8 ms·
This, and before that taxi driver murderers were also heard of often in China (though I’m not sure if they were more likely to be murderers than average). Also
by seanmcdirmid 8y ago
This, and before that taxi driver murderers were also heard of often in China (though I’m not sure if they were more likely to be murderers than average).
Also, Chinese police are overworked (China is extremely under policed ironically enough) and so tend to focus on seemingly easy but impractical solutions to fighting crime.
- village-idiot 8y agoThere’s often political pressures on police departments to fix unpopular statistics, and not the actual issue. Most famously this leads Japanese departments to label difficult murder cases as suicides.
- 0x8BADF00D 8y agoExcellent point. This is a prime example of how government intervention mucks things up by setting up relatively benign goals, but in practice leads to an outcome that is unchanged, or perhaps even worse. What if all Japanese citizens were allowed to carry guns out in the open? An armed society is a polite society.
- EliRivers 8y agoAn armed society is a polite society "Polite" just means "in keeping with cultural norms". If it's polite to deal with disagreements, injuries and insults by pulling a gun, that's still polite but I certainly wouldn't feel safe.
- baybal2 8y agoYou can legally own an artillery piece in Pakistan, but I can't vouch for manners of locals
- jstarfish 8y ago> An armed society is a polite society. If you believe that, you've never lived in Atlanta (or Japan for that matter).
- jchb 8y ago> An armed society is a polite society. Perhaps suggesting that the Japanese need more guns to be polite wasn't the best example. Japan is already one of the most (the most?) polite society in the world - at least talking about how strangers interact.
- village-idiot 8y agoIt’s less about governments, and more about how the law of unintended consequences applies in all human matters. Example: anthropologists believe that on the whole, more polite societies typically murder each other at a higher rate than less polite societies.
- bopbop 8y agoThat's an amazing stat - do you have a source for that?
- village-idiot 8y agoHere’s a forum thread with an overview and some links to primary sources: https://www.debatepolitics.com/philosophical-discussions/221604-polite-cultures-more-violent.html https://www.debatepolitics.com/philosophical-discussions/221...
- bopbop 8y agoamazing, thank you.
- tdfx 8y ago> An armed society is a polite society. *An armed society of rational people is a polite society. And people tend to slip in and out of a rational state depending on their emotions, pride, sobriety, etc.
- azurezyq 8y agoDo you have data supporting data for your claim? I'm a Chinese and this kind of murders are really rare. The last one I heard in my hometown (a small costal city) is over 10 years ago. And with taxi-hailing apps' commence, this is becoming really rare since the driver can easily pin-pointed (by cross-referencing ubiquitous street cams). Actually in this case the murderer got arrested soon afterwards. While I agree China is under policed, they are generally more effective in body offenses and thanks to street cams (again). These years even home break-ins are rare. As who lived in SF for a year, it's definitely better than SFPD.
- dmoy 8y agoI don't think the point was that cab murders were high, just that both were low, so the whole freak out is probably not rational. The "heard of often" just means it gets plastered on the news / social media when it does happen.
- gbraad 8y ago> not rational If it could have been prevented, it is the right reaction. Besides, this is how China works most of the time. Pressure (boycot) on companies leads to results... or put them out of (nearly) business.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoI believe that was my original point: Chinese officials will rely on didi to police it’s drivers, since having the police instead do that isn’t practical. But it winds up being worse than that, since if didi wasn’t around we would all be taking anonymous black cabs again.
- gbraad 8y agoWhat is wrong with the usual cabs? Sure, slightly more expensive but reliable.
- 8y ago
- illuminati1911 8y agoChina has one of the lowest intentional homicide rates in the world. I’m actually writing this from Didi at the moment. It’s quite irrational to overhype these didi-murders since China is a country of about 1.4 billion people and statistically these incidents are pretty much meaningless. I guess it’s same kind of irrationality like in the west, when people try to come up with problems about Uber that have always existed in other contextes.
- dis-sys 8y agowell done on defending the company with zero social responsibility in mind. the problem is never about the murder itself, it is all about the fact that didi worked extremely hard to intentionally prevent any help that can be offered to save the victim - 1. another customer reported the murder a day before for harassment, Didi refused to look into the case 2. when the victim's family & friends reach out to Didi after receiving messages from the victim asking for help, Didi refused to do anything other than asking them to wait. 3. when the victim's family & friends reported the incident to the police, the police immediately contacted Didi but again Didi refused to provide any help.