7 ms·
Bethesda blocks resale of used game
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoWow, this seems to be taking a piss all over the first sale doctrine if this article is not somehow playing fast and loose with the facts. Seems like an open and shut case for somebody like the EFF to take on, with some great press for themselves in the process. Feels like there has to be some piece of the story missing here.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- throwaway080383 8y agoFrom the article: Bethesda’s letter claims that Hupp’s sale is not protected by the First Sale Doctrine, because he is not selling the game in its original form, which would include a warranty. The letter says this lack of warranty renders the game “materially different from genuine products” that are sold through official channels. IANAL, but it seems to me that if this argument goes through, it would render first sale doctrine useless, as you could tack on a warranty to just about any old product.
- throwaway13337 8y agoThis is a common legal refrain when trying to get around the first sale doctrine. I've received letters from lawyers about the re-sale of physical products being illegal because of the lack of the original warranty. It didn't seem to have teeth at the time but it sure scared me.
- ams6110 8y agoWarranties for software are notoriously narrowly scoped. Not warranted for any particular use or fitness for any purpose, etc. About all they will warrant is that the media itself works and offer to replace it if it doesn't. So just warrant that what you are selling is what it claims to be and offer a refund or replacement if it isn't. That seems to be materially the same as what the original seller provides.
- trophycase 8y agoWho the hell are the lawyers who are making these cases. These people need to be held accountable for slowly making things worse.
- ikeboy 8y agoThis is common, I've had multiple claims of this nature myself, including from Vorys. But bringing a lawsuit is expensive. Here's somebody suing over similar claims from tp-link https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/6846972/starke-v-tp-link-usa-corporation/ https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/6846972/starke-v-tp-lin... I've dealt with tp-link myself and they are extremely abusive, they ignored anything I sent them including a letter from a lawyer, and filed dozens of false complaints against me. I hope they lose that case and have to pay a large judgement.
- ikeboy 8y agoThere's an organization trying to fight back against these kinds of abusive companies. See https://aftaus.com/afta-goes-to-dc-guest-blog-post-by-afta-internet-seller-matt-colvin/ https://aftaus.com/afta-goes-to-dc-guest-blog-post-by-afta-i... and http://mattcolvin.com/fighting-back-against-bogus-claims-with-afta/ http://mattcolvin.com/fighting-back-against-bogus-claims-wit... I'm sure they'd accept help from the EFF if it was offered.
- stephengillie 8y ago> Bethesda recently sent out a notice to at least one seller on Amazon’s Marketplace who was trying to sell a sealed copy of The Evil Within 2, demanding that they remove their listing. This could be an attempt by Bethesda to rein-in what they see as "counterfeit" products, since Amazon is largely unwilling to police their own Marketplace. Though the article states "Bethesda is a notoriously litigious company", and have a heavy-handed history.
- jjeaff 8y agoThey could actually be charged with perjury if they are using the DMCA to take down listings that they have no proof are counterfeit and turn out not to be. Though I am not sure if DMCA applies in this case.
- Covzire 8y agoAfter their apparent pivot to becoming an MMO company, I don't expect many more good games out of Bethesda anyway.
- shrimp_emoji 8y agoI expect Fallout 76 to be a Day Z-ish shell of a proper Fallout title, but I'm excited about ES6! Inb4 voiced main character, forcing smaller range of dialogue and story options and limiting roleplayability, and those five voice actors behind every NPC, etc. etc. :3 Cinematicness!
- benjaminjackman 8y agoHas anything been announced in the ES6 front?
- ovao 8y agoJust a teaser trailer with some presumably pre-rendered land flyby. Really just an announcement that it’s in the works, and that it features...land.
- falcolas 8y agoI think it's worth considering if we should support a company who carries out these kinds of intimidation tactics against its player and fan base. I get it, their games are good - perhaps even one-of-a-kind - but much like Uber and Riot, perhaps even with their great service they aren't worth supporting. Just an observation.
- 15charlimit 8y agoFor quite a while now, their games have only been made "good" after significant time and effort by the modding community to fix common game-breaking and progress-losing bugs, along with endless quality of life improvements and the fixing of console-port-related issues. "Vanilla" Bethesda games are pretty bad by reasonable standards, particularly on and shortly after launch.
- classichasclass 8y agoIf this expansion gets to and is upheld by the courts, it makes me wonder about DVDs and Blu-rays people sell with either now expired or previously used digital codes and whether this would be subject to the same "material difference."
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoNothing to do with them then, it's not their product you're reselling as it's "materially different" - oh right, so for copyright purposes it's an exact copy, but for any natural rights the consumer should have it's a different product. This sort of evil should be stamped on hard by government.
- lisper 8y agoYou mean the same government that is currently controlled by corporations and doing everything it can to maximize corporate profits? Yeah, good luck with that.
- beerlord 8y agoCan Blu-Rays be manufactured to make each disc unique, with an embedded code that is used to link a license of the game to an account? Then the publisher could simply decide to disallow games from being activated on another account. Or, bundle a CDKey inside the case, but I think this exposes significant fraud risk if a rogue employee cracks open hundreds of cases from a shipment, sells the keys online, then reseals them.
- morganvachon 8y agoCombine your first idea with your second and you may be on to something. A uniquely encoded disc that must pair with the printed CD key in the case. Kind of a public/private key thing, I guess? Crypto isn't my area of expertise so I have no idea if that is feasible.
- dfox 8y agoThis is how some 90's CD copy protection systems worked. The CD-key was essentially hash of encoding defects on that particular CD.
- morganvachon 8y agoWow, and that makes perfect sense too.
- LeoPanthera 8y agoI believe this was how the XBox One was originally going to work, but the outcry was so loud that Microsoft had to backtrack before the console was launched. A particular criticism was that you would not be able to play any games without internet access, which would have made it useless for many people, including for example some military personnel deployed overseas.
- beerlord 8y agoIts just a matter of time before that happens. How many gamers who aren't on a plane, in a train or in a base in Fallujah don't have constant broadband access? I think those instances are being reduced yearly all around the world. The next generation of consoles will have a low-end version that hosts some of the calculations locally, such as input and collision detection, but all of the detailed rendering etc. on the cloud. All games will be inherently 'online only', distribution of optical disks will become pointless and everything will be linked to an account - no resale.
- rpdillon 8y agoThis is an interesting legal move: using a warranty to claim that a resold good is 'materially different' from an original, and therefore is not subject to first sale doctrine. If it held up in court, it seems extremely dangerous for consumer rights.
- greenyoda 8y agoHow is that different from selling a used car that's no longer under warranty? If this ever gets litigated, is a court likely to make a decision that undermines the U.S. used car market? Or is the company hoping that it can intimidate sellers into backing down without ever having to go to court? I suppose that it would be stupid for car manufacturers to attempt to put restrictions on resale, since that would significantly reduce the value of a car. But the same thing could happen to games: if someone knows that they can't resell a game if they get tired of playing it, they'd be somewhat less likely to buy it in the first place (or not be willing to spend as much for it).
- seanalltogether 8y agoThe arguments only apply to the sale of copyrighted material, not general goods.
- ikeboy 8y agoWarranty is used to get around first sale rights for trademarks, not copyrights. The argument is the trademark can no longer be used if the goods are "materially different", such as by not having a warranty.
- sandworm101 8y agoWont stand up in court. This is about trademarks ... ie "Ford" or "BMW". Such a ruling would kill the entire used car industry. Not going to happen anytime soon.
- jrhurst 8y agoIf I was a business re-sell games. I'd definitely wouldn't try to settle. I'd want it on record if my business model was legal or not in court
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoDid they notify consumers that they were bundling a warranty, sounds like all the purchasers should be due a partial refund and any people with damaged discs should get replacements, under their warranty.
- CocaKoala 8y agohttps://help.bethesda.net/app/answers/list/search/1/kw/warranty/dym/1/p/886 https://help.bethesda.net/app/answers/list/search/1/kw/warra... There's no mention of a warranty on the Evil Within 2 support page https://bethesda.net/en/search?q=warranty https://bethesda.net/en/search?q=warranty And no mention of a warranty on their main website either. The amazon store page says that for warranty information, you can contact the seller (which would be amazon, and presumably amazon's warranty) or that more information may be available on the manufacturer's website (and the above links demonstrate that it isn't). So yeah, my question is "Does anybody know about the warranty, and if not, how is a warranty that you don't know about materially different from not having one?"
- ikeboy 8y agoVorys is corrupt. I've received threatening letters from them as well, that came to my physical address despite it not being listed anywhere on my Amazon store. It also contained false assertions (I'd bought the goods in question from an authorized distributor that confirmed to me that the letter was simply lying). I know multiple other sellers that also had this issue. It is my belief that Vorys is illegally paying Amazon insiders to get contact information for sellers, as there is no legitimate path to get that information that does not involve a subpoena to Amazon, which would involve an active lawsuit. Unfortunately, this is hard to prove.
- ikeboy 8y agoIn general, companies can be extremely abusive if they don't want their stuff being sold online. I know multiple people who have bought directly from companies, and later had the company claim to Amazon that they were infringing IP. The listing goes down, sometimes the entire account as well, till you send in invoices and convince Amazon to accept them and reinstate the listing, which takes time.
- close04 8y agoI wonder if this is more of a Bethesda initiative or a law firm initiative. Is Bethesda aware that bad PR these days can cripple your launches? Are they really risking an increase in "revenge piracy" or loss of sales just for a marginal reduction in "losses" from these Amazon sellers? People who buy used games don't want to pay the new price, and they won't. One way or another they'll get it for the discounted price. It's best if you don't alienate your customers for something that will bring no palpable benefit.
- ikeboy 8y agoIt's the law firm. They go out and pitch brands on using this to control distribution. See https://markettrack.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/Vorys-and-Market-Track-Unauthorized-Reseller-Webinar-Slides-81116.pdf https://markettrack.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/Vorys-and..., which pitches brands on creating bogus "warranties" so they then have a flimsy legal basis to threaten sellers with. Most sellers, even businesses, will fold out of fear and want to avoid a lawsuit, so these claims aren't often tested in court. Also, to be fair, this case was someone selling as new. The game was sealed, but it does cut down on their own sales. I know people who'll go to e.g. bestbuy, buy games using launch discounts or clearance, etc, then sell on Amazon. Perfectly legitimate business model in my view.
- bitwize 8y agoSoftware is licensed, not sold. Generally speaking if the license indicates it's nontransferable (which it almost always does), the software is not subject to first-sale doctrine and is illegal to sell.
- roywiggins 8y agoNot unless the copyright holder can produce documents proving it was a licensing and not a sale: https://www.finnegan.com/en/insights/copyright-infringement-case-is-blocked-by-first-sale-defense.html https://www.finnegan.com/en/insights/copyright-infringement-... If I just buy a copy of a game from a physical store and I don't sign a licensing agreement, it's hard to see how that would pass the test here- he never even opened the jewel case.
- digi_owl 8y agoWas gifted Fallout 4, and what was in the case was one DVD. Upon install, that required a Steam account, it would pull down 2x or more that of the content of the DVD to make the game playable. And then i had to go mod hunting basically on day one, because they had implemented a non-optional head bopping on the first person camera...