6 ms·
If you want to do development in a language other than python/ruby, or even want to use python libraries written in c, avoid the macbook. If you are certain yo
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
If you want to do development in a language other than python/ruby, or even want to use python libraries written in c, avoid the macbook. If you are certain
you will stick to {svn, git, django, python, vim}, you'll be fine. My mac ownership timeline:
Day 1: Ooh, pretty.
2-3 days: I fucking hate iTunes. Luckily ports install mpd works.
1 month: Ooh, the pretty magsafe connector saved me from dropping it when I tripped over the wire.
1.5 months: Arrgh, finally numpy works.
2 months: I miss XMonad.
3 months: Fuck, random C/C++ library (e.g., amqp_lib, boost for a while, quantlib, some Fortran medical imaging libraries) doesn't work. Or maybe it would work if I messed around with it more. Neither do many Haskell libraries (e.g. HFuse). I never managed to get postgres working either, though I've heard others have.
4 months: I want to get work done. Open up virtualbox, boot ubuntu server in a VM.
2 years later: load linux onto a thinkpad. Woohoo!
[edit: I am being a little unfair to the macbook. It has one fantastic feature which I still miss: keynote + LaTeXit + that little remote control. This makes pretty and very effective scientific presentations. OpenOffice Impress is not in the same league. It's less relevant to me now, since I'm no longer an academic mathematician.
Also, I don't mean to be unduly negative on macs. They just didn't satisfy me as a development box.
Lastly, things might have changed recently. I gave away my macbook early this year.]
- buro9 16y agoUncanny. I'm also 4 months in and am running Ubuntu in VMWare. That's now where I spend all of my time and I'm wondering why I haven't just dual-booted already or just over-written the OSX partition.
- megamark16 16y agoAre you me? 'Cause you sound just like me. I've even installed Ubuntu on a separate partition via Boot Camp, but I haven't had time to get all the stuff that doesn't work out of the box working. Maybe that will be my weekend project, we'll see... Good luck to you...me?
- qtcoder 16y agoInstalled virtual box on the first day and running Ubuntu since then.The day i convince myself(atleast fool myself) that i haven't spent too many bucks for OSX, will overwrite the partition.
- lusis 16y agoLast company I was at provided me a quad-core 8GB mac pro. After the first week I wiped it and put Ubuntu on it so I could actually get some work done. The biggest problem with OSX is that, for a unix-based system, it's so un-unix alike in key places that it's frustrating.
- igrekel 16y agoYou mean un-unix or un-linux? Which parts?
- lusis 16y agoThat's a fair statement. I think there were two big ones: - the service registry/init system - filesystem paths The second is minor in the grand scheme of things. It only affects my user account but the first one was greatly annoying. My history is in AIX/HP-UX before going Linux full time so I'm familiar with the smit/sam model of doing things but have you ever tried to actually usea traditional unix/linux model for managing apache in the default OSX install? What about LDAP? It's weird and annoying. Launchd? Seriously?
- igrekel 16y agoThe Mac I have is in the living room for family use so I have not "worked" a lot on it. I didn't use much of the default tools and relied more on macports for unix stuff. I was asking because I am considering a Mac to replace the windows laptop with cygwin I use for dev. I use Linux for servers but I am from the world of Solaris I also had HP and Irix workstations at different jobs in the past and a NeXT at home. I know the defaults are all Linux oriented these days so any different flavor of unix is always a little extra work if the filesystem differs to much. Macports also adds a little twist to that. I found launchd verbose (and the xml is not even that self descriptive) and I am not sure its worth the departure from the usual way of doing things but I didn't think it was so bad. I only did a few simple things anyway. These seem like things I don't rely on too much on a dev laptop anyway. But I now believe I have to investigate a bit more before I buy the new machine. Thanks
- cvg 16y agoI, like many others, also use virtualbox for development. So much easier to develop on something close to my production servers, but it uses up too much memory. I've been looking at some cheap Walmart/Frys PCs to install ubuntu on and develop.
- rafiq 16y agoUnfortunately the dual boot solution does not work if you're writing low-level code as I found out when playing with some gnu assembler code. I mostly do development on a VirtualBox machine. I'm considering switching back to a PC.
- fragmede 16y agoCan you be more specific? As in, why not install your preferred host OS, be it windows or some flavor of linux, and run virtual box on top anyway?
- tjr 16y agoJust to toss this question in, because I've seen lots of people make a similar comment, but never have really seen an explanation as to why: what is the problem with iTunes? For me, I don't do much in the way of using iTunes; I set up a play list, press play, minimize it, and enjoy listening to music while I do other things. Maybe I'm not a music player power user?
- watty 16y agoI dislike iTunes because it's so bloated and memory hungry (unless it changed changed over the years). I use Foobar2k to do the same thing, load up and just play music.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoSome "features" of iTunes: When I import my music folder, iTunes copies all the files to it's own private directories, using the filesystem as an index. Thanks, but my music is already arranged the way I like. iTunes doesn't play flac or ogg. And when I rip a CD, it wants to save it in some proprietary flac-like format (which, as far as I know, does not work on non-macs). I enjoy controlling my music from a phone/tablet/other computer. Shameless plug: http://github.com/stucchio/DJ-Pirate http://github.com/stucchio/DJ-Pirate http://cims.nyu.edu/~stucchio/software/djpirate/screenshot1.png http://cims.nyu.edu/~stucchio/software/djpirate/screenshot1.... http://cims.nyu.edu/~stucchio/software/djpirate/screenshot3.png http://cims.nyu.edu/~stucchio/software/djpirate/screenshot3.... iTunes + iPod also has some extremely unpleasant anti-features: http://support.apple.com/kb/ht1202 http://support.apple.com/kb/ht1202 (Note: this may not all still be true, haven't used iTunes since 2007. )
- docgnome 16y agoYou can turn the copying files "feature" off. Still annoying. I also hate iTunes.
- silentbicycle 16y agoThe Venn diagram of (people who like iTunes, people who like mpd* ) would look like two circles, separated by hundreds of miles of barren tundra. That's like the intersection between plumbers and meerkats. * Self included. Lua mpd library, FWIW: http://github.com/silentbicycle/lua-mpd http://github.com/silentbicycle/lua-mpd
- tkaemming 16y agoOdd — I'm running Snow Leopard and haven't had any issues with many of the libraries or apps you mentioned (boost, ampqlib, postgresql), although it's probably worth noting that I installed them all through Homebrew (http://www.github.com/mxcl/homebrew/ http://www.github.com/mxcl/homebrew/).
- yummyfajitas 16y agoThat reminds me of another thing I disliked about macs. An open question: who is in charge? Macports? Fink? I couldn't pick one, because neither one had what I wanted. I think Homebrew is fairly new. If it works, I'm glad, but it didn't exist a few years back. So, a disclaimer I should have included in my original post: things might have changed in the past year. The package manager I found useful was virtualbox + apt-get.
- __david__ 16y agoMacPorts and Fink both annoy me. Not because they are bad but because they are "so close but so far." I end up mostly compiling stuff manually and managing /usr/local with GNU Stow. Which is frustrating because so many mac installers seem to want to install stuff into /usr/local. I've learned to unpack the installer and install it manually so my beautiful stow-ness isn't compromised.
- bradendouglass 16y agoSame here, homebrew rocks Fink and Macports way out of the water. If you need any type of packet management and you are on a Mac, it should be your go to option.
- babeKnuth 16y agosex packet management? homebrew is definitely the true sound of the digital underground
- dzlobin 16y agopsycopg2 on snow leopard has been notoriously fucked forever. There are thousands of blog posts on installing this, of which only one has worked for me in the past. This, granted, wasn't through homebrew; I wonder if that would have worked back then
- timwiseman 16y agoI must say that while I am not a huge fan of OSX, Macs have amazingly well designed hardware. I remembering staring and marvelling at the magsafe power cord the first time I saw it, and every piece of the hardware is well made too.
- kevinbutler 16y agoHaving just had to replace a magsafe power cord (fortunately Apple does it free now, even out-of-warranty), I think the design needed a bit of tweaking, which later models have received. http://support.apple.com/kb/ts1713 http://support.apple.com/kb/ts1713 issue #6 , "strain relief issues" kb
- eru 16y agoCan't you just run Linux on your Macbook?
- yummyfajitas 16y agoThe Blub paradox applies to operating systems, not just languages. You can only avoid the Blub paradox by truly immersing yourself, and I was making a genuine attempt to do that. Macs are truly not right for me - if I gave up and switched to linux 3 months in, I'd never have known that.
- eru 16y agoPerhaps. Have you given the BSDs a try?
- yummyfajitas 16y agoI'm dabbling with FreeBSD on a VM right now. I plan to build a router/fileserver on FreeBSD at some point in the near future. ZFS looks sweet.
- eru 16y agoOK. On a grander scale, we should probably look into non-Unix operating systems more often, too.
- thecoffman 16y agoI do my primary development on a Mac and haven't had problems with boost, etc. I occasionally run into dependency problems or other frustrations, but no more than I would on any other system. I just enjoy the overall flexibility of having the POSIX system for development, but a ui that doesn't look and work like it thrown together by some kid in a garage when I want just want to web surf or play media, etc. I would highly recommend going the Mac route personally , but it really boils down to personal preference.
- boothead 16y agoI recently (2 days ago) installed refit on my macbook pro and now have a dual boot with ubuntu 10.10 (which, by the way, rocks so hard I might not boot back into OSX again). That's the best of both worlds for me: mac hardware, OSX for my wife and ubuntu for me. Perfect.
- technomancy 16y agoMacs are a lot more solidly-built than they used to be, but there are a few of things still keeping them from being competitive with Thinkpads. 0) They don't try to compete on screen resolution. The 13-inch Macbook screen is only 800 pixels tall, which is fewer pixels than my phone. 1) They're quite heavy. In particular the 13-inch is only marginally lighter than the 15-inch. 2) The glossy screens make them unusable outdoors. Perhaps if you mostly keep your laptop on your desk this wouldn't be a big deal, but it rules them out for people who like to move around.
- slantyyz 16y agoI don't think you could do much work on a 13" screen anyways. The 15" mbps, however, are competitive with resolution with the latest generation.
- jamesbritt 16y ago"I don't think you could do much work on a 13" screen anyways. " I used a 12" Toshiba portege laptop as my development machine for some time, and the 1920x1200 res rocked. So much so that ever since then I made a point of getting 1920x1200 on each new laptop. This was one reason I skipped on getting a macbook. Poor rez options, and no trackpoint mouse.
- saveriomiroddi 16y agoConfirmed here. I've chosen a Thinkpad x200s over a MacBook Pro. Advantages of an x200s over a MacBook Pro 13": - high screen resolution: 1440x900 - smaller and lighter - I can change the HDD very easily - one USB plug more - the x201s also has support for Intel Core i7. Disadavantages: - Battery life, I guess - Speakers, but doesn't matter for business users - Webcamera, whose lank on TP is quite strange DVD writer is personal preference. I explicitly don't want it in laptops. From a strictly techical perspective, although more loosely business one, choosing a Thinkpad x20*s over a Macbook Pro 13 is a no-brainer.
- slantyyz 16y agoYou would have saved a lot of time, pain and effort if you just spent Day 1 installing Linux on your laptop whether it was a dual boot or via virtualization.
- fnl 16y agoI use OSX 10.6 for C and Python, at times Cpp and only if forced to I even do Ruby or Java development on my MBPs (got two - boast...). I do not like either fink or MacPorts and install everything myself. So far, I have not encountered a single library or program I needed and was not able to install after some research at worst. This means virtually all essential C and C++ libraries mentioned in these posts (I do not bother with "junk" - and OSX comes with a sensible default selection, too). The only big boo-hoo is that OSX' Python build is a narrow build, but fixes a socket problem that makes using MacPython slightly unattractive. So, if you really only want hardcore development from your beloved shell and vi, get a laptop and run Gentoo. If you want to enjoy digital media (movies, sound, etc.) while working and want to have a consistent and interoperable UI experience, go Mac. Period.
- vilya 16y agoI agree, but you forgot to mention the killer issue (for me): there's no '#' key. Having to press Alt+3 for a '#' gets annoying pretty quickly when you're coding. It's even worse if you're running Linux on the MacBook. You have to fiddle with a mysteriously named keyboard preference ("Key to choose 3rd level") to get even the Alt+3 combination to work - and once it does, you can no longer Alt+Tab to switch between windows. Fortunately you can choose a different key; the best compromise I've found so far is to the right Alt key. That way you can enter '#' symbols and Alt+Tab back and forth, but it turns what should be a single keystroke into a two handed combination. That and the lagging OpenGL support are why my next computer won't be a Mac.
- artlogic 16y agoI'm confused by what you're saying here - do you have a keyboard with '#' as a primary key? Every keyboard I've ever used requires shift-3 to generate a '#'. Your reference to 3rd level keys seems to refer to an international keyboard. Is your keyboard not a U.S. layout?
- eru 16y agoCan't you just use your own layouts on the Mac, if something about the keyboard bugs you? (I only tried using dvorak an the Macbook, and it works fine.)
- vilya 16y agoTo be honest I've never tried. I use a standard UK keyboard at work and I've got a vague feeling that there'd be too much cognitive dissonance for me to learn a new layout without the right labels on the keys.
- eru 16y agoHow about not learning a new layout, but just using a `normal' layout you are used to? Instead of having to get used to the Mac layout.
- 16y ago
- more_original 16y agoI had almost exactly the same experience. I had a Mac (Powerbook) for almost 3 years and could get work done, but development was sometimes a hassle where it shouldn't have been (just to upgrade gcc one had to download 2gigs of XCode; installing exotic C/C++ libraries had to be done by hand; any X11-app, like inkscape, is a real pain to use; things like that). And in the end I was only using apps that have a natural home on Linux anyway (vim, latex, ocaml, java, inkscape). I now run Ubuntu on a Thinkpad and that "Just Works" for development more than the Powerbook ever did.