19 ms·
Skim reading is the new normal. The effect on society is profound
- jorbrad 8y agoThis was a mental test not to tl;dr
- visarga 8y agoI skimmed anyway.
- Treegarden 8y agoI think this is good. Reading and really understanding a text is not cognitively easy. It should be a privilege for a text to be read by me. I am a productive and I work a lot with my head. I in my free time I listen to a lot of Audiobooks (fiction and factual) and I view that as the best vessel for taking in information in a causal way. If I really need to study something then I read it. But how dare you to think your text is important enough that I study it - especially in the age of click-bait and low quality journalism. If it is an extremely good text then I will recognize it as such by myself and study it.
- benrbray 8y agoWell said. News articles/editorials/blogs are especially bloated these days. It often not worth spending the mental effort when not a lot of mental effort was put into the writing.
- zasz 8y agoI agree there's a lot of crap out there, but the point of the article is that even for text that is worth the effort, your ability to supply said effort will have been diminished by a lifetime habit of skim-reading. The ability to read deeply has to be exercised constantly. It cannot be turned on and off. The other thing is, will you still be able to recognize every text that is worth your time? These seem like worthy points to me.
- ethbro 8y agoIt's a good point. Trying to reread some classic texts that I missed in a STEM curriculum, I've definitely noticed my attention is not what it used to be. But, like anything: exercise creates ability. And so I try to keep plowing my way through.
- AmericanChopper 8y agoI chronically skim read articles and emails, because people are generally very bad at writing those things. They will usually contain a lot more information that I don’t care about than information that I do care about. But I also read about 1 book a week, and I don’t struggle to devote my full attention to them. I don’t think switching between skimming and comprehensive reading is the problem, I think it’s that if you never do comprehensive reading that you’ll struggle to get back into it.
- zasz 8y agoYeah, and that's the other problem this article is pointing at--young children aren't developing deep reading skills like you have, because the girls are getting waylaid by social media and the boys by video games. They won't have the option of skimming the bad shit and deep reading the good stuff.
- andrepd 8y agoDid you read the article? Your response has nothing to do with any of the points raised in the article. Besides, how presumptuous is it to proclaim "how dare you to think your text is important enough that I study it"?
- criddell 8y agoMaybe he skimmed it.
- scarejunba 8y ago> Besides, how presumptuous is it to proclaim "how dare you to think your text is important enough that I study it"? Not at all. I'm 30. I'm going to live to be 80 at best. I've only fifty years left. Fifty years of fifty weeks each. 2500 weeks of 7 days each. If I spend two hours reading every day, that's 35000 hours left. That's 70000 half-hour works. Is this work in the top 70k that Man has ever written? That's the standard. I only have one life. And to me it is everything. What I read needs to be at the 99.999th percentile. Life's too short for anything else.
- fjsolwmv 8y agoAnd yet you are chitchatting on HN instead of reading one of those top works.
- scarejunba 8y agoBecause those need attention. If I'm waiting for my Lyft to take me to my book club meeting, like I am right now, I only have three minutes. I can't use that to make any progress on Conjectures and Refutations. So these things have poor cost structure for what they provide. I like The Economist on my morning fifteen min BART for instance. And that's because that's dense. But if I have half an hour, that's enough for me to read something worthwhile instead of this stuff.
- andrepd 8y agoAgain, that's not the point. That tirade has nothing to do with the article, it's just something you wanted to say.
- wruza 8y agoSkimming through bs was normal in pre-screen era, iirc, it is amount of texts that increased. We simply have no time to dive into yet another attention seeking writer’s subjective today. Otoh, there are still texts that slow you down since ‘objective meaning’ per line ratio is damn high. The pace of reading naturally correlates with the quality of text as a medium of conceptions. If you’re short of interests, then skimming everything is not a primary problem. If you develop a protection against drowning in bs, it’s actually good, since it is not going anywhere.
- mar77i 8y agoGo back a century, and your "objective meaning" per line ratio goes down a significant bunch. Language has never be this condensed, and the number of words to convey an idea never this small. One of the problems in this, though, might be one of the ever-increasing over-simplification, over-abstraction and superficial impositions of meaning, where certain phrasings make a thing true just because this is the way young people would express it™... It's complicated.
- ghaff 8y agoI'm fairly involved with creating or having created various materials for people who might be interested in buying our products. Even in the past 10 years or so, we've shifted to shorter pieces, survey results presented in the form of slides rather than words, short videos, etc. It's definitely more about things you can share on social media that people will glance through for a minute or two rather than carefully read on a plane.
- Bjartr 8y agoIs your market larger than it was 10 years ago?
- ghaff 8y agoYes, but I'm not sure I see a direct correlation. Materials created 10 years ago were presumably appropriate for the marketing at the time. I think a lot of what companies create today would be viewed as too short and fluffy if you go back in time. (And doubtless for some audiences today, they are.) Styles and preferences change. Look at the information density of ads as you go back in time.
- nickthemagicman 8y agoSkimmed this article. Looked pretty decent.
- finnthehuman 8y agoLife is short and there is very little written word that deserves the amount of your time that the author wants to take. Don't let them guilt you into it.
- anthony_franco 8y agoThe point is that you’ll be unable to deeply read even the “very little” that’s worth your time. Because we never practice it.
- trukterious 8y agoSure we do. Most reading is really a form of search and then we re-read the stuff that seems important. (At least I do.) If one cannot enjoy reading a book over and over again, there is no use in reading it at all. ― Oscar Wilde
- wimgz 8y agoAlso writing a concise, captivating text is a skill few master
- kylec 8y agoI skim articles that are unnecessarily verbose, like this one
- elpakal 8y agoyou beat me to this...
- deviationblue 8y agoDefine unnecessarily
- 8bitsrule 8y agoThorstein Veblen vs. E. B. White.
- dingaling 8y agoAnything you wouldn't read-out loud if you were presenting the article verbally to an audience. My wife occasionally reasds BBC news stories to me and it's remarkable how much 'blah blah hang on a moment til I find the story' even those contain.
- zzzcpan 8y agoAs far as I remember eye tracking usability studies skimming was always the norm on the web. Since people have to process a lot of information to get anything done. And deep reading was always special kind of activity for rare things.
- danielalmeida 8y agoI think the main point made by the author is that we should _be able to_ read properly and consciously make the decision to do so for some texts. I don't think anyone would argue that we should carefully read every single shallow, poorly written blog post out there. "We need to cultivate a new kind of brain: a “bi-literate” reading brain capable of the deepest forms of thought in either digital or traditional mediums. A great deal hangs on it: the ability of citizens in a vibrant democracy to try on other perspectives and discern truth; the capacity of our children and grandchildren to appreciate and create beauty; and the ability in ourselves to go beyond our present glut of information to reach the knowledge and wisdom necessary to sustain a good society."
- spicymaki 8y agoThe reality is long-form articles are probably not the future of conveying complex ideas to a mass audience. Skimming is the only way to sift through the insane amount of content produced daily. Of course, if you skim an article and find it interesting, switching over to slow comprehensive reading is the next step.
- aijoe 8y agoYes I think modern mediums provide better ways than long text for exploring deeply complex ideas.
- emodendroket 8y agoSuch as?
- emodendroket 8y agoAs the article suggests, this behavior, taken to a pathological extreme, leads to a sort of sloppy thinking where readers are simply unable to engage with or evaluate complex ideas, even when necessary. But you might have missed that if you didn't read it too closely.
- ksec 8y agoI think one of the problem is we try to know too many things but nothing well enough. We have access to infinite amount of "snippet" information. We want an "answer", now, and not the reason of how and why we arrived at those answer in the first place. Lots of people searching for just an "answers" and not thinking, and we end up in a world where we have far easier access of information than any other period in human history and our time to think and learn has been taken up by social media and other easy access entertainment. Another problem of long reading is the quality of writing has degraded over the years. Or may be we have far too many information so the average or median quality are lowered. The last great pieces of long Tech article i enjoyed were written by Anand lal shimpi, founder of Anandtech, but he left the site and went to work for Apple.
- cocacola1 8y agoI don't think it's the quality of writing that has degraded, but rather the democratization of writing. Now everyone can write and make their thoughts known and it's not unreasonable to conclude that much of it will be chaff. I don't think there's anything wrong with that, but it does place a heavier burden on the reader to be more critical of the avenues through which they consume information & content. Curation is, I've found, a difficult process.
- jurassic 8y agoI’ve been reading a lot more poetry lately. One thing I like about it is that it directs focus very intensely but the works are small. You only need to bring one page worth of focus at a time.
- Mediterraneo10 8y agoPoetry can be longform, too. A single poem can range over several pages or even extend to book length.
- nkcmr 8y agoDid anyone else click through to the article and think: “okay, try not to skim the article about how bad skim-reading is!”? I really like this article. It is aligning with very formless thoughts I have been having over the past year about the varying qualities of information and how it can affect your minds health. Much like a food diet, I have been thinking that it is wise to cultivate a healthy “information diet” in order to preserve good mental health. Amid frustration with my degrading attention span last year, I swore off a lot of the social media things (Twitter, most of all) to see if I could regain the ability to actually get through some books. The results were quite astonishing in my case, I was able to crack through a few books and actually focus on side projects. Unfortunately, I am not as optimistic as the writer here that we will be able to pull out of it. Much like modern society battles overweightness, diabetes and all kinds of ailments that stem from poor diet, I think we will suffer a similar fate when it comes to moderating our information intake.
- LrnByTeach 8y agoI repeat with my kids about this very concept like a broken record hundred times. 'Mental obesity' is as real as 'physical obesity' > Much like modern society battles overweightness, diabetes and all kinds of ailments that stem from poor diet, I think we will suffer a similar fate when it comes to moderating our information intake.
- zzzcpan 8y agoWhy do you think your attention span is degrading? Think about it this way: if you are able to concentrate enough to watch a movie, there is nothing wrong with you and nothing is stopping you from deep reading, but maybe just too boring and uncompetitive text (uncompetitive with other content and other forms of content).
- RachelF 8y agoWhen you dumb things down, and shorten them you reach a larger audience. Another factor to consider is that journalism is no longer attracting the quality of authors it used to, and that clickbait is the easiest way for online newspapers to make money.
- gurumeditations 8y agoI’ve found that much high-brow literature (such as that found in The Atlantic which I like to read a lot) enjoys taking multiple sentences and paragraphs to explain an idea that only needs 10% of the words that are actually used. AKA fluff to give the appearance of intellectualism. It’s why I skim.
- tw1010 8y agoOn the other hand, that's probably a good sign you should select your inputs more carefully. Try reading some time tested classics or a bunch of books that you know have a great signal-to-noise ratio. You'll probably find your noise ignorer starved soon enough.
- robax 8y agoThis comment hits the nail on the head for me. I’m mostly a non-fiction reader and so many authors dance around their point or reiterate it over and over. Robert Greene is the first offender to come to mind for me but I’m also reading Sapiens and feel the same there. If anyone has any low-fluff book recommendations I’d love to hear them!
- josephjrobison 8y agoRepetition of the core concepts from multiple different angles is a great way to reiterate the lessons over and over. I also don’t like when they beat around the bush, but repetition increases retention.
- mirimir 8y agoThe classic form is 1) summarize what you're going to say; 2) say it; and 3) summarize and discuss what you've said. But this piece repeats the same arguments, in different words, just a few paragraphs apart. And that annoys me. But maybe it's written for people who just skim. Also, when reading nonfiction, I typically read the beginning and the end, and then skim the rest. If it seems worth the time, then I read the whole thing.
- tw1010 8y agoEveryone that writes on the internet seems to assume everyone in their audience spends too much time on the internet. I know plenty of people totally outside this weird circle jerking ADD-ish skimming internet addict sphere who manage life just fine and has zero problem reading texts deeply without skimming. Just don't get stuck with the idea you also have to have bad habits just because everyone else has them (or that it's thus ok to have them).
- k__ 8y agoI do it because otherwise I'm a really slow reader. Somehow I have to read every word on its own.
- madrox 8y agoMy hypothesis is that the measurable difference between skim reading and deep reading is small if even statistically significant. The difference between reading at all vs not reading is large. If I have to be ready for deep reading before I read anything, then I'll never read anything.
- Theodores 8y agoA related skill on the wane is listening. A barometer of this in the UK is Radio 4 - the BBC's 'speech only' service. Nowadays there are plenty of listeners but they are stuck in their cars on some silly commute and needing to pass the time as they shuffle through fumes, therefore this new audience is only getting the government's version of 'news', not the full Radio 4 experience. This audience doesn't tend to tune in to Radio 4 at other times to listen to stories, documentaries, 'Woman's Hour' and the other delights of Radio 4, when back at the ranch there is TV and the world of digital delights for ambient entertainment. You can do stuff whilst listening to Radio 4 style speech radio (not to be confused with 'talk radio'), however I don't think many people do that these days or have the skills to patiently do so. I wonder how low the critical mass of listeners has to get before 'Radio 4' loses relevance and is no longer something that can be discussed in 'the shires'.
- kwhitefoot 8y agoBut there is perhaps a growing number of people who listen to podcasts instead. I listen to podcasts in my car either via the car's own system (Tesla S) or using my mobile via Bluetooth.
- nebulous1 8y agoI question the article's use of the word digital which covers both e-ink and LCD devices. The Mangen study it mentions was e-ink vs paper, but it was only 50 people and her own later work appears to call it into question. In the other studies mentioned it's not clear from the article if they were LCD or e-ink, and I suspect they were LCD. The "technology of recurrence" is interesting. I do use e-ink and I'm considerably less likely to go back a few pages to check something out than if I was reading a paper book.
- emodendroket 8y agoThe Kindle makes flipping back and forth tough and I won't use it for reference works for this reason.
- mindcrime 8y agoMaybe it's just because I read a lot of books and have been doing so for many years (I'm 45, so I've been reading a long time), but I don't feel like I've lost the ability to focus on reading. I still frequently pick up an interesting novel and read it in one or two sittings. A new novel by one of my favorite authors (say, Daniel Silva or David Baldacci) I'm quite likely to sit down and read in one single 8 hour session. OTOH, what I do absolutely struggle with is watching video content. I think it's largely to do with the fact that I consume most of my video content on my laptop, so the lure of another browser tab (with, say, Hacker News or Reddit) is always there. I'll start watching a ~30 minute episode of "The IT Crowd" and it'll take me 90 minutes to watch it because I'm obsessively hitting "pause" every couple of minutes to check my email, check HN, etc. :-(
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y agoThe article claims: > English literature scholar and teacher Mark Edmundson describes how many college students actively avoid the classic literature of the 19th and 20th centuries because they no longer have the patience to read longer, denser, more difficult texts. Nothing new here, surely? I'd hazard a guess a huge majority of people, throughout eternity, will never read 19th and 20th century literature, myself included. Unless we come up with some way of uploading books directly to our conscious awareness or whatever. Project Gutenberg was founded in 1971, and as of June 23rd 2018 contains over 57,000 books. If we ignore for a minute all of the online book stores where one can go to buy books, and how well some of those stores are doing, then Project Gutenberg alone has probably done more for reading than we may have lost due to swipe-and-skim reading. How many of us have bought and pirated more eBooks than we've read paper books. I work with tradesmen. I've asked so many of them "read any good books lately?" and they typically reply with something like "books? fuck off, I'm not gay". Seriously. But even the majority of these people, especially those under about 35 years old, are, in their spare time, reading constantly. Okay, so they're skim reading non-sense on Pinstabookwittertube, or whatever the kids are into this five-minute-period. I can't keep up, must be getting old, get off my lawn, etc. etc. I'd say that's still a huge improvement over the nothing similar cohorts were reading a decade a go. I'm still convinced some of the older guys can barely read well enough to get through their every day lives. And, generally speaking, I'm skeptical of most 'The Sky Is Falling: Younger People Are Worse at X (And Y and Z and A and B ...' positions, for all the obvious reasons.
- RachelF 8y agoYes, the kids have always been delinquent: “Young people are so pampered nowadays that they have forgotten that there was such a thing as Rhetoric" Aristotle, 4th Century BC
- wallflower 8y agoI've been studying Spanish to a medium-to-high intermediate level, and I find skimming something in Spanish to be very difficult. This is probably because my reading speed can average 1/10th of it would be in English (depending on the difficulty). I think we take for granted the ability to skim an article in our native language. When we skim, our brain is probably taking advantage of so many fast "pattern recognizers" and models to make sense of the whole, sampled in parts. Perhaps skimming effectively like "being able to go to a comedy show in that language and actually laugh" is a true test of language proficiency. My Spanish teacher who is pretty competent with English agrees that skimming is something that she cannot just do either.
- pergadad 8y agoEnglish is not my mother tongue, but I can skim it easily, maybe not easily than my native German. A lot might also be about writing style: English has developed a very anecdote/story- heavy style. Try to find an article by an author with English as mother tongue - they breast universally use this approach. E.g. article about tax law starts with one story, article about politics goes in depth on some specific scene or encounter, etc etc. There is often much mention of 'unimportant' detail that fill the mental picture, and English language media often repeat and stretch out information (rather than strive for information density). In comparison of DE-EN-FR I even find this in more in-depth documents like textbooks, not universally but much more than in the other languages. Of course fluency plays a major role. But i can skim a french-language fluff piece or story or recounting of an event, even if that's not exactly a strong language for me. At the same time I can't skim an in-depth description of this or that political conflict or technical report in EN or DE if I want to understand the course of events or details. So it's at least to some degree (at least for me) a matter of the writing style - stories read easily, and non- English media is much less story-heavy. For an English native you might be able to compare yourself skimming an Economist article or something academic vs e.g. guardian or independent and see if it feels different. In a twist, I find it sometimes harder to read a FR language fluff piece closely/carefully - they tend to use words that are more slang/informal and which i won't know as well how to interpret them in the context. But getting the gist of easy. This might be particular to foreign language reading though.
- didibus 8y agoThere's skim reading and there's selective reading. I tend to read only what I need to move forward either in thought or on a project. I learn faster this way. And I can do this now because of the power of search.
- Marazan 8y agoTL;DR
- jarfil 8y agoRight? I thought that was the new normal.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- chubot 8y agoIt's a fine line to draw... On the one hand, I feel like I have some form of "new information addiction". Even my dad, who is 70, has pretty aggressive surfing habits. On the other hand, I skimmed books back in the 90's, before I surfed the web daily. (There was much less "new" high quality information online then.) I would check out 5 books at a time from the library, and read the best one, and skim the rest. I also studied for my AP History test in exactly one day by skimming, and got a great score. IIRC, I read the first and last sentence of every chapter in a 200 page book in one night. It's not a bad way to read if you're looking for the high level structure of stories and arguments. Many authors are in love with their own prose, and it is too long. My blog looks dense but I've gotten good feedback on it, mostly because I use skimmable headings, and delete words from sentences, so it's short and dense: http://www.oilshell.org/blog/ http://www.oilshell.org/blog/
- mbell 8y agoI don't buy that this has anything to do with the rise of the 'digital world'. The unfortunate reality is that adult literacy statistics are scary. A huge number of adults just aren't capable of understanding more than the most basic writing. See NAAL (https://nces.ed.gov/naal/ https://nces.ed.gov/naal/) and PIAAC (https://nces.ed.gov/surveys/piaac/ https://nces.ed.gov/surveys/piaac/) data.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- 0xcde4c3db 8y agoI'd be quite surprised if the problem were actually screen use rather than the cognitive and emotional effects of feed-based content delivery that optimizes for so-called engagement. By that term, web-oriented people usually mean staying on the site/platform, not necessarily engaging with the actual content or fellow users. Whether it's an endless-scrolling social media feed or auto-play on YouTube, we're up to our eyeballs in companies that are doing their damnedest to keep us in continual anticipation of the next blob of content coming down the pipe rather than looking away. To the extent that a difference is observed with screens, I suspect it's not some intrinsic inferiority in screens as a medium, but rather a behavioral link between being in that context and the activation of feed-conditioned habits. Television has had a larval form of this pattern for decades, but with television there were at least times when the spell was broken because "nothing's on". Nobody could analyze all your habits and interests on an individual level and create your perfect "channel" that's on the air all day, every day. That's what we're moving toward now, and it's becoming more apparent with time that even being a few steps down that road doesn't seem entirely healthy. I don't have a fistful of neuroscience studies to cite, let alone a solution, but I have a bad feeling that this is going to get worse before it gets better.
- quickthrower2 8y agoI skim articles alot that are posted from HN because I need to evaluate if the article is worth reading. What would stop me skimming is to a straight to the point article. I dislike a wafflely story that is of no interest at the beginning and I can't be bothered to read it. For example I could prefix this comment when "Back when I was a boy I stacked straw on the farm, ...", and that would be similar.
- bodas 8y agoIt's worth noting that programming requires a kind of extreme reading comprehension so the premise of this article probably doesn't apply to programmers (or scientists, writers, lawyers, etc).
- namibj 8y agoThe best books I read were written by scientists, people who think they are scientists (sociology, and mostly due to failing rigorous approaches), and books written for teens (I no longer read fiction). All have in common that the reader has an aversion to fluff, by way of not finishing it/not buying another book by the same author. These also don't really work for making you feel intelligent among your friends, who will likely not understand much of it anyway. Some of the papers I read recently, like the "Instant field meshes" one, also exhibit this careful balance of concept density without going to the point where you need Kant-level mentality to comprehend the conveyed concept (referring specifically to Kritik der reinen Vernunft).
- amelius 8y agoIf only we could "skim-watch" videos ...
- emodendroket 8y agoThis is one reason I find videos for purely informational content are often frustrating. It'd often be so much faster to just read text.
- dredmorbius 8y agoYoutube-dl, then play at your desired speed in mpv, xine, mplayer, or VLC. Keyboard control to skip forward and back. There's mps-youtube for audio-only playback (it also supports video). Even with this, shitty production -- say, couple of jokers' completely unedited stream-of-blather 2 hour vlog that only got remotely near the point by 20 min in, but failed to hold together through the 30m maark, where I bailed (skipping through, aggressively) -- is intolerable. Mind: there is very well-produced material. Lectures, audiobooks, documentaries, etc. But like any large complex work, it takes skill, preparation, a goal in mind, and time.
- nottorp 8y agoWhy would I jump through all these hoops when I can just find a text based article on the subject?
- dredmorbius 8y agoIt depends, of course, on what you are interested in. I find that the presentation of a true expert or master beats, or at the very least complements, text. There are also times listening is more conducive than reading. A Feynman, or academic lecturer, or a truly goog author discussing their work, generally. Mind: typical news or opinion pieces rarely reach this level.
- moreati 8y agoVideo speed browser extensions make it less bad. I use https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/videospeed/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/videospeed/ and https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/video-speed-controller/nffaoalbilbmmfgbnbgppjihopabppdk https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/video-speed-contro...
- vinceguidry 8y agoSkim reading is definitely a art and skill. At the highest levels of that skill, you're basically trusting your subconscious to alert your thinking mind that a phrase or passage is worth putting in that extra few seconds. It's also something I automatically do just to get a sense for the piece of writing once, whether or not I choose to read it deeper. It makes deep reading that much easier. The way out of the problems caused by skimming is to skim more. I skimmed the whole Atlantic piece to digest the point, then decided it wasn't worth a deeper examination. My own experience with the concept is probably way way better than the author's. And the stated thesis of the article just isn't important to me. Writing a lot helps with reading. Spending lots and lots of time putting together arguments and points sets yourself up to recognize common patterns extremely quickly in recently-written prose. When dealing with older prose, or poetry, especially something like the Bible, my mind slows way way way way down to an almost glacial pace, the subconscious just isn't primed to understand the writing as the culture in which it was written is long long gone.
- itronitron 8y agoI think this just reflect that a lot of the writing available on the internet is just really bad now, it's not like readers are in a rush to get to the clickbait articles at the bottom of the page. I can't recall the last time I read an article that did not have a significant grammatical error in it. This sentence contain two as for example. If an article doesn't immediately support the article's headline then people are going to skim until they find information supporting or refuting the headline.
- ggm 8y agoSkim reader since 1968 grew up in a house of books. Can somebody give me the tl;dr? I've got about three on the go right now, too busy to skim /s
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jgamman 8y agothe new new normal is to check the HN comments first...
- bbcbasic 8y agoWell skim them of course
- calebm 8y agoTL;DR anyone? ;)
- inamberclad 8y agoIt really feels like I need to skim read at times. I'm in engineering school, and the textbooks don't have very much depth, but god help you if you try and understand it all instead of jumping ahead to find the information you desperately need for your homework.
- jl2718 8y agoI did the same. After grad I was marooned so I read them end-to-end. Bag of tricks becomes coherent incremental subject.
- Aardappel 8y agoThe problem with most texts is that they're linear and structure-less, which means it is hard to efficiently extract information from. I should be able to decide exactly how much of a text I want to read, depending on how interested I am. If text would be hierarchical, with top level items being summaries, and each successive (indented) level going into more detail, I could tailor the reading of the text to my needs, interest level, and prior knowledge of the subject. Why do we not write like this?
- asah 8y agoI have some ideas/prototypes around this, drop me a note if curious (not ready for show HN). adam dot sah at gm
- emodendroket 8y agohttps://www.nngroup.com/articles/f-shaped-pattern-reading-web-content/ https://www.nngroup.com/articles/f-shaped-pattern-reading-we... Jakob Nielsen was making this observation ages ago with regard to Web pages. I think it's a bit of a mistake to lump reading books on a Kindle in with checking e-mails on an iPad (at least assuming we mean the e-ink version); the former is much less task-oriented than the latter and I find I'm actually reading many more long and challenging books on the Kindle than I used to. Though of course I can't really explain why the students in the study mentioned had so much worse results.
- purplejacket 8y agoI can do better than skim reading. I just save to Pocket.
- Phantasmagoria 8y agoWriters should take after leaked government cables. Those things are really no BS.
- jl2718 8y agoI blame writing classes in high school. Expositions are useless. Get to the point.
- tluyben2 8y agoSometimes the phenomenon is annoying; like when you think you are having an interesting discussion on an Internet forum/social network and when you actually write something longer than 1 sentence which you are passionate about and thought about longer than 1 second, you notice that people only respond the start of the first line and end of the last line. Which makes everyone sound stupid including you who thought was actually having a good convo.
- HealthGoth 8y agoI think I agree with the main points, although I didn't read it very thoroughly
- hyperpallium 8y agoThe underlying problem is not readers, but writers. Writers being underpaid because of the present economics of text. Sorry to write such a long article, I didn't have time to write a short one. - Cicero, Pascal, Twain, etc.
- renjimen 8y agoI don't know if it's always laziness or time constraints which stop people from condensing their thoughts more. Fluffy articles remind me of when I wrote essays in school: I made them as long as possible because I thought longer = more important, even if the information density reduced as a result. Fluffy articles often remind me of that mindset, except there are no marks for effort on the internet, only originality.
- fjsolwmv 8y ago"present" with a citation to Cicero, ironic.
- pas 8y agoCare to elaborate for the ignorant masses?
- loco5niner 8y agoThey weren't connecting Cicero with present writing.
- mrmondo 8y agoI agree with @gurumeditations who made a comment about how much padding / fluff articles tend to have in them and that for the majority of online articles it's more of an annoyance than anything that adds to the content. Personally, I can't skim read - I've never been able to. I've always have to read word by word which can really affect my reading speed. This I've learnt over the years has had both positive and negatives as you might imagine. In school it was a big negative, if something didn't hold my interest - bugger it - I wasn't going to waste my time and would get in trouble, but if it was interesting to me I'd spend the time and generally understand the content very well. In later life I've found myself to rely on article summaries to decide if I need to read the full source or not. Reading a novel takes me a lot longer (say 2-4 weeks) than say my Grandfather who in his 90s smashes out 4-5 novels a week with great ease and while still leading a busy life, however he was saying to me that whenever he skim reads he knows he doesn't taken in as much information from the text and for him it's more about enjoyment of reading 'in the moment' rather than post-reading pondering of the book which I tend to do a lot more of. Personally I find reading books on an e-ink screen a _lot_ quicker than an LCD screen like my iPad Pro and a still a little quicker than reading a physical book probably down to page turns and object weight.
- adityapurwa 8y agoI don't know whether this is the effect of me having read a lot of documentation by skimming, now I skim almost everything that I read. I think most non-tech people that I met still reading normally.
- sigi45 8y agoPerhaps we as an internet generation just read too much? There are so many articles/topics repeating themselfs. It starts to happen @hacker news for me as well and that makes it boring. I don't need to read the 20.000th article about a specific topic in full. I only might wanna see if the author got something new, which is often just not the case. I didn't read that much text when we only used newspapers. I read the paper after lunch for half an hour or so. Thats it. No newspaper on sunday.
- ur-whale 8y ago"Skim reading is the new normal" says the 10k word article. "screen reading is the problem" says the internet article.
- mothsonasloth 8y agoAll the more for machine learning to crunch texts and provide a succinct summary for the reader.
- jaclaz 8y agoOnly seemingly unrelated: https://quoteinvestigator.com/2012/04/28/shorter-letter/ https://quoteinvestigator.com/2012/04/28/shorter-letter/ Blaise Pascal (and more people after him): "I have made this longer than usual because I have not had time to make it shorter."
- ilamont 8y agoMost journalists, authors, and college professors are still writing in the analog mindset, when most audiences are attuned to digital mediums AND are extremely time-constrained. Editors who have responsibility for major websites (and who have high double-digit mobile readerships) still hand out assignments like it's 1998 - "800 words on topic X" or "write me a 1500 word feature on Y." A few new media publishers understand that they need to retool content for the new generation of readers (think TMZ and early TechCrunch) but they are still the minority in the English-speaking world. Yes, it's sad that long-form reading and comprehension levels are in decline. But this is the evolution of media and communication at work, and people who publish need to adapt to new ways of communicating. Humanity has had shifts like this before (orality to the written word, hand-copied text to the printing press, the impact of broadcasting, etc.) and we'll still survive.
- late2part 8y agoThis is scary. I used to read 2-3 books per day in the summer as a kid. I used to read books on planes or at coffee houses. Now I skim iPhone or iPad. I need to start reading real books again!
- Timpy 8y agoI skimmed this article, and I skimmed the comments here too
- jameskegel 8y agoWe have so much information to take in, and it is so often something we already know, or a well worn trope being repeated that skimming becomes a survival trait. We cannot ingest this amount of input without disqualifying a few bits in the data stream.
- plaidfuji 8y agoThe only way I'm going to deeply read an entire article is if (a) it's relevant to my strongest interests, (b) it's concise, and (c) the author has credibility on the subject. Very seldom are all of these fulfilled, even in peer-reviewed academic literature. For example, I didn't read this article because "the effect on society is profound" implies that the author doesn't have a strong conslusion, meaning that it's uninteresting (a) and probably not concise (b). Alternatively, if the writer has a strong voice or unique style, I'll read the article just to appreciate that.
- FullyFunctional 8y agoIt's pretty ironic to have an article decry skim reading that itself is littered with distracting (and pointless) text extracts and useless photos, all designed to distract. It took me deliberate effort to resist the distractions.
- noetic_techy 8y agoAs other commenters here have alluded, if you read a lot, especially a lot of non-fiction, you start to realize that much of what is out there is mostly fluff hiding the true point the headline alludes. That's why you see the rise of apps like Blinkist, which summarizes whole books in 15 minutes. As an avid reader, I don't care for the backstory, I don't care for how you arrived where you are, and I don't really care for your musing or anecdotes or examples or any fluff you use to make an article an article. At some point, if you're intelligent enough, you feel like you've heard it all and just want to meat. The sad truth is that most articles can be summed up in one paragraph, or even bullet points. The points can even be highlighted from the fluff and those who don't care to read it. Skimming isn't some degradation of society, its society adapting to the information overflow. A good, well written book will have quality content that keeps you from skimming.
- Barrin92 8y ago> if you're intelligent enough, you feel like you've heard it all and just want to meat no, if you are intelligent then you value context, details, nuance and looking at the same point from varied angles. If you're intelligent you try to become deeply knowledgeable about one topic that you are passionate about rather than trying to memorize bullet points, which gets you nowhere. The unique feat of human intellect is deep excellence in individual domains, not being able to quickly absorb bullet points. Deeply intelligent individuals dive into topics to such a degree of detail that it would even bore the average 'deep reader' to death. The answer to information overflow is not to trade detail for bullet points. Key is to be able to discern what is relevant to you and what is not, and to focus deeply on the things that are. The fact that people tend towards skimming is a sign that they are not able to do this.
- noetic_techy 8y ago> The points can even be highlighted from the fluff and those who don't care to read it. The best of both worlds. You're correct, if I truly care for a topic, I will read the fluff. The vast majority of internet articles don't fall into this category. I disagree, the fact that they skim means they ARE able to do this.
- makecheck 8y agoApparently they equate “length” with “depth”, which can correlate but they don’t have to. You can always have both brilliant quotes and dumb tweets, and you can have both insightful tomes and rambling messes. The need to skim is more a comment on how quickly many things can now be accomplished. People are trained to think that anything should be quick these days. Unfortunately, it takes time to condense good material into bite-size chunks. It’s not hard to see, in a zero-time-to-publish society, how the “easy” and poorly-written bites win out over anything better. A person can spew out 100 dumb tweets in less time than it takes to compose one well-researched concept in a sufficiently short space to be consumed.
- axilmar 8y agoPersonally I skim read in order to evaluate the text. If it grabs my attention, then I read it carefully. I read works of art normally, without skimming.
- Lidador 8y agoI never read the first paragraph. Works every time.
- sytelus 8y agoIt was very hard for me not to skim this article but I forced myself to read every sentence and below is virtually all of its information content. Rest of the article just keeps repeating these same points over and over. - Reading ability required development of new brain circuits about 6000 years ago - This circuit adapts to new environment and mediums, currently digital media - Fast and multi-tasked reading has advantage for large volume information but comes at cost of ability for "deep reading" - College students now actively avoid the classic literature of the 19th and 20th centuries because of "cognitive impatience" - Anne Mangen did experiment to have 50% student read a story on kindle and 50% on print material. Later group showed superior comprehension, re-construction and retention - Many readers now use an F or Z pattern when reading in which they sample the first line and then word-spot through the rest of the text - Physicality of print material enables association with space and time allowing readers for re-examination aka “technology of recurrence” - Negative effects of screen reading can appear as early as fourth and fifth grade impacting comprehension and empathy
- thomzi12 8y agoContrarian opinion: repetitive writing is actually important in helping us remember what the article or book is talking about. Humans learn via repetition. If we took out the fluff, the article/book would be <50% as effective as it is with fluff and repetition.