16 ms·
YouTube's tendency to push everyday users toward politically extreme content
- msie 8y agoSilicon Valley is ruining the world. Between programming nerds and business bros you have no one to look out for the consequences of social media.
- anticensor 8y agoI misread as "Silicon valley is running the world".
- Proven 8y agoYeah humans are stupid and can’t make good decisions without government’s rules shaping what they see or don’t see. So let’s put some ehm, people, in charge of deciding what the masses should decide... The other problem I have with this crap is, anyone who isn’t radical in their thinking (including against annoying busybodies in the government, especially public education system) is either a psychopath or statist (or both).
- dang 8y agoThis is a substantive article. We've changed the title to a representative sentence from the main text, in the hope of not plummeting straight into national-race-ideology war. If you post in this thread, please don't post that kind of thing. It just leads to predictable flamewars. Instead, follow the site guidelines. They include "Comments should get more civil and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive," Eschew flamebait," and "Please don't use Hacker News primarily for political or ideological battle." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- cliffordthedog 8y agoSeemingly mostly right wing content.
- Alex3917 8y agoSee also Danah Boyd's talk on how media literacy classes push some students toward extremism. The gist is that schools have been promoting programs where students are taught not to take what they see in the media at face value, and to go Google/YouTube it for themselves. Which, because of the sorts of things discussed in this article, results in a certain percentage of students becoming radicalized and basically (or literally) becoming nazis. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0I7FVyQCjNg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0I7FVyQCjNg
- CzechTech 8y agoWe should all blindly trust what the NYT and CNN tell us. Otherwise we risk becoming Nazis. That's what you just wrote. Good job.
- benbenolson 8y ago> We should all blindly trust what news articles tell us, otherwise we risk becoming Nazis. I search facts behind news articles all the time, but never find anything even closely related to the Third Reich. Am I doing it wrong?
- chriswarbo 8y agoI suppose there's a need for "Internet literacy" (or "Google literacy"). One rule I instinctively follow is, if I find some claim surprising, e.g. "there was more X under president Y, than president Z", I will search for something like "X USA graph", look for a source I recognise (and hence know the credibility and biases of), and see if the data supports either or neither of those alternatives. I will specifically not search for "X president Y" or "X president Z" because that will be priming the algorithm to confirm my biases.
- DavidWoof 8y agoThe focus of this article is on right-wing extreme content, but I think the tendency is true on both sides. The fact is that partisans are more likely to seek out news content, and partisans are happier with content that matches their prior viewpoint. And so the extreme content rises in popularity and is presented as the recommended option to the less partisan. It's a worthwhile question as to whether this is a flaw in the algorithm or if the algorithm is simply accurately mirroring democratic preferences. Maybe everyone's tendency is toward more politically extreme content, and youtube is simply giving the people what they want. Which is, after all, what YouTube probably sees as the correct goal.
- jpfed 8y agoI suspect that enough differences may exist between liberal and conservative subpopulations that there may be differences in the media they prefer to produce and consume. For example, talk radio is much more popular for the right wing than the left. Left wing commentators and performers have occasionally tried to break into talk radio and they generally don't accrue an audience. Given that, I wouldn't be surprised if YouTube in particular (or any one site by itself) had more right-wing extreme content than left-wing extreme content. Left-wing extreme content may exist in equal proportion overall without having much of a presence specifically on YouTube.
- meowface 8y agoPodcasts are starting to become a more varied mix of left and right (though popularity-wise, still probably skewed to the right).
- throwaway2048 8y agoIt is important not to put the cart before the horse, its youtube that controls recommendations, thought various mostly opaque means. Do not confuse that with what people want, you hear plenty of stories about how somebody watched some $stupid_shit and then their recommendations are pure $stupid_shit for the next two weeks.
- DanBC 8y ago
- saagarjha 8y agoIt's repeatedly emphasized in the article that the recommendations algorithm gives viewers "what they want to see" and what has high engagement. Unfortunately it looks like these criteria seem to push towards fringe and extreme content because that's what evokes people are interested in watching and causes them to react. YouTube, on its part, probably does not intend for it to be this way, but seeing as its goals are the same (albeit to maximize ad revenue using these guides), I'm not optimistic in this being fixed unless there's a massive rethink on how to surface content to users.
- goes 8y agoThe fix is not complicated. They have to play with the control variables producing the feedback loops. People and content creators are influenced by the view/like/dislike count. Instant feedback through these counts produces all kinds of unintended consequences. Instant feedback is overrated and unnecessary. It's like constantly getting a live upvote/downvote from your spouse or boss or prof on everything you do. What kind of behaviour does anyone think this produces? In such real time conditioning environment ppl turn into rats in a B F Skinner experiment. The Russians or any bad actor don't have to create content anymore. Just find a lunatic and encourage/prop them up with views and upvotes. YouTube will then take care of distribution triggered by the view and like counts. Hide or delay the counts to both the creator and viewer and the world changes over night. The experiment can be run on HN. Hide the upvotes on certain controversial threads and see what kind of conversations happen.
- joe_the_user 8y agoJust anecdotally, Youtube's recommendation system seems effectively self-referential. On virtually any subject I look at, recommended videos seem to cycle between just a few themes or even just a few specific videos. I think there's a logical reason for this. I imagine for a given topic you wind-up with: [broad video] related to [other broad but unrelated video] plus [extremist video]. And [extremist video] related to [other extremist video only] Since youtube's recommendation system is entirely naive, once you choose [extremist video], that is the video that gives the system the more specific clue and thus [other extremist videos] will be what's recommended. It's a function of naive recommendations as such. If a system knows that X likes two videos, one that the entire population likes, one that only "metal heads" like. What can it recommend? Metal is the only sensible thing. And if the system then shunts many people to metal and they seem to like it, metal will count even more as a logical recommendation.
- jdminhbg 8y agoI see the same thing on a completely uncontroversial subject: music videos. If I watch e.g. a Beatles video, the recommendations aren't [Rolling Stones, Kinks, Badfinger, ...], they're always [Beatles, Beatles, Beatles, ...]. I don't know if it's naive and bad or if it's actually good for engagement and I'm just an outlier in what I expect to get.
- gboudrias 8y agoI only wish I would get songs by the same band... It sort of seems like Youtube tries its darndest to steer me away from the current band. I'd be happy if it just cycled between hits from the same artists, but I've never seen it do this recently. I think what's most frustrating about it is I don't know what game they're playing. Recommendations used to be logical, now they're almost a waste of screen real estate. What even happened?
- anticensor 8y agoDislikes and "not interested" are important.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ardy42 8y ago> Perhaps most striking is what was absent. The algorithm rarely led back to mainstream news coverage, or to liberal or centrist videos on Chemnitz or any other topic. Once on the fringes, the algorithm tended to stay there, as if that had been the destination all along. I wonder if part of the problem is the "news coverage" on YouTube is mostly amateur. People in the mainstream don't feel the need to produce amateur news coverage, since that's done professionally. However, people on the fringes produce and consume vast quantities of amateur news content, because there's so little fringe content that's professionally made. That leads to a large, focused single that Youtube's algorithms have trouble filtering out because they're too coarse and they confuse activity for quality.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dwaltrip 8y agoI use incognito mode for probably close to half of the YouTube videos I watch, as a defense against the algorithm. That technique, plus freely using the "not interested" button, has actually resulted in a pretty good experience.
- nnq 8y agoSame here. After getting bombarded with extermist-ish content after watching some random socio-politics video, now I use incognito for lots of stuff I watch on YT that's not tech/science/unpolarized-art/business.
- pasquinelli 8y agoI actually want youtube to recommend me videos, because it recommends me stuff i'm interested in a good deal of the time. I can keep it fairly clear of toxic content in the same way i can keep my garden fairly clear of weeds: constant vigilance.
- dwaltrip 8y agoYeah, perhaps I wasn't completely fair. For some of the content I watch, I'm quite happy with what they recommend. But as you said I have to be constantly vigilant with the rest.
- CzechTech 8y agoLike CNN said, it's up to them to interpret for the people. Now back in line sheep, and get ready to be sheared...
- b0rsuk 8y agoThis was addressed more broadly in "We're building a dystopia just to make people click on ads" by Zeynep Tufekci on TED. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15891014 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15891014 She remarked that Youtube's recommendation system invariably pushes people towards more extreme views on anything, not just politics. Interested in vegetarianism? Here's something about veganism. She has a hypothesis it works this way because the goal is to make people spend as much time on a site as possible, and feeding people progressively more extreme content works for that. My comment: what does it say about us humans that we fall for progressively more extreme stuff? Perhaps that few people actually hold balanced views and nowadays a compromise is looked down upon and a mark of a weak character?
- walrus01 8y agoI very strongly recommend watching the video of Zeynep's presentation on this subject.
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoI think the answer lay almost entirely with echo chambers. These exist not only in the digital world, but even increasingly in the real world as people connect to people through digital filtering. Vegetarianism is a good example. Many, though not all, vegetarians are going to be going in that direction due to some form of objection to how animals are treated. But when you surround them with nothing but other people who hold views that are at least as far away from the mean, they're going to suddenly seem quite trite. And this pushes people ever further down one path or another. By contrast when you have a diverse array of views, the real position of stances can be clearly seen. That is to say for one that agrees that eating meat implies inherent mistreatment of animals, vegetarians are already taking a more active stance than ~97% of Americans. The same would be approximately true for those that e.g. go for fish + veggie diets. But in a world where those 3% are surrounded by only those 3%, vegetarians are extremely 'conservative' in their views. The whole thing is people need to surround themselves with a good number of people they disagree with on things. But this is not an easy thing to do, and so most people do not. And in fact even things like voting systems on these social media sites discourage such behavior. Many people do not downvote as a matter of something being inappropriate, they downvote because of disagreement. And that pushes views that go against the plurality's grain further and further out of site to the point that people no longer even think they exist. And of course on another site the exact view bias is instead being pushed to the top with everything else being removed out of the groupthink. It's not a very dangerous problem for a democratic nation.
- paradite 8y agoFor people who are new to this topic and find it to be surprising: This is not new. There is a term for this called "echo chamber": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Echo_chamber_(media) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Echo_chamber_(media) I have observed this trend happening on Internet since 2014 and written about it in my blog: https://paradite.com/2014/11/11/internet-polarized-society/ https://paradite.com/2014/11/11/internet-polarized-society/ Previously it was more for closed communities like reddit and Facebook groups, but seems like now it is also substantial on open platforms.
- 0x4f3759df 8y agoI've only ever heard the term 'echo-chamber' as a pejorative against people who hold anti-establishment views, ie 'Hillary lost because middle America is stuck in right wing / alt-right echo chambers.' It's appears to be a derivation of the 'conspiracy theorists are mentally ill argument' or 'Yes, people hold these views, but its not their fault, choose one (mental illness/echo chamber).
- fareesh 8y agoThe international corporate media has not been honest in its reporting of the refugee situation in Europe. This is becoming clearer year by year, because some of the facts that were earlier dismissed as racist rhetoric are now becoming very difficult to ignore. For example earlier this year, Chancellor Merkel finally admitted that there are "no-go" zones in the country where even the police dare not go. This is an extremely serious problem. People flock to this content because they are not getting the whole truth from the corporate media, and that is the root of this problem. YouTube's content would not be compelling if these things were being reported honestly, and given the same degree of volume as other important stories. In my country, India, there are plenty of places in which the value systems are completely at odds with ideas of gender equality, religious tolerance, racial equality, and LGBT equality. If a western country were to create pockets of populations where people held these values, it would be extremely incompatible with the norm in the societies that they have achieved today. As a result, these places would be radically transformed into incredibly dangerous areas, particularly for women and LGBT folks. It is not bigoted to point this out, it is true because this reality exists in our country, and it is one that we are aware of and grapple with. Of course it will exist in another country if a large enough number of people who hold these ideas are imported en masse. If these values existed in Syria or Sudan or other parts of the world where refugees are coming from, of course this will become a problem for the country that is resettling them. This was a valid criticism that did not get a fair enough deal from the media, and the consequences have been life altering for many Europeans. The dream of multicultural societies where everyone lives together in harmony requires everyone to buy into it. If there are bad actors, and others are aware of this, it does not make them bad actors too. The media seems to have been hesitant, perhaps because of fears of stoking xenophobia by providing it with legitimate information that could be compelling for their cause. There is never a good reason not to tell the truth about these things, this is the result of what happens when you go down that path. At this point, many are convinced that the news media had sinister and not well intentioned motives, behind why this was done, and as a result trust in the news media too will decline rapidly, in favor of rag tag YouTube operations.
- erikpukinskis 8y agoIt can be true and racist at the same time. If you never care about rapes except when it’s a dark skinned perpetrator in a white dominated country, then you are both racist and correct that that rape amongst refugees is an important issue.
- ahana27 8y agoInstead of trying to solve the "problem" of YouTube showing pro-AfD content to users who are searching for information on a stabbing, how about removing asylum seekers from Germany so people don't get stabbed in the first place? Saying "we shouldn't let asylum seekers enter the country because they might be dangerous and we don't have enough information on them to assess the situation correctly" shouldn't be an "extreme position" to begin with!
- meowface 8y agoBecause greatly increasing the suffering of millions of people who flee a warzone just because some of their ranks are criminals, extremists, or terrorists posing as refugees is very unfair to the vast majority of these people. People shouldn't be allowed in without vetting, but refugees need to go or be placed somewhere.
- ahana27 8y agoIt also is not an extreme position to say that that is not my problem, that I don't care, and that I don't want to sacrifice my safety to help them.
- jazzyjackson 8y agoClimate change is going to make refugees everyone's problem (if it doesn't make you a refugee yourself) so I would encourage you to keep your eyes open for effective means of absorbing migrant populations.
- ahana27 8y agoActually no, it doesn't have to be our problem: in an extreme case we can just shoot to kill.
- ronilan 8y agoI am the YouTube algorithm and I recommend these related comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17939803 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17939803 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17939859 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17939859
- partycoder 8y agoMost useless recommendations: "Can you cast obsidian?", "Important videos" aka Yee
- meowface 8y agoI'd argue Yee is quite important and not useless, though. It's brought joy to many.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- alexey454545 8y agoHello everyone, my name is Alexey. After my relationship with David for years, he broke up with me, I did everything to get him back, but all was in vain, I wanted him back so much because of the love I have for him. I explained my problem to my friend and she suggested that I should rather contact a spell caster who could help me cast a spell to bring him back, but I'm the type who never believed in the spell, I had no choice but to try it, I mailed the spell caster, and he told me it was no problem everything will be okay before three days, that my ex will return to me before three days, he cast the spell and surprising in the second day, it was around 16:00. My ex called me, I was so surprised, I answered the call, and all he said was that he was so sorry for everything that happened that he wanted me to return to him, he loves me so much. I was so happy and went to him, that was how we started living together happily again. Since then I have made the promise to anyone I know to have a relationship problem, I would be helpful to the person by referring him or her to the only real and powerful spell caster who helped me with my problem. If you have any problem whatsoever, contact him on this email: drasakaspelltemple@gmail.com Contact him for the following and see the great work of Dr Asaka: 1) Love Spells 2) Lost Love Spells 3) Divorce Spells 4) Marriage Spells 5) Binding Spell. 6) Breakup Spells 7) Banish a past Lover 8.) You want to be promoted in your office/ Lottery spell 9) want to satisfy your lover Contact this great man if you are having any problem for a lasting solution through email: drasakaspelltemple@gmail.com
- dprescott 8y agoI was a casual youtube watcher. I am talking 2012 style fail videos, music videos, and broad areas of interest. Now I can not stand YT. 1st, they have clearly decided that they want to compete with IG as their 'Trending' section is nothing more than influencers. 2nd, it is likely the case but the 'Trending' section is always loaded with liberal, nonsensical, click bait videos, and artist of no interest to me. I am clearly no longer their target demo.
- slig 8y agoTheir trending section is much like TV: content build for the masses. Log in and like videos that you enjoy, and you'll have a personalized recommendation page that excellent, in my opinion.
- ericdykstra 8y agoThis article seems a bit sensationalized. The examples they give are a single video with 500,000 views, and a couple of channels whose views average 20-30k. If YouTube is recommending "extreme" channels so often, why aren't they getting more views? > “Lies, propaganda and manipulation are harmful for society, but on their own are not illegal — and so our hands are often tied,” said Mr. Ipsen, of the government-linked internet monitor. Good. I think it's insane that the German government is even trying to establish a Ministry of Truth. It seems now more than ever, we are getting biased reporting from mainstream media outlets, and I guarantee that any government crackdown would not include these mainstream news sources. Here's an example from just a couple of days ago: CNN's Chris Cuomo as well as a number of major news outlets reported on Judge Brett Kavanaugh "snubbing" Fred Guttenberg, father of a victim of the Parkland shooting, by not shaking his hand at the event. None of these outlets bothered to mention that the day before on Twitter, Guttenberg said: "I will be at Kavanaugh hearings and I hope to play a role in ensuring that this man does not become the next Supreme Court Justice." (https://twitter.com/fred_guttenberg/status/1036600460726161408 https://twitter.com/fred_guttenberg/status/10366004607261614...) They also didn't mention that Guttenberg was the only one trying to approach Kavanaugh, or that Kavanaugh's kids were removed from the room for safety concerns shortly prior. That seems like manipulation to me. I don't say this because I want CNN banned, or anything like that. I'm just completely against any censorship, especially government censorship, of ideas. I believe in the liberal values of free exchange of ideas (or "Liberal Science" as Jonathan Rauch calls it, in his excellent book, Kindly Inquisitors).
- ehsankia 8y agoAbsolutely. Those numbers are peanuts in Youtube scale. Popular Youtube videos regularly get 10m+ views. It's similar to back when WSJ went digging for days and managed to find 2-3 racist videos with 10k views, then refreshed them until a Coca-Cola ad showed, to screenshot it. Most of these are manipulating reality to drive their narrative. I've yet to see a proper scientific and thorough example of this actually happening.
- ericdykstra 8y agoYeah, just pluggin in the "far-right figure on YouTube" that they highlight under the heading "From fringe to mainstream" into Social Blade, you can see just how "mainstream" this guy is: https://socialblade.com/youtube/channel/UCYo2MjFS5C7Wynyty9wTM7g https://socialblade.com/youtube/channel/UCYo2MjFS5C7Wynyty9w... Subscriber rank: 347,946th Video view rank: 680,665th If YouTube is promoting this content so much, at the very least you would expect the video view rank to be higher than the subscriber rank, right?
- puppymaster 8y agoAnecdotal but +1. Watched a couple Jordan Peterson videos and YT started recommending far right wing channels everywhere. Identity politics is exactly the kind of thing he preached against.
- bachbach 8y agoThat is not meaningful. In Germany a new edition of Mein Kampf was published - and it sold a lot of copies. Nearly all of those copies were to people who were already anti-Nazi. I read all sorts of stuff - doesn't mean I buy it.
- hguhghuff 8y agoYouTube needs to ban accounts that republish TV news.
- stareatgoats 8y agoThe west has long lived by the rule of laissez-faire, until something bad happens and only then try and fix things up. It has been effective albeit somewhat risky. We are still in early, lassez-faire days of the internet, meaning we have got a lot to learn about funneling the vast sea of information responsibly. Maybe we'll learn it eventually, without sacrificing core democratic values like freedom of expression in the process. This problem in particular seems to be caused by the need for ads (since the recommendation engine seems to be geared towards clicking on ever new videos). Maybe a solution to this and similar issues that currently turns the internet into a sewer is to promote a 'responsible ads policy' for the internet that puts the initiative in the hands of the user: 1. no recommendations alongside the main content (only under a separate filterable view), 2. no ads alongside the main content (only under a separate filterable view). 3. No ads in the middle of main content (i.e. in the middle of a video, only in a separate filterable view). It may seem idealistic, but with small increments of public momentum it could eventually make a dent. I don't see any other way, really.
- mattbierner 8y agoSay a perfect recommendation system existed. Should it give me what it knows I'll like or challenge me? Should it give me what I ask for even if it's wrong? Should it aggregate information for me to judge or analyze the content and judge it for me? Is it optimized for me? For the company? For what's best for humanity? And who decides what's best?
- pendenthistory 8y agoIt just struck me that this explains a lot of changes I've seen in people near me and myself. My mother started getting really into stuff like essential oils. My dad (non-american) spends a crazy amount of time watching videos and reading news about how crazy Trump is (yeah, he IS, but we don't even live in America!). My sister got really into nutrition and diets, with a bent towards complete suspicion of western medicine. My wife, while not a full on anti-vaxxer yet, is now suspicious of vaccinations and wants to wait to vaccinate our child, and skip some of them all together. This after having watched some "documentary" series on Youtube. Myself, I've also seem to have become more extreme in what I'm willing to try to improve my health, personal finance, mental abilities etc. I'm not sure if all of this is due to Youtube specifically, but definitely due to the internet in general. However, I do believe that for many topics, the center/average view is usually wrong. For example the average views on things like diet, exercise, personal finance, materialism is just bad. The average Joe eats like crap, rarely exercises and has less than a few thousand dollars in savings/investments. Therefore, I'm starting to wonder what else out there I might be doing wrong that I haven't even considered yet.
- dnomad 8y ago> My wife, while not a full on anti-vaxxer yet, is now suspicious of vaccinations and wants to wait to vaccinate our child, and skip some of them all together. This after having watched some "documentary" series on Youtube. Out of curiosity is your wife college educated? It's the radicalization of "average" people that is most interesting. I suspect what your wife discovered wasn't just a series of videos but a whole community of people deeply committed this nonsense. This is the secret of radicalization: it appears as just a (very rigid) community of like-minded souls. This shows up again and again in the literature and the news. The internet is doing its job of bringing people together. What's not clear is whether any of these communities are actually beneficial.
- factsaresacred 8y agoA week ago the 'mainstream media' spoke of mobs and pograms. Yet here's Saxony's Minister President: > He also criticized the role of the media in the reporting of the events, saying that "there was no mob, no hunt and no pogroms." You see it's all about narrative. Yes fringe Youtube accounts may have misinformation, but so may mainstream news. In fact people flock to Youtube because the media tend to commit lies of omission or editorialize their reporting. https://www.thelocal.de/20180905/saxonys-minister-president-there-was-no-mob-in-chemnitz https://www.thelocal.de/20180905/saxonys-minister-president-...
- im3w1l 8y agoIf I understand the methodology correctly, he built a spider that recursively followed all outgoing recommendations. He was able to find fringe content when starting with mainstream content. But is that so strange? I remember playing the "Hitler wikipedia game" where you start on a random page and try to find the Hitler page with the minimum number of clicks and it's typically possible to get there in a handful of clicks. I don't think he has done enough to establish that there is a problem. EDIT: On the other hand whenever I see someone respond to "source?" with a youtube video, I immediately tune out and disregard their argument as in my experience it will be either cranky, long-winded or both.
- losvedir 8y agoThis is a good point. It seems plausible to me that a recommendation algorithm should "feel out" a user by putting a variety of options in the sidebar. What I don't totally understand is how it determines the directed nature of the recommendation graph, and how the destinations are labeled. What does it mean to "end up" at "alt right" videos? Do the recommendations have to exclusively lean right or just mostly? What about higher vs lower recommendations? If there are recommendation patterns that go left but don't end up in a tight loop are they considered somehow? There could also be some dependence from the chosen starting video / topic. I'd be curious to see the results from a variety of starting points. Basically, it's an interesting exploration but I'd like to see it with the rigor of a peer reviewed paper, more than just the NYT.
- abhiminator 8y ago> Users searching for news on Chemnitz would be sent down a rabbit hole of misinformation and hate. And as interest in Chemnitz grew, it appears, YouTube funneled many Germans to extremist pages, whose view counts skyrocketed. As a long time YouTube user, I've noticed this myself. The starting video doesn't even have to be extreme. For example, watching a 5-minute daily news video on Fox News channel primes YouTube's super sensitive [$] algorithm to nudge me toward channels with considerably more ideology-driven content (like 'PragerU,' for example). Watching the next auto-recommended video primes the algorithm to an even greater extent that nudges me toward channels with even more extreme positions ('1791L,' 'Computing Forever,' for example). Rinse and repeat a few more times and you end up on channels that server as a gateway to radicalization -- channels whose names I'm not comfortable mentioning. YouTube's algorithm needs some urgent tweaking, especially to its topic/video recommendation sensitivity. It gives more weight to recently watched content, which is fine, but should not be at the cost of previously watched content by the user. [$] When I talk about YouTube's 'super sensitive' algorithm, I mean to say how watching even a single video on a particular subject primes it to keep showing me similar videos everywhere -- from homepage to recommendations to the auto-play ones. P. S. The aforementioned example is also perfectly applicable for channels on the opposite end of the political-spectrum.
- blattimwind 8y agoI very rarely use youtube on my (iOS) phone; I'm not logged into any Google account on it. Before Chemnitz started I showed some friends a video of a robot marching to "Erika" (a WW2 marching song)... a few days later I got a push notification by the Youtube app on my homescreen of a video posted in some fringe-AfD channel which was full-on propaganda. Youtube will literally push extremist right propaganda onto peoples homescreens based on what I can only assume a single video view.
- abhiminator 8y ago> Youtube will literally push extremist right propaganda onto peoples homescreens based on what I can only assume a single video view. Absolutely. It's as if YouTube forgets about your previously viewed videos and channels, and tunnel-visions you into watching content around your most recently viewed single video.
- mrow84 8y agoAssuming the youtube recommendation algorithm is mostly just "people who watched this also watched", then couldn't the asymmetry in the recommendation graph structure simply be a relatively accurate reflection of asymmetry in the underlying data? It seems plausible to me that the probability that people who hold "extreme" views will watch "moderate" content is lower than the probability that people who hold "moderate" views will watch "extreme" content. I haven't run any experiments, but it seems to me that a difference in probabilities like this would induce the kind of "closed group" structure being discussed on the resulting recommendation graph. The low number of steps to the closed groups shouldn't be that surprising, given previous famous results about degrees of separation in these kinds of graphs.
- lsmarigo 8y agoAs a content creator it's very quickly apparent the best route to driving views and subs is to push extreme/edgy content. Balanced content gets no engagement. It's really that simple, with the ADHD short attention span of the current gen of heavy media consumers (read: kids) you have to shock them/surprise them/make them laugh ~once every 5-6 seconds to keep them on the video. YouTube offers very detailed metrics on engagement and you can study the exact time where people lose interest/close the video. Only massive established channels have the privilege of pushing non-edgy content as their audience is built in already, for anyone new it's shock value and hard-line extremism or your voice will be lost among the noise.
- pasquinelli 8y agoYeah, but if you are shocking and edgy, is your voice preserved? Sure, people may watch but it's in one ear and out the other, a swell in the sea of noise. I'm sure most youtubers don't care, but viewer engagement is not the same as being a notable voice.
- Reedx 8y agoThere are some exceptions fortunately and a growing hunger for the very opposite. See Sam Harris for the best (IMO) example. And long form interview formats like what Joe Rogan is doing.
- beeforpork 8y agoIt also happened to me. I was watching some completely unrelated stuff (technical stuff) when I noticed that a polemical and obviously stupid and dumb right-wing AfD propaganda video showed up high in the recommendation list. I was watching stuff in English, yet BS in German was shown (just to be clear: that it happened to be German was not the problem, but additional to be puzzling that it was such BS, it was also strange to show me something in a different language). I don't remember what the current news was at that time, but when I then searched for something related to that, that extreme right BS pub talk stuff was all over the place. It was obvious that the recommendations were skewed. I was puzzled. I closed the browser (cleared cookies) but it remained the same. One video was recommended regardless of how non-political the videos were that I tried to watch. And once I searched for that topic, again, every second video or so was extreme right BS. It took a few days before that video was not shown anymore. Scary. Definitely a problem.
- k__ 8y agoAt least for me it does it on both sides. I get ContraPoint and Jordan Peterson.
- claydavisss 8y agoWhat is "radical"? At one point in history, the suggestion that you would vote for your leader was "radical". Giving the vote to women was once considered "radical", etc etc
- megous 8y agoHow about encouraging others in demonizing, targetting and killing emergency workers/first responders. Seems pretty radical. Yet it's becomming more and more normal to amplify voices of freaks who do this on social media. I'd rather not for this relativism of "what's radical?" to spread too much, because you can justify pretty much anything with it.
- zimablue 8y agoYou have to remember that these articles are to some extent manual stitchers writing critiques of the sewing machine. The newspapers are what is getting killed by new media, and honestly they deserve it. They've had an oligopoly on pushing their agenda for a long time, and it's hurt people (eg. beating the war drums for Iraq, leaving the American people objectively misinformed). There are criticisms to make but these people are not the ones to make them.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- MichaelMoser123 8y agoBut people know how to form their own opinion - YouTube likes to show me talks by Noam Chomsky, but I don't have to agree with him. I think they are blaming too much on these evil algorithms.
- trukterious 8y agoYes. 'Extreme' refers really to the emotional temperature rather than the content. 'Moderate' views, compromises, etc, don't make much sense and are therefore ultimately boring. This doesn't imply moderation or the battle for centre ground in politics is bad. After all we know more than we can tell, so we can't always explain our decisions and policies. It's merely that there's less to understand and/or criticise.
- garysieling 8y agoI got frustrated with the Youtube recommendation system, and built a search engine of videos I scraped: https://www.findlectures.com https://www.findlectures.com I'm relying primarily on trusted recommendations - if someone I trust likes a speaker, I'll index channels where they speak. This doesn't scale well, but it has made for a tool that works really well for doing research.
- le-mark 8y agoHave you written about the challenges involved in this? Like does yt allow it? What do you index exactly? The implementation? Would be very interesting reading. There used to a few yt aggregrators around. I think the most successful was whatever became youtube kids (someone correct that please).
- DennisP 8y agoThis seems like it could be inherent to recommendation systems. How would one go about making a recommendation system that doesn't have this effect?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bborud 8y agoIn 1999 I was working for a web search company and one of the things we really wanted to do was to make search personalized. Eventually we started talking about what years later became known as "filter bubbles". It would be bad if people were constantly fed stuff from the same information universe, right? In retrospect, it didn't get all that much of our attention in terms of work done. Sure, we got very obvious (and measurable) feedback mechanisms and we did spend considerable amounts of time countering the aspects that more directly affected percieved quality of the product. But in terms of what it means, we figured "we have time to deal with it later". Just figuring out how to do this inside a few milliseconds per query was more than enough of a challenge in the near term. Since then (and probably before then) I'm sure thousands of teams have had roughly the same experience. You know that there are going to be problems ahead, but you build it anyway because if you don't someone else will. Your paycheck depends on it. When you implement software that anticipates the preferred path a human likes to take through content you end up amplifying what tendencies are present in the person. This is "harmless" in the sense that you are not imposing some editorial direction. You can't be criticized for imposing your opinion or notions of good/bad, right/wrong etc. However the results appear to be polarizing in that they allow people to navigate to certain maxima. The really hard problem here is how you counter this effectively without imposing your view. I think there's interesting work to be done in that area.
- Reason077 8y agoIt's not just politically extreme content it does this for. You watch one video about how NASA supposedly faked the moon landings and suddenly it's trying to get you to watch all kinds of wacko conspiracy stuff.
- bobwaycott 8y agoRight. The point of the article—and many of the comments here—is that YT is always pushing people toward extreme version of X, whatever X may be.
- severine 8y agoFWIW, original title: As Germans Seek News, YouTube Delivers Far-Right Tirades
- ilamont 8y agoGoogle News works the same way. I've been using Google News since it was a list of links to news sites. The algorithm is very good at surfacing breaking news, but can't help showing the most extreme clickbaity BS among the legit stories. Interested in stories about Oceach Science? We'll show you "Holy S*, These Triassic Ocean Reptiles Were As Big As Hell" https://twitter.com/ilamont/status/983714720153612289 https://twitter.com/ilamont/status/983714720153612289 We see you read about NASA and space flight. Then you'll love this story about a Russian boy who who says 7-foot aliens reside on the red planet! https://twitter.com/ilamont/status/929392451193835520 https://twitter.com/ilamont/status/929392451193835520 Or fossilized alien footprints on Mars, covered up by NASA! https://twitter.com/ilamont/status/970814193631981568 https://twitter.com/ilamont/status/970814193631981568 Trying to get an update on news about China and foreign relations? Let's show you a "news" headline that suggests WWIII is about to break out: https://twitter.com/ilamont/status/1037765753162919937 https://twitter.com/ilamont/status/1037765753162919937
- ajross 8y agoTwo criticisms: one old tweet (edit: parent added extra tweets after I posted this -- and... I can't find them when I do equivalent searches anywhere near the top of the page. ilamont appears to have some kind of axe to grind here) doesn't carry much weight. A current search for "ocean science" on news.google.com in fact looks pretty much like what you'd expect. Secondly: sorry, what exactly is wrong with a sensationalized headline about interesting content? Some of those animals were, in fact, "big as hell", and it's worth covering in popular media. This appears to be the article in that screenshot: https://gizmodo.com/holy-shit-these-triassic-ocean-reptiles-were-big-as-he-1825106733 https://gizmodo.com/holy-shit-these-triassic-ocean-reptiles-... And it's a good article! It's a writeup of this paper, and it even links to it: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0194742 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal... So... what's your criticism here, exactly? That Google put a good story up on their front page even though it had "shit" in the title?
- jonthepirate 8y agoI once clicked on a video of Ben Shapiro speaking at a college campus. Now I see Ben Shapiro videos nearly every time I go on YouTube.
- ajuc 8y agoI regularly view videos on Polish politics and geopolitics. I am constantly suggested videos by fringe extreme right geopoliticians and conspiracy theorists ("it's all a Jewish conspiracy to destroy white race and Poles", "EU is USSR", "muslims will rape us", that kind of videos - Michałkiewicz, Braun, Kowalski and similar). I regularly click "don't like this suggestion, stop showing me it", and I'm still suggested it after a few days/weeks. It seems there's endless supply of these videos and they have hundreds of thousands of views. It's like youtube wants me to become a right-wing nut. That despite me mostly watching mainstream news and liberal news-as-comedy shows. My coworker is a right-wing estremist and he gets suggested the exact same videos, he doesn't see liberal or mainstream news in youtube suggestions, ever.
- DyslexicAtheist 8y agodang and I thought the whole point of youtube was to end up in its weird corners. So many memories of me whistling to the cheerful tunes of the Arctic Monkeys, 4 hours later I'm googling "anxiety" to the background music from Boards of Canada. And whenever I fall asleep to the stimulating and thought provoking ideas of Yuval Noah Harari, I wake up several films later and likely half way through a 4 hour documentary of the 4 horsemen & NWO. But I guess the remedy is to use Google even more, deactivate my adblock and embrace the milking experience as intended. So that they can build a more accurate picture serving me "better" content. :)
- CynicalDio 8y agoIt's quite bizarre, the way YouTube works. I will watch a video that covers something like climate change and immediately I am bombarded in my recommendations with left leaning news clips and stories, the same goes for when I watch a video that could be considered conservative, right away I am suggested videos like "Professor puts liberal sjw student in her place - compilation."
- ahelwer 8y agoWatching any video involving comedian Bill Burr will immediately get you anti-feminist and even white nationalist video recommendations. It's just weird how close that cliff is to fairly mainstream videos.
- awt 8y agoWho decides what is extreme? Abolitionists were extreme yo!
- benjaminjackman 8y agoThis is my largest gripe with these recommendation systems. They are patrimonious and regressive and not aspirational in any sense. What do I mean by that? I mean that they are built with a very sacrosanct attitude towards the algorithm knows best (so maybe algorimonious). They allow no ability for the user to control and guide the process, to mold what they consume to be the person they aspire to be. More concretely I never ever want a recommendation of “late night talk show interviews celebrity person” even though I am somewhat likely to click on that, and waste my time on hollow vapid content, and tell the algorithm to regressively drag me down towards that content. I have gone so far as to go to each of those channels and banned them but that doesn’t stop the video recommendations from randomly popping up in the sidebar so I think it must just block those channels ability to comment on things I post. What I would prefer overall: An ability to guide and control the recommendations to the point of writing my own code that runs in a google cloud function because everyone will be a bit different in what they’d like to see. Personally, I’d then write something that flat out blocks certain keywords and attempts to show sidebar recommendations similarly to how they used to do them: closely mirror the current video with very little if any skew towards the current users history. So I think the issue we face here is one of limited user control, users are not being given a voice or meaningful input to the algorithm that determines what content they see. Instead the only input they are given is their own watch history. Right now YouTube is a buffet. It’s the only buffet in town. It loads the bar with all the junky food people are statistically most likely to eat whether they want to have that food sitting their tempting them or not, and whether it’s even good for them or anyone or soceity as whole or not. It doesn’t give them any ability to say “no French fries” in the buffet. If you put French fries on your plate before and they observed you to eat the French fries, by golly, you’re getting French fries in that buffet from there on out, mental waistline be damned.
- jumperabg 8y agoYep YouTube is recommending me Alex Jones videos and memes. They are just overflowing.
- slothtrop 8y agoWith a clean slate (no cookies stored), the front page can get as ridiculous as recommended videos. For half the music out there yt will recommend anything between chemtrail videos, weird christian conspiracy videos, aliens, all manner of tinfoil hat shit. It's vile.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- briantakita 8y agoI like the recommendation system. It provides content that I'm interested in and I'm surprised over how "fair" it seems given what I'm interested in watching. Maybe Youtube can provide a choice of algorithms. For example, if somebody wants a more curated "socially acceptable" experience, they could opt-in.
- oblib 8y agoIn essence they've perfected a way to profit off of our innate gullibilities with no regard to either the individual's or societal consequences. "Soulless" comes to mind when I ponder this sort of thing.
- qubax 8y agoWhat is politically extreme? Would a company that hires someone like sarah jeong be viewed as politically extreme? The problem isn't youtube. The problem is the news. The news has become politically extreme and that has seeped into youtube. And it's a bit hypocritical of the nytimes to whine about youtube when they pressured Alphabet ( youtube and google ) to give them priority status on both platforms. Anyone else getting sick of the news media attacking social media for all the ills they themselves created and are creating even further? Youtube, and social media in general, has become politically extreme because the news industry ( in particular CNN, Washingtonpost and the NYTimes ) has been pressuring it relentlessly to push their content on social media. And since they are so politically extreme, it creates an extreme backlash against it. Lets not forget that their political extremeness is why fox news was created and why fox news is so popular. If news media companies were a tiny bit honest and objective and fair, we wouldn't be having this problem. But these people running these companies surround themselves with sycophants and create such an impregnable bubble that they can't see how extreme they have become. Get off your high horse already. You are the problem, not youtube.