8 ms·
> Because Facebook forwards posts that are marked as false to third-party fact-checkers, she said it was important to build systems to assess whether the posts
by vorpalhex 8y ago
> Because Facebook forwards posts that are marked as false to third-party fact-checkers, she said it was important to build systems to assess whether the posts were likely to be false to make efficient use of fact-checkers’ time.
This seems like a "the road to hell is paved with good intentions" kind of thing. On one hand, I understand not wanting to forward every single story when a troll is mass-reporting, on the other hand though, this seems like a very 1984 approach that like all algorithms is horrendously naive.
Any closed group is likely to have a skewed sense of reality. On one hand, third party fact checkers are hopefully true to their title, but on the other hand, they could just be adding their own bias to the decisions with no oversight in a way that affects users going forward.
Add in no ability to appeal and no visibility into the system, and you have a closed system ripe for abuse.
Good job Facebook, you have learned nothing.
- reaperducer 8y agothird-party fact-checkers This is the part that stood out to me. It's allows Facebook to tell lawmakers and the public "Hey, look! We're taking things seriously!" Until something goes wrong. Then they can lay the blame on someone else and issue another non-apology apology saying, "We can do better."
- traek 8y agoWhat would a better solution look like, in your view? Is it the third-party aspect that you take issue with, or the fact-checking? Or the combination of the two?
- creaghpatr 8y agoIt gets even worse when you find out who the 'fact' 'checkers' are.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- a235 8y agoFB published a bit on selection of the fact checkers - those are independent journalist organisations. I'd say contrary - that would be so wrong for FB to verify facts in-house. This way they are more transparent
- mipmap04 8y agoWhat would be a viable alternative? I don't think they can just ignore the issue and, as you mention, can't review every single story. They'll have to rely on some form of sampling for the reviewers. Would it be better to just take a truly random sample of all reports? I don't think that would be very effective given the number of publications they have to review. Do you let users review the content for veracity? Seems like that just creates a situation where the group with the most participants pick the news. I'm not sure this is the optimal path, but to say that Facebook has learned nothing is disingenuous.
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago[deleted]
- traek 8y ago> Lakes turn into swamps which turn into forests given enough time. While this is literally true, it's not clear to me that it's a relevant metaphor for online communities.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoOn second thought I agree.
- cambalache 8y agoPerhaps, but do nothing is the only sane response. Mind you, I mean on a basic level. On top of that you can evaluate options, for example, "channels", if you are a democrat/liberal/SJW you can subscribe to channels of only approved sources if you dont want to read libertarian/russian/GOP ones. You can argue that this will promote an echo chamber, but lets be honest it is what happens already. So I dont want censorship on top of that.
- ravenstine 8y agoEmail. I wish we'd all go back to it.
- Tarq0n 8y agoDo you check your spam filter to see what it's been filtering still? Text classification has gotten very reliable over the last decade, the process just needs to be transparent. Valve also does something similar with their anti-cheat system called overwatch. A machine learning system selects which replays are most likely to result in a conviction, then those replays are shown to human peer-reviewers who must come to a consensus on whether the replay shows cheating or not. The pre-selection stage greatly increases the efficiency of the system.
- xienze 8y agoThere’s a difference between filtering for spam content and the much more complicated job of determining “truth”, especially given that what is “true” in political matters is highly subjective.
- nradov 8y agoYes I check my spam folder frequently. The Gmail spam filter has many false positives. In the real world text classification is still too inaccurate to rely upon for anything important.
- PopeDotNinja 8y agoAt a superficial level, it sounds like China's social credit system. [1] Hopefully booking a flight never requires one to log into Facebook. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_Credit_System https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_Credit_System
- matt4077 8y agoIt's just basic reputation, a mechanism humans have used to improve cooperation since before they had become homo sapiens. There's absolutely nothing nefarious about remembering previous interactions you had with someone. In fact it's impossible not to do so. The problem with China is how it tears down the natural separation between different spheres of your life, how all-encompassing their panopticum can become because it has access to any data source it desires, and that the issues it engages with all seem to be of the this-doesn't-concern-you-and-nobody-is-actually-harmed variety, such as peoples' porn consumption or eating habits.
- danielblazevski 8y agoGood intentions? I would even argue against that. I find it hard to believe facebook has good intentions with this. Remember, Mr. Zuckerberg is alleged to have called Mr. Trump the night of the election to congratulate him. Let’s stop pretending like the tech industry is full of good intentioned people making an “oops”
- NeonVice 8y agoWhat are you insinuating? Facebook as a whole leans left.
- danielblazevski 8y agoWanted to give an example showing that not everyone in tech is progressive and has good intentions. Anyone who goes out of their way to congratulate Trump is not someone who sympathizes with the population as whole, and find it impossible to believe Zuckerberg has good intentions in how he makes major business decisions because of this.
- furgooswft13 8y agoRidiculous. Bigwigs placing congratulatory phone calls to the President Elect after victory is traditional. Lots of people did it. He would have done the same for Hillary if she had won. And it's not going out of your way, it's 5 minutes of someone's time.
- debaserab2 8y ago...or he wants to position his company in a favorable way to the new administration just like every other large mega corporation in America. I don't read any intention other than that. He wasn't the only tech CEO to reach out to the administration shortly after the election.
- danielblazevski 8y agothat basically proves my original point that he is not well-intentioned.
- 1001101 8y ago> third party fact checkers Seems like infinite regress and turtles all the way down to me. Who fact checks the fact checkers?
- matt4077 8y agoyeah, this is the rather basic flaw in what lots of people, including on HN, are proposing: They seem to demand a sort of proof from first principle for journalism, where every reader can (and must!) verify an article without any heuristics such as a medium's track record ("Argument from Authority!", they will complain, "FALLACY!"). Yet such a system is simply impossible. In practice, because nobody would ever have the time & energy to verify any meaningful fraction of the information they consume. But even in theory, there just aren't any methods to distribute "proof": you could be an eyewitness, which doesn't scale. You could inspect original documents, which also doesn't scale, and where almost nobody has the expertise to actually verify them. Oh, and then there are distributed ledgers, which could help around the margins but nobody knows how (Bitcoin, incidentally, is the outgrow of exactly the same mechanism, only for the financial system: the breakdown of trust in institutions such as the law or the FED, and the attempt to replace it with technology). One of many incarnations of this dynamic the widespread criticism of the use of anonymous sources. And while the practice does have its problems, it's almost universally misunderstood by those criticising it today. When journalists use anonymous sources, they substitute their own reputation, and that of their publication, for the source's. Which is why, when you go back and read articles from a year or so ago, you'll find that each and every single anonymously reported fact has actually been proven correct, or remains unknown. The system works (worked), because everyone in it is playing the long game. But that would require trust. And people today aren't just distrustful. They completely deny the utility of the concept. They try to evaluate all information with complete disregard for the source (and fail). They assume equivalence between anonymous internet commentators and institutions such as universities, newspapers, or established politicians, without even noticing how this conflicts with their criticism of anonymity as described above. This mindset is related to a perversion of the scientific method, one that denies the usefulness of all emotion, of the social sciences, and of all human relationships. It's perverse because even its proponents entirely fail to live by it: if you're more willing to let your spouse borrow you car than just any stranger, you're using the very same mechanisms (familiarity, the game theory of long-term relationships, reputation) that you otherwise reject. So that's a long-winded way to say: these fact-checkers are supposedly different than whoever posted the material in question. You, and everyone else, can observe them over time, and they will have a reputation to defend. They will presumably also be recruited from the set of people and institutions that are established as trustworthy, at least among the minority that still believes in such a thing might actually exist.