23 ms·
Teens who refuse to use social media
- m1573rp34130dy 8y agoI would hire these kids almost sight unseen
- drewmol 8y agoDidn't find much but if any of them are in Reading, PA you can buy printed classified in Reading Eagle newspaper here: http://www2.readingeagle.com/Readingeagle-Media-Kit/classified-format-and-rates.html http://www2.readingeagle.com/Readingeagle-Media-Kit/classifi...
- thecatspaw 8y agohow does not using social media make people valuable as an employee?
- m1573rp34130dy 8y agoit displays a mindset that is outside of average, and demonstrates awareness rather than intellectual vulnerability... I would add i look for skills but i also look for potentials that may be developed, partnership in development is important and superior to using a biological robot that needs constant maintenence...
- grenoire 8y agoErhm... Intellectual vulnerability is really pushing it, and it's a bit degrading. Not everybody currently using social media is blindly addicted to it.
- m1573rp34130dy 8y agothats why these kids are leaving it, they are not blindly addicted to it... i think blindly addicted is a somewhat degrading euphemism as well the manipulation that occurs so someone can make ad revenue is one thing, the attack on the wetware is another look at present POTUS
- grenoire 8y agoYou are ignoring that for many others it's a platform that they rely on for communications. Quitting Facebook was easy in my circle, but I still have people who message me through Instagram. Network effect is often not negligible.
- TheForumTroll 8y agoThey message you on Instagram because they can..
- grenoire 8y agoI don't disagree with that but you gotta' realise that some people only use Instagram and Facebook for their communications, so I can't get them to WhatsApp, SMS, or email me.
- 4rgento 8y agoAs stated elsewhere in this thread, social media is about collecting your data. This includes what you like, what you hate, what makes you happy, who you love, who you look up to, etc... Now, this can be used to set your(not you but the social media user, no need to be an addict) mood and thus your emotions. This is what advertisers use to target ads or design them. Your "intellect", in the short therm, is heavily dependent on your mood and your emotions. By "intellect", I'm referring to how you interact to the environment. (E.g. a sad person would interact with other people differently than a person that just made a million dollars). So, if social media has such a handle on your emotions they have a handle on your intellect (its manifestations, which is the only thing other people can perceive ). I would say "that intellect" is vulnerable. Because it is not serving your best interests. Because it's been manipulated to make you want to buy a new car, for example. PS: I know this is controversial opinion and a lot of people will hate it. But I do believe this is the case given my current understanding of machine learning capabilities and human cognition.
- m1573rp34130dy 8y agovery interesting analysis
- ddebernardy 8y agoNot the OP, but all things being equal, the lack of incessant notifications makes a huge difference to one's ability to stay focused and thus to one's productivity.
- m1573rp34130dy 8y agothank you...
- thecatspaw 8y agoAgreed, its the notifications which are the productivity killer. Not the social media platforms. With all of them you can disable notifications. Funnily enough my biggest productivity killer at work is slack.
- ddebernardy 8y agoOh yeah, Slack (or equivalent) is a monster too. But it's unfortunately there to stay, at least for remote teams. A good way to ignore it, btw, is to disable notifications (including the one on the icon) and to spend most of the day in Do Not Disturb mode. It ensures you only read it on your schedule while leaving some leeway for when something urgent comes up. Another big productivity killer IMO is email. But that one's easier to manage if you stick to doing it once or twice per day only and have rules that get corporate email noise out of your way.
- m1573rp34130dy 8y ago...the demand for a response is wired in to most undamaged wetware... ...willing compliance is a phenomenal leverage point... being social creatures the whole tribe is in chaos if we dont comply or come to consensus of group action, thus blind faith in authorities of all types exist as a conditioned response
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoGo back to a decade ago (with today's knowledge of how social media would transform and grow, to make things fair), and imagine you were able to program yourself. Over the next decade how many hours would you allocate to 'waste time on social media'? How many hours did you actually spend doing that? I think there's hardly a person that's satisfied with the amount of time they spend on these outlets, yet actually stopping can be very difficult. It requires immense self discipline, an ability to realize where and how time can be more effectively spent, as well as a big picture view to even realize there's an issue to begin with.
- thecatspaw 8y agoWith today's knowledge, I wouldnt create any facebook and reddit accounts (only social media where I feel like I wasted a lot of time on). Now I dont have any accounts there anymore. It wasnt hard to quit. All it took was a serious "oh fuck this shit" moment, just like I quit smoking. But am I a better employee because of that? I dont think so. Not having social media doesnt solve any motivation/discipline/attention span problems
- m1573rp34130dy 8y ago...But you escaped the skinner box ! kudos... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operant_conditioning_chamber https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operant_conditioning_chamber
- toomanybeersies 8y agoGo to a cafe and see how many employees are staring at their phone. When I used to work in hospo it seemed like the front of house staff spent more time on their phones than doing actual work. I don't know what it used to be like, I assume that disinterested employees found other ways to sham off work, but social media and smartphones are a real productivity killer.
- m1573rp34130dy 8y agoi believe the two [smartphone+socialmedia] are a bitter pill... i actually destroyed the first smartphone i bought, reason being everytime i attempted to do something constructive the device had other plans, notifications, upgrades in the middle of a task, FB wants your attention or some piece of info, web queries or http lookups funneling through google, but not bcz i have no G+ account... [speedball pitch/smashingglass] and then i swore off smartphones
- thecatspaw 8y agoSure, but that is not a problem of social media, its a problem of bored workers looking to cure their boredom. If they arent on their phone they would be reading something or staring holes into the air. I dont have any of the traditional social medias, yet I still slack of frequently, get distracted all the time. Imho there is very little to no connection between social media usage and productivity.
- m1573rp34130dy 8y agothe usage of social media isnt a productivity issue its the skinner boxing that is deployed by almost all outlets, the many onion skin layers that slowly morphed what was a very effective tool for communication into a brain training device similar to television... HN is one of the few that are still a blogalike format... there is a wonderfull limitation to a single media format such as flat_ascii vs multimedia...
- thecatspaw 8y agobut even HN is a skinner box. It rewards you with points for writing comments that people like. Its exactly the same as reddit in that regard. Yes, social media is used to shape people's thoughts and opinions, same as advertisements, television, newspapers, books, people you're talking to. So I can only repeat my question, what makes me better than someone else who has facebook and reddit? I am not invincible to operant conditioning, advertisements and people pushing their own agenda on me either
- draw_down 8y agoYuck
- kowdermeister 8y agoAny openings left? https://cdn.vox-cdn.com/thumbor/MpA2HVftSFntl9HhmhlQA3MEjIU=/0x0:1409x785/1200x800/filters:focal(622x252:846x476)/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_image/image/55701647/Screen_Shot_2017_07_13_at_1.09.20_PM.0.png https://cdn.vox-cdn.com/thumbor/MpA2HVftSFntl9HhmhlQA3MEjIU=...
- m1573rp34130dy 8y agoyup im older than dirt too... does cult of the dead cow or temple of the screaming electron sound familiar? };=-
- gm-conspiracy 8y agoCDC! Back Orifice?
- m1573rp34130dy 8y agoBO was something in its day ... .-" "-. / \ |. .-. .-. .| | )(__/ \__)( | |/ /\ \| (___ ^^ ___) |_|IIIIII|_| _| B.O.|_ | \IIIIII/ | \ -- / `------' ...a little ascii jigsaw puzzle courtesy of format mangling... ...and no, im not sir dystic ...I also just had the association ! BO gives a different connotation to R.A.T.S in a box....how about that astalavista on sk.box :-D
- black_puppydog 8y ago- among the 45-plus age bracket, the proportion who value social media has increased from 23% to 28% in the past year why is social media uncool? because all the parents are there now :D well, and all the other reasons...
- majewsky 8y agoThis argument ignores that social media is not socialmedia.com, but several different networks. If you're on Snapchat, it doesn't matter if your parents are on Facebook.
- spuz 8y agoYes and no... teenagers are pretty smart. If they think it's lame when their mum spends all weekend scrolling through her Facebook feed, they are going to recognise the same bad habits in themselves scrolling through their Snapchat feed. From talking to teens, it seems they are pretty aware of the harms of social media in general it's not just a matter of doing what their parents don't.
- Gustomaximus 8y ago> Generation Z – people born after 1995 – half of those surveyed stated they had quit or were considering quitting at least one social media platform That seems incorrectly taken statement. They represent it as though people are leaving social media. That is a false logic. E.g. Peeps may have swapped instagram to snapchat... It would be interesting to know what % dont use social media by age group.. Something here: http://www.pewinternet.org/2018/03/01/social-media-use-in-2018/ http://www.pewinternet.org/2018/03/01/social-media-use-in-20...
- adrianratnapala 8y agoTrue, but the existence of churn is interesting in itself. A few years ago we feared people would be stuck on one platform because all their friends are stuck there. That doesn't mean people are exactly choosing freely now, they might be following the herd because all their friends are following the herd. But at least upstarts can compete for the future herds.
- SimplyUnknown 8y agoFunny that your link includes WhatsApp as a social medium. I don't see it like that at all. For me it is just a free alternative to SMS. Besides, they say it is big in Latin Amercia but in my country, Holland, I would guess that by now it is present on >95% of all smartphones. (latest source I could find was from 2016, which states that 92% of all smartphones in the Netherlands have WhatsApp installed, https://tweakers.net/nieuws/109689/whatsapp-staat-op-11-komma-2-miljoen-nederlandse-smartphones.html https://tweakers.net/nieuws/109689/whatsapp-staat-op-11-komm...). I would consider reddit, missing in the article, more of a social network than WhatsApp.
- saagarjha 8y agoI'm not going to kid myself into thinking that I don't spend time on social media (hello, Hacker News), but as someone who fits the age range described in the article and doesn't have much of a public account on the platforms listed, the only largest issue I've had is the increasing tendency towards disseminating information only through these channels. Usually I grab someone who does have an account and get them to relay the information, but I'm probably missing things that I don't realize.
- moreira 8y agoWhat makes Hacker News social media? It's just a forum, essentially, like the forums of old. There are threads, and people can reply to them. There are no friendships or any kind of social graph associated with it, which is what makes a social media platform, for me.
- voltooid 8y agoHacker news is definitely more a forum than social media platform. But the temptation to collect "likes" and the resulting dopamine high is a thing on HN too.
- blackbrokkoli 8y agoIt is also usable as an endless stream of infotainment if your concern is plummeting productivity
- barrow-rider 8y agoThat hit close to home. Gonna go shell into a server and start fixing stuff now...
- rland 8y agoAnd it has the convenient sleight of being somewhat related to work, so it can ocassionally bypass the “this is unproductive B.S.” procrastination filter.
- makach 8y agoI'm pretty sure they are communicating somehow, through creating their own ad-hoc social media - possibly also without them knowing it themselves, or thinking that this is social media. I am guessing that they are creating their own communities, which we haven't been discovered yet! A golden opportunity for the entrepreneur to monetize once the pattern becomes obvious! Social media today has many issues, maybe kids opposing it is the big autocorrect which is needed to improve it and get them back on board.
- satori99 8y ago> A golden opportunity for the entrepreneur to monetize once the pattern becomes obvious! ...which leads to inevitable over-commercialization. Then the cool kids abandon it to start new secret communities. A golden opportunity for the entrepreneur to monetize once the pattern becomes obvious! ...
- m1573rp34130dy 8y agoThis is what i find outstanding...there is a level of self awareness, and situational awareness that seems uncommon...the ability to be outside the box as well as think outside the box demonstrates qualities that we headhunt for all the time...
- Rainymood 8y agoIronically, I came across this article first on facebook, of course.
- sigi45 8y agoI thought that Facebook as an family and friends image sharing will be great but now as it isn't used for that at all (in my circle) and people do care about memories but totally happy with only using Whatsapp, I also don't care for fun at all. Only for contacts I have on FB through messenger. No wonder that kids don't care.
- mrweasel 8y agoRecently I've started asking people around be about the Facebook usages, and pretty much everyone falls into the same pattern: Messenger / Messenger group chats. As for Facebook it self, very few people post anything, and they've all noticed that their friends are posting next to nothing. It's all people who share bargains from the local supermarket, chances to win some prize and the occasional funny video. It's different for difference circles of people of cause, but for many Facebook have been reduced to a stream of localized advertising and nonsense. Thing that Facebooks does seem to do well is small communities and crowd sourced local news.
- scarygliders 8y agoMy son was born in 2001 and only uses Facebook due to most communication routed through there from the Air Cadets he is a member of. Otherwise he doesn't particularly like social media and usually turns off all notifications/largely ignores the "wittering on" occurring on those platforms. He also does use Snapchat as there is a group of Air Cadets on that platform. He also plays the odd video game so has a Discord account. But he doesn't obsess over social media like perhaps a generation before his does. IMO that's a good thing. In my late 40's, I too have a Facebook account, but largely ignore it bar having to use it to read the Air Cadet's parent group for important information I should know about. If it weren't for that, I'd be deleting my account there - have done so before. Unfortunately I reconnected with quite a few friends and acquaintances, and have grown weary of the utter crap and banality a lot of them post on there - as time has worn on I find I have a lot less in common with a lot of these people than I thought I did, and the posting of twee political virtue signalling and rubbish or out of context memes only they get and find funny, has taken its toll. I need to go through the contacts list and perform a thorough 'cleansing', now that I think about it.
- thejj100100 8y agoThat seems similar to me, I only really have social media for air cadets as they require you to be in their Facebook group - I’d avoided Facebook until I joined air cadets but I never go on Facebook to look at the main feed, etc
- majewsky 8y ago> My son was born in 2001. > But he doesn't obsess over social media like perhaps a generation before his does. Back in my days, "a generation" was roughly 20-25 years. :) Generation X did not have social media when they grew up.
- phit_ 8y agoI have noticed there is quite the difference between born 2000+ and 1993+, due to the older of these groups still remembering a time where not everyone had a computer in their pockets. By the time someone born in 2000 made it to school almost everyone had a phone/smartphone.
- Memosyne 8y agoI absolutely abhor the current state of social media and its usage by young people. As a teenager myself, I have both experienced and observed the negative influences of these outlets and consider their existence unethical. Far too often have these apps condoned terrible deeds while encouraging foolish acts of vanity. As a young person, you feel compelled to participate in digital fads -- like "challenges" or "pranks" -- or risk being ostracized. Regardless of how extreme these things get, social media always manages to make them popular by appealing to a semi-educated audience -- teens. Social media is providing young people with an accessible form of communication, but its current mainstream implementation is seriously flawed. Every image or text seems to be filtered; kids are evaluating their self worth based on how close their photos resemble other heavily edited pictures. Trying to discuss actual topics is almost impossible because flagging dissenting views has become the primary form of discourse. Virtue signaling seems to be the only way to not be branded as a menace to society. Oh, and there's the whole problem of adults abusing their authority and fame to manipulate the reactions of kids. There needs to be regulations which prohibit apps from generating content which incites such stupidity. Sure, freedom of speech is precious but when kids interact with one another under the impression that there is limited oversight, they do dumb things. We've all been kids and we can at least attest to that.
- laumars 8y ago> Trying to discuss actual topics is almost impossible because flagging dissenting views has become the primary form of discourse. I see this happening a lot on HN as well. I think the issue isn't so much age or education but rather people are lazy and/or don't often like confrontation.
- jcims 8y agoI think HN does a better job of moderating than most. The times I do see dissenting views getting the boot is when the person can't manage to air those views without being a shithead. If you're a solitary voice for a perspective it can be hard to find the balance of force and civility necessary to get your point across, but it is important.
- 8y ago
- dumitrupetrov 8y agoMore like "choose" not "refuse". It's a choice.
- Jaruzel 8y agoAdding another anecdotal comment to the pile... My Daughter is 21. Depending on where you read, she's either tail-end Millennial, or early Gen-Z. Her usage of social media is very minimal - She posts rarely on Facebook, never on Instagram or Twitter. She does however have very active Snapchat groups and uses Messenger. Both are simply for conversations with her social group. Are closed chat groups 'social media'? If we were to say yes to this, then SMS texts and IRC and Forums are also social media. I'm not sure where the line gets drawn. As an old fogey in his 40s, I do not use Facebook or Instagram. I post to Twitter when I need to reach out to an organisation or a person, and it's their preferred way for contact. I also delete anything I tweet after a few days. I used to use Facebook heavily, but it just became a pointless waste of time, all people care about on Facebook are the likes and shares, and not the actual content. All social media is based on the emotional feedback loop of 'Share/Post -> Get Likes -> Feel Validated -> Repeat'. 'Likes' create an endorphin hit that many people get addicted to. In this manner it's no different from a class-A drug. Sharing stuff online is fine, but creators of these platforms insist on gameifying it with likes, ThumbsUps, Votes and Shares, and it's this part of the social media eco-system that's toxic.
- nabakin 8y agoI hope more people are starting to realize just how bad social media is. I'm 20 and I only use Facebook Messenger because the rest seems like a waste of time and a cesspool of memes/sensationalized news. Of course memes aren't inherently bad, it's just they drive that dopamine-induced feedback loop. Each platform has good aspects, but the cons really outweigh the pros imo.
- athenot 8y ago> I also delete anything I tweet after a few days. Interesting. An automated way to enforce my own retention policy on these platforms would surely be a good thing. More so for facebook than for twitter I feel (but that's just a personal preference).
- Jaruzel 8y agohttps://www.tweetdelete.net/ https://www.tweetdelete.net/ can do this. If you are happy with them having access to your twitter account. I used them to purge everything a while back, and now I just manually delete as I go.
- joaomacp 8y agoSocial media addiction will start to decrease just as tobacco addiction is decreasing on younger demographics. The youth have always been good at realizing how stupid some adult's habits are, and refusing to adopt them.
- iamkp 8y agoI don't have a Facebook, WhatsApp, Twitter or Instagram account now. But to me it seems like this is the new cool factor rather than choice, where quitting Facebook seems to make someone cool or distinct than using it.
- ratsimihah 8y agoNice one, save us Generation Z!
- woogiewonka 8y agoSlack (don't know if you'd qualify it as social media) has been raining havoc on my attention. For the life of me I can't seem to disable notifications and get constant emails and crap. Every new group you join you gotta go to settings and mess with settings forever. Why can't they just have 1 single button right in the channel that mutes EVERYTHING. Let me check the damn thing.
- wmeredith 8y agoBut their UX is so sticky! Gotta keep that engagement up! I am a UX director who hates Slack.
- eswat 8y agoAre these mostly public groups you’re joining? I think the friction towards turning notifications off stems from Slack being primary a tool for work, where you’d probably have more reasons to be notified of events than in a public channel.
- philip1209 8y agoMy girlfriend and I recently started "no phone Sundays". We keep our phones powered off from Saturday night until Monday morning. We spent this past Sunday navigating around Paris with a paper map, which was felt romantic in kind of a nostalgic way. I realized on the Metro that I kept making eye contact with people older than me - because they were the only ones not on their phones the entire time. I also realised how much not having a phone stimulates my curiosity - I spent my time looking around, listening to new things, and paying attention to what was happening around me. I think phones are powerful tools. But, your brain gets too used to constant stimulation. I think that it makes you less patient and more anxious as you get used to these constant hits of dopamine. You can never relax, and it makes it tough to live in the moment.
- pedroaraujo 8y agoSometimes I really wonder how people use their phones. Is it really necessary to go the extreme of needing to turn it off just to "fight off" the "addiction"? Speaking about myself, I only have notifications for emails and for messages directly addressed to me. I might check it occasionally on the bus to see what popped up in the news but other than that, I don't have the need to pull it from the pocket all the time. What exactly do people do different than this with their phones? I really feel that I have been missing something amazing with the smartphone usage when I read posts like this.
- TheForumTroll 8y ago>for messages directly addressed to me If that isn't only SMS messages you likely use it like most do. Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, WhatsApp, etc. I don't have a phone off day but I don't use any social media on my phone at all. I do believe anyone who does could use some time off because it is an addiction and most are addicted. Using it with other people around really should be frowned upon. Like back in the day when you only called people on the phone after 9 and before 21 and not at eating times. It is bad behavior really.
- gassiss 8y ago
- sam-mueller 8y agoThis is exactly why we set out to build Blink (YC SS ‘18), where you talk to friends face-to-face with video messaging, and share your plans to gather IRL for genuine, in-person connections. We think gen z will set a trend that bounces back from the social excess of the last decade, in favor of something more balanced and natural. This won’t necessarily mean ditching technology, but rather the technology evolving to facilitate healthy and more rewarding relationships. The most popular social apps out there optimize video for broadcasting your life at your friends (and followers), but not so much for actual conversation with your friends. Their Stories format only amplifies this concept: show off what you’re doing now to everyone who’s watching. Who should be surprised that it feels like a popularity contest competing for who has the most perfect life? What makes Blink different is a new video format we’re introducing that brings your words to life. Through a symbiosis of speech-to-text, NLP/NLU and kinetic typography, Blink captures your emotion and your words, resulting in video conversations that get the message across, sound or not! This is our foundation: Talk more, broadcast less. Message face-to-face, not with a text. If you’d like to see a preview of what we’ve been cooking up (and you have an iPhone), you’re welcome to check us out in the App Store: https://blink.cm https://blink.cm We’d love to hear your feedback!
- jumbopapa 8y agoIs there nothing about the app itself on the website? I'm interested in reading more about it, but I'm not ready to install it yet. Seems like a glaring oversight to not provide more information on the website.
- sam-mueller 8y agoYou can read (and see) more in the the App Store description without installing. We are pre-launch, so the focus has been on the app and platform rather than website & marketing material: https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/blink-video-messenger/id1199289898?mt=8 https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/blink-video-messenger/id1199...
- Chazprime 8y agoThis is a promising sign. Some children begin to exhibit behaviors resembling that of addiction when separated from their social media accounts, and in my experience, many parents don’t take it seriously.
- mbo 8y agoEvery time something like this gets posted, everyone on HN comes out of the woodwork and explains how they barely use social media. Snapchat makes it really easy for me to share what I'm doing, my location, and to quickly meet up with people. Messenger is great for group chats that I talk about garbage with mates all day. Instagram is good for sharing and talking about art and design. And Facebook is filled to the brim of fantastic memes, general shitposting and lovely private groups for specific interests. I'm constantly seeing events that my friends are attending on Facebook, and it makes it really easy to organise groups to attend them. What's not to love? Honestly, I read these threads and just think y'all just using social media wrong; no wonder why you're all having such a miserable time.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- woogiewonka 8y agoDid you read the article? The topic of conversation was teenagers who are looking to unplug because they are tired of what social media turns their peers into. They obviously have many things "not to love". I don't see anyone complaining about having a miserable time on social media - it's just that they recognize the need to unplug due to what social media does to your brain.
- mbo 8y agoYep. Do teenagers have unhealthy relationships with social media? Of course. They're teenagers. A lot of their relationships ARE unhealthy at that age anyway, and if disconnecting completely is the best way to rectify those issues, more power to them. What gets me is grown adults on HN talking about "abhoring social media" and "no phone Sundays with my girlfriend" and "having a minimal social media presence because I hate what it's become" and "I believe social media time should be controlled" and "social media is a class A drug". Like, chill. Go follow a few meme pages and hide the posts of the people you genuinely detest. There are ways to avoid those unhealthy cycles without entirely disconnecting oneself from literally all one's peers and losing the immense utility that social media provides.
- 8y ago
- lr4444lr 8y agoBut where am I supposed to meet them if they're logged off? (I kid.) Good for them!
- theLotusGambit 8y agoThis article has no substance. Its primary idea is that teens are moving away from social media, but lets look at how it actually backs that idea: So there's 5 anecdotes from 5 teenagers, all describing their dislike/disuse of social media. I don't know about you, but I think I could get 5 teenagers to back basically any claim I wanted with stories if I asked enough of them. I'm not saying that gathering opinions of the target audience is a bad thing, but just that 5 hand-selected samples out of an incredibly diverse group of people may not be entirely representative or meaningful. The only qualitative information presented here are the statistics, which I'll rattle off: 63% of British Schoolchildren in 2017 would be happy if social media was never invented according to a survey A survey of 9000 internet users found that in 2016, 66% said social media was important to them, but only 57% in 2018 58% of US teenagers had taken a break from one social media platform Facebook users aged 18-24 in Britain expected to fall 1.8% this year 41% of gen z teens said social media made them sad, anxious, or depressed I think it's entirely possible that there is a large trend among Gen Z of moving away from social media, but I don't think these statistics or anecdotes do a good job backing the claim up.
- jonny_eh 8y ago> The only qualitative information presented here are the statistics Do you mean quantitative?
- stephengillie 8y agoSimilar topic: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17856499 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17856499 Is today the "Submarine Ad" day for "Kids aren't using social media"? If so, who makes money from us knowing that young people don't use social media? What are they trying to sell to us?
- bobmarley1 8y agoYeah totally, the Snap and Facebook short sellers are astroturfing anti social media bias duuuude.
- booleandilemma 8y agoThere’s hope after all.
- yagodragon 8y agoI'm 20 years old, so i dont know if i'm within the gen Z range. I have a facebook and an instagram account. The problem is i think i don't know how this game works. I see some of my friends post mediocre photos or posts and get hundred of likes, others get a couple but they don't care. At first, my posts didn't get much traction and i was always shy to upload many photos. Nowadays, when i want to post something that i find interesting and talk about in the comments, i always think "what if no one cares?" "what if i don't get any likes". That has completely discouraged me for participating in the social media game and impacted my confidence. Now i only consume other peoples content. I see my friends talking about when to upload a photo so they can maximize their likes and i feel so out. It's like we have one more thing to compare one another. I'm not saying my friends value me for my likes, but i feel like it subconsciously creates a difference between us. Maybe i'm just very insecure or jealous but that social media thing just magnifies it.
- cirgue 8y agoI'm 29 years old, and I feel like the rest of generation got eaten by the internet. It's good to see some indication that people are starting to realize that social media is generally shit.
- thosakwe 8y ago(Disclaimer: I am Gen Z) Honestly, all of these "I refuse to use social media!" type articles just remind me of people who spam "all the music of this generation sucks; I'm 14 and I was born in the wrong generation" on YouTube videos. Going against the mainstream often is a package deal that comes bundled with a superiority complex against people who choose to engage in the activity that you choose not to engage in. I saw a comment in this very HN thread that goes so far as to say that youth who use social media display "intellectual vulnerability," and that _not_ using social media is an asset warranting immediate hire. Social media exists as a way to facilitate communication online over a long-distance, i.e. old friends who now live in different places. Problems that we think are "unique" to social media, like the loudest, wrongest voices getting the most attention, exist in human society outside of social media as well. It's not an exclusive phenomenon. Of course, not everybody has to use social media. But you're not a special snowflake just because you don't have an app installed on your phone...
- phil21 8y agoI'm Gen X, and unless you count message boards and HN-like places I've never used social media. Not because I thought "the music of this generation sucks" but because it was easy to see the horrific way the Internet was going to go with walled gardens and centralization. I predicted 10 years ago if you uploaded and tagged photos on facebook you were giving up 100% of your privacy forever, as now every single photo of you ever taken (private or in public) will eventually be tracked to a name. I think generations coming up today really missed out on seeing the potential of the Internet, and what's it's become is nothing resembling the dreams of the 90's. There are far more reasons to be wary and not participate in social media than "I'm just better than everyone". And yes - it's a huge hit to your ability to continue an active social life. But things like SMS, Instant Messenger phones, e-mail, etc. still exist. The other downside is you tend to collect friends willing to deal with that, so it can kind of put you into a bubble if you don't reach outside your comfort zone. I've found dating someone with an already established social media presence (e.g. too late to opt out, why bother) is a decent compromise :)
- thosakwe 8y ago
- faissaloo 8y agoGen-Z here: Facebook was invaded by moms, Instagram locked me out and their customer support is non-existent, Fedi was better than Twitter for sharing my thoughts and getting genuine conversations going. Mainstream social media is dying imo, there's just nothing really there that's worth the effort.
- tobyhinloopen 8y agoI hate the "Gen X/Y/Z" terms, why do these even exist?
- typetehcodez 8y agoI think a healthy level of social media use is to share photos, and ask for advice and recommendations. Anything else is social engineering that you are a deliberate manipulator of or unbeknownst participator. Flame bait, click bait, emotionally charged posts of the troll-or-be-trolled should be avoided. Also, comparison is the thief of joy. Don't do it. If you find yourself feeling inadequate compared to others, just keep in mind that most people feel that way, consciously or not. Keep in mind that you should only ever compare yourself to your past self, not to other people.
- TBastiani 8y agoI love that the teen on the top photo is reading brave new world. :-P
- lowow01 8y agoWell spotted
- triviatise 8y agoFor those of you who claim to not use social media. HN is social media..
- graposaymaname 8y agoI have no idea how legit the article is, but I strongly believe that social media should be controlled.It's never the case of quitting social media all together, but redesigning it according to human values, respecting it, might be the way forward. Personal Experience: I tried quitting WhatsApp for 3 days, months ago and I still remember the amount of shock my friends had.Upon checking it after 3 days, Most of the messages were like "Hey man are you dead or what??".But then, only one had called me.In no way does this show that others are not compassionate or something like that.It's because everyone is so used to using it that they can't imagine a world without it. Then I did something more exotic I quit WhatsApp for 2 months.Huu man. It was difficult.The fax machine problem is inevitable, I didn't miss out much important stuff because it was during summer break, when classes reopened I had to take it again(Or I would miss assignments :/ ).But at times I feel that the shit I skipped over was really worth it. PS: Go through http://humanetech.com/ http://humanetech.com/ I really wish every one adopted these as standards.Tristan Harris really seems to be talking sense guys.
- phonz 8y agoI was in high school when Facebook came out. I rejected social media and never engaged with it. I’ve never had a Snapchat or a Facebook or an Instagram. When Facebook came out it just seemed obvious to me that it was a bad idea. It was basically a brutal platform that hugely magnified the ugly, quantitative aspect of socializing. Who’s the most popular? Who’s the smartest and funniest? Friend count and likes and so on basically streamline the process of judging others and self evaluation. It’s brutal and anxiety inducing and it never made any sense. Of course the root of the problem is the people who use it who are viscious and mean. Affluent American teenagers are some of the worst human beings on the planet.
- coffeeandjunk 8y ago> As young people increasingly reject social media, older generations increasingly embrace it. This is like Tesla (and other startups generally) do it. Sell it to the rich people to garner attention, and then slowly when you've got enough growth/money/experience, sell it to others. Teens were the lead users. Old people are just the laggards in social media. Also, Facebook (in its infancy) used to be the place where cool teens hung out. Now if it's the place where your grand dad hangs out, it isn't so hip anymore. No surprise that teens would prefer dropping off.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]