learn male -- or yang -- leadership models. YC claims it is so successful because Jessica was maternal and nurturing and they had sit down dinners like an extended family. And I sometimes think that's what's lacking out in the world of work, that feminine influence that says you need to take care of your people to be successful and not just run them into the ground. /things I expect to regret stupidly voicing
- brickcitymang 8y agoI wish one day I report to a female boss.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI don't know that gender per se fixes it. Historically, men were in charge of certain kinds of work, the kind that is now paid, and women were in charge of other kinds. These complemented each other. As we move away from traditional family and tribe or community based social organization towards more paid work, our male leadership patterns seem to have become more dominant and we have lost that balance. Women with serious careers are frequently socialized to lead like men and they are sometimes harsher than the men as if to "prove" themselves or out of bitterness. I'm not sure how to fix this, but the Jessica Livingston story seems to be the exception, not the rule. From what I gather, she and Paul started the company together as equal partners and he soon roped his previous business partners into it. But it was initially the two of them. When you have a male dominated organization and women rise through the ranks, they seem to typically be broken of such feminine leadership styles. They typically have to lead like a man to get promoted. I'm not sure how we get there because currently the default expectation is that women learn to lead like men to get leadership roles.
- _prototype_ 8y agoI quit my software engineering job last May because of extreme burnout. I took 5 months off and just started working again and feel really good. Something is seriously wrong in this industry
- briandear 8y agoWe sit at a desk writing code. Air conditioning, comfortable chairs, often free snacks and high pay. I realize burnout is real, but until you’ve worked as a refinery worker, on a road crew or a police officer, it’s hard to say that something is wrong with “this” industry. Every single profession has burnout. Every single profession has stress. Most people should be so lucky to have the opportunity to get burned out in one of the highest paying professions. If our industry has a problem, it’s that its practitioners don’t really know what actual suffering on the job is all about. The luxury of taking 5 months off is something unheard of for most typical middle or working class people. Not to diminish burnout, but claiming that the industry has a problem is just incorrect. Some employers might have a problem — but employers in all industries have problems. The best industry in the world has shitty employers and the worst industry in the world has great employers. Any normal working class person would laugh at this. It’s like first class travelers complaining about quality of the champagne at the airport lounge. We are immensely lucky to get to do this job. I get close to burnout from time to time, but then I remember what it was like before I got into this industry when I got evicted and slept in my car while DJing at dirty strip clubs just to be able to afford food. I would have given anything for the chance to burnout sitting in an Aeron working with all this incredible technology. Perspective.
- brickcitymang 8y agoTelling yourself that you have it better than 99% of the world is only a temporary and ineffective remedy to career dissatisfaction. The answer is introspection, finding out what is missing, and the life-long pursuit of self-actualization and eventually transcendence.
- ryandrake 8y agoYou’re absolutely right and you’re getting silently down-voted by cowards who find it uncomfortable to take an honest look at their lives and realize how great they have it compared to 99% of the rest of the labor force in the world. I’ve done manual labor and dead-end fast food service work, and I thank my lucky stars every day that I currently find myself gainfully employed in a comfortable office.
- alayne 8y agoI'm extremely sympathetic to mental health issues, but this article is based on a survey by a mental health charity. This is junk science.
- tw1010 8y agoI used to read articles like this and feel like it gave me some excuse for feeling terrible myself. But then I realized that, nah, I have to just take responsibility for this on my own. Exersize and good (carb limited) diet and a good amount of sleep (and all the necessary vitamins), that was the key to me (not thinking my way out of it). (As well as avoiding toxic people and spending most of my evenings reading[1]. I rarely code on my spare time. That comes with career tradeoffs, but I'm ok with making them.) Sure it sucks that it's widespread, and maybe it aught to have been a call to action for me to fix the situation on a larger scale (create a company to tackle mental health), but those thoughts can prematurely add burden on you while you could've much more quickly solved the problem by simply ignoring all the world and its mental health problems and focus on improving your own life. [1] If you feel like "books are boring" then that's a sign you're not following your bliss. Put down that boring book. There are plenty to go around. You'll read at most maybe 1000 books in your life, and there are without a doubt a thousand books that all make you feel like you can't put it down. If the book you're reading isn't that, eject as soon as possible (before you've sunk even more cost into it) and go out searching for one you think will tickle the interest nodules in your brain to an ecstatic degree.
- projektir 8y agoI think you got it backwards. It's good that this worked for you, but this kind of thinking leads to a race to the bottom where the original cause is continually increased until individuals who can get out of it basically cease to exist. What's important is not whether some individuals can pull out. What's important is the overall effect.
- tw1010 8y agoI totally agree that it's a systemic problem and that society shouldn't ignore it. I'm not trying to shift blame from institution to individuals, it's just that I myself have noticed that thinking too much about how this was a problem in the bigger picture put unnecessary friction in a project that was already challenging enough (going from an unhealthy state to a healthy state). Just because I'm talking about this in public doesn't mean this is how I think the public think about it. Imagine my original comment as advice given in a dimly lit intimate one-on-one conversation, not something I'm shouting from a stage. I want institutions and policymakers to think of it as a systemic problem, but I want individuals to know that the most efficient strategy for they themselves is to ignore all the worlds ills and focus on using their limited energy in a way that is least likely to fail.
- philpem 8y ago"Only half of people talk to their employer about health and MH issues" Well there might be something systemic there.. like the culture of a lot of companies to "manage out" what they see as "troublesome" employees -- union reps and members, the unhealthy... Things like the rampant misuse of Bradford Factor Scoring (which the University of Bradford School of Business disowned some years ago) basically guarantee that taking sick leave or asking for help will result in a dismissal.
- komodosquirrel 8y agoIn Europe specialist jobs are highly taxed. Knowing that every month you have to give away almost 40% of your earnings, how much you had to sacrifice, you start to question whether it all makes sense. Way out is to take anti depressants and pretend everything is fine or ask for a raise so that you get your net pay and what you have been paying in taxes and then try to ignore even more tax you have to pay.
- ACS_Solver 8y agoI'm a software engineer working in Sweden, a country I chose because of its strong welfare society among other things. With a good salary, I'm paying more tax than the majority of Swedes, my marginal tax rate is over 50%, and in the election last weekend I voted to increase one of the taxes in favour of healthcare spending. My point is that paying a lot in tax doesn't necessarily make you less happy, let alone depressed. The way I view it, I'm contributing to a system that ensures affordable education/healthcare for everyone, and extra social assistance for those in need, things I believe really help the society as a whole.
- beaconstudios 8y agoyou're not contributing to that system freely though - the mechanism of the state takes away your agency to freely help others in this way. You can rationalise it that you're contributing to the welfare of others, but the reality is that your money is being taken from you and put into a bucket marked "welfare" that will go to welfare but also be inefficiently wasted, spent in ways you don't agree with, and so on. At least under private charity you can engage in effective altruism (or at the very least claim altruism).
- ACS_Solver 8y agoI have nothing against private charities but see them only as a complement to state-run programs. The social improvement that comes from people having healthcare/education/etc requires that the vast majority of people have it, not some, and not even a simple majority. I view it somewhat similarly to herd immunity through vaccination. When you have a 95% vaccinated population, diseases can be eliminated. When you have a 50% vaccinated population, it's of course good for those 50%, but doesn't provide the same global benefits. Is some of the welfare money wasted due to inefficiency? Yes, of course. But for a task of this scale, which has to provide benefits to everyone in the country, I only trust the state with it, and not a private entity. Can I opt out of the system? No, but freedom isn't a single variable you can straightforwardly optimize for. In this case, I believe the infringement on individual freedom through taxation results in considerably higher total freedom when considering all individuals in the society.
- lazulicurio 8y agoI wonder if there's any historical data back to the late 90s, and how much might be driven by anticipation of future economic conditions. I know at my work there's a sense of---not quite despair, but---waiting for the other shoe to drop. Even though the recession is officially over, the whole system still seems fragile. I'm sure there's other factors at play too, but I feel like at a macro scale the economy is towards the base of a society's pyramid of needs. It's a proxy for availability to food, shelter, etc. James Carville said it best: "it's the economy, stupid". Looking at the CCI[1], although it's recovered a bit since 2008, it's below historical levels. IMO, while there's plenty of other issues, it makes sense to address the more fundamental ones first. But I don't have any solutions---just my two cents. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consumer_confidence_index#/media/File%3AU.S._Consumer_Confidence_Index.png https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consumer_confidence_index#/m...
- mothsonasloth 8y agoThis article makes me think of the time I spent several hours discussing with my grandparents, on how they survived in the 50s, 60s in the UK. At first I was shocked about how my grandfather could finish up his work as a joiner, and then spend another week going around shipyards, factories and other places looking for work. When my granny had my mum she only took two weeks off to look after her. Then started working part time as a seamstress. I asked them if they ever felt sad or depressed and they flat out said no. They said they didn't have the time to be like that. I wonder if I would have been the same if I time travelled back to that era.
- tw1010 8y agoIf you'd grown up in that environment, then yes, of course you would be the same as them back then. Genetics certainly hasn't changed much in two generations.
- amelius 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epigenetics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epigenetics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Memetics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Memetics
- tw1010 8y agoI don't think memetics is applicable in this case since the idea assumed he was born and raised back when his grandparents were. (Same sperm and egg, different culture.) Maybe you're right about epigenetics though, I don't know enough about that.
- krageon 8y agoIt's poorly understood and not a given in the sense that we don't know that it would be different.
- pjc50 8y agoI've heard this line of reasoning before, and it glosses over a lot of the traditional downsides of this lifestyle - things like extremely heavy drinking and public or domestic violence. You got a "tighter" community at the expense of extreme conformism socially enforced.
- fallingfrog 8y agoWell, considering that "work" as it's commonly defined means "tasks done at the orders of a superior", it can hardly help but be mentally harmful. Any task done under the control and for the profit of another is in some sense abuse.
- OnlyRepliesToBS 8y agogiving sociopaths an unlimited supply of cheap, replaceable serfs... and somehow the subordinates' mental health suffers? 2 + 2 might round up to 4... the name of the game of tech is 'cog maker'
- bigbluedots 8y agoI wonder how much of a contribution is made by 'having to work' in order to survive. I suspect that most people would happily never work again if that was an option, and if that is the case then most people are spending a large percentage of their time doing something they don't want to do. At that point, issues with mental health are no surprise.
- seatdrummer 8y agoMany of the comments here align very closely with ideas presented in the unabomber manifesto.