7 ms·
No surprise to see a number of weather apps on here. Seems to be such an incredibly scummy category. The built in Apple app is fine for basic information. Ther
by MBCook 8y ago
No surprise to see a number of weather apps on here. Seems to be such an incredibly scummy category.
The built in Apple app is fine for basic information. There are plenty of high-quality third-party apps. Weather Line (my fav) is $2. DarkSky is $4.
Instead people go for these weird free apps covered in ads with terrible UIs. The NOAA one isn’t made by the government, seems like using that name should be some kind of copyright infringement.
Of course WeatherBug on desktops was adware/malware for a very long time. Maybe it still is.
Then you get scareware stuff like the earthquake notification app. You better let us track everything you do otherwise you might die!
There are so many good apps on the store made by good developers. It’s amazing how much better your experience is if you just avoid free apps when possible.
Of course some of these apps, like the ones that you NEED to use for certain parking meters, are especially evil because there is an any choice. If you need that service, you’re giving up your privacy.
I wish Apple would crack down on this stuff. I imagine a lot of these apps are doing things that already violate the App Store guidelines. If they don’t, they probably SHOULD.
- dwighttk 8y ago>There are so many good apps on the store made by good developers. It’s amazing how much better your experience is if you just avoid free apps when possible. Yes. It cannot be emphasized enough. Go pay for apps that are good.
- kupiakos 8y agoWhile generally true, I've also found free apps are usually decent and not-scummy if they're open source.
- magnetic 8y agoCould you give us some examples? I'd like to go check them out.
- modzu 8y agogenerally a good rule of thumb, though ive also seen a few cases of a good open source app having a bunch of scummy forks that end up being more popular on the app store (eg shuttle vs phonograph). i wonder if google promotes apps with advertising more than their ad-free counterparts? the conflict of interest is so obvious but i digress..
- mikekchar 8y agoGenerally I trust the Fdroid repository much more than I trust Google's repository. Though if Fdroid became very popular with the masses I don't think that could continue to be the case, unfortunately. It's a difficult problem to weed out the bad apps...
- modzu 8y agothanks for the link to fdroid, have never used it but it looks promising!
- threatofrain 8y agoThe best free apps I've found are just business moats to point you to another money maker. As callous as I'm phrasing it, those free apps tend to be leagues better than the population of paid apps.
- ekianjo 8y agoFDroid on Android has tons of FOSS apps that are quite good. Its a false dichotomy.
- rootlocus 8y agoIt's not a false dichotomy if you remember these arguments aren't generic, they're for the apple store.
- ekianjo 8y agoI thought we were talking about smartphones in general?
- jplayer01 8y agoHow do I get FDroid on my iPhone?
- ekianjo 8y agoYou dont have to restrict yourself to using an Iphone. Embrace choice.
- jtbayly 8y agoOthers have pointed out that there are good free apps. But more interestingly, there are bad paid apps. Take this paid Mac app for instance: https://gizmodo.com/top-apple-mac-app-secretly-sends-your-browser-history-t-1828881137 https://gizmodo.com/top-apple-mac-app-secretly-sends-your-br... What I’d really like to know is whether anybody has any evidence whatsoever that paid apps in these same categories don’t do exactly the same things in exactly the same percentages.
- dwighttk 8y agoIt is a simple rule and there are definitely exceptions in both directions. (Good free apps, bad paid apps) The safest assumption to make is that if you give an app permission to access information from your device that the information will be shared with a nefarious actor. From there, if you want to get benefits from uploading your information, you can make adjustments like "Oh, I know this guy, he's been making apps for a long time and seems trustworthy." or "This is a larger company and isn't likely to be bought just to strip mine their customer data. Additionally they probably have safeguards in place to keep rogue employees from running off with it." None of those is fail-proof, but it's all about risk.
- jtbayly 8y agoThe more I think about it, the more I think it is appropriate to say if an app is free, you are the product and can assume they will extract every bit of value from you that they can. If an app is paid, there is at least the possibility you aren’t the product. But you still might be.
- walterbell 8y agoIn the US, high quality weather data and forecasts can be bookmarked as a web page/icon for your zip code, https://www.weather.gov https://www.weather.gov. Works well and no data leakage.
- crtasm 8y agoBut you do get Google analytics and the dodgy sounding 4seeresults.com and cfigroup.com embeds.
- walterbell 8y agoI wonder if those are blocked by iOS content blockers, e.g. Firefox Focus.
- modzu 8y agoshameless plug for my app true weather: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=net.conceptualspace.trueweather https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=net.conceptual... Privacy policies don't need to be complicated: "TrueWeather does not collect any personal information."
- kbenson 8y agoThe problem is when not being complicated means they are aren't truthful. Do you track crashes? Do you have any logging that tracks an IP address? I view my dedicated home IP as personal, if not all that private, information. Does minimal logging actually require storing personal information? Is there a common, or legal definition of what personal information is? I'm all for simple policies, but I would also rather they be accurate, and I would hate to see people who are trying to do good by having a simple policy like that end up in trouble because the law doesn't quite agree.
- modzu 8y agothe app collects no data whatsoever. i have no idea what your IP address is (the app connects directly to environment canada to retrieve the raw radar data). no crash data/telemetry is collected automatically, but bug reports are welcome on the github repo. so please don't insinuate that this policy is not true. and yes, there is a legal definition of personal information. since im based in canada, that would be as defined by PIPEDA (the Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act)
- willstrafach 8y agoIt is totally awesome that you are not doing anything creepy, but I hope you can understand that some folks are going to be more wary nowadays and that is not a bad thing IMO.
- kbenson 8y agoI'm not trying to insinuate your policy isn't true, but to note that a simple policy isn't always applicable, and it might be a little complicated. All the "you"'s in my original comment can be taken as the "general you", not you specifically. I wasn't trying to insinuate your policy was wrong (I actually assumed it was likely correct, a weather app doesn't generally require much in the way of server support from anything except the weather service), but that "Privacy policies don't need to be complicated" might be a bit optimistic for a lot of apps.
- rjvir 8y agoI bet Apple will crack down on these location tracking SDKs, but it likely wouldn't eliminate this type of tracking. The main reason these apps are getting caught is because they are blatantly including the SDKs of the monetization firms in their client apps, and transparently sending data directly to the servers of those firms. But what's to stop a weather app from just doing it server-side, so it's undetectable to third parties? For instance, a weather app must send location data to some backend, in order to fetch weather data. That backend could send the location data to these exact same monetization firms. It would be difficult for Apple to detect and block this behavior.
- willstrafach 8y agoThe firms would then have a much harder time knowing if the information is genuinely from end users, if they no longer collect directly from user devices.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoBasically, the scoundrels don't trust other scoundrels. That's what's saving us from getting server-rendered first-party ads on most websites, that would make adblocking much more difficult.
- reitanqild 8y agoActually server side rendered ads would be a whole lot more acceptable to me compared to what we have today: less bloat, less risk of malware injection. Personally, I could live with a some advertising if that is how it was served and it was slightly relevant. When they want to try to track me around the web to see what technical and news sites I visit and then serve me ads for dating sites then I'll just turn on ny adblock again ;-)
- throwawaymath 8y agoWhat you're describing already happens. The only way to defeat that is with client-side mitigations like uBlock. DNS-level mitigations like Pi-Hole will stop the content from loading if the ads aren't loaded.
- samstave 8y agoI just think that installing a weather app in general is stupid. I just dont see the actual need to have one installed for the vast majority of people. Systems need weather apps/information: ships/boats, planes, etc... Your phone does not. Nor your desktop. There was a ship that was getting delayed weather information [0] and it sank and people died - and so its clearly important to track weather on ships and plans and transport that will be at risk in inclement weather. Otherwise, look out the window, or read the weather off google. Never install a weather app... [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YxTwfYH-PwI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YxTwfYH-PwI
- Doctor_Fegg 8y ago“Read the weather off Google” is weird advice in a thread about companies collecting user data, given that no one does more of that than Google.
- samstave 8y agomy point is that i dont need to install an app to type "temp in sf" in google and see if a jacket is needed.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoIt's a convenience/UX thing. Also, "read the weather off google" is essentially equivalent to having a very shitty weather app, with crappy UX and which requires you to always be on-line (whereas decent weather apps will cache their forecasts).
- kiallmacinnes 8y ago> The NOAA one isn’t made by the government, seems like using that name should be some kind of copyright infringement. I'm pretty sure copyright doesn't apply here! It's possible it's a trademark infringement? (No idea if the name or acronym are trademarked though), or possibly impersonation of a government entity? Either way, it's certainly not a copyright issue to use the name.
- MBCook 8y agoYou’re right, trademark infringement just what I should’ve written. It’s probably fine legally. They’re showing new NOAA weather data, so calling it a “NOAA weather“ or “NOAA Radar” is correct, just misleading.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoUsually "misleading" is what Trademarks are intended to prevent. If it's misleading (in the EU at least) then it's most likely an infringement. "NOAA weather" as the app name implies that the direct source of the _app_ is NOAA, "Weather using NOAA data" and similar wording disambiguates and avoids trademark infringement (and/or passing off ["misappropriation"/misrepresentation in USA] - which is a very weak unregistered version of Trademark which this situation nonetheless appears to fall foul of).
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- xenophonf 8y agoThe Lanham Act prevents anyone from registering trademarks that "Consists of or comprises the flag or coat of arms or other insignia of the United States, or of any State or municipality, or of any foreign nation, or any simulation thereof": https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/15/1052 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/15/1052 That includes government agencies themselves: https://cases.justia.com/federal/appellate-courts/cafc/12-1356/12-1356-2013-10-01.pdf https://cases.justia.com/federal/appellate-courts/cafc/12-13...
- hrktb 8y agoI think weather is a difficult subject for apps. A bit like calendar or to do lists, aside from the very basics, everyone wants something different. And people don’t like paying in general, but all the more so if they feel their needs are not completely met. I remember PocketCast founder explaining they started iOS dev with a weather app for Australia because none really worked for their country. This is also evident in all the local apps in every country. DarskSky you mention isn’t even available internationaly for instance. A flurry if low quality but free and mildly niche apps seems inevitable.
- awiesenhofer 8y agoI never understood why one needs seperate apps for all these basic informations. I just use homescreen bookmarks to my trusted weather/news/sports sites. Not only are they more secure and ad-free, they load faster too.
- acdha 8y agoIt depends on where you live. In Southern California I really didn’t care but on the east coast Dark Sky’s push notifications for imminent rain are handy. That app's also interesting because they also make forecast.io, which is a great example of a modern web app being competitive with an app on most fronts other than notifications.
- jimnotgym 8y ago> Of course some of these apps, like the ones that you NEED to use for certain parking meters, are especially evil because there is an any choice. If you need that service, you’re giving up your privacy. Which of course makes it a direct violation of GDPR. I hope a group of European citizens take some action
- phobosdeimos 8y agoActually you don't need to give location. Parking meters have a four digit code written on them that you can use instead. Location is just for convenience.
- PunchTornado 8y agoAdware Doctor, the number one paid utility in the Mac App Store, is secretly logging the browser history of users, and sending it to a server in China. The app is currently listed on Apple's Mac App Store as the company's fourth-highest "Top Paid" software programs, behind Final Cut Pro, Magnet and Logic Pro X. It is also the store's No. 1 paid utility. The app currently costs $4.99, is validly signed by Apple, and its listing on the Mac App Store is accompanied a majority of lavishly positive five-star reviews.
- MBCook 8y agoThere are exceptions everywhere. That case is really odd. I read the article about it. It’s really questionable how it got that high up in the App Store, and it’s from a developer who has ripped off other peoples apps and done questionable things in the past. It wouldn’t surprise me if the developer had used shady tactics to “buy“ a lot of copies of the app to push it up the rankings so that they could start to lure in real users. More than anything it just looks like Apple was asleep at the wheel with a sketchy developer.
- Krasnol 8y agoIn Germany the German Meteorological Office has their own app https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=de.dwd.warnapp https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=de.dwd.warnapp https://itunes.apple.com/de/app/warnwetter/id986420993?ls=1&mt=8 https://itunes.apple.com/de/app/warnwetter/id986420993?ls=1&... The basic weather warning features are free. The whole weather app costs 1,99€. It's been sued recently by a commercial app company (which also uses their data) for providing the service for free. So normal citizens have now to pay for it (even though they pay for the Office already through their taxes but well...that's capitalism for you). They offer a free version for people who work for fire departments etc. though. This is the only app I've ever payed for on a app store.
- octosphere 8y ago> It’s amazing how much better your experience is if you just avoid free apps when possible. It doesn't necessarily follow that because an app is free that it has a higher probability of being malicious. If anything developers will introduce malicious code into paid apps because those types of users typically have money in their iTunes account and are more interesting / have a better list of credentials to steal than 'freeloader' type users.
- TravisLS 8y agoOn the flip side, the market prices for most of these tracked data are not very high. It's only lucrative to sell this data if you have a very large user base. For paid apps with smaller user bases, the incremental revenue is likely negligible.
- Too 8y ago> Of course some of these apps, like the ones that you NEED to use for certain parking meters, are especially evil because there is an any choice. If you need that service, you’re giving up your privacy. It's amazing neither iOS nor Android has a location picker/Intent that can be launched by the OS to give an app a one time location. Like the ones that exist for contacts, picking photos or sharing links[1]. For parking meter apps i only want to give location access when i press the "find closest parking" button, never else. While we are on the topic, app store reviews should also be much stricter on enforcing usage of standard Intents. Many apps request full contact list, camera and full file system permission when they could use Intents for all their use cases. Maybe enforcing is a bit strict but apps not following the spirit of the OS architecture and requiring more permissions than needed should be ranked lower in app store rating and search results. [1] https://developer.android.com/guide/components/intents-common https://developer.android.com/guide/components/intents-commo...