5 ms·
GDPR is not enough unfortunately to stop the abuses of credit check agencies. As far as I understand it, them sucking up all your data is a legitimate business
by IshKebab 8y ago
GDPR is not enough unfortunately to stop the abuses of credit check agencies. As far as I understand it, them sucking up all your data is a legitimate business use, and you do have to give consent for it.
What we really need is regulation to limit the amount of information that can be used for credit checks (and insurance premium calculations while we're at it). Actually that is partly done in the UK - e.g. gender cannot be used while calculating car insurance premiums. But sadly they can still ask for your profession, marital status, etc.
- TheCoelacanth 8y agoGDPR does not only regulate what data a business can collect. It also has many other provisions that would be relevant in the Equifax data breach. It requires that appropriate security measures be taken to secure any personal data that you collect, which Equifax obviously failed to do. It also requires that data breeches be disclosed within 72 hours of when they are discovered while Equifax took about nine months to do so.
- mycall 8y agoWhat about the Right to Forget? Can't we ask Equifax to delete all of our information?
- TheCoelacanth 8y agoRight to forget is basically the right to withdraw consent. You can only make them delete things that they needed your consent for in the first place.
- mikekchar 8y agoThis is not actually true. The right to withdraw consent, the right to object and the right to be forgotten are all different. In the first and second case, the company has to stop processing the data, but they don't have to remove it. In the last case, they actually have to remove the data. The removal of data has a caveat that the company doesn't have to do it if it would be onerous (but what that means is left up in the air... so we'll have to see some judgements before we know exactly what it means). In the case of Equifax, they are a third-party processor. Under GDPR, you would have to be informed if the processing was necessary under contract basis. Once the contract is finished, you can request that your data is removed and the original processor must inform all third party processors. So Equifax would be required to remove the data. For legitimate interest or consent basis, you can ask to be removed at any time. You don't have the right to be removed wrt data collected for regulatory reasons. I think the key here is that Equifax (being a third party processor) does not have to respond to you if you say "Please remove all of my data". I think you have to go to the original processor (which sucks, because you have to track down how they got your information). I may be wrong about that, though (the company I work for doesn't collect 3rd party info, so I didn't pay much attention to that part of the law).
- wongarsu 8y agoIf you have to give consent to it, then under GDPR you can withdraw that consent (though not every purpose requires consent). Much more important in this context, GDPR forces you to adequately protect the data you have collected.
- lucb1e 8y agoAnd if you didn't have to give consent, you can object to your data being used anyway. They then have to give a credible reason that counters your objection. I mean, technically the law says you can only process data iff you have a purpose for it and must delete it when you no longer have an immediate purpose for it so I don't really get why there is a separate provision for this, but we all know how this goes (you don't make money by deleting data so nobody is on top of it) so I'm happy that provision is explicitly mentioned. (Disclaimer: besides IANAL, I'm also not actually sure if this was in the text of the law or if this was on the local regulator's site.)
- wongarsu 8y ago> gender cannot be used while calculating car insurance premiums. But sadly they can still ask for your profession, marital status, etc. How is that bad? An insurance works by collecting slightly higher premiums than the expected insurance payout. The more acurately the insurance can predict risk, the better. And if they calulate that some profession/gender/lifestyle/whatever carries a higher risk, it's only fair that those people have to pay more, after all they also cost the insurance more. Having people pay for their risk is also a net-positive force for society. If some profession causes people to be sleep-deprived and have more car accidents, their premiums go up, producing pressure to either reduce the risks or choose other professions. If you don't let insurances factor this in, you are just subsidizing those with riskier lifes.
- xenadu02 8y agoIf you hyper-specialize the risk pools it effectively prices lots of people out of the market, causing their risk pools to collapse. Insurance also loves to write exclusions if they aren’t prohibited. By your logic health insurance should exclude sickle-cell anemia coverage for black customers. For insurance to work as intended, it has to be spread across a large population and it needs to cover a wide variety of perils. Where insurance can be a force for societal good it should be allowed to discriminate. For example, insisting on better fire safety. Or basing your car insurance rate on your car’s safety rating. P.S. Insurance works by making money off the float, not by collecting more in premiums than they pay out. The expected payout is around 100% over the long run, but the payout happens over time. Until it does, the insurance company holds the money and uses it to make money. (Granted, in this low-interest-rate environment insurance companies may set the payout ratio a bit more favorably since the float makes them less money, but competition effectively helps keep a cap on that). Mutual insurance companies (owned by their policy holders) are different. Any profit of a returned to the policy holders, so there’s no incentive to set rates higher than required. However the tragedy of the commons kicks in: if they offer lower rates to high-risk groups, they tend to attract the worst of those groups, causing higher losses - especially with health insurance. That’s part of the reason government regulation of insurance is the way it is, the other being gross mis-management causing insurance companies to go bankrupt and be unable to pay out during times when people need it the most.