7 ms·
It seems to me to be a continuation of the pattern of labor 'Going Postal' in the labor hostile environment that has emerged since Reagan. This should be a wak
by salawat 8y ago
It seems to me to be a continuation of the pattern of labor 'Going Postal' in the labor hostile environment that has emerged since Reagan.
This should be a wake-up call to everyone in the country. We can't survive without being able to trust and respect each other as human beings. Part of that is recognizing that even the most humble occupations deserve a fair wage and chance at advancement in life.
If we can't respect the people who put in 8 hour days on our behalf and fulfill our obligations to them as responsible business owners/organizers, we are doomed to see repeats of this type of tragedy.
People seek purpose, and many are content to do even the more "mundane" jobs so long as the compensation is fair. Too many places seek to be successful on Wall Street's terms rather than in providing a service to their community.
I'm sure an MBA will surface and tell me I'm wrong, but I've not encountered a workplace that didn't marginalize their workers and generated a tragedy of the likes that has become a hallmark of the last 50 years.
God Speed, Russell. May your death have not been in vain.
[0]Going Postal: Rage, Murder, and Rebellion in America, Mark Ames
- hueving 8y agoPointless attempt to tie a political view to a tragedy, please don't do this. There have been massacres, bombings, dramatic suicides, etc long before the Reagan administration and none of them have claimed "If I would have only had 20% more compensation I wouldn't have violently murdered these 20 people." P.S. It's godspeed, not "God speed".
- pentae 8y agoI'd suggest looking at more data before we cast politics aside - I would like to compare the amount of mental health issues that manifest themselves like this one ranging up to mass violence with other countries. My hypothesis is countries with a larger middle class and robust social care (such as access to affordable health care) have less of these events.
- kingjacob 8y agoNo one says that outright but poverty and violent extremism are pretty closely linked. Its not the only factor ofc, and youll always have outliers, but comfortable people with things worth losing are less likely to do something to endanger that.
- ThrustVectoring 8y agoIncome inequality and violent crime are linked. Absolute poverty is tolerable to the psyche so long as everyone is in the same boat.
- hueving 8y agoThis was a suicide, not violent extremism.
- lisper 8y agoWhy pointless? It seemed quite pointful to me. In fact, I would go so far as to say that salawat's point, far from being pointless, is actually correct, and we ignore it at our peril.
- AlimJaffer 8y agoIt's less politics, and more to do with empathy for the common man. Mental illness is at an all-time high, wages are low, poverty is incredibly visible, and based off of postings on Reddit, Facebook, etc. there's a general attitude of being despondent due to the current economic and political climate. Something has to change, and it can only really start at the top - with government taking care of its citizens rather than constantly destroying the few social safety nets left.
- WillPostForFood 8y agobased off of postings on Reddit, Facebook, etc. there's a general attitude of being despondent due to the current economic and political climate. Something has to change Maybe spend less time on Reddit, Facebook, etc... Things probably aren't as bad as they look through the lens of social media.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoThe lens doesn’t change stagnant wages, health care and housing being out of reach, and income inequality. Things are terrible, and putting your head in the sand does nothing but exacerbate the situation.
- WillPostForFood 8y agoEmployment is low, home ownership is increasing, healthcare is too expensive but still more accessible than it ever has been. Things can be better, but I'd say, gently, that you lack perspective. You are mirroring a story that you see online on TV and social media that is created to make you think things are terrible so you'll watch more tv and spend more time on social media. Stagnant wages aren't terrible, 25% unemployment was terrible. Stagflation was terrible. You think housing is tough now, try a home loan at 16% interest rate like in 1981/2. You think things are politically divisive now? Look at the violence and political assassinations in the 1960's. Look at the crime rate which has been declining for a two decades.
- 8y ago
- peteretep 8y agoDoes it happen more in America than in European countries with more socialist policies?
- hueving 8y agoWasn't the last suicide by plane in Germany or Switzerland with a plane full of passengers?
- darpa_escapee 8y agoOften these types of suicides aren't given publicity, though this one was too much of a spectacle to ignore. There was a man who shot himself on the steps of a government(?) building, which is a town over from where I'm originally from, because he was laid off. A friend showed me the note he left on Facebook before it got deleted. It was very clear that he had been struggling financially for years and the layoff was the final straw. In a sense, the way he went out was his attempt to bring attention to the problems he faced and believes others were facing, too. While I'm not an advocate of martyrdom, it's kind of sad that the very act he thought would shine light on his suffering was disappeared from the record.
- deathhand 8y agoIndia's freemdom was gained, in part, by self immmolation. Can't be spreading that dissidence because it would lead to 'copy cats'. We don't actually want to fix the issue but rather sweep it under the rug like public mental health.
- selestify 8y agoWasn't entirely deleted from the record -- his story lives on in a small but nonzero way with this comment of yours, for example. But yes, sad that it probably didn't get the attention he wanted. Was there no news article explaining his suicide and the causes?
- lozenge 8y agoMental health organisations see reporting on the "cause" of a suicide as unhelpful, even when there is a note. Not that their guidelines are normally adhered to.
- nickserv 8y agoAt one point, this type of desperate act might have far reaching consequences in the US, it's a matter of how desperate society is as a whole. The Arab Spring revolutions were started by a suicide brought about by severe injustice and poverty.
- ithinkinstereo 8y agoI predict we're going to see many more such incidents of labor "going postal" in the near and medium term. Doubly so if the economy contracts and goes into a recession. Just look at the situation in NYC with ride-sharing and all the taxi driver suicides.
- pravda 8y ago>Just look at the situation in NYC with ride-sharing and all the taxi driver suicides. To clarify this, it is not 'taxi driver' suicides, it is suicides by medallion investors. Most drivers do not own medallions. http://www.slate.com/articles/business/moneybox/2012/06/taxi_medallions_how_new_york_s_terrible_taxi_system_makes_fares_higher_and_drivers_poorer_.html http://www.slate.com/articles/business/moneybox/2012/06/taxi...
- danielrhodes 8y agoThe medallion system reminds me of feudalism. It blows my mind that taxi drivers would defend this system and not flee to Uber/Lyft/etc.
- mschuster91 8y ago> It blows my mind that taxi drivers would defend this system and not flee to Uber/Lyft/etc. For those who defend the system, often enough the medallions are their life saving / insurance when they get old, and almost always financed by loans. The medallions going worthless at the same time invalidates their retirement plans and STILL leaves them on the hook for the loan.
- ethbro 8y agoThis is something that's made me think a lot about the health care debate. Would it not be just that, if we're going to rewrite the economic rules in some areas, we give partial compensation towards those we just screwed over? Presumably we're changing the rules because of progress (e.g. Uber and Lyft showing on-demand rideshare has a market), which is good for everyone. But say the human lifespan is 85 years +/-. 25 years for education to post-secondary graduation (e.g. bachelor's degree in US). Probably another 2-5 years of accumulating working capital for your venture. So there's a set number of "shots" a person gets in their life. In this instance, what's wrong with saying "We're doing away with the medallion system. Existing medallions will be repurchased by the government at a price proportional to ownership time. Funding will be accomplished by a tax on rideshare companies, that decreases yearly, and ends 5 years from now"? Otherwise, I see the following sequence of events: (1) people get screwed by technological upheaval -> (2) people become resentful against technological progress -> (3) people vote in politicians / laws that retard technological progress, to the detriment of all
- sehugg 8y agoI'm not an MBA, but I think it's way too early to attribute motivation to this incident.
- alkonaut 8y agoReading the dialog I think it's fair to say that both a) the man was not quite well, and b) the only motivation he actually DID suggest was the stress of low wage. So there's that.
- claydavisss 8y agoDentists alsohave a curiously high rate ofdepression despite being very well paid Literally anyone can snap. The only deterrent is precrime.
- GhostVII 8y agoHe seemed to throw the minimum wage thing in as an afterthought though, not sure that was actually a significant motivation for him.
- alkonaut 8y agoYes, definite afterthought. Or perhaps rather a best a guess at an unknown trigger. It seemed he acted on an impulse. It’s like if my doctor asks me why I think my blood pressure is suddenly extreme. It would be the first time I reflected over it.
- salawat 8y agoOccam's razor says he most likely meant what he said. If a program errors into a non-recoverable state, and I see something in the stack trace, odds are it had something to do with the issue. He showed intent to send a message. The fact he was about to end his life just amplifies it. Of all the things one could have focused on, that stuck out? Hardly dismissable. He knew where his life was going either way. Either because he would have ended it regardless, or because he knew that doing anything drastic enough to hurt the "people" who he saw as the source of his hardship would forfeit his ability to live any semblance of a normal life afterward.
- claydavisss 8y agoDo you own an iPhone? Do you know how much the people who build them make? Do you know that these workers also commit suicide on the job?
- closeparen 8y agoWell above the median income in their country.
- claydavisss 8y agolike plane mechanics
- jackvalentine 8y agoSeems to be a misreport, the guy wasn’t a mechanic he was a baggage handler.
- KozmoNau7 8y agoThe media is full of articles about how to avoid being stressed out, how to manage stress, how to avoid being stressed. Hardly do they ever even discuss that maybe our current labor/employer power balance and paradigm is fundamentally unhealthy, and only exists to fuel the greed of rampant crony capitalism.
- refurb 8y agoGuy is depressed and crashes plane and you’re connecting to labor relations? That’s a stretch!
- salawat 8y agoIt really isn't. I left the reference in my post for a reason. The fact is our society has a tendency to be unable to have meaningful discourse until someone provides framework for it. Just as the issue of Slavery back in the 1800's was fraught with the same types of rebellious antics and slaveowner hysterics, we're seeing the same patterns reserve at a time where inequality in the country has begun to reach a new perceived maxima. You're also seeing the same sort of outpouring of sympathy that many workplace shooters saw after they snapped, even from some people they shot. I'm not bringing the topic up lightly. I DON'T make a habit of bringing up the obvious or trying to find a way to turn things political. I've seen slices of life recently from the 1%, to teachers, to call center workers, to someone working the floor at a Tractor Supply, to an AM in a grocery store, to farmers, to the retired elderly for who the system worked. Every last one realizes that something is going amiss right now after a bit of time spent talking. Every last one feels helpless to change anything about it. In this type of environment it is frequently the mentally ill who are best able to perceive the flaws inherent in the System, and the most likely to ACT because of them. The 'crazies' in short, aren't the problem. The fact we as a society have normalized something so 'off' that even the 'crazies' are starting to get pushed over the edge by it is what we should be paying attention to. As I said, I was quite confident my post would prove controversial, but I felt it needed to be said, as it has been left unsaid for too long.
- ransom1538 8y agoSell large screen TVs all day or pack bags on a plane to Hawaii all day — then try to make 13.50$/hr during a bad divorce. Spend 20 hours detailing a bmw m7 and struggle pay for your kids school supplies. I am more surprised this isn’t a everyday thing. This country has a bad mental health issue. But ok. Make sure the lock is on the plane.
- throw2016 8y agoIf we take the conversation at face value this individual does not appear to be malicious. What's unsettling is a cheerful disposition mixed with deep resigned sadness. In a weird way its like he had given up and was broken but yet wanted his last shot at some 'fun', and also a bit of a protest while he is at it. It's feels both disjointed and coherent. He is another voice in a growing realization of the need to organize society around people and not markets.
- grkvlt 8y agoWhich part of an MBA syllabus deals with suicidally insane employees, again? I'm guessing the bit about liability insurance coverage, maybe? I'm 100% willing to bet it's not a section on how to help and retain employees with mental health issues by dealing with things in a sensitive and understanding fashion though, sadly...
- toomuchtodo 8y agoEthics, supposedly.
- supercanuck 8y agoEthics was just to educate on what they are, and how to manipulate other people’s ethics based on their view of the worls.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoYou can’t use education alone to force someone to not be a sociopath.
- grkvlt 8y agoOK, so what then? Lets try some MBA-approved brainstorming - nothing is wrong here, ideas are what is important! - A carefully calculated series of beatings? - The 'naughty step' for at least five minutes? - Some sort of heavy-duty drug regimen involving intravenous lithium and/or ketamine? - Maybe just pay someone to follow them around and prod them with a meter-stick whenever they seem to be getting a bit too excited? They could also hold up a warning sign, or maybe a color coded flag (as decided by either local church committee, or an act of parliament, depending on regional preferences) to warn people nearby (when not engaged employing the meter-sick, of course.)[0] 0. This last one is actually really good, as not only does it fix the sociopaths, it gets us closer to full employment, what with the flag people and all the committees, which will need planning meetings with secretaries and facilitators and note-takers and adminstrators, probably some sort of report will need to be generated after a while to see if the committees are working properly, or if we need more. And then there's the craftsmen who make the meter-sticks and flags as well. Probably the flag/meter-stick people will want a uniform, which adds a whole new layer of possibilities. In fact, I can't see why everyone doesn't just get up NOW and grab a long stick and go out and prod some fucking sociopaths just to show them who's boss. I think that was the idea, anyway.
- hueving 8y ago>It seems to me to be a continuation of the pattern of labor 'Going Postal' in the labor hostile environment that has emerged since Reagan. What evidence do you have that this is a trend? >I'm sure an MBA will surface and tell me I'm wrong, but I've not encountered a workplace that didn't marginalize their workers and generated a tragedy of the likes that has become a hallmark of the last 50 years. Isn't that every single employer that hasn't had an employee do this? What is your response to the European pilot that crashed a passenger plane full of passengers working for an airline in a country that eschews free market capitalism and has strong social safety nets?