9 ms·
FDA approves first generic version of EpiPen
- MaxGabriel 8y agoA good next step would be to make it easier to buy the injectors. In California, if you’re not a medical professional, you need a first aid and CPR course to buy one. This is for a device whose commercials consist of six year olds explaining how to use it, and one that can be life-saving if someone has an allergic attack in the backcountry (where lots of previously unknown attacks happen, because of unusual foods/insects).
- Johnny555 8y agoRequiring some base level of medical training sounds reasonable... Epinephrine injections can have dangerous side effects, so making sure the person with the pen knows when to use it sounds like a good policy. If you're worried about backcountry safety, taking a first aid class is probably more useful than carrying an epipen.
- Broken_Hippo 8y agoThis step makes sense. Random first aid person carrying an injector without proper knowlege on how to use one seems a bit... short-sighted. Sure, those 6-year-olds know how to use them because they've been trained on how to use them. So have their caregivers. Usually this is because they might need to use one on themselves, a sibling, or a parent - who has a known condition. The random person that doesn't come in contact with such a relative or housemate, however, might not even properly recognise the reaction. Even when they do, they still need the training on how to use the pen so they know how to respond. The prudent thing to do in these cases is to give a first aid and CPR course to those that wish to have one.
- jschwartzi 8y agoDoes this use the same autoinjector as the EpiPen? Because as I understand it generic epinephrine autoinjectors already exist, but they use a different autoinjector technology that isn't as easy to use as an EpiPen. Edit: We talked about them when we were using the EpiPen trainers in the first aid class I took.
- Symmetry 8y agoThe main barrier to other auto-injectors, as I understand it, is that doctor's prescriptions for "EpiPens" couldn't be used to purchase them. With these that apparently isn't the case.
- cryptonector 8y agoMind you, the patient could ask for a prescription for the alternative products, and the doctor could suggest it. If the patient doesn't, it's probably out of ignorance. If the doctor doesn't... it could be ignorance too.
- forkerenok 8y agoFrom the article > Other epinephrine injectors have been approved before, but they struggled to gain market share against a brand that used lobbying and marketing to establish a virtual monopoly on the market. This got me thinking that consumers are at fault as well. But then I read the following from the linked article[0]. > “Their most brilliant maneuver, clearly, was giving them [EpiPens] away to schools and making it the thing that they could say, ‘Well, the nurse knows how to use it,’ ” said R. Adams Dudley, a pulmonologist at the University of California at San Francisco. “What are the parents afraid of? Their child will be away from them, and they won’t be there to use it. If they can say the school nurse knows how to use an EpiPen; she’s never seen an Adrenaclick ... It’s just a fear thing.” With such (understandable) absolute risk averseness what is the way out?.. [0] https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/2016/08/25/7f83728a-6aee-11e6-ba32-5a4bf5aad4fa_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/2016/08/25/7...
- gameswithgo 8y agoThere are at least two other products on the market and they are easy to use. Just quit buying epi pens. Tell your doctor/school you won't be using it and deal with it.
- cryptonector 8y agoThe school may not want to accept that...
- lilott8 8y agoWhatever medicine I give the school to administer to my child at the appropriate times has to be observed; the school cannot wantonly withhold the medications I provide them, especially when provided a Dr's note. If I send my child to school with an "off-brand" epipen with a doctor's note and direct the school to use this instead, they have to observe it -- a nurse is in no way capable of making a drug administration decision without the consult of a licensed medical doctor.
- 8y ago
- pg_bot 8y agoWhile there are other epinephrine auto-injectors on the market (auvi-q and adrenaclick) the big difference here is that this is considered a "generic" version of the EpiPen. The significance is that pharmacists can recommend that a prescription for an EpiPen be replaced with this, where they cannot with the others on the market. I will also note that the cost of the EpiPen is not due to the drug, it is the patent on the auto-injector which is set to expire in 2025. If you wanted to actually improve this product, you would follow the SpaceX model and allow replaceable cartridges for the auto-injector instead of throwing away the entire housing when the medicine expires every 18 months.
- pkaye 8y ago> allow replaceable cartridges for the auto-injector I think the risk of reusing injection equipment is chance of infection. Also a more reasonable solution to the wastage is to do a long term study to extend the expiry date. The drug manufacturer don't do a long study because of the lost time plus potential extra sales.
- pg_bot 8y agoI am still for single use, but if it is unused and the medicine expires people throw away the entire thing. The reason for replacement every 18 months is that the medicine expires, if you could just replace the medicine if you didn't use it you may see cost savings. However, I am just spitballing here and it is likely that there are reasons why this cannot come to fruition which I have not considered thoroughly.
- pkaye 8y agoMost of the cost is just the patent exclusivity plus paying for R&D/testing. If someone invents a new mechanism it will have to start over again and will stay expensive for another decade or two. The simpler thing is do enough testing to extend the life of the current solution to 3-5 years. The manufacturer will have no incentive to do that unless there is some competition. https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2017/07/18/537257884/that-drug-expiration-date-may-be-more-myth-than-fact https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2017/07/18/5372578...
- exabrial 8y agoAh, the beauty of the free market at work! This is an awesome accomplishment and I hope to see more things like this!
- jly 8y agoThe cost of the non-Epipen / generic auto-injectors are still very high. Usually at least $109 for a 2-pack, from what I can tell, and often $200+ in some places. How much will these cost without insurance? Sometimes there are coupons available from the manufacturer, I guess. But why should I need to jump through these hoops? These injectors lose efficacy over time and need to be replaced regularly for those that need to have them available for a severe allergy. Epinephrine costs maybe $5 for a dosage. It's been sold for over 100 years. It's a WHO essential medicine for anaphylaxis, and is life saving for humans and pets. It's the same thing with other critical hormones like insulin. The market for this stuff (even with generics) doesn't work. We know how much these drugs cost to manufacture and it's very little. Essential medicines with overwhelming human impact need to have strict pricing regulation that makes them available worldwide at close to the manufacturing cost.
- maxerickson 8y agoGoodRx estimates cash prices (they are the PBM for the transaction, not insurance). They say $109 at a couple places: https://www.goodrx.com/adrenaclick?drug-name=adrenaclick&form=package&dosage=2-auto-injectors-of-0.3mg&quantity=1&days_supply=&label_override=epinephrine%20(Adrenaclick) https://www.goodrx.com/adrenaclick?drug-name=adrenaclick&for...
- tmaly 8y agoIs this old news? I bought a generic epipen in 2016
- ksherlock 8y agoYour generic EpiPen was actually a Mylan EpiPen with a different sticker and a slight discount. (but somehow cost 2-3 times what an EpiPen cost 5 or 10 years ago). This was manufactured by Teva and will provide actual competition to Mylan.
- smokelegend 8y agoJust going to leave this here It Costs $30 to Make a DIY EpiPen, and Here's the Proof - MIT Technology Review MIT Technology Review https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.technologyreview.com/s/602422/it-costs-30-to-make-a-diy-epipen-and-heres-the-proof/amp/ https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.technologyreview.com/s/6024...
- blacksmith_tb 8y agoRecently on HN, too: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17629436 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17629436
- joezydeco 8y agoIMO the AuviQ was a much better device. It was more compact and included audio instructions on how to use it. I'm glad to see someone is trying to bring it back.
- russdill 8y agoI'll just leave this here https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-04-24/generic-drug-companies-said-to-face-first-charges-in-u-s-probe https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-04-24/generic-d... (Teva and Mylan)
- dmix 8y agoFor anyone who wants a good background on why this is a big deal: http://slatestarcodex.com/2016/08/29/reverse-voxsplaining-drugs-vs-chairs/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2016/08/29/reverse-voxsplaining-dr...
- ChuckMcM 8y agoAnd then there is this: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/24/us/politics/pharmacy-benefit-managers-gag-clauses.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/24/us/politics/pharmacy-bene... The trick is getting people who need epipens to ask the pharmacist if they have the generic version available.
- uberduber 8y agoI've always had high-deductible insurance and for many years I specifically had allergists write me prescriptions for generic Adrenaclick. I've been to Rite Aid, Walgreens, Target, and CVS and they always magically fill it with a name brand Epi-pen. The pharmacy techs always refuse to fix it saying they can only fill it with the brand name. I have to insist on speaking to the actual pharmacist who apologizes, corrects the issue, and explains to the pharmacy tech how it works. My physicians are writing the prescription properly. One year out of frustration I made my doctor actually write "Adrenaclick" and "may substitute with generic" and they still filled it with an Epi and the tech tried to argue with me that "Adrenaclick" was another word for "Name brand Epi-pen" Last 2 years my allergist let me know Auvi-Q will give you them for free as long as you have any commercial insurance. They submitted the paperwork, I answered one call confirming my address and I got four Auvi-Q injectors in the mail the next day. Glad I didn't have to pay $100+ and argue at the pharmacy.
- MrBingley 8y ago> This approval means patients living with severe allergies who require constant access to lifesaving epinephrine should have a lower-cost option, as well as another approved product to help protect against potential drug shortages. I live in Canada, and there are already drug shortages. You cannot buy any EpiPens in Canada. Period. For whatever reason, we are all out. I had an allergic reaction this week, and took a gamble to go the emergency room before the anaphylaxis really kicked in, because I only have one (expired) EpiPen left and want to save it until I'm really desperate. Each EpiPen costs $35 to manufacture,and I have no idea how a multi-billion dollar company like Mylan can have a manufacturing shortage of a life-saving drug, especially given their 17x (!) profit margin. I'm usually not a religious person, but I can only hope there's a hell so those corporate executives can rot in it.
- amluto 8y agoIs Adrenaclick available in Canada?
- jlebrech 8y agodo we really need auto-injectors? what about a syringe that is administered much faster than a normal syringe? (slight distinction)