14 ms·
Vietnam Going Solar After Nuclear Power Plants Shelved
- wjnc 8y agoThe EU and US massively restricting / taxing Chinese solar has its upsides. This might be quite the leapfrog and actually getting solar into countries with lots of sun is quite a meta-efficieny effect. I wonder though how a country like Vietnam can get it's grid in order to cope with a lot more natural energy.
- jlebrech 8y agohome grown solar panel manufacture?
- AhshahP9 8y agoI don't know about Vietnam, but at least in many parts of India people are used to the grid being unreliable anyway.
- realusername 8y agoI'm living in Saigon now, it works well, I have maybe one power-cut every two month.
- radicalbyte 8y agoWe (the west) should be strongly encouraging this in developing countries. We have the money, we have the instruments, all we need is the will. The US put men on the moon using 1960's technology and brought them back alive. Switching the world to 100% carbon neutral energy production should be more than achievable.
- ForHackernews 8y agoThere's no political or economic will. It won't happen.
- Brakenshire 8y agoIt all depends on economics, people will switch if the new technologies are cheaper, or if they face tariffs for not doing their part.
- sgift 8y agoIf the west tariffs developing countries there will be an outcry over neocolonialism and forcing the poor countries to our will and whatever. The only thing the west is allowed to do is putting money into developing countries without any guarantees and hope they do something useful with it. It's frustrating.
- radicalbyte 8y agoWe pump plenty of money in now for specific infrastructure projects; which is exactly what we should be doing here.
- daliusd 8y agoI'm not sure about political but economic is questionable. I am pretty sure installing and maintaining solar and wind is cheaper than coal (based on https://www.drawdown.org/ https://www.drawdown.org/ book). Not sure about solar.
- adrianN 8y agoSo they want to be ~20% carbon free in thirty years? That is not a very ambitious goal. Especially if you consider that they want to increase the amount of energy produced from coal from ~30% in 2015 to ~50% until 2030. [1] [1] https://news.mongabay.com/2017/05/vietnam-makes-a-big-push-for-coal-while-pledging-to-curb-emissions/ https://news.mongabay.com/2017/05/vietnam-makes-a-big-push-f...
- realusername 8y agoYeah that's what I got from the article. > Currently solar power only accounts for 0.01 per cent of total power generation capacity in Vietnam, but the government plans to increase the ratio to 3.3 per cent by 2030 and 20 per cent by 2050. This is not very impressive, they plan to add 3.3% solar in the next 12 years, I don't find that revolutionary at the moment.
- MyticMoon 8y agohaving them moved away from that nuclear power plant is a big relief for Vietnamese people already. This is still a huge leap, I would say. Basically, they are just following what China is doing (slowly) so if renewable energy could make a huge impact in China, they might accelerate the program.
- realusername 8y ago> having them moved away from that nuclear power plant is a big relief for Vietnamese people already. Why so exactly? It would have massively reduced emissions to have that nuclear power plant, now instead you have a vague promise they put on 2050, purposely far enough that it does not bind the government to anything.
- cageface 8y agoVietnam doesn't have a good track record on public infrastructure projects. Due to corruption and cronyism they have a hard time even building roads to spec. The prospect of running a nuclear reactor in that environment is horrifying.
- baybal2 8y agoNuclear is too expensive, and small nuclear is even more so, but one has to remember that nothing can replace atomic energy as the closest one to ideal, flawless power source.
- ceejayoz 8y ago"Too expensive" seems like a flaw, as does radioactive waste. (Unless you're counting solar as a form of nuclear energy.)
- merpnderp 8y agoWe built profitable nuclear plants in the past. One might wonder how with mind bogglingly better designs and a much richer world, we can't afford to build them today. My money is that the blame lies between political reasons and that Nat-Gas is cheap, relatively clean, and wildly abundant energy source in N. America. Right now in N. America you'd be a fool to build anything but a mid-sized Nat-Gas generator which can be spun up/down quickly and costs less to run than anything else, while gaining major political points for outputting far less pollution than coal.
- selimthegrim 8y agoWell that’s interesting, because University of Minnesota ran simulations with MISO that stated batteries and solar would outperform a gas peaker on that grid financially in the next few years. http://energytransition.umn.edu/modernizing-minnesotas-grid-an-economic-analysis-of-energy-storage-opportunities/ http://energytransition.umn.edu/modernizing-minnesotas-grid-...
- corerius 8y agoThen it shouldn't be a problem at all. The power companies will simply veer towards solar if it's cheaper.
- selimthegrim 8y agoTell that to Entergy New Orleans (on the MISO grid) and a population fixated on “local” plants and jobs Relevant John Oliver clip below: https://www.theadvocate.com/gambit/new_orleans/news/the_latest/article_f3604214-9f1c-11e8-a641-5f79571d0914.html https://www.theadvocate.com/gambit/new_orleans/news/the_late...
- pjc50 8y agoThe incremental roll-out possible with solar, and the simpler project management, give it a huge advantage. The coal roll-out is alarming but as soon as it was pointed out that Vietnam has large coal reserves it was unsurprising. This is where the richer nations need to step up and find a way to pay to leave resources in the ground rather than extracting them. It's the cheapest form of "carbon capture".
- melling 8y agoDo you mean like the United States or Germany which are increasing or fighting a reduction in coal? https://www.wsj.com/articles/epa-is-set-to-roll-back-restrictions-on-coal-burning-power-plants-1534622001?mod=hp_major_pos7 https://www.wsj.com/articles/epa-is-set-to-roll-back-restric...
- WhompingWindows 8y agoCoal jobs are this bizarre holy grail of right-wing politics in the USA and Germany. It really makes very little sense in a macro view, because renewables are cleaner for the local populace's air and water, and renewables add some 5X-10X more jobs than coal. Coal extraction and processing is increasingly automated, the ole' miner with his pick is a thing of the past - these jobs are stagnant or decreasing in numbers over time. It's an industry in a steady decline, and yet the electoral college, and the coalitions built for Angela Merkel's party in Germany, prop up coal.
- hannob 8y ago> Coal jobs are this bizarre holy grail of right-wing politics in the USA and Germany. It's far more than a right-wing politics issue in Germany. The most dedicated supporters of coal are within the social democrats and even the left party has some vocal coal supporters in some areas.
- corerius 8y agoSssshhh. You'll ruin the narrative. It seems to me that the easiest way for a Germany to cut on energy needs is simply by having less people live there. I expect they would have been at negative population growth without shipping in a scad of people.
- pastullo 8y agoi'm sad to see a decline of nuclear energy everywhere in the world. While renewables are the end goal, nuclear was gonna be the perfect transition source for the next decades, providing emission-free and continuous energy to the grid. I have the bad feeling that cancelling a nuclear power plant, means building coal/gas plants in its place. This article actually mention the renewaleble goal of Vietnam which are really unimpressive. 3.3% solar inputs by 2030...WOW, in the mean time how are they gonna keep up with the energy requirements of a developing country? Probably coal.
- coconut_crab 8y agoCoal it is, the planned nuclear reactor could provide 4000 MW with 10 billions dollar construction cost. It was too pricy so the plan was shelved and replaced with... 3 coal powered power plants instead. The coal will be imported from other countries, hopefully they will be as clean as President Trump said /s.
- masklinn 8y agoIt already means manufacturers get less experience building nuclear plants, and it's much harder to de-king the building process of new designs. We've been feeling those effects for the last decade or, Gen IIIs are manufacturing disaster due to the combination of the ongoing popularity of Gen IIs and the dearth of new constructions in the 80s/90s.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoNuclear is good as long as it has very stable, secure and responsible local governance. You can't have political instability, people cutting corners, lack of oversight, lack of security or lack of resources ... or you have problems. To me that's the problem with Nuclear. Following specific rules and conventions, some nations will be fine, but so many ... it's iffy. If Vietnam gets a couple plants, Burma, Laos, Cambodia etc. will want one too and then the risk of something bad happening just starts to crawl up.
- eeZah7Ux 8y ago> Nuclear is good as long as it has very stable, secure and responsible local governance. ...and no terrorist attacks. And no war. And the governance remains stable and responsible for the next 100 years.
- rjmunro 8y agoHow are they going to balance supply from solar (which peaks at midday, and goes away entirely at night) with demand (which usually peaks in the evening)?
- jerven 8y agoSame way anyone else will. Displacing demand to easier times. If most demand is aircon based then moving it to pre-cooling (make ice during day/defrost during evening) etc... and economics will do that for the largest consumers. A bit of storage, and peaker plants. Storage kinds do not really mater as it is all about what is locally price efficient. Otherwise, it is the same as the nuclear case. Production does not match demand curve so fix it with storage, pricing and other tools. (i.e. if nuclear is baseload something else needs to produce when demand peeks, which in other words makes it rather similar in practice (see also why all the pumped storage in the UK was build in the 60-80's))
- ju-st 8y agoThe newest trend is to orientate the PV panels east-west instead south. If you want to know more: http://www.rechargenews.com/solar/1182796/is-east-west-the-best-for-pv-arrays http://www.rechargenews.com/solar/1182796/is-east-west-the-b...
- tjpnz 8y agoThe article briefly mentions security fears (alongside cost) as one of the reasons for not going ahead with nuclear. Is this code for a certain foreign power throwing their weight around?
- pg_bot 8y agoI think the greatest irony of our age is the progression of climate change due to environmentalists protesting against the development of nuclear power. While nuclear power admittedly has risks, the tradeoffs are clearly worth making if you look at emissions and deaths per megawatt hour. We didn't curtail energy demand, and future generations will pay the price for using fossil fuels instead of nuclear.
- addicted 8y agoNuclear hasn’t suffered because of environmentalists protesting. Nuclear has suffered because it is expensive and uneconomical. The only way it is even feasible is by having laws that protect the owners from liabilities caused due to catastrophic failure. Blaming environmentalists gives them way more power than they possess. Environmentalists have struggled to even stop pipelines running through the US whose sole purpose is to make Canada richer. Far more than environmentalists it’s NIMBY folks who have affected nuclear (but still not as much as basic economics).
- phobosdeimos 8y agoWestern countries are desperately trying to keep 1960s and 1970s reactors open for as long as they can because the prospect of building new ones is a financial and political nightmare.
- WillPostForFood 8y agoOne of the reasons it is such a hot NIMBY issue is there has been so much fear mongering about nuclear power.
- 7952 8y agoFor existing sites local people tend to be in favour and see the benefits. You would have difficulty building a new site, but that is true of any large scale development and is hardly unique to nuclear. Some people are just opposed to any development and will use whatever argument makes sense to try and stop the scheme. But with political support that opposition can be overcome. But that political support needs to be economically viable for the government involved, and that is the problem.
- jerven 8y agoWell this will give some place for the output of FirstSolar Inc. two Vietnamese manufacturing plants to go. (2.4 GW DC capacity a year, all online from Q2 2019) To be honest, nuclear industry hasn't done itself any favors by not building the plants they sold on anything close to time and budget. 15 to 20 years from idea to operation is just not nimble enough. I don't even think that the all of the proposed coal power will all be build to completion and in operation for long just due to the infrastructure costs.
- phobosdeimos 8y agoI never understood how a country like Vietnam could afford nuclear powerplants when in Europe costs of building new ones skyrocket to 10 billion euro.
- syntaxing 8y agoStandards. Not to say that Vietnam is unable to maintain the same quality, but doing something "right" is tough and expensive. Every little thing needs to be thoroughly planned and inspected which costs money.
- ben_w 8y agoWhat does it cost in labour-hours rather than dollars? According to Google, minimum wage in Vietnam was $166/month last year.
- baybal2 8y agoThe biggest advantage of PV energy is that it is almost scale agnostic - a single panel on top of somebody's rooftop is as efficient as one installed in a gigawatt scale plant. This is something no other commercial power source has. Rather than giving lump sum subsidies, a nation can make much much more by just ironing out feed in rules, and making sure the grid can accommodate that. It takes around 6-8k usd (5kw setup) to make an average Asian single family house energy neutral during summer using Chinese panels (basically we talk about 1 aircon and a fridge). Now just compare payout periods of such setups. Now, the last moment that can't be overstated, but almost always forgotten: the economic effects of feed-in tariff gets greatly negated when there is no real time pricing. See, in Asia aircon usage peaks proportionally to insolation, and so is the PV electricity production.
- Hoasi 8y agoSounds like a sound decision, plenty of sun in Viet Nam, all year long.
- catawbasam 8y agoCoal is what is actually being built.
- gwbas1c 8y agoI'm really curious if there will be massive storage systems?