7 ms·
I get the impression that ride-hailing is the new file storage or image upload business of our days: tempting but inherently not a valid business model.
by oblio 8y ago
I get the impression that ride-hailing is the new file storage or image upload business of our days: tempting but inherently not a valid business model.
- user5994461 8y agoNot at all. Free storage and free image upload don't have a business model, it has no revenues stream while it has high infrastructure/bandwidth to cover. Taxis apps are a very solid business model. 2 digits commission for every ride. There is hardly any costs or work involved to match a guy with a nearby taxi.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ghaff 8y ago>Taxis apps are a very solid business model. Subject to certain assumptions of how much customers are willing to pay, price/volume sensitivity, the geographic areas where the company can operate economically, customer acquisition costs, how much drivers need to make to work for you, fixed vs. variable costs, etc. I suspect that to survive the "ride sharing" app companies will end up significantly increasing prices when it becomes clear there's no magic bullet on the horizon. ADDED: Which means of course volume will go down and, almost certainly, valuations. But there is almost certainly a business model for some scale at some highish price in sufficiently dense areas.
- user5994461 8y agoTaxi rides is a 9 figures industry. Customers are willing to pay and they need an app to book their taxi. There is no question about that. That leaves 8 figures (over $10B) to be distributed between taxi apps (at least 10% fees). It's a simple business that is very profitable. There will undeniably be multiple competitors and they will vary per region, but that doesn't affect the viability of the market.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- gwbas1c 8y agoOh, ride sharing (and file sharing) are valid business models. It's just that competing on price alone means that some companies will take a loss. When I interviewed for my current job, (corporate file sharing,) the founder and CEO was very aware of this. He used the terms "race to the bottom" for companies that compete on price. Then, he explained that we had to focus on solving real problems for our customers that our competitors didn't solve. 7 years later, our cheapo competitors are out of business and we're a leader. This, in part is because we offer a feature set that no one else offers. What does this mean for ride sharing? It means that Didi needs to stop discounting its services and offer features that their competitors don't have. They might have to offer features that the rest of the market thinks are crazy; but crazy enough that Didi's chunk of the marketshare just won't choose the competitor.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoI don't think this is a viable option for ride-sharing. Once you get past the basics that all competitors can provide (non-buggy app, good response times, and a rating model to incentivize good driver behavior), the only thing that matters to the vast, vast majority of people is price. People just don't care about the "extras" that much to change their price-consciousness.
- jiveturkey 8y agobut if the extras amount to discounts, eg vegas taxi that takes you to a strip club and takes care of the cover charge (with kickback from club), then those extras will sell it
- tootie 8y agoI have lived in NYC since long before Uber and co were on the scene. I used to call a car service switchboard and give them my location and destination and they'd have a car there in 5-10 minutes max. They'd bring a car seat if I asked. The driver would get my number and call me if he was stuck or couldn't find me. Price was reasonable, drivers were pros. It was literally just one lady answering a phone. And now Uber/Lyft/Didi are employing like 10,000 highly-paid developers and providing a marginally better level of service. The biggest value-add by far is that they have a consistent name and brand that can provides drivers anywhere instead of having to pick a car service off of yelp. It's mind-boggling how over-engineered these businesses are in order to justify their status in Silicon Valley.
- type-2 8y agoYOur opinion
- oblio 8y agoObviously, everything I write is my opinion. Uber, Didi, Lyft are free to prove me wrong by turning a profit. So far, that doesn't seem to be happening.
- ghaff 8y agoIn all fairness, that is NYC (and mostly Manhattan in particular) which is very atypical. On the other hand, the cost structure seems insane and, like many "businesses" in .com 1.0, you have these services that are being subsidized until they "make up for it in volume" rather than simply accepting that their cost structure makes them relative luxuries--as in the case of black cars in Manhattan.
- tootie 8y agoThis wasn't for Manhattan. It was a part of Brooklyn that never gets yellow cabs. There's car services in most suburbs too. They're just less saturated because most people have cars.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y ago
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoI'm not sure why you were downvoted. I think there is a real question whether ride-hailing services can be anything more than commodity businesses. I.e. the multi-billion dollar valuations for Uber and Didi are largely around the network effects and "winner take all" aspect of a two-sided marketplace, but there is a real argument to be made that users will always pick the lowest price service (within "table stakes" parameters such as available cars and decent app functionality which actually aren't huge barriers to entry). So while I wouldn't necessarily say the business model isn't valid, I would say the business model should be more akin to an airlines model than a winner-take-all Facebook or Google model.
- mandeepj 8y ago> not a valid business model Really? Have you checked financial reports of box.com and dropbox.com? They are both publicly traded multi-billion dollar companies
- barbegal 8y agoBox.com made a huge loss in 2017 https://www.boxinvestorrelations.com/news-and-media/news/press-release-details/2018/Box-Reports-Record-Revenue-of-506-Million-for-Fiscal-Year-2018-Up-27-Year-Over-Year-and-Delivers-Positive-Cash-Flow-From-Operations/default.aspx https://www.boxinvestorrelations.com/news-and-media/news/pre... Dropbox made a huge loss in 2017 https://markets.businessinsider.com/news/stocks/dropbox-ipo-warns-potential-investors-that-it-may-never-be-profitable-2018-2-1016890571 https://markets.businessinsider.com/news/stocks/dropbox-ipo-...
- adventured 8y agoThat's ignoring context for Dropbox. Their "huge loss" was a one-time event. Their business is profitable and in fact looks great. 2Q18: "Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities of $111.9 million and Free Cash Flow of $102.2 million" "Total revenue was $339.2 million, an increase of 27%" "Paying users totaled 11.9 million, as compared to 9.9 million for the same period last year." "GAAP gross margin was 73.6%, as compared to 65.4% in the same period last year." "Non-GAAP net income was $48.0 million, as compared to $20.0 million in the same period last year."
- austenallred 8y agoAlso the value of businesses is in their ability to produce future cashflow (as reflected in market cap), not in their quarter-to-quarter income statement.
- specialist 8y agoI remain befuddled how the market for chat apps is apparently evergreen.
- jschwartzi 8y agoPeople really really like to talk to each other.
- austenallred 8y agoFriendly reminder that Dropbox is publicly traded and has a $10 Billion market cap