7 ms·
If this is actually true, it is easily provable: if companies have more access to capital than developers, then they should pay more to hire better developers,
by hn_throwaway_99 8y ago
If this is actually true, it is easily provable: if companies have more access to capital than developers, then they should pay more to hire better developers, and you should see developer salaries rise. If this does not happen, it just means they are bullshitting: they can't get developers at the current price they are willing to pay.
- baxtr 8y agoThat’s what the good ones are doing. For the rest it should probably read like: ”Companies worry more about access to cheap software developers than cheap capital” (because it's already cheap right now)
- MichaelApproved 8y agoThat's not necessarily how the reasoning has to work. It's possible companies have access to capital based on current profitability. If they raise employment costs, their profitability changes and their capital access can change as well. It sounds like capital markets are saying, we like this cost structure. Continue it and take more money. Companies are responding saying we can't scale because developers at current costs are rare. They will need to increase costs to hire more.
- dunpeal 8y ago> It sounds like capital markets are saying, we like this cost structure. Continue it and take more money. The capital markets care about the bottom line, not about internal cost structure. So for example, a company with 100 devs and 1 CEO looks exactly the same to "capital markets" if the CEO makes $105m and each dev makes $100k, or if the CEO makes $5m and each dev makes $1.1m. There's quite a large room to change the current cost structure without eating into the margins. Beyond that, those margins at tech companies tend to be quite wide, giving even more room for flexibility.
- sandworm101 8y agoTrue for the market, but markets dont actually give you the money. An investor (or rep) signs the check. When they show up they do indeed look at the structure and decide if they are happy or not with the pay structure.
- dunpeal 8y agoInvestors aren't some mysterious and capricious force that storms into your office and throws a fit over random reasons. They care primarily about one thing: their Return on Investment. If the company becomes more profitable by shifting more comp to developers, then the investor will support that wholeheartedly. Tellingly, some of the most profitable companies right now are those paying their developers the best, e.g. FAANG. Suggesting that paying developers more is a good move, financially, for the employer. Anecdote: I was involved in the hiring process of a certain tech company. The entire company had "engineers are a scarce resource, use sparingly" as a key principle. There were many rules about how to apply that, and people regularly got yelled at by the CEO for violating said rules. Fast forward to a hiring spree. The company was hiring for a particular non-technical position, as well as for engineering. They tell me how much they're paying each position. Pay is the same. The non-technical position had about x20 candidates than open positions. The engineering position had roughly 25% less, before screening out unqualified candidates and those who didn't pass technical interviews. Same pay. Doesn't compute.
- IMTDb 8y agoThe capital markets care about the bottom line, not about internal cost structure. > When you are raising money, the market very much cares about the cost structure.
- dunpeal 8y agoAnd who says "the market" wants engineer's relative share of the comp pie to stay exactly as it is? TFA and all other evidence points to the opposite conclusion: that engineers are becoming some the most valuable resource in the organization, the demand for them is only increasing, so they should be paid accordingly. Therefore, as an investor I'd be quite happy to see my engineers paid very competitively, thus ensuring their retention and performance.
- frisco 8y agoThis is not the case. The large amounts of liquidity available means that startups are easier to fund at a given price, but does not automatically have a big impact on that equilibrium price, which is driven by venture economics. Thus just raising more / paying more is not an automatically good answer if the venture loss / return rates haven’t changed, which they haven’t.
- fipple 8y agoThat’s exactly what’s happened... software engineer salaries at the top end have grown like crazy.
- dunpeal 8y ago> software engineer salaries at the top end have grown like crazy. All I've seen are 30-50% increases over something like a decade. These are hardly "crazy" increases for a field in which profits have gone through the roof, and they only apply to the "top end" as you say. Developers below that top - i.e. the majority - have seen very modest increases at best. Check how much executive pay increased over the same time span, to get an idea of "crazy growth".
- sulam 8y agoNew grad salaries have doubled in the last 20 years. They've gone up about 20% in the last _three_ years, in SF.
- dunpeal 8y agoDo you realize how long of a timespan 20 years is? 20 years ago is 1998, i.e. before the internet revolution and the first bubble! What are the numbers for the past 5 years? That's way more relevant. > They've gone up about 20% in the last _three_ years, in SF. How much did cost of living rise in SF during that time?
- adventured 8y ago20 years is plainly a long time ago for any professional in tech. Your time frames aren't correct though. The Web/Internet revolution ignited in 1994 with Netscape. The dotcom bubble started in August 1995 with the Netscape IPO. By September 1998 (20 years ago), it was already 3/4 of the way to peak bubble and everything was already very crazy. 1998 was prime Internet revolution (also the year Google was founded). The Nasdaq climbed 100% over two years, first hitting 2,000 in mid 1998. The dotcom mania topped out in late 1999, the market topped out shortly thereafter.
- xapata 8y agoSalaries have been rising in some markets.
- chopete 8y agoThis is provable more easily places in hub cities like Bangalore, Bay Area and Seattle. The benefits are trickling down to other cities slowly. Most people who are smart enough to jump ships now have 2-3 offers. In cities like Bangalore, a jump can fetch anywhere from 20-200%. 20% is minimum irrespective of the current salary. Perfect time for anybody who hasn't tried checking this in a couple of years.
- castlecrasher2 8y agoEven those of us who jumped recently can't keep recruiters off them if my LinkedIn messaging is any indication.
- austenallred 8y agoI know engineers at Facebook and Netflix making $500-750k/yr. Does that count?
- anothergoogler 8y agoNo, because the article is about a survey of executives.
- austenallred 8y agoThe parent comment said, “If it’s true that programmers are an undervalued resource then some will be highly paid.” There are many that are highly paid.
- sjg007 8y agoWow! Is that cash or total comp?
- stale2002 8y agoWell, we are seeing this happen, though. I am not sure if you have noticed, but over the last 10 years, software engineering as a career, has grown extremely quickly. Both in number of people joining the careers and also in salaries. I really don't think 150K salaries for new grads, and 100K salaries for recent bootcampers was normal, 10 years ago. Even in San Francisco. And yet in SF, that isn't too uncommon these days.
- joe_the_user 8y agoYou gotta read this stuff carefully. "Access to capital" means people who will loan you money. Most reasonably size companies with a cash flow aren't at a point where no one will loan them more money, even if they are at a point where borrowing more money isn't that good an idea. Basically, it's like saying "Is it easier to max out your credit cards or hire skilled people?" Well, sure it's easier to max out your credit cards, that's easier than a lot of things. Which is to say it's one of those journalist framing of a situation that means nothing.
- ubernostrum 8y agoYou probably want to spend some time reading everything Dan Luu has ever written about hiring and compensation in tech, and then get back to us on whether you still believe this.