8 ms·
YouTube download sites are “biggest piracy threat” to music industry
- eyeball 8y agoYou can have my youtube-dl when you pry it from my cold dead hands.
- anoncoward111 8y agoRight? Also I torrent the shit out of things anyway when I need non-potato-tier audio quality. You can have my Transmission and SkyTorrents over my dead body!
- bArray 8y agoTo be completely honest, I can't really tell the difference between a high bit rate MP3 and a WAV file. For videos I can see the value though, anything below 720 is quite obvious.
- y4mi 8y agoYouTube audio isn't high quality though... I think it's 128k
- anoncoward111 8y agoThis is the correct answer. You can hear the compression when cymbals are ringing out in a song quite clearly
- arbie 8y agoI thought 1080p videos used 160kbps audio?
- lozf 8y agoEven 720p videos can include up to 192kbps AAC audio, but who knows how many times it gets transcoded between upload and delivery in various sizes and formats.
- danmg 8y agoskytorrents shutdown last year.
- anoncoward111 8y agoskytorrents.lol still working for me friend
- danmg 8y agoNice. Thanks.
- bArray 8y agoI was just thinking "nobody tell them about youtube-dl"! I wouldn't be surprised if half of these YouTube-to-MP3 sites are using it in the background - why wouldn't they? Should be pretty easy to containerize the program. I actually wonder sometimes how they are able to provide these conversions given progressions in ad-blockers. There is absolutely no way to stop pirating. Long before the internet was fast enough (or even existing) people were recording songs with phones, copying tapes, ripping records, etc. Anything a human can hear can be recorded. Anything that a human can see can be recorded. It's a losing battle. There is evidence to suggest it helps improve sales overall [1] [2]. Like most laws, this will probably have the biggest impact on poorer people who can't afford to buy every single at the price point they charge. [1] https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2017/09/eu-study-finds-piracy-doesnt-hurt-game-sales-may-actually-help/ https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2017/09/eu-study-finds-piracy... [2] https://cdn.netzpolitik.org/wp-upload/2017/09/displacement_study.pdf https://cdn.netzpolitik.org/wp-upload/2017/09/displacement_s...
- tim333 8y agoI don't think they need to stop pirating so much as hassle people pirating sufficiently that a decent percentage still pay up.
- zeta0134 8y agoIf they'd just make the content available on Spotify, which all of my pirate friendly but otherwise non-technical friends use, they'd have their conversion. Piracy continues to solve the discovery and "listen to just this one song I like" problem that the industry ignores, and until the paid options are as useful as the pirate versions, the battle will continue. (Also, I'm ignoring some philosophical things: I like to own things and not stream them for bandwidth reasons, and tech folks tend to not like DRM, but the general public doesn't seem to care much about those things.)
- ttsda 8y agoUsually they will just fetch the YouTube direct mp4 link and redirect to that, in order to save bandwidrh.
- 8y ago
- tomcooks 8y ago> biggest piracy threat to Youtube's dishonest business model
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- CM30 8y agoOr their outdated business modal is the biggest threat to their industry. Honestly, my thought on anything like this is 'just go bankrupt and be done with it'. Your business model clearly doesn't work anymore, you may as well just accept it and shut down. Then again, that's my opinion on basically every business complaining to the government about how the internet is taking away their profits/how competitors/startups whatever are taking their market/can't stay solvent because of bad decisions (see banks). Capitalism is capitalism, the market is right, and if you can't deal with it, you go under. Simple as that.
- philipov 8y agoThat is precisely why antitrust issues begin long before a company gets a monopoly. Once a company becomes large enough where paying for friendly laws becomes easier than innovating, markets are going to stop working. If an organization is too big to fail, it's too big to be allowed to live.
- imperio59 8y agoExplain how it's an outdated business model? Content creator (musician, film studio) makes content. They must make money to recoup the costs of making said content so they can (at least) make more of the same content. Are you saying all musicians should just go back to only doing live shows and concerts and give up recording music altogether? This kind of comment just blatantly ignores the fact that there are very real issues at play, especially when big names in music are taking their music down from places like Spotify because they're just hardly getting any reward for it.
- Bahamut 8y agoFor the big labels, most of the money is not going into the costs of making the content itself - most of it is going into marketing, executives, etc. The musicians themselves get a small portion of it. The model faces some threat due to the shift of musicians moving to do their own marketing themselves without a label, and releasing the music themselves onto services like Bandcamp, or even directly to services such as Amazon, iTunes, etc. The internet has provided a powerful medium to fight against the entrenched interests of the big labels that don't feel like they need to do more for their artists.
- contravariant 8y agoDownloading the sound of youtube videos is illegal now?
- coldtea 8y agoIt has always been illegal. Both for songs and for regular videos, even vlogs. You don't have the copyright to the recording, the creator of the video (or the owner for the sync/mechanical rights for a piece of music) has.
- salutonmundo 8y agoReally? I was under the impression that there's no legal distinction between "the website sending you a file and you caching it in memory" and "the website sending you a file and you storing it on your hard drive". (Redistributing the file, or breaking DRM, are different matters.)
- coldtea 8y agoThe have a terms of service, and ripping in this way is against it. "It IS illegal to convert copyrighted music videos into downloads. That said, nobody has been sued for this (yet). Again, it is completely legal to watch any video you want on YouTube. Streaming from a legitimate site is permitted under copyright law. And if it doesn’t involve creating a video mp3 or download, you’re in the clear. But, it IS illegal to create a personal download conversion of a copyrighted work under US copyright law. That includes an mp3, mp4, or any other download file type from your videos convert process." https://www.digitalmusicnews.com/2016/10/10/youtube-to-mp3-sites-illegal/ https://www.digitalmusicnews.com/2016/10/10/youtube-to-mp3-s...
- framp 8y agoThat doesn't look like a reputable source for legal advice. It is certainly violating YouTube terms of service. Given the video is available publicly, copying the video is what happens every time you watch it from your computer. The conversion point doesn't apply as YouTube videos are mp4 and you can just play a mp4 as audio. I'd argue it's covered by fair use but I'm not a lawyer.
- fapjacks 8y agoSeems like they're always bitching about something. How about innovating, guys?
- rayiner 8y agoInnovation is what you need to do if people don’t want your product. Here, people clearly want the product, so how would innovation help?
- mikeash 8y agoI don’t think this is quite correct. “Want to pay for your product” would be more accurate here.
- coldtea 8y agoWell, would these people still not want to pay for that product, if paying was the only way to get it?
- Kenji 8y agoIf the product is DRM-ridden garbage music platforms, vendor lock-in and being forced to buy specific devices, then no, I don't want the product. I want clean MP3 or FLAC downloads, such that I own the product I bought and nobody can take it away from me. That is why I've spent hundreds of dollars (or more? I've lost count) on Bandcamp.com and will continue to do so.
- bArray 8y agoInnovation takes many forms, sometimes in selling a product, sometimes in securing a product's exclusivity - such as DRM. Look only as far as YouTube to see what content creators do when the money well dries up - a lot have turned to selling products/advertising themselves with direct deals (dollar shave club, Nord VPN, etc). Another method is through "merch", something Disney for example has been doing for years. Besides, many Countries simply don't respect media copyright full-stop, it wouldn't harm creators to learn to hustle for other (potentially wider) markets.
- 8y ago
- kapauldo 8y agoMusic wants to be free.
- daenz 8y ago500 years in the future, when we all have cochlear augmentations: >Listening to music is the "biggest piracy threat" to music industry
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- m1573rp34130dy 8y agoyou can have my youtube download site any time, what is very important to me is the ability to open web media with VLC and use the nifty tools available, such as recording transcoding and restreaming [yadayadayada]... ... i think youtube itself is the biggest online threat to all internet media...
- nathcd 8y agoSeems pretty likely that YouTube will switch to EME at some point, doesn't it? Seems like record labels and the like would be demanding it. When and if that happens, I hope PeerTube and other video hosts can take off in the fediverse.
- Rjevski 8y agoEME can be cracked if it isn’t already. Anything can be cracked. The only way to not get your content copied is to not give it to the user in the first place. If the user can see/hear the content then he can also copy it.
- icebraining 8y agoThey are already using EME (specifically Widevine, which is developed by Google itself) on some videos. As far as I know, youtube-dl is perfectly capable of removing it.
- sharkjacobs 8y agoThis doesn't make any sense to me. My impression is that listening to locally stored mp3 files is becoming less and less common in favor of streaming music services.
- Giorgi 8y agoStreaming music services does not have that obscure songs one might like, some remixes, not every country has universal internet coverage and not everyone likes to waste dataplans on music etc. etc.
- bootlooped 8y ago"Websites dedicated to “stream ripping” music from YouTube represent the biggest threat to the global music business, industry figures have warned... ... estimates suggesting that a third of 16-24-year-olds in the UK have ripped music from the Google-owned platform." I find the "1 in 3 young people have done it" highly suspect, especially if that estimate comes from "industry figures". Even if that were true, "1 in 3 have done it" doesn't say anything about the frequency at which they do it. I think this is mostly alarmist, and my personal opinion is that music piracy is in decline in the face of easy and cheap legal alternatives.
- catdog 8y agoThis alarmist thing is going on for decades now ("Home Taping Is Killing Music") but the music industry still exists.
- foxfired 8y agoThe biggest piracy threat to the music industry is my sound card. I can record any sound that comes out of the speakers.
- Krasnol 8y agoDon't say it too loud or they'll replace your ports with some fancy DRM safe stuff.
- fasafsaf3 8y agoLike they did with HDMI?
- jordigh 8y agoWait, what? There's DRM in HDMI? Bloody hell! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-bandwidth_Digital_Content_Protection https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-bandwidth_Digital_Content... Stop protecting bytes from being copied!
- jazzyjackson 8y agoWhich of course is added complexity and a source of incompatibility between playback devices and screens. Can't count the number of times in the early years of HDMI that I couldn't play a DVD because my projector didn't support it. On the other hand, the pirated copy still worked great.
- cududa 8y agoHDCP my dude. Take a jog up history
- Krasnol 8y agoWasn't there something about UBS-C too?
- giancarlostoro 8y agoI mean if you can hear it on your PC you can record it regardless with plenty of free open source software.
- whoopdedo 8y agoWe talk about the technical futility of copy protection. Or the erosion of fair use rights. But I have little sympathy for the parasitic websites that have built a business model out of violating Youtube's TOS. When Mozilla recently axed 23 extensions that were leaking browser history, 7 of them were for downloading videos or blocking ads on Youtube. This cottage industry is full of actors much less principled than the copyright cartel. Now, if Google was smart they'd find a way to sell downloads. But good luck getting the media licensers to agree to it.
- i_am_nomad 8y agoWith regards to the people who install such extensions and end up with spyware, I’m reminded of the saying, “It’s hard to cheat an honest person.”
- crtasm 8y agoI don't know about that, there's plenty of innocuous extensions that either started off with hidden bad intentions or sold their userbase and went rogue.
- downrightmike 8y ago"Hey, you've streamed this 10 times, would you like to download and save us bandwidth?"
- neotek 8y agoIt might interest some of you to know that youtube-dl has an awesome archive feature which will allow you to scrape a playlist periodically and only download new additions to that playlist. So when I stumble across a track I like, I just add it to my “favourites” playlist, and my PC at home will automatically download it, convert it to MP3, trim any silence from the beginning and end of the track, attempt to tag it (although that fails more often than not), and it’ll be there waiting for me the next time I feel like sorting through my music download folder.
- corobo 8y agoFor anyone else that wonders as I did, --download-archive downloaded.txt downloaded.txt will be used to store a list of video IDs. Any ID listed will not be re-downloaded
- wruza 8y agoJust mix half-loud ads into every stream and remove it in a player by using a sophisticated, autoevolving one-time js/wasm +cookie algorithm.
- binmanthrowaway 8y agoThis could become a genre, like rap when someone talks over music.