10 ms·
USA Temperature: can I sucker you?
- clircle 8y agoThis p-hacking without looking at the p-value, just graphs. Love it.
- craftyguy 8y agoGreat. More 'ammo' for climate change deniers to take out of context and spread around. Most folks would not bother with trying to understand the points this article is making when presented with the 'no change here' graph. HN readers are not 'most folks' so this type of data manipulation is obvious and wrong to many here.
- mmastrac 8y agoI wouldn't say that - he's basically reverse engineered the graph that a climate change denier is already using for evidence and shown how it's basically cherry-picked BS. Clearly the denialists are already well-versed with this particular approach.
- seiferteric 8y agoI don't even believe that people that produce such graphs are real deniers. I think there is a lot of money to be made by for people like this and they are in the "climate denier industry". Someone going out of their way to produce a graph like that must know what they are doing and have ulterior motives.
- Jtsummers 8y agoWell, the ammo was already out there (last graph). The nice thing about this is that it's ammo for the rest of us (it explains that last graph and where it came from). This is one of the problems in debating people with counterfactual beliefs. They'll start with false assumptions, but often everything after those assumptions are reasonably sound applications of logic and math. They may not even know what those assumptions are (as in the case of the flawed, final graph). They see a trend line that confirms their belief. The flawed assumption is that the data used to produce the trend line is itself sound and reasonable. Knowing where the data came from, why it's problematic, you can present counter evidence to their false beliefs.
- rdtsc 8y agoIsn't this doing the opposite by showing how one can play tricks with various time windows and such. The exact kind of stuff deniers would do to "prove" their point.
- craftyguy 8y agoRight, my point being that most folks would not bother with trying to understand the points this article is making, and instead take the graph showing 'nothing to see here' and run with it.
- rdtsc 8y agoAh, I see the point. In that respect it would have been better if they had illustrated the trick with a hypothetical widgets produced by a factory scenario than jump straight into climate change.
- stukh 8y agoThis is a very nice blog post. Quite instructive. Recently, several times I’ve run into people tell me that temps in the U.S. are rising and I’ve wondered why they make such a claim. The blog sources the claim and overall the point I take from the blog post is that it’s easy to deceive people since people seek, by and large, confirmation of preconceived ideas rather than the truth.
- mikeash 8y agoI don’t think you actually understood it. Its point is that the temperature really is rising, and you have to resort to tricks to show that it’s not.
- stukh 8y agoI think my comment has been badly misinterpreted given the down voting. I’ve reread my post and I’m not sure why it has been so misinterpreted. Clearly I failed to convey my intent. Obviously the blog post is about how one can construct a misleading graph by cherry picking data. The blog shows how one can cleverly display data to reinforce a prior belief. In this case the prior belief is that temperature is not rising. Recently I’ve encountered a number of people making the claim that temps have been declining. I’ve wondered why this claim is being made and now I know the source. As shown in the blog post the source is a purposefully misleading graph. As stated by the author this misleading graph has recently been making the rounds on the internet.
- mikeash 8y agoI think you must have forgotten a “not” or otherwise made a typo that reversed the meaning of your comment. “Recently, several times I’ve run into people tell me that temps in the U.S. are rising and I’ve wondered why they make such a claim.” As written, your comment sounds like you don’t understand why someone would say temperatures are rising, and ascribe it to confirmation bias rather than climate change.
- oh_sigh 8y agoWhat part do climate change deniers deny? Is it that the mean global temperature is going up, or the idea that it is going up because of human activities? I thought it was the latter.
- enraged_camel 8y agoThere's both kinds. Those who refuse to believe the mean average temperature is going up have been declining in numbers as the evidence becomes more and more irrefutable. So they have been jumping to the "OK but we can't know for sure that it is human activity causing it!" camp. There's also a third camp, which says "OK I get it, human activity is causing temperatures to rise, but we can't really do anything meaningful to slow it down, much less reverse it!"
- seiferteric 8y agoThat last one is not denialism (maybe defeatism) and from my vantage point isn't too far from reality. I have yet to see any realistic proposed solution(s) to climate change.
- cnasc 8y ago> I have yet to see any realistic proposed solution(s) to climate change. Sustainable Energy - Without the Hot Air [1] is a free book that has a good start on this [1] https://www.withouthotair.com/ https://www.withouthotair.com/
- rayiner 8y agoThere is a lot of scientific evidence for that last point. (Which, ironically, puts environmentalists on the back foot, causing them to deny science because a big chunk of environmentalism is based on political ideology and not the science or economics of the environment.)
- conception 8y agoIt was the former and then the was overwhelming evidence. Then it was the latter... And now there's overwhelming evidence. So it's morphing into "it's too late there's nothing we can do!" Or it's not possible to organize etc. Still not helpful.
- bagels 8y agoThis site has malicious ads on it.
- simplecomplex 8y ago> climate change deniers Otherwise known as Republicans.
- eloff 8y agoYou're getting downvoted, probably because you're bringing politics into a political issue, and generalizing when clearly there are many educated republicans who believe in climate change, maybe more than there are climate change deniers. But you also raise a fair point, how many democrat climate change deniers are there? A very rare species indeed. Bottom line, identity politics suck!
- analog31 8y agoPolitics aside, I'm aware of precisely one prominent organization in the world that promotes climate change denial.
- devmunchies 8y agoPeople causing climate change, otherwise known as Everybody. I’m a conservative, and vegan. I relate to most Democrats on issues of conservation, yet most of them won’t go vegan or ride public transit, etc. Democrats don’t have a moral high ground simply because they believe in climate change. I want them to make it the biggest priority of our generation through their actions.
- guelo 8y agoThat's the problem with anti-government ideology. We are not going to fix this via personal responsibility and individual action. The only solution is through collective action and that probably means the government because "the market" doesn't care about negative externalities like pollution.
- orf 8y agoI'd start improving my personal moral high ground by stopping supporting the largest and most powerful group of climate deniers on the planet, funded by the companies and interests that have an interest in keeping their voters ignorant of the real issues. It's no coincidence that 69% of conservatives think climate change is not real, whereas only 5% of democrats do. But hey, that's just me.
- sschueller 8y agoToxic chemicals in our water and air. Plastic in the ocean. Etc. Etc. These are all things that are killing us and are proven to be bad. We have to do something irregardless if climate change is mann made or not. The debate is irrelevant (at least until we get everything else cleaned up) Even climate change deniers want clean water.
- mikeash 8y agoClean water is fairly distinct from climate change. Greenhouse gasses are mostly harmless aside from their warming effect, and the stuff that makes air and water unhealthy doesn’t warm the planet. Sometimes these two things go together, such as when replacing coal power plants with renewables. But sometimes they’re in opposition. For example, the Volkswagen emissions scandal was that they increased particulate pollution in order to decrease greenhouse gas emissions. In diesel engines, there’s a tradeoff between CO2 emissions and other emissions.
- RaptorJ 8y agoOcean acidification is no small thing
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoErm, VW, decreased particulate emissions during testing in order to pass the testing and have the vehicles be higher powered (and more polluting) under normal use. They did it to sell cars and make profit; they weren't doing it to save the planet.
- mikeash 8y agoThey did it to meet fuel economy numbers. CO2 emitted scales pretty much with fuel burned.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoI may be misremembering, but AFAIR They artificially reduced diesel consumption figures by having the vehicles run different power curves during testing. Meaning they used more fuel, and made more particulate emissions than they claimed to. So they made it look like the cars would use less fuel than they actually did.
- techsupporter 8y ago> We can completely ignore the fact that over the years the average location of all the contributing stations has moved slightly northward to colder territory[.] Woah, that's not something I'd considered. Are weather stations that contribute to NOAA operated by the volunteer public, kind of like Weather Underground? Either way, that's pretty interesting that there's a distinct northward migration in at least one "demographic."
- gok 8y agoThat graph is...questionable. The entire Y axis only covers 55 kilometers. I’m sure the NOAA has more principled ways of accounting for station movement.
- jtbayly 8y agoSo the answer appear to be that, yes, he can sucker an awful lot of people.
- martinpw 8y ago55km is not insignificant though. Some very rough estimates - 55km is 0.5% of the distance from the equator to the pole. If the temperature range between those two extremes is 50C then the shift corresponds to a net cooling of 0.25C, which seems like it would have a noticable impact on those graphs. Obviously there is more to it than that, but I don't think it makes it a non-issue.
- prolikewh0a 8y ago>Are weather stations that contribute to NOAA operated by the volunteer public, kind of like Weather Underground? This would provide extremely poor data. A lot of people on Wunderground are running ~$100 Chinese weather stations that don't have proper radiation shielding, dubious barometers, and poor anemometers. While they're perfectly fine for hobbyists and accurate to some degree, a volunteer network for climate data would give non-scientific results.
- avip 8y agoTbh that location graph is meaningless.
- bjourne 8y agoWe really need to do something now! The summer has been un-fucking-believably hot. Climate change is not something that will happen in the "future" -- we have to avoid a global ecosystem collapse in the next 10-15 years. :(
- splintercell 8y agoI know the Pascal's wager argument for action on Climate change (which is that if there is even 1% chance of climate change being real then why not act on it since the downside of acting is nothing <to one political ideology>), but the question is, what if climate change is NOT man-made? If there is even 1% chance that climate change is a naturally occurring phenomenon then all our efforts to 'stop' greenhouse gas emissions is not going to give the results we want. Maybe building levies and moving cities inland be a better action plan? Maybe faster economic growth is a better solution than subsidized solar and wind. I am trying to figure our arguments against the above argument.
- saudioger 8y agoEven IF it were occurring naturally the downside of curbing our contribution is that everything we do is significantly cleaner and we aren't precipitating the problem. That's one of my biggest annoyance with deniers — worst case scenario is that we're doing something good for no reason.
- dagss 8y agoArgument against is simple: Mitigating effects climate change as you suggest will be extremely expensive. (Protecting cities from rising sea levels is really the least of problems...) If we can do something much cheaper (prevent climate change) and there is a 99% chance of it working then of course you should; probibalistically... Yet despite what the math says, the path the world is on is obviously to do nothing. The efforts done now to stop man-made global warming is a rounding error.... The Paris agreement is short of what is needed, and no country is close to fullfilling the Paris agreement. So our children have to pay for the enormously more expensive mitigation instead.
- freedomben 8y agoHonest question: Why such vitriol against "climate deniers?" The term "climate denier" is loading with negative connotation just on it's face, and it's rarely used in isolation in an otherwise respectful way. There will always be people that disagree with you about something. Some are honest, some are not. Why be an asshole and treat people poorly and disrespectfully? That makes you as bad or worse than them IMHO. Even when they are being assholes (which many are), it is an act of immaturity to lower yourself to that level. How do you expect to win over hearts and minds when you approach people like that? The worst thing you can do when trying to convince someone of your opinion is offend them by stereotyping, generalizing, and straw-manning their position. How do you feel when people do this to you? Do you find yourself intellectually engaging with them, thinking that they might have some good points?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- IlGrigiore 8y agoSince you do not like the term "climate deniers", what's your proposal for an appropriate and respectful term or definition to aggregate the people that believe that climate change is not happening?
- freedomben 8y agoThat's a decent point. I do find it unfortunate that the term has become polarized because it is a convenient and descriptive categorical term. I don't have any better solutions, other than maybe something more specific that tries to understand the position of the person rather than sticking them in a large group identity with which they likely don't conform to entirely. I generally like to ask people how they identify themselves, and then call them that. If they identify as climate deniers, then the term is completely fine. We find it terribly rude to label somebody with pronouns like "he" or "she" when they prefer something else. I don't see this as much different.
- leppr 8y ago
- bmmayer1 8y ago"If you torture the data long enough, it will confess" - Ronald Coase
- Ivoirians 8y agoIt's despicable, isn't it? Like, there are climate change deniers that are overly-skeptical or gullible and buy into the mountains of misinformation. And then there are those like Steve Goddard who sit down every day and work their asses off creating said misinformation (check his twitter). Actively manipulating and cherrypicking data to deceive for personal gain (whether it be paychecks, political favor, whatever). And they're winning, considering only half of Republicans believe climate change is even happening, let alone that it's manmade. This was probably the stupidest possible problem for the American political machine to make a wedge issue.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> This was probably the stupidest possible problem for the American political machine to make a wedge issue Read it as an issue that unites middle American industrialists and rural anti-elitists and the politics make sense.
- briandear 8y agoA fair question: has the climate alarmist side not cherry picked or even used fraudulent data to suit their cause as well? https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2010/feb/01/leaked-emails-climate-jones-chinese https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2010/feb/01/leaked-e... Our skepticism isn’t about the climate changing, (remember when it was called global warming?) it’s a skepticism about the causes and the degree to which human influence plays a significant role. Any time there is any skepticism at all, we get labeled “deniers” or otherwise ostracized. That’s pretty unique in science, usually skepticism is considered a healthy part of the scientific process — unless it’s concerning a topic that has substantial political implications. Given that a large segment of the climate change advocacy also “coincidentally” support far left economic policies as a “remedy,” how can it be a surprise that people like me have a deep skepticism of the whole human-caused global warming debate. Another time we had “settled science” with so much politicization was when Eugenics was being advocated. http://www.michaelcrichton.com/why-politicized-science-is-dangerous/ http://www.michaelcrichton.com/why-politicized-science-is-da... I’ll predict the inevitable downvotes, which really only proves the point: debating human causes of climate change is akin to debating the existence of Jesus Christ.
- ethagknight 8y agoMeta question: am I being suckered by his presentation of an unsuckered baseline? What about 1850? 1800? 1200?
- appleiigs 8y agoThe article says his available data starts at 1895. However, the point of the article is to reverse engineer a biased chart, and to show it's biased intentions. The article does not try to determine whether climate change is real or not (even though the author's opinion is obvious). So it doesn't matter if the author's data is limited... it matters that the author of the biased chart has been cherry picked.
- cool_look 8y agoI think this is a bit straw-manny. Tony Heller had been trying to show that by slicing data like climate alarmists do it is even possible to show a decline in temperatures. Although I don’t know much about the guy my guess is like most people it is clear some warming occurred, but the continuation and causes are in dispute.
- patrickg_zill 8y agoThe first thing that jumps out at me, actually, is the use of a shorter time period than is likely available. From 1900 or 1920 to now is a pretty short time period. We have (some) records dating back to the mid-1700s: https://www.archives.gov/research/guide-fed-records/groups/027.html https://www.archives.gov/research/guide-fed-records/groups/0...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- cfuen71 8y agoAnd they are trying to convince me using charts with a truncated y axis? How about doing it with charts that are not misleading?
- martinpw 8y agoWhat would you propose for a zero value on the Y axis? The only number that actually makes sense is zero Kelvin (since 0C and 0F are just arbitrary numbers). At that scale you will not see anything. But that doesn't mean nothing is happening. The charts are fine.
- cfuen71 8y agoAt a 0-100 Celsius scale, or whatever is the equivalent in Fahrenheit, there will be an almost impossible to see increase over the time span of 100 years. I'm not saying nothing is happening, but those charts are completely deceiving.
- kisstheblade 8y agoHow would you chart your body temperature? Starting with 0 kelvin? Then you could conclude that all is well because you can't spot a 2 degree increase, right?
- cfuen71 8y agoIf there's a 2 degree (or a 2 kilos) increase in my body over my entire life (which is similar to these 100 years) I wouldn't care.
- Grue3 8y ago>At that scale you will not see anything. But that doesn't mean nothing is happening. But then you can't say such things like "red line is rising scary fast", which is another example of manipulative language. With enough Y-axis magnification you can make anything rising or dropping "scary fast".
- wolco 8y agoWhat worries me more than climate change is the radioactive waste being pumped into the ocean daily for 6 years and no one is talking about it.
- nkurz 8y agoThere’s a graph going around the internet from Steve Goddard a.k.a. Tony Heller, claiming to show that temperature in the U.S. has been declining, using only high temperatures, using only summertime temperatures, using only data since 1918, based on a simple average without taking into account new stations coming online or old stations retiring or area-weighting or any of that “expert” stuff I like that this piece makes clear how conscious choices of which data to present (and which not to present) can make an argument more convincing without actually lying. I don't like that it makes accusations about a particular person doing so without the courtesy of linking to the person being accused. If your argument is strong, it's usually better to let the reader judge for themselves whether your accusation is accurate. Failing to do so can undermine an otherwise strong argument. I'm not familiar with Goddard/Heller. Searching for Tony Heller, I find https://realclimatescience.com https://realclimatescience.com. It includes a lot of graphs very similar to the ones Tamino dissects. The ones I saw were going day by day, looking at average temperatures for that day over the last 100 years. It's good to know that the start date might have been cherry picked to make the graph look better, and that this is based on raw unadjusted data, but it doesn't seem inherently unfair to use a particular day rather than the average for the entire year. Is there a better "smoking gun" where he makes the more grandiose claims that Tamino accuses him of doing? Maybe, but without a direct link I wasn't able to find it. And in the absence of better evidence, as long as the graph is clearly labelled "Summer Average Maximum Temperature", I have to say that it seems unlikely that he's actually guilty of "claiming to show that temperature in the U.S. has been declining", and more likely that he is making the more direct claim that summer highs have not been increasing. Which given recent newspaper headlines, I do find to be an interesting counterpoint. Searching for Steven Goddard, I find this: https://stevengoddard.wordpress.com/who-is-steven-goddard/ https://stevengoddard.wordpress.com/who-is-steven-goddard/. I like that he clearly links his pen name to his real identity, and makes clear his scientific and environmental background, and admits that he is not actually a climate scientist. Does "Tamino" have a similar page? Who is he, and what is his background? It felt odd for one pseudonymous author to be calling attention to the fact that someone else was using a pseudonym. At this point, based on a tiny amount of research, I feel a little more comfortable with Heller/Goddard than with Tamino.
- bibixii929 8y ago
- m3mpp 8y agoLook at the temperature chart for the last 10,000 years, the greenland core ice temperature, GISP2 for example, and you'll see a completely different picture. Everything looks extreme when looked at a very small scale...
- m3mpp 8y agohttps://www.heritagedaily.com/2018/07/doggerland-europes-lost-land/117925 https://www.heritagedaily.com/2018/07/doggerland-europes-los... Doggerland was submerged 5,000 BC because of water rising due to the ice cap melting...
- systoll 8y agohttp://hot-topic.co.nz/wp-content/uploads/2011/01/GISP210klarge.png http://hot-topic.co.nz/wp-content/uploads/2011/01/GISP210kla... Here’s the GISP2 data, plus samples from the past two centuries. Still seems pretty extreme to me.
- m3mpp 8y agoI think this one shows it even better: http://hot-topic.co.nz/wp-content/uploads/2011/01/GRIPtempBoxlarge.png http://hot-topic.co.nz/wp-content/uploads/2011/01/GRIPtempBo... And yes, there's a fast climb, but it's not the only instance in history, look at 800AD, 200AD, and a lot more in the past, it seems to be the way the temp fluctuates, very sharply. If we get back to the 10,000 years chart, do the last 150 years seems off the chart? If anything, it shows that we're cooler than the last 10,000 years.
- systoll 8y agoA graph that starts at 1840 doesn't show the past 10 000 years at all -- in the long view, that's all just a bunch of noise. What happened to the 'completely different picture' that the 10 000 year view held? Here's the 10 000 same graph with some colours https://i.imgur.com/GWhaGCU.png https://i.imgur.com/GWhaGCU.png Blue periods were colder than 2009. Yellow periods were warmer. The past 10 000 years were mostly colder than 2009, and we've only gotten warmer since then. And... precedent isn't the main issue here. Those large bumps have causes. This time, the cause is us. It's up to us [collectively] whether we want this. Maybe the Roman Period's ~-29.75C represents a better climate for humanity than the 1855 levels. That's right around that '2 degree limit' people talk about. If that's a target, it's about time to transition out of making 'as much CO2 possible as fast as possible'.
- mnm1 8y agoThe problem is that the kind of people that would be convinced by proper graphs and analysis like this are not the kind of people that need convincing on this issue. They are not the type of people who value science, logic, or reason. No matter the evidence, they will place beliefs and unsubstantiated opinions ahead of evidence and in places like the US, where people are often taught that beliefs are equally or more important than evidence and facts, you get a culture of anti-intellectualism that supports policies that hurt the entirety of humanity. We should remind people that beliefs are just opinions and as the old adage goes, opinions are like assholes: everyone's got one and they're not particularly interesting or compelling. They certainly should not be the basis of policy.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]