16 ms·
We Wanted Safer Banks, We Got More Inequality
- skybrian 8y agoSeems like the second idea (interest rates should be higher) contradicts the first (it should be easier for banks to make loans to small business). Higher interest rates would tend to discourage loans. Edit: I guess the idea is to increase supply and reduce demand?
- CamTin 8y agoIt would discourage people from taking loans, but why would it discourage banks from making them? In fact, higher interest rates would mean that the cost of liquid capital, a bank's main equipment for making money, were suddenly more productive, right?
- archbung 8y agoWouldn't it be pointless to make something that nobody buy?
- r00fus 8y agoClearly high interest rates in the 80s didn't prevent banks from making loans. Lets talk about the inverse of of what you're suggesting - perhaps the lack of ROI on loans is preventing banks from doing what they're supposed to be doing - lending to small businesses.
- JamesBarney 8y agoHow does a low interest rate prevent a bank from making a loan to a small business? A low interest rate is not a federally mandated cap on interest it is an increase in supply which drives down the cost. Which should increase ROI.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- a_d 8y agoWhat you say may be true for almost all the products, unless when the product is 'money' itself. Something worth considering. Easy access to low-cost loans creates the illusion of affordability and exacerbates over-consumption (over-consumption: a general malady afflicting most humans)
- skybrian 8y agoBut the article is arguing the opposite of over-consumption, that there are not enough loans to small business.
- JamesBarney 8y agoBecause the way the fed increases interest rates is by selling a bunch of bonds. Which incentivizes people to moves money from the private economy to the Fed, and which leaves less money available to lend to small businesses. >In fact, higher interest rates would mean that the cost of liquid capital, a bank's main equipment for making money, were suddenly more productive, right? Banks basically just borrow money at x then lend it out at x+y. With y being expenses, defaults, and profits. Now if x grows that doesn't grow y, if anything it shrinks it because there are less individuals looking for a loan at the increases price. Basically if banks were toy makers, the interest rate would.be the price of plastic. Sure if the price of plastic went up toy makers would charge more for toys. But they wouldn't be making more money, if anything they'd me making less.
- sbinthree 8y agoIt doesn't discourage loans. Fast growing small companies are one of the only constituents who can justify higher interest rates. Now giant companies and individuals going on vacation get cheap credit but small businesses mostly can't get any.
- skybrian 8y agoThis seems odd, because it seems like if a business is willing to pay a bit more when interest rates are low, it would mean more profit for the bank willing to take the other side of the deal.
- sbinthree 8y agoYes, the spread would be better, but banks don't do it unless you have several years of high cash flow and positive on-paper income. Even if the owner is deliberately trying to offload the income into another corporation, they can't figure it out and say the income statement looks bad. Banks don't even understand small businesses at this point.
- WalterBright 8y ago> predatory lending I've often wondered just what people are talking about when they use that term.
- bboreham 8y agoI think it refers to advertising that your loan is fabulous and easy to get, to people who would be much better off not taking your loan, and who are not sophisticated enough to realise this.
- jeffreyrogers 8y agoLending to people who will likely default, often by misleading them about the terms of the mortgage. You could also look at it from the other end and say that the people receiving the loans are predatory borrowers: people who can't afford to own the home they want but are taking advantage of lax lending standards to get one.
- mannykannot 8y agoSetting oneself up to be prey is not generally considered predatory - though faking it, as anglerfish do, is.
- jeffreyrogers 8y agoIn this case they are preying on the lenders, who don't really care because they are passing off the risk to someone else.
- mannykannot 8y agoThe issue is really who gets eaten. While the lender, or whoever ends up holding the loan, might get burned, it is very unusual for the borrower of a predatory loan to end up better off for it.
- WalterBright 8y ago
- core-questions 8y ago> What I am saying is that now some lenders — banks — are under rules so tough they can’t support equality-enhancing mortgages What is an equality-enhancing mortgage? My guess is that it's akin to an equal opportunity / affirmative action campaign. The thing is, actuarial tables aren't oppressive - they're merely reflective of reality. If a particular group presents a higher risk profile than another, the only sane course of action is to be more restrictive when lending to members of that group. The alternative is for banks to give out easy money again like in the leadup to 2008 and that didn't work out well. I'm sorry that some people can't get mortgages but the answer is not to aggregate out their financial problems onto those of us who do, in fact, pay our bills.
- gammateam 8y agoEquality-enhancing mortgages WERE subprime mortgages. Congress pushed the banks into doing them in the early 2000s to extend credit to marginalized populations! oh man, here we go again! I wonder if Y Combinator will fund my Collateralized Equality Enhanced Swap
- cuckcuckspruce 8y agoOne of the issues here is affordable housing. If the cost of housing were accessible to the common person without a loan then there would be no need to push the banks to extend who they loan to. It's one of the criticisms of the Affordable Care Act - it's really the Mandated Insurance Act. If the cost of healthcare were such that insurance was not needed for people to access it then there would be no need to mandate that people have insurance.
- piker 8y ago> Congress pushed the banks into doing them in the early 2000s to extend credit to marginalized populations! ...but didn't push banks to lever the loans 10x, securitize, sell and repeat over and over again. Fault for those days lied in a lot of places, and sub-prime mortgages aren't inherently a bad thing.
- 8y ago
- raintrees 8y agoI think "whack-a-mole" might best describe the proclivity for regulation to fix unintended side-effects of previous regulation, causing more unintended side-effects. Or maybe "the cure is worse than the disease?" Being on a very small governmental body, I witnessed first-hand the tendency to want to "do something" when confronted with a potential problem - And it did come to pass several times that we enacted policy that later seemed to have made the original situation worse or caused another flare-up in issues that had not existed before. My experience is it can be very difficult to enact good public policy... And frequently an efficient (unfettered) capitalist market will come up with a solution more elegant than what we could contemplate. I am left thinking this is a basic truism...
- petermcneeley 8y agoYes and this simple model worked quite well up until the great depression. "But this long run is a misleading guide to current affairs. In the long run we are all dead. Economists set themselves too easy, too useless a task, if in tempestuous seasons they can only tell us, that when the storm is long past, the ocean is flat again" - Keynes
- s73v3r_ 8y agoNo, the capitalist market will come up with a solution that is most profitable for business. Occasionally that will line up with what's better for everyone else, but not often.
- orthecreedence 8y agoEven worse, from what I've seen in my lifetime, markets are very reactionary. How often/well do markets predict 50 years into the future? For instance a good long-term solution for climate change might be the movement to renewable energy. A market solution to climate change might be opening condos on Antarctica.
- JamesBarney 8y agoThere are some policies that have lots of unintended consequences. But increased capital requirements is a pretty simple one that we understand. We knew there'd be less lending. That was kind of the point of increased capital requirements.
- ncr100 8y agoReading the analysis of unintended side-effects reminds me of programming, and contemplating how my system might fail.
- calyth2018 8y agoIf you're looking at banking regulation for causes for inequality, you're looking at the wrong place. The article pointed out the gulf widened at the 1980s. That should be more than enough hints as to how to fix it. There's no political will though.
- swagasaurus-rex 8y agoI'm not sharp enough to take the hint. What is the proper way to fix it?
- Frondo 8y agoUnions.
- prolikewh0a 8y agoUnions [1]. [1] https://www.epi.org/news/union-membership-declines-inequality-rises/ https://www.epi.org/news/union-membership-declines-inequalit...
- calyth2018 8y agoLabour losing their power is one of them. Trickle down "economics", slashing the income tax of the top bracket drastically would be another one.
- hippich 8y agowhat happened in 1980s?
- ddebernardy 8y agoNeoliberalism and supply side economics got tried out in the UK (Thatcher) and the US (Reagan).
- splintercell 8y agoThe political party I don't like got elected and remained in power.
- Someguywhatever 8y agoWhy can't people just improve their credit rating by doing credit worthy things?
- xutopia 8y agoIt is really hard for some people to get out of poverty. I recommend you read this article from a few days ago posted her on Hacker News: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17230047 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17230047
- howard941 8y agoI'm inclined to see this as correlation, not causation. Where is the powerful coupling between <10 years of tighter bank lending standards and income inequality?
- WhompingWindows 8y agoHow would bank lending standards affect income, wouldn't it be much more likely to affect wealth?
- igravious 8y ago“KP: I’m not blaming the banks. I’m blaming the unintended consequences of the rules. I think the rules unduly penalize equality-enhancing financial services.” (1) Bankers (rich people) lobby to have Glass–Steagall taken out back and shot in the head. (2) Banks go nuts with financial wizardry leading to a housing bubble. (3) Bubble bursts which ends up ruining the lives of millions, mostly lower and middle class folk. Nation enters into the worst recession since the Great One. (4) Banks are bailed out with taxpayer money because banks have somehow become "too big to fail". (5) Some regulations placed belatedly and half-heartedly on banks because of (1-4) (6) Hardly anyone rich loses their shirt and hardly anyone is locked up† and some make out like bandits. (7) Wall Street salaries and bonuses through the roof. (8) Gov Regulations (along with Fed quantitative easing – the Fed is kind of a collection of banks, no?) exacerbate income and wealth inequality. Where did the Secretary of the Treasury at the time of the crisis, Hank Paulson, work beforehand?‡ (9) Banking policy "expert" Karen Petrou says “I’m not blaming the banks” (0) In the words of Ace Ventura, “Allllrighty then!” † https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2017-07-26/why-no-one-went-to-jail-in-the-financial-crisis https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2017-07-26/why-no-on... ‡ “Before becoming Treasury Secretary, he was required to liquidate all of his stock holdings in Goldman Sachs, valued at over $600 million in 2006, in order to comply with conflict-of-interest regulations. Because of a tax provision passed under President George H.W. Bush, Paulson was not subject to capital gains tax. This saved him between $36 and $50 million in taxes.”
- JamesBarney 8y agoYou'll have to explain 8. From first principles it makes sense that reducing the price of capital would help workers, and hurt capital owners. And all the research I've seen backs up this intuition and show that a loose monetary policy helps inequality.
- pjmorris 8y agoQE 'printed' roughly 3 Trillion dollars out of nothing, including at least 1.7T that went to buying Mortgage Backed Securities from banks whose original mortgage borrowers were never going to be able to pay off those mortgages. That had the effect of raising house prices for everyone, while turning debts of many that were never going to be repaid into the profits for the banks who aggregated these bad loans. Yves Smith over at the Naked Capitalism blog has called it 'the greatest upward transfer of wealth in history.'
- mkirklions 8y agoExpecting downvotes, but looking for ideas- Serious question, what is the issue with inequality when low income people are overweight and have iphones? This is obviously a simplification, but in 1 sentence I think I got my point across. Standard of living is undisputed the best in human history, not even some 1960s era fantasy has overweight humans. This has nothing to do with 'unhealthy' food, this is abundance. So back to the serious question, what makes inequality bad? Some ideas >Political inequality >multi-generational oppression(which doesnt line up with the whole "First generation makes it. 2nd generation maintains it, 3rd generation blows it") I'm trying to understand the issue with inequality when everyone is living a fantastic by organic life standards.
- kartan 8y ago> Serious question, what is the issue with inequality when low income people are overweight and have iphones? People is overweight because they can not afford healthy food. Fruits and other healthier food is more expensive than junk food. Poor people does not have iPhones. They have cheap Android devices that they need to work, keep in contact with family, etc. > Standard of living is undisputed the best in human history In the USA you can see a difference of life expectancy based on their economically status. So, people is dying earlier and this can be avoided. > I'm trying to understand the issue with inequality when everyone is living a fantastic by organic life standards. So this is the end of all progress? We are good now, lets stop improving health care, education, etc.? Let people die at 70 even when they could have a more healthy live to be 80? Let a cancer patient die because "on average" society is better and his suffering is just statistics? Your argument is based in the misconception that things can not improve anymore. That people does not deserve better that what they have now. You will probably get support in the Amish community, for example. But most of the world moved past that point.
- mkirklions 8y ago>People is overweight because they can not afford healthy food. Fruits and other healthier food is more expensive than junk food. This is wrong. I study food as my expertise, and junk food is always less than 200 calories per dollar. Fresh fruit is similar while home cooked food is a significantly better value. I wont address the other points until you revise this one. Its factually incorrect. Google Calories Per Dollar or Nutrient Per Dollar, or Mcdonalds Calories Per Dollar. The data exists and you need to get up to speed.
- cs702 8y agoThe main claim is from a financial industry consultant quoted in the article: "As the country becomes more unequal, there are fewer middle class customers. That means middle class bank products become unprofitable, and banks follow the money. And banking regulations make it worse because the capital requirements imposed after the banking crisis make it a lot more expensive for banks to do a startup small-business loan than go into wealth management. Startup loans are riskier than wealth management, of course, but the capital costs have become prohibitive, and banks don’t lose money on purpose." Wait, what? I doubt this is the main or even a top-three cause of income and wealth inequality in the US. Other factors strike me as potentially far more important causes of inequality, including increasing automation of labor, winner-take-all markets, concentration of corporate and market power, minimal antitrust regulation... to name a few. The banking industry wants fewer regulations and lower capital requirements, as usual. This seems to be its latest rationalization for them.
- solatic 8y agoOne of the biggest contributors to income inequality is a lack of economic mobility. Maybe that sounds like a tautology - the difference between rich and poor solidifies the more difficult that it becomes for poor people to turn into rich people. To oversimplify, easy access to capital can allow a poor person to turn a great idea that solves real problems and a strong work ethic into a sustainable business that pulls him out into the middle class or higher. Without access to capital, the poor man is beholden to whichever employers are in his area, and whatever is on offer from them - odds are, it won't be enough to allow the poor man to send his children to private school.
- btown 8y agoTo elaborate, easy access to capital is what allows those employers in his area to actually hire him. That profitable restaurant down the road, owned not by a Wall Street mogul but by a passionate middle-class entrepreneur, needs capital to renovate a second dining room, and if it doesn't get it, it's not going to be able to hire servers for that new capacity. It's going to stagnate, maybe remain a profitable small restaurant, but never have a chance to become a multi-location or multi-state job-creation engine. And this is where the "middle class bank products" come in. Anything that artificially discourages banks from making the purely-economic decision to finance that owner to expand the business - and there's always the tantalizing option to just cater to silver-plattered large-business loans and wealthy clients instead - is going to slow growth and make general inequality in the area that much worse. There's a shrinking middle class of businesses just as there is of individuals. Now, sure, the economic decision to finance this person should not be based on the idea that you could make subprime loans and repackage them to unwitting buyers. But there are perhaps middle grounds from a regulatory perspective. And there are also opportunities to address non-regulatory aspects that discourage capital sources from lending/investing; my company Belstone builds software to allow lower-middle-market investment bankers, the advocates for medium-sized businesses in the capital markets (who have the same dynamics described above), to close deals on behalf of their clients more efficiently, to support more businesses and more job growth. None of these efforts on its own is a panacea, but we have to try everything we can to move the needle.
- mjevans 8y agoObservation: Housing is not affordable (for any but the rich). Hypothesis: Basic market theory suggests that the need for housing is probably inelastic (everyone needs it, can't do without it), therefore if housing is to become more affordable an increase in supply must happen. Prediction: If additional housing were encouraged (near where jobs are actually located) prices would eventually stabilize at sustainable levels. Prediction 2: non-inflated housing prices will also lower the cost of living in those areas, creating a net benefit for members of society (which are not of the rent-seeking classes). Testing: Please vote according to the above logic. Results: To be determined.
- ThrustVectoring 8y agoOne big problem with this is that people vote their incentives. If you're a homeowner in San Francisco, are you really going to vote to halve the price of your home and immediately put your mortgage underwater? People voting themselves higher house prices through using local zoning laws to create housing shortages is a national crisis. We need something pretty dramatic, like congress using the interstate commerce clause to ensure the free movement of labor via banning states and local municipalities from enacting their own zoning. Or a national land-value tax.
- wpasc 8y agoCould not agree with this more. I live in SF and the difficulty in building new housing is so outrageous. To make the housing prices in SF lower, supply must increase. While it makes sense for voters in a locality to have control/say in the environment around them, the ability of homeowners to control land they do not own and prevent new construction and shift the burden to other districts and public transportation is extremely flawed.
- pmwhite 8y agoThat is the fear, yes, but housing prices do not jump so quickly. They really are not likely to drop, as, perhaps, climb much more slowly. It seems we have achieved a self-reinforcing civic virtue "anti-pattern", where middle class anxiety about high housing prices ends up squeezing the future housing supply. In other words, the negative feedback via anxiety caused by high demand may be greater than the usual positive correcting effect we expect from the "invisible hand", to add supply in the face of high demand. IMHO it is a matter of homeowners acting on incomplete information. Sure, your house price going up seems nice, but it is only a significant benefit if you sell and move elsewhere for your retirement days. Those who actually like where they live and want to set roots have the practical problem of how affordable the place they live is now and when they retire. That is a death by a thousand cuts. Regarding the future, I do hope to make the world a better place through my job. But in the practical world of the now, we need mechanics, teachers, grocers, plumbers, nurses, handymen, construction workers/contractors, waiters, etc. etc. or the SF Bay becomes an expensive hellhole. Having enough people around who keep the community livable requires more affordable housing.
- jewelthief91 8y agoFreedom is a double edge sword. Some people use their freedom to elevate themselves, others are free to fail. In the West we treat an disinclination to handle freedom responsibly as either a moral failing (the right) or reject the possibility that failing to handle freedom can have anything to do with one's character at all and thus inequality must be blamed on external forces (the left). The truth is it is not necessarily a moral failing to handle freedom irresponsibility and handling freedom irresponsibly very likely has a lot to do with someone's personality.
- genericid 8y agoWhat does one's character depend on in your opinion?
- jewelthief91 8y agoGenerally an interaction between nature and nurture.
- genericid 8y agoSo, external factors.
- jwatte 8y agoThe article starts out with a "correlation causes causation" argument, and the unsubstantiated claim that the biggest driver of inequality is banking regulation. Then it implies that business financing matters to the 50-90 percentile of earners. Bullshit detected!