34 ms·
Good. Ultimately, the invasiveness of this sort of search is not worth the slim chance that something of legal interest may be discovered. Criminals have free
by jrockway 8y ago
Good.
Ultimately, the invasiveness of this sort of search is not worth the slim chance that something of legal interest may be discovered. Criminals have free reign to "import" data via the Internet already, so they're just going to go that route most of the time. If you suspect someone of a crime, get a warrant, and then have your customs officer seize the device. But the "we're just checking to make sure you're not doing anything illegal" is antithetical to the freedoms the United States guarantees, and should not be tolerated at the border... at least when the stakes are this low.
I hope this case sees trial and the judge understands how to weigh the invasiveness against the possible benefits.
- berbec 8y agoThey'll try like hell to keep it out of court for just this reason. I imagine she'll end up getting a dumptruck full of money and a crazy NDA
- koolba 8y agoI doubt it. They’d likely win in court as the laws applicable at the border are not the same as the rights you have being stopped on the street. Now if the trial itself leads to public outcry to change those rules that’d be great but as it stands now I think she’d lose.
- kodablah 8y agoBut is it worth the risk of bubbling up to a court that wants to make a precedence-setting stance against, say, the practice of copying/storing the data when the feds will have little to gain if they win?
- chias 8y agoHey, they can search my phone for a dumptruck full of money any day. While not as ideal as burning in court, that wouldn't be a bad precedent to set either.
- qrbLPHiKpiux 8y agoOr not decrypt it and sit in prison until you do. Philadelphia cop
- komali2 8y agoAll they're going to find in my phone is pictures of my bare ass, which I normally pay people to look at, so consider me in the same boat. I always wish I would get an aggressive BP agent because a lot of my pics are in a prominent "nothing illegal" folder on the first "page" of my phone.
- URSpider94 8y agoIt doesn’t set any precedent, because it’s done out of the public record, without admitting any wrongdoing. That’s exactly WHY they settle these cases, so there’s no precedent.
- DannyBee 8y agoAbsolutely not. This is well settled law at this point, as much as it sucks. Unless SCOTUS changes it's mind (which would cost a lot to get to - 100k+). Without a supreme court ruling, she'll get nothing and spent a lot on fees. They are going to not give a crap about this and probably laughed and threw it in the trash can when they saw it. This case is basically an attempt to see if courts will reconsider after Riley v. California.
- ivl 8y agoI think this is the craziest thing. It's easy to just leave an encrypted copy of all your phone's data online, reset your phone to factory settings, travel, and then restore your data to your phone. Seizing it to search is just... invasive and ineffective.
- jjuhl 8y ago"It's easy to just leave an encrypted copy of all your phone's data online, reset your phone to factory settings, travel, and then restore your data to your phone" - Easy indeed, but having to do so shouldn't be needed.
- nothrabannosir 8y agoGP is talking about The Bad Guys. Point being: if you're a Bad Guy, you're gonna encrypt your data. It's easy, and obvious. The likelihood of catching any Bad Guys with this is, therefore, very slim. Far outweighed by the price paid by the Good Guys, who don't go through that rigmarole, and just get their privacy violated. That's the argument, in essence (which I mostly agree with, the childish tone notwithstanding).
- pmiller2 8y agoYou will catch some Bad Guys with this approach, but only the ones who are also dumb. That’s not an insignificant portion of them, but it means the smarter ones, who are more dangerous, might get away.
- ilikehurdles 8y agoyeah but this way some middle-manager bureaucrat type gets to pad their numbers and request 15% more budget next year. Catching 15 nobodies a month looks better than catching 1 actual big fish a year.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoNot to mention that if you're only catching dumb ones there's plenty of other ways to catch dumb ones without violating people's rights.
- briandear 8y agoNo self respecting terrorist is going to cross a border with a hot device. To think otherwise is to ignore the tech acumen of terror groups.
- komali2 8y agoTechnically can't CBP do literally anything they want due to the Patriot (snort) Act? I recall 100 mile "no constitution zones?" I hope this skyrockets to the supreme court and neuters the Patriot (teehee) Act.
- yusyusyus 8y agoThis did not require the PATRIOT act. The law that enables search in this way was written in 1930 and was mostly the same prior. Fundamentally, whether you agree or not, it has been a long-standing tradition that customs (anywhere you go) has the ability to inspect _everything_ that comes through. That is their job. We hear about it more in the USA, but it can and does happen elsewhere. Now, I believe that this is a bit outdated considering the nature of phones today, but it is what it is.
- javagram 8y agoIt goes back many decades before the Patriot act. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Martinez-Fuerte https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Martinez-Fu... (1976)
- mtw 8y ago> the freedoms the United States guarantees I might be wrong, but I thought you didn't have any rights or freedoms at the border?
- iamthirsty 8y agoCorrect. > According to the government, however, these basic constitutional principles do not apply fully at our borders. For example, at border crossings (also called "ports of entry"), federal authorities do not need a warrant or even suspicion of wrongdoing to justify conducting what courts have called a "routine search," such as searching luggage or a vehicle. https://www.aclu.org/other/constitution-100-mile-border-zone https://www.aclu.org/other/constitution-100-mile-border-zone
- testvox 8y agoCertain rights not being fully applicable != No rights
- iamthirsty 8y agoWell the thread is about search & seizure, so you pretty much have no rights in that respect anywhere near the border.
- rootw0rm 8y ago"anywhere near" ~ 60 miles the border patrol checkpoint where San Diego county ends and Riverside county begins is around 60 miles from the border
- pmiller2 8y agoLast I heard, and, according to the article linked up thread from the ACLU, it was 100 miles. Two thirds of Americans, and many entire state populations live within this zone.
- Karishmra1234 8y agoThe folly of finding reason in CBP's actions ! The organisations sees these sort of actions as one tool in the box to harass people they do not like. If this tool is taken away they will find a way in something else. It was never about defending the law.
- amelius 8y agoI'm not sure if your argument holds, because convenience is important to criminals too. Analogy: phone taps; criminals could easily use encryption over the phone to avoid eavesdropping, except it turns out that phone taps are still useful.
- whorleater 8y agoYou have to get a warrant for phone taps
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- amelius 8y agoTrue, but the point was about the convenience which criminals value over anti-eavesdropping methods.
- freeopinion 8y agoNot true. You probably need a warrant to be able to submit any evidence in a trial. But that warrant can be obtained after the tap. And if the warrant never happens, you still have the information acquired from the tap which can be used for parallel constructions, etc. Phone taps today happen without the cooperation or even the knowledge of the phone company. Every telco is required to have a continuous tap on all communications. That tap must be wired to the authorities and the telco must have no ability to detect when the tap is being monitored. That's the law in the U.S.
- majewsky 8y ago> criminals could easily use encryption over the phone to avoid eavesdropping They do. It's called a cant.
- r00fus 8y agoIt smacks of intimidation on the premise of "national security".
- DannyBee 8y agoIt will not see trial. There is well settled law here for better or for worse.
- onetimemanytime 8y agoFirst, I agree with you. Odds are that you can find a few bad apples but you have inconvenienced tens of million innocent people. Now the devil's advocate: Say a tourist returning from x country has that type of p--n that should set off all our alarms. Wouldn't all cloud providers scan the contents and alerted authorities if he posted them online? Maybe encrypting them first might do it but not all take their time to learn.