18 ms·
Modi’s Cash Crackdown Failed, Indian Bank Data Shows
- jepler 8y agoI happened to take my first (and, so far, only) trip to India in January 2017. The aftereffects of this stunt were still being felt; as a tourist, I sometimes had trouble getting ahold of banknotes (you would still go from ATM to ATM hoping one would dispense some cash), and people were reluctant to take the "large" 2000 rupee notes, because they couldn't make change! It must have been even worse for locals, and when the process had started months earlier.
- deepGem 8y agoPerhaps, but on the bright side, I see an increase in digital transactions, particularly wallets. Almost every nook and corner shop in India now accepts payment by Paytm or an equivalent wallet. It'll be interesting to see the uptick in digital payments since the crackdown on cash. I don't necessarily think wallets are a better way to pay but they are a hell lot convenient than carrying petty cash and having to hit the ATM every now and then.
- j0e1 8y ago> To some degree, the banking sector did benefit. In the wake of demonetization, millions of Indians opened their first bank accounts. > But not all of that is attributable to Mr. Modi’s efforts. I think you give him too much credit in saying that.
- riantogo 8y agoDo you feel govt intervention was needed at such massive scale, causing widespread inconvenience to the people that didn't ask for it, so that everyone could move to digital wallets? Or is it that convince of digital wallets is simply not that great that people would have moved to it anyway?
- deepGem 8y agoI absolutely detest government intervention in any aspect of the society. In fact, I suffered personally like a billion others because of this crap that the government unleashed on us. I am just seeing the brighter side of things. I can't comment on the convenience of digital wallets for all sections of the society. For the urban middle class I can say with conviction, that digital wallets trump cash. The biggest obstacle for digital wallet adoption were the mom and pop shops. Now even a juice vendor accepts PayTM. I don't think the wallets are as harsh as the credit card guys on the merchants. So I see the adoption as a win-win, at least for the urban middle class. All of this doesn't negate the endless suffering ulneashed by the cash crackdown though.
- intended 8y agoThis is the half narrative that needs to be made completed for us Indians to have an actual discussion. How about this scenario - the govt one days makes every Indian pay a fine for holding cash, instead of using one of the many private e-cash wallets out there. This would be a massive state subsidy given to digital players- but would it be fair or correct workings of the market economy? Instead if the market was left to itsel the wallets would have invested in ways to convince people and improve services, all the while paying taxes and adding to govt coffers. One model is wealth creation and the other is regulatory waste paid by us at astronomical costs (1% gdp growth for better metro city use of e wallets??) No one who talks about this seems to mention the opportunity cost and massive wastage for effectively a one off payment to advertise private entities.
- adictator 8y ago> causing widespread inconvenience to the people that didn't ask for it I was one of them standing in line along with my 75 year old dad. The sentiment that I share with them is that although this was an inconvenience, we endured it gladly. Whether it worked or not, the reasoning of why we were doing it was clear & we will gladly go through it again. Not doing ANYTHINg would have been the worst thing for us.
- unmole 8y agoYeah, that makes it all worth it. The endless queues, the needless suffering, the lost productivity all made up for by the fact that the urban middle class now has the convenience of e-wallets!
- statguy 8y agoNot to mention, the 100+ deaths directly attributed to demonetization.
- axiom92 8y agoGreat! Try telling this to the families of one of the people who had the good fortune of sacrificing their lives for the motherland. /s
- TheArcane 8y agoYeah, bankrolled by PayTM which has been proven to spread propoganda for the ruling BJP government. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lvj8hRD1GY4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lvj8hRD1GY4
- davchana 8y agoFrom last two-three months, all small time shops in my city are charging extra if paid via PayTM, citing that they get charged when they take money out of PayTM to Bank. Because their wholesale supplier wants bank transfers.
- paragraft 8y agoPlanet Money had a great two part episode[1] on this and how it came about, and the guru who advocated it. Particularly fascinating was the gigantic PowerPoint presentation they embedded that formed the pitch deck for the proposal. It's one of my go-to examples now for why sometimes engineering-style systems thinking can be disastrous upon meeting reality, particularly in something as people-driven as an economy. 1: https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2017/05/10/527803742/episode-770-when-indias-cash-disappeared-part-one https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2017/05/10/527803742/epis...
- breitling 8y agoI think I listed to this when it came out over a year ago. The most unbelievable part of it for me was when the host asks about the difficulties endured by a poor farmer unable to exchange his dead wife's life savings (approx $50), the person just dismisses it saying, "he's a poor guy, he is used to difficulties" (paraphrasing here). India is taking advice from those sort of people who have no care whatsoever for the poor. Just unbelievable! Can't imagine how difficult life must have been for these people.
- Fjolsvith 8y agoReminds me of Richard Garriott's talk about how players destroyed the economic model in Ultima Online on the very first day of live play. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KFNxJVTJleE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KFNxJVTJleE
- duxup 8y agoOnce you hit the point of "well then people will think X and choose to Y" ... all bets are off.
- superkuh 8y agoIt failed at the cover story but succeeded in moving a large amount of people way from cash and so increasing government control and surveillance of transactions.
- anoncoward111 8y agoI agree with this statement. I'm in the US. I'm just waiting for the moment that my Venmo and Zelle transactions are sent to the IRS and they want to start asking me about my "income", aka splitting bills with friends.
- farazbabar 8y agoThis is already the case with 1099-K and even though the link at https://www.paypal.com/us/smarthelp/article/how-does-paypal-report-my-sales-to-the-irs-will-i-receive-a-1099-tax-statement-faq729 https://www.paypal.com/us/smarthelp/article/how-does-paypal-... refers to sales, the catch all mechanism is entirely driven by number of transactions and amounts which are easily attainable with an active social circle.
- Lazare 8y agoIt didn't even succeed at that. The same data shows that households are keeping more of their savings as cash, rather than less. Much of the impact of demonetization was experienced as an acute cash shortage, with restrictions on accessing money in bank accounts and difficulty withdrawing cash from ATMs, whereas actual cash could be exchanged relatively easily on the black market. The lesson learned was, quite correctly, not "keep your money in banks where it'll be safe from future demonetization attempts", but "keep your money out of banks where it'll be safe from future demonetization attempts". It was a failure on every level.
- jstanley 8y agoI don't know. If people learned that banks are not a safe place to keep money, I'd say it was a win on at least some levels.
- hirsin 8y agoI find it between puzzling and concerning that the mention of cash being used in real estate deals doesn't mention why. They mention that a table will be sold for a cash price, but miss the bigger picture - 2 million dollar homes were being sold the same way, with only the banked fraction being reported. Saying that demonetization is disrupting black money real estate deals is... Not evidence of pain or failure.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> I find it between puzzling and concerning that the mention of cash being used in real estate deals doesn't mention why. Can you not imagine legitimate reasons for doing this? A small business owner makes a deal with a property owner to operate the business out of the property on a payment plan where the profits from the business buy out the property owner over time. The customers of the business pay cash so the business pays cash. The buyer or seller doesn't trust the local banking system (e.g. because they have seen recent evidence of not being able to withdraw their money from it). The banks charge some fees that can be avoided by cutting them out of the transaction. Even small percentage-based fees add up to a lot of money on real estate sized transactions. The seller is also the buyer of a different property and they or the other seller wants to transact in cash for one of the above reasons, so they would prefer to have cash from this transaction to use for the other one. In theory the transaction could be made to involve the banks by everyone doing extra work for no reason, but at the margin that scuttles the transaction and even when it doesn't it still generates overhead that dampens the local economy makes peoples lives harder unnecessarily.
- hirsin 8y agoMy point was not that there's no reason for cash in real estate. You being up a real scenario, but my point is that the scenario I describe is so common and well known that anyone with some contact with the system would know to bring it up. That the journalist didn't brings the rest of the article into question. Imagine someone writing that anti-virus brings pain with it, because it has a negative side effect on programs that need to shim and redirect system calls. Yes, it does, because the vast majority of the time that use case is a virus. If that's all they wrote on that front you'd wonder if they really understood computers.
- patrickg_zill 8y agoIt was certainly a heated discussion at HN, when it happened...
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 8y agoHas there been any studies of Modi’s allies’ cash flows. It would be interesting to see if there was an uptick in connected people converting rupees to real estate, foreign currency, right before the cash crackdown was announced.
- Lazare 8y agoIt wouldn't be surprising, but since nobody rich seemed to have the slightest trouble converting cash after the crackdown either, it hardly matters. Central bank data shows 99.3% of the demonetized notes were exchanged; there was effectively zero "dirty" money destroyed via demonetization.
- shabda 8y agoThere was dirty money created by demonetizion. We have not yet accounted for 1. Cash in Bhutan and Nepal where indian currency was widely used. 2. NRIs who legally held INRs but the cost of exchange was too high 3. Residents who have loose cash lying around - under mattresses, long forgotten jeans and missed the deadline for exchange.
- axiom92 8y agoOf course, look at https://thewire.in/banking/bank-with-amit-shah-as-a-director-collected-highest-amount-of-banned-notes-among-dccbs-rti-reply https://thewire.in/banking/bank-with-amit-shah-as-a-director... for example.
- ravisutrave 8y agohttps://thewire.in/economy/mystery-demonetisation-rs-3-lakh-crore-deposits-15-days https://thewire.in/economy/mystery-demonetisation-rs-3-lakh-...
- ramshanker 8y agoI believe otherwise for following aftereffects. 1. Literally Every nook & corner shop now accepts digital payments. 2. I have seen cash-distribution by candidates during elections to influence votes! They were mostly absent in the immediate subsequent state elections. 3. Many "Poor" people made extra money by queuing in the line for "Rick" people. The commission went as high as 20% at some places. 4. Terrorist activity immediately stopped all over the place because they are mostly cash sponsored. 5. Situation normalized within 3 month. 6. Many of counterfeit presses in neighboring countries stopped working for some time at least. I also stood in line 4 or 5 times, but than every "Line" in India is average 10m long for any kind of services. We are used to it !!!!
- iamshs 8y agoEvery single point that you have said has been debunked many times over. DeMo was a stupid thing to even try accomplishing what you are trying to say it accomplished. For the want of killing crocodiles, we drained the whole pond and only ended up killing the fish instead. Crocodiles were back after a month.
- cscurmudgeon 8y agoA simple Google search shows you are wrong. > Overall, however, our study strongly suggests that India’s 2016 demonetization, the largest the world has ever seen, effectively stimulated the transition from a cash-based to digitally enabled economy. https://www.forbes.com/sites/nusbusinessschool/2018/09/01/indias-demonetization-drive-a-necessary-jolt-towards-a-more-digital-economy/#25698a7d3dc3 https://www.forbes.com/sites/nusbusinessschool/2018/09/01/in...
- axiom92 8y agoYou are only addressing 1/6 points mentioned by the OP, most of which is a load of BS. As for the gain in digital transactions, was there no other way to boost them? If the supreme leader comes up with another rule that anyone who uses cash will be shot, the cash-based transactions will reduce to nearly 0. But will it make any sense?
- farhanhubble 8y agoAlthough demonetization might have spurred digital transactions, it wasn't able to get rid of black money for the simple reason that black money owners weren't foolish enough to store large sums of cash. The average corrupt Joe who has a few millions in black money, invests in businesses, real estate, gold, sending kids abroad and so on.
- eklavya 8y agoNot entirely true, but I am amazed at just how creative people can get when it comes to money. “Everybody” got their whole lot in, one way or another. The biggest failure was the complete absence of any kind of centralised checks in the banks for any deposits. Although many poor have gotten rich as they are refusing to give back what was transferred in their account :)
- WheelsAtLarge 8y agoI would say that it's too early to tell. I think a better gage is the increase in tax compliance over the next few years. If the treasury gets an increase in money then I would think it was worth it for the government and society. People hate to pay taxes but if you go to a country where people avoid taxes you'll see an infrastructure that's just awful. I rather live in a country where people are willing to pay their share. I would also look at the increase of money other than cash. People love cash but a good banking system is vital to start small businesses to help people out of poverty.
- eklavya 8y agoIn my opinion deMo succeeded in all but the claimed main objective, which was removal of black money.
- adictator 8y agoProbably right. Maybe removal of black money was just a facade in order to achieve all the other actual objectives.
- kranner 8y agoYes it did succeed in rigging the UP elections in favour of the BJP.
- intended 8y agoWell that’s also hard to quantify- as you recall demo had so many as how reasons tacked on every other day. Day 1- This is to remove black money! Day x - removal of counterfeits! Please bear with us. Day y - cashless economy ! And I vaguely remember there being some other reason(s) which were added later. This was a farce. But it does show how deeply Indians feel about corruption and wealth inequality.
- thevardanian 8y agoMost people who had "black money" deposited their cash with albeit with a heavy penalty. The government allowed people to deposit their cash, but taxed it something like 50-70% if it had NO accounting at all.
- calvinbhai 8y agoI have listened to both the planet money episodes (I love Planet Money podcasts). I'm from India, living in US for more than 10 yrs. So I kind of have enough perspective of how Demonetization is seen within India and from outside India, including based on knowing personally who benefited or got screwed by demonetization, and who were left unscathed. Must say, with what I have known about the medium and long term after affects of demonetization, I found NPR / Planet Money's research / info in the podcast terribly biased. This bias is sort of ironic since it is from a radio station that is very pro-democrat from a country that keeps harping about "Trump won because Russia" even though the process was as democratic as it could be. Like NPR, NYT is also extremely biased against the current Indian administration, while simultaneously being subtly (sometimes overtly) anti-Hindu / anti India. I sincerely listened to the Planet money episodes hoping to find some genuine shortcomings of the demonetization process, but was totally disappointed at the kind of propaganda based content they came up with! Sadly, NYT does the same with this piece of writeup. There are many, many +ve effects (short, medium term) that I can talk about. But the main -ve point of this whole process is that one round of demonetization is not enough. A few more rounds of demo, and crooks will have enough fear in even accepting cash for bribes and probably will need to resort to barter system. I personally know many who stashed illegal unaccounted money in gunny bags, and have suffered a blow to their wealth (as I wished) and I know a few who have had their black money stash replenished partially after a year of demo. In either case, it was very heartening to see those who slept on mattresses made of cash suffer and struggle.
- iamd3vil 8y agoAs the data shows 99.3% of the cash returned. This doesn't include Grameen banks. So the number maybe more. Percentage of black money has increased. The amount of cash transactions with respect to digital transactions has also increased. Demonetization is a total disaster and I can't forgive Modi for making the country suffer like this and taking 100 lives for nothing.
- axiom92 8y agoAlso does not include cash still in countries like Bhutan and Nepal.
- billfruit 8y agoWhat angered me the most was the suddenness of the announcement, I thought it was authoritarian to have the executive capable of issueing such orders with immediate effect. There wasn't time for courts or citizens or even legilature to look into the legality of such a move before it was effected, and constitutionally challenge it. Such measures should have been pursued through legislative means rather than executive. The way it was done indicated the Indian Governments lack of faith in democracy.
- saagarjha 8y agoI think that was the point: if done quickly, it makes it impossible to find places to launder your illegally acquired income. Whether that was actually achieved was debatable.
- billfruit 8y agoBut implementating such arbitrary measures with immediate effect is tenable in a democracy or not is my question. I think not, because ends do not justify means.
- luoji_ 8y agoDoesn't seem like there's much left to debate. All demonetisation did was serve to legitimise a lot of illegal cash that made it back into the system.
- sbmthakur 8y agoTrue. A friend of my relative who is a Sales-tax officer had tons of cash(most of it illegal) in his home. His entire night was spent calling his friends and requesting them to take a part of his cash for some time.
- rm2889 8y agoLink to Hacker News post when Demonetization was announced - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12900965 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12900965
- schizoidboy 8y agoI find it interesting that the top three highest voted comments, and their top sibling comments don't mention any potential concerns about unintended consequences or the effects on the average and poorest people (the NYT article cites evidence such negative effects happened, including suicide). The first sibling comment of the third highest voted comment throws out a worry, and it was downvoted. I don't know what this means exactly, but I think it's worth the average HNer to ponder.
- throwaway-hn123 8y agoThere's a brigade of hardcore right wing Modi supporters who downvote anything that's critical of Modi.
- jopsen 8y agoI think it's human nature to desire action NOW. In practice, however, immediate action in complex systems is likely to have negative side-effects. We this desire for action in Trump and Brexit too.. Or when a young naive junior developer sets out to rewrite a system from scratch :)
- willwinger 8y agoDemonetization as a black money magic wand is a public face. The following is the other side of the coin, the following as narrated by a banker friend 1. Banks were at a historical low in availability of currency in the system due to bad money hoarding and non performing assets. Dangerously near collapse. Demo as the report points out has brought so much money back into the banking system and successfully overturned this. 2. Prior to demo. the capital in the stock market was dominated by FII (foreign institutional investors) almost 70%. This resulted in volatility and the Indian economy being vulnerable to external influence. Now the table has turned, the capital in the market is predominantly from the Indian banking system leading to greater stability. 3. Now that money is inside the system,anyone who has tried to take money out in cash beyond 5000 USD knows how difficult to near impossible it is now. This is the real effect on bad money, generation is now so damn difficult! 4. Anyone honest who has tried to buy a home from big realty developers in India recently would be pleasantly surprised that now you have to purchase it with good money and also pay proper GST tax for it. Before demo this was one major area of bad money generation. It is as good as dead now. Recent reports on the huge huge increase in GST tax revenue increase is a proof. 5. Good and bad currency sweeping back into the system (Gov allowed conversion also) has effectively nullified the funding of militancy and the fact that from demo the country has not seen any terrorist actions is a possible indicator. 6. Whether you like it or not one more area which encouraged bad money circulation was evangelism (convert to christianity for money) and that is one more area that also been severely impacted. Most US media outlets want to feed the stereotyped view of India and jump at any chance to do that. Most people who cry against demo are those who do it, just because they dislike Modi as a person (not a very charismatic personality). They would not be able to substantiate how they were personally impacted.
- kranner 8y ago> Most US media outlets want to feed the stereotyped view of India and jump at any chance to do that. You have no way to prove this. > Most people who cry against demo are those who do it, just because they dislike Modi as a person (not a very charismatic personality). You have no way to prove this. Also see No True Scotsman fallacy. > They would not be able to substantiate how they were personally impacted. You are implying nobody was actually impacted. And yet the economy lost a percentage point in GDP growth. The people that were the most impacted were people in blue collar jobs, and they are not on HN.
- godelmachine 8y agoWell, I’ll playing the devils advocate here. In case you are thinking it was a complete failure, I would like to cite one example where one unscrupulous builder went out of business. His name is DS Kulkarni and he ran a shadow bank of his own. Collected money from people promising huge returns on FD’s. Post demonetization, he couldn’t return their money, and now, he and his entire family is in prison.
- luoji_ 8y agoIt's an anecdotal silver lining thats far outweighed by the negatives.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- 1024core 8y ago> It is also the way he did what he did that ruffled many feathers. He did not consult Parliament. He did not solicit advice from many learned advisers. He did not give the public any warning. Anyone who makes such statements is a complete moron. Sorry about the inflammatory language, but that's the truth. Can you imagine what would have happened if the Parliament was "consulted" ? All of the money hoarders would have immediately converted their cash, negating the move. When you want to set a trap to catch something, the last thing you want to do is announce your intentions loudly and put big blinking signs there.
- mavelikara 8y ago> All of the money hoarders would have immediately converted their cash, negating the move. You mean those holding 0.7% of the currency?
- axiom92 8y ago>All of the money hoarders would have immediately converted their cash, negating the move. Unless you disagree with the figures RBI has reported, this (precisely this) has happened anyways; the move has been negated. I am baffled at the number of people on HN who still believe that this chicanery really made the rich throw their hoarded cash somewhere. I mean, come on folks! That's the whole point of the article we are talking about here! 99.7% of the demonetized currency is back. The rest of it could be in Bhutan or Nepal, with the NRIs or could be hiding under the pillows of those who were too poor to get it changed; we don't know.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sytelus 8y agoAny idea how black money hoarders were able to exchange their bills? I have heard stories like recruiting poor people to exchange cash with max allowed but still given the amount of such money in India this doesn’t sound scalable. I also think govt actually had pretty good set of rules to avoid this. Were there any other loophole they found out?
- Karupan 8y agoI wasn't in India when it happened, but from what I've heard, bank employees were bribed directly (my dad is a retired bank employee). They took a 30% share for converting illegal money to new currency and kept it off the records. That's also one of the reasons why the supply of new bills didn't actually reach the common man. As always, humans are the weakest link and can be exploited quite easily.
- quantummkv 8y agoNYTimes, like most media inside and outside of India, are looking at this from the wrong angle. The actual intent of Demonetization was not the removal of Black Money. It was just a cover. Anything else like digital transactions were side effects. The real reason for this was political chest thumping. The previous government was seen as incapable of taking decisions and getting work done. This was mostly a signal from Modi that he was willing to get work done, take hard decisions and see them through. That he and his government had the willpower to work and act, unlike his political opponents. The results of the UP elections that happened after this validate it. UP is a state with a lot of farmers and low income people, who were supposedly the worst hit segments of the population. Yet they voted for him. Just some food for thought.
- puranjay 8y agoAnother point to note is that Indian elections are funded by a massive corpus of cash, and when you suddenly make all existing cash illegal days before the elections, you cause complete disarray in your own political opponents' camps. This was as much a poll winning strategy as it was, purportedly, about demonetization. To me, regardless of whatever good this government does, it will remain one of the worst decisions economic decisions taken by any Indian government to date
- quantummkv 8y ago> Another point to note is that Indian elections are funded by a massive corpus of cash, and when you suddenly make all existing cash illegal days before the elections, you cause complete disarray in your own political opponents' camps. As well in your own camp. Your cash is not different from your opponent's cash. Unless the cash you are using is unaccounted.
- sbmthakur 8y agoA friend of my relative who is a Sales-tax officer had tons of cash(most of it illegal) in his home. His entire night was spent calling his friends and requesting them to take a part of his cash for some time. There are many such cases across India. Personally, I do think Demonetization was a failure but that's because shifting of goal-posts and not because it achieved nothing.
- TheArcane 8y agoSo we should believe it wasn't useless because of an anecdote you have?
- SureshrajanP 8y agodemonetization is good. after that incident, digital transactions are increased and Little bit black money got burned.
- chauhankiran 8y agoMight it failed, but there lots of advantages. All cash, directly or indirectly is countable now before was considered as Black Money. Transaction started to grow online. People started to become aware more about the payments. And people really give second thought when doing big deal with cash
- Scoundreller 8y agoWill the EU do the same analysis for its withdrawal of the 500 EUR notes? Sincerely, someone on another continent that has one of these and needs to beg a friend to go to a central bank while on holiday to “break” this legal banknote.
- ahamedirshad123 8y agoBJP leaders actually bought land worth crores, just a week before demonetization. They knew it beforehand. http://www.financialexpress.com/india-news/demonetisation-bjp-bought-land-worth-crores-of-rupees-a-week-before-note-ban/455728/lite/ http://www.financialexpress.com/india-news/demonetisation-bj...
- jakidud 8y agoJust my 2 cents: I have an Indian friend whose dad owns a college. When Demonetization happened, his dad asked all of his students to take cash and deposit into their account, and afterwards transfer into his account. To incentivise them he told them they would get a discount on college fees(off the books, ofc) for each cash deposit. Students were lining up all day for weeks to make deposits, many even got a lot of family members as well. Another friend's family opened a luxury car dealership overnight, buying cars wholesale from legitimate car dealers who could then pass off any income as legitimate. I'm very skeptical when anyone says black money was affected significantly by Demonetization.
- potlee 8y agoThis sounds suspicious. All these transactions are traceable now and it should be much easier for the income tax department to find out. No one in hier right mind would have so many people send money to their bank accounts like this.
- srean 8y ago> be much easier for the income tax department Question is did they. This entire thing was a stage managed farce to inconvenience political opponents. Citizens were collateral damage.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jakidud 8y agoJust asked my friend: apparently they used the college fees account. They were getting a lot of money transfers anyway so it's not such a bit deal at face value And since no one really raised any alarms during DeMo, no one really investigated further.
- ahamedirshad123 8y agoRBI: Loan defaults by small businesses double in a year. Here's another example of stress in the economy.This is what Demonetization did to small businesses https://t.co/PTRqqTgYR8 https://t.co/PTRqqTgYR8
- TheArcane 8y agoThere is a surprising amount of government supporters on HN.
- sseth 8y agoPresumably that explains why they were elected, and are now the government :-) Why is that surprising?
- TheArcane 8y agoBecause the ruling party is riding the anti-intellectual wave. It's about as surprising as waking up to find HN flooded by Trump supporters or Brexit Leavers, for example.
- jellicle 8y agoSeems like the data shows the cash crackdown was a great success, but there are some powerful people with a financial interest in presenting it as a failure so that other countries don't get any bright ideas.
- known 8y agoOnly an insensitive/ignorant clown will go for demonetization where 97% are poor by global standards http://idronline.org/addressing-inequality-in-india/ http://idronline.org/addressing-inequality-in-india/ and 1% own 73% wealth https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/indias-richest-1-corner-73-of-wealth-generation-survey/articleshow/62598759.cms https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/politics-and-natio...
- deafcalculus 8y agoPoliticians hate to accept mistakes / policy errors. It's no surprise that Modi doesn't want to say out loud that the note ban did not go as he had hoped; some positives, but not worth all the trouble, and he'd probably have abandoned the exercise had he known the outcome, but he isn't going to say that. Perhaps a lot of people expected him to be a better statesman and feel let down. Anyway, time to move on and clean up the balance sheets of banks before the next recession that many are predicting hits.
- intended 8y agoModi is India's greatest politician in recent years. If anyone thinks that he didn't get exactly what he wanted, they are absolutely incorrect. For the record, my meager guesses of Modi's moves once he became PM were correct, so I have faith in my assessment of him. Modi didn't give a rats ass about the stated reasons for this exercise. Thats why the target moved so many times. Cashless/Terror/ counterfeit etc. etc. Contrast that with ACTUAL projects he works on - those get targets, goals, and media communication which is spot on. Modi would never abandon the exercise, because in one move he crippled opponent political infrastructure. Every day, Modi fights a scorched earth political battle to destroy the Congress.
- mayankkaizen 8y agoDissing congress is all he has done with full efficiency and in the most ugliest manner. I mean, there was people like Vajpayee, Adavani and many others who have actually known Nehru/Indira/Rajiv more than Modi and even they didn't fall so far down to criticize Congress. They criticized but with dignity. Dignity is foreign word for Modi. And that is why, since his rise, stories like Nehru was sexually pervert and had STD, Mahatama Gandhi was homosexual, ancestors of Nehrus were Muslims and so on are on the rise.
- gawkface 8y agoYaay I told everyone that night how it's a nonsense move for the reason cited, lol those who mocked me then now don't have a face but I rub it into them everytime this comes up ^^
- wtmt 8y agoDemonetization was a disaster in many ways. The government was not at all prepared for the change and kept playing it by ear everyday, changing the policies on cash withdrawals. Those who had a lot of cash used the boon of the government — Jan Dhan accounts of the poor — to deposit their cash in smaller sums and got it out later. Talk about this move's ill effects and you'll find the other side changing the topic from black money to digital transactions to tax base and so on. None of those claims have been validated. Cash use is back to how it was before. Digital transactions saw a temporary increase, but have gone out of favor among those who didn't really use them often before. Tax increases have other reasons to credit. What's even worse is that the government made it easier to hoard large amounts of cash by invalidating the Rs.1000 note and by introducing a Rs.2000 note. The main use of the Rs.2000 note could be to hoard cash since it's not something that's useful on a day-to-day basis for most people (can't easily get the change when the spend is much smaller). Tax evasion is primarily done through real estate, gold, etc. Cash bills form a minuscule percentage. The government could've focused on bigger things than attempt to flush badly run banks with cash by this move. Hopefully this or any future government won't dare to try this kind of a gimmick again.
- ahamedirshad123 8y agoWe should not call it demonetization, if you ask me.They didn't even demonetize 500 notes.