9 ms·
Cubans cheer as internet goes nationwide for a day
- toomanybeersies 8y agoIt seems that Cuba is slowly but surely liberalising. It will be interesting to see what happens in the future, apparently they're having a referendum in February for a new constitution that's somewhat more free-market friendly, as well as LGBT friendly. The USA reimposing embargoes on Cuba seems like the worst thing it can do to try and force liberalisation. 50 years of sanctions has proven to be a complete failure.
- qop 8y agoWell, to ignore it would be to appear complacent on the issue, given our past record with Cuban relations. It's hard to fix a country when Communists run it and can just murder opposition without consequence. But something is better than nothing otherwise we'd just be ignoring it. Cuban people are the greatest hope for Cuba. The inhabitants of any Communist nation will inevitably reach a point of disenchantment with communism and decide that life would probably be better if they could vote and have a political say without being murdered. LGBT is a weird, rather irrelevant point but it does share the same analog that people will see it and realize that no matter how repulsive the behavior, freedom to engage in it must surely be preferable to a Communist prescription of their daily lives and inner lives. Cuba will fix itself. They just need more Cubans who want to help do so.
- dang 8y agoPlease don't take HN into generic political or national flamewars. It just leads to the same fights over and over. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- lordlimecat 8y agoI'm a little bothered by the flagging of this comment. What guideline has he broken? He engaged with the parent comment, was not uncivil, and while the content of his post is surely contentious, the topic of this submission is inherently contentious. Are people not allowed to express the opinion that Communism is problematic on a discussion on the state of freedom in one of the few remaining communist countries? Should we just say "yay Cuba" and move on?
- dang 8y agoYou certainly don't have to yay Cuba or yay communism, but the discussions people get into when topic becomes this generic and this divisive usually end up in flames. That's what we're trying to avoid here. Notice how it went straight to Saudi Arabia? That's a flamewar move, not a substantive one. And then we get https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17763463 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17763463, and so on and so on. We moderate HN this way because the site has a clear mandate: thoughtful conversation on topics of intellectual curiosity (https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html). At this point we have over 10 years' experience with where the community's limits are in terms of what can be discussed that way versus what spills over into flames. When the needle starts to go into the red, that's when we moderate. I assume that the users who flagged that comment were doing much the same.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- gautamdivgi 8y agoSaudi Arabia does all the above things but the US and most of the western world is fine with it. Your statement is hypocrisy at its best. The problem is Cuba doesn’t have enough money.
- qop 8y agoWhy would you make that point and imply that my opinion matches up just because other people think that way? Saudi politics are possibly more detestable than Cuba. Id have said as much if I figured some clueless HN user would pigeon hole my argument.
- qop 8y agoThis is almost a cliche of people who don't know shit shout cuba. They've had an Internet for years with no wifi. They have mechanics that can reliably work on cars from a half century ago. Cuba is a wealth of intelligent engineering minds, plagued by reprehensible Communist rule. Money has never stopped the cuban spirit. It's a disgrace to compare the Cuban spirit to Saudi Arabia.
- gautamdivgi 8y agoThat was exactly my point. Why single out Cuba for sanctions when the US has normal relations with countries that have sketchier track records.
- sremani 8y agoCuba is treated different because Cuba is close to HOME. The only time US was close to a nuclear war and main-land invasion was when Cuba gave their enemy a foot hold. I would be mad, if US civilian and military did not treat Cuba or any other Caribbean Island differently from the countries on Eurasian land mass.
- amaccuish 8y agoAnd Japan did Pearl Harbour, so what? The idea that you apply sanctions for historical reasons is absurd. Further, the US actually tried to invade Cuba (but of course Cuba has no right to feel threatened by the US...)
- toomanybeersies 8y agoAt the same time the USA was imposing its embargo on Cuba, it was propping up right-wing dictatorships in Latin America. They funded rebels and coups to overthrow democratically elected governments on the whims of fruit companies. They supported Pinochet in Chile while he was throwing people out of helicopters. In practically every Latin American country the USA was systematically involved in brutal repression of the leftists and anything vaguely pro-Soviet [1], without any regard to human rights or democracy. The USA also did almost nothing in response to the atrocities of the Duvaliers in Haiti, despite being orders of magnitude worse than Castro. To say that the USA embargoes Cuba due to human rights concerns is completely and utterly laughable. The USA didn't give a toss about human rights in Cuba under Batista, who was incidentally another brutal dictator propped up by the USA. The USA has never cared about human rights and freedoms in its neighbours. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Condor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Condor
- ant6n 8y agoI was there a couple of years ago, and it seemed the country was already in the late-communism early-capitalism phase that Eastern European countries went through around 1990. This was especially visible in the tourism industry, i.e. with 'casas', apartments/rooms rented to foreigners. In this market, people were already getting separated into economic winners and losers, as often happens in this quick transition to capitalism. It seemed that people had a feeling what was happening, everybody seemed in a rush to get as much of the tourist currency that's pegged to the dollar, rather than the locals' currency.
- emersonrsantos 8y agoI'm not sure Internet will free the Cuban people, but it's certainly a step in freedom direction. It is impossible to find a dozen people for whom the word freedom means the same thing, in the same way. I just hope they achieve freedom in their lives.
- microcolonel 8y ago> It is impossible to find a dozen people for whom the word freedom means the same thing, in the same way. Not being tricked out of your ancestral land by a serial rapist who then goes on to rob your country blind for decades and play dice with your nuclear neighbor is a start, maybe.
- tpurves 8y agoAre you refering to Trump or Castro here?
- dang 8y agoPlease don't do this here.
- microcolonel 8y agoWhat exactly did I do? I was noting that an improvement in the freedom of Cubans is hardly subjective, given the effects of the ongoing Castro period. Almost any country is freer than one which decides who can and can not communicate with the outside world, or own the product of their labour. Where in the guidelines does it say that I have to use the driest, dullest language to describe anything or make any point?
- dang 8y agoYou posted a flamey political rant. That drags down discussion quality in its own right and leads to worse from others. If that's the game you want to play, please play it somewhere else. There are probably contexts where it's possible to have a high-quality discussion with that sort of rhetoric in it, but the open internet is certainly not one of them. It just sets things on fire, and scorched earth is boring.
- DINKDINK 8y agoRelated: Measuring Internet Censorship in Cuba's ParkNets https://ooni.torproject.org/post/cuba-internet-censorship-2017/ https://ooni.torproject.org/post/cuba-internet-censorship-20... ParkNet: Short Documentary on Internet Censorship in Cuba https://ooni.torproject.org/post/parknet-short-documentary-cuba/ https://ooni.torproject.org/post/parknet-short-documentary-c...
- xrd 8y agoAwesome. Thanks for sharing this.
- dougmwne 8y agoHere's an incredible case study of "El Paquete" an ad hoc sneaker net that developed in Cuba to trade news and media in the absence of widely available internet connections. https://michaelannedye.files.wordpress.com/2018/01/el-paquete-chi.pdf https://michaelannedye.files.wordpress.com/2018/01/el-paquet...
- LMYahooTFY 8y agohttps://media.ccc.de/v/34c3-8740-the_internet_in_cuba_a_story_of_community_resilience https://media.ccc.de/v/34c3-8740-the_internet_in_cuba_a_stor... Really cool talk by two guys who flesh out internet connectivity in Cuba (one of them is a Cuban engineering major at a Cuban university), apparently citizens there may well operate the largest mesh network in the world.
- girvo 8y agoYep. They even have hacked video game consoles to play multiplayer games with each other on. I got to have a go with an Xbox (the original haha) in Havana last year — was a lot of fun!
- friedman23 8y agoAs a descendant of Cuban refugees I have to thank fate that my grandfather had the foresight and conviction to abandon everything and come to the United States. Just the thought that through a few twists of fate I could have been born in some totalitarian nightmare state is enough to give me chills. I must urge everyone that is against the US taking in refugees to consider that by banning refugees we are trapping people in places most of us would consider to be Hell.
- eberfreitas 8y agoFor a lot of americans driven out of their homes by gigantic medical bills, the US is hell...
- derekp7 8y agoI've not heard of any hospital taking a person's house to pay a medical bill. Typically it goes into collections and on your credit report. Now a lowered credit score will affect the ability to get loans, possibly needed to effect repairs on a home, but that is a bit more of a stretch. And if it goes to court then wages can be garnished, affecting your ability to pay a mortgage -- but I believe that garnished wages are limited. Oh, and if you pay almost any amount on a monthly basis towards a medical bill, then that can keep it out of collections too.
- PhasmaFelis 8y ago> I've not heard of any hospital taking a person's house to pay a medical bill. Nor I. That might actually be an improvement. What we have instead is people dying because they couldn't afford lifesaving treatment in the first place, and banks taking other people's houses for no reason at all.
- xor1 8y ago>Just the thought that through a few twists of fate I could have been born in some totalitarian nightmare state is enough to give me chills. I'm curious about this line of thinking. Do you think your specific consciousness was being held in reserve somewhere, and it would have been placed into a mortal body regardless of when you were due to come into being? Plus if your grandfather had stayed in Cuba, who's to say your parents would have still met, started a relationship, and conceived a child? The way I see it, I only exist because of the exact series of events leading up to that one moment where I was conceived. I exist because of a combination of a specific sperm and a specific egg. All sorts of factors contributed to all of us getting extremely lucky, even up to the final hours, minutes, and seconds before fertilization. We won, and we denied a countless number of other potential minds the privilege of existence. There's no way to prove it of course, but I feel like a different sperm being responsible for fertilization would have meant I would have never existed at all. My parents would have had a different child with a different consciousness. Even if a specific consciousness is tied to the egg itself, that gives a window based on the menstrual cycle.
- eberfreitas 8y agoI love the freedom of the internet, but today it is led by just a few companies that control information for profit and some sketchy things. I'm afraid that the internet is not as free as it used to be as it reinforces and "locks" you on a culture of individual consumerism over communal well-being. I can only hope that the internet won't erase from memory what the Cuban revolution was all about.
- lugg 8y agoThe internet is just if not more free than it ever has been. Maybe the way you choose to use it has changed? For me, I have more access to free information, than I ever have. Im trying to not let this fall into a snarky "use Facebook less" reply but it's pretty hard not to when you're making claims like "the internet is not as free as it used to be." The fact the mainstream signed on and wanted centralised services over many decentralized and democratized services isn't a suprise nor is it an indicator the internet is less free. Simply that it's got some new citizens and they happen to want to do things a different way than you would like. Don't get me wrong Google, Amazon, Facebook etc having such dominance is frightening and worrying for their own respective and distinct reasons but let's not lazily frame it as the internet being less free.
- bdamm 8y agoYour point is valid and, in the sense of TCP exchanges, true. However for most people "the Internet" is the experience of the services that are available to them via that medium. For the general non-technical, it has always been centralized services, and there seem to be larger more centralized services now than there were in the earlier times. The ability of companies to customize the user Internet experience into a reinforced echo chamber has unquestionably arisen. But back to TCP. Governments have certainly improved their ability to monitor, restrict, and even manipulate that traffic flow. Is the Internet more free? I'm not sure.
- ian0 8y ago>The internet is just if not more free than it ever has been. Maybe for you - not so for most [1]. But I get your point. There is indeed much more amazing content out there now than there was 15 years ago. If you can squint your eyes just right and focus in between the billboards.. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_censorship_and_surveillance_by_country https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_censorship_and_survei...
- rosege 8y agoI visited Cuba in 2009. One of the places I went was a communist museum. It was mostly full of what you'd expect. But in the gift shop (yes even in communist countries the museums have them) they were selling a used VB programming book.
- sawmurai 8y agoUnrelated to the topic, but if there is a frontend developer with reuters.com reading: please consider fixing that replacement of the url in the address bar once the user scrolls to the end of the current article (not the start of the new one strangely) ... with fixing being removing the "feature".
- jasonkester 8y agoAw, that's a shame. Cuba is a really cool place, and a lot of what makes it special is the lack of internet. It's disconnected in a way that you really can't experience anywhere else in the world. Want to change your flight? Too bad. Can't do that. Want to research the next town? Pull out a book or ask somebody. Going there is like travelling was back in the 90s. You take a bus to the next town, then walk around with your bag asking at various houses if they have any rooms available. The lady at one may direct you a block down to her friend, and it all works itself out. Better still, go to a restaurant at night, drink a beer and watch the amazing local band playing. And talk to people because nobody is engrossed in their phone. They can't be, because there is no internet. Other places, I can't remember the last time I was able to strike up a conversation with travelers through the barrier of their phone. In Cuba, I was talking to random people every single night. Because that's all there was to do. It really drives home how much connectivity can wreck things. And it'd be a shame if we lost the last place in the world that still works like that.
- forgingahead 8y agoThis is an insane "povertarian" mindset -- what about all the benefits connectivity brings to actual Cubans?
- jasonkester 8y agoSadly, I suspect that opening up to the rest of the world will actually make things worse for the average Cuban. Take a stroll through old town Havana and look at all the amazing old buildings that would be converted into million dollar condos during the first six months that rich Americans were allowed to buy property there. There is a lot of Carribbean around to compare the place to, and frankly, it doesn't compare well to present day Cuba as far as quality of life for the average citizen. As to your personal attack, I don't know... I don't really see anything wrong with enjoying visiting a place. Or with being nostalgic for what a place used to be. I also, for example, think it's a shame that Belltown in Seattle replaced its cool dive bars with trendy restaurants and condos. But it would be a bit silly to blame me for those dive bars having been there in the first place.