8 ms·
IMF staff made misjudgments in Greece, became cheerleaders for the euro (2016)
- Arnt 8y agoPlease read http://www.ieo-imf.org/ieo/files/completedevaluations/Executive%20Summary%20Print.pdf http://www.ieo-imf.org/ieo/files/completedevaluations/Execut... before you comment. The best of many good sentences IMO: "Lessons from past crises were not always applied, for example when the IMF underestimated the likely negative response of private creditors to a high-risk program".
- raesene9 8y agoI would think this needs a (2016) tag, as it's a couple of years old now.
- abduhl 8y ago"At root was a failure to grasp the elemental point that currency unions with no treasury or political union to back them up are inherently vulnerable to debt crises. States facing a shock no longer have sovereign tools to defend themselves. Devaluation risk is switched into bankruptcy risk. “In a monetary union, the basics of debt dynamics change as countries forgo monetary policy and exchange rate adjustment tools,” said the report. This would be amplified by a “vicious feedback between banks and sovereigns”, each taking the other down. That the IMF failed to anticipate any of this was a serious scientific and professional failure." This is so obvious it boggles the mind how it could be ignored or not seen. Anti Eurozone people have been saying it since the formation of the Eurozone.
- muro 8y agoPeople making the decision had no cost to themselves if they were wrong.
- RobertoG 8y agoIt's deeper than that. The adoption of the Euro without a fiscal capacity at the Euro-area level means that the Euro countries are basically working with a foreign currency. That means that monetary issues are beyond political control. That means beyond democratic control. Some people consider that is a good thing. Another issue is that the Euro is not a bad thing for all the countries in it. Germany, for instance, as a big exporter, get a currency devaluation for free an unencumbered access to a huge market. Interestingly, this success of the German economy have not reflected, for the best, in the quality of life of most of the Germans, but maybe, this is a discussion for other day (even if in my opinion is really the same issue, see first paragraph).
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoGermany made €2.8bn from the Greek debt crisis - so not a bad deal for Germany.
- cinquemb 8y agoThey'll make even more in Frankfurt when holding defaulted PIIGS sovereign debt when the ECB exhausts its capability to be largest marginal counterparty bidder while also trying to target asset price stability…
- matt4077 8y agoThat's like €25 per person. It's basically meaningless. Meanwhile, Germany's annual net contribution to the EU is €220 per person. I'm not pointing this out to complain–the EU is worth far more than that, and seeing the giant improvements these transfers have supported in Eastern Europe, or Ireland, or Portugal makes their usefulness obvious. But suggesting that Germany (and the other countries involved) took on billions and billions in risk hoping to earn what are obviously below-market returns is laughable. Not everything is motivated by money.
- RobertoG 8y agoYou are forgetting that at the start of the Greek crisis, the debt was owned by private banks (mostly German and French), now it's owned by the Europeans. So, basically we saved those banks, make the life of the Greeks worse in the process, and now they owe even more money than before.
- deandm 8y agoThis even feels like it could be a quote from The Shock Doctrine by Naomi Klein. After reading that book it's hard not to start thinking that it was completely intentional.
- beojan 8y ago> Devaluation risk is switched into bankruptcy risk And for the inhabitants, this is a good thing. Look at Venezuela to see what happens when a country devalues its currency to pay its debts. The situation would have been even better (for the Greek people) if the European Union hadn't permitted Greece to introduce capital controls (which negated some of the advantages of a currency not tied to the Greek economy).
- conmarap 8y agoVenezuela has had a long history of high inflation, much like Turkey. The problem is not that, it's that people lost faith in the currency and all the non-circulated (ie savings or foreign reserves) came into circulation again very fast, flooding the market and ultimately causing hyperinflation.
- beojan 8y ago> it's that people lost faith in the currency What do you think happens when you devalue your currency to pay your debts?
- conmarap 8y agoHigh inflation due to government-initiated devaluation has happened even in the US, but it didn't result in a hyperinflation. The Weimar Republic is a good example of a government that got screwed because of this. What makes hyperinflation unique is that the price is ultimately sunk by the actions of panicked citizens who rush to spend their fiat currency because they think that it won't have value in the coming days/weeks/months. This is like a domino effect and eventually everyone jumps on the bandwagon, thus flooding the market with currency that wasn't circulating or contributing to the GDP. Hyperinflation usually comes right after a short-lived deflationary period which, in turn, comes after a very long period of high inflation (10-30% typically). You can clearly see the pattern in Venezuela's inflation chart: https://www.businessinsider.com/venezuela-hyperinflation-chart-2017-4 https://www.businessinsider.com/venezuela-hyperinflation-cha... Because of this $1 equals 206941.00 Venezuelan Bolivar, up from $1=119k Bolivar from a month ago, which in turn was up from $1=10 Bolivar from February (according to Google - not sure how accurate it is).
- brightball 8y agoThere are a lot of things that people warn about that seem like basic economics, yet people ignore them or dismiss them as party politics. Misinformation is easy when people don’t think through what they are hearing.
- timrichard 8y ago> That the IMF failed to anticipate any of this was a serious scientific and professional failure. And maybe there's a consensus that everything is lower priority than ever-closer integration. Great for Commissioners, not so great for Greek pensioners.
- RobertoG 8y ago"At root was a failure to grasp the elemental point that currency unions with no treasury or political union to back them up are inherently vulnerable to debt crises. States facing a shock no longer have sovereign tools to defend themselves. Devaluation risk is switched into bankruptcy risk." This is the fundamental issue. It's not a surprise. It has been explained by many commentators even before the Euro existed (see, for instance: [1]). [1] http://www.bondeconomics.com/2015/07/book-review-eurozone-dystopia.html http://www.bondeconomics.com/2015/07/book-review-eurozone-dy...
- nutjob2 8y agoSeeming ignored in these discussions is that right up to the bailout Greece's problems were entirely self inflicted. When you're unable to take responsibility for or support yourself you suffer the whims of others. That's the real lesson here.
- rsj_hn 8y agoThat's just not the case. When Greece had its own currency, it could devalue against the Deutsche Mark and keep people employed. That devaluation would cause some inflation and it would also raise interest rates a bit -- no debt bubble, no collapse of Greek industry. Rather, German industry finds that it's currency is more expensive to counteract increased Germany productivity and Germany fails to export more, and thus does not accumulate excess savings. There is no flow of jobs from Greece to Germany -- Greece keeps its jobs, Germany keeps its jobs, Greece is forced to consume a bit less with the lower Drachma relative to Germany, and Greece is forced to borrow a bit less with the higher interest rates. With a forced peg against the DM, money was just being vacuumed out of Greece, which created a recycling problem in which excess German savings could be used to purchase Greek bonds. That lowers the interest rate in Greece artificially, creating more debt in Greece even while Greek production becomes less competitive and Greek jobs leave for Germany. That never ends well, and was only caused by the Euro. The crisis was just the unravelling of the above unsustainable trends, but these trends were created by the Euro. You can't "until the crisis, Greece was creating these problems" -- the problems were created by the Euro. The same thing for Greece's problems collecting taxes. When governments can't collect taxes efficiently, they print more money, creating more inflation, which is basically a tax on financial assets. So the money is still collected by the Greek government. Now that the Greek government was no longer able to print money, it was at the mercy of financial markets -- international financial markets, which of course can't help the Greek government collect money in the same way that an inflation tax can. Greece simply has never been in a position where it could give up its own currency and join a pegged regime with Germany. All of this was foreseen as part of the folly of the European project. There are other bad effects, too.
- tormeh 8y agoWell, the Greek government cooked the books in order to be allowed to join. This is clearly Greece's fault. The real lesson is that weak and corrupt governments are bad for most involved with them and very hard to fix, even if you try very hard. So, if you can, keep them at arm's length. They should never have been allowed to join the euro. In fact, given their conflicts with Turkey and Macedonia, they shouldn't have been allowed to join the EU at all.
- jvkersch 8y agoReminds me of another turbulent IMF intervention: South Korea's bailout in 1997. See https://www.koreaexpose.com/imf-economy-south-korea-asian-financial-crisis/ https://www.koreaexpose.com/imf-economy-south-korea-asian-fi...
- nutjob2 8y agoThe Europeans are a crafty bunch. This arrangement is by design, not by accident or ignorance. The main problem among EU members is the lack of reforms. Devaluation has been used as a panacea for all manner of economic ills, but devaluation achieves nothing except inflation and decimation of income, savings and assets. Without the ability to devalue, members are in a vice, and the only way out is much needed reform. In the case of Greece, things are so broken that reform is very hard, but at least their suffering serves as a warning to others who thing they can get away with it in the long term.
- RobertoG 8y agoWhat those 'reform' means? Are you suggesting that Greece should become Germany? What about Portugal or Spain? Should all the countries to be net exporters at the same time? Sounds mathematically impossible. More interestingly, should Greece to become Germany without making any investments? only by reducing their economy? All this is craziness. In any currency union is going to be imbalances, that's unavoidable. I don't think I have to cite examples here, only think in your own country, whatever it is, and you will see that it's true. The solution is a fiscal capacity that compensate those imbalances. If you are not ready to finance those lazy Greeks, then you can't be in the same currency union that they are. So simple like that. I agree that the arrangement is probably by design. It makes it even more evil, in my opinion.
- Kurtz79 8y agoReforms are generally intended as addressing overly generous social security programs, corruption, tax evasion. Portugal and Spain (and Ireland) implemented some of these reforms and, lo and behold, a few years later are some of the fastest growing economies in the Eurozone. https://qz.com/1207039/portugals-economy-is-growing-at-its-fastest-rate-for-17-years/ https://qz.com/1207039/portugals-economy-is-growing-at-its-f... https://www.ft.com/content/be9d3fdb-d2fd-335c-929a-09b69752efff https://www.ft.com/content/be9d3fdb-d2fd-335c-929a-09b69752e... https://www.irishtimes.com/business/economy/irish-economy-growing-three-times-faster-than-any-other-european-country-1.3383307 https://www.irishtimes.com/business/economy/irish-economy-gr... Why Greece should be any different (as an Italian, why Italy as well?)
- sbt 8y agoNote that the Telegraph backed Brexit.
- growlist 8y agoAd hominem?
- oblio 8y agoHow is stating a possible bias an ad hominem? :)
- growlist 8y agoIsn't that the very definition of ad hominem - drawing attention to the source of the material, rather than tackling the material itself? Paul Graham's def: 'attacks the characteristics or authority of the writer without addressing the substance of the argument' https://bigthink.com/paul-ratner/how-to-disagree-well-7-of-the-best-and-worst-ways-to-argue https://bigthink.com/paul-ratner/how-to-disagree-well-7-of-t...
- beojan 8y agoNo, the Telegraph has a known anti-EU bias.
- growlist 8y agoAnd? Some people would say it's 'known' that CNN is fake news. That statement and yours are equal in nature - neither of them tell us anything useful about the content in question.
- beojan 8y agoThey're not equal. British newspapers on both sides have well known biases that they're pretty open about.
- addicted 8y ago
- economistrator 8y agoIf you are curious about the policies forced on Greece and how Greece is doing today, Macro Affairs had a good article on it recently. https://macroaffairs.com/ten-years-after-the-financial-crisis-the-problem-for-greece-is-the-same-but-bigger/finance-economics/ https://macroaffairs.com/ten-years-after-the-financial-crisi...
- claudius 8y agoWith wisdoms such as: > There were two decent solutions that would have ended this crisis within a year or two. One would have been that Greece default on its debts, paying back for example 30% of outstanding loans. Another would have been for Greece to leave the Euro Zone and go back to using the drachma (their currency before the Euro), and pay its creditors in the new currency. This new drachma would quickly fall in value as the Greek central bank would print more drachmas, making it easier to repay the devalued drachma loans. How would defaulting on debts have solved any problems? Still nobody would have bought new Greek debt and since Greece was running at a deficit before it still would have run at a deficit, just without any additional funds. They still would have had to get their administration in order to actually collect taxes etc. The second proposition is even more ridiculous, nobody would have bought the new debt, the Drachma would have been entirely worthless and any sort of import (of, e.g., medicine) would have been impossible. Edit to add: And what happened of course proves that these two "alternatives" would have been ridiculous. Greece could easily have (on its own) decided to default or switch to a new currency. No outside power could force them to stay in the euro or pay their incurred debts. Yet somehow they decided against these measures and instead took the horrible low-interest loans offered to them.
- spiralx 8y agoThe Greek Government would buy the debt, assuming that we're talking about bonds. That's how you run a deficit.
- axilmar 8y agoGreek here. The sufferings of Greece is first and foremost due to Greece's own faults and less due to the Euro. Greek pensioners had very generous pensions. The Greek pension organizations had a deficit of around 10 billion euros each year, and the Greek state covered that through borrowing. In 2001, Giannitsis, then minister of the greek government, suggested a pension system reform, which was ferociously opposed by every part of the Greek society. Lots of people in Greece ended up getting pensions of around 1200-1300 euros (after taxes/insurance), which was extremely above what these people have given as insurance when they worked. The end result was the Greek deficit was getting larger and larger and therefore the Greek economy blew up. Had it been a different case, where the Greek governments made the necessary reforms, not only in the pension system but also in other sectors of the economy, Greece would never have this crisis.