6 ms·
The reddit discussion for this post is a telling confirmation of the articles complaints about the community forums/interaction: https://www.reddit.com/r/elm/co
by detaro 8y ago
The reddit discussion for this post is a telling confirmation of the articles complaints about the community forums/interaction: https://www.reddit.com/r/elm/comments/9a0hc6/elm_019_broke_us/ https://www.reddit.com/r/elm/comments/9a0hc6/elm_019_broke_u...
- kragniz 8y agoTo see the deleted comments: https://www.ceddit.com/r/elm/comments/9a0hc6/elm_019_broke_us/ https://www.ceddit.com/r/elm/comments/9a0hc6/elm_019_broke_u...
- lugg 8y agoHaven't really been paying any attention to elm, all I can say now is that I never will.
- MBCook 8y agoI have, I thought it’s philosophy was pretty neat and I love the idea of being able to use something like Haskell in JavaScript land. I’ve seen complaints about how slow it moves and the fact that there is effectively one developer has certainly worried me. I never made a serious try to get it into production. It’s now very clear to me there’s no point in EVER trying unless there’s a massive shift in the project. The community/leadership sounds very broken. This seems more like what I would expect from someone’s hobby project that got out of hand and accidentally got a bunch of people who follow along no questions asked.
- lallysingh 8y agoReflex-FRP is finally getting documented and usable. I looked at ELM and decided that I could wait for reflex.
- vmchale 8y ago> This seems more like what I would expect from someone’s hobby project that got out of hand and accidentally got a bunch of people who follow along no questions asked. It does, but then you realize he actually advocates using it in production and tries aggressively to grow the community. See e.g. http://elm-lang.org/blog/how-to-use-elm-at-work http://elm-lang.org/blog/how-to-use-elm-at-work
- always_good 8y agoEh, I wouldn't exactly be a martyr for these deleted comments. dulac91 has been "leaving Elm" starting at least six months ago, supposedly only still around to let others know of his decision. superdisk and type_level_memes are piling on about how much Elm sucks in multiple comment threads, random examples being "Elm's BDFL is just a DFL" and "Elm is not the language for [me]. Or... anyone, apparently, since writing Elm code can be considered a liability at this point", respectively. This sort of dismissive toxicity just begets more of it and turns off newcomers. Sometimes you have to make your point and then leave the theater so others can enjoy the show.
- vmchale 8y ago> Elm's BDFL is just a DFL Which is true. > This sort of dismissive toxicity just begets more of it and turns off newcomers. Ah yes, legitimate criticism of Elm turns off newcomers so it's entirely justified to ban legitimate criticism. Wonderful.
- always_good 8y agoNothing quite like the self-aggrandizement of confusing your hot air of entitlement with "legit criticism."
- kbumsik 8y agoI’m very surprised. The moderators’ move is a way extreme to me. Unless they are personal attacks, deleting comments can never be good for the community. I cannot see any good reasons deleting those comments.
- vmchale 8y agoDon't be! This is how Elm works: with Evan as a petty dictator micromanaging every aspect of the discussion imaginable and in fact banning people from posts in other forums.
- evanrelf 8y agoLooks like they locked the thread and removed it from the homepage. I understand they are set in their ways and aren't interested in changing the language in ways some people want, but removing any and all posts that criticize them feels more like censorship than anything.
- salimmadjd 8y agoA few months ago on r/elm I made a post about how Evan was killing the momentum of Elm by not communicating about Elm's timeline more clearly. I was told, I was lucky not be be banned from the r/elm. A month or so later someone else posted on r/elm referencing my prior post. So I replied back and said I was the OP and that I agreed with his view and how nothing has changed. That reply go me banned from /r/elm. The elm forum has a very strict rules, almost dictatorial [1], Posters who demonstrate a Pattern of participation in Conflict may be banned from any Elm Forum....A Pattern may also arise within a single conversation. [1] https://github.com/elm/forum-rules https://github.com/elm/forum-rules
- star-techate 8y agoEvan probably talks about you in the first minute of https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uGlzRt-FYto https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uGlzRt-FYto
- lugg 8y agoOh my lord. Those Forum rules are hilarious. Like its written by a cute 5 year that thinks they're being clever and nobody will know what they mean is that they will block, delete, and ban anyone ever voicing critical thoughts. Like how do they ever think that language will improve? Either say nice things or I ban you. There is no appeals process.
- geofft 8y agoIt is interesting that the message locking the post seems to portray engaging with people with opposing views about design decisions as taking time away from working on Elm, instead of being itself a form of working on Elm! Maybe Elm needs some sort of "Please do not use this language in production" sign, and no "Community" link at the top of the home page. There's nothing wrong with a group of folks making a language for themselves / their employers, perhaps putting it on GitHub because why not, but not having a home page at all and making it clear that this isn't a stable language for others to use and they will put much more emphasis on the feedback from their own experiences than from others'. There's definitely nothing wrong with them doing that until they get to a 1.0 they're happy with, and then releasing it to the community.
- krainboltgreene 8y ago> Maybe Elm needs some sort of "Please do not use this language in production" sign That's the point of 0.X.Y supposedly.
- MBCook 8y agoI think the problem there is that far too many projects live in that world for years and years and years despite being obviously used in production. At this point if a project has been around for a long time and has version numbers like that I just assume it’s not real semantic versioning.
- geofft 8y agoI looked at http://elm-lang.org/ http://elm-lang.org/ and the "Install" link (to make sure there was no comment about not using it in production). There is no mention of the version number anywhere. There are, however, testimonials from (what sound like) real companies using it in production.
- lallysingh 8y agoAnd that counts a lot more than any version number - advertising it for production.
- protomikron 8y agoActually many deleted comments are indeed uncalled for or criticize the creator in a personal way, so I don't have a problem with removing them. Furthermore the discussion about type-classes is getting old. YES Haskell has them and NO Elm doesn't have them at the moment or maybe never. It's similar to the Go generic-type flame-wars that emerged in many Go discussions.
- senorsmile 8y agoI posted that article yesterday. I decided to do elmconf before strange loop this year, and so I'm learning Elm before the end of September. I have to admit that I was thoroughly confused at the locking and removal of the thread. It also means I didn't even have the chance to respond that I don't necessarily agree or disagree... I'm a new part of the community. I'm still going to continue learning and implementing a few small projects that I have planned. However, I'm a little worried that I'm going to be burnt by some in this community calling real needed debate a diatribe and silencing people that don't agree with them.
- btown 8y ago> The (apparent) view that the people who spend the most time working on Elm are not people, but unfeeling robots who exist to create and distribute free software in their free time, and then to take unlimited amounts of verbal abuse on their own forum. If they respond to this verbal abuse by exercising moderator powers like banning, that makes them tyrants. > The core team has spent countless hours discussing these topics again and again. People get exhausted explaining and re-explaining themselves until they are blue in the face. Honestly, posts like this are what makes contributors want to quit This is a disappointing mindset for them to have. If people have questions about design decisions, and express dismay about the real-world effects those design decisions have on them as production users of the software, then it's an opportunity to convert those passionate users into engaged contributors to the core, rather than considering them as abusive adversaries. If you are explaining things until you are blue in the face, that's a bug in your documentation - and sure, bugs are frustrating, but it's the sign of an effective developer to not let them cause emotional distress. (And while the original post was direct in its depiction of the BDFL, it was far from toxic in its wording, and not meant to be an ad hominem attack.) Instead, the thread is locked, the poster is confused, there's even a slimmer chance of the blogger reintegrating into the community to stave off these types of issues in future releases, and the language is worse off for all of that.
- vmchale 8y agoNot to mention, it's not actually verbal abuse that they ban. The Elm forum rules are totally batshit: https://github.com/elm/forum-rules https://github.com/elm/forum-rules
- Lazare 8y agoMy working opinion of Elm is that it's a very promising language hamstrung by poor governance and crippled by a shockingly toxic community. ...and that Reddit threat certainly doesn't give me any reason to change my mind on any of those points. :) Edit: I should note, I sympathise with the situation the Elm project is in. The extremely limited resources they have for development mean they have to make some compromises, and I'm not sure they've even made the wrong ones, given their goal. If they waited until a 1.0 version before trying to get adoption the project would lose relevance, so they have to get people to use an unstable beta in production. If they didn't make breaking changes to enforce a vision on the project, you'd end up with a ugly soup like PHP. If they devoted significant time to dealing with the community, they might not get anything done. Golang has charted a similar course but has had way more resources (and still has made a number of people angry); Rust has kept people happier, but in exchange for a much more community-driven vision, and not without cost in terms of false starts and dropped features. Developing a new language as anything more than an exercise is very hard!